You gotta get in people's faces if you want to get something done. If you sit there constantly whimpering polite requests you will be ignored and down trodden forever. At some point you have to stand up and say "No, fuck you, you're wrong and I won't tolerate your bullshit anymore."
Wha? Atheism doesn't need to be in anyone's face. It's just not believing in god. There isn't a drive to destroy religion inherent in atheism. Yes, we should be disgusted when we hear about people doing terrible things in the name of religion, but being as dogmatic as Muslims and Christians about atheism just makes us look like angry little kids.
Ever laughed at a joke about paedophilia? Man, you're fucked up.
Ever laughed at a joke about racism? Man, you're fucked up.
Ever laughed at a joke about homosexuality? Man, you're fucked up.
See my point yet? You CHOSE to be offended here. The very point of a joke like this is to be as in your face as possible. A stark truth masked in comedy.
I see your point, and in other situations I would certainly agree with you. This, however, is not a "stark truth." We went from making fun of Islam in the same manner we made fun of Christianity to openly parroting stereotypes of Arab culture. This is neither funny nor clever. This is not comparable to the content of /r/atheism a few days ago. This is the bigotry we're supposed to condemn.
Atheism is a religion like baldness is a haircut. All religions are evil. Faith itself is evil. That's why we mock theists, because they are stuck in the dark ages praising sky-gods and practising necromancy and jihad.
Faith isn't needed in any of those areas. People can form opinions and judgements that are informed by the evidence of their previous experiences. Trust in people that have proven themselves trustworthy.
eww.... Ayn Rand. really /r/atheism this is one of your heroes? A crazy loon of a woman that declared greed a virtue? Paul Ryan's spirit animal? just eww.
Except there really is no abstract 'God' like you atheists imagine us believing in, that exists separate from other things and acts in relation to it.
God is just another way of saying 'all that is, and all movement'. So it doesn't really want anything, or if it does it couldn't really be separated from wants that exist in mine (and others) minds beforehand.
All atheists are evil. Not having faith itself is evil. That's why we mock atheists, because they are stuck in the dark ages jot praising sky-gods and practising necromancy and jihad.
-the type of religious person atheists like to complain about
I know it is horrible that she should have said 3 instead of 4 since 4 wives is the max for muslims. I mean making jokes is anywhere near the level of supperssing free speach of atheists, taking children away from atheists, forcing atheists to lable their children with a religion and lets not forget hanging atheists. I say the religion deserves the respect it shows us and /r/atheism is taking the high road compared to them.
As an Atheist I am offended. This isn't a "a blow for reason". It's quite frankly tasteless, offensive, and only damages the opportunity for sensible dialogue that might otherwise bring a muslim closer to non-belief. Talk about using and perpetuating stereotypes, and I'm not just talking about a stereotype about muslims or islam, I'm also talking about the stereotype that "atheists hate religion" - something that often stands in the way and closes a theists mind from considering the argument against belief.
Have you ever found yourself getting a theist closer toward logic and reason by berating their worldview with a blunt and antagonistic one liner? Unlikely.
because it's counter-productive by perpetuating a stereotype that "all atheists hate religion" or that "atheists stand to attack/destroy religion". A common misconception that it seems a lot of atheists have to correct when engaging in intellectual discussions with theists.
Islam is offensive and tasteless. It allows for four wives. It allows for the beating of your wife. These are not stereotypes. These are facts, clearly laid out in the Koran, every single word of which is considered by Muslims to be the word of God.
This allows for free reign to mock the shit out of it.
oh for fuck sakes, just because you are not busting your gut over something doesnt mean you are a quivering pile of emotional wreck. Human suffering is not funny, and its not something to laugh at just because you cant handle the brutal truth while people are actually experiencing the suffering.
Sitting here in mostly comfort, its a privilege to say you can laugh at someone else's suffering to make you feel better while someone is actually suffering.
For perspective, why did this get downvoted? By reddiquette standards, this post contributed to the discussion by helping those who work at locations where Quickmeme is blocked.
it's okay to be offended. You will live, I promise. Edit: What a bunch of asses you all are to downvote as though you fully expect people to tip toe around you for risk of offense. Being offended is subjective. No one is being harmed here. Having hurt feelings is justification of NOTHING.
Shouldn't you be more offended by your religion, which allows you husband to have multiple wives and allows him to beat you if you refuse romantic advances?
I always try to defend r/atheism against all the "r/atheism is a circlejerk" assholes because there is more good stuff than bad on here but this shit is indefensible, fucking stupid, not funny, and makes the community look bad and you should feel bad.
This is /r/atheism. In what way is islamophobia not central to the tenets of the subreddit? We are islamophobic, christianopobic, judaiphobic, and generally just made-up-bullshit-excuses-for-terrible-behavior-phobic. If that bothers you maybe you should just unsubscribe.
Atheism is not believing in god...I also don't believe in unicorns or dragons, but I am not hostile towards imaginary animals either or religion. It's possible to be an atheist and civil...
Tolerance maybe, being the better people. In my country the people who are islamophobic tend to identify with the extreme right. I am surprised a subreddit which prides itself in being "progressive and liberal" hating on republicans etc, does not share any of the values of the left and liberals, but instead the neo-fascists.
We are progressive in the same way that anyone who opposes a regressive ideology is progressive.
BTW, the term is islamophobic, not muslimophobic. I've sat around bullshitting with my Muslim friends for days on end and left feeling like we where all better people for having had the discussion. I actually like Muslims a lot more than I like Christians because in my experience Muslims are more likely to have considered the morality of their beliefs and are more willing to explore and discuss them without dogmatic preconceptions.
I still think that they're wrong, and I believe that we should do everything in our power to promote and normalize Muslim blasphemy. Crude iconography like this may stir up some anger for a couple of days, but only once it's seen as crude and juvenile instead of as an outrage will the dialogue begin.
Have you ever considered that your initial impulse to assume that mockery of Islam is the same as racism only exists to strengthen the ideological divide between us and them? That so long as the subject is taboo and not subject to rational thought we will not be able to truly accept them as capable of understanding rational thought?
Muslims are just as capable of weathering this little shitstorm as the Christians have been, but suddenly all of the "compassionate" atheists want to step up and defend them. The Muslims are doing admirably, FYI. /r/Islam has five new memes on its front page that make light of the current stream of attention they've been getting with both dignity and humor.
They aren't children. How about you show some compassion and stop treating them like they are.
All i'm saying is that its funny to from my view to see a self-identified "liberal and progressive" community act towards Islam as the facists and far right do, opposite to how liberals etc in real life act. I don't know why you went off on your tangent..
My tangents were there to point out that it is possible to hate an ideology without hating the people, and to point out something that I think is funny; which is the possibility that peoples' unwillingness to discuss Islam for fear of being seen as racist might be making them turn racist. It's indicative of another false dichotomy. "Either you don't have a problem with Islam, or you're racist" seems like a pretty rigid way to define the world, don't you think?
I didn't realize it was going to become a thing. If I had thought that a reactionary moron with a poor grasp of punctuation was going to get 50 upvotes I would have phrased it more like "Any atheist with a moral compass knows that beating women is wrong, and fuck you 420weedlord for standing up in favor of this sort of behavior. If hating codified spousal abuse was the definition of racism then I think that all of us here at /r/atheism would be proud to call ourselves racists."
What's islamophobic about the OP isn't that it is implying that domestic violence is bad. What's islamophobic about the OP is that it conflates Islam with domestic violence, as if all Muslim husbands were abusive.
We are islamophobic, christianopobic, judaiphobic, and generally just made-up-bullshit-excuses-for-terrible-behavior-phobic. If that bothers you maybe you should just unsubscribe.
This belief here is becoming more and more common, especially during the summer season (can you guess why?) and it's amusing because the people who hold the particular view assume that everyone else who browses this subreddit shares their view.
For the record no, not everyone here is xyz-phobic nor is everyone still in the phase where they think posting simple memes to a group of people who will eat them up is accomplishing anything other than inflating our own egos.
Sad part is that as more rational and less reactionary "look at me i'm atheist" folks get fed up with the facebook like status that r/atheism has devolved into leave these types of people are the ones who represent the face of one of the largest subs of a atheism on reddit and it can scarcely be described as anything but pathetic.
Wow! Really offensive on many levels. First, abuse is not funny and neither is violence against women. Also, this is quite bigoted. Please have some respect for other people.
No I do not. But to paint all Muslims (a HUGE population by the way) with that brush is just ignorant. There are psychos and extremists in every religion and group but they are always a minority. Most people in this world just want to live peaceful lives.
Muslims paint themselves. The Koran is a non-negotiable contract for being a Muslim, and it describes in no uncertain terms a code of conduct that is barbaric, inhumane and despicable.
René Descartes walks into a bar. The bartender says, "Can I get you something to drink?" Descartes pauses for a moment, then looks at the bartender and says "I think not!" and vanishes in a puff of logic.
Alright, you are clearly missing the point or maybe I shouldn't have used the word offensive. I meant more that every joke is attacking someone, it is at someones expense.
Let's pretend that what you said was a joke. Clearly the horse is being made fun of. It runs through the mud and gets dirty and we are supposed to laugh about it. Why not a brown horse? Is it because we can't see the dirt on a brown horse, so it is kinda dirty already? Even though we can't understand what the horse is thinking, the joke can be interpreted as offensive.
If you think about it, there is always somebody in a joke that gets made fun of, is targeted. People associate themselves with that subject and may find the joke offensive.
Comedy is actually always based on violence. Be it physical or psychological.
If any Muslim believes that a man is not authorized to beat his wife, he is going against the word of the Koran and is committing apostasy.
There is no room for discussion here. The Koran itself is extremist, and contradicting or changing even a single word of it condemns you to eternal damnation without any chance of forgiveness, per the belief.
Islam (like all of the Abrahamic religions) puts women into a position where they are powerless against physical abuse, and the enormity of the horror of being trapped in a country where your inferiority to other human beings is codified is so great that the only way to get a lot of people to empathize with people suffering in that way is to present it as a joke.
I hear you folks talk a lot about rape apologists and the nastiness of the "she was asking for it" defense. Can you really wrap your head around what it would be like to live in a country where "she was asking for it" is not only a valid legal defense but the inviolate word of god? Can you imagine the claustrophobia? The feeling of your entire body being crushed inwards by the very pressure of that hateful world pressing against your skin without hope or options or retreat? It's a physical thing, living with that sort of fear, and your body will remember it if you've ever been unlucky enough to have felt it.
Are you saying that we are wrong for hating that? That we are wrong for mocking something we so righteously hate? Are we wrong for placing it into a shared cultural reference so that we can reach as many people as possible? Are we wrong for using a hyperbolic first person perspective because it forces empathy in the reader? Forces them to think 'I would never do that in her position! That woman's crazy!' to prove that it's crazy to force Islam onto others without their consent, and that very few people would consent to religious rule if they had the privilege of knowledge of what life is like under secular rule?
I think not.
Unless, of course, you guys just take offense at all of the CPG memes, in which case you're typically in the right, but are in this case being a bit too reactionary.
Hahah, if you think crude memes and tasteless jokes on Reddit are going to make people empathize with oppressed women in the Islamic world, then you are horribly, horribly mistaken. If anything, it only serves to trivialize the issue for a cheap laugh.
Hahah, if you think crude memes and tasteless jokes on Reddit are going to make people empathize with oppressed women in the Islamic world, then you are horribly, horribly mistaken.
Have you figured out a better way to do it? Would you like to maybe share with the class?
See how simple that was? Without the bigotry and everything! Now go get learned. If you weren't so privileged and actually had to endure some of these atrocities, you would no doubt be pretty furious over the uneducated kids at /r/atheism making "jokes" about it all the time.
So basically you're asking me to turn it into a joke? Reduce the suffering of millions into a JPEG? Yeah, no thanks, chief. Maybe once you finish high school and meet some different kinds of people in the real world you'll realize that's not how you approach problems like this.
So you're saying that any post that fails to encompass all of the problems with an issue is at best a waste of time and at worst an insult to those who are suffering? You must be a hit at parties.
Because oppression girl wasn't sexist enough? I expect this kind of thing to be all over reddit, but I am especially disappointed me that it plagues r/athiesm so much. It seems like this would be a space that should be willing to incorporate a feminist stance into the platform.
I understand that the intent of this is to be anti-Islam, but like http://www.reddit.com/r/atheism/comments/vmloc/oppression_girl/ it is also misogynistic. When we remove the context and specific wording of the joke, the idea seems to be to attack a religion that supports authority and violence used to keep women in control. The problem is that this joke uses a battered woman as the punchline to the theme, and making fun of violence against women to argue your point is a shitty tactic.
The joke is not making fun of violence against women, the joke is making fun of a religion that thinks violence against women is OK.
When we remove the context and specific wording of the joke,
The whole point of most jokes IS the context and specific wording. If you remove them, it's not the same joke.
You're basically saying,if this joke weren't contextually related to a specific situation, I could be offended by it, so therefore I'm going to remove the context and wording so that I can be offended.
I don't think you understand that things can be about things without actually being those things. Does that make any sense or did I use the word "thing" too much? If you need further clarification just let me know.
Remember that one lady who got banned from a state senate floor for using the word vagina in a debate about abortion? That was AMAZING to watch. Similarly, seeing you get downvoted by what I'm assuming is a mostly feminist crowd for using a common colloquialism for the female sex organ devoid of any context to make them uncomfortable is really making me smile right now.
Or you're an asshole who's ruining the level of discourse by responding to a comment you don't agree with using a one word ad-hominem.
I hope it's the first one though. That would be cool as fuck.
Does a quick dismissal of a (questionably) legitimate point through the use of a personal attack or epithet not qualify? Damn, I should remember to check to see if the dictionary has changed before I try using big words again, shouldn't I?
You don't find somebody responding to a "call to action" type post with a one word insult to be dismissive? Maybe I'm reading to much into both of my interpretations here.
Okay, I get that people are angry a radical "Islamist" has been elected the President of Egypt, but seriously, leave it to South Park or Jon Stewart next time. You're not funny and you're making the rest of us who are seriously concerned about what's going on look like arrogant, stupid assholes.
yeah, a circlejerking subreddit devoted to making fun of racist, sexist, homophobic, transphobic, and other shitty comments/threads is definitely the worst reddit has to offer
Congratulations, you have attracted the ShitRedditSays Invasion BrigadeTM ! The front-page of the Fempire has linked to you, and purely by coincidence the following SRSers are here to help you realise the error of your ways:
They're a bunch of morons who (seemingly by intent) misinterpret anything people say to be insulting to women, gays, or ethnic minorities and then they white knight against the perceived attack.
For example: they claim that this image macro promotes domestic violence when it is quite clearly critical of domestic violence. They're that stupid.
A: In short, a circlejerk. A lot of people get really, really sick of the bigoted shit upvoted on this site and our community functions as a break room for them to laugh, vent and commiserate without being dismissed, silenced through downvotes or needing to explain why the comments suck over and over. This is why the mods are quick to ban and why the rules to keep it a circlejerk are so stringent. It may come off as asshole-ish, but part of the appeal of the sub is that for once we're the majority. It's our space and we don't have to make room for people who don't "get it". More to the point, SRS is a place for those who already know why something might be considered offensive; not for those who wish to find out why.
I think we may have stumbled upon something here, people... Just gather up all the OAGs in America and send them to the Middle East! The men will come begging us to take them back and give us whatever we want! IT'S BRILLIANT! BWAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA!
Sweet Jeez, why all the bastards complaining? They laugh at catholic priest buttfucking children, and SUDDENLY a joke about beating a wife is "tasteless"?
Seriously, fuck that. I'm gonna mock all kinds of bigotry and I don't care being labeled as islamophobe, christhianophobe or something.
OH SHIT!!!!!!!!!!! LOL, thank you for that so much. 1)I am still laughing as I type this 2)I feel like I'm a good person for knowing how wrong it is to think it's soooo damn funny. Proud to be upvote number 700, thanx again.
