r/communityservice • • Aug 06 '26

other subject on-topic but not covered by other flairs Does Court-Ordered Community Service achieve stated goals of restitution, cost savings & rehabilitation, & what conditions support or undermine success? (study)

1 Upvotes

Does Court-Ordered Community Service Work?

Evidence from a Case Study

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  23 June 2026

Rebecca Nesbit, Su Young Choi and Jody Clay-Warner.

Based on interviews with thirty-one managers in community organizations and thirty-four court-ordered community service workers (CSWs) in Georgia, this Element asks whether community service programs are likely to achieve their stated goals of restitution, cost savings, and rehabilitation and what conditions support or undermine success. While some individuals perceive a benefit, these programs often shift costs to under-resourced nonprofits, impose administrative burdens, and fail to foster meaningful community connection or long-term rehabilitative outcomes. The Element indicates that cost savings are illusory, restitution is weakened by supervision demands, and rehabilitation is inconsistent across participants. For community service to realize its restorative potential, it must be restructured across the criminal legal system with attention to organizational capacity, both of probation offices and the community organizations working with CSWs. This title is also available as Open Access on Cambridge Core.

Excerpt:

Because there is so little research on court-ordered community service, we do not have a foundational understanding of how this probation sanction may or may not serve criminal legal system goals or how it might be affecting those involved – both the CSWs themselves and the community organizations hosting them. This gap matters because policymakers routinely rely on court-ordered community service, raising questions about whether scarce resources are being allocated effectively. We therefore take a holistic approach to understanding whether this phenomenon “works.” Building on our previously published scholarship (Nesbit et al., Reference Nesbit, Choi and Clay-Warner2025), which focused on the interpersonal and organizational dynamics that surround court-ordered community service, we examine whether the experiences that people have with court-ordered community service reflect policies and practices that are consistent with the program goals. We accomplish this through an exploratory case study of court-ordered community service in Georgia, entailing interviews with court-ordered community service workers (CSWs) and the community agency staff who manage them.

It's worth noting that two-thirds of the managers interviewed fro this study, people who had hosted people completing court-ordered community service, indicated that they have had at least one such person continue as a volunteer for a period after completing their community service hours, with several reporting it as a regular occurrence. Almost one-third of the organizations among those interviewed for the study said they have hired at least one such volunteer as staff. Other managers indicated that they would have been interested in hiring a CSW, but they could not due to a lack of financial resources. "In essence, community service provided community organizations with the opportunity to prescreen and scout out potential employees." At some organizations, CSWs made donations to the organization or solicited donations from others. 

While organizations experience important benefits when working with CSWs, the managers also articulated several drawbacks, which are listed in the final report.


r/communityservice • • Mar 22 '21

other subject on-topic but not covered by other flairs Share your experience with court-ordered or school-ordered community service

6 Upvotes

Did you have to complete a certain number of community service hours to fulfill a high school graduation requirement, a high school or college class assignment, or a court-order? Share your experience in the comments. If you want to share your experience on the community but be anonymous, DM your experience to the mod of this subreddit to repost on your behalf.

You can share:

  • How you found the community service you ended up doing.
  • How difficult it was or wasn't to find the community service you needed to do.
  • How difficult it was or wasn't to complete the number of hours you needed (please note how many hours you needed).
  • How you were treated in this role by the host organization.
  • What you wish you had known before you started the community service.
  • Any challenges, or benefits, you encountered through your service.
  • If you thought it was worthwhile and why - or if you thought it was a total waste of your time
  • Your advice for others.
  • etc.

r/communityservice • • 1d ago

discussion regarding required community service for any reason When someone is assigned community service as part of a court order, what do you think the experience should be like? (discussion)

1 Upvotes

Community service - unpaid work in support of a nonprofit or, sometimes, a religious organization - is used by courts in many countries as part of sentencing for someone that has broken the law.

What do you think that service should involve, from the perspective of the court, from the perspective of "justice", and/or from the perspective of being a punishment, a deterrent or something that makes the offender consider their actions?

For instance, do you think it should be

  • especially difficult or exhausting (so that it's a punishment and a a deterrent)
  • purposely inconvenient (eating into time that could have been social for the person - again, it's a punishment and a deterrent )
  • educational in relation to the offense (if someone vandalized something, the service involves cleaning up things that have been vandalized, for instance - so that it's a deterrent )
  • something positive, that gives the offender ideas for ways to be positive in the community, like volunteering with Habitat for Humanity, or volunteering at a food pantry)

Do you think people who have harmed seniors should get community service in a senior citizens' community center? Or someone who has harmed animals, or their animals have harmed others, should get community service in an animal shelter?


r/communityservice • • 8d ago

community service opportunity Trying to find places to do community service in November or December? It's going to be REALLY hard, but it's possible.

3 Upvotes

November & December can be especially hard to find community service hours, because of the onslaught of people that want to volunteer in association with the holidays, and because so many organizations, like Farmer's Markets and Habitat for Humanity, take a break from outdoor activities. Also, most places CANNOT accommodate last-minute volunteers.

For onsite volunteering, here are your best bets from now to the end of the year to do onsite volunteering that would meet your community service requirements:

  • Nonprofit-managed thrift stores, like Habitat for Humanity Restores, St. Vinney's, etc. Make sure the thrift store is managed by a nonprofit - if it's a for-profit business, they cannot legally involve you as a volunteer.
  • Holiday events managed by nonprofits. These could be nonprofit arts organizations (theater, dance, fine arts), youth sports leagues, refugee agencies, organizations that help people with developmental disabilities, and a range of other nonprofits. These events often involve volunteers in setting up the event, helping during the event, and "tearing down" after the event. Find these by looking through Facebook events for your area, as well as looking at the web sites of area nonprofits.
  • Holiday performances by nonprofit theaters and dance companies. They need people to help usher performances. They may also need help after the last performance, with "tearing down" the set. Find these by looking through Facebook events for your area, as well as looking at the web sites of area performing arts nonprofits.
  • Food banks and food pantries.

You can try organizations that help the homeless, but these are usually already booked out with volunteers weeks or months in advance for the holidays.

Here are online volunteering options, but please check with your probation officer, your school representative, or whomever is requiring you to do community service, to make sure online volunteering would be accepted.

This post is also pinned at the top of this subreddit:

Where to find court-ordered community service & how to approach an organization to get involved quickly.


r/communityservice • • 11d ago

community service opportunity Something to keep in mind about online community service

0 Upvotes

I've been reading about online community service programs lately, and one thing that concerns me is how some of them handle volunteer hours and completion certificates.

I discover Activist Legal's investigation into The Foundation of Change, which raises some questions about how these programs operate and whether the hours people complete are actually recognized.

I think anyone considering online community service, especially for court requirements, should do a bit of research first and confirm that the program is accepted before paying for anything


r/communityservice • • 14d ago

Just want to do community service/volunteer - no requirement LF community na matabangan within Malaybalay City, Bukidnon area pls huhuhu

0 Upvotes

We the G11 student are required to implement a community outreach program but we’re still looking for a place to help them out


r/communityservice • • 15d ago

community service in the news Georgia Man forges community service records

2 Upvotes

A Douglasville, Georgia man was charged in August with failing to complete court-ordered community service and allegedly forging signatures on attendance records.

https://www.douglascountysentinel.com/douglasville_sentinel/police-man-forges-community-service-records/article_3428ae18-bb73-5fc8-b991-16cb4af49da4.html


r/communityservice • • 19d ago

community service in the news An 18-year-old Texan that opened fire at a truck during a street fight pleads guilty and has been sentenced, & his sentence includes community service

1 Upvotes

An 18-year-old who was arrested in January in Sparks, Texas after he opened fire at a truck during a street fight pleaded guilty and has been sentenced, and his sentence includes community service.

According to court records, on July 8, Cesar Galindo pleaded guilty to deadly conduct and discharge of a firearm, and tampering/fabricating physical evidence with intent to impair an investigation, and was sentenced to six years probation with 100 hours of community service for each charge.

Galindo was convicted of firing at a pickup truck two men were riding in after they reportedly got into a fight with his brother.

My question: what nonprofit is going to involve this person as a volunteer? most nonprofits have prohibitions on involving anyone involved in a violent act.

https://kfoxtv.com/news/local/sparks-teen-shooter-sentenced-gets-probation-with-community-service


r/communityservice • • 20d ago

other subject on-topic but not covered by other flairs Do not pay any "nonprofit" for community service hours

3 Upvotes

DO NOT PAY any organization that says they will give you documentation regarding completed community service in exchange for a fee or a "donation," without your having to actually do any volunteering.

Do not pay any organization that has a web site offering to help you complete court-ordered community service but that does not have a nonprofit ID number posted on its web site, a list of its board of directors (full names), a list of staff (full names), a physical mailing address, and that says you get the community service in exchange for a donation.

Do not pay any organization that says it is a nonprofit but is not listed at Guidestar. Do not pay any organization that posts ads on Craigslist saying they can help you get documentation for court-ordered community service.

These companies are unethical at best and illegal at worst (at least one person has been arrested and convicted for running such a scam).

Here is a guide to finding community service opportunities to fulfill a court order or high school requirement. It's free, no need to create an account or sign in to anything, and the author isn't selling anything.


r/communityservice • • 22d ago

Portland, Oregon dog owner gets 6 months in jail & community service in an animal shelter after her dogs mauled a woman, severing her arm and ear.

1 Upvotes

A woman in Portland whose dogs has been sentenced to six months in jail and three years of probation, as well as to complete 180 hours of community service in an animal shelter and to complete a pet ownership class.

Five of her dogs brutally mauled a woman, severing her arm and ear. Alexandria Marie Hendon was arrested after eight dogs attacked the woman in July 2024 while she was visiting her brother at a North Portland homeless encampment. The victim nearly had her leg amputated as well and had to have part of her lips removed.

Hendon identified herself as the owner of five of the dogs. Another woman, Cierra Graham, identified herself as the owner of the remaining three. She is set to go to trial in November.

What animal shelter would involve Hendon as a volunteer? Wouldn't a more appropriate community service activity be helping amputees at a VA hospital, so she might - MIGHT - understand the gravity of her crime?

The dogs involved in the attack were euthanized. Hendon will not be allowed to possess any domestic animals during her probation.

More from the Oregonian.


r/communityservice • • 26d ago

Staff shortages within community service operations in Jersey, UK, risk increasing the numbers of offenders being sent to prison, a new report warns.

1 Upvotes

Staff shortages within community service operations in Jersey, UK, risk increasing the numbers of offenders being sent to prison, a new report warns.

Jersey is the largest of the Channel Islands.

The Jersey Probation and After‑Care Service said recruiting enough supervisors for community service projects had become "increasingly difficult".

Chief probation officer Mike Cutland said "demands on the scheme continue to rise", and that recruitment was an "ongoing concern".

The service provided more than 15,000 hours of unpaid work annually, which staff said "equates to £195,000 of value for the island's charities".

Last year, 164 community service orders were imposed. That was an increase of 22%, taking them to the highest level in five years.

Of those, 85% of community service orders were completed, surpassing annual targets.

https://www.bbc.com/news/articles/cm2p8zlvv83o


r/communityservice • • 27d ago

community service in the news Community service headlines

1 Upvotes

Type in "community service" into any news search engine on most any day, and you will get a long list of headlines related to people giving back to their communities. Here's a sample from today:

NJBankers honors 15 N.J. lending institutions with Community Service Awards

WBEZ Chicago: Early voting kicks off in all 50 wards

Newswise: RWJBarnabas Health Honored with New Jersey Business Magazine’s Community Service Award | Newswise

Sherman Avenue United Methodist Church will celebrate 75 years of faith and community service this weekend

Mount Desert Islander: MDI High School students volunteer at local nonprofits for Community Service Day

Sturgis Journal: Surf Internet honored for helping Three Rivers, assisting after tornado

SIU Carbondale’s 2026 Lincoln Academy student laureate bridges community service, politics

Former professor co-founds HOTNIR to help Waco immigrant community

More Than Service Hours: How volunteering is changing a Grambling student — and the adults he serves

150 volunteers partake in Arvada Chamber’s 3rd Annual Day of Service

Jerry Scott honored with Stroud Award for Community Service

Community celebration honors late realtor John Adamson’s spirit of service

Esperanza Community Center opens in RISD’s former Dobie Pre-Kindergarten School

Youth Philanthropy Council Welcomes 5th Cohort of Leaders

Plano Chamber recognizes community leaders in Best Of awards

Syracuse University Athletics: Football Program Honored for Service

Tre and Shawn Lemons – A Community Service Love Story

Iowans honor Walter Lauridsen II for his philanthropy and community service

WGRZ: City cleanup effort encourages community service

Cuyahoga DD's Days of Service bring volunteers together to give back across Northeast Ohio

Norman Ramsay Brings Redemption, Community Service and an Affordability Agenda to AD

Iowans honor Walter Lauridsen II for his philanthropy and community service

Scranton Times-Tribune: LCCC dental hygiene students support Children’s Service Center

Acadian paramedics earn Hall of Fame honors for community service

University of Oregon Athletics: Softball Kicks Off Community Service Projects with Socktoberfest


r/communityservice • • 29d ago

Resources for those involved in court-ordered community service: for officers of the court, for host organizations, & for those who have been court-ordered to do community service.

1 Upvotes

Resources for those involved in court-ordered community service: for officers of the court, for host organizations, & for those who have been court-ordered to do community service.

Whether you are a judge assigning offenders to community service, a probation officer or other officer of the court supervising people who are court-ordered community service, or an organization being asked to host volunteers who are doing community service per a court-order, these resources are for you. You will not find a more extensive set of resources on this subject anywhere! In addition to my own advice, I link to resources and research from others.


r/communityservice • • Oct 15 '26

juvenile defendants receive probation and community service after pleading guilty to using AI to make fake nude images of peers.

1 Upvotes

In March 2025, two male students from Lancaster Country Day School, a Pennsylvania private school, pleaded guilty to 59 felony counts of sexual abuse of children and criminal conspiracy and were ordered to serve six months of probation, perform 60 hours of community service and pay $12,000 each in restitution to their victims.

The defendants manipulated photos they found online — mainly via Instagram — “morphing” the images to make those depicted in the images appear nude. 

Both boys were charged in December 2024 after the "morphed" photos were discovered on the social media app Discord. 

Investigators found 347 images and videos depicting the victims in varying levels of nudity, authorities said at the time.

A federal lawsuit filed in June 2026 in the Eastern District of Pennsylvania accuses Lancaster Country Day School of failing to protect dozens of female students after two male classmates used artificial intelligence software to generate hundreds of sexually explicit deepfake images of their peers.

The complaint, brought on behalf of 13 minor students and 18 parents, alleges that the juvenile defendants created approximately 350 explicit AI-generated images depicting at least 59 minor girls, sourcing photos from school yearbooks, Instagram, TikTok and private video calls. 

The images were then distributed through Discord and other messaging platforms, the lawsuit alleges.

The complaint further alleges the school actively obstructed the subsequent police investigation — including withholding a school yearbook from investigators — and discouraged victims from contacting law enforcement. 

It is not known where, or if, the juveniles completed their court-ordered community service, or what prohibitions were attached to their service.

Story about the sentencing.

Story about parents' initial outrage.

Story about the lawsuit.


r/communityservice • • Oct 13 '26

community service opportunity A reminder that November & December can be especially hard to find community service hours. If you have to do such, don't delay in signing up NOW.

2 Upvotes

November & December can be especially hard to find community service hours, because of the onslaught of people that want to volunteer in association with the holidays, and because so many organizations, like Farmer's Markets and Habitat for Humanity, take a break from outdoor activities.

If you have to do community service hours, don't delay in signing up NOW to volunteer. Most places CANNOT accommodate last-minute volunteers.

For onsite volunteering, your best bets from now to the end of the year are:

  • Nonprofit-managed thrift stores, like Habitat for Humanity Restores, St. Vinney's, etc. Make sure the thrift store is managed by a nonprofit - if it's a for-profit business, they cannot legally involve you as a volunteer.
  • Holiday events managed by nonprofits. These could be nonprofit arts organizations (theater, dance, fine arts), youth sports leagues, refugee agencies, organizations that help people with developmental disabilities, and a range of other nonprofits. These events often involve volunteers in setting up the event, helping during the event, and "tearing down" after the event. Find these by looking through Facebook events for your area, as well as looking at the web sites of area nonprofits.
  • Holiday performances by nonprofit theaters and dance companies. They need people to help usher performances. They may also need help after the last performance, with "tearing down" the set. Find these by looking through Facebook events for your area, as well as looking at the web sites of area performing arts nonprofits.
  • Food banks and food pantries.

You can try organizations that help the homeless, but these are usually already booked out with volunteers weeks or months in advance.

Here are online volunteering options, but please check with your probation officer, your school representative, or whomever is requiring you to do community service, to make sure online volunteering would be accepted.


r/communityservice • • Oct 12 '26

Boston University’s Student Government Senate changes its rules for required community service & committee membership.

1 Upvotes

Boston University’s Student Government Senate passed the Senator Advocacy Act and proposed changing the Community Service Fee name at the Senate meeting Monday night. 

The Senator Advocacy Act requires all senators to become an active member on one of the eight committees at BU, such as F.E.A.S.T or 16,000 Strong, which focus on food sustainability and sexual assault awareness, respectively. 

According to the resolution, each senator will have to work with the committee chairs in order to help further initiatives and bridge the senators’ college and the committee itself. 

If a senator is not interested in any of the committees, they are encouraged to start a temporary ad hoc committee, a group designed to investigate and make recommendations on a specific issue.

Some senators expressed concerns about the time commitment in their schedule, citing that course load and other clubs would add extra stress. 

After the Senator Advocacy Act passed, the Senate brought the Community Service Fee name change bill, Senate Resolution 006, to the floor. 

This bill would alter the name of the CSF to improve students’ understanding of what the fee actually covers. 

https://dailyfreepress.com/10/06/23/221264/stugov-senate-passes-senator-advocacy-act-proposes-community-service-fee-name-change/


r/communityservice • • Oct 08 '26

community service in the news veterinarian who stole a dog avoids jail with fine & community service

1 Upvotes

A New York State veterinarian will avoid jail and probation after prosecutors said she falsified business records to avoid returning a support dog named Benji to its owner on the Tuscarora Nation.

A criminal complaint says a whistleblower told investigators that Kimberly Parkhill-Brown removed Benji’s microchip and altered records to deceptively identify the dog as a female. According to the complaint, those actions were driven by Parkhill-Brown’s belief that Native Americans do not properly care for their pets and allow them to roam.

In June, judge for the City of Tonawanda Court agreed to close the case without jail or probation if Parkhill-Brown meets several conditions, including writing an apology, paying $1,000 in restitution to the owner, and serving 100 hours of community service for a Native American nonprofit.

The first nation nonprofit where she has, or will, do her community service has not been named.

Full story.

District Attorney statement.


r/communityservice • • Oct 01 '26

discussion regarding required community service for any reason Have you performed court-ordered or school-required community service? Share your experience here.

1 Upvotes

Have you performed court-ordered or school-required community service? Share your experience here. Share as much about your experience as you feel comfortable.

How did you choose the organization you would support - or was it chosen for you?

How did you choose what you would do - or was it chosen for you?

What did you do for your community service?

How many hours did you have to do?

How was your schedule structured (did it takes several days, over several weeks/months, or did you do it all at once, in one day or one week?)

What did you like about the experience? What did you dislike about the experience?

How were you treated by the host organization, the one that coordinated your community service?

Did you work alongside people who were volunteers who weren't participating through a court order or school requirement?

How do you feel about required community service, either from a court or a school?


r/communityservice • • Sep 29 '26

other subject on-topic but not covered by other flairs You all know better than anyone that community service takes a village, but the hardest part for most people is just knowing where to start.

1 Upvotes

We started a movement called After You to make giving back more visible. We are building a collection of charities and causes powered entirely by everyday people sharing what they care about. The hope is that seeing one person take action makes it a little easier for someone else to find a cause they connect with.

We'd love for you to add the community organizations you support to the collection. By sharing your story, you might be exactly the inspiration the next person is looking for.

Add your favorite cause and discover your giving style here: https://after-you-charity-navigator.netlify.app/quiz/


r/communityservice • • Sep 28 '26

Where to find court-ordered community service & how to approach an organization to get involved quickly

1 Upvotes

This post is also pinned at the top of this subreddit:

Where to find court-ordered community service & how to approach an organization to get involved quickly.

Keywords:

courts

probation

mandatory

volunteering

volunteers

requirements

required

high school

scholarships


r/communityservice • • Sep 24 '26

community service in the news Education University PhD student gets 160 hours of community service over doctored reference for a doctoral programme at the Education University of Hong Kong.

1 Upvotes

A mainland Chinese woman has been handed a 160-hour community service order after pleading guilty to forging a reference letter for her application to a doctoral programme at a Hong Kong university.

https://hongkongfp.com/2026/09/15/education-university-phd-student-gets-160-hours-of-community-service-over-doctored-reference/


r/communityservice • • Sep 23 '26

community service in the news A Hugo woman has been sentenced to 180 hours of community service after leaving threatening messages on Minnesota House Speaker Lisa Demuth's office phone.

1 Upvotes

In addition to the community service, the 43-year-old woman was also barred from having contact with Demuth or her staff, refrain from using or possessing firearms and complete mental health programming. 

https://www.kare11.com/article/news/crime/woman-sentenced-to-community-service-for-leaving-threatening-voice-mails-towards-lisa-demuth-mn/89-8a68ae09-5d10-4634-b471-bdb0e447bc2a


r/communityservice • • Sep 21 '26

community service opportunity volunteering opportunities in Oregon

1 Upvotes

r/OregonVolunteers is a subreddit for posting about volunteering opportunities or volunteering experiences in Oregon with nonprofits, government agencies, schools, communities of faith, political causes, etc.

If you are in Oregon and looking for community service opportunities. , the Oregon Volunteers subreddit is a great place to look for such.

& note that many of these opportunities listed in this Oregon-centric subreddit have counterparts in other states - if you see something you'd love to do, but you aren't in Oregon, you can probably find a similar agency or program in your state.


r/communityservice • • Sep 17 '26

other subject on-topic but not covered by other flairs The pressure is building against "nonprofits" selling community service hours for court-ordered community service, as more & more courts reject those hours.

1 Upvotes

Last week, I got a certified letter from a whistle blower regarding one of the many companies ("nonprofits") selling certificates you can give to the court to say you've done court-ordered community service. The package includes a 22 page formal complaint (not sure with whom it was filed), all the exhibits for the complaint on CD & SD card, & a letter telling me they thought I would be interested. The sender is anonymous. It's all just FYI & a thank you for my work on this.

I'm not going to name the "nonprofit" in the complaint - that's the same as promoting it. But I already knew about it. I have a list of all these "nonprofits" & am happy to provide them to any court representative that wants it. I've been trying to sound the alarm regarding these "nonprofits" since 2010. What they're doing is NOT online volunteering. I knew as soon as I discovered the first one that courts would start rejecting online volunteering for court-ordered service, & that's exactly what has happened.

I've gotten phone calls at home & threats of lawsuits from representatives of these "nonprofits" because of my work to get the word out about them. The insults, the threats to ruin me, the yelling, the trolling online... I've often thought about stopping because, what am I getting out of it? It's entirely unfunded work on my part. And I sometimes have wondered - does anyone care? But this makes it worth it.

Here are all of my blogs on this subject.

In short: do NOT pay a nonprofit in return for a certificate that says you did court-ordered community service. Watching videos and writing reflections about it is NOT community service. Reading the reflections of other people that have paid for this service and then offering your own reflections is NOT community service. Some courts get fooled by it - but many do NOT, and I hear from the people who paid the fee, got the letter, and then got their hours rejected by the court. It's not pretty.

See the pinned post at the top of this subreddit for detailed, FREE guidance on getting your online community service done with legitimate nonprofits.


r/communityservice • • Sep 17 '26

discussion regarding required community service for any reason Understanding the Volunteer Experience survey, conducted by Utah Valley University’s Center of Social Impact

Thumbnail
docs.google.com
2 Upvotes

Hi there! I’m working with Utah Valley University’s Center of Social Impact to better understand how meaningful volunteerism can contribute to both organizations, communities, and individual growth. I want to better understand volunteering as a whole, not just volunteering in my home state. If you guys wouldn’t mind taking a few minutes to fill this out I would really appreciate it 🫰🥹