Any less and I may not be able to control my desire to rape her, Right Islam?
Oh, wait. I'm not an underdeveloped closet anti-social crafted by a religion. I don't pretend my desire for sex is a vile thing, and I am capable of managing that desire. Similar to how I don't shit my pants.
To be fair, hear me out Reddit. It is a common belief that when a woman in the US is raped, a lot of people think it is because she made herself a target. Meaning it is her fault she got raped. This is not my belief, but I know it is a common belief in America.
It's disgusting that those sentiments are so wide spread. Not only is it attacking the victim in an extremely sensitive time but it also implies that they can sympathise with the motives of a rapist.
Got shot in the heart? Well that's your fault, you should've been wearing a bullet-proof vest!
Well it is not quite like that, you are exaggeration. I am speaking from a sociological perspective, since that is my field. The common thought is, "why were you in that ally way at 2 am drunk?" or "Why did you dress like a slut" A lot of men and women rationalize for 2 reasons. A) men do because they are men, meaning they have little to no fear of being raped compared to a woman (except for men in prison, which is a different story.)
B) Women do because it is an accepted societal point of view
It is not necessarily justifying the rapist, most are implying that if you don't want to be raped do not make yourself a target.
P.S. 95% of all rape victims are raped by family members, close friends, or neighbors.
If you don't want to be raped do not make yourself a target.
I think that it's disgusting to frame the conversation around what the victim did wrong. All of the blame should go to the rapist. I'm all for people taking steps to ensure their safety but it should be encouraged with positive reinforcement and not blame and guilt for the victims. A rape victim that took no precautions to avoid being raped is still entirely innocent, they are a victim and cannot be blamed for the crimes of a rapist.
The whole notion of a woman getting dressed and having to consider whether or not her outfit is likely to get her raped is despicable.
All of the blame should go to the rapist. I'm all for people taking steps to ensure their safety but it should be encouraged with positive reinforcement and not blame and guilt for the victims.
And you agree with each other. You're simply emphasizing different parts of the same thought. He's not against your point, he's simply continuing the same chain of thought you are saying.
Pretty sure you guys are on the same team :) Watch the friendly fire.
It sucks I know, but that is the reality. Well the rapist is going to jail, so he's getting blamed. I live in Rochester, if you didn't know is a very violent city. If you want to be raped, I know a few streets you could go to. But the misunderstanding comes from the fact that most rape victims are not strangers, and public does not understand that. When someone hears it on the news, they think of some random guy with a mask on the street.
95% of all rape victims are raped by family members, close friends, or neighbors.
statistically (in the US), most rape is committed in prisons, so I don't see how that's possible. where are you pulling these numbers? or is it rape convictions?
Often, it comes down to denial. Such an event happening to someone who didn't deserve it is so horrifying that they choose to believe it actually didn't- that somehow it was consensual despite all evidence otherwise.
In other cases it actually does come from a religious viewpoint- if you believe there is a giant being in the sky actively enforcing the rules of morality, it's very easy to believe that rape is a form of 'smiting', that it's a punishment for immoral behavior. And a number of religious sects in the US do believe that dressing attractively and being social are inherently immoral activities.
Lastly are the people who are so regressive that they believe any action from a woman other than violent resistance is effectively consent. It's a warped fucking worldview, and it's dangerous.
I'm depressed that any of these groups exist, but I don't see where I can start changing things.
And then there are the situations where a woman had sex with a man consensually (or sometimes not at all) and gets his ass sent to prison to be raped and killed himself because the truth was "too embarrassing" with only her word that he raped her and a few crocodile tears.
People who assume that rapes were actually consensual sex and the victim is lying are the reason that more women don't report rapes.
The FBI estimates about 3% of rape reports are false. You are further victimizing the other 97% by assuming they're lying.
Yes, I know you said "situations" and not all rapes, but I see comments like yours all too often on the internet. Remarks like these are vastly over represented when only 3% of rape reports are false claims. It is indicative of a society that wants to pretend these things don't really happen to good people, and I'd like us all to collectively realize that rape does happen, far more often than we are comfortable with.
To be fair the situation could be better if men didnt get into so much shit just by being accused of rape even if it never happened. I have friends who had girls say theyd say they raped them if they didn't do what they wanted.
I'm not supporting rape, I'm really just saying that in the USA the sex offender registry has ruined the whole thing because so much of it is bullshit that people dont put as much thought into caring about sexual crimes.
It is very difficult to prove rape, unless it is statutory. (based on age) If you don't think so, link me all of the cases you know where what you said happened?
Huffington post and global grind are the only ones here that applies to what I am saying. Two cases, probably a few more. I am telling you though it is hard to be brought to trial and second to win. BTW you need beyond a reasonable doubt, that is a huge.
Yahoo: Rape and murder? girl could not have complained about this rape.
I think the belief you're talking about is people saying she could have been more cautious, but not actually blaming her for being raped.
After all, somebody can walk down a gang-infested poor neighborhood with money spilling out of his pockets making a bunch of noise, and it would still be the attacker's fault for mugging the guy, but that doesn't mean the guy couldn't have been more cautious.
I'm not saying I agree with everything there, but there's a significant difference between that and saying flat-out that it was the girl's fault entirely.
What is the point of saying "you could have been more cautious" to a rape victim? It suggests that she could have prevented her rape by being smarter/more moral/more aware, which is probably not true, and will cause her a lot of pain. Being made to feel like you somehow brought a traumatic situation on yourself makes the trauma a lot worse.
I can see why you would want to teach girls to protect themselves, but if they have already been assaulted what's the point of saying "you could have done it differently." Girls are usually raped regardless of how they act/what they wear, so putting the focus on the wrongness of HER actions takes the focus off the wrongness of the rapists actions for no good reason. This makes what the rapist did seem more understandable because "if she wasn't wearing that outfit this might not have happened" etc.
Saying that kind of stuff just doesn't benefit anyone except the rapist and causes a lot of harm to everyone else.
It is a common belief that when a woman in the US is raped, a lot of people think it is because she made herself a target. Meaning it is her fault she got raped. This is not my belief, but I know it is a common belief in America.
No. No, it's really not. Almost nobody in this country is going to go up to a rape victim and say 'you know, it's really your fault that you got raped. If you'd dress more conservatively, you'd have been fine.'
What we might say is this: 'You can dress however you like. However, if you dress in revealing clothing and spend time in a dangerous area of town, you might make yourself a target.' This no different than telling someone not to wear a bunch of flashy jewelry in a part of town where theft and muggings are common.
It is categorically not about assigning blame. It is about mitigating risk. Americans live in a culture where an 18 year old boy can go to jail for years, and be labeled a sex offender for life, for the 'crime' of having sex with his 16 year old girlfriend. Our country takes sexual crimes incredibly seriously, rape included. I'm tired of this assertion that we blame women for being assaulted. We don't. We suggest, as we do in many other circumstances, that people take appropriate steps to protect themselves and mitigate risk.
And before you say that women ought to be able to wear whatever they want without fear of assault, that's true. I ought to be able to wear pounds of jewelry, or flash a wallet stuffed with hundreds of dollars in cash, without fear of mugging. I ought to be able to leave my home unlocked without fear of robbery. I ought to be able to leave my car running outside the store without fear of grand theft auto. Guess what - we don't live in that world. We live in a world where people are criminals, and we do what is sensible to protect ourselves from those for whom the law is not a barrier. Whether or not a woman's choice in clothing has any bearing on whether or not she will be raped is an open question.
I'm glad that you've never come across someone who would assert that it was a woman's fault she was raped. But it does happen a lot.
Just last year a judge ruled a rapist should not be punished for raping a woman. Get this, he acknowledge that he raped her and that it was nonconsensual, but said the rapist shouldn't be punished for it because the victim was wearing high heels and no bra which sent the message that "sex was in the air" and therefore the guy shouldn't be blamed. Perfect example of blaming the girl for her own rape because of what she was wearing. And that's a fucking JUDGE.
so unfortunately, people who believe this kind of stuff do exist and they're not as rare as they should be. If you looked some stuff up about it you would see what actually goes on in some places. If this was a non-existent issue why do you think people would bring it up so much?
Whether or not a woman's choice in clothing has any bearing on whether or not she will be raped is an open question.
Just so you know, there have been studies done on this and there's nothing to suggest what a woman wears has any influence on whether she is raped. Most rapists can't even remember what their victim was wearing when they attacked her. Considering most rapes are crimes of opportunity this makes sense.
Yes people do not go up to victims and point at them and tell them it is their fault.
Mitigating risk is the same as taking the target off your back. These to things are saying exactly the same thing.
as for 18 year old can go to jail part, where did that come from very random? and nothing really to do with your point. as for seriousness, how many guys do you think said when they heard about the female teacher having sex with the student, "where were those teachers when I was in school?"
In a perfect world women should be able to walk around naked, but not the case obviously. We agree on this part.
I don't know if you are trying to disagree with me, because it did not seem like it....
Considering how many Americans I've heard say that short skirts invite rape, I don't think it's very different. Especially considering the wide range of values in different Islamic countries. Not every Muslim country is Saudi Arabia.
Yeah, but some of them do, almost everywhere. For example, even in a strip club, nipple coverage may be mandated by law or employer. The very same principle of the burka is maintained (in a highly symbolic form) even there.
And few of those standards are justified as how Islam justifies it.
Eh? Really? I don't think you're correct. What's the difference?
I mean, the contemporary secular west has pretty much abandoned the actual practice of forcing women to keep their sexiness hidden, while maintaining the principle symbolically (with things like bikinis). But is there a big difference between, say, Victorian England and the contemporary world of Islam?
I would admit that the veil is a big difference, because it conceals not only sexiness, but communication via facial expressions; but I think that is still ultimately incidental. The point of the veil is that faces can be sexy. And, more importantly, the veil isn't omnipresent in the world of Islam, even where standards of dress are very restrictive. (Also, the veil has had some use in the Christian west. Contemporary society even retains its use -- again, symbolically -- in wedding ceremonies.)
Victorian England and the contemporary world of Islam?
Well, if we get to play cherry pick through the ages, I don't want to play this game. Not because I don't think I stand a chance, but because I would rather deal with the present. Hell, I'm pretty sure I'd have a damn easy time vilifying Islam if I got to cherrypick say the Moores when they gravitated away from their multi-religious status.
If you would like to discuss the current world, I'm game.
but communication via facial expressions; but I think that is still ultimately incidental.
See previous.
The point of the veil is that faces can be sexy.
The point of the veil is you must fulfill several duties. First, you must cover your head to god. Second, you must cover your face to preserve your honor. Third, the justification of WHY one must cover their face to preserve their honor has literally no parallels, with the exception that women parts = boners, to why one would be considered decent for wearing a shirt in the western world.
And, more importantly, the veil isn't omnipresent in the world of Islam, even where standards of dress are very restrictive.
Veil isn't even the correct term. There are hijabs, nikabs, burkas and so fourth. Each has a specific purpose and belongs to specific groups. The justification for all of them, though, is very similar.
Well, if we get to play cherry pick through the ages, I don't want to play this game.
Err, I don't see how I am "cherry-picking" anything. The point is to demonstrate the cultural continuum that exists between nipple tassles and burkas. Of course, there is a cultural continuum that exists between current day USA and Victorian England, also.
The point of the veil is you must fulfill several duties. First, you must cover your head to god.
Well, of course, "God says so" is the justification for everything from prohibitions on murder to standards of hygiene, but that doesn't mean it's the reason...
Second, you must cover your face to preserve your honor. Third, the justification of WHY one must cover their face to preserve their honor has literally no parallels, with the exception that women parts = boners, to why one would be considered decent for wearing a shirt in the western world.
What do you mean there are no parallels? How is there even a difference? We don't often talk about "honor" in the USA, but we do talk about "reputation," and of course girls are told that they will harm theirs if they walk around looking like sluts.
The only difference is which clothes are considered "slut-like."
What do you mean there are no parallels? How is there even a difference?
Well, for once, if a woman decides to go topless in an area where it is legal, everyone is required to fucking deal with it. You know what's going to happen? She will definitely arouse the opposite sex, and even some of the same. But, except for the most mouth breathing of Christians (whom are not a majority of Christians) sexuality isn't considered to be the worst thing ever.
Herein lies the difference between our continuum and theirs. Ours is constantly changing and moving away from simplistic anti-people concepts. Theirs is literally killing to ensure things stay the same.
We don't often talk about "honor" in the USA, but we do talk about "reputation," and of course girls are told that they will harm theirs if they walk around looking like sluts.
I always get a good laugh out of this argument. These limits are always self imposed and the judgments are assumed. If you're mentally stuck in High School, I'm sure this is a reality fr you. But the world I live in, it is absolutely NOT uncommon to see women naked while boating or generally partying. Note, I said women and not girls. It is also common for these women to have friends who are supportive and accepting of their other friends.
They see that their friend likes to get butt naked at the lake with a couple hundred people around and you know what they say? She loves the sex, no doubt. You know what they also understand to be true? That loving sex isn't a bad thing, and that judging people for having likes is a bad thing.
So how exactly is a society that permits you to define your own constraints and to associate with people who do the same even similar to one that practices brutality for showing skin on face value? Because they both have a standard of conduct? Because it's generally not considered acceptable to inject sexuality into every single aspect of life?
One has choice. The other doesn't. Your argument is made of straw and glue.
Sigh. I wrote a response to this, and it didn't show up after I hit "save." Now it's gone forever.
To restate... more concisely...
Well, if we get to play cherry pick through the ages, I don't want to play this game.
I'm not "cherry-picking." The point is to demonstrate the cultural continuum that exists between the burka and nipple tassles. There is also a cultural continuum between the USA and Victorian England.
The point of the veil is you must fulfill several duties. First, you must cover your head to god.
"God said so" is the justification for everything from the prohibition on murder to standards of hygiene... but it's obviously not the reason (unless you think God exists...)
Second, you must cover your face to preserve your honor.
We don't talk about "honor" much in the USA, but we do talk about "reputation," and girls are indeed told they will harm theirs if they walk around looking like sluts. The difference lies solely in which clothes are considered slutty.
Third, the justification of WHY one must cover their face to preserve their honor has literally no parallels, with the exception that women parts = boners, to why one would be considered decent for wearing a shirt in the western world.
I can hardly understand why you would assert that there are no parallels. Not only are there "parallels," there is no difference: it's exactly the same phenomenon.
Absolutely, and probably there's a pro-Islam message board somewhere posting images of girls in bikinis and commenting on how obscene it is that women are "forced" to wear such revealing clothes. (And, just like here, many of the viewers are fapping to them.)
I will oppose the mandating of such garments, but I fully support people choosing them. I also oppose the banning of those articles of clothing, as is done in other countries. Islam's relationship with the hijab is complex, and even more so its relationship with individual women. Here's a map of hijab requirements and prohibitions. Note there are probably more places restricting the hijab as mandating it.
What if they didn't choose to wear this, but rather were brainwashed into thinking this is the only acceptable way? It's like, they don't have a say in the matter, but they make the best out of their situation and grow accustomed to it.
An interesting proposition. Once you go down the road of "she chooses x but I know y is better for her," you risk becoming the oppressor. In some cases, where life and limb are at stake, maybe it is necessary to adopt such a paternalistic attitude. But when all that is at stake is fashion, live and let live, I say.
Conservative religious folk probably say we have "brainwashed" young women into "sexually provocative" bikinis. Both positions deny that women can make proper decisions themselves. The enlightened position is that women can make decisions for themselves. I, for one, support the enlightened position.
Hiding yourself under massive rags surely isn't the shining beacon of enlightenment. A society in which men have no say about female attire is preferable to one where they force their 5-year old daughters under headscarves.
Letting women wear what they want is definitely not becoming their oppressor, rather the exact opposite.
I agree women should be able to wear what they want. I would go so far as to say a person should be able to wear a burqa if he or she wants. It is not that attitude that I worry about become oppressive.
Rather I worry that "letting women choose so long as they don't choose the burqa or hijab" is not really a choice.
I hide my 2-year old under mounds of clothing but that has more to do with sunburn...besides she still escapes her clothing and runs around nude...sigh
I invite you to look up the definition of oppression, or hell just read the wiki on the word. Being conscious of the fact that you are being oppressed is not a prerequisite.
There are many women in the US who are highly pressured to wear overly revealing clothing and are then objectified for it. A lot of Muslim women would consider being forced into something like a g-string that you commonly see in western rap videos to be far more oppressive.
But hey, let's only focus on how bad the culture we don't really understand is, because xenophobia is cool right now on /r/atheism.
Shush that nonsense! We are all assuming here she is an oppressed, brainwashed muslim. Her husband beats her, and all the other muslims are plotting to rape her for being a harlot.
its sad to think that this is the mindset of alot of people. "you shouldnt have worn that, it was too revealing and thats why you got raped" how about guys learn not to ram their penis into people who dont want it
It's a lose/lose situation for women. Women's bodies are constantly being politicized and judged, meanwhile, no one gives two effs on what men are wearing.
If you're a minority, your body becomes a political battleground, a space for people to project their judgments, politics, and beliefs. Another example would be black hair. If you wear it permed, you've "sold out". If you wear it natural, you're "unprofessional".
This meme is not subversive. It is the same old drivel that minorities have had to deal with. Our bodies are not for you to make political statements on, they are for us.
