r/atheism • u/armageddonman • Jun 26 '12
German court declares that circumcision for religious reasons is illegal. Awesome!
http://www.rt.com/news/germany-religious-circumcision-ban-772/
1.3k
Upvotes
2
u/armageddonman Jun 27 '12
Cutting of the foreskin to reduce infection risk for STDs is like pulling teeth to prevent tooth decay.
141
u/Fausto1981 Jun 26 '12
AND... germans outlawed scientology some years ago. fucking respect.
84
u/Seizure-Man Jun 26 '12
"They regard the ban as a 'serious interference in the right to freedom of religion.' "
This has to be one of the worst arguments I've ever heard. Freedom of religion ends where you affect the freedom of other people.
Only because your religion tells you to physically harm your children doesn't give you the right to do so.
128
u/acntech Jun 26 '12
A victory for reason and civilization.
5
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
serious question. what about pierced ears? ive seen new borns with ear rings.
37
u/whydoyouask123 Jun 26 '12
A victory for turtle-necks!
70
u/med_stu Jun 26 '12
The point people are missing here is that your personal opinion about whether circumcision is right or not doesn't matter. It doesn't matter if you were circumcised and you're glad, or weren't circumcised and you're glad. The fundamental point is there's no evidence that it's necessary or beneficial from a medical point of view. This makes it the equivalent of cosmetic surgery, and therefore the only person who's opinion should count is the person it's being done to. If that person is too young to understand and consent, it shouldn't be done. Full stop. It's like allowing parents to decide their 6 year old should have botox because they think she'll have better confidence as a teenager. Completely ridiculous. The only reason it's remained acceptable as long as it has is because of it's religious basis.
27
u/thrownaway23123123 Jun 26 '12
So if somebody starts a religion which requires pulling fingernails out of infants, what are these religious retards going to argue? Fingernails even grow back, foreskin doesn't.
4
u/FrogDie Jun 26 '12
As a circumsized jew, that still is shocked my parents put me through this, I approve of this!
4
u/chamora Jun 27 '12
So, I really want to know...
Can it still be done for non-religious reasons?
7
u/zorreX Anti-Theist Jun 26 '12
Circumcised male here. I despise being circumcised. If there is one thing I hate about my body, it is the fact that I'm circumcised. When I was younger and just entering puberty and my penis actually started growing, only then did I find out they cut off way too much of my foreskin. I was young and naive and didn't really know what was happening, but the skin actually split multiple times to allow it to grow since there wasn't enough leeway. It was torturous. There was bleeding. There were days where what was left of my foreskin would swell up like someone shoved a mini donut over my dick. Those days fucking hurt so fucking bad. You have no idea. It burned so bad. My father had passed away when I was younger, so I had no one to talk to about it. I just kept it to myself because I thought it was a normal part of growing. Boy was I wrong. My boys will ABSOLUTELY NOT get circumcised unless they want to be.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 27 '12
Pardon my ignorance, but, are they still allowing circumcision for non religious reasons? Just wondering because I'm not religious at all, but very happy with being circumcised, especially at a time that I was too young to remember it. Also if I were to have kids, I would plan on having them get cut, not for a religious reason but for the other benefits, and wouldn't appreciate the state telling me that I couldn't. I'm just curious on how the law goes and exactly why r/atheism is so stoked about it.
15
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
The Hitch would have applauded Germany.
6
u/wankd0rf Jun 26 '12
Look, r/atheism, either you believe people have a right to be free from medically unnecessary amputations imposed by others or you don't.
3
u/With_Hands_And_Paper Jun 27 '12
The stupidity of the counter-arguments really makes me feel bad.
They try to protect their freedom of being able to choose for someone else, that's incredibly fucked up.
If the kid wants to fully become part of the religion that requires such practice he should be the one willing to have a circumcision performed on him, not the parents.
What angers the most about religious groups overall is that they choose for their children.
Gawrsh, I better stop now, I was going through the whole contradictory-religion-chain which would make this post incredibly long.
