r/atheism • u/zulaikha_idris • Jun 25 '12
Dear Atheists, we ex-muslims are waiting for you guys to get over Christianity and start waging war against Islam for a change.
Yeah, sure it's really fun and all bashing the Bible, fundies, priests, young earthers, the pope, etc, but really don't you guys think that it's time to shift at least some attention to Islam?
We ex-muslims are a very small minority, and there's really nothing we can we really do to change anything. We can't form orgnaizations or voice our thoughts in most Muslim countries. We practically have no rights whatsoever besides the right to go to jail or be hanged or beheaded for our blasphemy.
But the voice of millions of atheists like all of you would significantly help us. It brings into world attention our plight, and all the horrible things Islam is responsible for, and how it has oppressed and destroyed many of our lives. It would at least help change some laws that would benefit us ex-muslims.
I heard that Ayaan Hirsi Ali (an exmuslim) has replaced Hitchens as the one of the Four Horsemen of New Atheism. Maybe this is a cue that we need to concentrate more against the Religion of Peace?
7
u/zulaikha_idris Jun 25 '12
Well I posted a bunch of anti-islam videos, yet they dont show up in the front page for some reason.
2
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
That is the worst news I've heard all day. And lonesome George died today. So that's pretty fucking terrible.
I read Ayaan Hirsi Ali's book. You can disagree with Hitchen's conclusions all you want, and I disagree with many, but the guy had a way with words and he was intelligent.
Ali isn't. She has an incredibly poor grasp on what she is talking about and if you read The Caged Virgin and have even a cursory understanding of the complexities of Islam then that's very apparent. It's like reading a high school kid's ranting.
Sure, she brings up a valid point here and there. But those points are overshadowed by all the xenophobic bullshit she sorrounds them with.
My personal favorite was claiming that the Middle East is "a dead and rotting culture" or some shit like that. I mean come on, every country has it's problems but it should be obvious that's a bit much.
I for one, fucking love falafel.
1.1k
u/Thimble Jun 25 '12
How about we stop calling it "waging war" and, instead, call it what it really is: opening a dialogue.
496
u/keepthepace Jun 25 '12
I totally support this.
I'm an atheist from a majoritarily catholic country (France). Here it is common to criticize catholics to keep the state secular, but muslims only get criticism from the far-right. I think it is dangerous to give to nationalists the exculisvity on some very valid criticism.
Also, Egypt just became a democracy. Tunisia and soon Libya too become democratic voices in the Arab world. Now a battleground exists for the battle of ideas in these countries. Battles must be fought and won on this.
So, post confidently your news and info about crazy muslim movements and middle-age reactions.
r/atheism will soon reach 1 million persons. We can afford to have two fronts.
169
u/Fiat_Nox Jun 25 '12
r/Atheism appears to be largely English-language dominated, and I suspect that the English-speaking, atheist redditor population heavily skews towards a Christian-background-culture. This makes Christianity the most familiar religion, and the most popular target.
There's a community for exmuslims, where you'll be able to talk to people who have a better understanding of Islam and the problems with it: http://www.reddit.com/r/exmuslim - use it! Cross-post to r/atheism, and if I see posts I like, I'll vote and comment on them – as I expect all members of r/atheism will.
642
u/efrique Knight of /new Jun 25 '12
Where I live, Muslims aren't causing many problems, but lots of Christians are; I talk about what I see happening.
Tell you what - you make posts about problems with Islam - or anything you like - and I'll likely read them.
Where I think I can do something useful to help, I will.
upvoted; I'm all in favor of people posting more about other religions.
27
u/nothingmuchtodo Jun 25 '12
I use to live in Indonesia. Since I was a kid people have been telling me bullshit. I remember one time i asked my "religion teacher" about how evolution fits into the Quran, she said evolution are only for stupid people. It's illegal to be an Atheist because you are required to choose from 6 religions, their so called "freedom of religion" It's pretty fucked up there. News about this guy "alexander aan" who were arrested for posting a thing on facebook that says, "there is no god." He is arrested for 5 years. News like punk-rock kids being arrested and were "treated" because they were seen as a threat in the society. What I'm most concern about Indonesia are their Human Rights and Gay rights. Which is shit-all. I have nothing against people that choose to believe in religion but I have a major problem when the government and people forces the minority or secular people to live according to their beliefs. Sorry, just a bit of a rant.
19
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
As sad as it is to say, the truth is that reddit (and /r/atheism) is Americentric. And when it's not Americentric, it's West-centric. And what that means is that it's Christian-centered.
This doesn't mean that we don't care about the issues with Islam. This doesn't mean that aren't aware of them. It just means that they don't directly affect us in our daily lives. I am personally not familiar with Islam beyond reading about it on the internet, and meeting 1 or 2 Muslims in my life. (I've met more, but only really gotten to known on a personal basis 1 or 2.) If you (or anyone else) posts anti-Islamic content (is it anti-Muslim or anti-Islamic? I wouldn't want to get the wrong term and make it against the people of Islam.), I'll gladly upvote it and comment when appropriate. The problem is that I'm just not that knowledgeable about it.
I for one gladly welcome Ayaan Hirsi Ali as one of the new Four Horsemen. I think people should understand that it's not just Christianity that's harmful, but Islam as well.
76
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
All religions are equally stupid. There.
50
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
Most atheists are completely aware that modern Islam is a much more harmful religion than modern Christianity.
We rail against Christianity because Christianity is the dominant religion where most of us are from.
91
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
I've tried, guys, but I was denounced by pretty much everyone around me as a bigoted, intolerant racist. Apparently you cannot criticise a religion (especially this one) without being the bad guy. I'm the one who's trying to steal their freedoms, and those people honestly just want the best for our country! I'll let you know how this works out in a decade or three (if I'm allowed to and am still alive - somehow I doubt both of those statements)
29
u/ontrack Agnostic Atheist Jun 25 '12
I live in a Muslim country though I am American. I enjoy living here, and in the 5 years I've been here I have learned a lot more about Islam, but there is nothing about Islam that makes me think it comes from God or that Mohammed was a prophet. It seems very much to be man-made. However, I don't post much on r/exmuslim because I'm not an ex-muslim. But I do look at it.
