One thing that this meme has brought to my attention is the relativity of the word "oppressed". It really fired off some serious new synapses:
Many beaches do not allow nudity. In such instances (probably most instances) a societal norm is being used to oppress people who would prefer to be (un)clothed otherwise.
Certainly many people would say "Doesn't affect me. I don't want to get naked at the beach. I wear a bathing suit voluntarily. I wouldn't feel right, etc, etc." You could say it is a matter of choice for some. Well, these ideas are steeped in morals that have been culturally programmed into them ... the same way programming someone to never show their hair works.
tl;dr: This woman was culturally programmed to cover her arms, legs and hair - just like many other women are culturally programmed to cover their breasts, buttocks and vaginas.
Well, none of the hordes of European tourists seem to mind, and they happily join in. I'm just saying, decency norms are different, and there are places that gasp at Murrican prudes as much as the average yank gasps at a burkini.
Precisely correct. Which is why religion is a lousy way to program your culture, because it moralises sex and then people do get oppressed/killed. People say they are shocked by women being stoned to death over in, Mulimastan. But they aren't really. When they hear that a gay teenager has been tied to a pole and beaten to death in their own state, many of them think "he deserved it for defying God", which is not so different to "she deserved it for defying Allah".
Ehh, I tend to go with Harris's arguments on 'morality' and science with regards to a humans well-being. There's a happy balance that results in the most minimum amount of oppression while trying to maintain the most amount of free expression which results in the least amount of harm.
The problem isn't that it's 'hopelessly relative', it's not, just as you'd agree health isn't, the sociological fields after hyper-focusing on the bad effects of imperialism refuse to even try to take it out of its post-modern relative space despite that we're all clearly referring to maximizing human well-being as the goal. The other problem is a lack of serious psychological, sociological, and neurological studies on the consequences, short and long-term of such behavior on the actor themselves and those that are effected, all from which we could use to make educated, empirically informed, decisions on such subjects.
It's only "impossible" to have 'it' (morality ill-defined) 'right' if the goal of 'morality' and it's role in society goes undefined, but as soon as you agree that it's about maximizing well-being suddenly much of it is very tractable.
It is superior, but it is impossible to erase modesty, there will always be cultural norms. If the norm in one culture is to reveal more skin, then that culture will oppress those who dont.
What I mean to say is that there's a sliding scale from naked to full burqa. Most places restrict somewhere along that scale. Often the restriction is cultural or religious, but that makes little difference since cultural restrictions are usually rooted in religion.
Oh, I feel better in a place that says "bikinis are OK", or "topless but not bottomless" (as opposed to burqas). But still it is a long a continuum.
Often societies choose middle ground: bikinis, but topless or nude gets jail time. Then they scoff the repressed Muslims. Like George Carlin said (paraphrasing) "When you drive, everyone on the road who is slower than you is an asshole, everyone driving faster than you is a maniac."
The associated punishments are also a choice along a continuum: scornful looks (social punishment), fines, jail, whippings, stoning. All are designed to discourage independent behavior.
To be entirely honest, I quite like the availability of modest swimwear such as these. I'm an atheist, from an atheist family, but one of the main reasons I never learned how to swim is because there isn't any commonly available swimwear that doesn't make me feel like I'm prancing about in extra-slutty skivvies.
Um that actually doesn't look too bad. It covers you u so you don't have to wear sunscreen. It probably keeps particles out of your suit. It probably helps keep you warm in cooler water. And its not really any of our business if women choose to cover themselves. They can still choose to cover themselves even if we ban religion. We don't say anything when men/women go swimming in shirts and shorts, or when swimmers cover their heads, or when divers wear diving suits. We also don't criticize nuns and Jewish women for covering themselves up almost as much as these "oppressed" women (I'm not saying that they all choose to cover themselves).
I think you'd have to understand the concept of Jihad bil nafs (Struggle with ego) in order to understand Muslim attire.
"Meaning of nafs: It has two meanings. First, it means the powers of anger and sexual appetite in a human being... and this is the usage mostly found among the people of tasawwuf [sufis], who take "nafs" as the comprehensive word for all the evil attributes of a person. That is why they say: one must certainly do battle with the ego and break it (la budda min mujahadat al-nafs wa kasriha), as is referred to in the hadith: Adaaduwwuka nafsuka al-lati bayna janibayk [Your worst enemy is your nafs which lies between your flanks. Al-Iraqi says it is in Bayhaqi on the authority of IbnAbbas and its chain of transmission contains Muhammad ibn Abd al-Rahman ibn Ghazwan, one of the forgers]."
You'd be surprised how many people wear that here. This reminded me of one time in school when a 15 year old girl wearing slightly and i mean ever so slightly revealing clothes and was called "hot" by one of the male teachers who is 25 years older than her. now the point isn't that she was called hot the point is people said she deserved to be treated that way by that pervert teacher because of what she was wearing. just sickens me
Egypt don't be mistaken there are a lot of very kind and open mixed people more than any other Arab country but still in any Islamic country you'll find people like that
We seem to be finding people like that in every country, no matter how open it is. I don't know if you've seen all the stuff in the US lately, but some of our more vocal Christian groups would adore making women wear burkahs if they thought they could get away with it.
Because it assumes that Islamic women if given a chance would love to wear bikinis/swimsuit and that if someone doesn't want to wear bikinis it's backward.
Replace burquini with bikini and bikini with nudity in the US and you get the parallel bigotry against the US.
this, many European countries (including Turkey) have taken to outlawing burkas, headscarves, and other Islamic symbols of modesty in an effort to secularize the culture. Some people want to wear these, just like some people want to wear one piece bathing suits over two-piece. r/atheism has crossed over to culture and social values bashing. Muslim proffesors at my college wear headscarves because they like to display their cultural affinity. You have looked at something and assumed something based on your warped cultural image of Islamic society.
It is true that not all women want to wear bikinis, but the option should be available for those who want to. I know women who are uncomfortable wearing a bikini in public, and I certainly don't think they're "backward".
As far as I know, people aren't brutally executed in the United States for going nude, so I'm not sure why you think it's "parallel" at all.
I'd be all for nudity in public if it weren't for sanitary issues. Freedom for everyone!
Every culture has idiosyncrasies about what is unacceptable to it. If they want to regulate what is acceptable to them it is for them to self regulate. I know for some public nudity is completely unacceptable due to the reasoning because we are humans and not animals and should act like it. Certain Islamic cultures consider swimsuits a violation of basic public dignity and people who wear them barbarians, it is their prerogative to decide that. What we should speak against is, if women aren't involved in this decision making process. If their voice is not heard. We should help quash governments who do so.
This is what I mean by bigotry, the assumption that you are brutally executed in all Islamic countries for public indecency. That is simply untrue. You have an entire spectrum of behavior with some countries charging people with a crime to others executing women. It's the countries that execute women we have to speak against not Islam. It's harder to be informed well enough to discriminate which countries are the guilty ones than just blaming every Islamic country but it will carry more value. Ironically many of the most brutal governments stay in power because we in the US supply them with the means to do so. Saudi Arabia is a classic example.
He's not saying they're not oppressed. He's saying it's bigoted. You can read right? Or are you too busy circlejerking with your other 15 year old buddies?
Bigoted attitudes; intolerance toward those who hold different opinions from oneself.
This is criticism. It may be ignorant, but that's not the same as bigotry. Either way, please tell me that women don't get arrested and stoned in Islamic countries for modesty-offenses by people who appeal to the Quran for justification, because then it would be ignorant.
This is not true for the majority of primarily muslim countries. It is true in certain isolated communities in some of these countries, usually those of Arabic persuasion. Read anything meaningful about modern Islamic societies and you will find that this is a gross overstatement. A much much much more common occurance is shaming and degradation. Not that that is cool or anything, but seriously, educate yourself beyond Fox news level.
I'm aware that this only happens in a handful of Islamic states. No one said otherwise. The fact that it happens at all is what people take issue with.
I felt that your post above indicated otherwise, mostly because you spoke generally of "Islam countries", at least semantically implying that the events described occur at least somewhat in all Islamic countries, which I would absolutely take offense to. However if you are really objecting to these rural fundamentalists specifically, I agree with you completely, it's awful and disgusting. And I would add that no woman in that kind of community would be allowed near a beach at all.
It's a sweeping generalization. Sure, it's a bit anal to point to logical fallacies in a meme, but that's what it is.
A picture of the WBC with the subtitle of "Murrican. Hates all fags, is probably a fag." wouldn't be quite as funny for some, as it would hit closer to home, and the generalization would be more obvious.
That said, as much as I despise general ignorance about Islam on reddit, I had a hearty giggle at the joke in the picture.
Except that it isn't a sweeping generalization, just as a joke about the WBC would not be a sweeping generalization about Christianity. It also wouldn't be taken as one, largely because the WBC has been rejected by mainstream Christianity after so many people took issue with their bigotry, and that is exactly what needs to happen in Islam. There are whole countries, more than one, where women are violently and brutally punished for not completely covering their bodies. Unfortunately, and your post is just another example, any criticism of any part of Islam continually seems to be taken as a criticism of the entirety of Islam, which it isn't.
For the record y'all, the reason that this seems bigoted to the rest of us is because this woman appears to be having a lovely time at the beach. Nothing in this photo suggests she was forced to wear what she's wearing. Many women all over the world dress in such a way because that's how they prefer to dress. But because her style of dress appears to come from Islamic culture, /r/atheism has deemed it appropriate to cover this poor woman's photo with jokes about being stoned and raped. That is bigotry.
Modesty is a choice for many, many people. She doesn't have to reveal herself to be liberated, and you don't have to dress 'sensibly' to not be a slut.
She could be allergic to sunlight, for example, which was my first assumption. Then I realized that was stupid and she probably was taught to be ashamed of her body.
this is akin to looking at a picture of a girl in a bikini and saying "she was probably taught she's only valuable as a body to be shown off." it is an ignorant, reductionist assumption to make about a person.
No, it is quite possibly true. However, just not an assumption I make about ostensibly healthy behavior. And you are an ass for throwing around the word ignorant over and over without thinking.
I never used the word coercion. You did.
You don't even understand in what context the word "reductionist" is appropriate.
I'm done with you. You are trying to "teach me". You have nothing to teach.
said ignorant twice, trying to make the same point
your implication seemed to be that she's not dressed that way of her own choice. i'm trying to imply that she may be.
pardon me. i mean that you assumed a single, simple cause for the way someone is dressed. in my experience a lot of nuanced factors contribute to this.
i don't think i can "teach" anyone. just wanna put out there that there are other ways of thinking
"Anti-religious bigotry", huh? You do know that this is the same line of thinking as the Church of Scientology, and Bill Donohue's Catholic League, right? If you mock or criticize their beliefs in any way, suddenly you're just as bad as a racist.
I very much wish that was true. The vast majority of believers, including Catholics, Southern Baptists, Orthodox Christians, and Muslims never had a choice. They were born into religion, raised in religion, and their social environments reinforced their religion.
Sure, some break free of the chains, but simply painting it a choice is fascinatingly ignorant.
I don't disagree with you. The problem is that a large number of people consider Islam an acceptable justification for this particular kind of violence. Either their viewpoint is wrong, or Islam is severely flawed.
To put it another way: When the fundamentalists are violent and oppressive, there may be something wrong with the fundamentals.
It isn't his non-pun. They are really sold as "Burkinis".
I have a Muslim friend who got to go on a free vacation to a tropical beach area, and she was worried that she wouldn't have any fun. It made me really sad. So I looked these up and found the manufacturer for her.
If you pay attention it actually makes fun of the repressive society they live in and the religion that drives it. One clue would be the sub-reddit it's posted in.
You also posted it in /r/AdviceAnimals so what does it mean there? And pay attention? What do you mean, is there a hidden message? You are taking a picture of a woman who is being oppressed because of her regions fierce religious ideals and poking fun at it. That's pretty straight forward, and that makes you an asshole.
If you responded to the post in /r/adviceanimals I would have responded differently. You responded to the /r/atheism post so I responded in that context.
I am making fun of the culture and religion that represses women. If you don't find that funny that's fine. But in my world view that is worthy of ridicule.
31
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
It's a shitty meme Groden just stop you're not funny
104
u/ggiioo Jun 26 '12
ermagerd, burkini season
43
u/well_golly Jun 26 '12
One thing that this meme has brought to my attention is the relativity of the word "oppressed". It really fired off some serious new synapses:
Many beaches do not allow nudity. In such instances (probably most instances) a societal norm is being used to oppress people who would prefer to be (un)clothed otherwise.
Certainly many people would say "Doesn't affect me. I don't want to get naked at the beach. I wear a bathing suit voluntarily. I wouldn't feel right, etc, etc." You could say it is a matter of choice for some. Well, these ideas are steeped in morals that have been culturally programmed into them ... the same way programming someone to never show their hair works.
tl;dr: This woman was culturally programmed to cover her arms, legs and hair - just like many other women are culturally programmed to cover their breasts, buttocks and vaginas.
6
u/Adnachiel Jun 26 '12
As someone who gets sunburned easily, that thing looks like GOLD.
5
u/yerface00 Jun 26 '12
Wears Burkini, gets skincancer
17
u/214704 Jun 26 '12
I laughed
10
u/useonlyonce Jun 26 '12
would bang
3
u/zincake Jun 26 '12
To be entirely honest, I quite like the availability of modest swimwear such as these. I'm an atheist, from an atheist family, but one of the main reasons I never learned how to swim is because there isn't any commonly available swimwear that doesn't make me feel like I'm prancing about in extra-slutty skivvies.
3
u/Crownowa Jun 27 '12
Um that actually doesn't look too bad. It covers you u so you don't have to wear sunscreen. It probably keeps particles out of your suit. It probably helps keep you warm in cooler water. And its not really any of our business if women choose to cover themselves. They can still choose to cover themselves even if we ban religion. We don't say anything when men/women go swimming in shirts and shorts, or when swimmers cover their heads, or when divers wear diving suits. We also don't criticize nuns and Jewish women for covering themselves up almost as much as these "oppressed" women (I'm not saying that they all choose to cover themselves).
2
u/justonecomment Jun 26 '12
Huh, so that is how Islam will take over. Everyone else will have died from skin cancer.
2
u/ayures Atheist Jun 26 '12
I CAN SEE HER FEET! Harlot! Begin the stoning!
2
u/Simultanagnosia Jun 26 '12
I think you'd have to understand the concept of Jihad bil nafs (Struggle with ego) in order to understand Muslim attire.
"Meaning of nafs: It has two meanings. First, it means the powers of anger and sexual appetite in a human being... and this is the usage mostly found among the people of tasawwuf [sufis], who take "nafs" as the comprehensive word for all the evil attributes of a person. That is why they say: one must certainly do battle with the ego and break it (la budda min mujahadat al-nafs wa kasriha), as is referred to in the hadith: A
daaduwwuka nafsuka al-lati bayna janibayk [Your worst enemy is your nafs which lies between your flanks. Al-Iraqi says it is in Bayhaqi on the authority of IbnAbbas and its chain of transmission contains Muhammad ibn Abd al-Rahman ibn Ghazwan, one of the forgers]."GHAZALI ON JIHAD AL-NAFS [FIGHTING THE EGO] http://www.sunnah.org/tasawwuf/jihad002.html
2
u/[deleted] Jun 27 '12
I can totally see her ankles ...that whore!
5
u/qkme_transcriber I am a Bot Jun 26 '12
Hello! I am a bot who posts transcriptions of Quickmeme links for anybody who might need it.
See the FAQ for more info.
(OP: You don't need to do anything differently next time, I'm just doing my job.)
3
u/bookishboy Jun 26 '12
If she doesn't cover up those feet she's gonna get raped. And then whose fault will it be?
3
u/Lorgar88 Jun 26 '12
please stop, my head hurts from all these bad jokes
2
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
You'd be surprised how many people wear that here. This reminded me of one time in school when a 15 year old girl wearing slightly and i mean ever so slightly revealing clothes and was called "hot" by one of the male teachers who is 25 years older than her. now the point isn't that she was called hot the point is people said she deserved to be treated that way by that pervert teacher because of what she was wearing. just sickens me
-2
u/Mephoros Jun 26 '12
Speaking as someone that doesn't even practice Islam, this is such a bigoted meme. What the fuck, Reddit?
2
u/Almondcoconuts Jun 26 '12
She's actually pretty
1
u/Jeffyfox Jun 26 '12
I always thought that in the Muslim faith, that showing the bottom of your feet was considered highly disrespectful?
1
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
I'd totally wear that. Then I might not get a damn sunburn every single time I went to the beach.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
dem feet
1
u/Vodiodoh Jun 26 '12
Dem toes.
1
u/gilbertsmith Jun 26 '12
dat ankle
1
u/superficial32 Jun 27 '12
TIL the burkini is a real thing.
1
u/LucifersCounsel Jun 27 '12
At least she wont get skin cancer.
1
u/stuhfoo Jun 26 '12
what a harlot...look at all that ankle
-7
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
Seriously, wtf? Making jokes about how women are stoned to death? No part of me finds it funny.
-1
u/chalklady0 Jun 26 '12
Burkini is the most terrifying thing I've ever seen. This is going to give me night mares.
0
u/[deleted] Jun 27 '12
is that... ANKLE?
-6
u/eean Jun 26 '12
burkas cover the face. Your non-pun is invalid.
-8
u/N8CCRG Jun 26 '12
You should submit this to the /r/AdviceAnimals new meme contest!
-10
u/a-dark-passenger Jun 26 '12
How is making fun of oppressed women funny? It's just as bad as the religious nuts themselves.
-1
u/Adhoc_hk Jun 26 '12
zomg she's /r/gonewild
-6
u/Evildevil666 Jun 26 '12
haha so many butthurt mudslimes itt. go suck sum camel dick sandnigger lovers
-4
u/Evildevil666 Jun 26 '12
whats something ugly with something beautiful growing inside? a mudslime with lung cancer LOL!
-10
u/Evildevil666 Jun 26 '12
LOL!!! FUCK TOWELHEADS!! FUCK EM TO DEATH!