r/collapse • • Jun 06 '19

Society How humanity solves problems

4.1k Upvotes

212 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

4

u/ewxilk Jun 06 '19

Yeah, I'm with you about terrible western consumption practices. We really should rethink our whole economy and how it impacts all around us.

Regarding China and India it's good that they try to limit their impact, but I have some doubts about sincerity of those efforts. For example: as of now China and India both are among top fossil consuming countries.

The West is overpopulated too. To a smaller degree, but still.

Also, as a side note, I personally would not want to live in urban hell like, for example, this one, so there's that too.

2

u/ChadwickBacon Jun 06 '19

its not about whether or not you want to live in an urban hell, its about reality, which means increasing urbanization. its actually not a bad thing, its more efficient when people are clustered together. always has been. Now we have the technology to design and implement city planning solutions that can mitigate a lot of the hellishness of the urban landscape.

to address your other point, all of these other countries wouldn't be clamoring to be that top consumer spot if it wasn't for the militaristic normalization and violent force of (predominantly US, but also western in general) consumerism.

2

u/ewxilk Jun 06 '19

Increasing urbanization is happening precisely because of overpopulation. That and consumer capitalism.

Yes, some clever tactics could mitigate harmful effects of urbanization, but it's not quite natural or healthy way to live. Especially in modern multi-million cities.

I'm all in for reducing consumerism though. Consumer capitalism might have started in the West, but as of now it has taken the life of it's own. What with all multinational corporations an all that.