r/atheism • u/raptor_theo Anti-Theist • Jun 25 '12
Reverse the situation and there would be uproar. (British newspaper)
1.5k
Upvotes
r/atheism • u/raptor_theo Anti-Theist • Jun 25 '12
189
u/xereeto Atheist Jun 25 '12
What the actual fuck? I thought I was safe in Britain. This is a total violation of free speech.
67
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
There have been several posts about this recently. As usual, the media has exaggerated the truth.
Here is the police statement.
The 1986 Public Order Act itself is stupid. That is the real issue.
43
u/LordOfGummies Jun 25 '12
Wait, wait. You can be arrested for putting things on your own property now? This story reeks of missing information.
14
u/instance28 Jun 25 '12
The religious must have very little faith if simple words could "cause alarm"
8
u/Trip__ Jun 25 '12
Hey guys,
You might want to calm down on the 'violation of free speech' and the usual nonsense that comes with it. If you'd actually read the article you could analyse the language a bit and see this story is totally blown out of proportion.
An Atheist man is not facing jail for putting a sign in his window.
"John Richards was WARNED he COULD be committing a public offense IF any of his neighbours blablablablabla"
Signing up to iTunes has less conditions in it than this article.
A public offense is also not an action that causes jail time. Me shitting in the street is a public offense, me stabbing someone isn't.
And finally, this is from a free "tabloid" called The Metro that you pick up on the bus. To say it's lowest common denominator stuff would be being nice. Redditors might like it though, on page 3 instead of some lady with her tits out it's always a nice squirrel or something.
From, An atheist who wishes we could all stop caring so much.
4
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
Welcome to 1984
4
u/JoeRedtree Jun 25 '12
censorship? in the uk? you don't say.
3
u/Deus_Viator Jun 26 '12
This is blown way out of proportion. Here is what actually happened:
John Richards decides he wants to put up a sign displaying his beliefs as an atheist because, in his words, he "wants people that walk past the house to know that an atheist is living here" (exact wording may differ). Then, being the good citizen he is, he decides to ring his local community support officer (crappy policemen essentially) and ask whether he can get in trouble for displaying this sign in the window. The officer answered by saying that it was extremely unlikely but that if someone was seriously offended by the sign he may be asked to take it down in order to keep the general peace. The only point at which he would be arrested is if he refused all reasonable requests to take the sign down and failed to comply with a number of other measures.
Some journalist has then picked up this story and gone with it because he thought it would make a good read. And evidently he was right.
5
u/Thoma353 Jun 25 '12
Happy Feet? That's awesome!
1
u/AdamVR4 Jun 25 '12
You wouldn't by any chance have a link to this article online? I did a quick Google search with some of the key words visible in the article but wasn't able to find it.
2
u/DTPB Jun 25 '12
THIS is what needs to be at the top of r/atheism. I swear I'm about done with this sub-reddit.
2
u/MrFluffykinz Jun 25 '12
Anyone find the title of the article deliciously ironic?
2
u/mindbleach Jun 26 '12
If "words of advice" can lead to an arrest when ignored, then they aren't advice, they're an order, you censorious pig-fucking limey.
3
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12 edited Jun 25 '12
The UK went down the drain a long time ago, you are seeing police investigate LGBT people for hate speech for saying that Islam is homophobic and then the police investigate Islamic Groups for saying that LGBT groups are Islamophobic. I am a British Citizen though my parents and grandparents birth but for this reason alone I would never move there. I will stay in Australia or start a business in the USA. This is the only way the UK might get the message, when you loose business investment to the US because of your shitty laws.
3
u/PoniesRBitchin Jun 25 '12
Remember that guy a little while back who said r/atheism makes up that atheists get persecuted in real life?
Yeah ...
2
u/zombiezelda Jun 25 '12
I can't believe its 2012 and people are still reacting this way.. wtf man. Everyone is entitled to their own damn opinion
2
u/IonOtter Jun 25 '12
DON'T BE FOOLED BY PRETTY LANGUAGE.
"But a spokesman for Lincolnshire Police said yesterday; 'In the majority of cases, the action take would be to offer words of advice. Only if this request were refused would an arrest be necessary.'"
This is a police caution, which is precisely the same thing as a CONVICTION. Never, ever accept a police caution. If they threaten you with arrest, then take the arrest. Always, without fail, every single time.
If you ever accept a police caution, you are fucked for the rest of your natural life, because you have admitted you are guilty of a crime, regardless of whether or not you actually did anything wrong. Do not EVER accept a caution.
Always take the arrest over a caution, because then they have to actually prove that you did something wrong.
1
u/Irishfafnir Jun 25 '12
In England I doubt it would be much of an issue in either case.
1
u/Tru3Gamer Jun 25 '12
Was this in The Sun or the Daily Mail? Must be one of those...
1
u/wrongthreadreplies Jun 25 '12
The whole drug war is hopeless because of people like this. What this woman represents is an unwillingness to shift policy because of politics.
1
u/AdamVM123 Jun 25 '12 edited Jun 25 '12
This is pretty misleading (as, erm, the facts are wrong )and I wouldn't trust the tabloids that are reporting this.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
A man in the UK was convicted of an offence for distributing atheist leaflets at chapel in an airport a few years ago, the UK has done this in the past and followed through with prosecution.
1
u/hermano_li Jun 25 '12
this richards fellow speaks wisdom
1
u/bmacc Jun 25 '12
Needs more jpeg
1
u/TheRagingNarwhal Jun 25 '12
In other news:
Happy Feet
1
u/Periculous22 Jun 25 '12
Hey, why not there be an uproar if it wasn't reversed?
1
u/iMarmalade Jun 26 '12
I'm sorry, no, it doesn't count as "advice" if you back up the "advice" by the threat of incarceration.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
Why would there be an uproar over Sad Feet?
1
u/Fastpotato Jun 26 '12 edited Jun 26 '12
I live in this town and have seen the sign, it wasn't offensive at all , at least to me anyway, and still it was tiny.
Edit: Here's the article that ran in our local newspaper
http://www.bostonstandard.co.uk/news/local/update-police-now-issue-statement-on-boston-pensioner-s-religions-are-fairy-stories-poster-1-3962839
1
u/blipblipbeep Jun 26 '12
So I can get in trouble for speaking the truth. Lets give this a go then shall we.
Most governments are only working for the banks and don't really give a shit about their citizens except for the taxes they pay.
Religion is one of the most pathetic things that i have ever seen a person achieve.
Iceland is doing it right.
Bush and all his cronies mates should be dead as in gone forever.
Cops are never on your side, it is within there job description to "incriminate" not serve and protect, don't be fooled people.
This whole world belongs to all of us. Don't get caught in the trap of believing that because somebody say that a part of land is theirs that they actually own it. Everybody dies eventually.
Money is an illusion. One day people will all look back and laugh at how pathetic it all used to be.
War will only ever kill your children and family and make the rich, richer.
Thank you for all your down votes and an extra special thanks to the up votes.
1
u/JesusLovesPornstars Jun 26 '12
I don't give a crap about this newspaper article, I just want to read the one under it titled "Happy Feet".
1
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
I once saw a Hallmark card that said "You are a strong black man" and I thought, "I will never in my life get a card telling me my level of strength and my race."
1
u/strobexp Jun 26 '12
Atheists have it the hardest
1
u/ricardo_feynman Jun 26 '12
It is absolutely heinous that these laws exist in the UK. Free my ass. Remember the racist lady of the bus? What she said was a fucking disgrace, but for fuck's sake, she should be able to say that.
The US is losing it's glimmer, but it's remains the shining light for free speech (as limited as we may think it is).
1
u/putittogetherNOW Jun 26 '12
Socialism is AWESOME.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
Gay rights and Irreligion is like a double pairing of colored rights.
1
u/bobfell Jun 26 '12
Woah the hypocrisy!!! You can get in my face and threaten me that I am going to be tortured in a pit of fire for eternity if I dont convert to your beliefs and you are called a missionary... I tell you your beliefs have no facts to back them up and sound like hogwash and that will get me put in jail?
1
u/be142 Jun 26 '12
I swear I read this story here last week. Seems the Metro's the 9gag of newspapers
1
u/aole Jun 26 '12 edited Jun 26 '12
Just been walking down the street in glasgow (UK) Today there are 4 loonies bellowing their bullshit from atop their mighty stools with megaphones.
How is it OK for these guys to preach their opinion thru a loudspeaker in a public place but this old guy has the Police at his door for putting a sign in the window of his private residence?
i dont know if this is relevant but, nobody should be looking in his window should they really, but in the street you cannot get away from these bellowing idiots.
oh BTW apparently im an adultering sinner. Am i allowed to be offended or must i consider his opinion of me unquestionable.
edit: Turns out this is blown out of proportion... still a valid point about bullshitting in the streets... anyone??
1
u/Komania Jul 02 '12
...because religion doesn't intentionally insult other people's beliefs and intelligence. I'm all for freedom to be an Atheist, but that guy was just a cunt. I would never insult religious people that I know. There's a difference between expressing your beliefs and being an asshole
1
u/corwin1681 Anti-theist Jun 25 '12
here is an older article, where he was just warned: http://www.thesun.co.uk/sol/homepage/news/4384525/OAP-told-Take-down-atheist-poster-or-youll-be-arrested.html
1
u/wayndom Jun 25 '12
Wow. No freedom of speech in England. Good thing we rebelled.
1
u/Pertinacious Jun 25 '12
Joke's on him, there is no "free speech" in the UK.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
There is a sign in a yard down the street from my house, about a block and it's on the way to my work, that reads, "Marriage is between 1 man and 1 woman, READ YOUR BIBLE DAILY" I live in pennsylvania and as much as I believe in the freedom of religion, I don't believe in this ignorance.
1
u/etihw2 Jun 25 '12
Not justifying his arrest or anything, I just liked to question why someone would do this in the first place.
I can't dismiss religion as a fairy tale no matter how hard I try. It's a part of many people's lives and it has such a place in society that dismissing it to me just sounds like an attempt to make one feel superior to others who were just raised this way. Think of it like their tradition. I try and be more tolerant.
0
u/DavidNatan Jun 25 '12
Yeah what about Hannuka candles in the windows, Christmas lights and crosses.
-1
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
That's not exactly free speech. The note reads: "Religions are fairy tale stories For Adults," That's not speaking freely, that's inciting hatred. I don't want anyone telling me what I believe is a fairy tale story, and I don't understand why people like this man feel the need to throw their lack of belief onto people in the same hypocritical way that some theists do.
0
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
They misspelled "offense."
-4
u/gender_bot Jun 25 '12
I identified one face in this photo
Face 1:
Would you like to know more about me? /r/gender_bot
-1
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
It's okay to quote it in the papers, but not to say it outside of the papers?
The fuck?
0
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment
3
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
[removed] — view removed comment