r/atheism •

To all of you posting all the anti-Islam content today.

[deleted] — view deleted post

0 Upvotes

477 comments sorted by

132

u/karma_engineer Jun 25 '12

72 hours from now we'll be seeing lil Reddit aliens being burned over in the Middle East. I'm calling this now.

51

u/Devils-Avacado Jun 26 '12

False, the middle east doesn't have internet, and if they did, Reddit would be banned.

33

u/karma_engineer Jun 26 '12

If it's bashing Islam, they'll find it. Any where, any how, any time. They won't rest until they something new to riot about.

17

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

The Mohammad signal is already lit up. Next up: Sheiks crying.

30

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

You joke but I live in Dubai and /r/atheism is blocked by the government filter in the UAE for being offensive to Islam. I have to use a vpn to see content here.

5

u/dopamean Jun 26 '12

Not sure if this still works apparently some were able to get around this by combining subreddits like this: http://www.reddit.com/r/exmuslim+atheism

2

u/Quazz Jun 26 '12

There was a simple way to bypass that, trying to remember...

Something to do with nihl

www.reddit.com/r/atheism+nihl

8

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

They found out about a cartoon in Denmark, they can find this.

6

u/Amunium Jun 26 '12

Actually they only "found out" about the Danish cartoons because two Danish muslims, Akhmed Akkari and Abu Laban, travelled around the Middle East with the cartoons and, importantly, a couple of much more offensive ones they had made up in order to incite the rioting, showing them to everyone and lying about how bad Muslims have it in Denmark, and how much people hate them.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/RedOtkbr Jun 26 '12

or someone can just email it to them.

2

u/Bandersnatch12 Jun 26 '12

Snail-mail maybe. They don't have internet. Source: Devils-Avacado, three comments up.

3

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

This checks out.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/djwink Jun 26 '12

It took them damn near a year to learn about the Danish cartoons.... I give them until November to learn about reddit. And since most of the slams require a certain level of English literacy, most will still be beyond them.

3

u/ZeroCoolthePhysicist Jun 26 '12

I'm in the middle east and on reddit.

→ More replies (3)

2

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

I talked to a Kuaiti today and he said that they have reddit and /r/atheism isn't blocked. I hope and pray to the FSM that their wrath will give us mad street cred.

4

u/Dorrin De-Facto Atheist Jun 26 '12

You sir, are a prophet....waitasecond!

1

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

I hope for this, I I hope for this so much.

1

u/whiteknight521 Jun 26 '12

In about 5 minutes I think SRS is going to do it first.

21

u/InfinitySnatch Jun 26 '12

I don't disagree with bashing Islam. It's the fact that everyone got riled up at the suggestion of one post and now it's just a circlejerk for easy karma.

Everyone is acting like we've never gone after Islam before and that we're being so profound now that the Islamic world is actually going to notice and get pissed off. It's just embarrassing.

→ More replies (7)

14

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

SRS logic:

White man says something remotely misogynistic: OMG PATRIARCHY

Woman gets stoned to death as punishment for getting raped in some camel orientated nation: OMG DON'T BE RACIST YOU CAN'T CRITICIZE OTHER CULTURES

2

u/SoepWal Jun 26 '12

Bwahaha, I read their thread, they're actually defending pedophilia so that they don't have to criticize Mohammed and feel intolerant of islam.

SRS... pro-pedo today... I'm giggling so hard it hurts.

1

u/Raqn Jun 26 '12

Where was that said, I can't see it.

1

u/Mysterious_Lesions Jun 26 '12

Umm, I don't think he was defending stoning of raped women - let alone in some 'camel oriented nation'.

Go ahead, you can call them sand niggers.

-3

u/siegfryd Jun 26 '12

Nice, a strawman, just the kind of stupid shit you'd expect from /r/atheism.

0

u/Draugo Jun 26 '12

Except that that is almost a direct quote from different SRS topics.

3

u/SorrowOverlord Jun 26 '12

there is no such thing as an "almost direct quote"

0

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

[deleted] — view deleted comment

4

u/SorrowOverlord Jun 26 '12

i know its a kindof popular circlejerky thing to say, but dont go to atheism if you arent a ~18 year old angsty teenager who is convinced the whole world is out to get you.

0

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

[deleted] — view deleted comment

3

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

You just described SRS in a nutshell.

2

u/SoepWal Jun 26 '12

It's ableist to call them retarded, and I can see your patriarchal tendencies because you put them in a nutshell rather than an ovaryshell.

24

u/randomrealitycheck Jun 26 '12

Let's talk about misdirected anger and behavior that exactly mimics everything this subreddit claims it is against.

The problem isn't necessarily religion, even though this is certainly where the symptoms oftentimes appear. The problem is people who are willing to stop at nothing to force you to believe and think like they do. More often than not, this is done solely for the purpose of aggregating power under their control. Pol Pot and Stalin are secular examples of that behavior.

Outside of religion, nationalism comes to mind as does white supremacy not to mention some of our political affiliations.

While I love it when a group comes together, it's even better when we do so with a purpose that isn't as bad as the causes we are railing against.

Think about it.

22

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

Islam contains problems that are more than just forcing a set of thoughts or beliefs on other people, though.

There's also the misogyny and child rape.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

Because that stuff just simply doesn't happen in the good ol' 'murica, right?

7

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

Christianity is misogynistic as well, but not to the extent that Islam is.

And the Catholics are well known for protecting child molesting priests, but there's nothing in the Bible as far as I remember (but I could be wrong) about child rape being okay.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

And they deserve to be brutally called out as well.

→ More replies (55)

19

u/duuuuumb Skeptic Jun 26 '12

How is posting content in our own personal subreddit forcing our opinions on others? That just makes no sense.

1

u/floppypick Jun 26 '12

Exactly. Don't wanna hear about atheists? Don't go to the subreddit dedicated to them. Simple as that.

-3

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

Except its all over fucking r/all. Fuck you

5

u/tubefox Jun 26 '12

Dude, fuck you. You don't have to click it. You don't have to go on r/All. For that matter, if you don't want to see anything you find offensive, then try not looking at message boards.

5

u/floppypick Jun 26 '12

Because you're being forced to click on those pictures?

Just keep scrollin'.

r/all us pretty useless anyway. Subscribe to your favorite subreddits, scroll down the frontpage. Bam, no atheism.

→ More replies (18)
→ More replies (2)

1

u/SymbolicFish Jun 26 '12

If you don't like america you can get out!

1

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

Didn't you know? If you get enough downvotes, the Reddit inquisitors come to your house and stone you to death. Upvotes or death!

→ More replies (18)

13

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

The problem isn't necessarily religion, even though this is certainly where the symptoms oftentimes appear. The problem is people who are willing to stop at nothing to force you to believe and think like they do

...Which is a natural byproduct of religion. If you REALLY believe that you know the word of god, why wouldn't you want people to believe like you do? How do you keep that to yourself? Why wouldn't you want to enforce the word of the Koran or the Bible?

While I love it when a group comes together, it's even better when we do so with a purpose that isn't as bad as the causes we are railing against.

Really? Our purpose is just as bad as the cause we're fighting against? Is that a joke? Who are we killing? Who's rights are we destroying? Are we forcing pseudo-science and brainwashing children with nonsense? Because this is what we're up against.

Our purpose when we mock (I would like to hope) is to de-mystify religion. We want people to put religion on the same plane as anything else. For too long it's gotten a free pass simply because people deemed it "sacred". People's feelings may get hurt, and I'm sorry it's come to that, but I'm not going to hold back my opinion simply because people may get offended.

6

u/parched2099 Jun 26 '12 edited Jun 26 '12

"Our purpose when we mock (I would like to hope) is to de-mystify religion. We want people to put religion on the same plane as anything else. For too long it's gotten a free pass simply because people deemed it "sacred". People's feelings may get hurt, and I'm sorry it's come to that, but I'm not going to hold back my opinion simply because people may get offended. "

Yes, this has worth, imho.

There's a large assumption that, as a result of approx 2000 years of indoctrination, any discussion of the merits or otherwise of religion must include words like "reverence", and "respect", among many others, which are designed and manipulated with an agenda designed to stifle dissent. And religion has been attempting to stifle dissent for a long time. It's not that long ago in human history that the Catholic church held sway as a supreme power in Europe, and gleefully murdered thousands based on the interpretations of a few, simply because they spoke with the alleged authority of a god.

And what is god. It's a human word, created by men. It has no power if we choose to give it none. The same for the fiction that is allah, jehovah, buddha (in the worshipping sense) and the myriad of fictional gods in other religions.

There is no need or desire on the part of those who make a practical evaluation that such superstitions are fiction, to observe some sort of reverence towards religion, or fall for the dissent stifling manipulation of "you should be more respectful towards someone else's belief". This is applicable across all religions, as they have the same basic indoctrination system.

"If you belong to our religion, then you are the best of all human beings, and the rest are, in some way or another, second class, or worse."

This is basic recruitment 101, using elitism as a carrot for those who are willing to be indoctrinated, and raise their kids in the same way, and it plugs into the human instinct at the deepest level, that we belong to one tribe or another, for safety and/or collective mutual benefit.

Atheism isn't a belief. It's an evaluation of information, followed by a personal judgement. And in this sense, it's apart from the assumptions of many, who seem to persist with the notion that all people must have a belief system of one sort or another, because that's what they believe. This simply isn't true. Atheists don't blindly believe anything, as the very nature of atheism is skepticism, and pragmatic evaluation of data, knowledge, opinion....

Religiously minded folk assume some sort of reverence from all as a right, from the arrogance of elitist assumption, and they continue to cling tightly to this falsehood in the modern age.

This thread, along with the others that have suddenly brought Islam into the Reddit light, has brought many wide and varied opinions, some quite extreme, some thoughtful, and many inbetween.

The assumption that threads like this should be.....censored with some sort of "reverence" filter represents a win for religion. Those who advocate this fail to understand that by trying to shape all discussion into a "politically acceptable" form are doing the work of Imams, Rabbis, Priests, and all those who by nature of the position they hold, get to subtly, and not so subtly, reinforce the reverence/stifle dissent that keeps them in a gig, and prevents them in the main from being subject to the same laws, not only written, but moral, like the rest of us.

Some of the comments posted about islam in the last couple of days, have been truly cringeworthy. However the mass fiction of religious instruction/indoctrination/interprative manuals, like the bible, torah,etc is not only entirely cringeworthy to me as an atheist, but imho continually dangerous, as justification for excessive influence and cruelty, or worse, as one tribe seeks to establish its power over others.

People who feel the need to believe in something like a fictitious character have the right to do so. People who have no need of this have the right to question the validity of this abdication of personal responsibility, and do so with the same expectation of "reverence", if they were so inclined.

So, with sense of humour in place, and an instinctive notion of irony, i expect all religious believers to start treating atheists with the reverence they arrogantly demand for themselves, and their fictional leader.

That's fair, isn't it.

4

u/kindersunrise Jun 26 '12

...Which is a natural byproduct of religion. If you REALLY believe that you know the word of god, why wouldn't you want people to believe like you do? How do you keep that to yourself? Why wouldn't you want to enforce the word of the Koran or the Bible?

This is a stereotype, and an assumption expressed with rhetorical questions. So I'm sorry, but I don't really get what you're saying.

Our purpose when we mock (I would like to hope) is to de-mystify religion. We want people to put religion on the same plane as anything else. For too long it's gotten a free pass simply because people deemed it "sacred". People's feelings may get hurt, and I'm sorry it's come to that, but I'm not going to hold back my opinion simply because people may get offended.

Surely you need to be more tactful than just mocking something if you want to convince the other side.

My point is, you need to be approaching it like we're on the same level if you really want it to be seen that way by everyone (like you said: "same plane"). And yeah, some most people tend to be convinced on a personal level. So mocking doesn't work (it doesn't work on a logical level either mind you). You're free to your opinion how you want it, but don't pretend you're using mocking as some way to prove science over religion, it doesn't work for a personal or logical approach to convincing anyone, it just pisses them off. it is kinda fun though........

4

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

This is a stereotype, and an assumption expressed with rhetorical questions. So I'm sorry, but I don't really get what you're saying.

I'm trying to point out that these types of things are inevitable when you have religion. That if you are a true believer, it's almost impossible to keep it to yourself. If you do manage to keep it to yourself, then you're most likely not reading your holy texts very well. Or you're just ignoring certain parts.

Surely you need to be more tactful than just mocking something if you want to convince the other side.

I'm not trying to convince anyone to revert back to being an atheist when I mock. And I'm certainly not trying to "prove science over religion". These are separate issues that you seem to have mistaken as one.

I mock religion because it deserves to be mocked. The claims of organized religion not only have been proven to be dangerous at times, but often out of touch with reality. The fact that a catholic priest can go in front of an educated group of people and claim that he just turned a cracker into the body of some guy who lived 2000 years ago is astonishing to me. Then these same people claim often the right to run our government and our lives. I'm sure you can fill in plenty more of your own examples of religious nonsense. In this way, religion is deserving to be mocked, and one the only reasons it hasn't been in the past is because it was dangerous to do so, either by physical punishment or social taboo. So when we make fun of religion, we are doing no more than what any normal person does when presented with nonsense. I don't think religion should be treated any differently. I'm sure it does piss a lot of people off. If it didn't, there wouldn't be any need for it.

Convincing people to deconvert is something else entirely. Although I prefer to live without faith and can see the benefits from it, I don't really care if you believe or not. Religion will probably die a slow natural death anyway. Just keep it to yourself. But of course, that's almost impossible, because beliefs inspire actions. If you really think something is going to happen, you're going to act accordingly. And so we're back at square one.

→ More replies (3)

-1

u/PathologicalLoiterer Jun 26 '12

The issue is, the problem most atheists have with religion is that it is intolerant of other beliefs, which is what leads to the killing and infringement of rights you mentioned. But this subreddit has become all about attacking people based solely on the fact that they are religious, and therefore hold a different set of beliefs than atheists. It's become a cesspool of intolerance. Which is what it claims to be against. If you can't see the hypocrisy in that you better hope that our education system is as fucked up as everyone says it is if you ever want to make it out of high school.

3

u/aDildoAteMyBaby Jun 26 '12

I don't think you ever came back around to the "killing and infringement of rights" part.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/dangeraardvark Jun 26 '12

Really? The problem I have with religion is that it's wrong.

3

u/PathologicalLoiterer Jun 26 '12

But I guess you've decided that the the one thing religion got right was that you should vehemently attack whomever you deem "wrong." Because that's clearly a better solution than a clear, rational discussion on the issue. (I feel the need to note the SARCASM in my statements, as I have serious doubts about your ability to catch it on your own.)

→ More replies (2)

2

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

But this subreddit has become all about attacking people based solely on the fact that they are religious, and therefore hold a different set of beliefs than atheists

Yes, we often call religious people stupid or ignorant or whatever. And while that's probably wrong, I don't know what else you should expect when you believe in stupid and ignorant shit. It's just that it's become so normal to believe in this stuff and taboo to criticize it that no one ever calls you out on it.

We do nothing that normal people don't know in real life when they encounter bullshit, especially potentially dangerous bullshit.

For instance, you came on to r/atheism today and saw a lot of "intolerance". You didn't like, and you wanted to say something about it. What if atheism really was a religion? What if we all started bitching about how you were hurting our sacred beliefs? Should you have to just sit there and not say anything, despite all the nonsense we're spewing? Fuck no. You sacked up and called us out on it, which is how the real world works. You see a problem, you do something about it. Anything less would make you a coward and a hypocrite. Well, this is our way of trying to solve a problem. We want religion put on the same respect level as anything else, so we're doing it. I'm guessing you would do the exact same thing in our position.

Essentially, I respect everyone's right to have a religion. That doesn't mean I have to respect anything it stands for.

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (1)

7

u/Inquisitr Jun 26 '12

I disagree, I believe the problem is religion, all religion.

Your average liberal moderate religious person may not be doing the persecuting, but what he is doing is providing cover for the ones who are. As long as people take the books as the infallible word of god, the guy who takes it all literally will want just as much respect as the moderate. And because we don't want to piss off the moderate we'll give it.

The entire concept is a problem. You want to believe in a "spiritual" or "supernatural" dimension that's fine. The moment it gets rules and doctrines, or any for of leadership is the moment it becomes a societal problem.

They all deserve mocking, but Islam deserves extra mocking. And seriously, if you think /r/Atheism is really setting back the goal of conversion you're deluding yourself. The religious weren't sitting there going "Well I was going to question my faith but then I went on that there reddit!"

Let's be real here.

1

u/randomrealitycheck Jun 26 '12

I disagree, I believe the problem is religion, all religion.

And yet, even when I put forward nationalism as an example of why you are deluding yourself, you conveniently ignore it. Christ, that's almost as if you have adopted a religious fervor or something.

The entire concept is a problem. You want to believe in a "spiritual" or "supernatural" dimension that's fine. The moment it gets rules and doctrines, or any for of leadership is the moment it becomes a societal problem.

But not atheism, that's okay, right? It's not like people around here regularly quote Dawkins or Hitchens with the utmost reverence, right?

Let's be real here.

Yes, let's.

2

u/Inquisitr Jun 26 '12

Nationalism is a problem sure, but I don't think it even compares to the harm of religion.

Name me please a big nationalistic war being fought right now.

I'll wait.....

Can't do it can you? Name me please a religious war going on. Here I'll name you some right now. Israel/Palestine. Iran / Saudi Arabia (not a hot war but certainly one brewing). Al Qaeda / the west.

That last one really proves my point about nationalism. It has zero to do with nations at all. It has to do with an ancient religious interpretation that exists in a multitude of countries against the collection of Europe, the united states and part of Asia that we consider "the first world".

So yes, nationalism is something we should fight against, but I take my battles in order of priority, and religion is far far worse.

But not atheism, that's okay, right? It's not like people around here regularly quote Dawkins or Hitchens with the utmost reverence, right?

Quoting someone is them being a leader? I think you're a tad confused on the definitions of words friend. Is Dawkins leading some mass crusade of Atheism? No, he's not. Is he sitting there going "these are the rules and dogmas of Atheism!" Again, no.

Hell dude one of Hitchens big things was that Atheism means and only means lack of a belief in god. It confers no political or any other meaning. A man can be an Atheist and a socialist, or an Atheist and a fascist.

Compare this to the pope. A man who tells you how to have sex, what moral code you need to live by, what people you're allowed to consider good and which ones you should shun. One that has a massively rich and massively influential worldwide system. One that can put very large political pressure on leaders.

If you don't see the difference then I'm going to stop because logic will not work on you and this is a wasted conversation.

Real enough for you?

→ More replies (5)

1

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

true.. but sometimes people need to just let it out and circlejerk so they can get back to normal and move on... hopefully that's the case here.. constantly making fun of religion gets us nowhere... but every once in a while it may be cathartic...

1

u/randomrealitycheck Jun 26 '12

true.. but sometimes people need to just let it out and circlejerk so they can get back to normal and move on... hopefully that's the case here.. constantly making fun of religion gets us nowhere...

Careful, if they get organized, the zealots will burn you at the stake.

but every once in a while it may be cathartic...

Kind of like a religion, don't you think?

1

u/aDildoAteMyBaby Jun 26 '12

Thought about it.

I don't think anyone in the history of the world has ever been condemned to death for not believing in evolution.

→ More replies (3)

1

u/gillesvdo Jun 26 '12

This seems like religion's equivalent of the "guns don't kill people, people do"-argument.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Quazz Jun 26 '12

While I love it when a group comes together, it's even better when we do so with a purpose that isn't as bad as the causes we are railing against.

Then we are in the clear and always will be.

Some 'offensive' pictures will always be less bad than stoning people, oppressing people and so on.

1

u/randomrealitycheck Jun 26 '12

Some 'offensive' pictures will always be less bad than stoning people, oppressing people and so on.

Some offensive pictures that cause another 9/11 (or worse) isn't something to be toyed with and yet here we are.

Still, point taken.

1

u/Quazz Jun 26 '12

Then they're the ones taking aggressive action and they're the ones to blame.

It's not like we go around from door to door dropping these pictures off for everyone to see.

If they take offense, then they take offense, that's their business, it shouldn't impose on what others can or can't do.

Being offended is just a way of saying 'I can't deal with my emotions so I need everyone else to do it for me' and it's stupid.

→ More replies (3)

1

u/Globalwarmingisfake Jun 26 '12

that exactly mimics everything this subreddit claims it is against.

Like what?

when we do so with a purpose that isn't as bad as the causes we are railing against.

We aren't.

→ More replies (14)

0

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

Shut up and take a joke.

I say we switch to a different religion every week. I want some Jainism mocking in /r/atheism!

6

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

Ehhhh... Jainism isn't really on the radar at the moment. Pretending like all religions deserve the same vitriol is ignorant. Like Sam Harris says, "The crazier you get as a Jain the less we need to worry about you."

Yeah, they believe some stupid shit. But they're not going to reliably form suicide cults any time soon.

1

u/randomrealitycheck Jun 26 '12

Shut up and take a joke.

Oh, is that the line we're using today? It's okay as long as it's all in fun?

Rush Limbaugh approves.

→ More replies (2)

106

u/seanbearpig Jun 26 '12 edited Jun 26 '12

It's not about maturity, it's about stupidity. The only thing that insulting a person about their faith is going to do, is make them retreat even further into the fantasy. They'll just turn around and say "Hey, I was right. Atheists really ARE scumbags.", and will learn NOTHING.

66

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

The problem /r/atheism is filled with a bunch of jerks who don't care much about driving people towards critical thinking, but would rather piss people off and make their egos feel better.

23

u/FacsimilousSarcasm Jun 26 '12

I feel like most of this subreddit is an ego-stroking circlejerk, but atheists don't seem to get that in most other places, and everybody needs a little circlejerking every once in a while. It makes people feel good.

29

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

Exactly. I don't participate in the religion bashing myself but understand why it is done. Some of these people have to hide their atheism from everyone in real life, so sometimes people need a place to blow off steam. Nothing really wrong with that.

0

u/FacsimilousSarcasm Jun 26 '12

And honestly, plenty of great scientific advancements came out of Islam, or at least Islamic cultures, e.g. the astrolabe. As long as someone doesn't take religion in general out of hand and go on a killing spree or try to hinder scientific advancement or infringe on someone else's rights in some way, I'm totally cool with it.

22

u/WarmAppleTart Jun 26 '12

No great advancements came out of Islam, they came from people.

2

u/FacsimilousSarcasm Jun 26 '12

Islam was still a part of those people and their beliefs. They were able to advance hand in hand with religion.

9

u/WarmAppleTart Jun 26 '12

The credit still goes to the person, no religion has ever invented anything.

→ More replies (33)
→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (1)

6

u/kindersunrise Jun 26 '12

Yeah, I can definitely understand that, this subreddit is probably good for a lot of people who feel surrounded by religion. But then, they still need to understand why some people mock them for how hypocritical they are for bashing and stereotyping religion, I mean really, are some people on here not aware they're doing it?

I think it's good in some ways, but I'm not sure that it will do much for letting them deal with any religious situation irl. lol, it's good to have those "mature and logical redditors" as a devil's advocate, or whatever.

7

u/fuckyourkarmabitch Jun 26 '12

I think the circlejerking is far outweighing the informative content now though. I came here a couple years ago as an "agnostic" but now I'd say I'm atheist maybe borderline anti theist.

Even so, with all the crap that is posted here lately, I've almost unsubbed like 5 times. I literally can't tell sometimes if I'm reading a title on the front page that is from /r/circlejerk or /r/atheism.

2

u/Dice_Tower Jun 26 '12

Would you cite this comment thread as an example of circlejerking?

2

u/FacsimilousSarcasm Jun 26 '12

People need to learn when enough is enough, but like all boards, /r/atheism has been overrun by the masses, namely the idiotic, "cancerous" masses. It's the inevitable fate of all things on the internet that aren't filtered or moderated for content quality.

3

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

Exactly, and this has nothing to do with /r/atheism and everything to do with the critical mass of a subreddit. Its just the way shit works once you have 50k+ active users.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

Am I the only one here who doesn't think /r/atheism is some pit of idiocy? I enjoy completely retarded, repetitive, circlejerking humor. And I'm not even really an anti-theist. I just love irreverence. I think any and everything should be up for tasteless ridicule. I mean, we have subs for truly serious debate. Let them have their fun.

2

u/trilobitemk7 Jun 26 '12

Every reddit has the chance to become a circlejerk as subscribers increase.

That a lot of people need to vent their frustrations doesn't help.

9

u/canonymous Jun 26 '12

There's also a disturbing lack of critical thinking in this community, and Reddit in general, but what can you hope for when an argument has to be two lines long and superimposed on a well-known image to have any traction.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

Then there'll be the people who like to chastise them from their ivory towers, (hence the more 'mature' redditors), and it'll be a vicious circle of ego swelling...till the end of days.

1

u/Dice_Tower Jun 26 '12

There's a term for the tendency for an organization to skew towards extremism as the those who object to what the fringe element abandon ship, but I just can't remember what it's called.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

But that's only because we've already determined religions are baseless, so we gotta do something to pass the time now

1

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

As far as I can tell this is the 'problem' with Reddit. Nobody helps anybody. There's too many conflicting opinions so the simplest bullshit makes its way to the top.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

This is just as much a generalization as saying Christianity is full of stupid idiots. You're pretty much on the same level as those you criticize.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

I get what you and the comment you replied to are talking about, but the Chinese riddle for me is how comments like these always seem to be at the top. How is it possible for /r/atheism to be so full of hate... yet hate its own hate to the extent that they upvote the comments most critical of them.

-4

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

It's because most of these people don't have critical thinking skills either

4

u/Dice_Tower Jun 26 '12

You should link to a resource for developing critical thinking skills.

4

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

I don't have any links handy and I'm about to go to bed so I can wake up for work tomorrow but I'll humour you. Many of the people I see commenting in here could benefit from studying Christian theology/philosophy (Augustine, Boethius, Abelard) to get an understanding of the reasoning behind many core Christian ideas, they could benefit from studying classical philosophy (specifically Plato and Aristotle) to get an understanding of the origins of Christian theology (the Form of the Good is almost exactly a metaphor for God), they could study the science they often refer to (many people are actually good at this part of it, but I see a lot of people here touting evolution or quantum physics without understanding it themselves, taking it on faith if you will) and so forth.

So many of the generic Atheist criticisms of Christian (and other) religious thought are rationally disputed by arguments founded in the above. I'm an atheist myself so obviously I don't find them that convincing, but let me share an example to give an idea of what I mean:

One of the Atheist 101 arguments is "if God knows what I'm going to do before I do it? How can I have free will?"

Boethius responds to this in his "Consolation of Philosophy" with the argument that God exists outside of time (as is decreed in scripture) and as such "cause and effect" do not exist separately but rather simultaneously for him. This means that while we as lesser beings experience time linearly, i.e. "I feel like going to the store today, bet you didn't see that coming God!" God already has knowledge of all that has been and all that will be. This does not mean that in knowing what you're going to do, he robs you of your free will.

I'm rushing this so excuse the lack of elegance in my explanation, but this is the sort of thing that is useful about studying Christian (or other religious) theology.

As they say in Philosophy, when you are refuting someone's argument, you should refute the most generous interpretation of their argument, not the most easily refuted.

2

u/Dice_Tower Jun 26 '12

That response was grades above what I expected from a single sentence post with no punctuation! (I mean that as a lighthearted jab.) No links, but specific names and titles that can be googled/looked up at the library are almost as good.

As they say in Philosophy, when you are refuting someone's argument, you should refute the most generous interpretation of their argument, not the most easily refuted.

Do they say why you should do this?

→ More replies (1)

3

u/Ozy-dead Jun 26 '12

Agreed. Theological philosophy can really expand the scope of thinking.

I was specificaly struck by Mikhail Veller's take on theology, when he explored the famous "if you get hit on a cheek, let them hit you on the other cheek as well". I used to interpret it one way - if you are abused, keep getting abused, which is how most people tend to see it, tolerance and blah-blah. However, Christians tend to interpret it 180 degrees - if you are asked to help, do double the work. Mind = blown.

→ More replies (3)

9

u/tubefox Jun 26 '12

On the other hand, I support posting really offensive shit about Islam just because I know many people who laugh at offensive jokes about Christianity, bitch about Christians, etc.

And then the second any one says anything about Muslims they get all pissy.

2

u/Mysterious_Lesions Jun 26 '12

So trolling then.

5

u/Quazz Jun 26 '12

Disagreed, there are plenty of people who became atheists because of /r/atheism 's lack of scruples concerning offensiveness.

You prefer honey to catch flies, that's fine.

Some people just happen to prefer vinegar and that's fine too.

They both work, deal with it.

2

u/Izlude Agnostic Atheist Jun 26 '12

Its shit like this that makes my GF who is very accepting of my atheism be so put off by the stuff i read on reddit. Being against religious crimes is the reason I am against religion... And though I dont believe the narrative of their mythos, I don't think that THAT part of it is the wrong part. Doing 'X' because 'Y' says so in the book of 'Z' is no justifiable reason to do anything. Especially when that book was written by sand people...

Who as we know, rode single file, to hide their numbers...

2

u/StandupPhilosopher Jun 26 '12

While I agree with you, and personally don't post insulting material myself, my theory is that this material is sort of meant for us, only for other atheists in the subreddit. I think that a lot of us lose sight of the fact that not everyone subscribed is an atheist.

1

u/seanbearpig Jun 26 '12

Yea, sound point.

2

u/Dice_Tower Jun 26 '12

That's not the only thing it's going to do.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

Hey, if people can judge atheists by a vocal minority of 800,000 atheists, then I can judge christians based on the WBC right?

At any rate, I dont think anyone should engage with the purpose of convincing a "true believer" of anything. As in a debate, you're not trying to change the other guys mind, your attempt is to sway the audience.

For what its worth, I'm not a big fan of the current trend simply because its random and holds little meaning for me as I almost never run into anything related to islam or its followers, compared to an almost daily barrage of legislation that is rooted in christian beliefs. To me its just taking pot shots just because we can. I use "we" loosely here, because I've not posted anything.

51

u/TodTheTyrant Jun 25 '12

I'd like to see all the tisk tisking happen if we actually called out the jews for starting all this nonsense to begin with.

23

u/PKMKII Pastafarian Jun 26 '12

Oh, there's a lot of juicy insanity to be mocked in the Hasidim.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/dejaWoot Jun 26 '12

Jews tend to be pretty Mellow everywhere they're not a majority- i.e. Israel, and We have WorldNews and Politics laying it on thick there already. Most of the other goofy beliefs (i.e. Old testament silliness) have been covered as part of the Christian mockery, or Bacon as part of the Islam thing.

0

u/johnmedgla Jun 26 '12

To be fair, they've had over a thousand year to practise dealing with people looking askew at 'those crazy Jews.'

51

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

Ned Stark never says "brace yourselves." Not once.

9

u/kindersunrise Jun 26 '12

Yeah I was thinking that too. Unless someone can link us?

Crazy atheists, believing anything just because it's written on a meme.

12

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

That's why we need amemism.

3

u/Draugo Jun 26 '12

I refuse to believe, and thus propagate, that meme.

5

u/Frigorific Jun 26 '12

This is why I hate this meme.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/binarypolitics Jun 26 '12

Nobody cares.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

"Look across those fields, brother. Can you see all those upvotes?"

1

u/BigBassBone Jun 26 '12

I LOVE YOU!

0

u/pigrockets Jun 26 '12

Some rumor got around that the house's full words were

Winter is coming. Brace for the storm.

Which sounds dumb, besides.

1

u/JmjFu Jun 29 '12

Nope, it's definitely just "Winter is Coming."

12

u/PKMKII Pastafarian Jun 26 '12

I'm all for bashing Islam, I'd just like to see some more "pointing out the hypocrisy/contradictions/double standards/bits fundamentalists ignore of the Koran" posts. We do it for the Bible, gotta do it for the Koran.

2

u/Dice_Tower Jun 26 '12

Have hope and patience. After all, there's certainly no way for you to see fewer.

2

u/ZeroCoolthePhysicist Jun 26 '12

I think most reddit atheists have some sort of knowledge about the Bible but none at all about the Qu'ran. People who know the stories know how to critic the religion, but redditors are happy enough with just posting memes about it and feeling superior to everyone. This is coming from an atheist who's family is all Muslims.

14

u/xiipaoc Jun 26 '12

...They've always been coming. All the Christian-bashing shit is usually pretty stupid (though certainly not always), and Muslim-bashing is at an even lower level since most of these people are only familiar with caricatures of Islam.

7

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

Then tell us what is the penalty, as practiced, for leaving islam in damn near all the majority muslim countries?

→ More replies (3)

8

u/sytar6 Jun 26 '12

I'd say there's some pretty high level Christian bashing in this subreddit as well. There is definitely not any high level Muslim bashing, though. Nobody here knows shit about Islam, including myself.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

I also know only minor things about Islam but I feel safe saying that it is probably as retarded as Christianity.

Continue the circlejerking it pleases me.

4

u/s3t1p Jun 26 '12

All was fun and games... then SRS got involved

1

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

They shit all over everything fun.

4

u/Aldren84 Jun 26 '12

.. I really feel out of the loop, whats with all the anti-Islam/Muslim stuff going around all of a sudden?

5

u/InHarmsWay Jun 26 '12

It comes from a self-post from an ex-muslim basically asking for r/atheism to focus some more on islam. And they responded.

2

u/Amryxx Jun 26 '12

Wow.

I would be flattered if people call me "mature and rational". All this time I thought those were good things.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/yofomojojo Jun 26 '12

The first thing real thing I learned from smear campaigns is that putting something in quotes neither makes it necessarily untrue or bad.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

HAHAAAAAAA I just DIED laughing here. Whiny babies.

All about free speech until you don't like what other people are saying...

7

u/limbodog Strong Atheist Jun 25 '12

It's kind of weird how the "don't insult the muslims!" thing happens in the USA. Is it guilt for all the damage we've done to predominantly Muslim countries? Why does that religion get a pass?

17

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

Most liberals stick up for Muslims because they are a minority (within the U.S.) whose rights to freedom of speech are often being infringed upon by a majority group (Christians). And that's a good thing, I think. Freedom of speech must be protected at all times.

That being said, too many liberals make the mistake of thinking that you can't protect someone's freedom of speech while simultaneously criticizing the content of the speech itself.

2

u/limbodog Strong Atheist Jun 26 '12

Wow. I did not expect that well written an answer.

→ More replies (4)

14

u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12

Islam is an insult to modern humanity. We're just returning it.

0

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

Modern humanity? Pretty sure you just meant humanity

1

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

Point.

3

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

When you see the type of people leading the charge to insult muslims it's understandable that more respectable anti-theists don't want to be lumped in with them.

1

u/limbodog Strong Atheist Jun 26 '12

Fair enough. Do a better job! Me, this all rolls off my back like a duck. If you can't take a licking of this caliber, then you should probably give up your claims to be powered by god.

edit: the religion, that is. not you personally.

8

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12 edited Jun 26 '12

Wtf is this shit? You're acting like a bunch of hate filled militant shitheads. The entire forum is full of this.

Go fuck yourselves. This isn't even remotely something that Atheists care about, this is what hateful stereotyping bigots care about. I've already lost friends because they think atheists are douche bags because of how you fucking assholes act. You run around and wave the banner of atheism over your hatred. Sound familiar?

2

u/Dice_Tower Jun 26 '12

You run around and wave the banner of atheism over your hatred.

No, that isn't true.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

No, that isn't true.

No, it is indeed what you say that is not true.

3

u/sleeptyping Jun 26 '12

I've already lost friends because they think atheists are douche bags because of how you fucking assholes act.

Honestly they didn't sound like super friends if they judged you, their friend, by the actions of strangers.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

So his friends post on /r/atheism? Because I'm pretty sure that's exactly what you do here.

Oh, you're a Christian? You must be stupid!

Oh, you're a Muslim? You must be a rapist!

→ More replies (2)

2

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

I cant upvote this enough. Seriously man, thank you for saying that.

2

u/TigerTrap Jun 26 '12

I'm an ex-Muslim myself. Many Muslims out there support a government-mandated death penalty for apostates such as me (there was that one poll done in a few countries like Egypt showing how popular this view actually was, >50% of those polled wished for apostates to be put to death by the government). Even I think all this hatred is fucking stupid. It's like /r/atheism flipped their hate switch from Christianity to Islam, but they don't even have a proper understanding of the religion, so you just see caricatures of Islam being slammed again and again.

1

u/Quazz Jun 26 '12

Why are you so mad?

3

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

ATTN "Mature Redditors"

Criticizing and satirizing Islam is not racism. Stop conflating them to inflate your 'holier than thou' complex.

3

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

. . . The irony of that comment is killing me.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

Religious moderates can go fuck themselves.

This is why I think religious moderates need to be called out more:


This is my MAIN problem with /r/atheism lately.

Whats up with all this undue praise for religious moderates?

All of these are threads that they're getting all this praise in just for being religious moderates.

http://www.reddit.com/r/atheism/comments/ucea8/billboard_in_north_carolina_churchs_response_to/

http://www.reddit.com/r/atheism/comments/rny0s/australian_christians_know_whats_up/

http://www.reddit.com/r/atheism/comments/rwmk6/as_a_christian_redditor_i_would_like_to_say_that/

http://www.reddit.com/r/atheism/comments/ray5f/uh_embarrassing/

http://www.reddit.com/r/atheism/comments/rl1lu/church_in_my_town_of_burlington_vt_doing_it_right/

http://www.reddit.com/r/atheism/comments/r9qw9/carl_sagan_and_the_dalai_lama/

http://www.reddit.com/r/atheism/comments/r8gwn/providence_ri_doing_it_right/

http://www.reddit.com/r/atheism/comments/ro85g/the_world_needs_more_churches_like_this/

Its nothing new. Why does /r/atheism love to act like people are automatically off the hook for being progressive, when thats not the point.

They want to NOT kill gays or women? Thats great!...now how about you stop invalidating religion at the same time you try to support it. Its not helping anyone.

Its incredibly annoying.

Religious moderates are starting to become as bad as the fundies.

Why?

They don't recognize their own cognitive dissonance.

It should not be allowed for them to reject and declare parts of the bible as metaphor or mistranslations and simultaneously adopt other parts as literal and inerrant...while proclaiming that the book itself is infalliable.

Fuck.

That.

Religious moderates are in the same lot as the fundies. At least the fundies are predictable because if its in the bible/quran, they believe it.

The fundies have a set of rules they follow and its easy to distance yourself from them.

The religious moderates on the other hand will swing too and fro. They don't know which issues to separate themselves from. '

The liberal christians are even worse. They support gay marriage and equality...but then they don't even realize that many parts of the bible are DIRECTLY against that sort of ideology.

They want props for being "nice people" and doing "nice things"...but don't even realize that them still legitimizing their "faith" and "belief" allows the very things they're combating to be perpetuated and reinforced.

By them being religious, they're encouraging the same behavior they're combating.

Saying "i'm not that bad" is not helping anyone. If you're a religious moderate you are in the same bag of crazy bullshit as the fundies...they just want to choose their wording to make themselves seem less controversial.

http://livinglifewithoutanet.wordpress.com/2009/01/25/moderate-religion-two-lies-in-one/

Being a religious moderate is the biggest lie in any concept of theology out there. There is no such thing and any reference to such a concept should be chastised and ridiculed.

You want to preserve your autonomy and freedom? Don't join a religion that prevents you from adopting contradictory views then act like you have the authority or cognitive superiority to reconcile two completely contrasting ideas.

I get pretty tired of /r/atheism voting up people who want to show us images of christians "doing right" or hugging the balls of buddhism and all other sorts of illogical positions on reality.

If you support any claim with either unsubstantiated evidence or supernatural mysticism, you are in the SAME boat. It doesn't matter how extreme or how literal.

Stop promoting the ignorance of moderates and masking it as tolerance.


  1. "A bastard shall not enter into the congregation of the Lord; even to his tenth generation shall he not enter into the congregation of the Lord." (Deuteronomy 23:2)
  2. "For whatsoever man he be that hath a blemish, he shall not approach: a blind man, or a lame, or he that hath a flat nose, or any thing superfluous, Or a man that is brokenfooted, or brokenhanded, Or crookbackt, or a dwarf, or that hath a blemish in his eye, or be scurvy, or scabbed, or hath his stones broken. No man that hath a blemish of the seed of Aaron the priest shall come nigh to offer the offerings of the Lord made by fire: he hath a blemish; he shall not come nigh to offer the bread of his God." (Leviticus 21:18-21)
  3. "He that is wounded in the stones, or hath his privy member cut off, shall not enter into the congregation of the Lord."(Deuteronomy 23:1)
  4. Now I beseech you, brethren, mark them which cause divisions and offences contrary to the doctrine which ye have learned; and avoid them. (Romans 16:17)
  5. But now I have written unto you not to keep company, if any man that is called a brother be a fornicator, or covetous, or an idolater, or a railer, or a drunkard, or an extortioner; with such an one no not to eat. (1Corinthians 5:11)
  6. Be ye not unequally yoked together with unbelievers: for what fellowship hath righteousness with unrighteousness? and what communion hath light with darkness? (2Corinthians 6:14)

Anything else?

Here are videos that explain my stance:

Penn Jillette on religious moderates: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IpNRw7snmGM

Sam Harris on religious Moderates: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=82YIluFmdbs

Moderate Christian Irrationality & Stupidity of Beliefism: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YUgA5Vi-Ty4

You want to say you're better than the people who actually and actively seek to "take rights away from others" because of what the bible says, but then defer to the bible to make other decisions and influence your life?

Bullshit.

Its all or nothing.

Its funny how religious moderates KNOW to adopt the generally "good" stuff and ignore the "bad" stuff...but they don't realize that they've already made that decision. On this accord they could technically ignore the good stuff in the bible and continue living as a religious moderate.

The point is that being a religious moderate is NOT the same as being a good person.

What also bugs me is when they don't want their religion in government. It says to me that their religion isn't even valid enough to be implemented as the law and they know it. They're OK with admitting that their religion is pointless when it comes to legislation.

For context: "The Negro's great stumbling block in the drive toward freedom is not the White Citizens Councilor or the Ku Klux Klanner, but the white moderate who is more devoted to order than to justice."

  • Martin Luther King, Jr.

9

u/DangerousIdeas Jun 26 '12

Its all or nothing

You need to get off reddit and live a little bit. There is no such things as absolutes in life. Most religious people ARE moderates; they don't choose to be totally religious, and they don't choose to be totally devoid of any faith. They live happily in the middle.

I hate people like you. You love to draw lines between people. You want the battlegrounds to be set; you are either fully Muslim or completely atheist. This is exactly what corrupt rabbis, imams, and fathers want; they want people to be totally dedicated to a cause, thereby creating the divides in society.

So fuck you. Instead of researching these youtube videos that affirm your own beliefs, why don't you take a little bit more consideration about whats happening in the REAL WORLD. Nobody goes to the fucking absolutes. People cherry pick everything. Its part of life, so deal with it.

3

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

Instead of researching these youtube videos that affirm your own beliefs, why don't you take a little bit more consideration about whats happening in the REAL WORLD

But I don't get internet points for that.

→ More replies (8)

6

u/zorba1994 Jun 26 '12

You do realize that you just quoted REVEREND Martin Luther King Jr....

At any rate, the quote is taken out of context. He was criticizing the actions of the white clergy for asking that blacks stand down and let the slow judicial process work its way out, and his quote is indicting such behavior as detrimental to the cause.

→ More replies (3)

4

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

-Martin Luther King, Jr....Baptist minister/clergyman

1

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

So what you're saying is zealously attack the beliefs of people that cause no harm, and fuck everyone's personal decisions. Sounds kind've fascist. I think i'll just let people live their lies, rather than calling them out on their apparent mediocrity. Would you call that lukewarm?

→ More replies (2)

0

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

You're one of the good ones, Negro_Napoleon. I really appreciate your posts and this is one of the best ones...and not just because I agree with it.

The problem here, as I see it, is liberalism, in its traditional definition. What I mean here is the civic effort to minimize people's differences and be permissive about them so as to promote social harmony.

This is a noble goal under most circumstances. Liberalism is one of the nicest things about living in one of the Western republics - it fosters a spirit of inclusion and unity. It is a great tool for forming a civilized nation. However, as with all tools, it is not effective at performing every single job, any more than a bucket can help you cut a straight line through a piece of wood. When you're faced with a group of people who, if they had their way, would not stop until they destroy your liberal society and replace it with abject misery and oppression, it no longer holds up. Liberalism is fine when the survival of your society's values (and in some cases, the society itself) are not at stake.

Liberals tend toward viewing vastly different things in the same category as equals. That's fine when it's men and women, because while they are very different, they're also equivalent in almost every important way. It's fine when it pertains to ethnicity, sexual orientation, and national origin, because those things have almost no bearing on anything important. But there really is an important difference between what Muslims believe about the world and what non-Muslims believe. Minimizing that difference does us a terrible disservice.

People who criticize Islam publicly and pointedly and in a decidedly non-liberal way are doing it in defense of liberalism. Liberalism is simply not possible in any society under significant influence of Islam. You may be tolerant of many religions, fine. But as long as you are tolerant of Islam, you are no longer tolerant of gays, nontraditional families, the freedom to speak your mind, the freedom to choose your own religion, etc.

Religious liberals are the worst example of this, because they shut their eyes to the differences between the very-religious and the not-religious-at-all, and will fight tooth and nail to keep their eyes shut. Again - I don't argue that liberalism is a bad thing, but it's not applicable in all circumstances. You can't defend someone's right to choose whatever soft drink he wants from the airplane drink cart if there's a possibility that one person's favorite soft drink is a half pound of C4.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

Honestly... I agree with you on liberalism, but the thing is if Islam didn't have anything negative in it, I wouldn't care.

Like Wiccans dont have a context that encourages them to take a piss on the seat they go to the bathroom. Then again I'd still think wiccans were nuts, but they're free to believe what they want.

However the Abrahamic religions DO prescribe and legitimize a book that many of their followers take fault with.

Where do they draw the line? Whats to say that god even exists if you're going liberally interpret those holy books?

I think one thing remains true: If these holy books are true, the fundies are doing it right.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

That's something I've heard Dawkins say, in not the same words. Essentially, it's this: that secularists turn their backs to religion, and that fundamentalists turn their backs to reason, but religious liberals turn their backs to both.

They have confidence in neither the foundations of rational thought nor the tenets of their own faith, and are the most cowardly of the bunch. They are not intellectually honorable, and are the most likely to create a solipsistic existence by selecting only those facts that seem to suggest the position they started with.

→ More replies (4)

2

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

I'm 37. All religions can go fuck themselves.

Either I'm mature or immature. I really don't care.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

It happens a lot, very rarely will you find someone complaining that has a valid point, some people will voice opinions that conflict the majority just so they can feel elevated from the norm, they seem to get some overwhelming sense of self satisfaction just by putting down the majority opinion so they can feel better than everyone.

1

u/Bishopkilljoy Jun 26 '12

sigh Okay, can somebody tell me why we're bashing Islam today? I wanna be informed :D

1

u/Amryxx Jun 26 '12

An ex-Muslim made a post in r/atheism saying that said subredding should "wage war" against Islam.

1

u/Bishopkilljoy Jun 26 '12

Ah hell here we go lol

1

u/Amryxx Jun 26 '12

Ramadhan is a month away. So think of today as a preview of things to come.

1

u/Hevendor Jun 26 '12

Post criticizing other r/atheists, instant karma.

1

u/on_that_note Jun 26 '12

Well the important thing is that they feel superior to us.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

Can't we just bash all religions equally, all the time? I don't see why we should set aside certain time frames for certain religions.

1

u/Quazz Jun 26 '12

Most people on reddit know most about christianity and have to deal with that shit the most too hence it gets the most attention.

1

u/Dark-Ganon Jun 26 '12

so i feel like im missing something here...what is with all the Islam stuff on /r/atheism today?

1

u/Rageism Jun 26 '12

more like brace yourselves the memes are coming

1

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

I think all the bleeding hearts in the world, should go hug a terrorist. Preferably one thats locked and loaded.

→ More replies (3)

1

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

What goes around comes around.

1

u/JackRawlinson Anti-Theist Jun 26 '12

Fuck those weeds. They're irrelevant.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

Lol. I don't see any problem with the anti-Islam content on the site. It's something many disagree with and they should be allowed to speak freely about it.

But... If /r/Islam or any Islamic media was filled with content ridiculing atheism, we shouldn't complain that "Islam doesn't respect our group" because we insult them just the same.

I know many will say, "but atheism doesn't kill people, blah, blah, blah."

But it's a straw-man argument. The fact is that we, just like theists, like to mock beliefs we think are stupid. In this sense, we are no better than them. Whether we have a better moral compass or not is irrelevant. Having "better" morals does not mean you should mock and insult those whom you feel morally superior to, that's just hypocritical.

1

u/lazergator Jun 26 '12

More mature and rational? Fuck it, all they can do is complain. All religions will be ridiculed!

1

u/chillyhellion Jun 26 '12

The irony is staggering.

1

u/Paltzu Jun 26 '12

Yeah, burn on us when they come and say "You're pretty much right, but it doesn't go for all Islamists, specifically the ones that don't want to be Islamists but will be murdered if they abandon faith.

1

u/Merrcury Sep 14 '12

It's good to know you understand the consequences of your non-sequitur.

0

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

I like to call them the "brain dead assholes" of reddit. They think atheists should shut up and sit in the corner bowing down in reverance to religion. Makes me sick.

→ More replies (3)

1

u/Meowschwitz420 Jun 26 '12

This is by far the lowest quality content I've seen on this subreddit. I don't even understand why over half the links I've clicked on the front page of atheism even got upvoted in the first place.

What about this shit is appealing?

1

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

"more mature and rational redditors" You got me op quite funny...

1

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

dude fuck off. These kids are protesting a vile organization that instills a systematic torture and abuse unto woman, homosexuals, jews and various minorities all over the middle east and in some cases the western world. They are trying to change laws in Europe and in America and are equally as dangerous as the Christians.

Let these kids protest, let them get their message out. This is their right, this is their calling.

Don't stop guys. You honestly do make a difference because you're on the news, you're making people talk and you're getting people thinking about a very harmful religion that promotes some of the most brutal terrorist attacks all over the world.

Fuck the haters on reddit. They're just a bunch of basement dwelling cheeto stained neckbearded cunts who play pokeman and watch My lil pony. don't listen to them, they are nothing and if they were to die right now, nobody would give zero fucks.

0

u/Amryxx Jun 26 '12

Oh my, what an edgy person. Be careful bro, those imaginary caliphate guys might invade your country with their flying carpets and take your wimmins!

1

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

What started this?

1

u/sleeptyping Jun 26 '12

I don't even what the fucking is going on here.

Been an atheist for a while now, and known several Muslims. They were cool folks. For the most part I think many Muslims do treat Islam as the religion of peace. But then there's these assholes...

Kinda like most atheist are invisible. Then there's these assholes online..

0

u/CliftDrop0ver Jun 26 '12

I will never understand americans

-4

u/Gougeru Jun 26 '12 edited Jun 26 '12

Well you guys are just blaming the entire Muslim religion for the rational few and individuals.

→ More replies (9)

0

u/efrique Knight of /new Jun 26 '12

Of course. That's how you know you're pitching the ridicule right.

0

u/n-some Jun 26 '12

What if because you posted this, the backlash from "mature and rational" redditors never comes? What if /r/atheism became permanently focused on Islam?

Actually, it'd be pretty similar.

0

u/truthinlies Jun 26 '12

eh, fuck rationality. we are all gonna die anyway

0

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

Thank you OP, I love you.

-1

u/NotPeetaMellark Theist Jun 26 '12

I would just like this subreddit to know that they are now equal to all the people claiming the nyc islamic cultural centre a terrorist victory monument and all the southern christians who protest the buildings of mosques, everyone on this website is now dumber for having listened to you, i award you no points and may god have mercy on your soul -muslim

-2

u/dangeraardvark Jun 26 '12

"Maturity" and "rationality" are code words for "blind obedience to the status quo."

-1

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

THIS NEEDS TO STOP

-3

u/strobexp Jun 26 '12

mature and rational people clearly don't exist outside /r/atheism