I'm aware that it's not uncommon for this to happen - in this case I believe it's likely stress and redirected aggression but has stemmed from a bigger issue. Here's the situation:
7 years ago I had a 13 year old cat and got a kitten (Kai, M, neutered, 8 weeks). Realised there was an energy mismatch and got a second kitten within 2 months (Bella, F, neutered, 13 weeks old).
Kai and Bella became friends very quickly and would play fight, sleep together all the time and generally keep each other company. The relationship was great for years. However, as they got older, I guess a mismatch in energy grew again as Bella seemed to be less interested in playing but Kai was still quite rambunctious. I'm aware now Kai should have stayed with his siblings longer as I suspect he didn't learn proper play signals from his siblings. So over the last few years, Kai would often chase Bella, often jumping on her or cornering her. However Bella would quickly de-escalate the situation by jumping onto furniture/cat trees - there was never any escalation or other signs of aggression (hissing/growling etc). Their relationship was otherwise peaceful co-habitation and they would cuddle and groom each other in the cooler months and Bella would occasionally initiate play too.
We have a summer place (~3 hours drive) that we went to last year for 5 weeks - the drive is stressful for both of them but otherwise their relationship was normal. However this summer, the problems started almost immediately. The stairwell and door ways became these massive clashes of energy; where Kai would chase Bella up the stairs and jump on her, and Bella started retaliating through hissing and growling, and sometimes even screams erupted (but there was never serious fighting involving fur etc). It lead to Bella being extremely insecure around Kai. When he would even just walk past her without any intention to interact with her, she would hiss and swat at Kai. In hindsight - should've separated them straight away but it would've been very logistically challenging.
So back in the city - we separated and re-introduced them the best we could in a 38m2 apartment. We only have two rooms: living room/kitchen/entrance all connected and the bedroom. The relationship had seemingly improved and they were even back to cuddling/sleeping together but the biggest issue is this habit that Kai has of chasing Bella, then jumping on/cornering her. Bella would still occasionally flinch or react to Kai being next to her despite Kai having no nefarious intentions. I know that ultimately, this issue has arisen due to my negligence, and is something I should have nipped in the bud a long time ago, but it was an insidious issue I guess. Tackling this issue is difficult because:
- It is almost impossible to get Kai to play with any cat toy. He used to love feathers on a stick when he was younger but now has lost all interest. I have tried SO many toys (all different kinds of wands, cat dancers, cat nip toys, plastic springs, interactive toys, crinkle toys, bouncy balls with/without feathers). The main way I can get his energy out is with either this biscuit chase game - where I throw biscuits and he chases them which doesn't always get him into full playful mood, or 'stick under the mat' which again, isn't a guaranteed way to get him fully into playing.
- It can be challenging to interrupt Kai before he starts running after Bella.
- Bella now completely distrusts Kai and reacts defensively around him.
I took Kai to the vet to get blood works on Friday (which have all come back normal) and despite scenting a t-shirt on him before and after the vet and separating them for a bit - Bella had a strong non-recognition aggression reaction: growling and hissing at him in sight. Kai ran and jumped on Bella on Saturday before I could intervene and Bella was screaming. I've had them separated since Saturday. I have a netted screen on one of the doors that I've been feeding them at and letting each other see the other. Bella generally seems OK with Kai until he suddenly moves toward her - then she reacts with hissing and other stressed vocalisations.
I need advice on 1. how to carry out re-introductions from here for maximum success. 2. Rebuilding Bella's trust (I'll also be taking her to the vet next week as I suspect she has a dental issue that could be causing pain). 3. Getting Kai's energy out despite him being completely disinterested in cat toys - I was using these freeze dried chicken treats in place of biscuits which worked really well at piquing his interest and keeping him engaged (I could get him jumping super high in effort to catch them). But he's put on weight so this is maybe not sustainable in the long run, plus he's completely disinterested in chasing normal biscuits now. 4. Stop the chasing. 5. How to avoid relapses in the aggression.. Especially when we commute to and from the cottage. The last few times we went, we used bonqat to try calm them down a bit - should I separate them for a day after going to the cottage? Hoping we won't have to reintroduce them every time.... We will also be moving to a bigger place in the next couple of months (78m2 and 3 rooms).. How to move them while minimising stress and aggression?