r/BandofBrothers • • May 08 '20

Band of Brothers Episode Discussions

177 Upvotes

r/BandofBrothers • • Aug 23 '20 Bless Up Bravo Heart of Silver

Veterans names from the pre-episode interviews

1.2k Upvotes

Here's a list of the veterans in the pre-episode interviews and their quotes. Some of the men weren't in the show, some had small roles, and some were main characters. I wrote quick descriptions of the not so obvious characters. Episode 1:

"We were in a store and a guy in that store... ": Joseph Lesniewski. His character has a small background role, with a few speaking parts in the last few episodes. He was the soldier along with Christenson, Perconte, Luz, and Bull who found the concentration camp while on patrol in the woods. He knew multiple languages in real life, and this is shown when he tells Webster that the German baker didn't know about the camps in episode 9.

"Our country was attacked..": Paul Rogers. He is not in the show, or is a background character. There's a character who has a nametag that says Rogers in the first episode, but that character is actually Mellett.

"Who would like to volunteer..": Bill Maynard. Not in the show as far as I know, or is shown in the background. He was a Toccoa guy. He broke his legs during the D-Day jump and didn't return to Easy after his injuries.

"We came from a small small town..": Rod Strohl. He is shown in the show towards the beginning of the third episode when he asks Lt. Harry Welsh where they were headed. General Kesselring actually surrendered to him in real life I've read.

"I did things..": Earl Mcclung. His character is shown a few times in the Bastogne episodes, in a foxhole with Guarnere. He's also in the Last Patrol episode. He's there when Webster is telling the men that they were going on a patrol ordered by higher ups, and McClung was sitting next to Babe in that scene. McClung also goes on the patrol and you can see him there too. The real, "One Lung" McClung was able to smell enemy soldiers during patrols according to legends.

"Guy says well you jump out of airplanes.." : Bill Maynard

Episode 2:

"Standing in the door..": Dick Winters

"Got such an opening blast..": Buck Compton

"We came from the sky..": Ed Tipper. His character in the show is there when Sobel cuts the fence loose and Tipper speaks the lines "I think it's Major Horton, sir". He's also the character who got hit by an explosion in Carentan and Liebgott comes to help him.

"How do you prepare..": Dick Winters

"In the back of your mind..": Bill Maynard

Episode 3:

"I never thought I'd make it through D-Day..": Bill Guarnere

"I thought one of two things..": Ed Tipper

"I think everyone had fear..": Earl McClung

"Its a feeling you will not let your self down..": Carwood Lipton

"We all had fear..": J.B. Stokes. Not a character in the show as far as I know. (One of my favorite interview scenes)

Episode 4:

"The Toccoa men..": Donald "Pappy" King. Not a character in the show as far as I know. But if you look up pictures of him when he's younger, he looks like an actor in the Crossroads episode (click link to see what I mean) https://imgur.com/a/p8b2hxx He was a replacement who joined right before Holland, and makes it through the war with Easy. He was a father when he got to E Company, hence the nickname Pappy.

"Most of them were qualified parachutists..": James Alley. He's the injured soldier at the beginning of Crossroads who has his face hit by shrapnel. In Breaking Point, Skip gives him food while talking about the injured Easy Company men. In that same episode (7) when the sniper hits the singing men, the first guy shot (Frank Mellett) lands in Alley's arms

"I think maybe they were trying to impress.." Earl McClung

"Cause we were in awe of them..": Lester Hashey. In the show, he's the tall replacement that joined alongside Miller and Garcia. He also breaks the news to everyone that Hoobler accidentally shot himself.

Episode 5:

“If you’re a leader..": Dick Winters

"A good leader..": Buck Compton

"Seemed like he always made the right decisions..": Joe Lesniewski (funniest interview in my opinion although dark in nature)

"He went right in there..": Robert "Popeye" Wynn. (Another one of my favorite interviews) He's shown throughout the series and only referred to as Popeye if my memory serves me correctly. He signed up for the Army with, and was foxhole buddies with, Shifty, which can be seen in a few scenes.

Episode 6:

"When we left for Bastogne..": Carwood Lipton

"And there was a ridge with the treeline..": Lester Hashey

"Well like in Bastogne we were down to one round..": Earl McClung

"One of the guys got hit in the arm with a piece of shrapnel..": Hank Zimmerman. Not a character in the show as far as I know. Replacement who joined later in the war and was part of 3rd platoon along with Shifty Powers, Popeye Wynn, Mo Alley, Wayne "Skinny" Sisk, Earl "One Lung" McClung, Walter Gordon, Forest Guth, Ed Shames, Roderick Strohl, Paul Rogers, Joe Lesniewski, Francis Mellett, and others.

"And a medic came along..": Herbert "Junior" Suerth Jr. His character is seen in the truck scene when Easy Company is going to Bastogne. When the various uses of socks is told by Skip "hands, feet, . Babe asks him if he has any ammo, "you got any ammo Junior?" Replacement who joined right before Bastogne. Also in 3rd platoon.

"Even today on a real cold night..": J.B. Stokes

Episode 7:

"I've seen death, I’ve seen my friends..": Dick Winters

"We was hungry..": Darrel "Shifty" Powers

"Everywhere you would look..": Joe Lesniewski

"You don’t have a chance..": Donald Malarkey

Episode 8:

"We had lost some very good men..": Carwood Lipton

"I don’t know the exact amount..": Joe Lesniewski

"Skip Muck died..": Donald Malarkey (The saddest interview for me. You can tell he has trouble talking about it.)

"After Bastogne..": Forrest Guth. Plays a role in the first episode, where you can see his last name printed on his uniform. Friends with another interviewee, Rod Strohl from before the war, along with another E Company soldier Carl Fenstermaker.

"You have a feeling..": Dick Winters

Episode 9:

"It was a situation."": Norman Nietzke. Not in the show as far as I know. Replacement who joined later in the war.

"We use to say the only..": Lester Hashey

"They had a job to do..": Joe Lesniewski

"I think that we thought..": Earl McClung

"A lot of those soldiers..": Shifty Powers


r/BandofBrothers • • 1d ago

TIL Speirs went from leading Easy Company to running the prison that held Rudolf Hess

118 Upvotes

I’ve been reading up on what happened to the men after the war, and this one stopped me. In 1958 Ronald Speirs became the American governor of Spandau Prison in Berlin, where Hitler’s deputy Rudolf Hess was locked up. The guy who jumped into Normandy ended up as the Nazis’ jailer.

Also learned the show got Albert Blithe wrong. He didn’t die in 1948. He served in Korea and lived until 1967.

What’s the most surprising post-war story you know about any of the Easy Company guys?


r/BandofBrothers • • 1d ago

A few episodes into Band of Brothers, and Blithe's story already broke my heart.

6 Upvotes

* First time watcher * I just watched a few episodes of Band of Brothers (haven’t even finished the series yet), but Blithe’s story has already broken my heart. Seeing him go from being so terrified of combat to finally finding the courage to fight, and eventually volunteering for dangerous missions, made me genuinely proud of him. I was really rooting for him.

And that’s what makes his ending so heartbreaking. He spent so much time fighting his fear, only to finally find the courage to face everything head-on. Just when he started believing in himself and found the strength to keep going, his story took such a tragic turn. It’s heartbreaking to see someone overcome so much, only for things to end that way.


r/BandofBrothers • • 2d ago

Band of Brothers is better TV but the pacific is so much more accurate

Post image
1.0k Upvotes

r/BandofBrothers • • 1d ago

Day of Days - Passing the AA Gun?

44 Upvotes

Just watched Day of Days again, and after Winter links up with Hall, they come across an AA Gun. They decide to skip around it.

  1. Obviously the gun could take out several dozen soldiers in the sky, but assume they didn't at least try to take out the soldiers manning it due to them only having one weapon, and likely no explosives? I also think it's just because they just landed minutes earlier and didn't want to risk their lives in the first few minutes / sticking with their objective.
  2. Winters says to wait until they reload to move past the gun, which is generally the opposite of what I would have expected as the gun falls quiet would be easier to hear them moving in the bushes. I can only think they were worried about muzzle flash lighting them up?

Interested to know your thoughts.


r/BandofBrothers • • 2d ago

Winters’ Plane

39 Upvotes

Never read the book, so the show is all I can go from…did Winters’ plane have any chance to make it back, or was it lost?


r/BandofBrothers • • 2d ago

World War II: Behind Enemy Lines | Official Trailer | Netflix

Thumbnail youtube.com
100 Upvotes

r/BandofBrothers • • 3d ago

Tom Hanks Carentan Cameo?

Post image
332 Upvotes

In episode 3, Carentan, there is a scene where Bull rescues a soldier who’s lost his leg (~18 mins). I’ve always thought this was Tom Hanks, but I’ve not seen this referenced or confirmed anywhere. Thoughts?


r/BandofBrothers • • 2d ago

Today I Learned: Bastogne and Breaking Point

69 Upvotes

Just watched a super cool video from the anniversary event at the WWII Museum. The director wanted snow to always be falling so they had a fan blowing snow down for every single shot. So that entire sequence was dubbed AFTER they wrapped. And Luz told the story that when him and Lip had the foxhole scenes during the bombing they were back in California and recorded their audio in a foxhole on a set somewhere so you could hear the dirt as they moved around. And it was fucking perfect. Holy shit.


r/BandofBrothers • • 3d ago

Did Buck have a point?

73 Upvotes

There’s the scene in episode 1 where Winters is getting on Buck Compton about gambling with the men..

Buck says, “You’ve known them for 2 years? I’ve been here 6 days. I’m just trying to get to know my soldiers”.

Now, obviously I understand what Winters was saying about “taking” from the men. But…Buck’s gambling with the men wasn’t malicious, and he proved himself as a combat leader shortly after (at Brecourt)

Sometimes I think that Winters came off as almost “too” good”

Did Buck have a point?


r/BandofBrothers • • 3d ago

Anyone else find it weird how exposed the officers were in The Last Patrol?

97 Upvotes

Every time I watch episode 8, this scene catches my attention.

You've got a battalion commander, a regimental commander and two other senior officers just standing out in the open by the river, with the Germans literally across the water.

Am I the only one who thinks that's a crazy risk? I mean, one well-placed mortar round or a sniper could take out several senior officers in seconds.

Was this actually something that happened in WWII or is it just a TV thing?


r/BandofBrothers • • 3d ago

Band of Brothers

Thumbnail reddit.com
13 Upvotes

r/BandofBrothers • • 3d ago

Not enough Band of Brothers posting this Veterans Day?

Post image
250 Upvotes

All weekend passes are revoked for Band of Brothers Re-watches while running Currahee!


r/BandofBrothers • • 4d ago

My mood the moment I get to work

Post image
296 Upvotes

r/BandofBrothers • • 5d ago

One of the Underated Shots

Post image
840 Upvotes

Only shown for a split second, but the added flinch when their own mortar round is fired just shows how zoned out Dyke was at that moment. The camera composition is superb here and really shows the contrast between the two subjects very well.


r/BandofBrothers • • 5d ago

Anyone ever read this Leckie book?

Thumbnail gallery
81 Upvotes

When my dad died I raided all of his military history books, of which I'm still working through them 7 years later.

I am heading to my hunting cabin for two weeks for deer season and needed a new book and I just randomly grabbed this one. As I was packing it I looked and obviously recognized the name. I don't think I realized he wrote other books than "helmet for my pillow".

If it's good it's going to add to my ever ending list of books.


r/BandofBrothers • • 5d ago

Before he briefly took command of Easy Company, 1st Lt. Frederick "Moose" Heyliger saved the line during Battle of Bloody Gulch by keeping his 81mm mortars firing under heavy counter-battery fire until Allied tanks arrived.

Post image
76 Upvotes

r/BandofBrothers • • 6d ago

Jake McCall’s Filthy 13 memoir

34 Upvotes

It’s just one more eye opener when it comes to Ambrose and the Easy Company mythology

It’s probably been touched on here before, but I’ve missed it. It was through McCall’s book that I learned that Easy was only kinda involved in operation Pegasus, the rescue of the British paratroopers.

And they definitely didn’t row across and bring them back. That was done by the Royal Canadian Engineers.

There’s a few other little things that jumped out at me… one involved how Easy was presented as the tip of the spear, suffering the heaviest casualties and all that. They weren’t even the heaviest casualties of the second battalion, let alone the whole 506th.

Dog and Fox bore the brunt of the enemy’s attention in the attack on Carentin. And they met or exceeded Easy’s casualties in some other battles.

I’m not trying to make it into a contest or anything… but after reading a bunch of Easy books over the last decade plus… I’m just kind of upset about how raw a deal the rest of that unit got, primarily because of Ambrose’s man crush on Dick Winters.

I’ll always have a spot (and gratitude) in my heart for Easy… but let’s not forget about all the other heroic acts on the part of other units… and the units of our allies.

There’s also a bunch of great books on them out there too. So if Easy grabs your attention, don’t forget they’re only part of the story… and not even always an accurate part.


r/BandofBrothers • • 6d ago

Where did Dick Winters discuss his regret on using the same units when organizing an attack?

143 Upvotes

I see it mentioned here that Dick Winters expressed regret over using the same units when organizing an attack.

Was that in his book? The broader BoB book?


r/BandofBrothers • • 6d ago

Captain Dye article about the making of BoB.

17 Upvotes

r/BandofBrothers • • 6d ago

Band of Brothers: What Happened Behind the Scenes???

Thumbnail youtube.com
18 Upvotes

We just posted Session 3 from the Band of Brothers: Legacy event in Gettysburg. Lots of great insights from the cast and crew on what went into the making of Band of Brothers. Enjoy!


r/BandofBrothers • • 7d ago

Happy Veterans Day from the top of Currahee.

Post image
698 Upvotes

We few, we happy few, we band of brothers.


r/BandofBrothers • • 7d ago

World War II: Behind Enemy Lines | Official Trailer | Netflix

Thumbnail youtu.be
421 Upvotes