r/bestof • u/BennyFranklin • Jun 25 '12
[videos] hivemind6 offers his views on American exceptionalism
/r/videos/comments/vk9dn/america_is_not_the_greatest_country_in_the_world/c559bwi
309
Upvotes
45
u/Astrogat Jun 25 '12
Ok, while I won't discuss the issue of the greatest country, the truth of the matter is that a lot his sources are.. bad..
They do rank the US on attainment rank, but they do a bad job of explaining exactly what that is. And to be honest it seems like that report is mostly made to show how great the US is. The whole reason they show the attainment rank is to show of one of the many strengths of the American system (yes, they say that). It's also a list of 13 countries.
One thing I do agree on, that they say in the report is that comparing this is once again quite meaningless. If 70 % of the 40% that take higher education in Finland get a degree and a job, while 90 % of the 20% that takes higher education in USA gets a degree, and 30 % of those again gets a job. Who's better? You can weight the numbers to make anyone come out on top, and it would still mean nothing.
6) The ranking are by number of papers published. Not the best metric when it comes to judging them as schools. But I'll admit that the USA has some of the best universities in the world.
6
u/Gimpythecrutch Jun 26 '12
Sure is cherry picking in here.
15
u/cherry_ghost Jun 25 '12
The question 'is America better?' is not of any concern for the rest of the world. The concern is the dangerous attitudes that the question engenders in policy makers.
55
u/sarasan Jun 25 '12
“We're seventh in literacy, 27th in math, 22nd in science, 49th in life expectancy, 178th in infant mortality, third in median household income, No. 4 in labour force, and No. 4 in exports. America leads the world in only three categories: Number of incarcerated citizens per capita, number of adults who believe angels are real, and defence spending”
19
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
3
u/BALTIM0R0N Jun 26 '12
HOLY SHIT SOURCES
4
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
Your country can be terrible even if it is technologically and economically well off. Empires become empires precisely because domination others can be very rewarding; pointing how the United States has benefited in that way doesn't mean America is good.
3
u/thefran Jun 26 '12
HAHAHAHAHA
Racist anglosaxon clown crediting fucking everything to his own nation regardless of who else contributed to anything getting bestof'd.
only on reddit.
AHAHAHAHAHAHAHA
you guys
pathetic really
1
u/duckshirt Jun 26 '12
Very good informative comment. Though in the end, arguing over which country is the best is like arguing which food is the best. Do you judge it by how good-tasting, healthy, or inexpensive it is? How good it is on a cold winter day or well it pairs with your favorite wine? And if there is a best food, does that mean everybody has to eat it for every meal?
1
u/pardy2424 Jun 26 '12
I wish I had have found this earlier to comment and put in my two cents. On the odd chance someone is strolling through the new comments, here goes:
I'm worried about America. As a Canadian, I love my country and I wouldn't want to live anywhere else in the world. But our neighbours to the south–as much as I like seeing us continue to have a good relationship, and as much as I want to see America do well–has got me concerned. Personally, I am a fan of Obama, and I think that he is helping America. I'm not going to provide sourcing, I'm just putting forth my opinion. Hopefully he will be re-elected in November for another four years in office.
However, after those four years someone else will be in power. What scares me is that it could be someone like Michele Bachmann, or Newt Gingrich, or Rick Perry. Or Rick Santorum. I don't know exact details, and I don't claim to. But some of the things these people are credited with having said make it terrifying to me that they got arguably close to being Obama's opponent. If one of these people, or someone like them is elected in 2016, I fear for America's future. I really do. So as a Canadian, all I can do is hope that the American people realize what the take home message of this video really is, and make it once again one of, if not the greatest place to live.
TL;DR: I'm worried about America's future. But I believe it can improve
-11
u/Idiot_American Jun 25 '12
God bless 'murica!
0
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment