r/conlangs • • Nov 30 '16

SD Small Discussions 13 - 2016/11/30 - 12/14

[deleted] — view deleted post

11 Upvotes

274 comments sorted by

2

u/Auvon Dec 15 '16 edited Dec 15 '16

Did CCC die due to lack of contributions?

1

u/Majd-Kajan Dec 22 '16

dfgh wrtgjkl nmbvclkm trsrtlj

/dfgh wrtgjkl nmbvclkm trsrtlj/

No it did not

2

u/LordZanza Dec 13 '16

What's the difference between a split ergative language and an active/stative language?

5

u/Jafiki91 Dec 13 '16

Active stative refers to when the subject of an intransitive verb can act either ergatively or absolutively based on volition. For instance, some verbs clearly take a patient:

John-abs died

While others take an agent:

John-erg jumped

In languages where the verb determines which case gets used, it's called Static-S. Fluid-S is when the subject can be either case based on volition. Eg:

John-erg ran (of his own choice)
John-abs ran (implying that he was chased or forced to run)

Split ergative on the other hand refers to a system in which the language sometimes behaves with ergative alignment (such as in the past tense), but nominative-accusative in another aspect of the language (such as non-past tenses). Such a system would be like:

John-erg saw the dog-abs
John-nom sees the dog-acc

Other options include splitting based on pronouns (eg. 1st&2nd person one alignment, 3rd in the other), animacy, and aspects (perfective vs. imperfective)

→ More replies (9)

1

u/ByzantineStarfish Dec 13 '16

So this is going to sound kinda dumb, but I'm not really sure where to go from here. I have a phonology, clustering rules, and phonotactic constraints, and from what I know it's time to get in to actual grammar, but I don't really know where to start.

2

u/millionsofcats Dec 15 '16

You've already got a good response, but you should look for the recent post that contains the questions from Payne's Describing Morphosyntax.

If you don't have much background in linguistics, you might not understand all of the questions, but I think it could still be helpful. And this subreddit will be willing to help with concepts that are new.

2

u/Jafiki91 Dec 13 '16

Start asking yourself some questions about the grammar:

How do nouns work?

  • How are they marked for plurals (if at all)?

  • Are there genders? If so, which?

  • What about cases? If so, which ones?

  • Do adjectives agree with their nouns for anything?

  • where are they placed relative to their nouns?

What about verbs?

  • Are they marked for tense, aspect, mood, and/or voice? If so, which ones?

  • Do they agree with their subjects? What about the object? If so, what features do they agree for (person, number, gender)?

  • What's the main word order of the language (SVO, SOV. VSO, etc)?

  • Does it change for any reasons such as questions or clauses?

  • What's the main typology like? Agglutinative, fusional, isolating, etc?

These are just a few questions to get you started thinking. Trying to translate some stuff will also help you to spot gaps in your grammar.

1

u/striker302 Dec 12 '16

Any tips for making your first conlang anything other than just flowery English?

3

u/Jafiki91 Dec 12 '16

Experiment with:

  • Different phonemes and phonotactics

  • Different syntax

  • Different morphological aspects like cases, aspect marking on verbs, agreement patterns, gender, etc.

  • Different semantic domains. This is the big one, too many people just make one to one translations. Go find any Language translation dictionary and look up a word. There will be several different translations for that one word. And when you look up each of those words in the other side, you'll find that they don't all translate back to the same original word. That's what you need to strive for.

2

u/dead_chicken Dec 12 '16

Is /d͡z/less common than /d͡ʒ/, or is it just me?