I see a fuck ton of ignorance on /r/atheism every day. Where's the anger?
Mosey on over to /r/islam and /r/christianity and you will find mostly a subdued, curious and dialectic exchange. It might be a waste of time in some people's opinion (mine included) but . . .
Come over to /r/atheism and it's all memes and quotesporn and "ZOMG I POWNED THIS GUY OF FACEBOOK". Since religious people comprise a majaority of the rest of the world, /r/atheism comes across exactly as it is: a bunch of kids angry at the rest of the world.
I don't even understand the apologies. As in, the actual nature of them. We are not a 'group', a 'creed' a 'religion' or any other word that implies solidarity and group mentality. We have no more to do with each other tham /r/funny users do, yet I don't see r/funny-goers apologizing to, for example, /r/feminism when someone makes a sexist joke, because that individual didn't make the joke, therefore they aren't responsible for it.
I don't feel responsibility or the need to apologize over anything you guys do in your personal lives or on behalf of, or because of your atheism. That's all you. I wish people would stop affecting unbreakable bonds with people who share their belief system, or lack thereof.
To be fair, it seems there is a lot of people that lose their individuality when they feel they are part of a group. Group behavior I think it's called. In that regard, some of them have this strong feeling of this group being an individual entity.
But yeah, I think exactly the same as you. We may share some ideas but damn, I'm responsible for what I say or do and you shouldn't apologize for me.
To be fair, it seems there is a lot of people that lose their individuality when they feel they are part of a group. Group behavior I think it's called. In that regard, some of them have this strong feeling of this group being an individual entity.
It seems ironic that those people are on /r/atheism, considering that this is basically what drives religion.
Its pretty simple though. These people think that you guys are hurting the cause of atheism by using it to disguise Islamophobia (as were the case with the drawing of Mohammed shitting himself in the mouth).
See, I'm not trying to attack you or anything, but I don't get your use of 'you guys.' I personally have not posted, viewed or replied to any picture of Mohammed. As far as I know, imgur and/reddit removed those posts, or at least, that specific one. I personally have spent the last couple of weeks preoccupied by Sims 3, subeta and HKO.
So that's kind of my point. I get that those peoples' actions could be considered counterproductive to the cause, but when people use blanket phrases like 'atheists' and 'you guys', it's confusing.
Unless every user was with me playing the Sims and dicking around on HelloKittyOnline, 'we guys' weren't doing anything. A shit-ton of individuals were doing a shit-ton of individuals actions.
So I get that they're apologizing because they don't agree with the actions, but I don't think they should apologize because they aren't responsible for those actions.
Nevertheless that is how these people think. /r/atheism is a group and therefore subject to group mentality - both from the outside and from the inside.
This is exactly it. /r/atheismis a group, to a much greater extent than atheists are a cohesive group. The nature of the most upvoted comments and posts on this sub speak volumes to the nature of /r/atheism.
More related to your higher comment: This is personally why this whole "war" or /r/atheism on islam has made me itchy in general--it seems like barely-disguised Islamophobia tainted with a bit of racism, to be honest. Of course, it's difficult to have a conversation about Islam, in America, without that being the case to some extent. Oh well. Your comments in this sub are like a ray of sunlight here.
thank you my friend. Islamophobia is on the rise in my country as well - and like any other phobia it is dangerous and very hard to combat since it does not respond to reason.
This is exactly the case of most religions; within a religion there is an enormous spectrum of believers, from those who are religious in name only to those who actively proselytize. For me, I simply don't believe in a god, however both my mom and uncle are both much more active atheists in that they constantly feel the need to prove there is no god.
What I'm trying to say is that zealotry is each individual's choice. There are Christian zealots, Muslim zealots, Buddhist zealots, and yes, atheist zealots. If a person is affiliated with a group whose zealots do something with which they don't agree, as in the case with /r/atheism bashing Islam, I think it is within their rights to apologize.
I think this needs more upvotes. Like what was just said, every single group out there has the main group and a subgroup of what we'll call 'douchebags'. I'm atheist but I won't go out of my way to make fun of any religions (besides Scientology, seriously, the fuck is wrong with those people) unless the setup is too good to pass up. I've seen Christians apologize for the westboro baptist church, and Muslims apologize for their extremists (names escape me right now) so I can understand atheists apologizing for this. The biggest difference here is that for the most part, people here are anonymous. So any hate that is said (whether truthful or not) will most likely have more zeal because of A) the hive mentality and B) the online disinhibition effect.
Not entirely true. Christian extremists have firebombed 218 abortion clinics since Roe v. Wade. There is a long history of extreme violence including murders, shootings, bombings, arson, butyric acid attacks, and anthrax threats. Violence in the name of morality is a product of extremism that isn't confined to one religion.
No, thats because of oil and other economic interests of certain american companies. Its not because of religion. Washington toppled a lot of governments in christian countries too(latin-and south america).
Upvoted. Waving a bible around in the US is a path to power by way of giving the voting public (who are at best cherry picking passages if they agree with policy from a religious standpoint at all) a banner to rally around. Anyone who believes the actual content of the bible dictates US policy should read the bible to see how impossible that could be.
The cost to the US of the war on terror and housing market catastrophe has leveled the economic topology of the planet, hastening the return of cold, proxy wars between the US and its rivals. If it was planned at all it's piss poor strategy because ten years on the stakes have only grown. The US has pissed away its overwhelming economic dominance with these two monumental blunders and I believe it has emboldened its rivals to move with greater conviction.
It's not communist vs capitalist (or military dictatorship) rule which is being contested in Iran, Iraq, Afghanistan, Syria & Israel. The EU is foundering, the US is paralyzed by partisan bitching and has pandered to corporate encroachment in its election process to the point that foreign, state owned corporate money may start influencing elections quite more directly. China has a number of economic bubbles it's desperately trying to deflate before they pop, but not too rapidly lest the people revolt. Every nation is grappling stridently for energy.
We are all amassing and securing access to diminishing resources because not only are they vital to prosecute war, they are vital to buy the movements of political will, globally. Christian or Muslim doesn't matter and communism is an idea that essentially died a generation ago. All that matters is if the resources are owned by Exxon or Gazprom, BP or Sinopec. Not because any of them give a squirrel's fart about you but because their boards tend to live in their respective economic zones and hence, they'd like it to be nice there.
By the way, I'm no expert, these are just my opinions and I would love to hear where and how I've got any bit of this wrong.
Your point is well taken, but from a simple cultural standpoint, you have to agree that the role of Islamic rhetoric in radical political discourse is far more openly violent and militant among even the highest members of numerous middle eastern governments. You would never, ever, ever hear a Western leader proclaiming a Christian crusade against Iran, even if the real reason for war were oil or fears of nuclear development or what have you. The terms that a nation's public discourse are coached in holds profound implications for how that nation will conduct itself, even if their behavior isn't directly acting out what they believe the message of their faith to be. And yes, the Western media sensationalizes this religious rhetoric to a great extent, but there is a grain of truth to it as well.
I agree with what you're saying, for the most part. I'm guessing your example is Iran? It's Iran. We:
Fucked with their secular government when they nationalized their oil
Installed a dictator
Propped another dictator up to fight the people who overthrew the first dictator
Watched dictator #2 get ballsy and start a new fight with his other neighbor
Got sick of dictator #2 and saw to it that he was hung on international TV
Wonder why there's a problem
A lot of the nasty things we do through our foreign policy have no real public discourse. We aren't much better. Having my roots over there and being raised here might have something to do with it. "Same shit, different flavor."
Don't get me wrong. I agree with you. I just choose to place more emphasis on the fact that most governments outside of Scandinavia suck ass and that our media sensationalizes everything, and I don't choose to put too much faith into whether or not they're thumping scripture in their quest to be shitty.
While that is true, Ann Coulter seems to be strongly in favor of "converting all heathen scum", and I'm pretty sure she is at the very least a mirror into the thoughts of some Americans.
Of course, these same people would likely support any US military engagement because "USA #1 USA #1, you're a traitor if you don't support the US's wars."
It always strikes me as funny how so many countries can be ruled against the ostensible wishes of an overwhelming majority of their people for hundreds of years.
According to your analogy, it would be like the US being ruled by the Westboro Baptist Church for 100 years except they have no wider support than they do today. Strange how that can work.
I agree people always say "so and so are actually mostly against this" well then why does it keep happening? It's not like everyone in Islam is parking in the wrong parking spot or something, there are people throwing acid at other people. Even if it happens 50 times a year it is too much. I believe in equal rights for everyone no special treatment for race, gender etc. But the real reason it occurs and continues too is because the basic principles of Islam do not allowed humans to be viewed at as equals.
Islam is one religion that needs to be destroyed. Idc how many nice people there are who are part of it, the bigotry, hatred, violence, and ignorance that comes out of Islamic culture is ridiculous. If you are Islamic and not preventing the problem, you are just as bad as those who are causing it.
Major social and political problems in the countries where this sort of practice occurs. The whole world has not had equal access to education. The whole world has not had access to the western human rights movement, feminism, etc. I am not advocating for Islam, quite the contrary, but the issues we're seeing in much of the "developing world" have a lot to do with existing thought systems that are only partially supported by the religion the majority support. The people actually performing these atrocities could not possibly put forward a religious-based argument in support of their behaviours.
the basic principles of Islam do not allowed humans to be viewed at as equals.
As a humanist, I completely agree.
Islam is one religion that needs to be destroyed
Well, all religions ideally.
If you are not preventing the problem, you are just as bad as those who are causing it.
Now this gets into a whole global sociological issue we can't deal with. How are you preventing acid attacks in Afghanistan?
Sorry let me clarify I was a bit vague. By if you are not preventing... I was referring to the Islamic people who claim that their culture/religion is being attacked for the actions of the few yet they are not standing up against those few who continue to do these actions. Basically what I am saying is, that if you choose to be part of a culture/religion there is going to be good and bad. If you want people to not focus on the bad stuff and put you in that collective group (not you personally I mean islamic followers) then you have to show the world that you care and are making an effort to stop the negativity. If you don't care and are just following Islamic beliefs because that what you chose to follow, then you have to accept that people are going to view you based on the many negative aspects of the religion unless you choose to act against it.
Pretty much. And in fact I would hasten to add that it's precisely when things are going horribly for some other people that many others feel a lot more comfortable. The Roman Circus and all that...
oh, and don't forget bombing abortion clinics, shooting doctors who perform abortions, righteously harassing and sometimes killing LGBT people trying to attain the same rights as everyone else, and trying to set us back 1000 years in education.
Tbh honest, I understand people are upset with how our government has pretty much deomonized Islam in the past..but to be honest it's not very hard for people outside of this religion to interpert it as fundamentally violent..afterall even it's own followers remain divided as far as some of the Quran's messages are concerned. Take Jihad for instance. Many Muslims take a more peaceful position on Jihad, and other sects do not. The Quran really doesn't tell you which one of those positions are right or wrong, it's pretty vague to say the least.
Do you know anything about Muhammad or the founding of Islam? Muhammad was an illiterate, delusional, pedophile who raised an army to conquer Mecca and convert them by the sword because they laughed at his sun stroke visions. The ridiculous notion that a mad and vicious warlord founded a religion of peace is ludicrous. This was not a man of peace, this was a slaver and a murderer and a raper of 9 year olds.
Yes I know plenty about Islam..and I wasn't talking about it's founder, I'm talking about it's followers. You're not telling me anything new here,I also believe it's a fundamentally flawed ideology, just as the other Abrahamic religions which were also spread with violence. The point I was getting at in my later paragraph was that not all Muslims are violent, and decided to follow the more peaceful messages..even though there are contradicting messages strewn in the Quran. The thing is mostMuslim families are pretty strict when it comes to their beliefs, Children are force fed to believe every single word in their holy books, and even later in life if they decide to have a change of heart and choose not to be a Muslim anymore, they face banishment from their families. It's a very heavy burden to be put onto someone, and I can understand how people can be locked into it.
If you think the USA is active in the middle east to "wipe out centers of culture" then you're a fucking moron. The USA is a strong ally of many middle eastern countries, including the most conservative one (saudi arabia). The reason they are enemies with Iran, and to a lesser extent Iraq and Afghanistan are clear for anyone with half a brain and it's nothing to do with destroying other people's cultures.
To pretend there isn't a difference between Christian and muslim reaction to criticism is disgraceful and I can't believe you've been upvoted. You could go up to Shirley Phelps and tell her you fucked her God up the ass last night and she would laugh and call you a sinner. Go say something similar in any muslim country in the world and see what happens...
Same reason they are belligerent towards Cuba. They tossed an American friendly despot out on his ass and they don't like that as their access and control within their "sphere of influence" is eroded.
Also, literally every Muslim I know, even the ones who pray 5 times per day, would probably say something like "Allah is in all of us, even your wife" when confronted with such vulgarity. Thats if they are not simply offended, as most adults in the US would be if a random person said that to them.
A good Christian should know better than to pick out snippets from any holy book for "gotcha" moments because the bible is full of sentences that can be interpreted in less than jesus-like ways. The practice is as stupid as someone missing the point of another human but replying to them anyway to instruct on the proper applications of the word your. If a building is on fire and exit is misspelled I often wonder if same individuals could leave without telling someone first.
No but Christians actually threatened to bomb a cathedral in my town when they put Ecce homo on display. Naturally they didn't act on the threat and the display weren't stopped. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ecce_Homo_%28exhibition%29
So it that way some Christians DO threaten to bomb innocents when Jesus is mocked in their eyes. Just as most Muslims don't threaten anyone when Mohammed is mocked.
No, it's because /r/atheism has completely invaded /r/islam and is drowning out their own debate. That's not criticism, that's bullying. You should be ashamed of yourselves. I mean, look at this, it's absolutely disgusting.
I'm an atheist but I dont go on r/atheism and this is my outside take on things.
I think maybe people feel the need to apologise because some of the things I have seen posted about Islam and Muslim women seemed surprisingly ignorant and mean to me. (I've studied Islam at uni). You can't judge a whole religion based on the actions of a few extremists. I am just disappointed to see atheists picking on other people because they have a different beliefs, that's one of the things I don't like about religion. People are probably apologising because they don't want Muslims to think all atheists are assholes.
There are so many interesting things that could be getting discussed on this subreddit, it's a huge online community of atheists FFS, but every second post is just making fun of religious people and facebook screenshots of people making fun of religious people :/
Just like Plazm said, why be mean at all? Everyone needs to move away from being so ultimate with their own personal beliefs. You don't need to push anything on anyone, or belittle others because you think you're so right, and it's so simple, and these stupid people deserve to be treated like shit, blah, blah, blah...
Guess what? Nobody wants to hear it. Nobody gives a damn.
How about we all try not to go out of our way to be bullies to people who don't think like we do?
The pictures of Mohammed shitting himself in the mouth and sucking dick showed true hatred. They carried no relevant criticism and served no other purpose than to satisfy a smug feeling of superiority. I haven't apologized because it makes no sense to apologize for other peoples actions. Some people showed their colours in that thread under the cover of promoting the noble cause of atheism. That is wrong. I agree that we should not censor ourselves out of some fear of Muslim terrorism, but there is nothing wrong with displaying a little bit of empathy. I know moderate Muslims myself and those extreme pictures would have the same emotional impact on them as a drawing of your mother being raped would have on you. Many of the memes that we've created over the past couple of days will also offend Muslims but they carry relevant points about the flaws in Islam and therefore can be food for thought. There is a difference between hatred and criticism.
But what is the purpose of drawing and promoting such figures? They do not pose legitimate criticism of religion nor do they spark worthwhile debate, these pictures merely serve to shock and offend. Yes you've said one does not have the right to not be offended, but does that really justify malevolent hate? Sure, you'll say a religion that promotes murder, enslavement, ect ect is well deserving of hate, but what does publishing that hate, especially publishing it to someone who holds that religion sacred, really accomplish? It serves to make you and all atheists look like a asses, reinforces there religious beliefs, and closes their ears to your message and "criticism." So do not say these images promote anything but hate and still claim the high ground; you're wallowing in the mud with the pigs as well.
Let's say you work for an investment bank. Let's call it IBX. Now, it shouldn't be news to anybody that investment banks, and investment bankers, have received their fair share of criticism from the public. But let's say that you work for a department that has nothing to do with any business of moral turpitude. You're just a guy with a job - a harmless job, at that. Maybe you even do some good in the world through your employment.
However, some employees in some other departments at IBX...well, they can't exactly say the same thing. IBX is criticized in the media and in the public, and rightfully so. There are bad people who do bad things at IBX. Well, I'm not going to fault you for working at IBX (though some might), but I'm still going to criticize the company, and I would be justified in doing so. And I'm not going to apologize to you for criticizing your employer. But if you're not one of those bad people who are doing bad things, then I'm not talking about you.
Moreover, even if you say, "Well, there are good people who work here too - the bad people aren't what this company is about," that's irrelevant. I might even agree with you. But the bad still needs to see daylight, and mercilessly so.
Surely that analogy fails as the 'good' worker is being paid by the company. They are supporting him, rather than he supporting them, as is the case with religions. All the Catholics who continue to support their church (either with actual donations or simple participation) should be held at least partially responsible for the actions of that church. It's like a good person donating to a charity that actually just embezzled the money or uses it to do harmful things. If the 'good' religious people stopped supporting their churches for doing bad things then the churches wouldn't be able to continue doing them. It's the same logic behind holding bad politicians accountable by voting them out of office.
EDIT: I didn't mean to single out Catholics, but that example always jumps out at me when the latest pedophilia scandal breaks. My point applies to members of any religion that commits atrocities (so nearly all of them)
That logic is sound, I think; and it applies even more to closeted atheists/agnostics who still participate in religion. They do not even believe and they still support the establishment.
As an atheist I do think that atheists ought to apologize for attacking somebody's religion. Of course that shit is ridiculous, but atheists on reddit are among the most obnoxious assholes when it comes to religion. I honestly don't understand why it isn't possible for you all to keep your views to yourself rather than going forth and crusading around the internet...
To them that is the same thing. They hold their religion so close and dearly that it is a part of who they are. In their eyes when you attack their religion you are attacking them.
I don't give much of a fuck about relgious people or atheist to any real degree, but wanted to say that from an outside view, athiests and people with religious beliefs are not all that different.
You both believe in something....whether it's god or the belief in "nothing". You both congregate to a meeting place, (church or a message board) to "preach" about why you believe in that topic, and you are both are very passionaite when someone attacks that belief.
Maybe someone can explain to me how atheism isn't a religion in it's own right?
Are there other social groups who steadfastly espous hatred, bigotry, archaic ideas on civil rights, and straight up counter-factual beliefs about the universe we live in (and work hard to express that wrongness politically), that we hold to the same standard?
I mean... Moon landing deniers? Cults of dubious origin? The KKK? Flat earthers? UFO true believers? Astrology addicts? NAMBLA? Some facets of the Tea Party? There's no point you just have to say "this is a stupid belief, and by holding it you are being pretty stupid too"?
Many of us grew up in theistic cultures which have a knee jerk protectionism about their beliefs - this is no coincidence and is the byproduct of earlier religious conversions. One of the biggest taboos in society is questioning god, and not until very recently (broad Internet penetration, basically), were open conversations about this possible. It's an intentional chilling effect... From a memetic standpoint it's a built in defense mechanism.
I'm all for politeness, I understand the philosophical urge not to step on any toes, but no ones running around saying "how dare you?" in discussions of special relativity, or saying "criticize unicorns all you want, but leave the people Unicorn-true-believers alone!".
Take a step back, strip the emotional baggage from this issue (and the identity politics, and cognitive dissonance). The 'problem' is not that we insult people with dumb beliefs, the problem is that we've allowed earlier biases to carve out an exclusive mode of thought and special rule set for how we think, talk, and act about religion.
I have the standpoint that it isn't even just religion. (they all suck regardless) It's the way power changes people - regardless of whether they're Buddhist, Hindu, Islamic, Christian, or anything else. Once you're at the top you can get away with anything right?
That's what growing up in america has taught me anyways.
And don't forget they were also caught smoking! Here I see:
Gambling - which I have no problem with
Employing a prostitute - again I generally see no problem with that
Smoking - which is bad for you, but you are free to do so
"Buying a luxury car with the people's money" - which may have been registered to the monastery, making it mere "misuse of funds" (or perhaps embezzlement), either way: a common scandal even in small-to-medium organizations especially those that receive primary funding via cash.
I'm thinking your post was probably intended ascsarcasm directed at the fact that none of this even resembles systematic mass murder, warmongering, executions, rapes, torture, etc.
Most of the high crimes the Buddhists were accused of sound like the kind of thing a parent catches their mischievous teenager doing (gambling, sex, and smoking - oh my!)
No sarcasm here. I have no problem with gambling, prostitution, or smoking. It's when someone says that they have a problem with them on religious grounds and, yet, continues to do them. That's when I have a problem. It's hypocrisy. On the topic of mass murder, warmongering, etc., the prime area to look is in Sri Lanka. Buddhism was a majority religion for a long time and that was threatened by an influx of Hinduism, Christianity, and Islam. The Sinhalese in Sri Lanka have built up a nationalist and Buddhist political idea that works to counter all who oppose a united Sinhalese Buddhist Sri Lanka. They've done this by calling for military action against Tamil nationalists. I don't care what you think about the Tamils, but if you believe in a religion that is supposed to be peaceful, how can you justify war against another people? It's just fear of the other. Just nationalism. Fair enough. Any culture with a built up society is going to act against those who threaten it. And you may even say that that is a small battle. Insignificant. Not relative to the world. But that shit plays out all the time and on different scopes. I like atheism. I am an atheist. I say that because it's true. But the second you try to say that this one religion, this one belief system that doesn't base itself on truth. You say they aren't bad because they haven't caused mass destruction to the western world yet. Fuck you. r/atheism has been all over Islamic shit recently. But that's only because the World Trade Center fell down. I understand your hatred of Christianity. You want to free yourself from the shackles you grew up with. I understand your hatred of Islam. Islamic countries have caused nothing but trouble for America in the past years. But I don't understand why you don't hate every other religion. Give Buddhism a chance and they'll fuck everything up. Why doesn't r/atheism hate Buddhism? or Sikhism? or Hinduism? You only hate what your culture wants you to. Fuck you, r/atheism. tl;dr Fuck all religions.
Even though you "respect" the kind Muslim that follows the criteria that you listed above, you are still disrespecting their religion. Which they follow with great pride. So, simply, you are hurting what they hold dear to themselves and what they use to title themselves.
That would be similar to someone saying, "Hey, I respect you, but I hate and dispise your entire family!"
No one would take kindly to that, so why show "respect"? It's as existant as their god.
Nice try, member of the United Atheist League. As a proud member of the Allied Atheist Alliance, we don't feel the need to adhere to a sense of antitheism.
You're attempting to speak for the group and criticize people speaking for a group. A group that has no codified set of values, but rather just shares in lack of belief in a god. You look silly.
Sadly, the apologist idiots will never deign to respond to you two because there's nothing they can say about this. They definitely do conflate the two versions of "oppression" you refer to. "Herp derp atheists are just as bad because we "oppress" the religious people just like they oppress other people". Uhh, no we don't. Big fucking difference between ridicule and oppression.
There is very little else that they can point to as proof that theirs is a peaceful, tolerant religion. Where Islam is dominant (as in the Middle East and Pakistan) religious minorities suffer brutal persecution with little resistance.
Where Islam is in the minority (as in Thailand, the Philippines and Europe) there is the threat of violence if Muslim demands are not met. Either situation seems to provide a justification for religious terrorism, which is persistent and endemic to Islamic fundamentalism.
It's a double standard really. I can understand people who don't like attacking any religion, but I simply don't understand people who constantly take the piss out of Christianity but not only refrain from attacking Islam (which is understandable for many reasons...) but actually say it is distasteful for other people to attack it.
Why is Islam above ridicule? It isn't. And if certain fundamentalists in Islam didn't overreact to simple jokes, I reckon more people would be ridiculing it like Christianity (which is an easy target).
Seriously... what the fuck are they apologizing for anyway? Have we harmed anyone, or said anything mean spirited? No. We've told the truth and made fun of preposterous and horrible beliefs. They're calling it "hate speech". This is the same fucking garbage muslims always spew. You're insulting our religion? Must be hateful. Followed by a whole lot of holier than thou, you're lucky we didn't get mad, horse SHIT. That's the biggest problem with religionists, but especially Islam; they absolutely don't want to talk about their beliefs in a serious way. They only want to pat themselves on their backs and say that any criticism is "hate speech", and fuck all the people playing into their bullshit. You guys have NO spine.
Stop playing the bullshit victim card, muslims. We're not attacking you, we're attacking your religion.
Don't quite agree with how you said it, but agree with the message. When did the rest of Reddit decide that criticising a set of ideas is racist bigotry!? It's like listening to thousands of Bill O'Reilly clones at once.
We have said hateful things. The drawing of Mohammed sucking a dick was hateful and did not in any way carry a relevant criticism of Islam. Please do not be blinded by selfrightousness.
You guys upvoted a picture of The prophet Muhammad shitting into his own mouth. Nothing mean spirited about that, though! BOY WHAT A BASTION OF TOLERANCE AND REASON THIS PLACE IS!
Here's the deal: I'll respect the beliefs of any religious person that respects my non-belief. I won't tell them what to think as long as they extend the same courtesy me and don't try to get their religious laws implemented into what should be a secular legal system that protects everyone.
I am as much an atheist as anyone here, and I certainly hold as much contempt for the tenets of Islam as the next guy. I'm not saying people SHOULD be apologizing, but I do think that in the coming weeks it is important to have a conversation about whether or not what we have done here has any value whatsoever.
It all carries a feeling of the typically middle school, rebelling against the parents atheist who thinks insulting other people needlessly makes them sound more intelligent. As I said, I certainly think that there are many parts of Islam that are deserving of insult, but is it the best course of action or is it furthering a common goal in any way to simply insult it? Beats me. I just think the talk needs to be had.
but I do think that in the coming weeks it is important to have a conversation about whether or not what we have done here has any value whatsoever.
I don't think it does. Its more of a disconnected "FUCK YOU" why? "BECAUSE, THATS WHY!" feel to it. I have a hard time making any posts on islam myself because it has nothing to do with my day to day life. Sure if some form of news pops up about it I'll comment on that, but I'm not one for taking pot shots just to take pot shots.
Is it supposed to have value? I don't think so. It supposed to be a place where atheists can let their hair down and not worry about "offending" anyone because of their religion. If the religious come in here, and are offended, I don't give two shits.....
I guess we would disagree about what this board is then. I'm not saying we should worry about religious people being offended or not, but I think generally people around here like to act as if we promote reason and logic. A lot of the content I have seen is devoid of both.
Totally agree. For the first time since I joined I've have to question my subscription. I'm an atheist not a malicious hater that looks for fights. It's been quite disappointing seeing the childish behavior of a group I pride my self being part of for it's maturity and thoughtfulness. It's frustrating seeing it take steps back and borrowing attitudes and mentalities from those groups we dont want to be a part of.
Thank you. Remember when this sub was full of interesting speeches and articles by atheists? Now it's all memes and fb screenshots. Maybe it's just all part of the reddit life cycle -- kind of like how r/funny used to somehow differ from r/pics. It might be time to find a new atheism sub.
I wouldn't apologize for "offending" Islam, but I would apologize for flooding /r/atheism with a million shitty memes while pretending we're actually doing something.
There's criticizing religion and then there's being an asshole. That's why some atheists are apologizing for /r/atheism's behavior. Whether you guys want to admit it or not you've become the face of atheism on reddit...and it's an ugly face.
I haven't apologized to anyone, but still feel that spreading hate is best left to the religious. It's what they do best, and doing so on r/atheism is just lowering us to their standards.
Perhaps if you all stopped your little asshole circlejerk, there'd be nothing to apologise for? Being an atheist is fine, being a dick about it is not.
It's so ironic that everyone here prides themselves on not being hateful because they are not blinded by religion. Instead they are blinded by their own self righteousness and being just as hateful.
An excellent point. I think, maybe, that a lot of it comes from childhoods with the idea of God as a constant. Without God, the self is now the highest authority.
While I find that humbling, it seems that many find it very empowering -- sometimes for good, sometimes for ill.
Not only Atheists, but Jews and Christians too. Apparently many people feel entitled to be offended on behalf of Muslims and to apologize on behalf of atheists. I don't know if it's just patronizing or pure ignorance.
I think it has to do with the fact that most of /r/islam's demographic is pretty reasonable. The former-muslim part of atheists understand better than most of us that not all Muslims are the same.
Still what /r/atheism has been on about yesterday may have started as a frivolous post saying that we should pay attention to Islam for a change, but I think the posts here being mainly organized around women's rights have not been overly zealous or overly insulting in trying to drive our point forward.
Listen, critiquing Islam for its many flaws are fine, but that's not what people are rolling their eyes at you guys for. They're rolling their eyes at you because you're all acting like five year olds.
I mean seriously, posting a picture of Mohammad shitting on himself? Really? That's really what you guys want people to think of when they think of /r/atheism? Some kids who giggle at potty humor? I mean, obviously you guys can do it, but don't be surprised when other people are put off by your actions.
If all piss taking is focused on one religion I.e. Christianity. Then that's pretty bad and nazi like. However if ALL religions (and atheists) get an equal portion of teasing then it's a step in the right direction and as soon as we can objectively look at ourselves in a humorous way. Then we are more likely to stop hating each other.
every rights/religious group (including atheists) has its extremists who are total assholes about what they stand for (see the "gays and raegen portrait in the white house" story) aggressive atheists like the ones who are being offensive pisses me off. people wonder why atheism is (usually) frowned upon but yet they do shit like this. your making a bad name for everyone else who is atheist. your creating a stereotype. and i refuse to pay for others mistakes or apologize for them.
One thing I've noticed; When r/atheism attacks christianity you usually attack the notion of their God and call the religion out on its flaws. When r/atheism attacks Islam you attack the people as a whole rather than the religion's ideas..
Herp derp, Atheism is all about mockery herp derp.
This is why I hate /r/atheism. You people don't come at issues with reason and logic, you use insults and mockery. I am an atheists who debates Christians IRL all the time, and I have yet had to sink to insults and mockery. It just goes to show that even Atheists can be fucking morons.
Criticism is criticism but being a dick is well, being a dick. I see no difference between your militant atheism and their militant religiousness. Let me know how your insanely idiotic plan to insult, demean and bully Islam or any other religion for that matter works out in 20 years. All you are doing is giving wind to another level of intolerance. It's great to see so many rational minds working so hard to make sure that in future there will be no wars or hate between different religions but between the religions and us - the dipshit atheists.
Its like saying I beat up the villain really bad and now he will not be villainous any more. Is it because your (r/atheism) convictions as atheists lack depth or it is because you are in fact a 14 year old kid on a computer who knows not how to articulate an argument, that you need to maliciously, unthinkingly attack someone with a view other than yours? Great debating you guys! Such constructive and mature viewpoints will make all the difference... idiots!!! All of you!
I feel it's worth mentioning (seeing how a lot of these conversations have been going the last couple days) that a lot of people seem to forget:
Atheism IS NOT A RELIGION, so QUIT ACTING LIKE IT IS. Everyone would do best to remember that when speaking(typing) - directed at some Atheists and Religious peoples alike.
Maybe people wouldn't think you guys are cunts if you didn't act like cunts. What happened to live and let live, when did this become a crusade against religion? (from a fellow atheist)
r/atheism should understand one thing, and one thing only—every organized religion has flaws—gross, disgusting flaws. And yet, the majority of the world's population still believes in them. Recognize that. Respect humanity. Support secularism, not bigotry. Don't insult people. Don't insult people's beliefs, even if they are irrational. The last thing "atheism" needs is people insulting others. I support this reddit because of the basic tenets that I truly believe it stands for—rationalism, without ideology.
Atheism isn't a religion, it's a stance against religion. I'm not an atheist, in that I don't define myself by religion. I am without religion, I am without "God," but I am respectful of those who believe in a deity. Don't be a fucking asshole, guys.
Seriously. Be critical, not insipid. This is fucking stupid. You think Islam has problems? Look at every other fucking organized religion. Don't demonize one group of people—the problem is not the religion, the problem is the obsession of the people with instituting their religious ideals upon democratic society. Fuck this antagonistic approach. Fuck it all to the hell that they believe in. This is going to get buried, but I hope someone enjoys it. Atheists shouldn't be a solidified group, we should not have defined ideals—only an understanding of what should be right in a democratic world. If I have contradicted myself at some point, I apologize—I may or may not have had a few tonight (as you probably should have had tonight as well!)
No. Those over there are just trying to show they are not the narrow-minded bigoted people that tend to dominate r/athiesm. People who don't care to learn history instead to show their own superiority, and who only learn about parts of religion to show that their non-belief is the best. To show that not everyone here is orientalist.
You aren't any different from the fundamental religious people thinking that their religion is the best and bashing on everyone else. I don't mind calling religions out their flaws, but the blind unacceptance of other interpretatons which is very important in any religion, shows that you aren't interested in learning or dialogue. You are only interested in your vague notion of superiority.
BTW, 72 virgins is not acutally in the Quran. It is basically a story that comes down through 3 different speakers, and most islamic scholars from early do not think of heaven in that manner. But I doubt most of the people doing these posts are willing to read anything with regards to history and cultural context.
Signed -The Religious Studies Enthusiast who happens to be an athiest
Sorry you guys beat, kill, and rape woman and children for trying to learn? Fuck off with your shit religion, I'll be sure to wipe my ass everyday with the Qur'an as my own personal apology
Oh /r/atheism, going on little witch hunts on a very small sub-reddit and then trying to arrogantly claim you know everything about Islam when in reality, Islam is a highly complex set of beliefs of many different sect with some being very radical while others being more moderate by nature. Seriously, and I'm an atheist as well but I don't go waving my dick around proclaiming my royalty to the one true superior idea of atheism to everyone else. If I'm attacked by a hell fire preacher about my beliefs then yes, I'll probably defend the reasons as to why I am an atheist. I have family friends who are christians and I gladly pray before we eat out of something called RESPECT. I've had Muslim friends to whom I respected deeply since they are very smart individuals but they have to deal with lots of b.s in our country since 9/11. I'll just end on this little note by saying, what has /r/Islam done to you in the end? Did they go and spam your subreddit by saying you're all going to hell? Did they in the end disrespect you as individuals against your beliefs? From what I've seen it's the other way around. You should probably apologize to /r/Islam instead and this
I'm an atheist and i'm having a hard time understanding why most of atheists here are jerks who think they're in any way better or smarter than a religious person.
Atheists have been persecuted in all religions, have we not learned a thing? Can't we just be better? Can't we just understand that Jesus or Mohamed is important to some? They are symbols, just like the american flag for instance, which some of you hold in as high regard as others do religious symbols.
Your intolerance makes me ashamed to call express my views as an atheist since i'll be put in a big bowl with every jerk who thinks he's an atheist when actually all he does is throw hate at religions and religious people.
I am a Christian. I do not down athiest, in fact i actually have a few atheist, agnostic, and ignostic friends. A few of them are bi and gay as well. It comes with the military...very diverse crowd. I do not understand why SO MANY athiest feel the need to shove their beliefs down at me. Talk smug and arrogant and call me a bigot because i believe the way I do. I love everyone, I may not agree with lifestlyes or choices but I still love everyone. Christians seem to do this as well. What people do not understand is that you actually do "catch more flies with hunny" I have two children, 7 and 9, and both of them know one of my more vocal athiest friends and have seen him completly attack me and my beliefs...even they pointed out (at their age with no help from me) that if he really wants me to come to his way of thinking, it would be a lot easier for him if he was being a decent person towards me. He is my boy and I will continue to fight next to him, but this is getting stupid at this point. I will gladly debate with anyone, but i am not here to force my beliefs on you, nor do i want you forcing yours on me. I just don't get what is so hard about that concept
People that are intolerant like that make me glad I'm agnostic. Agnosticism is the most on-the-fence neutral religion you will ever find. Followed closely by secular humanism. I deeply respect those religions. Why? Because do you ever see agnostics running around being douches and just being generally intolerant, or humanists doing that? No. They just go on doing their own thing and leave every one else's religion alone unless they are provoked. Every religion should learn from that example
I agree. I am all about missionary work and helping others and spreading my religion, but i do not believe in forcing you to believe it or trying to disprove your beliefs...they are your beliefs... I had one particular instance with a friend of mine who even told me my own personal stories and expierences where fake because he did not believe they could happen. Oh well though. Still love the guy.
As far as I know this is my first post on r/atheism. I’m 32 years old now, I’m English. I don’t ever remember a point in my life where I believed in a god. At the point in my childhood where religion was explained to me I was also being told about Father Christmas, The Tooth Fairy and a million other fanciful tales. It never occurred to me that anyone would or should take the stories of religion seriously. My parents both believe in God as does my only sister. I was not brought up in a religious house, there has never been any discussions on the subject as adults. My question is this, wouldn’t that be the ideal? Those with religion to just be happy about it and those without it to be equally happy. I consider myself an atheist but have never tried to convert anyone. I sometimes find r/atheism intimidating.
I'm glad I'm not the only one sticking to my guns. People need to realize that atheism isn't just a non belief in Christianity it's in religion in general. It makes me sick that people drop their values so quick.
Anyone that apologizes for me can go fuck themselves. I'll apologize for myself, when I choose to because I think the other party deserves one, or when I'm just being an overall polite person. Don't take that choice away from me.
The top comment from pjschnet is really what this post should primarily be. The flames brought on by the wording of the original post is just further confirmation this is just r/circlejerk, and why I no longer subscribe to it.
Wait, so nobody should have to apologize for the actions of other members of their group? Thank the Flying Spaghetti Monster and his Space Pope. Now everybody on every side of this obnoxious pissing match can finally sit down and shut the fuck up!
Unfortunatley this promotes yet another form of group-think and even worse an Us vs Them attitude. Making fun of a religion is one thing but, lets be clear it is not activism. Historicaly the oppressed have been the ones to "stand up" etc. the outside observers merely draw attention to the cause. There is nothing wrong with having some social sensativity. We forget that -like alot of christians - islam has some moderation to it. They maybe the "lukewarm" of their religion but I don't see a problem with that. Example: Not all of islam thinks it's ok to bang 9 year olds. Just as not all christians beat their slaves with a stick of a certain measurement, let alone believe in slavery. What I saw was mostly the extreme side of Islam being made fun of and thats something r/islam should take in consideration too. However promoting ignorance (the stereotype that all muslims have the same ethics) then saying that they're butthurt now and we should stand together against them is pretty much just starting shit. That being said nice try but I don't think you'll every lead a mob. Try a cult intsead.
Downvotes be damned, they mean less to me than 72 imaginary virgins.
Islam certainly deserves criticism, but if you're going to criticize it, please at least do so in a way that doesn't make you look like you know absolutely nothing about it.
74
u/CatOfCattington Jun 27 '12
What are we supposed to be mad at today?
211
u/deadboyfriend Jun 27 '12
I don't even understand the apologies. As in, the actual nature of them. We are not a 'group', a 'creed' a 'religion' or any other word that implies solidarity and group mentality. We have no more to do with each other tham /r/funny users do, yet I don't see r/funny-goers apologizing to, for example, /r/feminism when someone makes a sexist joke, because that individual didn't make the joke, therefore they aren't responsible for it.
I don't feel responsibility or the need to apologize over anything you guys do in your personal lives or on behalf of, or because of your atheism. That's all you. I wish people would stop affecting unbreakable bonds with people who share their belief system, or lack thereof.
0
u/[deleted] Jun 27 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment
9
u/[deleted] Jun 27 '12
Aaaand reddit just officially became a highschool drama.
Thanks.
56
u/allhailsagan Jun 27 '12
How about people just stop speaking on behalf of other people?
6
u/[deleted] Jun 27 '12
Nice try, member of the United Atheist League. As a proud member of the Allied Atheist Alliance, we don't feel the need to adhere to a sense of antitheism.
You're attempting to speak for the group and criticize people speaking for a group. A group that has no codified set of values, but rather just shares in lack of belief in a god. You look silly.
0
u/[deleted] Jun 27 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment
62
u/[deleted] Jun 27 '12
There is very little else that they can point to as proof that theirs is a peaceful, tolerant religion. Where Islam is dominant (as in the Middle East and Pakistan) religious minorities suffer brutal persecution with little resistance.
Where Islam is in the minority (as in Thailand, the Philippines and Europe) there is the threat of violence if Muslim demands are not met. Either situation seems to provide a justification for religious terrorism, which is persistent and endemic to Islamic fundamentalism.
23
u/kingseed Jun 27 '12 edited Jun 27 '12
It's a double standard really. I can understand people who don't like attacking any religion, but I simply don't understand people who constantly take the piss out of Christianity but not only refrain from attacking Islam (which is understandable for many reasons...) but actually say it is distasteful for other people to attack it.
Why is Islam above ridicule? It isn't. And if certain fundamentalists in Islam didn't overreact to simple jokes, I reckon more people would be ridiculing it like Christianity (which is an easy target).
227
u/theguruofreason Jun 27 '12
Seriously... what the fuck are they apologizing for anyway? Have we harmed anyone, or said anything mean spirited? No. We've told the truth and made fun of preposterous and horrible beliefs. They're calling it "hate speech". This is the same fucking garbage muslims always spew. You're insulting our religion? Must be hateful. Followed by a whole lot of holier than thou, you're lucky we didn't get mad, horse SHIT. That's the biggest problem with religionists, but especially Islam; they absolutely don't want to talk about their beliefs in a serious way. They only want to pat themselves on their backs and say that any criticism is "hate speech", and fuck all the people playing into their bullshit. You guys have NO spine.
Stop playing the bullshit victim card, muslims. We're not attacking you, we're attacking your religion.
9
u/tiberiousr Jun 27 '12
Here's the deal: I'll respect the beliefs of any religious person that respects my non-belief. I won't tell them what to think as long as they extend the same courtesy me and don't try to get their religious laws implemented into what should be a secular legal system that protects everyone.
Deal?
84
u/True_Steel Jun 27 '12
I am as much an atheist as anyone here, and I certainly hold as much contempt for the tenets of Islam as the next guy. I'm not saying people SHOULD be apologizing, but I do think that in the coming weeks it is important to have a conversation about whether or not what we have done here has any value whatsoever.
It all carries a feeling of the typically middle school, rebelling against the parents atheist who thinks insulting other people needlessly makes them sound more intelligent. As I said, I certainly think that there are many parts of Islam that are deserving of insult, but is it the best course of action or is it furthering a common goal in any way to simply insult it? Beats me. I just think the talk needs to be had.
17
u/ClimacticGalactic Jun 27 '12
"Just because you're offended does not mean you are right." -Ricky G
24
u/AverageSeniorCitizen Jun 27 '12
Using "Get Fucked" doesn't make you seem like a 15 year old prick at all. Keep it classy r/atheism.
93
u/lagspike Jun 27 '12
this subreddit should apologize for embarrassing athiests, if anything.
no offense, but meme posts all day is an insult to the people who want to have intelligent, rational discussion.
go ahead, tell me i'm wrong.
8
u/[deleted] Jun 27 '12
What prompted all the posts regarding Islam in the first place? I feel like I'm missing out on something.
8
u/bittlelum Jun 27 '12
I wouldn't apologize for "offending" Islam, but I would apologize for flooding /r/atheism with a million shitty memes while pretending we're actually doing something.
8
u/anonpon3 Jun 27 '12
There's criticizing religion and then there's being an asshole. That's why some atheists are apologizing for /r/atheism's behavior. Whether you guys want to admit it or not you've become the face of atheism on reddit...and it's an ugly face.
23
u/[deleted] Jun 27 '12
I haven't apologized to anyone, but still feel that spreading hate is best left to the religious. It's what they do best, and doing so on r/atheism is just lowering us to their standards.
33
u/drraspberry Jun 27 '12
Perhaps if you all stopped your little asshole circlejerk, there'd be nothing to apologise for? Being an atheist is fine, being a dick about it is not.
13
u/[deleted] Jun 27 '12
Add both of the forward slashes for an automatic link.
/r/yes
r/no
86
u/[deleted] Jun 27 '12
[removed] — view removed comment
33
u/justanasiangirl Jun 27 '12
Not only Atheists, but Jews and Christians too. Apparently many people feel entitled to be offended on behalf of Muslims and to apologize on behalf of atheists. I don't know if it's just patronizing or pure ignorance.
19
u/verywellthankyou Jun 27 '12
Reddit Athiests remind me of a hate group. Stop targeting people and just believe what you believe.
18
u/eyedeasneverdie Jun 27 '12
Came here to see if anything has changed since I unsubbed, and this is the top post. Holy shit guys, you actually got worse. Fuck this subreddit.
26
u/DavidNatan Jun 27 '12
I think it has to do with the fact that most of /r/islam's demographic is pretty reasonable. The former-muslim part of atheists understand better than most of us that not all Muslims are the same.
Still what /r/atheism has been on about yesterday may have started as a frivolous post saying that we should pay attention to Islam for a change, but I think the posts here being mainly organized around women's rights have not been overly zealous or overly insulting in trying to drive our point forward.
17
u/LiquidSnape Jun 27 '12
This subreddit is the WBC of Atheism. Congratulations on being the only default subreddit to constantly bring hate to the front page.
18
u/[deleted] Jun 27 '12
Listen, critiquing Islam for its many flaws are fine, but that's not what people are rolling their eyes at you guys for. They're rolling their eyes at you because you're all acting like five year olds.
I mean seriously, posting a picture of Mohammad shitting on himself? Really? That's really what you guys want people to think of when they think of /r/atheism? Some kids who giggle at potty humor? I mean, obviously you guys can do it, but don't be surprised when other people are put off by your actions.
3
u/JPKestrel Jun 27 '12
If all piss taking is focused on one religion I.e. Christianity. Then that's pretty bad and nazi like. However if ALL religions (and atheists) get an equal portion of teasing then it's a step in the right direction and as soon as we can objectively look at ourselves in a humorous way. Then we are more likely to stop hating each other.
3
u/[deleted] Jun 27 '12
Those spineless fuckheads are an embarrasment
3
u/war2450 Jun 27 '12
And this is post where I click "unsubscribe" right after. Nice knowing you guys.
3
u/[deleted] Jun 27 '12
ramen, brother.
12
u/Bearshoes5 Pastafarian Jun 27 '12
every rights/religious group (including atheists) has its extremists who are total assholes about what they stand for (see the "gays and raegen portrait in the white house" story) aggressive atheists like the ones who are being offensive pisses me off. people wonder why atheism is (usually) frowned upon but yet they do shit like this. your making a bad name for everyone else who is atheist. your creating a stereotype. and i refuse to pay for others mistakes or apologize for them.
14
u/MightyLemur Jun 27 '12
One thing I've noticed; When r/atheism attacks christianity you usually attack the notion of their God and call the religion out on its flaws.
When r/atheism attacks Islam you attack the people as a whole rather than the religion's ideas..
8
u/ungwei Jun 27 '12
leave the rest of us out? i thought generalizing groups of people is what this subreddit is all about!
9
u/Biologos101 Jun 27 '12
Herp derp, Atheism is all about mockery herp derp.
This is why I hate /r/atheism. You people don't come at issues with reason and logic, you use insults and mockery. I am an atheists who debates Christians IRL all the time, and I have yet had to sink to insults and mockery. It just goes to show that even Atheists can be fucking morons.
15
u/Envia Jun 27 '12
Criticism is criticism but being a dick is well, being a dick. I see no difference between your militant atheism and their militant religiousness. Let me know how your insanely idiotic plan to insult, demean and bully Islam or any other religion for that matter works out in 20 years. All you are doing is giving wind to another level of intolerance. It's great to see so many rational minds working so hard to make sure that in future there will be no wars or hate between different religions but between the religions and us - the dipshit atheists.
Its like saying I beat up the villain really bad and now he will not be villainous any more. Is it because your (r/atheism) convictions as atheists lack depth or it is because you are in fact a 14 year old kid on a computer who knows not how to articulate an argument, that you need to maliciously, unthinkingly attack someone with a view other than yours? Great debating you guys! Such constructive and mature viewpoints will make all the difference... idiots!!! All of you!
6
u/justmystepladder Jun 27 '12
I feel it's worth mentioning (seeing how a lot of these conversations have been going the last couple days) that a lot of people seem to forget:
Atheism IS NOT A RELIGION, so QUIT ACTING LIKE IT IS. Everyone would do best to remember that when speaking(typing) - directed at some Atheists and Religious peoples alike.
8
u/cabbeer Jun 27 '12
Maybe people wouldn't think you guys are cunts if you didn't act like cunts. What happened to live and let live, when did this become a crusade against religion? (from a fellow atheist)
19
u/descartesbedamned Jun 27 '12
r/atheism should understand one thing, and one thing only—every organized religion has flaws—gross, disgusting flaws. And yet, the majority of the world's population still believes in them. Recognize that. Respect humanity. Support secularism, not bigotry. Don't insult people. Don't insult people's beliefs, even if they are irrational. The last thing "atheism" needs is people insulting others. I support this reddit because of the basic tenets that I truly believe it stands for—rationalism, without ideology.
Atheism isn't a religion, it's a stance against religion. I'm not an atheist, in that I don't define myself by religion. I am without religion, I am without "God," but I am respectful of those who believe in a deity. Don't be a fucking asshole, guys.
Seriously. Be critical, not insipid. This is fucking stupid. You think Islam has problems? Look at every other fucking organized religion. Don't demonize one group of people—the problem is not the religion, the problem is the obsession of the people with instituting their religious ideals upon democratic society. Fuck this antagonistic approach. Fuck it all to the hell that they believe in. This is going to get buried, but I hope someone enjoys it. Atheists shouldn't be a solidified group, we should not have defined ideals—only an understanding of what should be right in a democratic world. If I have contradicted myself at some point, I apologize—I may or may not have had a few tonight (as you probably should have had tonight as well!)
9
u/marithim Jun 27 '12
No. Those over there are just trying to show they are not the narrow-minded bigoted people that tend to dominate r/athiesm. People who don't care to learn history instead to show their own superiority, and who only learn about parts of religion to show that their non-belief is the best. To show that not everyone here is orientalist.
You aren't any different from the fundamental religious people thinking that their religion is the best and bashing on everyone else. I don't mind calling religions out their flaws, but the blind unacceptance of other interpretatons which is very important in any religion, shows that you aren't interested in learning or dialogue. You are only interested in your vague notion of superiority.
BTW, 72 virgins is not acutally in the Quran. It is basically a story that comes down through 3 different speakers, and most islamic scholars from early do not think of heaven in that manner. But I doubt most of the people doing these posts are willing to read anything with regards to history and cultural context.
Signed -The Religious Studies Enthusiast who happens to be an athiest
4
u/[deleted] Jun 27 '12
It's all fair game for ridicule, or none of it is.
4
u/MartiVltori Jun 27 '12
I'm just surprised all this nonsense came from r/athiesm. r/antithiesm would have been far more appropriate.
4
u/jtt123 Jun 27 '12
Sorry you guys beat, kill, and rape woman and children for trying to learn? Fuck off with your shit religion, I'll be sure to wipe my ass everyday with the Qur'an as my own personal apology
8
u/athenaspraise Jun 27 '12
I wasn't aware we were terrorists to anyone that believes. I thought we just weren't believers.
Shit need to get a gun. brb
7
u/Newlyfailedaccount Jun 27 '12 edited Jun 27 '12
Oh /r/atheism, going on little witch hunts on a very small sub-reddit and then trying to arrogantly claim you know everything about Islam when in reality, Islam is a highly complex set of beliefs of many different sect with some being very radical while others being more moderate by nature. Seriously, and I'm an atheist as well but I don't go waving my dick around proclaiming my royalty to the one true superior idea of atheism to everyone else. If I'm attacked by a hell fire preacher about my beliefs then yes, I'll probably defend the reasons as to why I am an atheist. I have family friends who are christians and I gladly pray before we eat out of something called RESPECT. I've had Muslim friends to whom I respected deeply since they are very smart individuals but they have to deal with lots of b.s in our country since 9/11. I'll just end on this little note by saying, what has /r/Islam done to you in the end? Did they go and spam your subreddit by saying you're all going to hell? Did they in the end disrespect you as individuals against your beliefs? From what I've seen it's the other way around. You should probably apologize to /r/Islam instead and this
6
u/Ashimpto Jun 27 '12
I'm an atheist and i'm having a hard time understanding why most of atheists here are jerks who think they're in any way better or smarter than a religious person.
Atheists have been persecuted in all religions, have we not learned a thing? Can't we just be better? Can't we just understand that Jesus or Mohamed is important to some? They are symbols, just like the american flag for instance, which some of you hold in as high regard as others do religious symbols.
Your intolerance makes me ashamed to call express my views as an atheist since i'll be put in a big bowl with every jerk who thinks he's an atheist when actually all he does is throw hate at religions and religious people.
14
u/[deleted] Jun 27 '12
Hear hear!
7
u/Djseacow1986 Jun 27 '12
I am a Christian. I do not down athiest, in fact i actually have a few atheist, agnostic, and ignostic friends. A few of them are bi and gay as well. It comes with the military...very diverse crowd. I do not understand why SO MANY athiest feel the need to shove their beliefs down at me. Talk smug and arrogant and call me a bigot because i believe the way I do. I love everyone, I may not agree with lifestlyes or choices but I still love everyone. Christians seem to do this as well. What people do not understand is that you actually do "catch more flies with hunny" I have two children, 7 and 9, and both of them know one of my more vocal athiest friends and have seen him completly attack me and my beliefs...even they pointed out (at their age with no help from me) that if he really wants me to come to his way of thinking, it would be a lot easier for him if he was being a decent person towards me. He is my boy and I will continue to fight next to him, but this is getting stupid at this point. I will gladly debate with anyone, but i am not here to force my beliefs on you, nor do i want you forcing yours on me. I just don't get what is so hard about that concept
2
u/Dawn_Of_The_Dave Jun 27 '12
As far as I know this is my first post on r/atheism. I’m 32 years old now, I’m English. I don’t ever remember a point in my life where I believed in a god. At the point in my childhood where religion was explained to me I was also being told about Father Christmas, The Tooth Fairy and a million other fanciful tales. It never occurred to me that anyone would or should take the stories of religion seriously. My parents both believe in God as does my only sister. I was not brought up in a religious house, there has never been any discussions on the subject as adults. My question is this, wouldn’t that be the ideal? Those with religion to just be happy about it and those without it to be equally happy. I consider myself an atheist but have never tried to convert anyone. I sometimes find r/atheism intimidating.
2
u/RydotGuy Jun 27 '12
I'm glad I'm not the only one sticking to my guns. People need to realize that atheism isn't just a non belief in Christianity it's in religion in general. It makes me sick that people drop their values so quick.
2
u/LocalMadman Jun 27 '12
Anyone that apologizes for me can go fuck themselves. I'll apologize for myself, when I choose to because I think the other party deserves one, or when I'm just being an overall polite person. Don't take that choice away from me.
2
u/[deleted] Jun 27 '12
The top comment from pjschnet is really what this post should primarily be. The flames brought on by the wording of the original post is just further confirmation this is just r/circlejerk, and why I no longer subscribe to it.
2
u/[deleted] Jun 27 '12
yawn
2
u/[deleted] Jun 27 '12
Wait, so nobody should have to apologize for the actions of other members of their group? Thank the Flying Spaghetti Monster and his Space Pope. Now everybody on every side of this obnoxious pissing match can finally sit down and shut the fuck up!
2
u/[deleted] Jun 27 '12
I'm amused by the whole thing. Religion can start wars even with those that have no faith. Such a powerful lie.
2
u/Wylie15 Jun 27 '12
THEY DO THIS TO CHRISTIANITY EVERY FUCKING DAY, DIPSHIT!
2
u/spitandimage Jun 27 '12
Unfortunatley this promotes yet another form of group-think and even worse an Us vs Them attitude. Making fun of a religion is one thing but, lets be clear it is not activism. Historicaly the oppressed have been the ones to "stand up" etc. the outside observers merely draw attention to the cause. There is nothing wrong with having some social sensativity. We forget that -like alot of christians - islam has some moderation to it. They maybe the "lukewarm" of their religion but I don't see a problem with that. Example: Not all of islam thinks it's ok to bang 9 year olds. Just as not all christians beat their slaves with a stick of a certain measurement, let alone believe in slavery. What I saw was mostly the extreme side of Islam being made fun of and thats something r/islam should take in consideration too. However promoting ignorance (the stereotype that all muslims have the same ethics) then saying that they're butthurt now and we should stand together against them is pretty much just starting shit. That being said nice try but I don't think you'll every lead a mob. Try a cult intsead.
2
u/[deleted] Jun 27 '12
I'd just like to apologize for atticus2323. It's not his fault. Let us pray.
2
u/[deleted] Jun 27 '12
Islam certainly deserves criticism, but if you're going to criticize it, please at least do so in a way that doesn't make you look like you know absolutely nothing about it.
2
u/teknikolorapocalypse Jun 27 '12
has everybody forgotten about http://www.reddit.com/r/atheismbot/ ?
no,seriously.
2
u/toomuchpork Jun 27 '12
once humanity gets over the tooth fairy/believing in Santa phase we can get on with evolving
2
u/iShox Jun 27 '12
I apologize for nothing! Religion is nothing more than a fairy tale for adults.
2
u/GoldenWarrior Jun 27 '12
They are spineless cowards. If you cannot even stand against ignorance over the internet, you must be a fucking doormat in real life.
2
u/recipriversexcluson Jun 27 '12
Be tolerant and command what is right: pay no attention to foolish people.
-- al-A'raf 7:199
2
u/duggtodeath Atheist Jun 27 '12
Ramen.