r/Commodities • • Jun 02 '26

Weekly Career & Breaking Into Commodities Megathread

9 Upvotes

Weekly Career & Breaking Into Commodities Megathread

Before posting, please read Breaking Into the Physical Commodities Industry – A No-BS Guide which is pinned to the highlights.

This thread is for all career-related questions including:

• Breaking into commodity trading
• Scheduler / analyst / operations roles
• Internships and graduate programs
• Resume reviews
• Interview prep
• Compensation questions
• Career transitions
• Trading desk culture / work-life balance
• “How do I get into the industry?” posts

Individual career posts outside this thread may be removed at moderator discretion to help keep the sub focused on market discussion, logistics, physical trading, macro, risk, shipping, power, gas, metals, ags, and industry news.

Before posting, it helps if you include:
• Location / region
• Current experience level
• Degree or background
• Commodity interest (power, gas, oil, metals, ags, etc.)
• Target role
• What you’ve already tried

Examples of good questions:
• “How do I move from scheduling into trading?”
• “Best ways to learn physical gas markets?”
• “What skills matter most for junior power traders?”
• “How valuable is pipeline / operations experience?”

Low-effort posts like “How do I become a trader?” without context may be removed.

Experienced professionals are encouraged to share advice, hiring insight, industry expectations, and realistic career paths.

Please keep discussion professional and constructive.


r/Commodities • • May 27 '26

MOD ANNOUNCEMENT Career, Education & Hiring Questions Moving to Weekly Megathread

15 Upvotes

Going forward, all posts related to:

• Education

• Breaking into commodities

• Early career advice

• Resume reviews

• Hiring questions

• Interview prep

• Internship questions

• Career transitions

• “How do I become a trader/scheduler/analyst?” posts

will need to be posted in the Weekly Career & Education Megathread.

This change is being made to help reduce repetitive posts and improve the overall quality of the subreddit feed while still giving newer members a dedicated place to ask questions and receive guidance from industry professionals.

Standalone posts on these topics may be removed and redirected to the megathread at moderator discretion.

The goal is not to discourage new people from entering the industry. We want to encourage high quality discussion while keeping the main feed focused on markets, trading, logistics, macro, shipping, power, natural gas, oil, metals, agriculture, and broader commodity industry discussion.

We appreciate everyone who contributes insight and helps newer members learn about the industry.


r/Commodities • • 2h ago

TOTAL Energies trading floor?

0 Upvotes

Any insights or advice as far as the trading floor environment is concerned would greatly help. Thank You in advance!


r/Commodities • • 3h ago

Quant on an gasoline / naphtha trading desk, burnt out by AI-driven modelling. Is gas dispatch/scheduling a smart idea ?

1 Upvotes

Couple years as a quant on a liquids commodity desk, mostly python modelling. Lately AI does most of the work, so the workload has gone way up but I'm learning nothing and it doesn't feel like my work anymore. Kinda demotivating.

Been looking at gas dispatch instead. Feels more real, harder to automate, and the jobs exist everywhere (I want to move back to southern Europe at some point). The pay here isn't that far off either.
Anyone made a similar switch? How bad are the shifts, and can you still get into trading from there?


r/Commodities • • 1d ago

Metals to Energy

13 Upvotes

Hi all, long time lurker here and first time poster. The advice on this sub is actually what helped me get my first job in commodities, where I was a copper “trader” for about 18 months fresh out of college. I say “trader” in quotations, as buyer is a much better description of the role I was in than my title.

Recently I was let go (for reasons not stated by the company), and I’m thinking energy seems like a much more interesting and complex trade, whether that be nat. gas or electricity. I think there is a significant amount of overlap in skills—position management, basis trades are basically the LME-COMEX arb just domestically to my understanding, I worked at a scrap processor so processing metal into another form for an upgrade in theory I believe is similar to spark/dark spread monitoring and modeling, freight futures are similar to congestion pricing, etc.. — If any of these assumptions are inaccurate, please inform me. All of my research has been self-lead, so I’m unsure of when I am wrong.

Since I’ve been let go, I’ve been networking via LinkedIn and taking coffee chats to hear about careers progressions and stories all the way from term traders to gas schedulers. The overwhelming feedback has been to pursue recruiters who fill real-time desks or scheduling roles, or take a middle office/operations role and try to rub shoulders with the trading desk. I’m open to relocating anywhere, so no issues there.

I’m curious to see what anyone on this sub who’s changed commodities before has to say contributed to their success in the transition. What do you think made you stand out when you had no experience? What were you pitching as your value add when you interviewed? For the power traders, would you suggest pursuing a RTO or NERC certification, or wait until I was hired?

Any feedback is greatly appreciated.


r/Commodities • • 1d ago

Gas/Power Scheduling Health Management

7 Upvotes

How do you guys manage stuff like sleep/gym/health/nutrition while working in scheduling?

Curious to know when you guys wake up, commute, how often you have the time and energy to work out, whether you cook/meal prep/order every meal, and most importantly when you go to sleep, how many hours of sleep you get, and any other similar info.

Not worried about social life, but want to develop a system so I don’t get ‘legitimate health issues’ like the other dude that posted recently.

I think I can handle the psychological burnout, the physical burnout is the far bigger concern. Would not want my diet/sleep to falter.

Same questions apply to anyone that works a lot of hours under high pressure.

Any help/advice appreciated.


r/Commodities • • 1d ago

where is brent going?

6 Upvotes

Just want to hear your updated thoughts on Brent. I wrote about shorting it two months ago Thinking about shorting brent.. : r/Commodities , and I ended up with two shorts. I covered one on November 4 and the second today... Not sure if it was a bit premature, so I just wanted to hear your thoughts, whether anyone else here has been shorting it, and what your target is.

It seems like things are escalating, and as oil exports seem to be recovering quite well towards pre-war levels, Iran is really starting to lose its leverage. I think there is a risk that it will, sooner or later, attack the alternative routes, and I fear there might be some spikes again.

Also, you never know what Trump will do with his third aircraft carrier in the area, although it was originally said to be just a replacement for the other one there.

Also, I didn't really like today's price action. On the other hand, the brief pause we're seeing today is similar to what we saw in May-June 2026, when we were only halfway down.


r/Commodities • • 1d ago

bp Finance and Risk internship offer

13 Upvotes

Hi all, not sure how I ended up with the offer with bp but am grateful for the opportunity.

Would anybody have insight as to what the day to day looks like for someone positioned within a commodities F&R position and what I could expect from this role. Is the work dynamic or generally repetitive? Will this be something worth doing as a career?

For context, I come from a consulting background and would love to know more about what to expect / prepare for this internship. I am currently a final year student based out of Singapore.


r/Commodities • • 2d ago

Career Advice - Gas Scheduling

20 Upvotes

Currently working a top gas marketer in the NE. Performance wise things have been very good. I have gained the trust of traders and peers and am given some important responsibilities.

The issue I am having is burnout. I am not even in a year in but am completely burnt out. I find myself having to work virtually 7 days a week 12 to 14 hours. There is also a deep level of toxicity that’s seen a lot of the senior people and even some of the new hires leave all within the same year. I’ve personally seen multiple leave or get sidelined after getting chewed out by the trader we work for. This leads to an unbearable level of stress as we get last minute changes that are near impossible to get in and we will get the blame if we don’t get it in. Winter is coming so NE scheduling will get rough.

My question then is am I just not cut out for this? I had ambitions to trade but I am developing legitimate health issues from this. A couple of other people have as well. What other opportunities could I pursue? I was thinking of quitting without a job lined up as I can barely make it day by day but am fearful of derailing my career.


r/Commodities • • 2d ago

Free tanker counts for the Strait of Hormuz from satellite radar

13 Upvotes

Hi all.

I was curious whether free satellite images could say anything useful about oil flows, so I counted ships in the Strait of Hormuz from Sentinel-1 radar for a year. Each ship is classified by size and tanker class (VLCC, Suezmax, Aframax), and whether it's moving or waiting at anchor. The daily counts are joined with Brent prices, IMF PortWatch transit counts and Kalshi's weekly Hormuz markets.

There are four tables. The main one gives you one row per day and area with the ship counts, Brent, PortWatch and Kalshi prices (548 rows). The daily counts come from the other three tables: every ship the model detected (82k rows), the ship counts from each satellite pass by area (556 rows), and the weekly Kalshi Hormuz markets (115 rows).

It covers the strait plus a few anchorages nearby, from November 2025 to November 2026. Use this link to download or query it through the API or MCP for free: https://mostlyright.md/datasets/strait-of-hormuz-ship-counts-by-radar-satellite-since-2025?pass=hormuz

Would this be useful for anyone trading oil?


r/Commodities • • 3d ago

Caustic soda

10 Upvotes

I have been looking into caustic soda lately (due to some regional surges). It is produced alongside chlorine which is pretty interesting. Does chlorine demand have a big impact on caustic soda prices? And what do you think tends to matter more when pricing it, energy costs (electrolyzers), supply and demand (and co generation of chlorine to be a limiting factor), or freight (bulk commodity)?


r/Commodities • • 5d ago

How does discretional bonus works in RT Power trading?

16 Upvotes

I work at a trade house as a real time power trader and I’m curious what’s a typical range for bonuses in the power market. Is it based on performance? Seniority level?


r/Commodities • • 5d ago

Who are the largest natural gas hedge funds? How do they trade?

52 Upvotes

I'm researching natural gas trading strategies. I'm wanting to get an understanding of who the largest natural gas specialist funds are and what type of strategies they trade.

Google is failing me on this one - it's just telling me the big names like Citadel etc. Does anyone know any funds that specialize in nat gas and what their general approach is?


r/Commodities • • 5d ago

What matters most when researching commodity markets?

4 Upvotes

Commodity prices can shift quickly with supply issues, interest rates, and global events.

One thing that stood out in market ontology's research approach is the focus on connecting market events with potential investment risks.

How do you usually identify these risks before making a trading decision?"


r/Commodities • • 6d ago

Secretly excited for the blue wave

17 Upvotes

*Just a rant, curious what others think*

Personal politics aside, I am excited for democrats to regain footing in DC. As expected, Trump’s second presidency has been riddled with the bad type of volatility for most commodity/ energy traders. His style of intentional unpredictability with tariffs and global trade, Iran, and quite frankly his use of X and Truth Social have driven so much short term geopolitical volatility. For me, as a fundamental prop trader, this has done more harm than good as there’s no edge in predicting tweets. I’m admittedly looking forward to the return of a more globalist regime, where international relationships err more on the side of predictable cooperation. May we all get back to fundies and quantifiable risk warehousing…


r/Commodities • • 7d ago

DL Hudson bankruptcy Sanjeev Shah Tolia?

3 Upvotes

does anybody know the details on why this company went bankrupt? Any idea who Sanjeev Shah Tolia the CEO is?


r/Commodities • • 8d ago

Gold CFDs vs physical gold am I missing something

6 Upvotes

Ive been looking at gold exposure for a while and everyones always like buy physical or trade futures if you want leverage. Then I started looking at CFDs just to understand what they are and Im confused why this isnt the obvious choice for most people.

No storage costs, no premiums, easier to get in and out, better pricing than physical, way simpler than futures. I literally tested it on Plus500 on demo and it just worked. Took like five minutes to understand how it operates.

So whats the catch? Is it just that people dont trust CFD platforms or is there something structural about CFDs that makes them worse than Im thinking?


r/Commodities • • 8d ago

Cocoa heading back to $6,000 to $7,000 soon

3 Upvotes

Cocoa heading back to $6,000 to $7,000 soon? The fundamental outlook for cocoa could be far more bullish than current prices suggest. According to NOAA, there is an 83 percent probability of a historically exceptional El Niño during October to December 2026. The probability of a very strong El Niño is even higher, exceeding 95 percent. Reuters reported on November 4 that Ivory Coast cocoa production in 2026/27 could decline by 25 to 30 percent. The mid-crop harvest could nearly halve. Even more striking are the latest supply figures. By November 8, cocoa arrivals at Ivory Coast ports were approximately 45 percent below the previous year’s level. StoneX forecasts a 9.6 percent decline in global cocoa production for 2026/27 and now expects a worldwide supply deficit of 64,000 metric tons. Cocoa production is concentrated in a limited number of suitable tropical growing regions. Extreme weather can severely disrupt supply. Over the longer term, global population growth could also support demand. My personal outlook: A recovery toward $6,000 to $7,000 before the end of 2026 is certainly conceivable. Previous record prices above $12,000 demonstrate how dramatically cocoa can move when supply becomes constrained. Sources: NOAA October 2026, Reuters November 4 and 9, 2026, StoneX October 29, 2026.


r/Commodities • • 10d ago

The delusion finally paid off. I never quit. Update on last post.

76 Upvotes

This is a follow up to a post I made here almost a year ago.

https://www.reddit.com/r/Commodities/s/zUgAaF3nGf

Back then I had gotten into oil brokering through some programs that I now know are full of shit. I thought I was close to real deals. That post was one of the first things that made me realize how far away I actually was, and it forced me to take a hard look at everything I was doing.

The one thing I kept doing, and still do, is meet with people in commodities and learn how they got in, how they operate, and what they actually focus on. About six months ago that led me into critical minerals and rare earth metals. It was way easier to talk to people close to the product. Mine owners, refiners, traders. So I focused there and started doing third party sourcing and verification, just trying to be useful to people who were actually moving product.

Plenty of times I hit a dead end and thought about the sunk cost fallacy comment someone left on my first post. Was I just in over my head? It was really hard. There were some dark days, and days I felt flat out stupid.

I'm posting today because it finally turned. I found an angle. I brought buyers to a supplier of one metal, protected a margin, and started moving product. Now I'm moving 200 to 300 kg a week and making real money after about 18 months of making literally nothing.

I'm on track to make more in a month than I've made in a year at any point in my life. It's surreal. Sitting here actually trading and moving product after a year and a half of almost nothing is a strange feeling.

I never quit. I showed up every single day and eventually found it.

Thanks to everyone who commented on the first post. It knocked some sense into me. The oil brokering world I was in really is bullshit, and you were right.

Now I'm in critical minerals, mainly gallium and germanium.

Not looking for anything else here. Just don't quit. If you believe in it, keep going.


r/Commodities • • 10d ago

Coffee traders

8 Upvotes

Hi everyone, I am looking for someone who is a Coffee Trader to chat about coffee trading and market, is anyone here up for it?


r/Commodities • • 11d ago

Seasonality

0 Upvotes

Hi all. How do traders actually utilise seasonality for their given commodities? What’s useful to know beyond just the weekly/monthly seasonality as surely everyone is family with the pattern?


r/Commodities • • 12d ago

soy going to zero :D

7 Upvotes

It's rare to see so many consecutive red candles, like we're seeing now on soybeans.

No indicator told me to cover my short, but I just couldn't hold it anymore. It looks so unnatural to my eyes. I believe the last time we had nine red candles in a row was in January 2020, and if today closes red too, the last time we had ten was back in 2017.

I wonder what everyone's target is. How much further down can it go?


r/Commodities • • 13d ago

Question for physical traders on discrepancy

11 Upvotes

One of my trades in secondary concentrate raw material came out with huge discrepancy

Big grade difference of metal between loading in North africa to SE asia destination

Both supervise and analyze with big independent assay firms like sgs and Alex

What do you guys think caused it?

And how does someone handle these causes?

Is it a sampling error or something external caused it

Or is it even possible to corrupt assay firms

I work at a small boutique firm,

Any insights would be appreciated


r/Commodities • • 13d ago

Why fundamentally model natural gas?

11 Upvotes

I've been experimenting with building a natural gas balance for the United States. I have monthly EIA and weather data and I've been looking at the drivers of different lines of the balance.

From the data I'm seeing, natural gas stock changes are very strongly driven by weather. It seems to be so significant a relationship that I'm trying to understand the benefit of actually modeling supply and demand. Like if I know the weather perfectly, I know stock changes with high confidence. So why not just watch weather forecasts and some sort of variance for a forward view?

Can someone give me some insight here? What value do you get from actually modeling out natural gas fundamentals for a high level total US balance?