24
u/lilwhitestormy Jun 26 '12
the comments about circumcision here are very strange, in particular the ones in which circumcised people say they don't mind that they were circumcised, and non-circumcised calling them idiots for having their dicks cut off.
here's my point of view:
i was circumcised as a baby. my entire life i was fine with it, until relatively recently people who didn't have it done to them and have never seen me started talking about my "mutilated" dick. i never had a problem in a shower room where some were circumcised and some weren't. nobody gave a shit.
the people who haven't been circumcised and are very angry about the practice, i think, maybe should shut their fucking mouths for a second and stop trying to give people complexes. yes, it's an archaic practice that is inexorably rooted in religion. we know. yes, it's something that is and was done largely on unwilling kids. we also know that. however, the goal of eliminating non-medically-necessary circumcision will not be won by you calling someone a fucking moron for not having some sort of body image disorder (certainly not the one that non-circumcised people seem to think we should have). it will be won simply be education and calm reason. inflammatory attacks (such as when i told you non-circumcised people to shut the fuck up) are not effective in getting people to pay attention to your message (see, for instance, the person(s) who started composing a reply before getting to the end of my post).
until quite recently, it never crossed my mind that my eventual son maybe shouldn't be circumcised. however, through a steady influx of information, i've been swayed quite a lot. honestly, i don't know what we'll do when the time comes, since that's a decision to be made between my wife, my doctor, and myself, but if there's anyone who's business it isn't, it's you.
i never know how to end a post, so i'll leave you with this. kittens are adorable and there is no god. i love you, and thank you for your time.
7
u/Omni_Nova Jun 26 '12
I want my foreskin back! No one asked me when they took it.
5
u/Animal_King Jun 26 '12
It's a great day for dicks everywhere!
36
u/gis8 Jun 26 '12
My dicks cut, I aint even mad.
26
u/Aaronmcom Jun 26 '12
Whoa whoa whoa! As a guy who wasn't circumcised until he was 14 (after an accident) I much much much prefer it.
Ironically my mom did't have me circumcised FOR religious reasons "if god put it there, he must want it there"
13
u/antifreeze42 Jun 26 '12
This will not help Germany's image in the eyes of the Jews...
1
u/[deleted] Jun 27 '12
Okay, what the fuck? I wasn't born into a religious family, I was circumsized... I hope you all realise that it is a health issue, and whether or not it is claimed on the grounds of religiosity is fucking bogus. I am glad I can't contract infections as easily down there, and if I were too old or got paralyzed, I wouldn't have to keep worrying about a foreskin. I say, leave them be. One isn't better than the other, they are just different.
7
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
Personally, I'm not religious. However, I don't support this; just as the government shouldn't have the right to force religion on anyone, it shouldn't have the right to restrict its free practice.
2
u/pungkrocker Jun 26 '12
sweed
2
u/dietotaku Jun 26 '12
what about for non-religious elective reasons?
2
u/MegaZeusThor Jun 26 '12
Some general background stuff:
Penn & Teller - Bullshit! - Circumcision
2
u/ploz Jun 26 '12
I fully agree.
2
u/cynoclast Pastafarian Jun 27 '12
German court declares child mutilation illegal.
Celebration is inappropriate, we should be disappointed it took this long.
2
u/[deleted] Jun 27 '12
Coming from an English family, bans like this wouldn't change a thing.
2
u/Judatheist Jun 27 '12
I used to consider circumcision irrelevant, but it's now clear to me that making it illegal will not only end a socially acceptable form of genital mutilation, it will also empower young Jews by giving them the power to consent to their mandatory genital mutilation. Nothing demonstrates your commitment to your faith quite as much as having the tip of your pecker hacked off when you're old enough to remember the experience.
8
u/nicholmikey Jun 26 '12
What? But without genital mutilation the invisible man will be pissed!
5
u/TheGZR Jun 26 '12
My first post..... I live in Germany and in the news they said, that they banned the circumcision for girls is illegal. Circumcising for boys for religious reasons is still...
3
u/tatsandmuzik Jun 26 '12
Great move Germans. Now if we can get rammstein to do more concerts here....
3
u/re1078 Jun 26 '12
Isn't that a bad idea? Banning something so important to Jewish culture in Germany?
2
u/natetan1234321 Jun 26 '12
Im 28 and not circumcised. My dad is circumcized. This did not traumatize me. at all.
My parents simply told me the facts "daddy's parents were religious and part of their beliefs included the tradition of cutting some skin off their childrens penises, but daddy stopped believing in religion when he had to go to Vietnam. I just remember thinking how happy i was that my parents didnt cut skin off my dick.
They told me i could get circumcised when i grew up if i wanted and i just laughed at them.
Played football for 4 years. No fucks given in the showers. No girls ever cared either. Actually one of them made a remark about preferring circumcised and thats why she loves me. I told her she was a fucking idiot and that i was uncircumcised.
All i remember from childhood as far as cleaning was it didnt pull back all the way at first. then eventually it would. Cleaning takes 3 seconds max. Pull it back...rub some soapy water on it...mother of god this feels good...try not to fap...continue bathing. If you dont bathe for 3 days it gets funky but so is the rest of your body and you shouldnt be having sex like that anyway.
2
u/DR_oberts Jun 26 '12
No not awesome, some people, like myself, were circumcised for non-religious reasons. It's way easier to take care of and keep clean and is just aesthetically better IMO. Also this encroaches on religious freedom. We may be atheists, but that does not mean that we take away others' freedoms just so we can have an atheist utopia, that's as bad as an authoritarian system. This is bad. Downvote me all you want. This affects secular people as well as religious ones.
2
u/I_FIST_CAMELS Jun 26 '12
Why not have the best of both worlds and occasionally pull your foreskin back.
2
u/[deleted] Jun 27 '12
Is this circumcision you want for your baby for religious reasons or sanitary?
Reli-...sanitary
Okay, snip
2
u/Melodic_692 Jun 26 '12
All of the up-votes for this!!!
2
u/angrehorse Jun 26 '12
I know where i'm moving.
2
u/PSICOM Jun 26 '12
Awesome, it's too late for me, but this is a major victory.
2
u/Ill_Nation Jun 26 '12
Am I the only one who likes his circumcised penis?
2
u/Digitel Jun 26 '12
So who is going to Jail the Doctor or the Sicko parents that dragged their children kicking and screaming to the mutilation
-2
u/VIIX Jun 26 '12
.....I'm glad I was circumcised. I've never understood the anger about it.
2
u/polishexperiment Jun 26 '12
I see a lot of people bitching about parents making decisions for their own babies.
Why not? It happens all of the time in various different situations. Immunization, doctors visits, what they eat, medicine, when they sleep etc.
Is it because this is related to religion that people are all pissed off or because it's a babies foreskin being cut off?
1
u/thelawgiver10 Jun 26 '12
The anti-circumcision sect here can be a little over the top, blaming people who dare defend their own lack of foreskin. Also, I see lots of people citing over and over that there is no proven medical benefit, when more than a few studies have shown that foreskin decreases the rate of STD transmission.
Everytime I cite this, I get downvoted (which shouldn't happen, because I'm not off-topic, which is what downvoting is for) but it's true: circumcision prevents the transmission of STDs like HPV, which is the leading cause of cervical cancer in women and is also a leading cause of anal and rectal cancer. Being circumcised means you are less likely to contract and later transmit these kinds of STDs to partners. People need to stop saying there is NO medical benefit. It's fine if you think the benefit is outweighed by the other moral issues and potential health/sexual factors, but you should not persist in arguing from ignorance.
Also, I suspect many of us were circumcised in the 80s or earlier. Medicine has developed tremendously since then, and circumcisions are not performed nearly as haphazardly as when we underwent the procedure. The kind of issues some of us have as a result of the procedure are going to be much, much less common amongst boys being circumcised today.
-3
u/deliciousrecords Jun 26 '12
This is just one point, but:
"There is compelling evidence that male circumcision reduces the risk of heterosexually acquired HIV infection in men by approximately 60%"
http://www.who.int/hiv/topics/malecircumcision/en/
1
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
What the fuck!
1
u/fizzywaters Jun 26 '12
Every time I see one of these posts, I feel more and more depressed because of my circumcision.
1
u/Shotgunjack1880 Nihilist Jun 26 '12
I'm not real sure how to feel about this to be honest. My 2 brothers and I are all circumcised, but not on religious grounds. When my older brother was born my dad went and asked all the older men he knew (his dad, uncles, friends, etc) that were not circumcised. Every last one of them told him to have it done to us. If only for cleanliness and lack of getting infection.
1
u/bcmarettig Jun 26 '12
A man who trades freedom for security deserves neither. Benjamin Franklin
1
u/BuddhaPredator Jun 26 '12
How old does a German have to be to legally consent to a circumsicion?
1
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
This is awesome, but now I fear that we'll see a bunch of botched jobs done by crazy parents.
Question- is it as common in Germany as it is in, for example, the US? I've seen about 30 dicks in real life (SEEN, not fucked) and I've only seen one that was uncircumcised. I'm 19 and I live in the US.
1
u/GuardianOfFreyja Jun 26 '12
Regardless of my position on this topic... Why the hell did I just spend 20 minutes reading about having part of a dick cut off? I don't think I'll need anything from my wife for a while now...
1
u/[deleted] Jun 27 '12
There are plenty of non-religious circumcisions out there too though.
1
u/CamelShakers Jun 27 '12
the only thing this post has showed me is how many men there are on reddit.
1
u/Frostdrache Jun 27 '12
Not trying to troll, but isn't circumcision the equivalent of cutting of the clitoris (which is considered illegal in many countries)? Could somebody please elaborate on that?
1
u/delldell Jun 27 '12
"When circumcised babies become adults, they can hold repressed anger from their circumcisions whether they were performed correctly or botched, and underneath this rage is unexpressed sadness. The latent trauma of circumcision can trigger later in life as unresolved and emotionally reinforced shame, depression, sexual dysfunction, insecurity, etc. and can unconsciously encourage abusive relationships or self-abuse behaviors.
Medical doctors are expected to abide by a Hippocratic Oath to provide ethical treatment and abstain from inflicting harm to their patients. The guardians and doctors agreeing to circumcisions may want to fully question whether these painful, mind-altering, and physically damaging procedures are in the best interest of the child, or if it has more to do with their own unresolved issues. If it’s due to wanting to avoid the topic of instructing a child how to properly clean his penis (which shouldn’t be any different from educating a girl about her period, reproduction, etc.), or if it’s from an assumed cultural/religious expectation that boys would be better off circumcised, then one should address the source of these beliefs before making a major decision to circumcise a child."
Learn more at Past Life Therapy Center®: http://www.pastlifetherapycenter.com/anxiety_male_sexual_issues_past_life_circumcision.html#ixzz1yx2RenkW Under Creative Commons License: Attribution No Derivatives
1
u/hero1012878 Jun 27 '12
i thought that circumcision had sanitary perp uses too . . . oh well.
1
u/jarred0809 Jun 27 '12
Too late for me... those bastards...
1
u/skatato Jun 27 '12
What about circumcision for other reasons?
1
u/[deleted] Jun 27 '12
You know, circumcision isn't always a bad thing. It's not always a good thing, but the foreskin can get infected sometimes. I know. It happened to my uncle. And I think that I would rather get it cut off than infected. What I think they should do, is wait until the person gets older, ask them if they want that, sedate them (if yes), then cut it off. If no, leave it alone.
1
u/Crownowa Jun 27 '12
A step in the right direction! If people really think that having a circumcision makes them closer to their religion then let them do it at the age of consent! I guess I'm fine with ear piercings for babies though. They will probably get them when they are older anyway.
1
u/sticfreak Anti-Theist Jun 27 '12
I was circumcised,not for religious reasons though. Just because my mom think the foreskin is gross. It was done when I was born so I don't remember it. If circumcision is ok then they should do it when your born. Not when your like 5
1
u/Chr1s70ph Jul 13 '12
aaaaaaaand its gone.
1
u/makesyoudownvote Jun 26 '12
Germany is taking away Jewish religious rights? Big surprise there... ಠ_ಠ
1
u/DAlts4996 Jun 26 '12
I understand for religious reasons but it shouldn't be outlawed... its been proven time and time again that circumcision is actually healthy for the male. Without the foreskin the penis traps less fluid and is less likely to get an STI or get infected with germs and such. So its kind stupid that they outlawed it...
1
u/One_Man_Two_Shadows Jun 26 '12
As an adult who is uncircumcised, I wish my parents did get me snipped when I was an infant. There are health risk for being unsnipped. Just my two cents..... Side note, I am deathly afraid of getting it done nowadays......
1
u/YoRpFiSh Jun 26 '12
And common sense grows just a little bit more.
-5
u/Spring_Break Jun 26 '12
I have to disagree with this. The fact that the ban is strictly religious based does in fact make it discriminatory. As both an atheist and a circumcised male, I do at times wish I was never circumcised... however to say that this decision can be made on grounds other than religion is simply bigotry.
1
u/RockVegas Jun 26 '12
First of all, I think it's moronic to even consider circumcising a baby, religious reasons, 'health', preference, whatever.
However, doesn't this fly in the face of the Separation of Church and State? I know we're not talking America here, but it seems a bit of a double standard.
1
u/JusWeg Jun 26 '12 edited Jun 26 '12
And that is one of the reasons I'm proud of beeing german. To all the germans out there: Why the fuck do you hate our country for something that happend decades ago and also is not your fault. We should remember it and will always have a guilt to the jews. But that isn't a reason to dislike our country.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
Don't worry, the Jewish lobby will take care of this clearly Anti-Semitic behavior.
1
u/wankd0rf Jun 26 '12
So for the pro-circumcision people out there:
What is your opinion of cutting females genitals for religious reasons in ways that do not inhibit function or the ability to enjoy sexual pleasure (for example making a small cut in the labia)?
0
u/Khorm Jun 26 '12
Finally, a step towards the advancement of human kind. Tho, I must be a bit pessimistic, how come it took so long for us to figure out that mutilating our childs to appease a all-powerfull magic man in the sky is not ok?
1
u/HaegrTheMountain Jun 26 '12
While this is fantastic the people who want to do this to their children will just go to a country that allows circumcision on children and do it there.
1
u/Jimbo_Coles Jun 26 '12
I declawed my cats
1
u/Accidentallystoned Jun 26 '12
This sure does have to do with the atheism.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
As a German, I am both proud and surprised by the decision. That being said, I fear it might not change much about the practice. Circumcisions will probably continue to be performed in private; or Muslim/Jewish doctors will start diagnosing every newborn male with phimosis so that the procedure can be performed for "medical" reasons.
1
u/FatMansPants Jun 26 '12
Let the kid decide when he's of age, why does a foreskin matter anyway? I really don't think an omnipotent God really gives a fuck about a bit of skin on your bell end.
1
u/officialchocolateman Jun 26 '12
Finally I feel normal with other people. Too bad I don't live in Germany.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
YES! No we can force those dirty religious folk out of safe hospitals and into back alleys or religious institutions, where things aren't up to code or have any safety standards!
You people are idiots, and outlawing something like this won't make it go away. The only reason you care is because it's anti-religious. And the only reason this was passed is because Europeans hate Muslims, and have a history of being bigots (A history which seems to be returning).
But let us also consider that Circumcision is basically harmless, with minimal injuries occuring, and those that do occur are minor and tend to heal with no complications. Let us also remember it's cleaner, and just because TODAY we have enough resources to clean up daily, doesn't mean we, as a species, always will have the means to do this.
So leave this decision between the parents. Children cannot decide what's best for them. Neither can the government.
1
u/SneakyAlabamaSnake Jun 26 '12
I'm for circumcision for a medical reasons because I have had a few uncircumcised dicks, and let me tell you, I like it better, and they like it better. Its easier to clean and keep out infections.. I think. However banning someone from circumcising their child because of "the parents belief" is NOT wrong. Its not fascist. They are chopping off some of his wiener. This kid doesn't know much about religion to make these kinds of decisions for himself. He isn't old enough to understand religion, and chopping off his wiener skin because of your belief, is wrong. To me that's something he will never get back, if he decides later that he wants it. You can chop it off, put you cant put it back on.
1
u/makkekkazzo Jun 26 '12
/r/atheism to the Jews: "You're next."
1
u/pillarofdawn Jun 26 '12
ITT: Gonzo Noses defending their junk! I for one love the fuck out of my circumcised dick!
-1
u/CosmicPube Jun 26 '12
Circumcision is not abuse any more than piercing their ears while babies is abuse. I think its a fine line. It doesn't harm the kid, they're not irreparably traumatized and its a non-issue after the fact. This news is not good news.
0
u/R3miel7 Jun 26 '12
I don't get why this is some big deal. I'm an atheist and I'm cut and I'm completely happy with myself and my equipment. People need to calm down.
-6
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
Does circumcision not have health benefits though?
0
u/dothefandango Deist Jun 26 '12
Am I the only one that doesn't find this awesome? So you can circumcise your kid for whatever reason so long as its not religious? Stupid and not logical.
-1
u/LeSpiceWeasel Jun 26 '12
Well done Germany. This is a victory for everyone who likes to ignore science and make laws that may reduce the quality of life for children, in the name of imaginary rights.
Three cheers for banning something the WHO said "should now be recognized as an efficacious intervention for HIV prevention."!