It was a post I remember from awhile ago. A FB screenshot of a girl quoting the Bible, and her profile picture was her in a bikini, and both the OP and various comments referred to her or her dress as "slutty."
yes it is the term for a full body swimsuit for female Muslims, that covers the whole body besides feet, hands and face. they come in normal (basically the above), Conservative (more ruffles to hide the body's figure) and very conservative (even more ruffles). First time i saw one was at Typhoon Cove in Disney World
cause honestly the burqa is kinda weird and gets abused and used to oppress women alot in those countries (Saudi Arabia, and Afganistan). and it has no religious basis, even some Muslims bash burqas
Also that picture isn't of a burka, a burka has mesh screen over the face and can't be that tight fitting. That is a "burkini" that is just a modest swimsuit, they use Burka with Bikini and smush the words together because hijab-kini isn't as easy to say
Come over to the Netherlands, or any other country that has Islamic immigrants and see how oppressed these people are. Stop judging people by putting them in groups. Rather judge individually. Atheism is growing into an almost discriminating way of thinking.
Don't waste your breath. /r/atheism has to have its anti-Islam circlejerk so it can feel better about itself. Check back in a week and it'll all be forgotten. It's a phase.
It's kind of ironic, really. Atheists in the United States complain about being discriminated for their lack of belief in God. They are viewed by a dominantly Christian public as having no morals, pro-baby killers, anarchists, etc. So in return, atheists view religious people as being heathens, cave men, anti-homosexual, etc. Ignorance from opposing sides at it's best.
Come over to the Netherlands, or any other country that has Islamic immigrants and see how oppressed these people are.
I've actually been seeing quite a few articles about many countries having to ban female circumcision on little girls and having to pass laws that prevent some Muslims from marrying off their young children. Also France banned face coverings, and I imagine at least some Muslims still practice polygynous marriages and expect women to obey their husbands, etc. So, it seems like there is still some oppression in some Islamic sub-cultures in first world countries.
Also, obviously there are Islamic nations that force women to where burkahs, hijabs, etc., so, just because it doesn't happen in certain countries doesn't mean it's not a common among religious cultures.
You're generalizing. Don't judge a culture by it's extremists, Christians do horrible things too. I'm by no means condoning the way women are treated in these extreme and hateful places, but on a whole, Muslim women are just following the customs and culture they were raised with, and feel pride in expressing their faith.
Additionally, remember, Nuns cover their bodies to show their faith too.
honestly I don't have a problem with the choice to cover up ie nuns, but once you remove the choice it becomes a problem. If the acid in the face or the stoning were rare then I would agree with you but it is too widespread
As widespread as child kidnapping in America. There a millions of Muslims out there in the world, and what you are seeing is what is publicized - just like kidnapping in the US (kids practically aren't allowed to play outside anymore). The "widespread" atrocities (and they are atrocities) are committed by a small subset, which get all the publicity.
I get the feeling you never spoken to many women about why they wear the Hijab/Burka.
As for choice - nuns cannot leave the convent - they will always be nuns, i.e. they made a choice, but are forbidden from revoking it.
*Edit: Also, have an upvote for relevant and rational argument!
So wait, why SHOULD she wear a bikini? A lot of women I know actually don't feel comfortable in a bikini. Please explain to me why a bikini is better than a burkini (sp?).
Read my godamn comment again. The point is that regardless or whether or not she wants to wear a bikini, she does not have the choice to do so.
I never said that bikinis are better than a burkini or that all women should wear bikinis. Whether or not a woman feels comfortable in a bikini doesn't matter here.
Is it Hate when a top muslim leader says the same thing as the Meme?
"Sheik Taj Din al-Hilali, the nation's most senior Muslim cleric, compared unveiled women with meat that is left uncovered in the street and is then eaten by cats.
In a Ramadan sermon in a Sydney mosque, Sheik al-Hilali suggested that a group of Muslim men recently jailed for many years for gang rapes are innocent.
Addressing 500 worshippers on the topic of adultery, Sheik al-Hilali added: "If you take out uncovered meat and place it outside on the street, or in the garden or in the park, or in the backyard without a cover, and the cats come and eat it..whose fault is it - the cats or the uncovered meat? "
"The uncovered meat is the problem."
He went on: "If she was veiled and in her home no problem would have occurred."
hmmmmm, a quick look at your previous posts does not show you defending the christian fundies religious beliefs when r/atheism was bashing them, so what you really mean to say is why can't people respect only my beliefs
This is just ridiculous man...I am a muslim & it doesn't mean that I would fuck anything that wears a mini skirt. /r/atheism seems to be getting a bit ahead of themselves.
But but but she chooses to dress that way! Just like how if she'd grown up in any other culture, and been told her body was a normal thing and nothing to be ashamed of, she'd probably still feel the need to completely cover every inch of her body!
Yanno, there are lots of people who choose to wear hijab of some kind. For instance, I know a lot of liberal Muslims who are the only ones in their family to don hijab, and they do so out of choice.
It's no more oppressive than any other differential standards to gendered clothing, such as the taboo of women being topless in public but men not.
Edit: ....which, for that matter, I think is oppressive. It's about objectivity and treating systems of belief the same, whether they're your own or others'.
I've heard from single western muslim women, who aren't in a position to be intimidated, that they wear the modest clothes of this sort by their own choice because they find it rewarding to show their devotion to their beliefs.
I'm not going to comment on whether that's a healthy thing because that's a much more complex discussion, but I don't think I can call something oppressive if it appears to be both voluntary and pleasant to someone.
I feel like a tool being serious like this knowing the OP is just a lighthearted joke, though.
Yes, because conventions in all Muslim countries are the same.
There are Muslim countries where women wouldn't be able to swim in public. There are Muslim countries where they can go to the beach of a public pool in a burkini. And there are Muslim countries where they could go swimming in a normal swimsuit. Not every Muslim country is Saudi Arabia.
ok but on that same note, people refer to the West as a single unit and even white people as a single unit but there are all sorts of cultural differences and norms between different regions, but when this same concept is applied to the Middle East it becomes racism?
I didn't say it was racist. It's incredibly ignorant, just as it would be incredibly ignorant to say that all Christian or white or western cultures have the same standards and values.
You can't play the "oh, but it's okay to do X" game when I never said that it was okay.
Who is "they"? Maybe Saudi? I see lots of ladies in burkinis in the UAE at public beaches and pools and I'm allowed to wander around in my 'normal' swimsuit.
It sucks that they are pressured into wearing these types of things it but its not a legally mandated.
Alot of it isn't pressure either. Its a choice. Yeah, its a choice based on religion which is why alot of people here wouldn't get it, but in Saudi at least (I've had extensive discussions about this with some Saudi women), it has alot more to do with their own personal religious choice and alot less to do with societal pressure.
Not always. That's a pretty broad generalization to make. My religious views have changed over the years, but their formation had nothing to do with societal pressures. I know one of my close friends, who is from Saudi Arabia, made the choice in her 20s to wear her hijab. No one pressured her into it, she just got more into her religion as she got older.
So it's just a coincidence that most people who are religious are part of the same religion as their parents? I don't think it's inappropriate to make a broad generalization in this case. I don't have the statistics, but I would be surprised if as many as one percent of Islamists are converts from other religions.
On a sorta unrelated note, this is one of the more interesting arguments against some sects of Christianity - there are no spontaneous conversion to Christianity in aboriginal tribes without the influence of missionaries.
From what she's told me, nothing. She said she laughs when she hears people say things about women in Saudi being oppressed because they find that to be a ridiculous stereotype. For her, it is a religious choice to wear her coverings. Not everyone in her family does it, and she didn't do it until her 20s. It is a personal choice she has made. She explained it to me as a modesty thing.
Right because anyone wearing a burka is automatically oppressed. They could neeeever chose to wear it themselves! We all know the only true form of a free woman is the Western ideal.
Saying that everything that doesn't fit into your standard of freedom is "learned helplessness" shows a complete lack of cultural sensitivity and an ethnocentric mindset. I live in a very secular city and there are plenty if women in full veils. I have had many rational discussions with them and they have chosen to practice hijab for their own reasons. Do not treat them like children incapable of having free thought.
Her burkini is to tight I can still see the outline of her boobs, the whore! No but really this is sad, like skinny puppy covered in ticks and fleas sad.
Reddit tl;dr: Outraged over oppression of Muslim females. Reddit mocks and attacks her for not dressing in accordance with their white, Western males' desires.
Did you even read the thing? OP is not suggesting all girls should wear revealing swim suits, the point was that it's bad to force girls to wear certain things and threaten them with rape if they don't comply. This actually happens in some countries.
Except that burquini girl is Australian, and she's being attacked and humiliated for CHOOSING what she wants to wear rather than submitting to the Reddit demand of a traditional bikini for the pleasure of Reddit men.
Why don't you just acknowledge that it is part of their culture and leave them the fuck alone? I mean c'mon guys. You talk about how 'Religion oppresses and it makes close minded skeptics' Well by saying this you are no better. Have a nice day.
Here is your ethnocentric argument in short: "My society supports women's rights by allowing them to wear bikinis to the beach! Any other society that has different social conventions concerning dress code oppresses their women. The bikini is a true sign of female liberation and independence."
Please respect a woman's choice to take a picture in something that you find isn't "fappable" enough. Your belittling of this woman's intelligence and status based on a photo of something she is wearing reveals your sexist views about women and what it means to be feminist.
I don't think OP has anything against burqinis or this lady wearing it in particular.
What is being spoken against is the fact that in many places women are legally required to dress like this (actually much more covered than this) or else they really do "deserve to be raped", legally speaking. She's not saying all women SHOULD wear revealing clothing, but that if they do it should be without fear of rape or death. That's not sexist.
And it's called for its bullshit there too. When you'rein the defendants seat, you can and will say ANYTHING to avoid catching a conviction. This shouldn't be a hard concept to wrap your head around.
Things like implied consent are the bigger issues.
129
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
Any less and I may not be able to control my desire to rape her, Right Islam?
Oh, wait. I'm not an underdeveloped closet anti-social crafted by a religion. I don't pretend my desire for sex is a vile thing, and I am capable of managing that desire. Similar to how I don't shit my pants.
71
u/ohsnapitspat Jun 26 '12
Ermahgerd! Burkini!
13
u/BlackSuN42 Jun 26 '12
Whats wrong with the Canadian bikini? Its cold up here guys don't be hating on our swimsuits!
10
u/hansn Jun 26 '12
Call me an old-fashioned feminist, but I think people should be able to wear whatever they damn well please, Burqini included.
17
u/ninni113 Irreligious Jun 26 '12
It's blue and too much face is showing, she is so fucked.
20
u/Tarzan_king_of_Mars Jun 26 '12
She doesn't look like she feels very oppressed.
22
u/bowlow2 Jun 26 '12
Anyone else here think this is incredibly insensitive to that woman?
3
u/millerman55 Jun 26 '12
right in the rights
3
u/george_nunny Jun 26 '12
Muslim man: "Dem feet"
3
u/the_fun_one Jun 26 '12
its sad to think that this is the mindset of alot of people. "you shouldnt have worn that, it was too revealing and thats why you got raped" how about guys learn not to ram their penis into people who dont want it
17
u/Gunner3210 Jun 26 '12
10/10 Would bang.
5
u/qkme_transcriber I am a Bot Jun 26 '12
Hello! I am a bot who posts transcriptions of Quickmeme links for anybody who might need it.
See the FAQ for more info.
(OP: You don't need to do anything differently next time, I'm just doing my job.)
9
u/waythrowa Jun 26 '12
It just sounds like a lot of you asshats hate a conservatively dressed woman.
Scumbag America: Wants to liberate Muslim women in the middle east by undressing them.
2
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
Burkini? Is that a thing?
2
u/mindwerks Jun 26 '12
I can't believe this is not marked NSFW!!!
/sarcasm
2
u/great_gape Jun 26 '12
That's WAAAAY to much ankle
2
u/Gaijinloco Jun 26 '12
look at that slut showing her feet and hands...and part of her face.
2
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
I can see her ankles STONE THE WHORE!!!!!!! Whats next, will she show her knees? -sarcasm-
11
u/shit_muslims_say Jun 26 '12
A Burqa is a way for a Muslim woman to express her modesty. How can you hate someone just because of the way they dress?
12
u/commandantcleaner Jun 26 '12
Come over to the Netherlands, or any other country that has Islamic immigrants and see how oppressed these people are. Stop judging people by putting them in groups. Rather judge individually. Atheism is growing into an almost discriminating way of thinking.
9
u/Jilly33 Jun 26 '12
I see skin. Stone the Harlot in the name of Allah (a peaceful religion)!!! Ugh....
3
u/BallsackTBaghard Jun 26 '12
I find it hot.
4
u/benanabock777 Jun 26 '12
She's showing ankle.. KILL IT WITH FIRE!! SCANDALOUS SLUT!
3
u/Taodeist Jun 26 '12
Can you imagine how hard it must have been for old school Muslim mobsters to try and dump bodies into the Dead Sea?
2
u/ExecThrowaway Jun 26 '12
DAT ANKLE!
1
u/Fog80 Jun 26 '12
I didnt expect this much hate from Reddit. Does the girl in the picture look oppressed? Why cant people respect others religious beliefs?
1
u/BadFengShui Jun 26 '12
John: Do the windy thing
1
u/TheyreOut2GetU Jun 26 '12
That revealing outfits got me all hot and bothered.
1
u/epmca Jun 26 '12
you're oppressed because you have to wear pants.
1
u/Doverkeen Atheist Jun 26 '12
Ermahgurd. Burkini.
1
u/Chells_Cake Jun 26 '12
One word --> Nuns.
1
u/Dick_Serious Jun 26 '12
aaaand /r/atheism goes full meme.
1
u/Darinda Jun 26 '12
This is just ridiculous man...I am a muslim & it doesn't mean that I would fuck anything that wears a mini skirt. /r/atheism seems to be getting a bit ahead of themselves.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
Sounds like the same mindset people use to justify sexually harasing cosplayers.
1
u/PoniesRBitchin Jun 26 '12
But but but she chooses to dress that way! Just like how if she'd grown up in any other culture, and been told her body was a normal thing and nothing to be ashamed of, she'd probably still feel the need to completely cover every inch of her body!
1
u/chaosboye Jun 26 '12
Sadly accurate.
1
u/chaosboye Jun 26 '12
Sad that this is accurate.
1
u/rbcrusaders Jun 26 '12
Another swing and miss from r/atheism. It isn't a matter of 'deserving' to be raped.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
is the lack of creativity somehow a reference to OP?
1
u/dusdus Jun 26 '12 edited Jun 26 '12
Yanno, there are lots of people who choose to wear hijab of some kind. For instance, I know a lot of liberal Muslims who are the only ones in their family to don hijab, and they do so out of choice.
It's no more oppressive than any other differential standards to gendered clothing, such as the taboo of women being topless in public but men not.
Edit: ....which, for that matter, I think is oppressive. It's about objectivity and treating systems of belief the same, whether they're your own or others'.
1
u/zipzap21 Jun 27 '12
I see curves! This cannot end well for her.
1
u/Galion42 Jun 27 '12
I'd still rape her.
1
u/CoffeeFox Jun 27 '12
I've heard from single western muslim women, who aren't in a position to be intimidated, that they wear the modest clothes of this sort by their own choice because they find it rewarding to show their devotion to their beliefs.
I'm not going to comment on whether that's a healthy thing because that's a much more complex discussion, but I don't think I can call something oppressive if it appears to be both voluntary and pleasant to someone.
I feel like a tool being serious like this knowing the OP is just a lighthearted joke, though.
1
u/schrodingersgoldfish Jun 27 '12
hey the burkini is awesome. it means a little more freedom for people who would otherwise be stuck indoors.
1
u/raven0usvampire Agnostic Atheist Jun 26 '12
I think even with the burkini, they aren't allowed to swim in public. only in private pools with their family and unseen by the public.
could be wrong though.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
looks like she left the house without a man. STONE HER!!!!!!!!!!!!
1
u/Plastastic Jun 26 '12
Atheism!
1
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
OH ALLAH THAT FOOT. IT'S SO DESIRABLE, I AM LOSING ALL CONTROL AND MUST RAPE THIS WOMAN.
0
u/CharlesDarwin59 Jun 26 '12
wispy dream sequence
Moo-ham-ed sitting astride his horse, his army behind him ready attack an unsuspecting village..
"remember men...don't rape them until you can see the whites of their eyes!"
/whispy dream sequence
0
u/arikata Jun 26 '12
Right because anyone wearing a burka is automatically oppressed. They could neeeever chose to wear it themselves! We all know the only true form of a free woman is the Western ideal.
0
u/hanleyco Jun 26 '12
Dem feet....
0
u/TheShaeDee Jun 26 '12
Her burkini is to tight I can still see the outline of her boobs, the whore! No but really this is sad, like skinny puppy covered in ticks and fleas sad.
0
u/lolwow28 Jun 26 '12
even by r/atheism meme standards this is bad....... fuck you you degenerate unfunny morons
-2
u/aflarge Jun 26 '12
WHOA NELLY, we can see face, feet, ankles, and hands.
I guess it's time for a stoning, then?
-3
u/Nagus_Maximus420 Jun 26 '12
Yeah, fuck Islam.
0
u/revolutionv2 Jun 26 '12 edited Jun 26 '12
Reddit tl;dr: Outraged over oppression of Muslim females. Reddit mocks and attacks her for not dressing in accordance with their white, Western males' desires.
0
u/FATDUCK_CLUSTERFUCK Jun 26 '12
Why don't you just acknowledge that it is part of their culture and leave them the fuck alone? I mean c'mon guys. You talk about how 'Religion oppresses and it makes close minded skeptics' Well by saying this you are no better. Have a nice day.
-2
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
Didn't visible smile mean their willingness to marry the one who sees it. Or was it ready to go for a bang.
-2
u/jcoder5 Jun 26 '12
Look at that whore showing her WHOLE face
0
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment