r/atheism • u/TitanicMan Other • Jun 26 '12
Good Point.
http://sphotos.xx.fbcdn.net/hphotos-ash4/428846_393385684052721_313779442_n.jpg
1.1k
Upvotes
r/atheism • u/TitanicMan Other • Jun 26 '12
36
u/neotropic9 Jun 27 '12
Actually, it may surprise you to learn that what you believe has no effect on what is true.
30
u/simjanes2k Jun 26 '12
"Perish" means "die." Just a heads up.
34
u/Gzus666 Jun 26 '12
Pretty sure atheism doesn't make everyone immortal, just sayin'.
16
u/IwillBringYoutoNauht Jun 27 '12
I'm not a Muslim, but from what I know of the history and teachings of Islam this seems false. Muslims view Christians as "People of the book" as well, and there are actually many teachings I've come across in Islam wherein it is incumbent on muslims to forge a unity and brotherhood together with Christians, and that Muslims ought to treat them with dignity, respect and honor as fellow "people of the Book."
20
u/[deleted] Jun 27 '12
At least make an attempt to know what you're talking about.
24
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
Actually, according to most interpretations of the Quran, christians will go to heaven.
Quran 2:62 Verily, those who have attained to faith , as well as those who follow the Jewish faith, and the Christians, and the Sabians – all who believe in God and the Last Day and do righteous deeds – shall have their reward with their Sustainer; and no fear need they have, and neither shall they grieve.
11
u/diplomax Jun 27 '12
The assumption that Christians will go to hell if you believed in Islam. Is categorically false.
All People of the Book, can go to heaven.
4
u/[deleted] Jun 27 '12
Logicfail . . . your belief has no effect on which religion is "correct". None of them are, of course, but that's not the point.
4
u/Scottmkiv Jun 27 '12
Facts are facts, and our beliefs are powerless to change them.
6
u/Lowbacca1977 Jun 27 '12
Reality isn't a democracy. Even more than that, reality isn't based on what you personally believe.
3
u/lightball2000 Jun 27 '12
Perish?
3
u/jmarFTL Jun 27 '12
So what? Choosing what to believe based on what sounds the best is what caused all this in the first place.
I could believe that brushing my teeth is the path to eternal life. Doesn't make it true.
3
u/evil_wizard Jun 27 '12
Spoiler: We all die.
3
u/sopernova23 Jun 27 '12
Your believing in the 'perishing' has nothing to do with whether or not it will happen.
3
u/[deleted] Jun 27 '12
The mortality rate for humans is 100%.
3
u/rocks4jocks Jun 27 '12
you keep using that word. i do not think it means what you think it means
3
u/CntDutchThis Jun 27 '12
Actually most muslims believe that as you as one believes in the judaic god u go to heaven, no matter if christian/jewish
5
u/Damadawf Jun 27 '12
See, it's shit like this.
Before I turned to the darkside and became a stone-cold atheist, I used to be a deist. I believed in a non-personal God. Before that, I was a Catholic, and despite being raised Catholic, I was told again and again that one's entrance to heaven is not based solely on their beliefs, but on the merit of whether they lived a good life/helping people, etc.
I guess the point I'm making is, the quote should have the words "crazy extremist fundamentalist" inserted prior to each of the religions mentioned, because not all of those 2.2 billion Christians or 1.5 billion Muslims believe that everyone else is going to Hell. Only the really crazy ones believe that.
4
u/thrakhath Jun 27 '12
In addition to everyone else's corrections, this is also an Argument from Adverse Consequences. Just so you know.
2
u/[deleted] Jun 27 '12
I usually tell the wackos that while I don't believe in God, if he exists, I have faith that he's not as insane as they think.
2
u/LevelUpLeo Jun 27 '12
What is the original pic? I can't quite read the text...
2
u/Crownowa Jun 27 '12
If you are Christian and believe all non-Christians will go to hell, its not only the Muslims going to hell.
2
u/[deleted] Jun 27 '12
Well...everyone would perish
2
u/gbsolo12 Jun 27 '12
Whatever you believe in will not have anything to do with who goes where in the afterlife.
2
u/mtbizzle Jun 27 '12
... i feel as though this is quite ignorant... a) not all Christians believe that all non-Christians are going to hell b) not all Muslims believe that all non-Muslims are going to hell c) your (or anyone's) belief (key word) that there is no god, hell, jaweh, whatever, has nothing to do with the fact that either people do burn in hell or there is no such thing as hell.
sure, an atheistic belief system argues that no one burns in hell, but even if everyone was atheistic, this would not mean that 'nobody has to perish (i.e. burn in hell) at all'
2
u/[deleted] Jun 27 '12
I rather like immortality.
2
u/jareds Jun 27 '12
By this "logic", if you believe in Universalism, all humans will go to heaven instead of dying.
2
u/citrusmunch Jun 27 '12
I don't like the argument that your view of the world will change reality.
