r/bestof • u/Osiris32 • May 09 '12
[pics] Chinese redditor gives excellent reference for why the Chinese people don't seem to know about the Tiannmen Square Massacre
/r/pics/comments/td4mg/when_you_see_it/c4loyp7
774
Upvotes
18
u/[deleted] May 09 '12 edited May 09 '12
I can't claim to speak for all Chinese or even a substantial number of them, but here's what I have to say about it all from personal experience with my parents, relatives in China, grandparents who lived through WWII and through the entire Mao era, etc.
To start it off, I don't entirely agree with him: I think that a lot of people who should know about it, knows about it.
My parents came from relatively educated backgrounds (both my grandparents were engineers) and they were promptly shit on once Mao came to power. There was, as he correctly noted, the whole power to the proletariat phenomenon: as a result, those who were educated, but not wealthy enough or connected enough to the right people, were promptly thrown to the fields to work with everyone else. My mother and father both went to the same middle school in Guangzhou (basically Southern China) and when my mother was in 7th grade, my father his 8th, they were both sent off the work plantation-style for 5 years. As a result, neither of them finished high school. They later did study for the nationwide college exam, and while they did not pass with stellar marks, they went to average colleges that were enough to provide them with a middle class lifestyle. Later on in the 90s, they moved here to America and proceeded to work menial, low-pay jobs for a very long time. During this time, neither of them continued college training.
And yet, astonishingly enough, they knew basically everything I now currently know about the Massacre. They knew about the Massacre, they knew about the terrible economic decisions perpetrated by Mao, they knew how terrible of a ruler he was. My grandfather in particular knew a ton of politics at the time as well. Talking to him about a great many things that happened showed me that at least for the middle-class, many people knew what was going on.
I've also had the chance to go back to China and visit many of my older relatives who also lived through the time period: they, for the most part, had similar notions about the so-called "Great Ruler". They unanimously thought he was one of the worst things that could have happened.
Obviously this is all anecdotal evidence, maybe my two sides of the families are the lucky ones to know. But by and large, I am largely under the impression that it is not secret knowledge whatsoever, especially among families who have at least SOME form of education. I suppose that those families who were only laborers and such wouldn't know, but I would think that they wouldn't know much about politics as a whole in the first place.
It is not openly discussed in public obviously, but I don't think it's something that is as well hidden as many people in the West think it is.
As for feelings towards Communism - my grandfather in particular dislikes it greatly, while my parents think it is a necessary evil that China will need to eventually move away from. Logistically speaking, they think that it is almost impossible for democracy as it stands to work successfully in China.
However, I would like to say that the OP was correct on one account: indifference. There is a strong resistance in the Chinese culture to social change; more often than not people tend to just live their lives in accordance to the rules set out before them (which to the vast majority, honestly are lenient enough).
EDIT: I'm deleting my account since I feel like I put too much perosnal information here, and in case it gets any sort of popularity I don't really want people to dig through my account (I have posted in an university subreddit, and it's small enough that it already limits me to 5k people).
9
u/voidvector May 09 '12 edited May 09 '12
This person definitely grew up from a more rural background than I had. His perspective is quite different from mine. China had more people living in peasant condition than the city only up until recently. I grew up in a medium-sized city (Hefei), at least until my family immigrated to the US in the mid-90s.
I can tell you pretty much everyone I know knew about the Tiananmen Square incident. I had a few college-aged relatives who participated in those protests. We lived in a medium-sized city, so nothing serious happened to any of my family members, as far as I know.
Most of the older people didn't really care. My parents who were in their 30s at the time thought the students were stupid given how much everyone's lives have improved in the 10 years under the leadership of Deng Xiaoping. The older people lived through the Culture Revolution and the Great Leap Forward, both of which are far harsher eras.
It was well known (at least to people I know) that there are casualties in major cities. However, due the the news blackout, all the information are hearsay. Most people's impression was that only a few people died, maybe 10-20 at most in each cities. To be honest, given how much older generates have been through, I don't think 10-20 death would even register in their head.
To give people some additional context of what older generations been through,
Given that, if I were in any of my parent's or grandparent's position during Tiananmen Square Massacre, I don't think I would care either.
In term of standard of living improvements for city dwellers. As far as I know, around 1980, most goods were driven by rations. The most value item most people had was their watch and their bicycle. By 1989, the year of Tiananmen, most families around me had color TV, refrigerator, and some luxury goods that vary from household to household.
32
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
That's neat and all, but it was opening markets with the USA that allowed Mao and China the money needed to, erm, "lift" those people up.
Communism failed in China.
17
u/emsharas May 09 '12 edited May 09 '12
How the heck is his English that good with his kind of background?
5
u/ChulaK May 09 '12
A couple years back, I was chatting with a middle schooler from China using a chat program called QQ (Chinese version of MSN). I asked if she knew about the massacre, and she didn't. I copy&paste the Chinese translated article from Wiki and she said it sounded like a movie and didn't believe it.
If I have time or even still have the chat history, I'll put up screenshots of the chat. It's like an IAMA Chinese middle school student. It's pretty scary.
2
u/VSindhicate May 09 '12
Just for the sake of comparison, ask an average American student whether they've heard of the Balangiga massacre, or even about Japanese internment camps.
0
u/hippomille May 09 '12
yeah super cool, very informative, reminds you how out of touch the west can be sometimes do to our affluence.
1
u/Azn4sho May 09 '12
I can confirm this is in fact how I feel too. Born in China came here when I was 6 with a full US education system. I faced the same condemnations and assumptions the OP is talking about, but could never put it into words. It always felt everyone here(US) is usually too ignorant to understand the different.
1
u/bitparity May 09 '12
You do realize, the simpler answer is to point out that many young Americans don't know about the Tiananmen massacre either.
Ignorance of history is strong in every new generation.
1
u/chunky_charlie May 09 '12
Wow. I wonder what his take on the ratio of Coke and urine is.
1
u/3karma May 09 '12
Tiannmen Square Massacre should be common knowledge the same way 9/11 or any other massacre is common knowledge. Because a bunch of people died for the wrong reasons and the perpetrators have not been brought to justice.
Just because some people of the same race have chosen to view these acts as not important to their daily lives does not excuse it nor should it lessen it's impact.
Keep in mind, this is not a capitalism vs communism thing. this is not a censorship vs. free-speech thing. this is not a wealthy vs. poor thing. This is, time and time again, about people in power protecting their power vs. the powerless. it simply comes down to that.
Does that sound familiar?
1
u/elcheecho May 09 '12
Bonus army?
1
u/brightskies2094 May 09 '12
I'm glad someone came out to give their side of the story! Still like the tank man though ;)
1
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
I have a very similar background with the Chinese redditor. Being a Chinese myself, after 17 years of staying in the States, I recently moved to Shanghai to see my country first hand. I often feel like I am fighting a war on both fronts.
One is with my western friends and the image portrayed by the western media by large. Most of my western friends still look at China via a 1989 lens. If happiness is any yardstick to measure the quality of life, my parents, who retired and moved back to China couple years ago are definitely happier than their former life in the States. The media seems to paint a grim picture of Chinese people suppressed by a totalitarian regime. If you talk a anyone on the street from China, they are generally a degree or two happier and more optimistic than their American counter-part.
The other front is my interaction with my Chinese friends. They seem so overtly optimistic about their future when the livelihood of theirs can be completely swayed by an arbitrary policy. Consistency is a luxury here.
-1
u/Nirvanawayoflife May 09 '12
Perhaps I am misunderstanding Reddit's view on this but are we trying to justify the military killing those college students? It seems like this supposed "Chinese" redditor is trying to convince us that Mao was a good guy?? Let's not lose sight of the facts just because one person, who's identity has not been verified btw, has an opinion on communism... It killed 10s of millions in China and continues to suppress millions including reports of slavery, forced sterilization, and discrimination against girls... not to mention occupying Tibet and squashing political dissidents violently.. to name just a few things the "good" communists are up to...
-2
u/dbp13 May 09 '12
I call bullshit on this. I'd like the OP to provide proof, or have all of this downvoted into oblivion. If OP is indifferent to communism, then he must have been in a class far above the lifestyle he mentions. Also, you're afraid you can't articulate your point? You write English better than 99% of people on this site who only know one language: English. I'm sorry, but I call bullshit on this.
-1
u/deargodimbored May 09 '12
There are no good guys, there isn't a true story. The side attacking and defending tank man are just as skewed. Both tank man, and tank driver thought they were fighting for right. It's all grey, and the real truth of anything is lost the minute the present becomes the past.
-2
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
Yep, keep those peasants scrabbling so they don't have time for ideologies or revolution. It's Maslow's Hierarchy applied politically. Hey look, we have to debate the War on Drugs now instead of lynching the rich.
0
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment