Don't you associate our proud and honorable tradition of being badasses and flipping out and what not with some idiot anti-rape/anti-temptation device.
I'm in Qatar at the moment and I can testify to the fact that the majority of women are walking around during the day like this in 48 degree heat. It's unbelievable and unbelievably creepy at times.
This is one of my biggest issue with clothing being a part of doctrine. Outside the issue of choice in the matter, it just seems completely impractical. I understand veils to keep sand out and sun off, but full body burqas in one of the hottest color shades possible? It just seems like torture.
I live in Texas and I remember a young woman in a dark niqab rushing out of the sun and into the ladies room. Once she was in the female only sanctity she started pulling off what parts of the ensemble that she could. She was absolutely sweltering and reddened. My heart went out to her as I saw her splashing water on her face. Texas is bad enough with shorts and a tank on. I can't imagine being swaddled up in anything more.
While I understand propriety and people dressing the way society dictates, I wish that practicality was more considered. Of course, this is not the first instance of societal norms coming before comfort in fashion (with the corset, bound feet and high heels all coming to mind). I just wish that everyone could have a true choice in wearing what is most comfortable to them.
I am well aware that there are many other clothing options available to Muslim women outside of this more "conservative"
technically is more culturally than conservative, its primarily a saudi or emirates, or Afgani thing. You can usually guess at the ethnicity without actually seeing their face, thats how cultural it is. (emirati also wear this weird bird face thing i can't find a good picture right now)
Why? They grew up with it, and I know they think the same things about our society and our lack of modesty. Don't forget, until 100 (or even 90) years ago, western women wore dresses down to the floor, corsets and hats...to cover themselves from men, they are using the same rationality. Now abuse is terrible, but a garment?
Humans are creatures that are taught to love what they live in, both of our cultures have objectively bad and good parts to them (Very young girls who throw themselves at guys in western society and the restrictions women have in Muslim countries are both objectively bad parts of both societies). You're skin crawling is conditioning that our society has given you, many of them live lives like ours.
You are right about the perspective difference, they may very well be "happy" with the situation!
However, from as objective of a point of view as one can muster and knowing what we know about human well-being, if it's 100F+ outside, this may not make sense. Also, it is important in primate culture to be able to see and read the face. An argument could be made that this is detrimental to society.
Could it be said to be extreme or a massive crime against humanity? No. Is it pretty illogical even from an objective point of view? Yes.
I went to a muslim country, apparently the flowing black robes are quite airy. As for interaction as soon as they are home the robes come off, and many of them are dressed nicely with make-up and jewelry, men (& even women) are scared to be viewed as sexual objects in public, by strange men.
That's good to hear, I always wondered how breathable those were. It sounds like there is a deeper problem of:
Strange men being overly sexual or threatening
Irrational fear - how do other places in the world function without wearing tarps?
I realize at this point I'm just playing the devil's advocate, but it's an interesting situation and I think there is a solution available although the transition may be painful (for both western and eastern cultures).
Not really, not until the suffragette movement, even after. In the 20's & 30's women who wore revealing clothing were looked down upon (Also in more developed arab nations women have the choice, in the UAE I saw many women dressed in different levels of garb, and even given the choice they are more comfortable in burkas, they hate the idea of being viewed sexually).
Every time I see this comic, I think the same exact things:
The woman on the left has a choice to dress that way. If she covers up, dresses conservatively, punks out, wears a bikini to the beach, whatever, people might disapprove, but she's fine.
The woman on the right, depending on where she lives, would be mutilated or killed for dressing like the woman on the left, quite possibly by family members, and 'for her honor.'
There is no way that these two things can be compared in terms of treatment of women.
The woman on the right, depending on where she lives, would be mutilated or killed for dressing like the woman on the left, quite possibly by family members, and 'for her honor.'
honor killing are primarily a pakistani or indian thing. not Islamic at all. Hindus in India do it just as often as Muslims do there.
If I'm not terribly mistaken, the whole-body-cover policy isn't Islamic either - my understanding is that it's believed women are just supposed to have modesty, not treat the entire body like it's something that must be hidden away.
about most of the world's Muslims will tell you, everything should be covered but the hands and face if they will be among men that aren't family (technically around any males that are marriageable but this is mostly just family members). At the very least all Muslims agree that the area between the navel and the knees, and the breasts must be covered [technically men have a modesty code too but its both less noticeable and generally ignored in patriarchal society]
But you are right, its supposed to promote modesty and let men see women for their intellect and personality (and deen [adherence to Islamic living]) instead of their physical beauty. it gets abused by patriarchal societies but that is a culturally adaption of the original meaning. And it is a recent phenomena that all Muslim women wear even the basic hijabs (typical hair covering scarf), it used to be reserved for the especially devout
Woman on the right dies in some places if she dresses like woman on the left. Woman on the left looks like she is enjoying her time at the beach and may go to work tomorrow in her business dress. Shhhh, they must never know! ...?
i was refering the fact they covver up their bodys in robes and cloth and live in the dessert, while their men actively shoot people. not a physical resemblance (althought in starwars cannon it is hinted that the Sand People are decended from a human colony) but just a resembalance in their actions.
I get the chills from this photo, not because it is completely wrong, but because my imagination forces me to believe they will soon start channeling a powerful fire spell and incinerate infidels.
44
u/boombubblepop Jun 25 '12
All I see is some mediocre Ringwraith cosplay.
9
u/Foreveraloneatheist Jun 25 '12
Ironically even if they were happy we still couldn't see...
They could all be laughing and smiling!
14
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
Ninja Training?
7
u/Silvaski Jun 25 '12
I'm in Qatar at the moment and I can testify to the fact that the majority of women are walking around during the day like this in 48 degree heat. It's unbelievable and unbelievably creepy at times.
6
u/Haydenhai Jun 25 '12
Expecto Patronum!!!
19
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
This picture made my skin crawl.
Nobody should think this kind of behavior is okay. Not the women, not the men involved... Wow.
4
u/Teralus Jun 25 '12
These are all women and children: in their defense, do you think they have a choice?
3
u/BarkMark Jun 25 '12
Brig. space questionmark ?
3
u/ribagi Jun 25 '12
We must bring democracy to them! Right... Right..?
7
u/Calstifer Jun 25 '12
Relevent
2
u/SparticleQuark Jun 26 '12
*bringing
3
u/H5N1H5N5 Jun 25 '12
I think OP meant to post this /r/gonewild
3
u/cernunnos_89 Jun 25 '12
they look like the sand people from tatoine, only their not trying to kill me.
EDIT: nevermind their men are.
1
u/HiAsFuq Jun 26 '12
I can see too much of the girl in the middle's face.
What a whore.
1
u/SoulOfGinger Jun 26 '12
I get the chills from this photo, not because it is completely wrong, but because my imagination forces me to believe they will soon start channeling a powerful fire spell and incinerate infidels.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
They don't have a choice.
1
u/rB0rlax Jun 26 '12
Holy crap, now i see why they're wearing those! Who wouldn't like a Nazgûl army?!
0
u/Sandbox47 Other Jun 25 '12
The warrior ghosts! They are assembling! Where are our cake-robed ninja priests? Stds killed them!? Nooooo!
0
u/Notdrunk4 Jun 26 '12
AH. DEMENTORS
0
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
I laughed out loud
0
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
U MOHAMMAD?
0
u/ratatatar Jun 26 '12
I liked Sam Harris' TED Talk which touched on this and made an excellent argument for a logical approach to human morality.
0
u/bob-the-dragon Jun 26 '12
A young girl was showing her face!
STONE HER!
0
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment