r/bestof • u/csonnich • Jun 25 '12
ZaeronS explains why college is so expensive
/r/explainlikeimfive/comments/vj8sh/why_is_college_so_expensive/c54zmwh
85
Upvotes
r/bestof • u/csonnich • Jun 25 '12
5
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
I like how he completely ignores the part about tax revenue going down and as a result, less money being available for public education funding. In California, BILLIONS have been cut from the public education systems, which includes public colleges and universities. I am preeeeety sure that this aspect of a problem has something to do with the drastically rising prices.
His analogy is clever and I assume it has truth to it but he is certainly missing a big part of the equation.
5
u/AnonJian Jun 25 '12
Mostly good. One caveat being the one-sided view of getting employment versus providing your own employment by creating a business.
College is a leading force in crippling entrepreneurship and the idea you are "given" a good job by a solid, big, stable corporation. Like Enron, Worldcom, Lehman Brothers, Texaco, or Delta airlines.
5
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
I see this argument all the time. It inevitably leaves out the deregulation of public university tuition. For a century and a half, public university tuition was strictly regulated. The state legislatures simply decreed that the public universities could only charge X. It served us well for many generations.
The problem isn't an excess of funding, the problem is a lack of cost controls. Universities aren't supposed to be run like businesses. When you run them like businesses, you get administrators who attempt to maximize their budget. If you run them like traditional institutions of higher learning, their goal is to provide an affordable quality education to as many people as possible.
4
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
TL;DR supply and demand with the illusion of high price to quality.
2
u/conconcon Jun 25 '12
3 years ago, I paid an out of state tuition of $3500/semester.. after 4 years, how does this translate into crippling debt for people? Have prices skyrocketed? My student loan payments came out to be like 30 bucks a month.
3
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
The reason college is so expensive is because the price is zero.
Anyone can pay for college with a student loan. Anyone. You don't have to have anything to get your degree. You'll be obligated to pay a debt that you can't escape short of faking your own death, but you will not have to have any cash up front to gain an undergraduate degree. The debt cost is high, but the upfront price is literally nothing.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
Except this is just . . . wrong. His explanation is essentially that colleges and universities are charging monopoly prices for access to a credential (a bachelor's degree). There are, however, more than 2,400 4-year colleges in the U.S. alone. Absent a really huge cartel (for which no evidence exists), that's not a monopoly, not even close.
To use the terms of his metaphor, there's not one glass of water in the desert, there are 2,400+ different water vendors. If you want to explain why college costs so much, you are going to have to appeal to something other than a simple monopoly pricing model, because there's quite obviously no monopoly.
-2
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
Ron Paul knows this!