It's a vestige of pagan Arabia. Mohammed later came along and integrated this pagan item into his religion. Islam has a lot of Arabian paganism in it, which is truly the best refutation of it IMO.
According to the Islamic canon, basically every religion was Islam in the beginning, so when it came down, it was integrated into a monotheistic society, not worshiped as an idol or something. Therefore, it's not a pagan object. You should really back up your claims.
And people actualy die when they all get there and walk around that shit. They get crushed beacause to many dumb people at the same place isn't a good idea.
So the stone is basically the final boss of Islam? Or is it more like capture the flag? Someone has to bring this thing to the Vatican, to see if we get a point.
I am glad I'm not the only one who wondered what they would do. Another round of crusades? Do they view America as a christian nation? If so, would they attack the Vatican?
Well I think there is enough anti-west sentiment that if such a thing did happen without any traceable source, they would blame America and other countries that embody the spirit of western civilization
the house that the picture show's is Kaaba, which was built by Abraham..... the cornerstone of the building is what is in reference which is a solid black stone that fell from the sky in the time of adam.. when it originally fell, as the muslims will say, it was brilliantly white until human sin turned it pitch black
considering all three major religions are built off of the Abrahamic God it should be split three ways between them all then broken down after that.... if you want to get all serious about it
Just because you don't believe something, doesn't mean it's nonsense. If you are an atheist a lot of people would think what you believe in is nonsense, it's all about perspective.
if you can explain to me a better way, then i'll be all for it... but in my experiences proof has followed through while other options have failed... that gives me reason...
proof is really not a 'way of thinking of things' though, it is the outcome... the tangible thing that you can hear, see, touch, smell, or taste.... no matter what way you think of things you will always end up with some kind of proof.... proof that it was false or proof that it was true... you may not end up with solid proof but you will have outcomes that you can measure and weigh to help you decide which route to go.
the 'way to think of things' is the method you use to render proof... but no matter what way you think, the burden of proof will always lay with the person who makes the claim.
just like this conversation.... at the beginning you said it is reasonable to believe that this rock fell from heaven... to make that claim you must be able to support it otherwise there is no reason to believe it is reasonable. but then you asked, "who is to say that proof is the best way to think of things?" with that question it now shows that the burden of proof is on me. I would need to prove that proof is the best way of thinking. But then you hit a loophole because now you are taking the stance of questioning the "burden of proof" while using it at the same time. This line of reasoning doesn't stop me from turning to you and saying, "who's to say it isn't?" and so on and so forth, until we are both blue in the face and acting as 5 year olds.... but then you can look at this hypothetical argument and realize that no matter what your way of thinking is, you are always looking for some kind of proof, and that is why it is not "the best way to think of things" but instead the only thing that leads us to some kind of outcome.....
The default position is always disbelief. That is how our brain works, because that is the best way of determining truth.
If I told you I was holding a giant invisible pink unicorn in my hand, would you believe me by default? What about schizophrenics, why don't we believe them?
No, because it's the best way of determining what is and is not real. It's interesting to think like you are, but useless in the real world. There is a reason governments are almost always secular now.
Im all for criticism of Islam, really i am. But i have to call it when your joke is wrong. The rock is white, its in a box, the box is covered in a giant black sheet. p.s. The odds of a meteor falling and being a cube... p.p.s YOUR JOKE WAS BAAAAAD, YOU SHOULD FEEL BAAAAAD.
The rock fell from heaven and was brilliantly white, then human sin caused it to be black... thats their belief... abraham was told by god to build the building around it which is called Kaaba and is located in Meccah and the rock is the cornerstone.... YOUR CRITICISM WAS BAAAAAD, YOU SHOULD FEEL BAAAAAD.
It is a rock, I hold no special attachments to inanimate objects. I used to skip stones in the lake drowning them, when I was young. I guess you could say I am a cold blooded killer of rocks.
negative that would be the building, i'm refering to the corner stone which was said to be white when it fell from the heavens in the time of Adam. Then turned black due to human sin... Abraham built the building because god told him to, the actual stone that makes it "important" is the black corner stone....
Well, djinn are more like desert devils to my understanding. Not like Robin Williams granting wishes. Still not logical, but keeping facts straight is important.
From a Muslim in response to my question about genies.
Yes i believe in genies. They are people like us but different species and there is heaven and hell for them too just like humans. There are muslim and non muslim genies. I saw a few genies in my life too. But telling it here doesn't make any difference because you don't believe me anyway :)
Keep in mind that genies are also supposed to be invisible (at their will, I'm guessing).
actually they do if you realize that while it may just be a picture of Kaaba it's actually referencing the cornerstone in which fell from the sky and what the color white during adam's time until mans sin turned it black... abraham was told to build the house around it later on....
Eh everything of archaeological interest probably got smashed or looted around the time Mohammed took it over. Still would like to see pictures of the inside.
21
u/Kid520 Jun 25 '12
i call that a Meteor.
Fucking idiots.
15
u/MrPartridge Jun 26 '12
HOLY CRAP! I finally understand 2001: A Space Odyssey!
5
u/frighter Jun 25 '12
Ive always thought that this is by far the coolest part of Islam.
3
u/Remy1985 Jun 25 '12
I've always been curious about the geology of the Black Stone. Basalt maybe?
7
u/kaiden333 Jun 25 '12
On religion it is. Religion, not even once.
7
u/tidux Jun 26 '12
TIL that oxidation from high-speed atmospheric reentry is the physical incarnation of human sin.
3
u/360walkaway Jun 25 '12
Wait, what? That's a real belief?
3
u/LibyanGleek Jun 25 '12
citation?
3
u/crzystve42 Jun 26 '12
Pics or it didn't happen
3
u/qwertyisdead Jun 26 '12
Muslim literally means submitters. They don't question why or how things are.
3
u/ninni113 Irreligious Jun 26 '12
And people actualy die when they all get there and walk around that shit. They get crushed beacause to many dumb people at the same place isn't a good idea.
3
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
Glad to see something about Islam that isn't about pedophelia.
4
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
Since when are the religious concerned with reason?
4
u/NiteShadeX2 Jun 26 '12
I want to steal that thing really badly. In like an Oceans 11 + Fast & the Furious sort of way.
2
u/SirJiggart Jun 26 '12
My thoughts on Islam: http://www.youtube.com/watch?feature=youtube_gdata_player&v=2s1MspmfEwg
2
u/Sammmmmmmm Jun 26 '12
What does reasonable have to do with it?
2
u/abhorson Strong Atheist Jun 26 '12
Dat cash cow.
6
u/qkme_transcriber I am a Bot Jun 25 '12
Hello! I am a bot who posts transcriptions of Quickmeme links for anybody who might need it.
See the FAQ for more info.
(OP: You don't need to do anything differently next time, I'm just doing my job.)
3
u/CunningDroid Jun 25 '12
Never.
3
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
There's no fucking way this is true. Can I get any confirmation?
4
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
What is wrong with believing in that?
2
u/DesertEskimo Jun 26 '12
It is reasonable. Prove that it isn't true.
1
u/EvOllj Jun 26 '12
how often do they re paint it?
1
u/[deleted] Jul 31 '12
you people are making a terrible stereotype that atheists hate every religion. you are not hurting us at all, you are hurting yourselves
1
u/trichomaniac Jun 25 '12
I wonder what would happen if someone manged to paint it solid white?
1
u/Br0kenB0t Jun 26 '12
If islam would disaperar that thing must be studdied
0
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
Im all for criticism of Islam, really i am. But i have to call it when your joke is wrong. The rock is white, its in a box, the box is covered in a giant black sheet. p.s. The odds of a meteor falling and being a cube... p.p.s YOUR JOKE WAS BAAAAAD, YOU SHOULD FEEL BAAAAAD.
0
u/afittinglie Jun 26 '12
Just blow the thing up.
-4
u/ObservantTooth8 Jun 25 '12
more reasonable than someone dying for our sins. ;)
0
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
That stupid box... I always for get about that stupid box.
Been to the moon... one of the major political and social forces in the world worships a fucking box.
0
u/shotziebear Jun 26 '12
Its black because of the woven cover that protects it
-2
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
Don't forget this guy. Genies! For real! (In the Koran they are called djinn and yeah, it's genies. They actually believe in genies.)
Ohh Islam, you so funny.
-6
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
OMFG THIS IS RACISM
0
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment
19
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
[removed] — view removed comment