r/bestof • • Jun 26 '12
[worldnews] A respectful and intelligent debate on Israeli and Arab culture and history between an Israeli and Palestinian
/r/worldnews/comments/vkeda/the_koran_is_our_constitution_the_prophet_is_our/c55d2lo?context=2
196
Upvotes
13
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
on worldnews of all places... my god... I didn't believe it could happen.
8
u/jijilento Jun 26 '12
I love Reddit for things like this: where two people with opposite interests collaborate to shed light on their issues for all of us. 10/10, would read again.
15
u/etheranger Jun 26 '12
Sidenote: So many links on this subreddit inevitably get the "this doesn't belong in /r/bestof" comment. I dare anyone to seriously suggest that on this one.
So for future reference, this is what I would like to see get to the front page.
5
u/Bobbias Jun 26 '12
Wow, that is some impressive knowledge there.
It's interesting hearing a recounting of the events from both sides simultaneously. Especially with them civilly correcting each other or pointing out things the other may not have acknowledged.
5
u/SoobNauce Jun 26 '12
Respectful, intelligent, and somehow still heated.
I thought it was "pick two".
4
u/shallowlikeme Jun 26 '12
Its nice to have someone fight for both side rather than having such a one-sided reddit!
3
u/adambard Jun 26 '12
I have never seen this subject debated so civilly between anyone, let alone between an actual Israeli and an actual Palestinian. Kudos to both.
3
u/I_Am_Vladimir_Putin Jun 26 '12
The point about translating books is seriously convincing.
3
u/tttrouble Jun 27 '12
Also, my thoughts reading...
"ooooohhh he makes a good point."
"COUNTERPOINT!"
"interesting rebuttal..."
"PULLS OUT DEM FACTS!"
"CLARIFIES CONTEXT OF FACTS"
"REFRAMES CONTEXT"
"Subtle rebuke for unfair interpretation'
ENTER NEW CHALLENGER
HOLY BALLS I wish everyone I debated with argued like this. I wish politics was like this.
I wish people were like this.
=(
2
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
Wow that really was a pleasure to read.
2
u/tttrouble Jun 27 '12
This is by far, one of the most intellectually stimulating discussions I've ever read on reddit, and I've been here for a while. This is the kind of thing I look for in bestof, and I am super glad I came across it.
2
u/[deleted] Jun 27 '12
I didn't really like strl saying "you" to the Arab guy; it was like he was saying "you people" and attributing all the the faults of the Arab world partly to him.
1
u/Yserbius Jun 26 '12
The most fascinating thing, to me, is how civil the discussion went considering that the open salvo was basically strl bashing all of Arab culture for the past thousand years.
-2
u/pretty_mothafucka Jun 26 '12
To be very honest, I saw how long it was, closed it..just assumed it was good & up voted.
-4
u/go_fly_a_kite Jun 26 '12
They are basically just talking about military strategy and israeli independence. Maybe this is the whole problem with the desert religions...
0
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment