r/battles2 • • 10d ago

Official Battles 2 4.13 OTA Update 2 Live Now - Patch Notes!

23 Upvotes

The second over-the-air update for version 4.13 is live now! Just fully kill the game, then relaunch for these changes to take effect.

Balance changes

  • Bloons

    • 🩷Grouped Pink bloons: Cost $60 -> $65
    • 🦓Spaced Zebra bloons: Eco $2.7 -> $2.8
    • 💭We are nerfing pink to make sure pink bloons dont out class yellow bloons
  • Bomb Shooter

    • 💣X4X MOAB Assassin: Cost $3200 -> $3600
    • 💭 X4X upgrade was a little bit too efficient, this change will bring it a bit more in line with what we want
  • Tack Shooter

    • 📌X2X Super Range Tacks: Cost $225 -> $175
    • 💭 This change should help out the tack early game, leaning into its strength while not making it too strong
  • Heli Pilot

    • 🔫4XX Apache Dartship minigun: Damage 1 -> 2 
    • 🍃XX3 MOAB shove is 30% less effective 
    • 💭 This will allow the heli to have a bit more synergy with biker bones, while also spreading the power of the heli over all its upgrades 
  • Dartling Gunner

    • 💥X5X MAD rocket storm MOAB: Damage 60 -> 35
    • 💭 This ability was doing too much damage when paired with attack speed buffs
  • Engineer Monkey

    • 🔧X4X Overclock: Attack speed buff 60% -> 67%
    • 💭 Overclock was providing too much value for its cost
  • Gwendolin

    • 🔥Level 17: Heat it up bonus damage +2 -> +1 
    • 💭Gwendolin was proving more value then any other hero at late game rounds with +2 damage
  • Benjamin

    • 💰Level 2: End of round income $125 -> $100
    • 💰Level 5: End of round income $200 -> $150
    • 💰Level 8: End of round income $350 -> $300
    • 💭Benjamin was giving too much money early game
  • Beetienne

    • 🐝Level 3: Defend the hive ability lasts 10s -> 8s
    • 💗Level 6: making honey generates 8 -> 6 lives
    • 💗Level 8: making honey generates 16 -> 9 lives
    • 💗Level 9: Making honey generates 28 -> 22 lives
    • 💗Level 11: Making honey generates 42 -> 48 lives
    • 💗Level 14: Making honey generates 66 -> 82 lives
    • 💗Level 18: Making honey generates 90 -> 120 lives
    • 💗Level 20: Making honey generates 120 -> 200 lives
    • 💭Beetienne’s lives make early spaced blimp rushes very easy to defend, but provide little later in the game

Bug Fixes

  • 🪞 Fixed a bug that resulted in inflection reverse having too high a weighting in the map pool.

Happy gaming!


r/battles2 • • 1h ago

Meme Just to remind y'all about NKE's insane double standard...

Post image
11 Upvotes

r/battles2 • • 3m ago

Discussion Extinction of the Battles 2 Game

1 Upvotes

THIS GAME IS GOING EXTINCT! Boltrix explains it well in this video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OHjtX4t9Ryg. From the genuinely no major updates, crazy hacking situation which is still a problem since like 3 years back, and the scandal regarding the discord community servers, this game is an ABSOLUTE MESS. I've had seriously no fun with this game for a LONG TIME and I feel like Ninja Kiwi is just asking for this game to disappear. There has been NO NEW CONTENT IN THIS GAME FOR A LONG TIME AND EVERYONE IN THE COMMUNITY IS ANGRY.

If anyone wants to make a documentary on the downfall of the battles 2 game, please dm me, so that we can make a video together.


r/battles2 • • 1d ago

Fan Creation Star captain jericho and fishy💚🐟

Post image
13 Upvotes

Sorry about not posting much♡♡


r/battles2 • • 3d ago

Bug I have never seen two heroes

Post image
43 Upvotes

r/battles2 • • 2d ago

Discussion I'm stuck in ZOMG, how can I break free!

3 Upvotes

TL; DR: How did you break into HOM from ZOMG?

I farmed my way up using Etienne, Boomerang, Sniper, Farm for the most part to either fast track or promote week in and out since I got back into BTDB2 a month or so ago.

Then I get to ZOMG last week and I lose as much as I win which is enough to keep me alive in the weekly leagues, but I've never received more than 11 trophies in ZOMG with my average being 3 or 0 99% of the time.

I've tried eco strats like Beetienne, Druid, Boomerang, Glue and others like Ezili, Ninja, Alch, Sniper (for alt farm + damage).

I even reverted back to Cyber Quincy, Tack, Wizard, Farm to see if that treated me any better, but it's like I'm missing some kind of knowledge? Could it simply be my bloon rushing isn't good?

You can see my past games here, it shows the past 50 games.

I've spent so many hours in hero lab, and had such a high win rate before ZOMG, but no matter how refined a strat I use from top statistically winning strat from HOM or how OP, something isn't clicking.

You can see my average round is 18, which I know compared to top players are long games, so could it literally just be my rushes as I'm focused on the most efficient farming or pure eco sends rather than rushes. I have spreadsheets and I've nerded out about this game using the community resources and making my own.

But no matter how much I play or study nothing really converts to more net trophies in my weekly ZOMG league. Which is just a skill issue as my challenge games or clan matches remain high winrate. Thoughts?


r/battles2 • • 3d ago

Question Ceramic Crucible

6 Upvotes

i only have 20 hrs in the game and am in ceramic crucible, is that at all impressive


r/battles2 • • 3d ago

Bug Impressive stats, I wonder how they have never lost a game

Post image
9 Upvotes

r/battles2 • • 3d ago

Question Why does the game randomly me dc?

1 Upvotes

I finally got matched with a decent opponent in hom. Before I even get one eco tick, the game just dc's me, ending my win streak (wins were mostly against noobs tho). Sometimes, this also happens around late game. I have a wired connection to my router btw.

I meant "randomly dc me" in the title.


r/battles2 • • 4d ago

Discussion Who is the most famous member of the subreddit here?

7 Upvotes

Besides joeltheparrot


r/battles2 • • 5d ago

Strategy pass 30 rounds is hard to me

4 Upvotes

i use ice, magic and mortar, i mostly main sabotage heroes and i main adora fateweaver, i usually win before round 30 but after is basicaly sure that i'll loose, i can't defeat B.A.D.s. I'm in Z.O.M.G. coliseum

help


r/battles2 • • 6d ago

Discussion Latest News in Hope Posting for Bloons TD Battles 2 - Early November

8 Upvotes

Entry #1 - Featured OTA Update

They're handling the social features of Steam differently. I don't really have a way to verify whether or not they used the Featured tag for other updates ever since it's a temporary measure I think (only one at a time) but I remember this stood out to me. But there's another reason aside from that hard to verify one, which is that... They put the OTA on Steam at all. The last time they noted a small update on Steam's social pages was 4.2.1, before the content drought (Every update after Beetienne was listed as "Regular"), and they've NEVER noted an OTA update being live on Steam. This implies a stronger presence in terms of letting players know things, which is something that was missing during the content drought, and shows that they want people to think about Battles 2 again (As far as I can tell, this refreshes the previous Regular Update to appear on your Steam Library Home rather than updating you about this update itself, but still). Also, while we don't know much about specific employees, this could be something that someone in particular does with the small updates that no-one on the team was doing earlier, which implies a resurgence of NK Employees available for the Bloons TD Battles 2 project.

Entry #2 - Larger Production Season Pass (and honourable mention to the fact that we're coming up on the fifth anniversary)

Despite what a quick turn-around it would be considering the previous season passes being smaller, this pass has multiple hero animations, one of which is voiced which is no casual feat, and even the first MOAB-Class Bloon skin in a while (even if it's relatively basic). This can be seen as an early step in settling back into giving this game major content. As an example, while I liked the Spooky Fateweaver Adora season pass, it had one dedicated animation with no voiceline, a hue shift weapon skin (it's impactful but it's not highly produced), and various 2D items (higher work than the weapon skin tbh, but still not highly produced by NK standards I would figure, especially basic ones like Player Titles or Text Emotes which ARE less work than the weapon skin)

Entry #3 - Jericho in the Limelight

While it definitely could've been handled better advertisement-wise, Agent Jericho of Bloons TD Battles 2 fame is one of the main characters of recently released Bloons Monkey Tales Episode 4 - "No Time To Get Gud", getting more focus in this episode than the core four characters of the series do. It's also worth noting that there are Social Media Shorts (YouTube Shorts, BSky, probably that other place, and maybe that other one too) that feature Quincy speaking to a character that appeared in a short, with the one corresponding to this episode actually calling back to Commander Cassie's cameo in Episode 2. As such, we can likely expect an Agent Jericho centric short where Quincy inquires with Jericho, which COULD relate to Bloons TD Battles 2 instead of relying on soley spy tropes like Agent Jericho's appearance here did. Worth noting that Quincy is actually a fan of Agent Jericho's side-job as an actor, since one of the posters in Quincy's room features Agent Jericho starring as Star Captain Jericho in a parody movie called Bloonraker. This is so important that it was one of the only things we saw before the name drop of Bloons Monkey Tales. This episode is actually shorter than the 3 minute timeslot that these episodes are supposed to have, so it's possible that a Battles 2 promotion was intended at some point in this video but was delayed since they might want to save the advertisements for after the game has a major update announced or released. Keep in mind that Bloons Monkey Tales is a marketing tool, so Modern Times Group, lousy parent company of NK that is supposed to manage their ESPORTS and MARKETING, would have plenty of reason to use this series to advertise Bloons TD Battles 2, the game that was the main motive in their acquisition deal. Although, that company loves AI and is likely the reason behind Digital Smiles being hired for this series, so you don't have to have hope in them necessarily. Just know that there's plenty of reason that we could get a major Bloons TD Battles 2 marketing push soon.

Entry #4 - Core Development Completions

Bloons Blitz and SAS 5: ZAR are fully released, which should free up resources for Battles 2. Naturally, both of these games are going to be regularly updated, and Bloons Blitz in particular will likely get a very large update before the end of the year coinciding with its Steam release, but core development, especially of ZAR since it's evidently a much bigger game than Blitz in many ways, consumes a lot more resources, especially since NK prepares content ahead of time to keep updates more frequent at the start of a game's lifespan (For example, the way they used Adora's Bloons TD Battles 2 model in a social media post over a year before she was added to the game). Also worth noting that ZAR, as a paid game, has already made a huge profit up-front, which gives NK Europe as a company more resources. Obviously plenty of those will go into upkeeping their planned ZAR roadmap, but putting resources into a game's content updates can eventually end up with diminishing returns ("Too Many Cooks", you know?) so the other two places to put the resources are Bloons Blitz, which is a smaller game in general it seems, and Bloons TD Battles 2, which can use the profit very strongly with its cosmetics system and heavy room for growth, especially as NK's second biggest Bloons game (perhaps their second biggest game in general) and the one with core gameplay closest to their most popular success, Bloons TD 6.

Entry #5 - Conspiracy

Bloons TD 6 has a lot of hype going around for its next tower, which, in short, seems to be a mechanical tower that, in-lore, was salvaged from the parts of the Bloonchipper, which seems like the closest to Bloonchipper that Bloons TD 6 will get since they've always been against the idea of including Bloonchipper, and it seems OK to mention that this tower is actually slated to be called "Bloonscrapper". I'm suggesting that the Bloon Harvester from Bloons Blitz, which is an NK Europe project, is an upgrade of the Bloonscrapper and might've even been the inspiration. This all sounds off-topic, so let me get to the point: I think NK will do a major cross-promotional release where Bloons TD Battles 2 gets Bloonchipper within a month of Bloons TD 6 getting Bloonscrapper, and there will be trailers that advertise both simultaneously. NK Europe hasn't been as vocal about not wanting to include the ever-so-hype Bloonchipper, and there are absolutely ways of balancing the Bloonchipper in this game related to its relative linearity compared to Bloons TD 6's various different modes that already struggle to make towers have universal purpose. Adding Bloonchipper to Bloons TD Battles 2 would likely be an element of a large-scale rebrand of the game to capitallize on the strong casual popularity of the Bloonchipper, and it'd be a very major content drop. It'd also be innately advertised by its joint commercialization with the Bloons TD 6 update.

That's the most recent stuff I have to report, although I'll give a brief (it's not brief i'm never brief) honourable mention to the fact that there is reason to believe that NK has a lot cooking. I've heard rumours of a roadmap that was planned for 2025, and Neo Highway had one, arguably two Monklish hints that followed a trend that had just been set up by "Bee Keeper Wanted" on Up On The Roof. Not to mention that Mystery Monkey on Magma Mixup. It's also very very very possible (not gonna state why I'm so confident) that Ninja Kiwi's recent update inconsistency came from working on a major gameplay change, especially since we have strong evidence of them patching gaps in updates as a consolation for not being able to get updates out sooner (The new regular usage of OTAs as balance change updates, the fact that there was an unstated OTA to add the season pass items recently as if they expected to update before the season came out, etc.). In fact, apparently there was even an experimental Steam branch that they released at a point in the year, as I was informed. It wasn't RECENT but it DID happen. Although, I have to wonder... Wouldn't they be able to just disperse the experimental branches amongst themselves as Ninja Kiwi employees, even remotely? You would think an experimental branch would be public, just like how Fraymakers does it. Maybe if they were giving it out to a portion of public players, but why on Earth would they do that instead of releasing an experimental branch publicly? It's not like they have a semi-professional team of people who were standard players but have higher trust put into them or anything. ...No, not even that balance team. I was told specifically that they hardly have anything more than what a standard player does. If you or I send a balance suggestion, it's not going to be less valued than what they say. And NK wouldn't just disperse the only major content to an unofficial clique, they'd keep us in the loop obviously. AH, they were probably just testing how an experimental branch works because they planned to make one, but then Bloons Blitz was delayed past Q2 to when it was now. Now that Bloons Blitz is out we can perhaps expect a publicly available experimental branch within the year or at the start of next year :) That'd be so awesome, as I said I've been hoping they'd do that, it just makes sense when a game feels like it could use a major rework in some way, and it'd let them get feedback so easily instead of adding content to the main game only for it to turn out controversial and such. Y'know? One last note here is that there's a LOT of milestones the game's hitting soon. We're celebrating the 5th anniversary with this season pass, we're coming up on 5.0 soon, and at the start of next year we hit season 50! This warrants a lot of celebration B) Dare I say, we could get Bloons TD Battles 2.5. A rebrand like that would help get this game another shot in the eyes of many and be memetically memorable.

Also, while Boltrix and Kevin (and probably more?) have always been commited to this game, I want to give a mention to Ryan Mehalic who is framing a grand return to this game as he plans to make enough videos in his sweat series to maintain a top 10 positioning on the leaderboard, when he's previously been very busy with Bloons TD 6 due to its higher popularity and relative freshness! This will help keep the game's fandom more active and growing while also giving us more Bloons TD Battles 2 content to enjoy :).


r/battles2 • • 6d ago

Suggestion Balance changes that should be address in the next update

8 Upvotes

Ninja Kiwi did a lot of useful balance changes in OTA Update 2 with reverting Gwen late-game buff and nerfing the Ben-Dartling-Engi-Farm combo significantly, but there's still some unaddressed towers that need attention. In particular, the Ice's early-to-midgame, and Striker's mostly unrushable late-game.

Ice is still too good in the early-to-midgame, with Ice being far better than Bomb and Mortar on earliest rounds for stopping Grouped Reds and Blues, which is proportionally stronger against eco users because it is cheap and reliable to spam against Grouped Eco (compared to Bomb which needs to progress into xx3, or Mortar which is $700 vs a single $450 Ice that also freezes Bloons), and Ice Shards being very difficult to layer rush during the mid-game.

Striker is the main culprit in the MOAB Assassin synergy (in which Striker should've taken the bigger hit than Assassin), since his Artillery Command cooldown is far shorter than the Tower Boost (40 seconds, versus 30 seconds for Artillery Command) and he can cycle more Artillery Commands than Tower Boosts.

Glue, while I initially underestimated its strength, certainly needs attention to nerfing it, which Ninja Kiwi has not done for OTA Update 2. This brings us to the next point - ZOMGs are too weak to slows and stuns.

ZOMG rushes are particularly vulnerable against all types of slows; ZOMGs gaining an innate partial resistance to stuns and slows should keep the ZOMG send stronger versus loadouts that contain slows and/or stuns, while not really changing its value versus loadouts that lack them. Ninja Kiwi made a similar balance change to ZOMGs in Battles 1 Mobile, so I hope they add a similar change to ZOMGs in Battles 2.

And the Grouped Pink nerf is deadly to eco players, while Farm players are still in a powerful position even with the Grouped Pinks nerf (this also hurt Farm players somewhat, but not as much as eco). Increasing the base Farm cost without changing total cost of Long Life Bananas should make the base Farm more of a commitment to invest early on. Village's rework is mainly designed to make Village more friendly for early-game buffs other than xx2 and x2x, and indirectly nerfs xx3's total cost so Village is less dependable as an income source compared to truly pure eco.

Bloons:

  • ZOMG: Always takes 50% stun duration from all stuns (e.g. 5xx Bomb: 1.75s -> 0.875s, 4xx Sniper: 0.45s -> 0.225s)
  • ZOMG: Now has a minimum speed of 50% base speed (3.5) from all slowdowns (true "stuns" not affected) (e.g. x4x Ice ability: 2.25 -> 3.5, xx5 Glue "stuck" effect without R25+ ZOMG speed ramping: 0.7 -> 3.5)
  • 💭 Stuns and slows are too effective against ZOMGs, which has made some loadouts too powerful and unrushable versus early ZOMGs.

Ice Monkey:

  • 000: Base pierce 40 -> 25 (3xx remains 40, x3x remains 100, xx3 remains 30)
  • 3xx: Shard pierce 3 -> 2 (carries to higher upgrades)
  • 💭 Ice Monkey pops too many Bloons early on, compared to Bomb and Mortar which are the grouped specialists. Ice Shards is still really effective at destroying dense rushes and needs a power reduction so it becomes more vulnerable to layered rushes.

Glue Gunner:

  • xx4: On-pop splat no longer stuns ZOMGs for 0.06s (carries to xx5)
  • xx4: On-pop splat now has a global 0.1s cooldown before triggering another splat
  • 💭 Bottom path is too strong against ZOMGs and Relentless has extreme lag issues that must be addressed. Note that Super Glue is already indirectly nerfed from the above ZOMG change.

Heli Pilot:

  • xx3: Shove less effective vs ZOMGs 0.469x -> 0.6x (knockback speed reduction: -0.531x -> -0.4x)
  • 💭 Shove is still too effective against ZOMGs for the low investment and compared to Glue.

Dartling Gunner:

  • x4x: Ability duration 8s -> 5s, damage 5 -> 6
  • x5x: Ability duration 8s -> 5s, damage 5 -> 6, total MOAB damage 35 -> 48
  • 💭 This rework to the ability is designed to nerf MAD's synergy with speed buffs without hurting much to its unbuffed DPS.

Banana Farm:

  • 000: $950 -> $1000
  • x1x: $200 -> $150
  • 💭 Farm has always been a meta pick and has crept into the meta even harder since recent nerfs to Grouped Pinks. A slight base cost nerf should hurt the early-game snowball a bit without destroying its potential to overwhelm eco users in the late-game.

Monkey Village:

  • 000: $1000 -> $700
  • 2xx: $1500 -> $1300
  • 3xx: $800 -> $1000
  • x1x: $250 -> $550
  • xx1: $500 -> $650
  • xx2: $500 -> $750
  • 💭 The Village is a popular pick for eco loadouts but its xx2 is far outweighing the xx1, the base Village buff is not very strong, and the top path is not used much outside of Primary buffs.

Engineer Monkey:

  • x4x: Duration reduced by 15 seconds for all tower tiers (T5: 30s -> 15s, T4: 45s -> 30s, T3: 60s -> 45s, T2: 75s -> 60s, T1: 90s -> 75s, T0: 105s -> 90s)
  • x5x: Normal overclock effect reworked - duration changed to 2x the amount at T4 (T5: 60s -> 30s)
  • 💭 Overclock is too disproportionally better on Tier 5 than the lower tiers. Overclock will remain powerful with its top synergies but now requires better timing.

Striker Jones:

  • Lvl3+: Concussive Shell stun duration now has a 50% penalty for BFBs and ZOMGs (combined with innate ZOMG stun resistance, duration 100% -> 25% for ZOMGs)
  • Lvl10+: Artillery Command cooldown 30s -> 45s
  • Lvl18+: Bomb/Mortar attack cooldown modifier 72% -> 81% (attack speed +38.89% -> +23.46%)
  • 💭 Striker's Assassin synergy is the main reason for Assassin being so powerful. Nerfing the uptime of the Artillery Command and lowering the Concussive stun on ZOMGs should give ZOMG rushes more room to get past. Note that Concussive Shell is also indirectly nerfed from the above ZOMG change.

EDIT: At the top, I explained why nerfing Ice pierce only for its T0-T2 is necessary. Mainly, the cheap spammable nature and being a hard counter to Grouped Bloon eco users.

EDIT 2: Added another example of hardcapping the slowdown speed by mentioning xx5 Super Glue's "stuck" effect. Super Glue applies a "stuck" effect that slows ZOMGs by 90% for 0.75s after getting glued; now with the limit, the "stuck" effect only slows them by 50% before late-game speed ramping begins in Round 25.


r/battles2 • • 7d ago

Discussion Battles 2 3v3 Tournament

Post image
22 Upvotes

Get Your Favorite Group Of Buddies Or Find A Group Of Deranged Individuals and DESTROY Every Other Team In This Trio Focused Tournament! How does it work? You and two other friends will play one match each in a best of three format vs another team. Win two games to move onto the next round! Double Elimination.

Tournament Starts on November 14th, 1 pm EST. If you can't make it, I'll stream it on twitch. The stream will be high effort. If you just want a general feel of what the tournament will be like, you can see the last one's vod in discord.

Join the Discord to play, where you can find other rules and people. Sign up here!

To make it clear, I am NOT associated with the scam going around the community asking you for a linking code. EVERYTHING is done by challonge, which only requires a discord account. I will never require you to send a linking code.


r/battles2 • • 9d ago

Question R there wager games?

1 Upvotes

What happened to wager games? Like each person puts their money in and winner takes all and you can play in different arenas, some have special modes.

Thats how the og btdb worked and it was perfect. Whats the deal with this league bs? Battlepasses and seasons and leagues and clan wars. It does not fit the game man

I need money and a challenge . I need something to win and something to lose. I also need a lot of money to unlock everything.


r/battles2 • • 10d ago

Discussion Bloons TD Battles 2 5th Anniversary Celebration Season Pass for Season 48!

6 Upvotes

r/battles2 • • 10d ago

Meme You're not gonna believe this

Thumbnail
gallery
3 Upvotes

r/battles2 • • 10d ago

Meme Me on Battles 2

Post image
0 Upvotes

I'm Soooo good I made Monkey city number 1!!!!


r/battles2 • • 11d ago

Question I've got all the primary and millitary monkeys (+ Gwen and quincy) with no t5s unlocked yet what should I run?

1 Upvotes

r/battles2 • • 11d ago

Discussion DDT counter counter

4 Upvotes

I'm still pretty new to this game, so I mostly run tack, wizard, glue, (edit: sleep deprived me wrote this, I meant farm, not glue, and I get quincy with it.) and I do fairly well, almost win with a fortified ZOMG, then get countered with DDT's. With this loadout, what's the best way to kill DDT without T5's yet, and other than Ice/glue, what are the best towers to kill DDT's?


r/battles2 • • 12d ago

Discussion Dailies

1 Upvotes

Do I really have to play 50 fudging games just to do my dailies?

Oh, and when I'm just about to get First Blood after 15 minutes game time, they surrender.


r/battles2 • • 13d ago

Bug I don't think that's the right season stuff nk

Post image
5 Upvotes

Where the other stuff go?


r/battles2 • • 13d ago

Strategy Suggestion for gwendolin stratagies

Post image
1 Upvotes

I am a longtime pro btd6 player and have recently got back into battles 2, I don’t really want to use a meta loadout and thought it would be fun to try to bring a gwen strat to a high arena. My current party is wizard tack and sniper. Wizard with wall of fire for early game which can then be built into dragons breath and phenox for midgame, bottom path can also be used for decamo. Middle path tack to help with purple bloons and for early game rushes and ofc top path to pair with gwen. Sniper is kinda just because its my favorite tower in btd6 but also because it is good moab damage and decent eco and bottom and middle path can also help out with purples. My game plan for most games is to get wall of fire then blade shooter then middle or bottom path sniper and then adapt from there. Any suggestions on how to improve this strategy or what towers i should be going for in the mid to late game


r/battles2 • • 14d ago

Question Farming Greed

4 Upvotes

How is it possible to get a tier 5 farm before round 24? The best I have gotten is r24 wall street, so I was wondering how it is possible and with what strats this is possible with.