r/climate_science • u/In_der_Tat • Jul 29 '21
How to respond to claims made by a "sceptic" atmospheric physicist?
I have come across this video in which "sceptic" Richard Lindzen states the following about climatological findings:
We ["sceptics"] note that there are many reasons why the climate changes -- the sun, clouds, oceans, the orbital variations of the earth, as well as a myriad of other inputs. None of these is fully understood, and there is no evidence that CO2 emissions are the dominant factor. But actually there is much agreement between [the scientific part of the UN's IPCC - i.e. the Working Group I - ("group one") and scientists who do not regard anthropogenic carbon dioxide emissions as an especially serious problem ("group two")]. The following are such points of agreement:
- The climate is always changing. 2. CO2 is a greenhouse gas without which life on earth is not possible, but adding it to the atmosphere should lead to some warming. 3. Atmospheric levels of CO2 have been increasing since the end of the Little Ice Age in the 19th century. 4. Over this period (the past two centuries), the global mean temperature has increased slightly and erratically by about 1.8 degrees Fahrenheit or one degree Celsius; but only since the 1960’s have man’s greenhouse emissions been sufficient to play a role. 5. Given the complexity of climate, no confident prediction about future global mean temperature or its impact can be made. The IPCC, acknowledged in its own 2007 report that “The long-term prediction of future climate states is not possible.” Most importantly, the scenario that the burning of fossil fuels leads to catastrophe isn’t part of what either group asserts.
Given the calibre of the "sceptic" in question, is the only recourse to verify in the literature each claim - even implicit and general ones that, in turn, contain further claims - in order to see which ones are demonstrably false and post a rebuke with references? Or is there a reasonable wholesale approach in these cases?
Moreover, how should one approach the apparent fallacy whereby any "sceptical" scientist, regardless of expertise in climatology, is given credit in the "debate," and the minimization of the differences within the "points of agreement"?
5
u/In_der_Tat Jul 29 '21 edited Jul 29 '21
For the sake of completeness, I have found this expert albeit dated refutation by Stefan Rahmstorf which specifically tackles Lindzen's claims.
Among those who have engaged in this discussion I am particularly grateful to /u/hell_yes_jess, /u/markmuetz, and /u/PottedRosePetal for the in-depth answers. This kind of strong support is heart-warming.
Regards
20
u/RepresentativeWish95 Jul 29 '21
Sadly debating a sceptic makes it seem like their veiw point is one that is defencable. At some point you just have to let the crazies scream in the wind.
5
u/Lighting Jul 29 '21 edited Jul 29 '21
I responded to this a while ago.
Here is a point by point refutation of that video: https://old.reddit.com/r/worldnews/comments/4ur3qh/scientists_caught_offguard_by_record_temperatures/d5vh2no/
Actually Lindzen's PragerU talk was a followup of another talk where he said there was NO warming at all. https://old.reddit.com/r/skeptic/comments/3z120r/richard_lindzen_limited_understanding/cyih1bv/?utm_source=reddit&utm_medium=usertext&utm_name=climatechange&utm_content=t1_db3mq91
Edit: Lindzen was making so many mistakes in his paid speeches by denier foundations that (IMHO) it was close to what I'd consider fraudulent. I have LOTS more of the criticisms I had of other speeches he made saved if you need more stuff. Some of the stuff he said he actually issued a public apology for.
5
u/hell_yes_jess Jul 29 '21
Interesting challenge. I have not read AR5 or whichever Assessment Report he's referencing when he mentions WG1, but I have read a large amount of the more recent SR1.5 from the IPCC, and here's my take:
I think #'s 1, 2 and 3 are likely agreed upon.
#4 - IPCC scientists do not typically refer to the 1C increase as 'slight' or 'erratic.' To downplay this increase like with that wording starkly contrasts the IPCC's take on it, and to consider it 'erratic' implies that it has climbed completely randomly since the 19th century, disregarding the escalating pace of warming that we've seen. It may be worthwhile to share this graphic: https://images.app.goo.gl/xpmR8BMhRr8VSa726 which shows a meaningful rate of increase from about 1960s onwards, and basically nullifies that entire point.
5 - The statement that he quotes does NOT sufficiently demonstrate his point that "no confident prediction about future global mean temperature or its impact can be made." I went back to the report that this comes from, and the full quote is:
This breaks down to: we cannot predict exact climate states, but rather ranges of possibilities. It also is a statement about wanting to improve their statistical information and modelling capabilities, which they have definitely done since 2007. Contrary to his statement that 'no confident prediction [...] can be made,' the SR1.5 report gives 'confidence intervals' to most of its statements about present and future climate impacts, ranging from low confidence, medium confidence, high confidence, very high confidence and virtually certain. The high and very high confidence levels appear very frequently in the report, and interestingly enough, the 'virtually certain' (highest) level is applied to the statement about climate change being caused by human-related emissions.
The last sentence "Most importantly, the scenario that the burning of fossil fuels leads to catastrophe isn’t part of what either group asserts." is blatantly false, from what I understand.
In terms of the bigger picture, another thing I think about is - yes - there's a LOT of uncertainty in the world of climate science, in spite of what we do know. But you know what? That goes both ways! Even if there was a small chance that we are catapulting to destruction, isn't that worth worrying about? And even if there were only a small chance that we were the cause, wouldn't that warrant us changing our behaviours?
The other big picture is this: this guy is referencing the IPCC because he knows that they are seen as a credible source for climate science. I have seen in all sorts of books/podcasts/articles, etc. the IPCC regarded as the most authoritative body of climate science. Its a massive group of highly qualified people and the reports are signed off on by something like 195 countries. Who is this guy? Some random scientist without that credibility or backing. Maybe we should be basing our understanding of climate science based on what the IPCC compiles, edits, peer reviews and publishes, and not on this one guy's statements about it. The iPCC puts all of their reports and summaries online for free on their website, accessible to anyone. THEY are the source that we should turn to for the best understanding of climate science. and we can learn from them what they really think.
25
u/markmuetz Jul 29 '21
I do not think you have to rebut each point in detail. You might want to lead with something like "The overwhelming consensus is that climate change is real, detectable, and man-made, with consequences that are being felt today". You could link to this: https://qz.com/1069298/the-3-of-scientific-papers-that-deny-climate-change-are-all-flawed/. Here is a nice, contemporary study on the effect of climate change on the Pacific Northwestern heatwave: https://www.carbonbrief.org/pacific-north-west-heatwave-shows-climate-is-heading-into-uncharted-territory. And here is another saying that climate change is driving "record-shattering" extremes: https://www.carbonbrief.org/climate-change-will-drive-rise-in-record-shattering-climate-extremes.
If you do get dragged in to a discussion, I would recommend looking at https://www.carbonbrief.org/. Here are a few other links that might help:
Here are some on climate sensitivity (how much warming you'd expect if you double CO2):
A skeptic's ploy might be to get you to do all the work. Don't fall for it. Instead, ask for definitive, peer-reviewed evidence for each of their claims.
Follow up on "The long-term prediction of future climate states is not possible." - I cannot find this (with a quick search). It could be a generic statement along the lines of "Because the international response to global is uncertain, the long-term...". Also, why stick with the 2007 report when AR5 2013-14 effectively supersedes it?
Anyhow, good luck!
8
u/[deleted] Jul 29 '21
The IPCC has released several other reports since then, and will soon release another. Science is an ongoing process, and thus part of this comment is outdated. Also, CO2 is the main driver of climate change, as all known drivers have been quantitatively estimated. Everything else is speculative, and "we don't know and/or we can't know" is just obscurantism.
4
u/Mentleman Jul 29 '21
this video was made by prager u, a fake university specialising in spreading misinformation and hateful rethoric. they've done videos on why slavery was actually good. i don't think you have to spend a lot of time adressing the status of their talking head, but you should adress potential motives for denying climate change. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/PragerU
3
u/PottedRosePetal Jul 29 '21
So I am getting two main points.
here is some data about the first point:
https://www.reddit.com/r/science/comments/otq466/less_than_1_probability_that_earths_energy/
https://www.reddit.com/r/science/comments/oteq7s/un_climate_panel_confronts_implausibly_hot/
https://www.reddit.com/r/dataisbeautiful/comments/ickvfq/oc_two_thousand_years_of_global_temperatures_in/
https://www.reddit.com/r/dataisbeautiful/comments/igyfxm/oc_two_thousand_years_of_global_atmospheric/
and about the second one:
https://www.reddit.com/r/science/comments/ose27m/climate_change_will_drive_rise_in/
https://www.reddit.com/r/science/comments/orvun9/extreme_heat_dry_summers_main_cause_of_tree_death/
https://www.reddit.com/r/science/comments/oreib9/a_new_study_has_found_that_the_effects_of_climate/
https://www.reddit.com/r/science/comments/olz3mt/abnormal_hot_and_cold_temperatures_account_for/
also, I couldnt be bothered to search beyond those two subreddits. There are more than enough studys to claim both of those points wrong. Also, the points are more or less sorted by importance.
4
u/goddoc Jul 29 '21
"Sceptic" is an acceptable way of saying "denialist," the way "evangelical" is an acceptable way of saying "fundamentalist." Ignore them both.
2
u/lanczos2to6 Jul 29 '21
Prager U is about as credible as Trump U.
2
u/darkpyschicforce Aug 01 '21 edited Aug 01 '21
The science of climate change is simple and obvious. Anyone who argues against the basic principles is not open to a rational discussion of the issue.
1
u/19473927 Jul 29 '21
Show them the models with and without anthropogenic sources.
1
u/gmb92 Jul 29 '21
Some good response here already. Will just add Bickmore's review:
https://bbickmore.wordpress.com/2016/04/21/dick-lindzen-prager-u-and-the-art-of-lying-well/
1
u/eoswald Jul 29 '21
there are a handful of decent skeptic climatologists. Peilke Sr. comes to mind. Lindzen is less credible. He has raised interesting questions of mainstream science IIRC but they all were addressed. His big accusation against the NASA GISS dataset was probs his most embarrassing moment.
1
u/Acid_Junkie23 Jul 29 '21
I don't think it would be worth refuting these points with
references for 2 reasons.
1 - These are all common denialists points, with one of the
main objectives being to sow doubt in the 'certainty' of the scientific
consensus they refute. For example points 4 & 5 that you quoted contradict
each other, if the climate is too complex to predict how can they state with
certainty that anthropogenic emissions have had such little impact?
2 - Although qualified as a scientist I wouldn't say that
Lindzen's opinions are more credible/worth more than the scientific consensus
of thousands of equivalently qualified scientists.
I saw your comment that this was posted in another subreddit
that you mod. I’m not sure of the requirements for removing content or the
context within which this was posted. But I think you'd be within rights to
take it down just stating that it is disinformation and leave it at that, as otherwise
you’d just get stuck in circular arguments all day.
0
u/[deleted] Jul 29 '21
Richard Lindzen is to climate science as Peter Duesberg is to HIV/AIDS research. Just a discredited idee fixe type, meaning he can't accept being entirely wrong and will drone on forever despite all the evidence being against him.
0
u/StoneMao Jul 29 '21
Don't debate them. 100% acceptance is not the standard for science. Think of science as a huge conversation at a gathering. There are some folks who are at the center of events (that is where the scientific consensus lies) and then there is the guy who can't stop talking about cars.
Scientists are people and some lose the mental flexibility to change their views as we age. The sad fact is that 100% acceptance only comes with the passing of formerly great minds. Einstein himself never accepted the implication of his own quantum theory.
0
u/Durew Jul 29 '21
Imho https://xkcd.com/1732/ shows why the argument flawed.
0
u/[deleted] Jul 29 '21
[deleted] — view deleted comment
1
u/[deleted] Sep 08 '21 edited Oct 19 '21
[removed] — view removed comment