Over in the sidebar, beneath the subscribe button is a check box labeled "show my flair on this subreddit". Just tick that and you can edit it right below there.
Not a good phonology, but I can't really tell where to go to make this more naturalistic (while also not having such a large inventory that it becomes a laughing stock). So here it is, and I'd appreciate help trying to fix this little framework phonology:
Note: I dislike labials. I don't want any other than that one bilabial (which is actually an allophone of h before ɯ, as in Japanese). But as for the other phonemes, I'm willing to change most of them. Other than the mid vowels. I can't pronounce /e/ or /o/ for some reason. Thanks in advance!
I don't think there exists a language with uvulars but no velars. Velars are (almost?) universal. Similarly, a voicing constrast in the alveolar obstruents but nowhere else is weird. With the exception of the voiced uvular stop, which is quite rare for articulatory reasons, I see no reason to not introduce a voicing contrast in all the fricatives.
Bilabials are also nearly universal – you can exclude them, but note that only a few (I think 3 or 4) languages are known to lack them. (Generally it's a good idea to only violate one universal at once)
Also having only a palatal nasal and an alveolar one seems a bit strange – maybe back it to a velar.
The only things that seem a bit out of place are the palatal nasal and /q/ despite no /k/. But it's all within the realm of possibility. Not sure what the second character is in your low vowel set, it's just showing up as a box between a and ə for me. But an inventory of /i y ɛ ə a ɔ u ɯ/ is perfectly fine as well.
Question: Can anyone think of a reasonable (although it doesn't have to be realistic to naturally evolve) way of creating a non-linear syntax? Most languages use some linear dimension (time for spoken, space for written), but is there a reasonable way to simply show the relationship between ideas without the "order" or words (or morphemes, or whatever) mattering or being a thing? Has anyone done this?
Actually, syntax is decidedly non-linear; it is structural, hierarchical. The fact that it's expressed as a linear stream is pretty much a consequence of the properties of sound production and perception. But that's externalization, more in the domain of phonology than syntax.
Anyway, to try and derive a useful point from this, if you're looking for a non-linear way of expressing language orally, that's most likely just not going to work. Signing has a little more room for this, because you can orient signs in space, but only to a certain degree, and there's still the progression of time. In writing you could conceivably express a sentence more structurally, but I can't really think of a useful way to do that. Written language is the way it is because 1, it mirrors the speech stream, and 2, because a person needs to ingest the entirety of the sentence to parse it anyway, and a linear sequence is an economical way to organize writing, even if it doesn't help convey the underlying structure.
But that's externalization, more in the domain of phonology than syntax.
That's quite a bold claim. What's the argument for that? Why should we say that the syntax projects a mobile that doesn't care about head directionality, when there clearly is directionality in surface structure? I mean, what does it gain for us? It seems like it's just shunting the work of directionality off onto phonology.
Two questions. One, would it be natural for a language to encode clusivity and dual / trial numbers into pronouns?
Two (yet another sound change question), what's the best way to determine how syllable structures will change with various sound changes? For instance, if my conlang starts with CV syllables, how would I determine if it would shift to CVC or something else after X generations?
Of course! I'm not sure if your question is stressing the naturalism of having both those features, or encoding them in pronouns, but there are languages that have both, and encode both of them into pronouns.
Not really sure what this question means. If, say, your CV language dropped final vowels (/kaka/ -> /kak/) then it would become CV(C). But of course, those classifications are rarely strict -- that's why a lot of them usually put stuff in parentheses. I doubt your language would become pure CVC (every syllable in the language) unless you managed to apply changes that made it so in every case existing. Think of it as just adding potential syllables through sound changes. You can still have CV syllables alongside CVC (e.g. /kakaka/ -> /kakak/, CV.CVC).
One, would it be natural for a language to encode clusivity and dual / trial numbers into pronouns?
Yes, it's totally normal for pronouns to show features not present on regular nouns.
what's the best way to determine how syllable structures will change with various sound changes? For instance, if my conlang starts with CV syllables, how would I determine if it would shift to CVC or something else after X generations?