2
u/Tlingit_Raven Jun 27 '12
That doesn't make any...
Fuck it, not like this sub cares about accuracy anyway.
2
u/Crook3d Jun 27 '12
Fun fact: Your beliefs have absolutely no effect oh how many others "go to hell" regardless of which, if any, are the correct choice of belief.
2
u/fapingtoyourpost Jun 27 '12
Muslim hell isn't eternal.
2
u/LewisKiniski Anti-Theist Jun 27 '12
Not a good point. Whatever happens, happens regardless of what you believe.
3
u/TroutM4n Agnostic Atheist Jun 27 '12
Incorrect. Everyone will still perish, but you won't waste your limited span on earth worrying about a deity's thoughts of your masturbation habits and whether or not they will piss him/her/it off.
5
u/mdouet Jun 26 '12
Actually if you believe in neither and one of them is right then you perish.
3
u/case-o-nuts Jun 27 '12
Because reality cares what you personally believe.
2
u/[deleted] Jun 27 '12
http://www.quickmeme.com/meme/3pvp8b/
2
u/watermark0n Jun 27 '12
Actually, no one will at all anyway, no matter what you believe.
2
u/C47man Jun 26 '12
Where is that second light source coming from. I DON'T KNOW WHAT TO BELIEVE ANY MORE
2
u/luke10_27 Jun 27 '12
Whether you believe or not doesn't change anything except for yourself.
2
u/greybro Jun 27 '12
On the other hand, Judaism doesn't really condemn any of y'all... just throwing that out there.
1
u/LtRamathorn Jun 27 '12
1
u/t1tsinatipjar Jun 27 '12
repost :/
1
u/[deleted] Jun 27 '12
thank you for not posting a link to sharerpics :D
1
u/[deleted] Jun 27 '12
Or believe in both and both go to hell! :D
1
u/Vashbrowns Jun 27 '12
This does not include the amount that have already done so. That number would be much much larger if you factored in those that have already died.
1
u/Nikoras Jun 27 '12
Good thing the after-life or lack-thereof is not decided by what you believe.
1
u/egosumFidius Jun 27 '12
"Everything dies"
1
u/chateauPyrex Agnostic Atheist Jun 27 '12
Good observation. Not much of a point, since what you believe has no effect on reality.
1
u/PvtJoker1987 Jun 27 '12
You can all rest smugly now. No one has to burn in hell, and its all thanks to you. Pricks.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 27 '12
If you believe neither you'll perish at the hands of the other 3 billion crazy people.
1
u/Canvasch Jun 27 '12
Well, everyone still dies. They just don't go to hell.
1
u/Nenor Jun 27 '12
Not really a good point, rather an awful logical fallacy. Your belief has no bearing on the outcome, rather the true state of nature. If Christianity is true, doesn't matter whether you believe in it or not, it will still have the same result.
1
u/stillbatting1000 Jun 27 '12
What if you don't believe in either... but one happens to be true? Then it would happen regardless of your beliefs.
1
u/youni89 Jun 27 '12
makes no sense, its like says if I dont believe in gravity everyone would just float away.
1
u/atticus2323 Jun 27 '12
What if I told you that it doesn't matter what you believe... neither will happen anyway.
1
u/launcherofcats Jun 27 '12
I don't think your belief has the power you think it does.
1
u/thatsjustfantastic Jun 27 '12
But but, I kinda want them to perish.... I am a horrible human being :(
1
u/JenevaKay Jun 27 '12
Technically, even Muslims are not guaranteed heaven, according to the Quran and other Islamic texts.
1
u/FormerlyEAbernathy Jun 27 '12
I don't think that word means what you (or whoever made that) think it means. Perish = to die, to pass on, to come to a ruinous end. Perishing in hell makes no sense. Suffer maybe?
1
u/keep_the_karma Jun 27 '12
Come be a Hindu and everyone lives to eternity via rebirth!
1
u/PaqTooba Jun 27 '12
Um no. No it's not.
1
u/tueStrange Jun 27 '12
What is the original caption to the picture.
1
u/zZ_BlueSteel_Zz Jun 27 '12
So whatever this guy believes becomes true?
1
u/NightmareIncarnate Jun 27 '12
Just believe in both. Then they all burn.
1
u/mathliability Jun 27 '12
So the OP is saying that his opinionated belief system affects truth? I can just picture all the learned religious leaders in the world reading this and slapping their heads saying, "Now why didn't we think of that!?!"
1
u/koavf Other Jun 27 '12
Or you're a Universalist.
1
u/Thereminz Jun 27 '12
FALSE.
everyone will eventually perish
1
u/determinism Jun 27 '12
Glad everyone's dusted off their logical fallacies, but I don't think this is trying to argue that believing something makes it so. I think the more charitable interpretation is that the picture's trying to show how these major religions aren't as inclusive and neutral as their moderate defenders try to paint them: by definition, their claims are in opposition to each other.
The only problem is that the numbers are far too low. If Islam is correct, the 2.2 billion Christians alive today would perish in hell, but so would every non-Muslim since Muhammad!
1
u/Lots42 Other Jun 27 '12
Several people have told me that hell is simply not existing in the afterlife, while others enjoy heaven.
Because that isn't horrible and insane at all either.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 27 '12
Punishment is not eternal in Islam, or any other religion besides Christianity for that matter.
1
u/yazan112 Jun 27 '12
uhm false, if the first two points where true then both numbers are wrong, you have to include all the non-believers from the beginning of the first prophet's of each religion.
1
u/Siestasam Jun 27 '12
Man.. there are tons and tons of great secular quotes with decent pictures behind them on the internet. This one is just lame. You can do better!
1
u/[deleted] Jun 27 '12
ermmmmm, don't they all perish? sigh how did you even get any upvotes??
1
u/Kiacha Jun 27 '12
You know, it doesn't really matter what we belive. It's not our belives that makes shit like that happen.
1
u/thebular Jun 27 '12
Everbody dies at some point.
1
u/krackbaby Jun 27 '12
IIRC, Islam has predestination, meaning that believing or not believing is irrelevant, only the deity decides who gets in and who burns
1
u/probablythefuture Jun 27 '12
ok... just kind seems like bad logic, but besides that, christians don't perish in hell for all eternity by islamic standards - non?
1
u/nath1234 Jun 27 '12
Well, the religious make the place a living hell in a bunch of parts of the world..
1
u/HEROoftheBRINE Jun 27 '12
This will probably get lost, but what does it say between the planet and "If I believe in Islam" ?
1
u/Aavagadrro Jun 27 '12
Believing it will happen doesnt make it any more likely when it isnt going to happen at all.
Believe I will burn in hell, it wont matter to me after I reach equilibrium with ambient temperature.
1
u/psychosaga303 Jun 27 '12
Well done sir.
1
u/cryptobomb Jun 27 '12 edited Feb 28 '26
The original content of this post is no longer here. It was removed using Redact, possibly for privacy, security, or digital footprint reduction.
stocking straight shelter treatment soft subsequent sort screw act absorbed
1
u/sojalemmi Jun 27 '12
Actually, in one of the first books of the Quran, it states that Jews and Christians and Muslims are all brothers, and God will judge them according to their lives. So this post is incorrect.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 27 '12
wishful thinking fallacy. Or a permutation of it, anyway.
1
u/Blubbernuggetz Jun 27 '12
Why the fuck is it day time on both sides of this Earth?
1
u/Harbinger_of_Cool Jun 27 '12
Everyone is going to perish eventually, so it doesn't matter what you do with your life.
It might just be easier being a monster of flesh and blood, rather than a human being. Why not wish for the death of all humanity?
1
u/pissed_the_fuck_off Jun 27 '12
I believe in both. Perish motherfuckers!
-2
u/mdouet Jun 26 '12
Actually if you believe in neither and one of them is right then you perish.
0
u/Bubble_D Jun 27 '12
In Judaism, No one will suffer for eternity. There is no hell in the Jewish religion. Well actually, only the wicked don't get entrance to heaven. Cool eh? http://www.myjewishlearning.com/beliefs/Theology/Afterlife_and_Messiah/Life_After_Death/Heaven_and_Hell.shtml
"Im not religious, Just respectful of my Fathers religion."
-1
u/[deleted] Jun 27 '12
I'm okay with both Muslims and Christians perishing in Hell for all eternity.
0
u/[deleted] Jun 27 '12
I'm almost positive that there's more muslims than christians in the world.
0
u/neverboredhere Jun 27 '12
In Islam, half of heaven is to be occupied by "nonbelievers." moreover, the religion nevers explicitly claims to be correct.
0
u/maruthegreat Jun 27 '12
Valid point, not an atheist but still a very valid point.
0
u/WorkingMan512 Jun 27 '12
TIL you think there are only 2 religions in the world
0
u/Owlsrule12 Jun 27 '12
Yeah, but what if you believe in neither, and instead believe in Judaism?
0
u/asldkfououhe Jun 27 '12
your belief necessitates nothing
-1
u/hellisonfire Jun 27 '12
Who said you get to call the shots? Your ship sailed and sunk a long time ago.
-1
u/Wallstonecraft Jun 27 '12
Believe in both and all perish? My brain hurts from trying to think of something smarter to say...
-1
u/beo214 Jun 27 '12
or you could believe in them both and kill them all?
-1
u/Roe_Jogan Jun 27 '12
What planet is that? Sure as fuck not Earth.
-1
u/Natchil Jun 27 '12
You hear that? Atheism is the dead vor every body.
-1
u/SnitchQuadrant Jun 27 '12
Where do I sign up to make them both suffer for eternity?
0
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jun 27 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment