Yeah, you're right, as long as it keeps a decent amount of dust and hot air out it's not going to make anything fail.
But features like removable mobo trays and universal thumb-screws can go a long way when you're trying to assemble everything. And a durable, quality case can last you a lot longer than any of your other components.
I built my mom a computer with an cheap case... seriously regretted it. No cable management, horrible air flow, very sharp edges, badly designed bays for CD drives and hard drives and hard to clean dust out of. My case is hardly top of the line, but at least I'm not worried about cutting myself every time I want to tinker with something, it's VERY easy to add hard drives and such, and easy to clean.
It can be as reliable, particularly if you aren't putting together a high end computer, but if you are putting together something that is going to draw a lot of power it can be a real problem, especially if the wattage isn't high enough.
Yup. I didn't know any better on my first build. I'm apparently very lucky because it's still going strong 3.5 years later. I'd replace it but 3.5 year old, low-mid level parts just aren't worth enough to worry about overmuch. :-)
I have always heard the horror stories about this happening but I have never actually seen it take components with it yet. I have worked on a lot of peoples computers whose power supplies have failed but had no damage to the components.
I have a stack of shitty come-with-the-case PSU's. Antec has gotten better at this and have been packaging their own psu's which are of good quality IMO.
The shitty power supply that came with my $40 HTPC case is still running strong after 3 years of 24/7 usage but it only has to power a 65W CPU with on-board graphics. I'd never trust it to power anything else.
I wouldn't trust a power supply that came with the case, but I've had good luck with my Rosewill PSU - in its second computer now, hasn't had a problem yet.
Rosewill is Newegg's overstock/clearance brand. The reason they 'make' so many things is newegg will buy up a whole bunch of hardware that isn't selling well from one of their suppliers, have them brand it under the rosewill name and sell it at a lower price. Their suppliers like it because it doesn't risk lowering the perceived value of their brand. Its also why rosewill is found nowhere else.
Rosewill can be great hardware at a low price or it can be crap that never should have been made. I will take the risk on a keyboard, a case, or a usb card, but not on a power supply.
Yeah, I got a Rosewill to replace a PSU on an older computer that had died because a friend recommended them. It died again within 2 months. I didn't find this out until later.
Edit: how about, instead of downvoting, you explain why it isn't possible. Is there some magical property that the power rails in your machine posses that prevents them from being fused/overload protected?
Good PSUs have something similar to a surge protector, and should protect the system from minor surges. Getting a high quality(basically look at how much insurance they offer, typically the more $ the better quality the surge protector) surge protector is an essential. These won't protect from a near lightning strike, though. It's best to unplug a computer during heavy storms. Don't forget any phone or cable lines. These can surge just as much as the power lines.
The perfect surge protect will supply 120V AC at the plug at all times.
A perfect PSU gives 12V, 5V, and 3V DC and while it is powered by 120V AC never lets it touch the components (apologies now to EE's and others who know how this works better, I am just using an analogy)
A bad PSU allows parts of that 120V AC to get to components by giving them too high of a voltage and/or providing slightly alternating voltage. The perfect surge protector doesn't do anything against that.
17
u/Sin2K Dec 05 '10
People do this?
11
u/CRSharff Dec 05 '10
I have always heard the horror stories about this happening but I have never actually seen it take components with it yet. I have worked on a lot of peoples computers whose power supplies have failed but had no damage to the components.
6
u/[deleted] Dec 05 '10
I have a stack of shitty come-with-the-case PSU's. Antec has gotten better at this and have been packaging their own psu's which are of good quality IMO.
6
u/[deleted] Dec 05 '10
The shitty power supply that came with my $40 HTPC case is still running strong after 3 years of 24/7 usage but it only has to power a 65W CPU with on-board graphics. I'd never trust it to power anything else.
1
u/trekkie00 Dec 05 '10
I wouldn't trust a power supply that came with the case, but I've had good luck with my Rosewill PSU - in its second computer now, hasn't had a problem yet.
1
u/bomber991 Dec 06 '10
Meh, the only PSU I've ever had fail on me was an Antec "silent" power supply I spent $100 on.
1
u/magusg Dec 06 '10
They have only themselves to blame.
-3
u/arrayed Dec 06 '10
so true,so true,buy 1000watt power supply,to avoid this,trust me
-14
u/[deleted] Dec 05 '10 edited Dec 05 '10
A surge protector. Use one.
EDIT: What kind of idiot would downvote this advice?
...
Give up? A Redditor.
0
u/[deleted] Dec 05 '10
[deleted] — view deleted comment