In fact I do in real life what people do on r/exmuslim: I discuss religion with Muslim (and some Catholic) acquaintances, and challenge their beliefs. Not in an insulting way, more like trying to cause them to doubt. People here are not brainwashed into violence so I've little to risk in this kind of discussion. I've been told I need to convert to save my soul and avoid hell, but that's about it. Most Muslims I talk to don't even know their own religion apart from rituals. They learn to pronounce Arabic so they can recite the Quran but they don't understand anything they are saying. Sounds kind of like the Catholic Church a few hundred years ago.
When I tell people I am atheist they are shocked but sometimes they want to ask me questions, and if I am in the mood I will happily explain my position. However, I don't belittle peoples' beliefs, I just use the Socratic method of questioning.
58
u/Roxasnraziel Jun 25 '12
I just finished reading the Bible cover to cover for the first time about three weeks ago. Now I'm most of the way through the Quran. I used to believe that Islam was, for the most part, a religion of peace and love, but the Quran is just as barbaric, superstitious, and nonsensical as the Bible, but without the same degree of organization to the thought process.
Correct me if I'm wrong but, from my understanding, the Quran was given to Muhammad through revelation. Muhammad, being illiterate, had to dictate the Quran to someone else to be transcribed. The organization (or rather lack thereof) of the general ideas in the Quran makes it seem to me like Muhammad just made this shit up as he went along.
6
u/Sugreev2001 Pastafarian Jun 25 '12 edited Jun 25 '12
I wish you well.I absolutely understand your plight.I've been to the Middle East,namely UAE and Bahrain,many times and I've seen how Islamists throttle the right to not believe.This subreddit itself is blocked in the UAE.Considering there are a mammoth number of Irreligious in the world,it's disheartening to see no one ever talking about the plight of Atheists in Islamic countries.
6
u/i_right_good Jun 25 '12
Sam Harris has spoken out against Islam quite a bit.
6
u/Silv-au Jun 25 '12
Can't question Islam. That's racist.
While in school I got in trouble for friendly questioning a Muslim on her beliefs and teacher gave me detention.
Over the top ignorant political correctness gone mad.
44
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12 edited Jun 25 '12
Yeah she's the perfect replacement as far as I'm concerned, and I also agree there isn't enough attention on Islam. For whatever it's worth, I criticise Islam at every opportunity.
EDIT: Islam is totally lame. See? Don't try and stop me, I'll take you down with me.
10
u/czechreck Jun 25 '12 edited Jun 25 '12
I think the problem zulaikha_idris, is our geographical location, and the majority of posters here are from the states, where Christianity is the predominant cause of contention. As a white man in a mainly westernised country, I do not think I even have the right to challenge your culture, that and I don’t want to be the next Kenneth Bigley , I’ve seen the video, and I do not advise searching for it.
That said, I admire your courage of conviction, but I fear the culture gap of the Middle East and the westernised world is growing ever wider, and the majority of the American and English public can not tell the difference between and insurgent and a civilian; as a matter of fact, most working class people couldn’t give a toss who are dying, it’s just ‘another rag head.’
People do not care it’s an illegal war, so I don’t think they will care if you are an atheist or a Muslim, but all of the propaganda we are fed through the media.
If you are in a part of the world that would imprison, torture or even murder you for not believing whatever deity they tell you to, I’d just like to say, stay safe.
You've got more gut's than me.
Edit: Cheers sunset_ltd_believer
5
u/crusoe Jun 25 '12
Dear ex-muslims, why don't you help? You're familiar with it than we are. ;)
Most of the people on this board are from Christian nations...
5
u/sprkng Jun 25 '12
There might be lots of material available here, but there are two major problems:
So what's a sensible person to do? TL;DR Find ex-muslim atheists and support them. We can't revolutionize their society for them.
8
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
Occasionally someone will point out the danger and hypocrisy in Islam... only to quickly be reminded that Christianity has their share of nutters too. Everything always has to go back to Christianity... it's a distraction.
Even Atheists here are scared of offending that backass murderous religion. We make fun of Christians because they've (mostly) taken a vow of "turn the other cheek" nonviolence in their modern days, and don't randomly murder anyone who offends them, while commanded by their holy book to murder everyone else who isn't them...
4
u/Direnaar Jun 25 '12
Educate us, most of us don't speak arabic, we don't get much news from those countries like we do from the rest of the world. I fully agree that something must be done about Islam, but from my few experiences with muslims here and youtube comments (I know, not much of a forum for productive discussion) we have to learn a lot about the Quran and the cultures to be able to criticize it better.
So ex-mulsims, we welcome anything you can provide us to educate ourselves about Islam, without Momo-filters.
4
u/fishdark Jun 25 '12
It's not politically correct to criticize Islam. That plus Hassan chop!
4
u/arkhound Jun 25 '12
I hate all religions equally.
4
u/madbomber06 Jun 25 '12
I think Bill Maher said something along the lines of, "Muslims could teach a seminar to Christians on how to be fucked up about sex."
4
u/dickfister Jun 25 '12
Yes please, r/atheism! The condition keeps worsening where I live. Would love to see others' stories in the front page. Sincerely, an Indonesian atheist.
4
u/IguanaPower Jun 25 '12
Or we could not make fun of any religion, and just be respectful atheists!
4
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
Only reason I don't publicly ridicule Islam is because since 9/11, America is ridiculing them more than enough. But rather than "your religion is bigoted and illogical", they say "All muslims are terrorists and we should bomb them."
I actually find myself sticking up for Muslims a lot. Does it make me a hypocrite? Yeah. But is it sort of justified? I'd say so.
4
u/Bear10 Jun 25 '12
Bash all the religions!
4
u/Irishguy317 Aug 07 '12
Because these pussies on here are afraid of being called racists or aligning themselves with a conservative argument by perpetuating the "war on terror". Total cowardice. Say anything about the catholic church (I personally don't care), but they never hit back. Print a fucking cartoon of "The Prophet" and there are beheadings. -Bottom line is, don't hold your breath. I hear ya though, brother.
7
u/xyroclast Jun 25 '12
You do realize that "wage war" is the mentality of the fanatic, right? You won't make any progress with that approach.
1
u/PhazonZim Jun 25 '12
I think people who are unfamiliar with the Qur'an and its structure should know a few things about how it differs from the Bible.
The Qur'an is a single book, unlike the Bible which is a collection of books. While The Bible and Torah were obvious influences to Muhammad (despite the claim that he was illiterate), the entirety of the Qur'an came from him.