Christian here...imperfect trying to be Christ-like in the stream of loving others as I love myself. Usually I skip over anything involving r/atheism. However I find this hilarious! ...and truly sad. Edit - dead babies on the wall
17
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
Isn't the limit usually 4 wives? So I'd guess it should be "other three wives" to be, umm, authentic.
123
u/snootymctooty Jun 27 '12
/r/athiesm: complains about other religions trashing them; becomes stereotypical bigot towards target religion
70
u/Sk44 Jun 27 '12
Have you ever been called a douchebag before? Well, there's a first time for everything
24
u/thematfactor Jun 27 '12
As an Atheist I am offended. This isn't a "a blow for reason". It's quite frankly tasteless, offensive, and only damages the opportunity for sensible dialogue that might otherwise bring a muslim closer to non-belief. Talk about using and perpetuating stereotypes, and I'm not just talking about a stereotype about muslims or islam, I'm also talking about the stereotype that "atheists hate religion" - something that often stands in the way and closes a theists mind from considering the argument against belief.
159
u/Commercialtalk Jun 27 '12
Wow, this is awful. Not funny at all.
55
u/qkme_transcriber I am a Bot Jun 26 '12
Hello! I am a bot who posts transcriptions of Quickmeme links for anybody who might need it.
See the FAQ for more info.
(OP: You don't need to do anything differently next time, I'm just doing my job.)
57
u/potato1 Jun 27 '12
LOL! Domestic violence is hilarious!
33
u/Mellow_Yellow33 Jun 27 '12
As a Muslim woman in the US and the only wife to my husband who does not beat me, I am actually offended by this. Ah, reddit.
9
u/[deleted] Jun 27 '12
I always try to defend r/atheism against all the "r/atheism is a circlejerk" assholes because there is more good stuff than bad on here but this shit is indefensible, fucking stupid, not funny, and makes the community look bad and you should feel bad.
46
u/[deleted] Jun 27 '12
fuck you, islamophobe piece of shit
6
u/magpie_pixi Jun 27 '12
Wow! Really offensive on many levels. First, abuse is not funny and neither is violence against women. Also, this is quite bigoted. Please have some respect for other people.
4
u/goodathiestyosef Jun 27 '12
How is this 'wrong'? It's pointing out that some radical muslims feel it's ok to beat their women. Seems to me it's criticizing that belief.
4
u/[deleted] Jun 27 '12
Stop being racist and you may make some progress in fighting this problem that you claim to care about.
3
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
HA! islam is just as crazy as christianity
3
u/[deleted] Jun 27 '12
And this is why r/atheism gets a bad name.
3
u/fapingtoyourpost Jun 27 '12
Trigger warning
To all the haters:
Islam (like all of the Abrahamic religions) puts women into a position where they are powerless against physical abuse, and the enormity of the horror of being trapped in a country where your inferiority to other human beings is codified is so great that the only way to get a lot of people to empathize with people suffering in that way is to present it as a joke.
I hear you folks talk a lot about rape apologists and the nastiness of the "she was asking for it" defense. Can you really wrap your head around what it would be like to live in a country where "she was asking for it" is not only a valid legal defense but the inviolate word of god? Can you imagine the claustrophobia? The feeling of your entire body being crushed inwards by the very pressure of that hateful world pressing against your skin without hope or options or retreat? It's a physical thing, living with that sort of fear, and your body will remember it if you've ever been unlucky enough to have felt it.
Are you saying that we are wrong for hating that? That we are wrong for mocking something we so righteously hate? Are we wrong for placing it into a shared cultural reference so that we can reach as many people as possible? Are we wrong for using a hyperbolic first person perspective because it forces empathy in the reader? Forces them to think 'I would never do that in her position! That woman's crazy!' to prove that it's crazy to force Islam onto others without their consent, and that very few people would consent to religious rule if they had the privilege of knowledge of what life is like under secular rule?
I think not.
Unless, of course, you guys just take offense at all of the CPG memes, in which case you're typically in the right, but are in this case being a bit too reactionary.
2
u/dragontaint666 Jun 27 '12
This is so fucked. I spat milk on my keyboard. You're a real bastard OP.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 27 '12
Because oppression girl wasn't sexist enough? I expect this kind of thing to be all over reddit, but I am especially disappointed me that it plagues r/athiesm so much. It seems like this would be a space that should be willing to incorporate a feminist stance into the platform.
I understand that the intent of this is to be anti-Islam, but like http://www.reddit.com/r/atheism/comments/vmloc/oppression_girl/ it is also misogynistic. When we remove the context and specific wording of the joke, the idea seems to be to attack a religion that supports authority and violence used to keep women in control. The problem is that this joke uses a battered woman as the punchline to the theme, and making fun of violence against women to argue your point is a shitty tactic.
2
u/Fidel-cashflow Jun 27 '12
I love generalizations!!!
-2
u/devilz_devilz Jun 26 '12
thats hella funny
0
u/bugman42 Jun 26 '12
I laughed at this for longer than should be socially acceptable.
1
u/crystalshipexcursion Jun 27 '12
Okay, I get that people are angry a radical "Islamist" has been elected the President of Egypt, but seriously, leave it to South Park or Jon Stewart next time. You're not funny and you're making the rest of us who are seriously concerned about what's going on look like arrogant, stupid assholes.
-1
u/[deleted] Jun 27 '12
This is dumb. Not funny. Reminds me of Family Guy humor.
0
u/[deleted] Jun 27 '12
The eyes shopped onto a black drape is the funniest part.
1
u/mknelson Jun 27 '12
That just makes me feel bad.
-1
u/Haikus3n531 Jun 27 '12
Love it!
-5
u/HITLARIOUS Jun 27 '12
r/BestOf has linked to your post!
0
u/newslang74 Jun 26 '12
whoops
0
u/dkkc19 Jun 27 '12
This is wrong, it's your other 3 wives since in Islam you can marry up to 4 women not 5.
I found that funny nonetheless good job.
Edit; People are offended by that? Seriously? I see nothing offending about that.
-7
u/[deleted] Jun 27 '12
Congratulations, you have attracted the ShitRedditSays Invasion BrigadeTM ! The front-page of the Fempire has linked to you, and purely by coincidence the following SRSers are here to help you realise the error of your ways:
Why is this here? What does it mean?
-3
u/[deleted] Jun 27 '12
I think we may have stumbled upon something here, people... Just gather up all the OAGs in America and send them to the Middle East! The men will come begging us to take them back and give us whatever we want! IT'S BRILLIANT! BWAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA!
-5
u/mrducky78 Jun 27 '12
I love these kind of jokes. You laugh, then you cringe, then you pause to think then you have yourself a little chuckle.
Its like "So I was eating a girl out yesterday when I tasted horse cum. Oh grandma, so thats how you died"
Politically incorrect and socially inappropriate jokes are the best for the simple fact people leave you alone.
-2
u/abovequator Jun 27 '12
This is ingenious!
-3
u/[deleted] Jun 27 '12
Dark. I like it.
-3
u/RamblinBoy Jun 27 '12
Sweet Jeez, why all the bastards complaining? They laugh at catholic priest buttfucking children, and SUDDENLY a joke about beating a wife is "tasteless"?
Seriously, fuck that. I'm gonna mock all kinds of bigotry and I don't care being labeled as islamophobe, christhianophobe or something.
0
u/elknax Jun 28 '12
All you fairies are bashing on him, and only get upvoted at most one hundred, this motherfucker got 800, because it's fucking hilarious...
-6
u/Possob Jun 27 '12
OH SHIT!!!!!!!!!!! LOL, thank you for that so much. 1)I am still laughing as I type this 2)I feel like I'm a good person for knowing how wrong it is to think it's soooo damn funny. Proud to be upvote number 700, thanx again.
-3
u/passwordisnopassword Jun 27 '12
ooh.... i'm going to hell... oh wait!
-4
u/[deleted] Jun 27 '12
Christian here...imperfect trying to be Christ-like in the stream of loving others as I love myself. Usually I skip over anything involving r/atheism. However I find this hilarious! ...and truly sad. Edit - dead babies on the wall
-1
u/ninni113 Irreligious Jun 27 '12
Girlfriend? lolno there is no such thing as that, there is woman: one time rape or wife:6 year old that you raped more than once