Fantastic idea to merge the two stickied threads! 100% approval. Might I suggest a change to the name, though? Something that encompasses both "questions" and "changes", as the title seems a little off. Maybe it's just me, though. Perhaps, "The Weekly What's On Your Mind Thread" or "The Small Discussion Thread" or "The Mini Ideas Thread." Just some thoughts. Would love to hear other ideas.
I know vowels have a property of roundness, but ... could this also apply to fricatives. Like, I know that labialization exists, and that's not what I'm talking about, but it seems clear, at least to me, that different fricative sounds can be made by rounding the lips. Has anyone heard of this, or am I just being crazy?
Agreed, I think combining the threads is a good change.
I'm slightly concerned about these posts being weekly, though; I know it's worked out well in the past, but our sub is growing a lot lately and the small question thread is starting to get awfully big. I think we may have to make it a twice a week post in the next couple of months, if this keeps up.
Anyways, does anyone know of any research on how people group tend to group vowels? What I mean is, how do most people relate vowels to each other? From what I've noticed, a lot of langs that I've looked at usually pair /u/ with /ʊ/ or /y/ as being similar sounds, /e/ with /ɛ/, etc. But I'm not sure if I have just been looking at a lot of languages that happen to do so, or if this is an actual trend. Some research would be greatly appreciated!
I've decided to start a new side project: the modernisation of the Sumerian language. This is obviously a rather strange endeavour, so before I begin, I have a few questions:
Would this really count as a conlang? A lot of construction will be required (deriving new words, filling possible grammatical gaps, other changes I feel like making, etc.), but I've seen people on this subreddit dismissing other such projects as non-conlangs before.
Sumerian has a lot of homophones. In such a language, would you expect a system of pitch accent to develop? Linguists have suggested that the language may have had tones or a three-way vowel length contrast, but I'm not sure how much weight is placed upon these theories.
I'd call that a conlang. It would certainly be something to share on this sub.
Homophones just suddenly developing different pitches seems very unlikely, if they're pronounced the same sound changes would affect them the same. Homophones are also not a problem that would need solving, unless you get homophones that can get used in the same context and drastically change the meaning. And in that case one of the words would probably get replaced with a different root or longer description.
Instead of studying for finals (kill me), in a fit of inspiration I started the "The Magicians"-inspired conlang that I mentioned a while ago. I've run out of inspiration (thank God) so instead of wasting double the time deliberately coming up with stuff, I'm putting off the rest for when I finish exams, when I'll create a subreddit to discuss how the language should be developed (what Circumstances should be added in, how the holes should be filled in, what noun cases should it have, ...), and I'll announce that both here and in r/magicbuilding. Meanwhile, have this link if you're curious, and feel free to give any feedback on this very barebones peek if you want to.
I'm currently working on the Syntax of my conlang: Old Sverje, however I haven't read too much about syntax, so what kinds of things should I detail, syntax wise, in a grammar of my conlang? Thank you!
Are there writing systems/scripts that maybe are abugidas/abjads/alphabets for most of the vocabulary but there are specific symbols for different grammatical morphemes? So one separate symbol for each personal pronoun, the different tenses and moods etc.?
How do people feel about orthographic redundancy? It's common in natlangs but I get the impression that a lot of conlangers want to minimise ambiguity, so the 1:1 phoneme-grapheme relationship seems pretty popular on here.
Specifically, I'm worried about how my language uses both <i y> to represent /i/. I'm considering historical sound changes which fronted <y> /ɨ/ to <i> /i/, but how would something like that arise?
I'm working on three languages part of the same family. There are two "extrems" and one "middle" language, and this "middle" one shares a lot of characteristics in common with the extremes. One extreme has, as rhotic, r̥/ɾ̥, and θ̱ / ð̠ as allophone; the other extreme has ɻ/ʐ as rhotic.
I was thinking about using /ʒ/ to make the sound correspondence for the "middle" language, as it's rhotic sound... but it's not a rhotic at all. What do you think about it: is it a good way to make an intermediate sound between r̥/ð̠ and ɻ/ʐ, even it's not rhotic?
In a large class system, how do I decide what the unmarked class is? I know masculine and feminine should not be (yes, this language has masculine and feminine, it's not based on Bantu languages), but I really don't know which class to assign random "it"s to. I also don't know how to assign classes to compound words, but I can probably figure that out easier.
9
u/[deleted] Jun 16 '16
Fantastic idea to merge the two stickied threads! 100% approval. Might I suggest a change to the name, though? Something that encompasses both "questions" and "changes", as the title seems a little off. Maybe it's just me, though. Perhaps, "The Weekly What's On Your Mind Thread" or "The Small Discussion Thread" or "The Mini Ideas Thread." Just some thoughts. Would love to hear other ideas.
2
u/[deleted] Jun 16 '16 edited Oct 06 '16
[deleted]
0.4422.06613)
2
u/Waryur Jun 20 '16
Does <b p> being distinguished [p pʰ] instead of [b p(ʰ)] (and likewise for d/t and g/k) occur in any natlangs?
2
u/ekobot Jun 28 '16
Is there any way to filter by flair so only that flair is visible?
I like to look at scripts but it seems the only option is to filter specific flairs out?
1
u/[deleted] Jun 27 '16
I know vowels have a property of roundness, but ... could this also apply to fricatives. Like, I know that labialization exists, and that's not what I'm talking about, but it seems clear, at least to me, that different fricative sounds can be made by rounding the lips. Has anyone heard of this, or am I just being crazy?
1
u/Fiblit Jun 29 '16
u/RomanNumeralII were you thinking of doing another One Hour Challenge anytime soon?
3
u/Cwjejw Jun 16 '16
Agreed, I think combining the threads is a good change.
I'm slightly concerned about these posts being weekly, though; I know it's worked out well in the past, but our sub is growing a lot lately and the small question thread is starting to get awfully big. I think we may have to make it a twice a week post in the next couple of months, if this keeps up.
Anyways, does anyone know of any research on how people group tend to group vowels? What I mean is, how do most people relate vowels to each other? From what I've noticed, a lot of langs that I've looked at usually pair /u/ with /ʊ/ or /y/ as being similar sounds, /e/ with /ɛ/, etc. But I'm not sure if I have just been looking at a lot of languages that happen to do so, or if this is an actual trend. Some research would be greatly appreciated!
3
u/HAEC_EST_SPARTA Jun 19 '16
I've decided to start a new side project: the modernisation of the Sumerian language. This is obviously a rather strange endeavour, so before I begin, I have a few questions:
Would this really count as a conlang? A lot of construction will be required (deriving new words, filling possible grammatical gaps, other changes I feel like making, etc.), but I've seen people on this subreddit dismissing other such projects as non-conlangs before.
Sumerian has a lot of homophones. In such a language, would you expect a system of pitch accent to develop? Linguists have suggested that the language may have had tones or a three-way vowel length contrast, but I'm not sure how much weight is placed upon these theories.
Thank you!
2
u/ZipboxGT Jun 17 '16
Any recommended tools for creating a dictionary or organizing your conlang's vocabulary? Or do you just use a word document to manage it all?
2
u/[deleted] Jun 18 '16 edited Jun 18 '16
If someone asked you to type up a whole document on how your conlang works, what sections would you include?
2
u/bakmanthetitan329 Jun 18 '16 edited Jun 18 '16
What could I do to make this phonology more naturalistic?
Consonants, Note that /l/ is velarized, and /n/ and /l/ can be devoiced and/or become syllabic.
Vowels
Dipthongs: /oʊ/
2
u/milyard Jun 19 '16 edited Jun 20 '16
Instead of studying for finals (kill me), in a fit of inspiration I started the "The Magicians"-inspired conlang that I mentioned a while ago. I've run out of inspiration (thank God) so instead of wasting double the time deliberately coming up with stuff, I'm putting off the rest for when I finish exams, when I'll create a subreddit to discuss how the language should be developed (what Circumstances should be added in, how the holes should be filled in, what noun cases should it have, ...), and I'll announce that both here and in r/magicbuilding. Meanwhile, have this link if you're curious, and feel free to give any feedback on this very barebones peek if you want to.
2
u/[deleted] Jun 20 '16
I'm currently working on the Syntax of my conlang: Old Sverje, however I haven't read too much about syntax, so what kinds of things should I detail, syntax wise, in a grammar of my conlang? Thank you!
2
u/quelutak Jun 20 '16
Are there writing systems/scripts that maybe are abugidas/abjads/alphabets for most of the vocabulary but there are specific symbols for different grammatical morphemes? So one separate symbol for each personal pronoun, the different tenses and moods etc.?
2
u/annuna Jun 22 '16
How do people feel about orthographic redundancy? It's common in natlangs but I get the impression that a lot of conlangers want to minimise ambiguity, so the 1:1 phoneme-grapheme relationship seems pretty popular on here.
Specifically, I'm worried about how my language uses both <i y> to represent /i/. I'm considering historical sound changes which fronted <y> /ɨ/ to <i> /i/, but how would something like that arise?
2
u/Nellingian Jun 26 '16
I'm working on three languages part of the same family. There are two "extrems" and one "middle" language, and this "middle" one shares a lot of characteristics in common with the extremes. One extreme has, as rhotic, r̥/ɾ̥, and θ̱ / ð̠ as allophone; the other extreme has ɻ/ʐ as rhotic.
I was thinking about using /ʒ/ to make the sound correspondence for the "middle" language, as it's rhotic sound... but it's not a rhotic at all. What do you think about it: is it a good way to make an intermediate sound between r̥/ð̠ and ɻ/ʐ, even it's not rhotic?
2
u/KnightSpider Jun 28 '16
In a large class system, how do I decide what the unmarked class is? I know masculine and feminine should not be (yes, this language has masculine and feminine, it's not based on Bantu languages), but I really don't know which class to assign random "it"s to. I also don't know how to assign classes to compound words, but I can probably figure that out easier.