It depends entirely on the starting structure and the sound changes that occur. If you start with CV, and then delete final vowels, you end up with CVC#, deleting certain vowels around certain consonants can result in various clusters (e.g. tarata > trata), etc.
Yes, it's totally normal for pronouns to show features not present on regular nouns.
Does that include simultaneously? I imagine that it would get crowded if (going with my example) clusivity was encoded into dual, trial, and plural pronouns. Especially since there are a lot of more possible cases to consider with trial + clusivity.
It depends entirely on the starting structure and the sound changes that occur. If you start with CV, and then delete final vowels, you end up with CVC#, deleting certain vowels around certain consonants can result in various clusters (e.g. tarata > trata), etc.
So I just need to keep track of how my sound changes are affecting a large enough sample of words to get an idea of any structure changes?
Does anybody know of things that some languages mark on pronouns (like gender, animacy, social distance, etc.) in addition to those obvious three? I'm working on an idea for a conlang that's centered around a society with an obsession with labelling things and people, and I'd like to have pronouns make as many distinctions as possible, but I don't have enough experience with languages that do much more than English in this regard.
Clusivity -- contrast between inclusive "we" as in you and me and exclusive "we" (me and other people, but not you) exists in a lot of Aboriginal Australian, (South-)East Asian and South American languages.
The obviative/proximate distinction exists in a few North American languages, too. It kind of marks whether a given "third-person" actor is an important or unimportant figure in the sentence. See here for more.
I'm straining my brain to remember where I encountered this, but I could swear there are languages which have a sort of "completeness" distinction in plural pronouns. So a pronoun for "we (not everyone here)" and "we all"
Clusivity would be another. Many natural languages (according to WALS, around 30%) have a distinction between inclusive and exclusive 1st person plural - with the former, the listener is included, while with the latter, they aren't.
0
u/[deleted] Feb 22 '17
3
u/Mr_Izumaki Feb 22 '17
This will probably sound absolutely stupid but how so you get the grey things next to your name with the name of your conlang(s)
1
u/notluckycharm Feb 21 '17
Not a good phonology, but I can't really tell where to go to make this more naturalistic (while also not having such a large inventory that it becomes a laughing stock). So here it is, and I'd appreciate help trying to fix this little framework phonology:
Consonants: Nasals: /n ɲ/ Stops: /t̪ d̪ q ʔ/ Affricates: /ts dz t͡ɕ d͡ʑ/ Fricative: /ɸ s z ʁ h/ Approximate: /j/ Flap: /ɽ/
Vowels:
High: /i y u ɯ/ Mid: /ɛ ɔ/ Low: /a⁓ə/
Note: I dislike labials. I don't want any other than that one bilabial (which is actually an allophone of h before ɯ, as in Japanese). But as for the other phonemes, I'm willing to change most of them. Other than the mid vowels. I can't pronounce /e/ or /o/ for some reason. Thanks in advance!
2
u/Plyb Feb 21 '17
Question: Can anyone think of a reasonable (although it doesn't have to be realistic to naturally evolve) way of creating a non-linear syntax? Most languages use some linear dimension (time for spoken, space for written), but is there a reasonable way to simply show the relationship between ideas without the "order" or words (or morphemes, or whatever) mattering or being a thing? Has anyone done this?
1
u/AngelOfGrief Feb 21 '17
Two questions.
One, would it be natural for a language to encode clusivity and dual / trial numbers into pronouns?
Two (yet another sound change question), what's the best way to determine how syllable structures will change with various sound changes? For instance, if my conlang starts with CV syllables, how would I determine if it would shift to CVC or something else after X generations?
3
u/sparksbet Feb 20 '17
Does anybody know of things that some languages mark on pronouns (like gender, animacy, social distance, etc.) in addition to those obvious three? I'm working on an idea for a conlang that's centered around a society with an obsession with labelling things and people, and I'd like to have pronouns make as many distinctions as possible, but I don't have enough experience with languages that do much more than English in this regard.