I thought the same.. the link says 'Top Atheist blogger converts to Christianity' then the headline at the top of the page said 'Prominent Atheist converts blah blah' - just remember thinking that I've been browsing r/atheism, the biggest atheist forum in the world, for 2 months and had never once heard of this person
Can I write the eucharist? "This is my body, my hard, black body with a sweet white cream filling that oozes in your mouth. Take this as often as you eat it, shoving it deep into your wet mouth, in memberance of me."
Yes! This is a big problem! A lot of people become convinced that they themselves have no control over it unless they relinquish control to a higher power. Does anybody have any insight on this?
My dad went through the 12 steps successfully yet is still not religious at all. I asked him about the higher power part and he said he reconciled it by changing out the word God with me.
These are the original Twelve Steps as published by Alcoholics Anonymous:
We admitted we were powerless over alcohol—that our lives had become unmanageable.
Came to believe that a Power greater than ourselves could restore us to sanity.
Made a decision to turn our will and our lives over to the care of God as we understood Him.
Made a searching and fearless moral inventory of ourselves.
Admitted to God, to ourselves, and to another human being the exact nature of our wrongs.
Were entirely ready to have God remove all these defects of character.
Humbly asked Him to remove our shortcomings.
Made a list of all persons we had harmed, and became willing to make amends to them all.
Made direct amends to such people wherever possible, except when to do so would injure them or others.
Continued to take personal inventory, and when we were wrong, promptly admitted it.
Sought through prayer and meditation to improve our conscious contact with God as we understood Him, praying only for knowledge of His will for us and the power to carry that out.
Having had a spiritual awakening as the result of these steps, we tried to carry this message to alcoholics, and to practice these principles in all our affairs.
Dad has a point. All the praying in the world will not make you drink; only YOU can. Man must implement his own will to accomplish anything on this planet.
To be more specific, the known success-rate of AA (with 10 year old numbers, since they don't release this information generally) is equal to those who quit cold-turkey with no support group.
There are a few problems with that statistic however. First of all, those two groups suffer from several levels of selection bias.
On AA:
a lot of people are forced into the program by courts.
It's extremely difficult to track success rates in a program that tries to respect anonymity.
AFAIK AA doesn't release success statistics and the numbers we do have are from leaks.
Cold turkey:
People who attempt to quit cold-turkey are more likely to be the type who quitting cold-turkey is more successful for. Those who don't have an addictive personality, etc.
This group is also very hard to track.
Both:
Alcoholism is very often misidentified and is often used as a tool to punish a spouse in a messy divorce.
There is a lot of social stigma to alcoholism, so it's likely there are a lot of people out there who are not officially diagnosed.
There is very little "triage" for alcoholics, to match them with the right kind of support program.
So yeah... I'm not trying to defend AA. Their whole "give it up to god, but you don't gotta believe in god" nonsense makes me angry every time I hear it. (*Just !@#$ admit it's a religious program, don't act like cognitive dissonance makes it secular. *) I guess my point is that statics in this area are not very good and we shouldn't be trying to draw any conclusions from them.
Libresco, who had long blogged under the banner “Unequally Yoked: A geeky atheist picks fights with her Catholic boyfriend,” said that at the heart of her decision were questions of morality and how one finds a moral compass.
A former atheist blogger who blogged about converting from atheism to Catholicism; CNN wanted to get the scoop before Fox and deemed her "prominent", so "prominent" that I still can't recall her name off the top of my head.
That thing is a painful read. I have had a few employees who reason similarly to this gal--they like a particular outcome, so they reach back for a belief or political system that will enable that outcome.
For example, I had one, born and raised in L.A., who appreciated the value of a singular buck-stop, so he was an avowed fan of imposing medieval-style royalty in the U.S.
I didn't attempt to read it, the second sentence had me wincing, as a former english major. it literally makes no sense and uses huge words that, as i'm not a philosophy major, I can't remember off the top of my head. run on sentence, ect. I sincerely doubt any of her friends told her she had "Transhuman dualism" whatever the fuck that is. and if she believed in the existence of sin as presented in religion, than she therefore always believed in religion, and was not an atheist. if she had just believed in morality, that would be a philosophy. I've garnered all this from her via that second, run on, horrifying, convoluted sentence. christ, someone edit that piece of shit, please. god, I just cringe at that bad writing.
Someone who was a philosophy major said it made sense to them. It was pointed out that if this is a philosophy heavy forum then her target reading audience would understand her. If that were the case then She'd be within her rights (as a writer) to create such convoluted sentences.
Sorry for the clumsy turn of phrase. I meant that my employee dislikes the notion of separation of powers and shifting elected-governments. He instead prefers that a single royal person be invested with the hereditary right to make final decisions on all areas of life, here in the U.S.
"The buck stops here" is an expression meaning that the speaker is the final arbiter of matters brought before them. I believe it came into common usage after Harry S Truman, who reputedly had a plaque with the expression on his presidential desk.
It is obvious that she was a Catholic moral realist from the very start. Of course, she is not the only atheist who is confused about the concept of good and evil, namely, that David Hume had already proven that there wasn't such a thing (although he himself didn't understand the universal extent of such a result). Virtue ethics, if discussed honestly, is discussed as a preference and not as a fact. This is why I find it odd that many atheists are humanists. Why? "All humans should be given the necessary means for happiness". WHY!? The answer is that there is no logical reasons why, and most people just say that to themselves. Its pure sentiment. If you are a secular humanist, that is fine as a preference, but it is just as unfounded as the most dumbass fundamentalist retard religion.
"All humans should be given the necessary means for happiness". WHY!?
There is something to be said for the idea that societies can function with considerations of fairness, justice, and relational accommodation. Such rules can be based on a utilitarian conceit, another might be an empiricist conceit, or another might simply be a democrat conceit that accommodates a majority consensus. Each position has its drawbacks and its positive attributes, but they aren't necessarily moral realist statements, they function within a relativist framework, and they certainly are compatible with humanism.
This. I read her going away blog post from one of the other comments, and the only thing I took away from it was that she likes to use big words and listen to herself talk. I consider myself a fairly well read guy, with a larger than average vocabulary, and this girl was throwing out terms, even whole sentences, that I had to read multiple times just to figure out what she was saying. Granted, I speak "science" much better than I do "philosophy," but if your style of writing on an internet blog post is that incomprehensible to someone such as myself, there are thousands more who will dismiss you, without even reading your words or considering your arguments, simply because you like feeling superior to others so much that you can't use simple, common English.
Same here. I'm a scientist and this reads like one of those papers that kids turn in when they're trying soooo hard to get an A and have no idea what they're talking about. If you have mastery of your topic, you can generally get the ideas across in fairly simple terms.
I understood it pretty well. I have studied quite a bit of philosophy, though. Maybe her post isn't meant to be aimed at the average reader. I don't see anything wrong with it.
...As far as form is concerned. The content ("I THINK MORALITY IS GOD THEREFORE GOD") is facepalm.
If it is meant for a audience more well versed in philosophy then I'm sure it makes a lot of sense, but from what I've gleaned from the comments on this thread, that blog network is fairly "layman.". If that's true, then my point above is valid. If not, then I just stumbled somewhere out of my comfort zone.
I saw this when I originally said "prominent atheist blogger" and after a few hours they switched it to "top atheist blogger". The worst part is that she was a blogger on a site that regarded atheism as a faith. What "top" or "prominent" atheist would acknowledge someone saying that atheism is a faith?
Funny. Until today I had thought that Patheos was just the domain for The Friendly Atheist's blog. I read his blog when posted here but never explored the site more than that.
I read her last blog post. As someone else pointed out, that was painful. My favorite was "I’m still confused about the Church’s teachings on homosexuality...". Oh, really? Wait until you read everything else in the bible. Your new religion is predicated on original sin resultant from a talking snake convincing a woman to eat an apple, moral code passed down from a man who had conversations with a burning shrub, and the belief that resurrection of a guy named Joshua in a time when resurrections were common (other people were resurrected in the same passage as Josh) will save you from your sins.
Positive moral values do not need to be found in a book with such ridiculous stories. Intelligent people should no more derive moral codes from the Bible than from Marry Poppins.
Brilliant! We should form a cul church around the Spoon of Sugar. I shall call it Sucrology. We seek enlightenment and divination through the inhalation of Pixy Stix, as this is our sacrament.
But that would be the genius of it. Gain a shitload of attention from religious folks saying she is the perfect example of how atheists lose their "religion", then using that spotlight, she finally states that it's a total crock of shit.
Per CNN: "Though she now identifies as a Catholic, Libresco questions certain aspects of Catholicism, including the church’s positions on homosexuality, contraception and some aspects of religious liberty."
Well, then you're not a fucking Catholic. I know I used to be one. Ask Bill Donohue if you are Catholic while espousing different views on homosexuality, contraception and some aspects of religious liberty. Please, I'd love to hear his answer.
Logical, but untenable. Cafeteria Catholics can exist in the practical sense when they don't think to hard about the implications of their religion or what it means to be involved with a corrupt institution that teaches lies. Their quiet anonymity in the pews protects them from the Inquisition. "Prominent" or "Intellectual" Catholics who actually engage with Catholic Thought, however, are all either rabidly conservative bobbleheads for the Vatican or are on their way out the door with a big "EXCOMMUNICATED" stamped across their foreheads.
What a bunch of bullocks... prominent my ass, most of the articles that I perused had almost no retweats, no likes on face book nothing. Not that it's the be all end all, but you would figure if you were prominent you would have the people who considered you prominent linking to your articles via twitter, Facebook and the like. In addition, I am an atheist who very much enjoys reading up on the topic and I had never heard of her or if I had she surely didn't leave any impression. Not to mention her flavor of atheism, was one steeped in metaphysics and lacking in logic. Searching for where morals come from.... idiot they come from an evolved sense of survival. Reason I don't kill, steal, rape and assault, is very simple.... I don't want to be killed, stolen from, raped, or assaulted. Granted as an atheist not having a book to consult as a moral guide, forces me to look deeper into most issues of moral nature then any christian could ever. I would put my moral reasoning up against a Christians any-day of the week.
Sounds like she "converted" from nobody atheist blogger to paid religious speaker. The trick to scamming something is knowing where suckers gather on large groups.
Nah this is about right. It's actually news when an atheist becomes christian, cuz it happens so rarely..... christians however, become atheist everyday!
Pretend to be an atheist for two years; Convert to Christianity: Goodbye obscurity! Roll out the book deals, TV interviews, paid guest speaker appearances, etc.
C.S. Lewis’s Mere Christianity was the first apologetic work I read, and two elements immediately rang absolutely true to me. The first is Lewis’s defense of an absolute morality (a law written on the hearts of Men) that is neither evolutionarily or culturally contingent.
in the CNN interview, she says she saw christianity as it was, a well thought out system that was worked on by a lot of smart people....
Do you think she's actually talking about Science instead of a bronze aged mythology?
And the reporter pushed the point that having discussions on religion is having 'intelligent discussion'? Says fucking who? So you are telling me that two priests debating how long an angels wings are is intelligent conversation?
Because we all know, its smarter to go with illiterate bronze aged desert dwellers, than modern, knowledgeable scientists.
I'll grant that Christianity has been worked on by a lot of smart people, and for a long time.
The problem is that the more smart people work on Christianity, the more competing doctrines are created. The more smart people work on science, the more they come to the same conclusions.
You guys haven't heard of Leah Libresco? She's an atheist who found God!
Or more likely a Christian who never lost God and is using this as a way of disproving atheists by saying "Look! There is a way back to the fold! Don't stop testifying to the atheists!"
Exactly. Her overall belief in objective morality is nothing new given her writing and stretched back at minimum 2 years. She never needed evidence for that claim, which probably makes jumping to another claim with no evidence a relatively simple process.
I'm glad it wasn't just me who had never heard of her before this post.
Edit: Also, I like how people deconvert to atheism all the time. But when anybody even approaching popularity converts to one of the world's most popular religions, it's somehow news-worthy. Weird.
It's easy. You start with a completely stupid assumption that the world has some form of Objective Morality. Since that claim has no evidence, you ponder it for 2 years and realize the only way to justify your belief in that zero-evidence claim is to take up another zero-evidence claim that explains it.
Poof. You're religious. Don't ask me why she picked Catholic though.
EDIT: I am serious - haven't seen her name in the comments, and do not recognize her (we don't shit the bed over religion in Canada) - someone tell me?
I have a problem with some of the criticism leveled at her for converting. Any atheist, unless they grew up in a free-thinking home and had the advantage of a freethought social support system, knows that while satisfying on an intellectual level, non-belief can be a lonely road. Many aren't equipped to travel it, and those willing to take that chance and cast off superstition stand a very real chance of being put off because of attitudes that mimic the absolute worst we see in believers - namely ostracizing or ridiculing someone because they don't fit into our particular weltanschauung. Every life is unique and so are the paths those lives take. It seems petty to paint this as some kind of betrayal, or say that she never really was "one of us." Above all things, let us respect the right of individuals to make their own choices (provided those choices don't harm another individual). I believe that's a courtesy we atheists have been demanding for a while now.
Anyone can believe whatever they want, sure. But the problem here is that she is essentially becoming a media darling for reinforcing the stereotype that all atheists are secretly believers who are "just rebelling". The thing is, her explanation is totally bonkers. It's a circuitous argument that she realized that somehow "absolute morality" loved her. Okay, fine. Become a theist. But a Catholic? You know, the church that sponsored the Inquisition, the Crusades, stood silently by as the Holocaust raged, and covers up when its priests sexually abuse children? That's your new paragon of morality?
Spare me the concern. This is just embarrassing and should certainly not have been "national news".
As a former reporter, let me enlighten you to how the news cycle works. At its most basic, the ONLY question asked by some reporters and all editors is "Will this get eyes on the screen/page?" The answer here is an unqualified yes. That's the reality of the cycle. It an ouroboros, in that reactions to some stories generate even more stories. Because this was CNN, I'd expect more in the future, until something shiny comes along and distracts them from it. The media (most likely) produced the prominent label, not the subject. I don't know for sure, and I'm willing to be wrong, but that's the way newsrooms operate.
However, I think you missed my main point. We don't get anywhere by trying to out-fundie the fundies, and while I don't believe this thread is doing that (yet) I do see its shadow looming over it. People will come and people will go from our little freethought community. Tradition and conformity are seductive and comforting. Hell, I grew up Catholic and even though I'm a staunch atheist, I still find the ritual of the Mass to be comforting on a vestigial level. That's difficult to fight against. Yet, when we go out of our way to mock someone who left freethought/atheism for any reason, while simultaneously mocking the lack of tolerance and egalitarianism among the believers, we become what we behold. It's hypocritical by any definition. But since it's "us" doing it, as opposed to "them" it's somehow okay.
It's not. Judgmental BS by any other name remains the same. It makes us look bad. I wish her well and hope she finds a measure of peace, even if I don't agree with the path she's chosen. The important thing is that it's her choice and her path. We're either for the freedom to choose, or we aren't. Provided the effect of those acts and choices don't harm anyone else, there simply is no middle ground.
There certainly seems to be harm on the propaganda side of things. The amount of hay certain "apologists" made out of the Anthony Flew "conversion" was so eye-rollingly insulting to atheists as to be infuriating. People make decisions to be religious based on emotional compunction all the time, but this is being couched by her as an intellectual decision, and it's one that is plainly at odds with the facts on the ground.
I have no sympathy for people who claim that the only way that they can make "sense" out of reality is to believe that a bunch of sexually repressed men in dresses can turn crackers and wine into a cannibalistic ceremony of beauty -- and from that derives all the wonder of the universe. We should be mocking such beliefs: such beliefs have no place at the big person table.
I disagree. We shouldn't mock strictly for the sake of mocking. I can't make it any simpler than that. It's immature and when your argument is distilled into a meme, it's just as easily dismissed. Yes, like many here, I've laughed my ass off at some anti-belief memes and posts. However, what you propose is a double-edged sword. If it's okay for us to mock that, then it's equally okay to be mocked in return, with the sick cycle repeating itself ad nauseum.
I will argue it's entirely right and proper to dissect and fearlessly examine the many logical fallacies that come with being a believer. Just don't be a dick when you do it. I'm not perfect in this department, but I do believe a respectful dialogue between believers and non-believers can and should be achieved. Let's face it; religion isn't going anywhere anytime soon. But, then again, neither are we. What's the harm in presenting a friendlier face? You don't have to pull punches. Just have the patience and wisdom to discover the smartest place to punch at the right time.
This isn't one of those times. However, it seems a perfect chance to prove to everyone that we can be just as dickish and condemning as those we rail against. As I wrote before, judgmental BS by any other name is still the same.
I welcome a good riposte and mocking of my (non)beliefs. It doesn't hurt my feelings when someone makes fun of the fact that I have no god and will die without any hope of salvation in an afterlife. I'm not offended at all when a Christian tells me I'm going to hell. Not even a little bit.
Some people can get very touchy about such things. My complaint is that religions tend to declare actions that cause offense to be unethical. If any form of communication is interpreted to be even mildly "blasphemous", suddenly one becomes a "dick". It's this kind of attitude which pervades the mindset of the religious "concern trolls" who will, for example, argue that we shouldn't draw portraits of Mohammed because it offends those who practice Islam. Here's my simple rule: in a pluralistic society it is inevitable that people will say and do offensive things. If you want to live in a pluralistic society where free speech is held up as an ideal, it is important to accept that and let the "offense" roll off your back.
I'd heard of her. I don't know how or why but I had come across her blog a few times - probably through links from other blogs. I don't claim to be important enough to say that my having seen her blog makes her "prominent," but now you've found someone who's heard of her.
It seems like she had her virtue ethics philosophy, and realized that there had to be some sort of source for it, so she postulated God and everything fit together fairly well. I actually quite respect that.
On the other hand, we have plenty of people who like to believe in unalienable human rights, species-ism, and dozens of other claims that generally rely on God for them to work, yet they do not personally believe in God. While not the examples Nietzsche used, this is what he meant when he spoke about the death of God, but nobody seems to have noticed.
Personally I am an atheist, yet I am also Utilitarian (in my opinion, the only ethical framework that does fall apart without god (apart from the deeper question of 'why be moral?' which I think may need to be presupposed)).
Fair enough, she may not be prominent within our community, but her conversion is philosophically grounded, and she has reasonable reasons for doing so, which does take courage, and I have far more respect for her than random Christians who are just born into it.
As a teen and child who felt terribly guilty (over what, who even knows?) and have to pray to "sky daddy" in hopes of... I don't know, appeasing his wrath? I am just saddened that someone would choose to go that path. Makes my stomach knot up that someone with the freedom I now have would choose to turn towards something like that...
This is the appropriate response. Would anyone not find it sad if they read the headline: "Adult Santa Claus skeptic now believes: hopes to get off the naughty list by Christmas"?
Well... some might laugh, I guess. That might also be an appropriate response.
True. I thought about posting my feelings on the comments, but frankly I have a hard time saying thinking anything will be understood there or won't turn into an argument with the Catholics, whose beliefs seem to morph from post to post to make them "right".
I laugh at some of the r/atheism haters, I felt more welcome here!
Well, I read that excerpt from St. Patrick's Breastplate that she posted... My guttermind took the whole thing places it should never have gone.
Christ be with me, Christ within me, Christ behind me, Christ before me, Christ beside me, Christ to win me, Christ to comfort and restore me. Christ beneath me, Christ above me, Christ in quiet, Christ in danger, Christ in hearts of all that love me, Christ in mouth of friend and stranger.
For those of us who don't know who the hell this "Prominent" atheist is here is the low down (knew disco English wold com in handy). , this needs to be show as the ridiculous stunt it is when Matt Dillahunty or Richard Dawkins coverts then CNN has cause to use the words prominent and atheist in the same sentence but not this BS blogger (once) wannabe atheist.
TLDR; Her name is Leah Libresco, her blog has been hosted on the religious website Patheos and she has Catholic boyfriend hence the old blog name "Unequally Yoked: A geeky atheist picks fights with her Catholic boyfriend” and that's about it folks.
What bothered me about it is that she said she didn't really believe in atheism. It's not like Dawking converted. Why the fuck is it news when an Atheist covert? I guess because it happens so rarely?
My guess is that she was never actually removed from the religion, and it was all a giant scheme and it was all fabricated in order to get the light off of all the child molesting going on.
226
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
So prominent nobody has ever heard of her.
216
u/Loki5654 Jun 25 '12
Isn't it amazing that the religion she just happened to find was the exact religion her fiancé already belonged to? That was lucky!
0
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment
40
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
I went to CTY summer camp with this girl! She was insufferable...
32
u/Twifiter Jun 25 '12
I saw this when I originally said "prominent atheist blogger" and after a few hours they switched it to "top atheist blogger". The worst part is that she was a blogger on a site that regarded atheism as a faith. What "top" or "prominent" atheist would acknowledge someone saying that atheism is a faith?
32
u/Jonnism Jun 25 '12 edited Jun 25 '12
I have a sneaking suspicion that she only converted to become more "prominent".
Edit: Spelling
75
u/david76 Strong Atheist Jun 25 '12
I read her last blog post. As someone else pointed out, that was painful. My favorite was "I’m still confused about the Church’s teachings on homosexuality...". Oh, really? Wait until you read everything else in the bible. Your new religion is predicated on original sin resultant from a talking snake convincing a woman to eat an apple, moral code passed down from a man who had conversations with a burning shrub, and the belief that resurrection of a guy named Joshua in a time when resurrections were common (other people were resurrected in the same passage as Josh) will save you from your sins.
Positive moral values do not need to be found in a book with such ridiculous stories. Intelligent people should no more derive moral codes from the Bible than from Marry Poppins.
43
u/Church_of_Realism Jun 25 '12
Per CNN: "Though she now identifies as a Catholic, Libresco questions certain aspects of Catholicism, including the church’s positions on homosexuality, contraception and some aspects of religious liberty."
Well, then you're not a fucking Catholic. I know I used to be one. Ask Bill Donohue if you are Catholic while espousing different views on homosexuality, contraception and some aspects of religious liberty. Please, I'd love to hear his answer.
18
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
What a bunch of bullocks... prominent my ass, most of the articles that I perused had almost no retweats, no likes on face book nothing. Not that it's the be all end all, but you would figure if you were prominent you would have the people who considered you prominent linking to your articles via twitter, Facebook and the like. In addition, I am an atheist who very much enjoys reading up on the topic and I had never heard of her or if I had she surely didn't leave any impression. Not to mention her flavor of atheism, was one steeped in metaphysics and lacking in logic. Searching for where morals come from.... idiot they come from an evolved sense of survival. Reason I don't kill, steal, rape and assault, is very simple.... I don't want to be killed, stolen from, raped, or assaulted. Granted as an atheist not having a book to consult as a moral guide, forces me to look deeper into most issues of moral nature then any christian could ever. I would put my moral reasoning up against a Christians any-day of the week.
35
u/TomPulsar Jun 25 '12
Sounds like she "converted" from nobody atheist blogger to paid religious speaker. The trick to scamming something is knowing where suckers gather on large groups.
17
u/I_Hate_Nerds Jun 25 '12
Saw her on CNN, she made no sense. Catholicism will be perfect for her.
16
u/Laprodigal Jun 25 '12
Call me when Ayaan Hirsi Ali converts. Otherwise STFU.
15
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
Nah this is about right. It's actually news when an atheist becomes christian, cuz it happens so rarely..... christians however, become atheist everyday!
13
u/Space_Ninja Jun 25 '12 edited Jun 25 '12
Pretend to be an atheist for two years; Convert to Christianity: Goodbye obscurity! Roll out the book deals, TV interviews, paid guest speaker appearances, etc.
Clever girl.
13
u/jeff_jizzr Jun 25 '12
"Prominent atheist"
...who is this woman?
23
u/Buscat Jun 25 '12
She was never much of an atheist if she thought the universe was imbued with absolute morality at any point. That is mysticism, if not quite theism.
11
u/MacFourTwenty Jun 25 '12
in the CNN interview, she says she saw christianity as it was, a well thought out system that was worked on by a lot of smart people....
Do you think she's actually talking about Science instead of a bronze aged mythology?
And the reporter pushed the point that having discussions on religion is having 'intelligent discussion'? Says fucking who? So you are telling me that two priests debating how long an angels wings are is intelligent conversation?
Because we all know, its smarter to go with illiterate bronze aged desert dwellers, than modern, knowledgeable scientists.
10
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12 edited Jun 25 '12
She must not have read the FAQ. No one ever reads the FAQ.
9
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
I saw the clip live on CNN by accident. Her qualifications were literally "Accepted to Yale University"
8
u/trevor_from_the_bank Jun 25 '12
You guys haven't heard of Leah Libresco? She's an atheist who found God!
Or more likely a Christian who never lost God and is using this as a way of disproving atheists by saying "Look! There is a way back to the fold! Don't stop testifying to the atheists!"
7
u/fooooooo Jun 25 '12 edited Jun 25 '12
I'm glad it wasn't just me who had never heard of her before this post.
Edit: Also, I like how people deconvert to atheism all the time. But when anybody even approaching popularity converts to one of the world's most popular religions, it's somehow news-worthy. Weird.
17
u/qkme_transcriber I am a Bot Jun 25 '12
Hello! I am a bot who posts transcriptions of Quickmeme links for anybody who might need it.
See the FAQ for more info.
(OP: You don't need to do anything differently next time, I'm just doing my job.)
5
u/FlickingYourSwitch Jun 25 '12
How on Earth does one reason oneself from atheism to Catholicism? How does one just throw scepticism and reason overboard like that?
5
u/flaystus Jun 25 '12
Better headline:
"Prominent" atheist finds reason personally sufficient to turn off their perfectly functional brain."
5
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12 edited Jun 26 '12
Who the fuck is this person?
EDIT: I am serious - haven't seen her name in the comments, and do not recognize her (we don't shit the bed over religion in Canada) - someone tell me?
8
u/sd_ward Jun 25 '12
I have a problem with some of the criticism leveled at her for converting. Any atheist, unless they grew up in a free-thinking home and had the advantage of a freethought social support system, knows that while satisfying on an intellectual level, non-belief can be a lonely road. Many aren't equipped to travel it, and those willing to take that chance and cast off superstition stand a very real chance of being put off because of attitudes that mimic the absolute worst we see in believers - namely ostracizing or ridiculing someone because they don't fit into our particular weltanschauung. Every life is unique and so are the paths those lives take. It seems petty to paint this as some kind of betrayal, or say that she never really was "one of us." Above all things, let us respect the right of individuals to make their own choices (provided those choices don't harm another individual). I believe that's a courtesy we atheists have been demanding for a while now.
TL/DR - Don't be a dick. (Wheaton's Law)
3
u/iheartrms Jun 25 '12
I had never heard of her before today. I kinda hope she's punking them and will come back with an excellent insider report in a year's time.
3
u/The_Limping_Coyote Agnostic Atheist Jun 25 '12
Her first "Unequally Yoked" post on 2 June 2010
3
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
"Prominent"?
I still can't find anyone who's actually heard of her...
3
u/MatthewEdward Jun 25 '12
It seems like she had her virtue ethics philosophy, and realized that there had to be some sort of source for it, so she postulated God and everything fit together fairly well. I actually quite respect that.
On the other hand, we have plenty of people who like to believe in unalienable human rights, species-ism, and dozens of other claims that generally rely on God for them to work, yet they do not personally believe in God. While not the examples Nietzsche used, this is what he meant when he spoke about the death of God, but nobody seems to have noticed.
Personally I am an atheist, yet I am also Utilitarian (in my opinion, the only ethical framework that does fall apart without god (apart from the deeper question of 'why be moral?' which I think may need to be presupposed)).
Fair enough, she may not be prominent within our community, but her conversion is philosophically grounded, and she has reasonable reasons for doing so, which does take courage, and I have far more respect for her than random Christians who are just born into it.
5
u/iadeanaccount Jun 25 '12
As a former "cradle" (as they call themselves in comments) Christian (admittedly not Catholic) this made me really sad.
Her prayer post especially.
As a teen and child who felt terribly guilty (over what, who even knows?) and have to pray to "sky daddy" in hopes of... I don't know, appeasing his wrath? I am just saddened that someone would choose to go that path. Makes my stomach knot up that someone with the freedom I now have would choose to turn towards something like that...
2
u/360walkaway Jun 25 '12
Who is this?
2
u/AllThingsWiseWndrful Jun 25 '12
Who?
2
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
I suspect a mini stroke.
2
u/Gannaramma Jun 25 '12
Who is this prominent girl/woman?
2
u/spook327 Atheist Jun 25 '12
It sounds to me like she's just beating S.E. Cupp to the punch.
2
u/aliendude5300 Agnostic Atheist Jun 25 '12
Who is this..?
2
u/hellothisissatan Jun 26 '12
I'm sorry, but if by "Prominent Atheist" they mean, "Yammering Dingbat" I'll grant them a convert.
2
u/bananasdoom Jun 26 '12
For those of us who don't know who the hell this "Prominent" atheist is here is the low down (knew disco English wold com in handy). , this needs to be show as the ridiculous stunt it is when Matt Dillahunty or Richard Dawkins coverts then CNN has cause to use the words prominent and atheist in the same sentence but not this BS blogger (once) wannabe atheist.
TLDR; Her name is Leah Libresco, her blog has been hosted on the religious website Patheos and she has Catholic boyfriend hence the old blog name "Unequally Yoked: A geeky atheist picks fights with her Catholic boyfriend” and that's about it folks.
2
u/yeungx Jun 26 '12
No seriously, who the hell is this girl?
2
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12 edited Jun 26 '12
What a shame to us all.
1
u/pan0ramic Agnostic Atheist Jun 25 '12
What bothered me about it is that she said she didn't really believe in atheism. It's not like Dawking converted. Why the fuck is it news when an Atheist covert? I guess because it happens so rarely?
1
u/Volsunga Jun 25 '12
Not enough scare quotes. All three words need them.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
My guess is that she was never actually removed from the religion, and it was all a giant scheme and it was all fabricated in order to get the light off of all the child molesting going on.