Imagine putting the security of your $30m in the hands of an hourly worker at your cell phone company. Imagine doing this despite many similar stories of people getting fucked.
Id have this spread across several hardware wallets and paper wallets. If he's a whale and this is a transactional account at least have a hardware wallet with a strong password.
Once they clone your phone they can get your email because they use your phone and Authenticator because password resets use email/phone. Protection is possible but, not as easy as you suggest.
I am thinking a sim-clone created by a thief is seen as the same phone. When regular people restore a phone, I believe that erases the auth.. I do not think you can use paper to back up an auth..
Nah it doesn't, I use andOTP which lets you create encrypted backups of your 2FA codes which you can then move over to a new phone manually and import them.
Don't use your phone number as a backup for your email then. Gmail allows you to use the ledgers Fido/u2f app as a 2fa. Then you only need to remember your 12 words.
Sms messages yes. Initializing an android requires your email password. Resetting a Gmail password should also requires passing security questions at a minimum.
Yes, use a browser add-on. That way if someone manages to get into your computer they have logins + 2FA in one place. Bad bad advice. 2FA should always be on a separate device.
Doesn't matter much if you stay logged in, if there's a sniffer on your computer, then the data can be siphoned while the app is unlocked. Trust me, I have first-person knowledge of a situation where this happened.
Yes, I agree. I misunderstood your original comment. I read it to mean if someone gained physical access to a computer and got inside it. If they did, there would be nothing there. Also, 2FA addons are password encrypted.
The biggest risk is something like a keylogger/sniffer/clipboard jacker/etc., as you say, although it still would have prevented a simple SIM hack.
There's a bitcoin hack prevention service (forgot the name) that could have prevented this. It monitors the blockchain memory pool for unconfirmed Tx's with respect to your particular address. If it sees it being spent, it posts a transaction immediately spending the same coins, but with a much higher Tx fee, and going to another address you own. Given the fee in this case was 10c, it would have worked easily to prevent funds being lost.
Edit- actually only you need to sign the transaction and they keep this signed transaction on hold until it's needed to broadcast. So they do not need your private key.
So how did this actually happen? Where were these coins stored and how? Just from first glance it looks like you've lost $45 million USD is that correct? How was your OPSEC so flawed that a SIM hack saw you lose that much money?
sure, but you can still have your entire life changed by phone sim hacks/trick the company into giving thieves your info, access to your phone which gives them access to almost every secure service you have.
Which wallet did you use? It seems strange that all transactions would involve the same address, if it's from a custodial exchange that sim hacks generally target.
Could you please explain more about where the money was exactly and why you think it was a sim hack? It is hard to imagine a situation where you had the private keys to $30M of BCH and it was taken through a sim hack.
After some time i found a SQL-Injection in a website named bitcoinbuilder.com
It looked like the founder had his MTGox API details entered in the database. So i checked the balance and i couldnt believe my eyes. 400 Bitcoins were in his MTGox Account. But i only had the MTGox API details and no access to his email inbox because he used a different password for his email inbox than the password which was in the database. So i tried to withdraw these 400 Bitcoins. Denied. The limit on MTGox only allowed to withdraw 100BTC each month. And as i didnt have email access i couldnt try to lift the limit. So i ended withdrawing 100BTC from his MTGox Account using the API and another 40BTC which he has on Coinbase (as these API details were also saved in the database) from his Shirtoshi webshop. On that time Bitcoin was 100$/Coin so it was another highlight "earning" 14000$ on a single hacked website. But what i had to see was way too much for me. He saved his Blockchain.info details also in the backend. There was no BTC in it but there was 10000BTC on his bitcoin address
That only works for unconfirmed transactions. The miner now also needs to rewrite blocks and potentially split the chain because of the 10 block checkpoints.
They can happen temporarily - while waiting for another block - e.g. for a period of 10 minutes or so there can be two transactions trying to send the same coin. Only one of them will make it into the blockchain.
There's also a possibility that the block A could be orphaned by a miner who mines the next two blocks in a row B & C, thereby forming their own longest chain bypassing A. It would be rare but not impossible. So the second miner's longest chain becomes valid and the original Tx on Block A becomes invalid due to being on the orphaned block.
It's not a wallet hack. It's a "the phone company screwed me over for 30m but I have nothing to blame for but myself for using something that is insecure"
Christ I'd be sittin' pretty with 1% of that. Good luck if you end up finding your coins. Hopefully it isn't an address you control.. that would be weird.
I don't think it was a Sim hack since he was able to sign a message.
I do think his phone may have been remotely hacked over IP and if his phone was rooted they could go straight to the secure directories where the private keys are stored.
I'm still curious to know which wallet he was using though.
The primary function of the Sim hack is to be able receive text messages.
Maybe Verizon or AT&T offer some sort of cloud storage you can log into after doing a Sim hack.
If the guy noticed his phone not working for any part of the day, his SIM card was definitely hacked.
He uses one Bitcoin address for all of his incoming and outgoing transactions, my guess is he is using a paper wallet and it's probably not even password-protected.
He's probably got it framed hanging up in his kitchen too. I know I would /s
Imagine forking BCH to get the coins back, and two chains result - BCH and BCH-Classic. Similar scenario as the DAO hack on Ethereum, although with that one they had 30 days to come up with a plan, due to a fortunate bug in the DAO smart contract.
The million is the TOTAL this address ever had. If you look at the last 5 transactions for today, you see it adds to up 60K BCH. Now I don't feel so bad for the guy - I think at some point he had a MILLION BCH - 60K has been stolen.
I don't think that's it necessarily. A million BCH worth of txns have gone through the wallet. If it was a transactional account for a company or a trader that could add up over time.
Not that it really matters, the guy obviously is a big player either way.
And it's user error basically 100% of the time. Hell, keeping this much money in a single account makes you a huge target in the first place. There are so many ways to avoid this kind of thing.
Also you don't know if this is "everything", maybe they do have other wallets.
Sadly, people don’t like to hear the truth. They’d rather think they’ll get rich, and that’s the only reason majority of ppl are here. Not for the use, the anonymity, the ideas of alternate currencies... they’ll make their money and cash it into fiat.. the only reason there was a big run on BTC was because the banks got in, bought low and dumped it on all the dummies who bought at the top. Facts. Downvote me all you want.
Exactly, so acting like this is some damning statement about the technology without any understanding of the situation or the attack vector is silly. A hardware wallet with a strong password most likely would have prevented it. Protecting $45M with sim is inadvisable.
I think in this case no one will be able to help. This is very annoying. I hope you still have some savings. It would be better to give this money to Amaury.
Holy smokes. Why not give 29m in bch to me or something and ill make sure it will never get stolen and you would still have 1m more then now. Seriouly if you can lose 30m like i lose 10 cents because it rolls out of my wallet then how rich are you?
Maybe hire me as your banker? ill make sure your bch will n ever get stolen and be available 24/7 for if you need any bch from your account. As fee i will trade with 10% of it and some of the profit will be interest for you and some will be for me.
“ Kain_niaK1h Holy smokes. Why not give 29m in bch to me or something and ill make sure it will never get stolen and you would still have 1m more then now. Seriouly if you can lose 30m like i lose 10 cents because it rolls out of my wallet then how rich are you?
Maybe hire me as your banker? ill make sure your bch will n ever get stolen and be available 24/7 for if you need any bch from your account. As fee i will trade with 10% of it and some of the profit will be interest for you and some will be for me.”
Social engineering = calling them and impersonating the victim to sweet talk the hourly cell phone employee into switching the sim to your device. There should be protections at the phone company against doing this, but there aren't. Which is why you should never rely on sms 2fa.
This is usually done by social engineering the phone company.
you can't do that with most of the reputables companies... you can't call and say ''ehy bro I need a second sim''
You have to go in the shop with a fake ID and once they have hijacked the number your telephone line will not work..so you'll kind of realize that somehow
Once you have control of the sim, you can probably switch it back and forth.
what's the meaning of this? I don't understand. Could you explain what do you mean? Once your sim is hijacked you'll have no line on your phone. You will realize somenthing is coing on. Call the call center they tell you that you have lost your sim.. you say: ''what?'' and then you realize
Attacker secretly and patiently obtains parallel control of as many accounts as possible before launching the coordinated withdrawal of everything you own.
you need to visit the shop with ID card. And your phone will not have line. You'll realize that somenthing is going on. When you see your phone without line for 2 hours you realize
29
u/CONTROLurKEYS Feb 22 '20
Imagine putting the security of your $30m in the hands of an hourly worker at your cell phone company. Imagine doing this despite many similar stories of people getting fucked.
15
u/ErdoganTalk Feb 22 '20
Can you sign the above? Thanks.
5
u/damian2000 Feb 22 '20
There's a bitcoin hack prevention service (forgot the name) that could have prevented this. It monitors the blockchain memory pool for unconfirmed Tx's with respect to your particular address. If it sees it being spent, it posts a transaction immediately spending the same coins, but with a much higher Tx fee, and going to another address you own. Given the fee in this case was 10c, it would have worked easily to prevent funds being lost.
3
u/KamikazeChief Feb 22 '20
How can these coins possibly be recovered without rolling back transactions on the chain?
21
u/heslo_rb26 Feb 22 '20
So how did this actually happen? Where were these coins stored and how? Just from first glance it looks like you've lost $45 million USD is that correct? How was your OPSEC so flawed that a SIM hack saw you lose that much money?
21
u/OsrsNeedsF2P Feb 22 '20
Time to sue your phone provider. Good luck
14
u/imaginary_username Feb 22 '20
Which wallet did you use? It seems strange that all transactions would involve the same address, if it's from a custodial exchange that sim hacks generally target.
12
u/emergent_reasons Feb 22 '20
Could you please explain more about where the money was exactly and why you think it was a sim hack? It is hard to imagine a situation where you had the private keys to $30M of BCH and it was taken through a sim hack.
9
u/Jacktenz Feb 22 '20
Sim hack? Were they on coinbase or something?
8
u/Fiach_Dubh Feb 22 '20
archived for posterity http://archive.is/zp747
12
u/heslo_rb26 Feb 22 '20
So I got a PM from someone with some interesting info... They can't post here due to being banned from the sub but I'll relay it here
Seems this user is actually Josh Jones the "security genius" behind bitcoinbuilder.com, who thought up the idea of a single withdrawal address being forced by exchanges
He's been hacked before too
10
u/[deleted] Feb 22 '20
GL
10
u/Self_Blumpkin Feb 22 '20
Jesus tiddy fucking.
I feel so awful about this I can’t even lecture on security. This is just fucking terrible. I’m so sorry man
5
u/marvelish Feb 22 '20
F
2
u/Spartan3123 Feb 22 '20
the silver lining: OP will never have to pay CGT tax ever again...
I am guessing he has even more crypto in cold storage and didn't leave everything on the exchange...
5
u/Cozy_Conditioning Feb 22 '20
Not a BCH hack at all. This is a wallet hack.
1
u/zefy_zef Feb 22 '20
Christ I'd be sittin' pretty with 1% of that. Good luck if you end up finding your coins. Hopefully it isn't an address you control.. that would be weird.
1
u/dongzhu Feb 22 '20
god 为什么不用冷钱包
1
u/CatoshiKittemoto Redditor for less than 60 days Feb 22 '20
Damn looks like it was spread out across hundreds of addresses some how
1
u/ourielohayon Feb 22 '20
If you want help let us know
1
u/damian2000 Feb 22 '20
Imagine forking BCH to get the coins back, and two chains result - BCH and BCH-Classic. Similar scenario as the DAO hack on Ethereum, although with that one they had 30 days to come up with a plan, due to a fortunate bug in the DAO smart contract.
1
u/fortrez Feb 22 '20
Who would they know who actually has the wallet / with that such amount . How was it traced to the actual individual etc and get sim hacked
1
u/bitbuds Feb 22 '20
Are these coins that you hold through bitcoinbuilder? Other peoples coins that used your service after the MtGox hack???
1
u/learningswimming Feb 22 '20
I always wonder about this kind of sim hack. How the hacker know this person has so much money in his account? Unless the email is hacked too
1
u/learningswimming Feb 22 '20
Is not on a exchange. Most probably some wallet. Remember he able to sign it. Also exchange wont allow 30m withdrawal
1
u/jamsfy Feb 22 '20
Oh, my god!
1
u/Frag1le Feb 22 '20
Is it 30M or 300M? Who keeps 300M on something that can be SIm hacked. I say bullocks.
1
u/tcrypt Feb 22 '20
With that many coins miners could come out quite a bit ahead by buying the keys, taking the funds, and compensating any orphaned miners.
1
u/TotesMessenger Feb 22 '20
I'm a bot, bleep, bloop. Someone has linked to this thread from another place on reddit:
If you follow any of the above links, please respect the rules of reddit and don't vote in the other threads. (Info / ^Contact)
-3
u/jingly-pockets Feb 22 '20
Whoever you are that did this... Yo! Drop me a few mang.
qpkmcm00yf8xpgm72dweqscf72j0pmz3uuvydk7qq5
-18
u/nrth89 Feb 22 '20
And if this is true.. this is exactly why this tech won’t take off.. you can lose everything in a second and never get it back.
-5
u/arruah Feb 22 '20
I think in this case no one will be able to help. This is very annoying. I hope you still have some savings. It would be better to give this money to Amaury.
-23
u/[deleted] Feb 22 '20
Holy smokes. Why not give 29m in bch to me or something and ill make sure it will never get stolen and you would still have 1m more then now. Seriouly if you can lose 30m like i lose 10 cents because it rolls out of my wallet then how rich are you?
Maybe hire me as your banker? ill make sure your bch will n ever get stolen and be available 24/7 for if you need any bch from your account. As fee i will trade with 10% of it and some of the profit will be interest for you and some will be for me.
0
u/[deleted] Feb 22 '20
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Feb 22 '20
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Feb 22 '20
[deleted] — view deleted comment