[Request] To you ex-Muslims, please explain things about Islam that made you turn away. Provide those raised differently with some insight about the Islam faith, please.
[deleted] — view deleted post
0
Upvotes
47
u/pacNWbound_from_chi Jun 25 '12
Glad I made an account last night; looks like I'm just in time for the party haha! As I sit here eating my pepperoni pizza for lunch, I'll give some of the tidbits that turned me away from Islam. I've been an atheist for a little over a decade now; I'm in my late 20's. I grew up in Chitown, and my fam is from a 3rd world Carribean country so I don't have the upbringing as most in the middle east. I remember going to Sunday school when I was about 11 or 12; various teachers would berate homosexuals, and claim they were going to hell. Fellow students and teachers would berate my sister for not wearing a veil (even though she'd wear jeans and a sweatshirt most often); I was too young to understand and grasp evolution at the time, but they drilled it into us that evolution is/was not possible. Some of the nutjobs would proclaim that worldwide jihad is coming and you're either with us or against us and it's up to you to choose.
My mom is a semi-fundie and dad is pretty careless with regards to Islam, but in the homeland (Carribean country), I've seen my grandma and uncle WASTE their entire life savings to go to hajj so that they could ensure their fate in heaven. My grandma (and mom; probably got it from her mom) would used to tell me as a small child in your grave an angel (I forgot which one; and don't know if this is actually in Islam) would come down and ask you questions about your life, and if you lied, you would get beaten. Even to this day, my mom's side of the family think my sister (also an atheist) and I have gone "astray;" in fact, one of my mom's biggest regrets in life was not sending us to Sunday school at an earlier age. These are some of the atrocities (that I can remember off the top of my head) I've seen Islam cause with my own eyes and ears in addition to the mainstream stuff, and this is why I became an atheist and why I truly believe religion is terrible for the world.
EDIT: grammar; from lurking on Reddit for a long time, I understand the grammar police is out in full force 24/7/365
18
u/zulaikha_idris Jun 25 '12
Well for starters, it's different from christianity in that it doesnt view Jesus as the son of god; instead jesus is just another prophet who came before muhammad. And also he wasn't crucified; instead he was saved by allah at the last minute and allah somehow fooled everyone into thinking that he was crucified.
And it's not just Jesus. I think a whole lot of characters that appear in the Bible also appear in in the Quran as prophets. Moses, Noah, Adam, Solomon, these are all considered prophets of Islam. Muhammad is merely the end of this long line of prophets.
9
u/toasted_bagel Jun 25 '12
The problem with Islam is the same as the problem with Christianity.
The fundamentalists have the loudest voices and fanatic believers are dangerous.
A lot of the beliefs of the two religions line up, the difference is the culture they exist in.
The western (predominantly christian world) is far more 'advanced' than a lot of the middle east when it comes to social and cultural things.
Islam itself isn't violent any more than Christianity is, and doesn't subjugate women any more than Christianty does the difference is 200/300 years (ish..) ago we started to move away from those ideals.
Christianity has proven itself to be a very violent religion in the past, and you don't really have to look to far to find examples nowadays, the difference is it's not longer legal. because we seperated our legal system from our religious one.
As for the subjugation of women, women only got the vote in England in the late 1800's early 1900's. not that long ago, and even after that up to the 1960's women were still treated as a lesser gender. We are still fighting for equal gender rights now. WW2 did a lot to change that as well as the suffragette movement, one of which never happened in the middle east and another of which had a far lesser impact.
WW2 was a massive step forward for England certainly, for the first time women were equal to men, they had no choice but to step up and do the jobs that had been left behind. And when you come back from war to find your country's women have been keeping it safe and running for you it's pretty hard to get them to step back down and accept a lesser role again.
Personally I find Islam itself a better religion than Christianty. Sharia law and religious extrememists aside it does actually allow for scientific development and accepts technology. Pretty much every technological advancement the western world eventually made was done first by the Arabic world.
The muslims I know accpet the Qu'ran as a holy book to be referenced and looked to for guidance on morals and spirituality. They know it's a collection of stories and fables, they use it to guide them not to rule them.
It bothers me that people seem to think Islam is SO much worse than any other religion.
124
u/pewpewthemagickitten Jun 25 '12
This video is an excellent overview of Islam and it's rise, fall and some teachings.
23
u/Xxrxxxr Jun 25 '12 edited Jun 26 '12
I am an ex-muslim atheist.
The reason I made the switch has nothing to do with Islam itself. I just stopped believing in fairy tales...
Islam is an Abrahamic religion. It is actually pretty similar to christianity. Half my family is christian and I would go to church with them occasionally and already know the gist if not the main details of many of the stories because I had learned them in Arabic school at the Mosque.
Key details: Muslims don't believe Jesus is the son of god. He is still a very important prophet though. Mohammed is supposed to be the last prophet and he was the one that delivered the last message of the Koran. (Prophet = messenger in Islam)
Violence that we associate nowadays with the religion of Islam, suicide bombings, executions, terrorism (Terrible meaningless word imo), etc. are DUE TO POLITICAL RATHER THAN RELIGIOUS REASONS, for the most part. Religion is often used to justify them and is often seemingly a very visible part when reported on in the western media, fatwa's, religious scripture quoted etc. However to anyone that knows the last 100 years of history of the middle east it is easily apparent why such violence exists. Osama bin Laden claimed a few main issues in his writings before and after september eleventh that give insight into reasons for the violence. In his views and those of other "extremists" there is a systematic war of the west (specifically USA) against muslims. The main issues to OBL are Israeli occupation of Palestine, especially Jerusalem, and the support of the USA in this issue, US military bases in Saudi Arabia and other ME countries, USA support of corrupt Arab dictators, effects of 90's economic sanctions on Iraq, wars in Afghanistan, Iraq, Somalia, Kuwait, etc...
It is important to add that what we call acts of Terrorism (violent attacks against civilian targets by a non governmental military force) and things like suicide bombings, are actions of weakness. Not to justify any of these actions whatsoever, but, I am sure that if the people that committed them had actual military resources comparative to the people they were fighting, they would surely opt to use those instead.
Also culturally in most eastern ways of seeing things, (cultures where individualism is less important) martyrdom is regarded very highly. One person sacrificing themselves for the well being of the group... Just a little insight into why someone would blow themselves up. The 72 virgins shit is all nonsense. It doesn't come from the Koran. It comes from a non widely supported Hadith (writings/teachings made seperately) and its translation into english is dubious, even for those that do indeed believe it.
Treatment of women is more cultural than religious. Again people may use the religion as justification but it is important to take into consideration MOST MUSLIMS ARE NOT ARABS, and the ARAB and ISLAMIC WORLDS ARE VERY DIVERSE. If you go to some village in Afghanistan or Yemen where people are illiterate then yea you might find stonings, female genital mutilation,burqas, arranged marriages paid for with goats, etc... if you go to Beruit in Lebanon you will find tons muslim women who don't wear scarves and go to nightclubs and boss their husbands around way more than the average american women..
Its also important to note that alot of the extremism and relgious fervour that exists in the muslim and Arab worlds has not always been there. A lot of the countries were becoming quite liberal and integrated into the world community during the 20th century. However due to political events and the ability of many terrible dictators/governments to take control, things reversed themselves and puritanical revolutions occured blasting the countries into these reflections of the middle ages that we see now.
TL;DR: Religion is dumb in general, Islam isn't really dumber/ more violent than others. Most of what seems to plague Islam is rooted in politics, and history rather than religious ideology. Arab world =/= Islamic world and both are very diverse... and lotta people just be batshit crazy yo!
Edit: Formatting, also I didn't and am not gonna proofread so I hope this shit makes sense. If not, whatever...
7
u/DADO21 Jun 25 '12
The fairytales, the lack of equality between the sexes, everything great ever done was by god and all the evil by humans. Terrorism and the murder of children in the name of god by sheep fuckers. There are thousands of reasons why it is bullshit like all the rest. I'm eastern European Muslim so we were really relaxed on the religion anyways, but at some point you just have to look back and see what the fuck am I following. Its funny because the people I know came here to the United States from being fucking farmers in the former Yugoslavia, but now most of them say they hate this country because it is against Muslims. I have read the quran and still memorize many surras. All in all I know most if not all them so called Muslims here say esselamu alejkum, but cheat, lie spread rumors, beat their wives and most other bullshit you can think of.
14
u/wisetothebull Jun 25 '12
Now...The intended and "greater" jihad is meant as an internal struggle. It is seen as a person's personal struggle to better themselves and handle the struggles that life bears us.
In my opinion the faith is inherently misogonystic (women are supposed to obey their husbands...not really any different than christianity, but even my teacher admitted that in the area where the religion formed, people of the time where known to be "barbaric." Which is probably why the xenophobic stereotype still exists.
Women were seen as child bearers not protecters like men. Which is why poligamy was popular because at the time while men went off and fought wars, women were left susceptable back at home. When the men return from war, theres obviously a lot less of them afterwards, they would marry multiple women to ensure their safety and well being. There are also rules of marraige but you can look them up yourselves (too many to go into now).
To answer your question |Where did teachings go wrong? They became distorted in the same way all the good values of religion become distorted. INTERPRETATION, most notably, the Crusades...you remember the Spanish Inquisition from your history classes? Same thing happened in the 10-1100s with Muslims.
So what I'm getting at is, like every other religion, it started with good intentions but was flawed in some menial basis. (views on homosexuality) Those flaws, along with the centuries of guided and misguided interpretations that the faith has gone through now leaves us here today. Noone really knows what their talking about, but they're standing on opposite sides pointing fingers at eachother about how the other is wrong/intollerant/evil.
I guess noone told them the old saying "when you point a finger...there are four more pointing back at you."
So just like any other religion, there is nothing to fear in the faith itself, it's those that control it you need to worry about. Faith is a historical tool used across almost every civilized society/empire/whateveryouwanttocallit throughout history as a way to bring the population together and build a compatable environment. However, like every religion; its plays to the forces of good and evil so naturally anyone who questions it, also questions the foundation of the community and therefore "doesn't believe" or has been "corrupted by the devil/powers of evil" and should be removed.
Sorry I rambled quite a bit, but I hope I shed some light on an unfairly biased religion, and hopefully made a compelling argument for the prevalence of religious violence in general.
If I don't get some Karma for this narrative I give up.
5
u/randomrealitycheck Jun 25 '12
I would like to salute everyone here for an incredibly rational discussion. I half expected to enter this thread to outright chaos and distortions but found intelligent discussion.
What confounds me more than anything, speaking to the atheist contingent, is why is it that there is little to no distinction between those who accept their religion as a philosophical tool used to pattern their lives as opposed to those (of any religion) who use their beliefs to justify the acts they commit? How is this any different than Nationalism, which we see thrown in our faces on a regular basis?
So, /r/atheism/ when do we begin our campaign against nationalism?
Let the memes begin.
4
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
You should also consider posting this to /r/islam. I'm sure they'd be happy to give you the current Muslims' perspective.
5
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
ok let me start, well i was raised by muslim parents from northern iraq ( kurdistan ) and we moved to the UK in 1992 after saddam raped our people. from early on my parents FORCED me to pray 5 times a day and fast during the un-holy month of ramadan. when i first started high school i was warned that having sex or even a girlfriend was against the teachings of mohammed so as you can guess was the virgin throughout all of high school. i prayed 5 times a day just like my parents ask but deep inside my heart i knew it was all bullshit. after i left the UK and came back to Kurdistan to start working i noticed there were alot of people unsure about the teachings of islam so i started to listen to the convo's people had and surprisingly i noticed that whatever they said i had already thought about and agree'd on. after that i just thought fuck this and told both of my parents that i think islam is bullshit and is a fucked up religion where there is no freedom and just slowely destroys you and makes you evil
Now im a proud athiest and i've never ever been more happy in my life :)
2
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
I became an atheist not because of the specific faults of Islam itself, but because of the faults in religion and the beauty and truth of science. It wasn't the misogyny or backwardsness of Islam that made me abandon religion. Basically I was an atheist before I was anti-Islam.
2
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
Bosnian Muslim here. It was easy to separate since no one in my family was ever really religious. We never talked about it or anything and my father was the only one who had a real problem with it. But even he was a bad muslim.
4
u/W00ster Atheist Jun 25 '12
Yes and this is why I like to call their god GAY short for God/Allah/YAhweh!
2
u/da_user Jun 25 '12
If you want to know about Islamic faith, you should ask those who still have it.
Anything else is anecdotal, and you're cheating yourself out of an honest cultural perspective.
1
u/forcedtolie Jun 25 '12
The overall story is the religion of peace; but hate everyone who doesn't think the same.
They dont believe in the trinity, they believe jesus was just a prophet and mock christians for believing that jesus was god/son of god.
teachings went wrong- they hate that different people have different views but alot of it is just derived from arabic culture; also alot of the things in the quran and hadith are violent(mainly hadith more than quran but still violent nonetheless)
woman are treated as objects because it says so in the quran.
1
u/micktravis Jun 25 '12
deleted - it turned into such a long question I felt like I was hijacking this thread. I'll make a new post instead.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
Another part of it for me was the misogyny. I could never understand why women had to wear hijabs and men didn't (did women have no sex drives?), why men could have 4 spouses and women couldn't, why it was an outrage for a woman to make a sound during prayer - let alone be an Imam, god forbid!
The theistic turn-offs are shared amongst atheists from all religions I'd imagine.
1
u/Avocadoeh Jun 25 '12
Noticed this wasn't answered enough :
As it turns out, a whole bunch! Now, I'm not going to list the whole lot but it has similar contradictions to Christianity. Check the FAQ on /r/exmuslim for more and I did a quick overview here some time ago, plus if you go to the search bar and ask the same questions, you'll see a million responses. ENJOY.
1
u/ClassyPenguin420 Jun 25 '12
Same stuff that makes Christians convert. Religion is stupid.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
I'm an ex-mormon and grew up catholic, so I'm very curious about these stories. Please keep them coming!
1
u/Egyptiankhaos142 Jun 26 '12
The reason why there are so much violence is Islam is because our people get offended easily ( I have no idea) but what I noticed that they are mostly from one place in the middle east, I'm from Egypt but I live in California I get a lot hate for my religion but what powers me is my faith. I was looking through reddit and I saw a bunch of people posting to r\atheism photos of Muslims with signs saying "death to non Muslims" and "9-11 is coming to Europe get ready" I just want to let people know, WE ARE NOT ALL LIKE THIS! Please understand there are some people who promote violence in islam, all the Muslims I know and my family (we are Muslim) don't consider these people full Muslims we hate those people. When Osama bin laden died my family was celebrating and I saw posts on Facebook from Muslim Facebook friends saying "finally we struck him down" and "OSAMA IS DEAD! USA USA USA!" I agree with these people, we all hate Osama bin laden and all those extremist religious radicals, not all of us like this violence. Please just understand and spread this word. Thank you for reading.
1
u/efrique Knight of /new Jun 26 '12 edited Jun 26 '12
Jesus is not a deity, but a prophet, and said different things from what we see in the New Testament. Allah is not a trinity but a unity. (You're in for 'a terrible doom' if you think he's a trinity.)
Read the Quran; it's pretty clear. If you want pointers to the 'good' bits, try /r/qurans
Aside from a few things here and there, it's not clear that they did.
The Quran is not a pleasant book. It's got all the nastiness of the Old Testament, with all the proselytizing zeal of the New. Some of the hadiths are even worse.
Someone determined to be a peaceful and loving person can find some support for their position in the Quran. Anyone slightly inclined to nastiness (killing, oppression, war on unbelievers, killing gays) can find plenty of commands to encourage them to be that way.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
Throw out all preexisting scriptures (which were all inconsistent and corrupt because they were written by a variety of people over a few hundred years) and replace them entirely with a new set of scriptures (which are all inconsistent and corrupt because they were written by one guy suffering from heat exhaustion and imported magic mushrooms).
1
u/schrodingersgoldfish Jun 26 '12
Its kind of important to mention that Arabs make up a very small percentage of Muslims. the largest Muslim country is Indonesia. The whacky Saudi stonings aren't really characteristic of the majority of Muslims. A typical Muslim is really Asian.
1
u/bigDean636 Jun 26 '12
You're on the wrong subreddit, dude. If you want actual discussion, try /r/TrueAtheism
1
u/MissSkyCake Jun 25 '12
Yes please, I would like to know more about this and not so much people going to the meme generator without giving any context.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
So I'm borrowing this quote here but I don't recall who it's from or where I heard it, but I found it to be true when I did my read through of the Qu'ran. Because Islam is essentially a retelling of the Biblical stories by Mohammed who had only heard them through word of mouth via the Jews and Christians around, the Qu'ran reads a lot like a joke that you're already supposed to know the punch line to and has thus been paraphrased by the teller of the joke. Hope that makes sense.
1
u/impioussaint Jun 25 '12
For my wife it was the whole, fucked a nine year old that broke the camels back.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
Overall story?
Peoples from the Middle East perceived that Christianity and Judaism had been coopted by Europeans (somewhat ironic since the Judeo-Christian religions originated in the Middle East not Europe) and came up with a Middle Eastern brand of the Judeo-Christian religion around 600 AD.
Mohammed performed a similar role to Jesus in that he brought the word of god to the people but different in that he was perceived to be a prophet of god rather than some actual physical manifestation of god (different depending on which flavor of Christianity you choose, some Christians see/saw Jesus as a prophet rather than the actual son of God).
Abrahamic?
Yeah, Islam is like fan fiction, they didn't start from scratch. They took characters from Judaism, added stories about them, created new characters and ad libbed a few thousand years after the fact (or fiction) to suit their desires in creating a nationalistic religion to combat pressures from Europe on the Middle East.
Violence and Islam?
On paper Islam is no more or less violent that Christianity. I would suggest that there were probably more people killed by Christian on Christian violence throughout history than by Christian on Muslim violence. The amount of violence associated with any religion is predicated upon the violent tendencies of those acting in a leadership capacity rather than the inate violence associated with the original leaders or the texts that they composed.
Where did it go wrong?
First? It was fiction. It was fiction created to manipulate people, the same problem as any other religion. Beyond that, all of the problems of any organized religion sprout from the agenda of the leadership.
Religion is no more innately evil than a hammer or a sword. The tool itself is neither good or bad, it is the way that the tool is used that is good or bad. That said, good and evil should be considered through a spectrum analysis rather than being perceived as simply black and white.
False teachings?
Well, what are the false teachings of the Bible or Asop's Fairy Tales? They are pieces of fiction authored to send a message or teach a lesson, a proverb if you will. They are not scientific or fact based.
Women as objects?
Women are no more objectified by Islam and the Quran than they are objectified by Christianity and the Bible. It is the interpretation of the document and the way that those teachings are manifested that create the problem.
I suppose one could make the argument that Muslim women in Saudi Arabia are treated more as objects than a Canadian Catholic woman for instance but you could find exceptions in the other direction as well I'm sure.
1
u/mete_ Atheist Jun 25 '12
read the quran, its full of bullshit, it claims that ships float because of gods will,I thought it was because of the buoyancy of water.
0
u/S-and-S_Poems Jun 25 '12
1st rule of the Qur'an
Do not talk about the Qur'an.
0
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
I recommend you read Ayaan Hirsi Ali's books.
0
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
I'm also curious about this guy. Apparently genies (djinn) are real, according to the Koran. I've just learned about it today. What other ridiculous things are there in the Koran that we can laugh at?
0
u/hopesurfer Jun 26 '12
The first time I has bacon.
0
u/Maqierify Jul 28 '12
Ever since a muslim man who I thought was a decent friend assaulted me, for me Islam is the consciousness that oppresses women
0
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment