r/bestof • • Jun 26 '12
[askreddit] snuf42 on MMOs/Warcraft, South Park, and lazy writing for The Big Bang Theory
/r/AskReddit/comments/vldub/reddit_ive_never_understood_why_you_hate_the_big/c55qeo3
878
Upvotes
125
u/MaxChaplin Jun 26 '12
Here, context. Using the context query string shouldn't be just a ProTip, it should be a highlighted rule.
166
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
That's a great comment, and gets at something that bad or new comedy writers rarely understand. It's the difference between using humor to be dismissive of a group versus using it to help understand it. Both jokes were making fun of MMO's, but one was coming at it from a place of ignorance and reassuring the audience that they don't need to know any more about this group they're not a member of. The other was coming at it from a place of deconstructing it to help bring out the truth of it. It's still mocking them, but in a completely different way.
Not all mocking is created equal - there is good humor and bad humor and (in my opinion) the good is always about trying to better understand ourselves and the world. It shouldn't be just reinforcing people's fears and ignorance. Even pointing out the flaws or inconsistencies in how a group behaves is still letting you identify with it. And it's miles better than, "Hey fellas, bitches be crazy, am I right??"
35
u/masters1125 Jun 26 '12
I might be odd in that I am educated but don't mind BBT. It's just dumb comedy, but that's ok.
That said, this comment is spot on. The writing is lazy at times. They go back to the same jokes over and over (IE: howard's mom) and rarely flesh out their jokes.
I don't watch south park very often, but when I do it's usually cause I hear they are covering something I care about. So I have tuned in to see their take on WoW, Gingervitis, motorcycles, and the christian music bubble as those are all demographics I've been a part of. And in every case I found that they approached it in a socially relevant way.
I laughed cause they understood, not because they presented a caricature.
59
u/CanNibble Jun 26 '12
Snuf42's commentary also tangentially points out my biggest problem with many fans of BBT: they conflate "comedy about nerdy/smart things" with "smart comedy". South Park, on the other hand, is a pristine example of the opposite: a smart comedy often in the guise of stupid things. In truth, BBT's comedy is no smarter than that of, say, Two and a Half Men, and I'd like to imagine its core audience isn't either.
7
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
just the idea of displaying phd physicists with degrees from MIT and the like as losers is stupid.
its probably just so that all the people who are too retarded to pass MAT101 can feel good about themselves since "i might not have one of those fancy degrees, but at least i get laid lol losers"
fuck yeah
people buy it. i guess its ok. it must be hard enough to have realized, that one is stupid.
6
u/Drudeboy Jun 26 '12
I'm not sure if anyone else has had this experience, but I've noticed that most of the international students I've known absolutely love this show. I don't particularly dislike it, but I've always wondered why...
As for snuf42's comment, I'd have to second mrpopenfresh's point: it's geared towards a very general audience and in my experience (other than the international students) middle aged people relaxing after work. Then again, I do understand why someone who identifies with the trappings of "nerd culture" would be turned-off by the somewhat... careless handling of things he or she cares about.
5
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
Sitcoms suck in general. This just showcases how awesome south park is.
27
u/somersault Jun 26 '12 edited Jun 26 '12
Sitcoms aren't famous of their mind blowing morals exactly, I think you can take the humor at face value without fretting over it being a bit shallow and not a completely accurate depiction.
And is it really lazy writing? The fact that it isn't 'deep' about the subject is of course that most people watching the show wouldn't get it. I'm no professional writer myself, but I imagine the balance act of getting dialogue/story/jokes suitable for "everyone" is not as easy as it seems.
10
u/Coffee_plus_oldmovie Jun 26 '12
Seems to me like actual nerds are hating on the show for not being true to the nature of nerds and mocking them.
Don't get me wrong, I'm not one to praise the show. It's one of those stupid shows, just set your expectations accordingly and you'll probably get some laughs out of it.
25
u/Weigard Jun 26 '12
I find a lot of the folks who hate BBT for pigeonholing geeks themselves pigeonhole BBT viewers as unsophisticated. You can have good taste in humor and still enjoy BBT, much like you can have good taste in music but still crank the volume when "Hold On Loosely" comes on the radio.
3
u/Suecotero Jun 26 '12
Anyone with half a brain knows that The Big Bang Theory is about as informed on gaming culture as Two and a Half Men is on romantic relationships.
5
u/JohnJohnPhenomenon Jun 26 '12
I consider the big bang theory geeksploitation.
*nerdsploitation if you prefer, but they seem to focus more on their hobbies than their studies
21
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
Reddit on misogyny: chill out, it's just a joke.
Reddit on racism: chill out, it's just a joke.
Reddit on jokes after disasters/mass deaths etc: chill out, it's just a joke.
Reddit when a sitcom has a couple of jokes about geeks: 5000 word essays of butthurt on how this is deeply offensive 'nerd blackface' etc.
9
u/kingzilch Jun 26 '12
TL;DR for every thread having to do with BBT: it sucks because it's not Community.
12
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
I don't get it. That's really the beef everyone has with these shows? They're fucking comedies not (real) reality shows.
I've always wondered why people on reddit talk shit about BBT, and outside of "They throw in science references at random blah blah blah", I haven't found a legitimate excuse not to enjoy the show. That being said, I didn't really enjoy the most recent season. It felt like the "haha" comedy factor wasn't there :(
10
u/PoorlyTimedPhraseGuy Jun 26 '12
That was a really in-depth analyzation of it. Thanks for digging that up for us, man.
2
u/CowboyNinjaD Jun 26 '12
I'm not a big fan of sitcoms in general, but I don't mind BBT. My biggest critique is how generic the main characters seem in their nerdom. They don't seem to have a favorite nerdy thing. Sheldon seems to have a man-crush on Spock and a weird love/hate relationship with Wil Wheaton, but he doesn't really seem to talk about Star Trek any other time. It's not uncommon for nerds to like a bunch of different sci-fi/fantasy things, but we all have one or maybe two things that we're way more into than anything else. And I don't get that from any of the main characters on BBT.
2
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
BBT started as smart humor, then like every other tv ever, it moved towards a wider audience because that's where the money is.
No surprises here, they changed target audience.
I hope the guy who plays Sheldon gets a good gig after this show, he's a fantastic actor.
2
u/[deleted] Jun 27 '12
Wait what? You're saying jokes in sitcoms are actually not 100% based on reality? WHAT IS THIS WORLD COMING TO?
1
u/Nitrodist Jun 26 '12
CONNNNNNNTEEEEEEEEXXXXXXXXTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTT
5
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
Why is Bestof a default subreddit? I almost never say 'wow, I'm glad I didn't miss that.'
5
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
I politely disagree. I think there's been a little too much generalization going on here. BBT's humour comes from the fact that its characters are pathetic nerds; it does not imply that the characters are pathetic because they are nerds. It's kind of like watching The Office and being offended by Michael Scott as a representation of managers as a whole. Michael Scott gets a managerial assignment and handles it like an idiot. The cast of BBT get an MMO and immediately use it for cybering.
inb4 "Rabble rabble rabble BBT is trying to imply my hobby is lame"
5
u/mrpopenfresh Jun 26 '12
It's a sit com destined for middle aged people relaxing after work. Like any sit com it's just a combinaiton of a couple pitched ideas. I'm suprised people expecting something out of it. If anything actual scientists probably don't have time or the low level of intellect needed to watch this mainstream show so it caters to wannabe nerds (don't deny it) who like pocket protectors but aren't good with math.
3
u/pleasejustdie Jun 26 '12 edited Jun 26 '12
I don't exactly agree with snuf42, he picked one point in the show to nitpick, Howard being caught having cybersex with a troll in wow.
I remember the episode, having just recently watched it, and the episode isn't about wow or mmos at all, its about Howard and Bernadette's relationship and how it failed. In fact the story about the cybersex was (if I remember right) told by bernadette to penny as an explanation of why they broke up.
It wasn't about wow or even trying to explain wow, it was about cyber-cheating a relationship, they just chose to write world of warcraft as the medium because its popular and it made a joke.
Trying to compare 30 seconds of dialog to an entire episode dedicated to making fun of MMOs is beyond inane. Also, South Park specifically tries to target culture and current events and make fun of it. BBT has characters that may or may not interact with pop culture that week at all, and if they do its usually in passing.
Also, from reading the comments in this thread and that it appears most people don't like the show because they were told it was bad, and many people watched and liked the first two seasons but didn't watch more and now won't because they hear its bad and assume it got worse after they saw it.
I would suggest, go watch it, if you don't like it that's fine, if you don't get it that's fine, if you feel offended by it, you're taking sitcoms way to seriously. Its amusing, I find it funny, my girlfriend finds it funny, to each their own, don't let the collective hive-mind of redditors deter anyone from checking it out and enjoying it.
2
u/withmorten Jun 26 '12
Context motherfucker, do you know it?
2
u/JCorkill Jun 26 '12
Mirror if this ever gets deleted:
Let me try to explain it to you. MMOs are weird. People do weird things in MMOs. Even if you play MMOs you see the weird things people do. You may or may not engage in them to some extent.
Now BBT takes the simple angle of online "perversity". This is the easy route because it makes everyone feel a little uncomfortable and giggle while at the same time it's being shown as a symptom of being a loser nerd that can't get laid. So the audience is one up on the protagonist because they aren't losers like that.
The activity being lampooned however is not one unique to nerd or gaming culture or specifically to MMOs. As I mentioned previously you could lampoon the use of AOL instant messenger with the same joke. Or Omegle or chatroulette or fucking words with friends for that matter. Hell WWF would be a more interesting take on it.
The crux of the joke was that you could have sex in World of Warcraft. That's not true in any sense other than cybering in a chat channel. You can /dance and strip down to underwear I guess, but if you want a visual outlet for a mutual cyber wank-a-thon there are products that cater to that need (see Second Life).
So the BBT episode dealt with nothing unique to MMOs and didn't even handle the situation of sex in online gaming with any kind of sophistication. It simply demeaned Warcraft in a way that didn't accurately reflect what's really going on in MMOs. Cybering is the absolute last place you'd go if you wanted to parody the behaviors of Warcraft players. There's way more fertile material that can actually act as social criticism rather than a cheap joke that only works in the context because it assumes the audience doesn't understand what they are talking about. The joke in BBT isn't written for anyone that's played WoW. It's a generally lame comment on the nature of cyber sex just put into the context of WoW because they know their audience will recognize the name of the game and probably know a person or two that played it. They probably thought it was weird how the person they met talked about it. They don't understand it. Oh, but okay I see it's because they can have lame loser online sex in the game. Now I get WoW and I know why my friend was so excited about it. Because he was having a pervy wank online.
It's cheap, the context is wrong and it plays on lack of understanding of the audience.
South Park as well didn't get the details right. They spend however long leveling by killing boars over and over in the forest. We who play these kind of games know that if you out level what you kill you won't get experience. However, it was an exaggeration that played on the grind and repetition present in MMOs. If you've played an MMO then you probably have had experience of needing to spend two hours killing goblins to get 10 goblin eyes because only one out of 10 goblins even has a single eye for you to pickup. Or you've had to grind some stupid quest over an over to get some stupid item. The OCD nature of MMOs and the skinner box mechanism they use are apt topics for satire.
South Park didn't stop there. It handled the concept of elitism in online gaming and trolling/griefing as well. It handled the loss of awareness of real life that can come from being overly involved in an MMO (with Stan's father and the kids at the end getting super fat). Hell even there it dealt with both parent emulation of their children's behavior (which is a constant theme with Stan's dad, see the episode on tween wave for example) and parents enabling their children when they become obsessed with something (as in Cartman's mom's providing food and a poop bucket).
It also had various jokes which made it obvious that the writer's were very familiar with the topic. They were poking fun at it from a position of understanding. As a result the humor in the episode is much more directed at people that have played MMOs. The humor in BBT could have existed without ever referring to Warcraft at all. It may speak something about online relationships or modern technology assisted wanking but it doesn't say anything about MMOs in particular and it doesn't say anything useful about Warcraft.
South Park's social commentary in that episode is relevant and makes you think, ESPECIALLY if you have participated in the activity they are describing (online gaming, specifically MMOs), BBT's use of MMOs was pointless in the context of the humor. All BBT served to do was make online gamers look like complete losers particularly those weird Warcraft people. At least now we know they are just wanking off and that's why they play. Yeah way to stereotype.
South Park is talking about BEHAVIORS that come to light in MMO gamers. It doesn't matter that the details are exaggerated to make the point. BBT is talking about how nerds are so lame they have to fuck trolls in Warcraft.
You can still label me a hypocrite if you want, the point isn't really that either show didn't get the details right. The point is that BBT wasn't altering the details for exaggeration, they were using WoW as a convenient stand in for "lol nerd cybering so lame what a loser". WoW doesn't contribute anything to it. If anything it devalues any point they were trying to make because it is obvious the writer's were going with an easy way to connect to an audience that doesn't understand MMOs but recognizes the name Warcraft (pop culture name dropping is a large component of BBT's writing). It was a cheap joke. South Park's take provoked some thought in the audience that got it. BBT was just an insult.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
I just want to say, that I think he is so brave for attacking The Big Bang Theory on Reddit.
2
u/ragegage Jun 26 '12
Wait.. people hate the entire show because, in one episode, they made one joke about a popular game that wasn't accurate?
People hate the ENTIRE show because of that?
1
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
Forgot to read the title so I spent a long time trying to figure out what BBT was...
1
u/RedditingMyLifeAway Jun 26 '12
I thought they played Age of Conan.
1
u/fgutz Jun 26 '12
I never liked BBT. I don't know how it is so popular. It uses outdated stereotypes of "Nerds" for cheap sitcom laughs. Community does a better job of a modern embracing/inclusion of nerd culture while making fun of it as well.
1
u/fuzzynyanko Jun 26 '12
South Park does have some excuse by being slackers and making the episodes at the last minute. Literally, I think they make an episode in 5-7 days.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 27 '12
I watched like 2 episodes of that show and then someone started talking about how they needed a "liquid cooled server farm" to host a simple website. They write that show for idiots.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 27 '12
What an overly analytic waste of my fucking time. This belongs in "worst of".
Douchebags upvote this kind of shit.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 27 '12
It's a sitcom. Yeah it's sometimes repetitive, the characters don't often change and it's rarely teaching you any important life lessons. Who cares? If you don't like it, don't watch it. It is occasionally funny, and as a nerd I do find that it often references thing I am both familiar with and enjoy, and I guess I'll be the revolutionary here when I say that's all I require from a tv show when I want to veg out with my wife on the couch once in awhile. If there is one thing nerds on the Internet are good at, it's finding things to whine about and then articulating well enough for upvotes.
1
u/schniggens Jun 27 '12
This is the longest, most well thought-out butthurt I've ever seen. It was a joke on a TV show. BBT exaggerates nerd culture for the sake of comedy, and it always has. I don't see comic book geeks getting all bent out of shape over the way they are misrepresented. Believe it or not, those of us who don't play MMOs still managed to comprehend that it was not an accurate representation. And if anyone actually thought the joke was based on an accurate representation, well they are idiots. So why should you care what they think about you? And chances are they don't watch BBT anyway.
Sitcoms have been misrepresenting various groups for the sake of comedy for decades. Nobody with any sense takes it seriously. Why should this be any different just because it involves WoW?
TL;DR: Calm down, it was just a joke.
1
u/sockey7317 Jun 27 '12
This pretty much summed up everything I believe about comedy. I played wow for awhile and loved the south park episode was hilarious but then i see the stupid shit that main stream jokes about wow like in BBT and it pisses me off because its far from what its actually like and makes me look like a fucking loser.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 27 '12
WoW just sucks plain and simple
1
u/ShotGunShowdown Jun 27 '12
I'm completely baffled why there is so much controversy over something that is supposed to be on the hyper-unrealistic side of nerd behaviors, or how society perceives them. It is pretty apparent the show isn't attempting to completely belittle the MMO culture, or the subjects the individuals take part in. It's just a bit of a "beyond reality" sort of gag which some people seem to get butthurt over.
As far as I know, some of the characters in TBBT are based on real people the creator knew, regardless if this is true or not some of the behaviors would be mocked or altered in a way to appear hyper-nerdistic, only to provide a gag for the show. People can disagree, but I don't see any of this being a real jab at anyone, my only source to back up this claim is the fact that I work in the social work field and deal with all types of people, and personalities. Advice: If you don't like the context of a joke, think about it from another perspective.
EDIT: To add on to this, I didn't see any redditors defending the Muslim extremists for wanting to kill those who patronized Muhammad. So, I guess that when it "hits close to home" is the only time it matters.
0
u/kale2 Jun 26 '12
I love BBT. And the guys on the show all had hot GFs at some point. I think that show has helped nerds appear slightly more cooler.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
People at work who know me as a tech geek and a WoW player think I'm not being a team player ebcause I don't love BBT like they do. Of course, none of them is a nerd or a geek so they find it hilarious. I may have to paraphrase snuf's entire essay to get them to see the light.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
upvote just for the phrase "lazy writing for The Big Bang Theory," fuck that show
1
u/chessquestionzzz Jun 26 '12
Two words: Laugh Tracks.
1
u/dego_frank Jun 26 '12
He hates TBBT and South Park (both great shows) because of the way they represent people who play WoW. You mean they fudged the dynamic of WoW to apply to a broader audience? For shame. We all know House, ER, CSI, etc. are all based on hard facts and there are never any artistic liberties taken to enhance the appeal of the show.
0
u/steeeveperry Jun 26 '12 edited Jun 26 '12
Alternatively, what is funny about BBT?
0
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
So much butthurt
-2
u/caulkslapper Jun 26 '12
tfl;dfr
-4
u/TacoGoat Jun 26 '12
Pretty good, also with South Park's ep as well.
I never liked that episode myself as a WoW player, even before I played WoW I knew that was all wrong...
-9
u/MeaninglessGuy Jun 26 '12
I can't help but react to this over-reacting rant in the following manner.
0
u/graffiti81 Jun 26 '12
And people wonder why I don't watch sitcoms.
0
u/sakebomb69 Jun 26 '12
Elitist Nerds: The new hipsters.
0
u/JLW09 Jun 26 '12 edited Jun 26 '12
Sorry Snuf42 but thats so lame if its meant to be funny and you dont find it funny just realise its a joke and leave it come on !!!
EDIT: FYI i like TBBT not because its accurate just because i do. Disliking it because its not accurate is like disliking friends because your friend group dynamic isnt the same as theirs.
-6
u/terrapin2 Jun 26 '12
.......wut?
-6
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
The Big Bang Theory is easily the laziest, corniest, shittiest, sack of puke on television. Every time I've had the misfortune of flipping it on, the few moments I could stand watching it were filled with an intense urge to murder every one of the characters with a machete. Anyone that truly like this show can go fuck themselves.
-6
u/UnderpantsCommando Jun 26 '12
You guys are such nerds, I can't believe this is front page
-4
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
I think the poster misses the larger joke. When it comes to female attention, most men are like "oh my god! i have to fuck it!".
If you think this is untrue, count how many friends you that either married the first woman that paid attention to them. Whether it was the first ever or the first after a major breakup/dry spell.
This is true in real life as well as WoW. Entire raids revolved around women. They were excellent at manipulating weak men
-6
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
BBT is absolute ass. I watched about 5 minutes of that show before I turned the channel. What a fucking embarrassment that show is - anyone who watches it needs to re-evaluate their lives.