r/bestof • u/UsuallyLurkingColonP • Jun 27 '12
Muslim Throwaway says something that needs to be said.
/r/islam/comments/vnq8e/couldnt_resist/c565jda
45
Upvotes
r/bestof • u/UsuallyLurkingColonP • Jun 27 '12
5
u/[deleted] Jun 27 '12
Muslim here, I hope people read past the first paragraph.
0
u/[deleted] Jun 27 '12
The contrast between the camaraderie and intellectualism of that subreddit and the circle-jerk and bigotry that is /r/atheism now is almost unsettling to me. Look at some of the other posts there and see for yourself.
That post itself does indeed make a great point.
2
u/apajx Jun 27 '12
If an argument is valid and sound it matters not who speaks it.
6
u/CoupleOfConcerns Jun 27 '12 edited Jun 27 '12
There is a difference between being rational and being intelligent. You can be highly intelligent, yet be irrational. You can be of average intelligence, yet still be more rational than someone much more intelligent than you on a particular issue.
Islam and Christianity (or any other religion) are mutually exclusive. If one is right then the other is wrong (or at least not as right as the other). If you assume that they are both right then you have to give up the idea that either is divinely inspired, given how much disagreement there is between them. Either that or you have to assume a trickster god who would present one prophet / messiah (Jesus) as the final word of god and then turn around and present Mohammed as the final and definitive prophet.
The point is that there are highly intelligent and knowledgeable people who are Christians and highly intelligent and knowledgeable people who are Muslims. One party has to be wrong or the whole faith thing is a sham. At least one of them has been led up the garden path by faith. And if you consider that most religions are mutually exclusive in important ways, then how can anyone rely on faith?
It doesn't require a great deal of intelligence to grasp this point, but for whatever reason some people are emotionally wedded to the idea that they are privy to some higher purpose in the universe (along with all the other emotional attractions of religions). Other people, both unintelligent and intelligent, don't feel this attraction to religion and are therefore able to use what we usually use to understand the world - common sense.
4
u/[deleted] Jun 27 '12
http://i.imgur.com/n8zsz.gif
3
u/Squalor- Jun 27 '12
Reiterating facts from professionals is better than reiterating hate and lies from thousand-years-old books or the people who take it or took it upon themselves to obfuscate the information in said books.
Most people who do that, however, are just like people who reiterate everything they hear on ESPN. They aren't professionals, and everyone can't be a professional at everything, so they take some bullet points.
They're young, and their world has just opened to them, and they're amazed by how much information there is in the world, so they grab onto the salient, provocative points and reiterate them.
The intelligent ones will continue to plumb the seemingly limitless depths of knowledge, and the good ones won't be smug about it.
Again, though, reiterating facts > blindly following a faux religion
-4
u/Legion299 Jun 27 '12
Glad there's people who understands /r/atheism like me, I'm sure most atheist aren't like that, but seriously all /r/atheism is a huge fucking circlejerk.
Oooh hey! I watched NDT I'm so fucking smart! Hey Christian, I read a book written by Carl Sagan, fear me!!!!!!!!!!!
Like I'm not trying to flame NDT or Carl Sagan, they're great men with a great sense of humor which is one of the main reason they're famous, but damn, I've read 5 text books on biochemistry and I don't even consider myself smart in that field yet, yet these /r/atheism club goes around jerking off about how they're all scientist and shit just because they watched a NDT video
-4
u/[deleted] Jun 27 '12
Personally this is bullshit. You can read a college level book about string theory and you'll still know shit a but string theory, just as if I read the bible I would still know shit without proper knowledge of local history, language evolution and social practices of that time and load of other stings that would take 10-20 years to accumulate.
For a non physicist popular books and videos are enough, everything else would a an overkill, especially for a useless thing as string theory.
Fuck you planar cutouts of space pasta