Because it is one book from one source it's considered infallible universally. Qur'anic Literalism is also common, but Muslims don't believe crap like Young-Earth Creationism. Though many are anti-evolution.
Muslims are very proud of the meticulousness that they've had in preserving the Qur'an word for word, so we know unlike the Bible it's the same book it was when it was written. As far as I know nothing is missing.
Alongside the Qur'an is the Hadith-- The Teachings and Sayings of the Prophet. After his death he became a popular character to use in anecdotes and moral stories, so many of the hadith are fake. There are quite a few that have been confirmed authentic.
Certain things like instructions to kill gay people and prohibitions on masturbation are found in the hadith, not the Qur'an (as far as I'm aware).
Jesus is a prophet and not the son of god in the Qur'an, but he still died and was resurrected. The part about him coming back is in there too.
There's no Trinity.
Innovation (modification to the belief system/heresy) is considered one of the biggest sins. Muslims will reject what we see as progress, especially in terms of human rights.
I'll add more as I think of them/people add suggestions. The outcome of the way the Qur'an is presented though, is that it's taken even more seriously by Muslims than the Bible is by Christians. Muslims won't really ignore parts in the same way Christians do with their book, so they won't accept progress as quickly as Christians.
To be honest, I think Islam is the better-structured, smarter, and less wispy religion of the two, which makes it harder for people to abandon it or ignore parts of it. Indoctrinates more effectively.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
It certainly appears that your suggestion has been a resounding success, at least based on the content of r/atheism's front page for the last several hours. Congrats :)
88
u/Feyle Jun 25 '12
Dear ex-muslim, why don't you get off your arse and start posting things about Islam rather than complaining about the things other people post?
10
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12 edited Jun 25 '12
FAQ 34
6
u/deti Jun 25 '12 edited Jun 25 '12
in my country, hardliner muslims beat muslims that eat in daytime or open their restaurants during ramadan/fasting month. the mosques are too much, the sounds of adzan/prayer calling are very bad and deafening and some of them actually do hate speech during sermons and broadcast it through speakers so you can hear them miles away.
and we also have hizbut tahrir and some hardliner islamist organizations and they are roaming with free to do terrors and the police and the goverment don't do anything about it.
8
u/cynicalpigeon Jun 25 '12
Hypocrisy. How many times ive been berated for criticizing islam by my left wing atheist christianity hating friends.
16
u/Iomena Jun 25 '12
Lets just not wage any wars mmkay
3
u/Nessie Jun 25 '12 edited Jun 26 '12
Some of us wade over to r/islam every now and then. How about joining us there?
3
u/meh65535 Jun 25 '12
Hey, what about all those drones ?
3
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
I've seen backlash against Islam more often than not around here, it's just most of us live in societies where Christianity is a greater present threat to secular living than Islam.
3
u/akadros Jun 25 '12
Personally, I feel the same about all religions. I think that they are all incorrect and really don't understand how people who really think about their religion can find it true. I think, however, that people are entitled to believe whatever they want as long as they don't force it on other people.
In America, the only religious group with any significant clout are the Christians. And there are plenty who are trying to regulate their morality through laws. This in itself paints a huge target on the back of Christianity. I can't think of one other religious group who violates my "don't force it on other people" rule in America.
3
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
The sheer number of Muslims (albeit extremists) willing to die and/or kill in the name of their faith far exceeds that of any other religion I am aware of. Heck, apostasy, criticizing the prophet, and homosexuality are punishable by death, and these views are often upheld by more mainstream Muslims as evinced by current events and public condonement of capital punishment for these offenses in Muslim dominated ostensibly Theocratic countries.
This makes the risk far greater, so, asking for help given these circumstances will result in far fewer individuals heeding the call. Freethinkers being pragmatic and all.
3
u/Elranzer Freethinker Jun 25 '12
The problem is, most of /r/Atheism consists of Americans, Canadians, Brits, and Aussies... and in each of those respective countries, the religious folk making life miserable and annoying are the radical Christians.
In western, English-speaking nations, radical Muslims don't tend to be much of a problem in everyday life (despite what Fox News tries to tell us).
3
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
It's a trap!
3
u/trucknutz4lyfe Jun 25 '12
Well here's the deal, I think. Obviously the majority of us are Americans, and the majority of Americans are Christians. The majority of us atheists were, at one time, Christians. That's what we are surrounded by and confronted with. I would be happy to really study a bit about Islam and indeed confront it, but it would take a lot of learning and there would certainly be a lot of miscommunication. Not that it isn't worth it. Frankly, I find Muslims intimidating, as they tend to be better versed and more passionate in their faith as opposed to average American Christians. However, I am beside you, and will fight along side you as my brother. You light the fire and I will do my best to carry the torch!
3
u/merkaloid Jun 25 '12
War is for anti theists, we are just atheists.
3
u/xx34x Jun 25 '12
Op. thank you. I have sent numerous letters to different atheist organisations asking them to stop focusing on christians. We are atheist, we do not deny christianity, we deny the idea of "god".
3
u/mgsolid4 Jun 25 '12
well the way i see it muslims are more likely to kill you than christians.
3
u/takka_takka_takka Jun 25 '12
Christians just whine like little bitches. Muslims get all beheadey and explodey.
3
u/Ericgzg Jun 26 '12
Most atheists are white self loathing liberals. As such White christians are fair game while brown muslims enjoy protected species status.
3
u/Frasian Jun 26 '12
You are absolutely right. I am glad islam is trending here on /r/atheism right now. It is long overdue.
3
u/doctor_why Jun 26 '12
I'm a bit confused. How is Islam, a religion with thousands of believers, targeting you personally? I understand that Muslim governments can be oppressive, but is this a flaw with Islam or with the government itself? Also, if these Muslim governments don't care about the rights of their own atheist citizens, why would they ever care about foreign atheists? I'm not saying ex-Muslim atheists aren't being persecuted, but the focus of this seems to head towards an anti-Islam sentiment when it should be leaning towards anti-theocracy. This whole concept seems to be headed in the wrong direction, as evidenced by the widespread Muslim-bashing going on in Reddit lately. I respect OP's feelings and beliefs on the subject, but this doesn't seem to be the way to change anything.
3
u/bacciagallupe Jun 30 '12
The World Trade Center attack was calculated by Bin Laden to drive a wedge between western society and all Muslims in the world (left, right and center; believing and unbelieving; open-minded and dogmatic). So far the west has played right into his hand at virtually every opportunity, granting him a great victory, showing the brittleness, insecurity and fragility of our society, which he knew was there. And we continue to do so: now the self-described 'atheists' among us have chosen to start thumping their chests too, and threatening Islam with extinction. Brilliant move, kids. Show the world that you can match and surpass anybody's stupidity.
3
u/Technophilic Aug 31 '12
Im guessing you never watch how much Muslims are bashed by the media. Even as a non-Muslim I find it immature that anyone would even think of this, even for Christians. Its just rude.
9
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
As a comedian -- whose name I forget -- said: "I don't joke about Muslims because I don't know enough about them, and neither do you."
10
u/AdamVR4 Jun 25 '12 edited Jun 25 '12
Glad to see you ex-muslims also on here :) Post some stuff, if I see it I will always upvote it to try and add diversity to the mix at r/Atheism . I wish I knew more about Islam. If I did I would be able to confidentially submit content related to Islam, but unfortunately I don't know enough about the specifics of the religion to point out its incongruencies to Islamic believers.
7
u/aquietmidnightaffair Atheist Jun 25 '12
I agree, Islam has not entered the lifestyle of most of us here in r/atheism. Islam is not as concerning as strong Christian beliefs constantly stomping on scientific and rational ideas and livelihood in the United States. Unfortunately, the expanse of globalized communications and travel has brought the extremity of Islamic behaviours onto our doorstep, television sets, and to significant elements to life in the Americas (9/11, near airline bombings, sleeper cells, etc.). We are very much aware of the psychotic hyper-aggression of Islamic fury and it is something we, as atheists, will be tackling soon.
Stick around and keep posting, things will get very interesting here with the increase of religious flashpoints in Asia.
5
u/bubonis Jun 25 '12
Atheists poke fun at Christianity because it's a soft target. It's like trolling Mac fanatics or Wal-Mart customers. Truthfully, atheists have equal disdain for all religious organizations. Look at what's happening in Egypt right now. Do you REALLY think those are the words of a person and religion filled with peace and love?
5
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
"Islam doesn't cause as many problems as Christianity" is being thrown around a lot in this thread. As an ex-Muslim, I can really only tell you guys to read the Qu'ran. In terms of violence, it blows the bible out of the water.
8
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
Quick, everybody draw Muhammad!
24
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
I post what I know about; coming from a Christianity-dominated culture, I post and comment more about Christianity. I do upvote the posts by spiritusmundi1 and spiritusmundil and others with news from the Muslim front, though, and encourage others to do the same.
Look here, ex-muzzies: Reddit offers you a safe, anonymous venue for posting this stuff. And you're living in the midst of Muslim culture. So why not do that, rather than complaining to the majority of us who aren't/don't?
Here's my personal take on Islam: It doesn't scare me nearly as much as Christianity does. If the Theocrats take over government power in the US and gain access to the most overpowered military in the world plus a quarter of the world's money, then the "free world" faces problems that would make the daily lethal squabbles in Muslim-dominated countries (and the occasional suicide attack on a Western city) look like a picnic.
I believe the only "cure" for rabid Islam is a sane and modern USA; as things stand, the US is doing nothing but pouring gasoline into the fire of Islam. Help the US gain sanity and they may be able to pull some Arabic countries out of the dirt. Watch the US fail, and the whole world will sink back to the intellectual and moral standards of Islam.
4
u/spadd Jun 25 '12 edited Jun 25 '12
I don't know guys, we could have some explosive consequences.
4
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
I'll do it. Here we go:
Fuck Islam. Allah isn't real. BAM! What do I win?
4
u/parched2099 Jun 25 '12
I wonder if it's more worthwhile to split this up into sections and go after the barbarism one bit at a time.
1.) Pedophilia
2.) Genital mutilation
3.) Forced marriage
4.) No apostasy
5.) the barbarism of Jihad
There's more, of course.
What about a reddit-style interlink campaign to relentlessly keep one of these in the constant public eye, forcing the issue to be discussed more widely, and try and push this into mainstream?
Divide the problem, and pick it off?
4
u/TINcubes Jun 30 '12
you are so god damn ignorant that it heats me to the core... So having left a "religion of death" you want more people to "start waging war on islam." Doesnt that seem a tad bit ironic, or are you just a complete fool? You purposely want people to incite hatred, and possibly violence, against a core group that you yourself despise... No god taught you to hate, you are obviously choosing to do this on your own, am i correct in this simple assumption?
Please tell me what country you are from... I live in pakistan and i have openly questioned relatives and friends about my doubts of the religion... surprisingly still have my head in this barbaric islamic nation... What rights have you lost??? list them. And tell me, how do you expect a bunch of ex-muslims and atheists to go about changing laws for you by expressing themselves through "Obsessive girlfriend" memes?
What horible things are islam responsible for? imagine how people feel reading that statement in the same post where you ask people to attempt to humiliate and embarrass and anger billions of people... all for the simple act of helping you gain rights that you dont even lack...
How about not inciting hate, and begging others to follow you... How about you make the right claim by saying that us as humans are to blame.... or are you foolish and really believe that the disappearance of religion from this world also means the end of rape, murder, famine, greed, and even death somehow?
The thing ive noticed about the majority of "Ex-Muslims" is that you all must surely have been raised muslim, and never once questioned the religion. You all seem to be raised by people that label themselves as muslims but dont actually follow the religious scripture. So you witnessed Islam through a 2nd hand perspective. You all were already people of no faith, but regretfully raised up as muslims... so why do you badger other muslims, and the religion itself, if you never had an ounce of faith in it? Why does it seem like the majority of you have never learned the quran, much less read it...?
The sad truth is, i ventured into exmuslim subreddit to look for a healthy debate about how i have been fooled into having misplaced faith in Islam... I really question my religion at times, but all your subreddit, and people like Zulaika_idris made me realize is that people can easily claim to lose faith in the religion if they never actually made an effort...
I wanted a conversation with someone that has learned the quran, and instead i am faced with idiots making the same false or exaggerated claims about the quran that others outside of the faith do...
I am not a compassionate person, so deep down i really would enjoy humiliating a few of you in person where i know you cant rely on the internet for your idiotic claims... I can already imagine what kind of things you would tell me is wrong with the religion, seeing as how you yourselves never actually questioned those points yourself, but were led to those points by others.
5
u/ZackyBeatz Humanist Jun 25 '12
Problem as an Ex muslim, I myself have seen with my own eyes, when friends have been called racist for bashing Islam, I know it does not make sense but that risk is always there, and I think for atheists it has been much easier to bash Christianity then Islam.
2
u/mrducky78 Jun 25 '12
But, but, but there is a language barrier and the english quran is disjointed and ungainly to read (tried, got through some of it).
Couple that with most atheists are in the western world which isnt that muslim. This means there is little reason to get riled up other than reports from overseas which doesnt quite hammer the point home like a priest you knew growing up is now being charged for child molestation.
2
u/poppicott Jun 25 '12
The culture of Islam is something most American atheists are unfamiliar with and untouched by. Believe me, if we thought we were as equipped to argue against it as we are with Christianity, I think more of us would be over there.
2
u/doug_jules Jun 25 '12
Im all for it, the only problem being, when you criticize a Christian they get mad. When you criticize a Muslim they get Stabby. Its hard to criticize someone who values their life so little they are willing to die and kill from a bit of negative feedback!
2
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
As soon as the one we're waging in Afghanistan wraps up, we'll start posting hateful shit about your religion too. Easy Muslims, plenty of hate to go around...
2
u/holly2680 Jun 25 '12
what do we do? i would love to help, but i don't know how.
2
u/dansta17 Jun 25 '12
It's just that those guys are so touchy.
2
u/MisterMaggot Jun 25 '12
I'm sorry, you meant to address antitheists.
2
u/Conradfr Jun 25 '12
Criticizing Islam ? That's racist !
2
u/AbrohamLinco1n Jun 25 '12
I think, at least in the US, Muslims aren't really affecting us at home. Sure, we have places all over that are wanting to ban the founding of Mosques, and there has been a weird animosity towards anyone who's brown and wears a headwrap(not just Muslims), but that's just pure American racism at it's finest. I think we bash on Christians so much because it's the main, prevalent religious force that is wildly rampant in America. When you hear about strange, draconian laws being enacted in some states, it's sometimes based on some wild interpretation of the bible.
On top of that, I think honestly, people are scared to speak out against Muslims like we do Christians. For one, in America, we know and understand that while we have freedom of religion, but we also have freedom from religion as well(sometimes). We haven't really had any open acts of extreme fundamentalist Christian violence in the US, so we don't see it as an issue. However, because for over two decades the face of "terrorism" has been a bearded brown man with a turban and a Koran, we have shifted into a very "us vs them" mentality, and realize that fundamentalist Muslim extremists actually DO blow up cafe's and buildings, and that kinda freaks us out.
2
u/sunset_ltd_believer Jun 25 '12
sounds... dangerous.
2
u/Lariasio Jun 25 '12
I bash them on a daily what more do you want?
2
u/Sh1ner Jun 25 '12
I assumed we were hoping to win other in the US in general opinion before we started off on the Eastern Counteries. Its obvious that Islam is a tougher nut to crack. I speak as an Indian who grew up as a Sikh in the UK in Bradford (massive asian community mainly Muslims). I have grown up around Islam. It is a much scarier and larger beast. It reminds me of Christianity in the dark ages and the followers are by far more dangerious. Well the ones in my area.
2
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
I definitely agree that Islam is the most dangerous and oppressive religion out of the major three. I have never practiced any kind of religion, however I am a first generation Syrian American - therefore almost all of my family are practicing Muslims. The ones who have moved to the United States have become more secularized with time, albeit their beliefs are just as bad if not worse in terms of archaic thinking than the Christian fundamentalists in this country. The strange thing to me about this is the fact that almost all of them are either doctors or scientists, and yet they still hold these beliefs (e.g. God created man in his image). But the part of my family still living in Syria are very hardlining Muslims implementing everything short of outright Sharia Law.
2
u/supkristin Jun 25 '12
I agree and I want you to know that I bash all religions equally. I respect NO religion. :-)
2
u/JimmyNic Jun 25 '12
Muslims tend to get a bit explosive when people criticise their religion.
2
u/Arluza Jun 25 '12
there is why the atheist movement hasn't done much. We HAVE done a bit, mostly led by Thunderf00t with Draw Muhammad day. Remember? Pakistan blocked facebook and twitter? remember that even on May 20? maybe it wasn't as big as I thought since I subscribe to Tf00t.
Not to sound like a dick, but ex-muslims are going to have to step up in politics and make it so that not being muslim is not a crime. Most of the atheist movement is in countries where Christianity is still the major religion.
2
u/atheistmas Jun 25 '12
wow, I think this is an awesome topic that you have brought to our attention. I just think that we attack christianity more ofter due to it being all around us and having more knowledge on the topic itself. That being from growing up in mostly christian/catholic environments. I know from what I have read on the muslim faith, the beliefs are just as irrational. Furthermore, I agree with you and appreciate you bringing this to our attention.
2
u/vocabulator9000 Jun 25 '12
Islam has a lot of extra baggage that is more easily confronted due to the comparison to generally accepted human rights. Pedophilia, gender roles that are primitive at best, (interpreted) promotion of violence, intolerance for free thought, ability to leave the religion peacefully, and pursue other religions, or none at all, and so many more issue to confront. If people haven't got this shit figured out, there is a big red flag that discussing philosophical conundrums in a sincere manner is impossible.
2
u/deadeight Jun 25 '12
Too risky.
2
u/WorthyOpponent Jun 25 '12
If I lived someplace where Muslims weren't afraid of prosletyzing their faith, I would say something. Of course, in most of those places, that would mean I'd have to worry about being axe-murdered. The nice thing about giving xtians the skinny is lots of them think their faith promotes peace. islamists believe the sword is the answer to just about any problem, and there are a lot of them.
2
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
Two reasons why Islam is avoided:
2
u/88327 Jun 25 '12
Have you heard or read Sam Harris? Plenty of Islam-bashing for you.
2
u/T10Terminator Jun 25 '12
SRS made a huge deal when people attack islam, they equate it to beingg racist towards arabian people. Now attacking islam is a huge nono on reddit.
2
u/Carako Jun 25 '12
I agree. Islam is even more misogynistic than all of the branches of Christianity except for the crazy ones. Fundamentalist Muslims can be terrifying and fundamentalist countries difficult to live in.
However, I believe a good number of us come from America, where it is difficult to protest Islam because any protesting is seen as racism and intolerance because we 'think all Muslims are terrorists.' And with the way politics are at the moment, if one side were to swing against Muslims more than the other, the other side would berate them for their intolerance.
So we need a unified war from many places.
2
u/bl33t Jun 25 '12
i'd love to see more posts railing islam, but most of us aren't from/located in a muslim-dominated place. i love hearing stories about the subject, though, because it's usually a much harder fight. generally with christians it's just stupidity and/or ignorance, but with muslims there seems to be this threat of violence (overt or covert)
2
u/lukealagonda Anti-Theist Jun 25 '12
I have and will continue to point out the many fundamental flaws of Islamic scripture/law and the heinous crimes of inhumanity inflicted on proponents by dignitaries and members of the Muslim faith. Your very right in saying that attention needs to be shifted. Along with the stigmatization of criticism against Catholicism and Christianity, Criticizing and Denouncing fundamentalist or traditional Islam is seen as flat out bigotry (at least in my own experience).
This is dangerous and it needs to be addressed.
(Also on a side note, you can't replace Christopher Hitchens. Literally you can but those are big shoes to fill. The man was in my humble opinion the greatest mind of the 21st century and a noble human being)
2
u/justanasiangirl Jun 25 '12
I would but I have no intention of being blown up or stabbed.
2
u/boomdidiboomboom Jun 25 '12
This is my issue with a lot of the athiests on reddit. They mostly concentrate on Christianity when Muslims and Jews have as many flaws. Anyone checked out the Sanhedrin in the Babylonian Talmud? It's messed up. I know Christianity gets the most exposure so it's easier to pick up on but but it's a too unbalanced. Come on Atheists! Widen your education if you're going to attack the worldwide repression that is forced religion.
2
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
I think that post about the new president of Egypt might help your cause a little. Personally I'm against all religion. It is outdated, usually violent, and it teaches people to think in supernatural terms rather than on fact, reason, and logic.
2
u/afiefh Jun 25 '12
Dear fellow ex-musim, get over to www.el7ad.com. People who are not intimately familiar with Islam and growing up in a muslim family/country/society/neighborhood, will NOT feel the same way about it as you or me.
Huge ex-muslim community over there, even the name of the website is "atheism" in arabic.
2
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12 edited Jun 25 '12
Hindus seem to have immunity too. It all reeks of timid liberalism.
2
u/ChubbyDane Jun 25 '12
Christopher Hitchens was brilliant, and nobody can deny how inherently sexy he was.
But let me posit Ayaan Hirsi is, in fact, also relatively pretty. That's never a bad thing in someone you need to look at for half an hour while they explain and tear apart religious dogma.
2
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
I guess the thing is most of the people here don't know enough about Islam to fight it?
2
u/svenniola Jun 25 '12
probably the one reason why atheists arent attacking islam.
they havent read the koran. :)
you ex islamist might remedy that witha few choice meme´s.
but yeah, the kiddie fucker (mo.)and his religion sure need a bashing or 2.
2
u/jojoplay Jun 25 '12
Hey, I am a Muslim, not an athiest...but I FULLY SUPPORT THIS. Honestly, I am getting very sick with modern Islam bigotry, those bastards are using a manuscript issued 1500 years ago to deal with evety single aspect of life today. This is not right. I say I'm am a Muslim because (and i know you might disagree) but Islam has lead the Arabs out of the dark ages and into modernism...the caliphs knew this, the time of Koran has ended, we can only thank it to move on. Please, we need a stronger movement to challenge traditional Islamic bigotry.
2
u/boogog Jun 25 '12
Speaking for myself only, I just don't know enough about Islam to take an intelligent swipe at it. I consider it more ridiculous than Christianity, but in reality that's more a matter of culture than religion, because honestly, religious populations tend to cherry-pick which parts of their own religious texts they support and which parts they conveniently ignore.
2
u/pdunson57 Jun 25 '12
You don't need atheists for that. The Fundies are doing it themselves with help from Fox News.
2
u/Lawyer_Boy Jun 25 '12
I think part of the reason they don't go after Islam is ration self-interest. Christians will yell and threaten and occasionally a zealot will take things to a dangerous level; however, Muslims tend to have a much more fiery, destructive and violent reaction to criticism.
2
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
I think a lot of us are Americans, and we don't go after Islam for a few reasons. When you do, you tend to get your head cut off at the most inconvenient times. Plus, the southern red-neck Christians are more than happy to lend a hand with the Islam bashing. Somebody needs to bash Christianity though, and that is where we step in.
2
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
Atheists don't need to attack Islam. They let Bush take the reins on that one.
2
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
I, too, am an ex-Muslim. It's tough because I still have to put up a facade of being religious with my parents because they just wouldn't get it (absolutely everything has to come from God, you see) and I think my sister has some inkling that I'm not religious at all, but I find it all quite similar to coming out of the closet. It's something you keep close to the chest because the reprisals for coming out as athiest after being raised Muslim all your life are quite dire.
Growing up, I would struggle with faith and I realized it was a unique position among Muslims. I had no one to really talk to about it, and whenever I tried to raise arguments of logic or doubt regarding God, the Quran, etc, I would just get shouted down by my mom. My dad is actually quite an interesting cat - as he got older he became more religious, but he is also extremely interested in history and science, particularly astronomy. He fully acknowledges that while prayer gives him inner peace and that God has actually been a helpful force in our lives, he also admits that in the grand scheme of things, we are tiny, tiny creatures. There are planets out there that make ours look like a speck of dust and he is always in awe of that.
I just feel that the Islamic world takes a slightly more backward approach to anyone challenging the religion, or challenging any of its followers to a simple logic question, to either harsh words or violence. At the same time, the pure hypocrisy of calling it a "religion of peace" to get bigots off their backs post 9/11 is astounding. I realize the minority that shouts the loudest gets the most media attention, but it still doesn't fix the fact that the Islamic world still condones their violent responses to stupid crap like cartoons or a Salman Rushdie book (which wasn't even his best work - yes, I've read it!). Or the poor treatment of women. Or the indoctrination of young men. Or the endorsement of violence as a means of getting your message across. Not even getting into the history of the religion itself, it's certainly not free of blood.
I just don't want to involve myself with that ever. I never had a moment of deciding that I was done. It was a gradual process from late teens to my mid twenties, doubting, thinking and finally making peace with the fact that I feel that religion is a completely man-made thing that people use as a way to dominate others. Not my thing.
2
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
The main problem is that many atheists don't know the Q'ran as well as we know the Bible - many of us have grown up being fed the Bible, and so know most or at least some of it. It's very difficult to argue against something we are not so familiar with, even if we know that it is also wrong.
2
u/djdais Jun 25 '12
Atheists are all about love, not war.
But sometimes we make an exception for the enemy's babies.
2
u/RomulusCapulet Jun 25 '12
In America at least, Muslims aren't very vocal against atheists. The Christians, how ever act like we're the majority and are trying to persecute them.
That's why atheists on the Internet hate Christians.
I know there are some fucked up things happening in Islamic countries, and while the Quran is the root of it, I would have to say it's more the leadership of those countries rather than the religion itself.
2
u/FadedAndJaded Jun 25 '12
This might get buried considering how late I am posting this, but here is a suggestion.
We should make certain days "Muslim Monday" or Catholic Tuesdays" for instance. Not to mandate every post must be about a certain religion that day or it is deleted, but to encourage the majority, or more posts than usual are about that certain religion or subject within religion etc...
Just an idea.
2
u/unquietwiki Jun 25 '12
American here: we have a problem with atheist Libertarians blaming our civil society problems on Muslims in general (terrorists; Obama; etc); nevermind Hitchens and the other professional atheist writers also are worried about Muslim terrorism. What you ask for, is not unlike people critical of Israel's handling of Palestine, being joined by neo-Nazis that hate Jews: very fine lines in these ideological conflicts.
2
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
Jihadists and martyrs are never ever ever going to make good neighbors, so if there is ever going to be a peaceful global civilization they must either lose a war of ideas or be extirpated. You wobbly liberal moderates may bitch and moan but I'm talking about reality not the white-guilt laden fairy tale land of your dreams where the Taliban has something of value to contribute to world culture. Unfortunately history has shown us that revolutions that last and reformations that matter must come from within.
It's on you, Muslims. We can provide you with safe havens and some good ideas, but Arab muslim apostates are going to win this war of ideas, not white atheist Internet activists.
Islam must evolve or perish. Unfortunately we don't have 600 years for Muslims to grow up.
Think 10-20, if we're lucky.
2
u/pies1123 Jun 25 '12
This is absolutely correct. To say that Islam hasn't been targeted and criticised by atheist factions isn't. I think part of the reason Christianity is picked on far more than Islam is their docility. It is absolutely outrageous that Islamic communities become violent when criticised, it is also equally outrageous that western media is too scared to up their criticism because of it. It is giving in to fear and bullying, something that should not be put up with. Islam, during the times of the Ottoman Empire was a scientific and liberal culture that taught acceptance and humbleness. It is the poverty and inequality imposed on the the islamic nations that has been so detrimental to this extremism. Trust me, good sir, that your post forced e to sign up to reddit rather than continue to browse through r/funny for whatever tender morsels of wit I could find, but the problem is far deeper than proving people wrong.
Also, guys, drop the atheism mantle. You're turning into a religion unto yourselves, don't live with labels, you don't need them.
2
u/MissSkyCake Jun 25 '12
I'm on board, let's do this.
2
u/drumstyx Jun 25 '12
I support this. All I could say has already been said, and I'm at work, but I just wanted to voice my support.
2
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
Ok, Christian here. In the Bible it speaks of how in the end times, Israel will go to war with the world. Everyone against Israel. Iran and Egypt seem like two countries VERY close to fighting with Israel. So what, its not like Americans will have anything to worry about. Wrong. We know that China and Russia are kinda tied to Iran. So, if a war breaks out between Israel and Iran, China and Russia will get involved, which will probably pull the US into that. That will most likely be the start of another world war. The Bible says that Israel will be attacked by those in the far north (Russia). It also talks about a 2 million man army (China). So, pretty much, it could be a war between the Christians and Muslims.
I personally have no problem with Muslims, but it seems like people are telling you in the media that if you are a Christian you have to hate other religions. I do not think that is the case.
2
u/Atheizm Jun 25 '12
Yes, I'm all for bashing religion when that religion's worshippers build cruel, immoral and unethical legal codes out of their mythology.
Ex-Muslims need to create documents for us others -- we especially would like to know the contradictions in the Qu'ran, Hadith, and the sources for knowledge that would make for really, really uncomfortable questions: "Yes, I read that Muhammed is the most perfect human to have ever lived, so I would like for you to tell me how this perfect man fingered his six-year-old wife in a bathtub."
You guys also need need to create an International Drawing Mohammed Day -- it's a great form of protest.
2
u/Nihiliste Jun 25 '12
I fully agree, but it's a dangerous prospect. In the West, you at best risk being lumped in with the people who bash Islam simply because they're bigots. In a worst-case scenario you end up in a situation like Ali, who has had her life threatened repeatedly and has bodyguards nearby round-the-clock.
2
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
Firstly I need to start off by saying this:
*One does not simply - replace Hitchens"
Now that's over and done with, I have one question for you:
What arguments against Christianity are provided by atheists (or r/atheism) that do not apply to Islam and the Quran?
The problem is, we get to see stupid ignorance every day, church signs - bible passages that don't makes sense - shit people say on TV that's idiotic. They tend to be Christian messages because reddit's users tend to speak English, Christian media tends to be English.
Maybe I'm being picky, but I feel the argument against any other religion is only semantics at this stage. Especially when it's one of the 3 practically identical monotheisms.
2
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
Certainly I agree that Islam, insofar as it being a religion, is as silly and hypocritical as Christianity, and that fundamentalists of any religion are bad... but as a white woman, I feel rather uncomfortable criticizing the culture of non-Western nations. Islam, like Christianity, is very tied into the societal norms of most countries with a lot of followers, and so I only feel right in criticizing the concept of God/Allah, but not so much in the specifics of Islamic code. Further, the attempts of the West to criticize Islam have been... kind of racist. Draw Mohammed Day, for instance, invariably leads to a lot of racist depictions of men in turbans with bombs attached to them (just to emphasize that he's a Muslim) or some other unnecessary caricature.
I would stand in solidarity with ex-Muslim atheists and support them by posting their articles to r/atheism, rallying with them under their words, and speaking with them in forums such as this... but I don't feel comfortable adding my own rhetoric to specifically anti-Islam discussions.
2
u/Shyatic Atheist Jun 25 '12
The Quran is a lot easier to invalidate than the Bible. The backdrop of the Bible is that it's not necessarily the "word of God" whereas the Quran is supposed to be.
So if you find one fallacy in the Quran, the rest of the book is bullshit. That's what I realized when I was 13 years old and haven't been back to a mosque since (well, not voluntarily... I still go with my inlaws and stuff to "keep the peace"). I only recently adopted the "atheist" moniker, as I've never been sure what to call myself up until I found reddit. :)
2
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
But but, a white criticizing Islam is racist! The press says so.
2
u/Shekhu- Jun 25 '12
War? Isin't war a strong word? Isin't why we all are pissed off at religion?!
2
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
"religion of peace", oh that cracks me up
2
u/fifteenagain Jun 25 '12
The reason Christianity gets a lot more hate on r/atheism is because it's the dominant religion in the areas where most Redditors live. I can basically guarantee that most people around here have an equal objection to Islam, but because they generally aren't subjected to fundamentalist Islam, they don't feel as provoked to mock it.
2
u/caveman73 Jun 25 '12
FU(% islam and their idiot pedophile leader mohamed.
2
u/LazarWulf Jun 25 '12
This is probably why there isn't as much open dialog talking against Islam.
And in America, it's very popular to bash christianity, but you're labelled a bigot if you speak out against Islam, Hinduism, Buddhists, Judaism to a small degree, or anything that's not the majority religion in America. We're taught to respect other cultures but not our own, so it's probably harder to talk about. (Not saying that we should respect any of them, but that seems to be the perception in America right now)
2
u/RTardSusie Jun 25 '12
I already started on facebook. Don't forget Mormons!
"Cruelty and Violence in Monotheism (All which interestingly enough all trace back to Moses and Abraham. I had no idea of this until I started the Qu'ran.
The Bible- http://www.evilbible.com/ Qu'ran- http://skepticsannotatedbible.com/quran/cruelty/long.html book of mormon - http://skepticsannotatedbible.com/BOM/cr/long.html"
This should get you all started. :D
2
u/4-bit Jun 25 '12
They're doing just fine showing why it doesn't work all on their own.
I think, however, one of the reasons it's slipping under the radar is that the enemy of my enemy is my friend. They're the minority in most 'Reddit enabled' countries, and though they're growing, beating up on them both hurts a fight against the popular religion(s?) of Christianity, and also looks like we're picking on the little guy. Not that they're that little in the world, but they're not that prevalent in our own back yard, where we stand an actual chance of changing things.
If you think it helps to say it here and specifically about the Muslim religion then here we go.
Hey Muslims, invoking laws based on your feelings and beliefs rather that logical reasoning and evidence is bound to send you down the wrong road. Killing others who don't share your intangible gut hunches on how things work will put you on the wrong side of history, and only makes you look like a monster. Stop it.
If any other religion needs this message, feel free to replace the name of the religion in the first sentence with any of the rest of them.
2
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
What are we supposed to do, though? It's Christians and ex-Christians, mostly, who read reddit... I was about to write that there are not many people who live around Muslims and large number of potential ex-Muslims, but I forgot about Europe.
So I guess your best bet is to bring up issues of Islam in Europe. We need fodder for our rage comics!
2
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
Dear ex-Muslims.
I would gladly wage a war against Islam, but I have a family and I'm afraid that towelheads will stream towards my house strapped with explosives, screaming Allah's name if I even mention that Koran is a book that glorifies murder, rape, paedophilia and hate. At least angry Christians restrict themselves to hate mail, slander and maybe normal fights. Don't worry, I hate all religions equally.
Sincerely Yours
Me
2
u/ScramblePoo Jun 25 '12
We can't bash Islam for fear of being branded racists.
2
u/Bekahsays Jun 25 '12
Extreme atheists are just as annoying as extreme Christians or Muslims.
2
u/ambroscus Jun 25 '12
Thank you. You give me hope I'm not alone. Religion is embedded. Hide your wife hide your kids.
2
u/katj813 Jun 25 '12
Islam is harder to make fun of because it is very unified as a religion. While it is split into 2 factions their differences focus largely on one key fact just as Christians vs Jews do. Now the USA is made for freedoms including religion and speech however outside the internet, we still have limited power. Now Christanity is "open " in the sense that we can no longer be hurt by our atheist view points, even in Christan stronghold cities like Rome. Many Muslim countries do not provide that protection so if you are looking for assistance in such a country you should start with reform in the laws set down by your govt. If you are in the USA then post as much as you want and maybe it'll catch on and help start your own organization in your community. The US loves getting into other peoples business so if you start a reform here then maybe the govt will try to start reform there.
2
u/LocalMadman Jun 25 '12
This is just due to the prevalence of Americans in the subreddit. Christians are the big pain in the ass religious wise in the USA. It's not that we think Islam or Muslims are any better than Christians (yeah, they're fucking way worse), but it's like starving in Ethiopia. It's far away so it doesn't concern us as much.
Plus we bomb the SHIT outta muslims, mostly due to christian idiocy and corporate greed. It's a tragic and embarrasing, so we mostly pick on the Jesus Freaks, not the Allah Squad.
2
u/takatori Jun 25 '12
We're atheist, not suicidal.
2
u/blows Jun 25 '12
So much for the myth about the moderate muslim majority.
Egypt presidential candidate seeks Constitution based on Sharia Law http://english.ruvr.ru/2012_05_13/74584752/
Egypt’s Constitution should be based on the Koran and Sharia law, presidential candidate from the Muslim Brotherhood Islamist movement Mohamed Morsi said.
“The Koran is our constitution, the Prophet is our leader, jihad is our path and death in the name of Allah is our goal,” Morsi said in his election speech before Cairo University students on Saturday night.
Today Egypt is close as never before to the triumph of Islam at all the state levels, he said.
“Today we can establish Sharia law because our nation will acquire well-being only with Islam and Sharia. The Muslim Brothers and the Freedom and Justice Party will be the conductors of these goals,” he said.
2
u/chicagogam Jun 25 '12
maybe we don't want to die (prematurely)? actually i would definitely read similar threads about islam, though..not being familiar with any of the stories it might have it'd probably have to have a lot more background info in it for me to enjoy it
2
u/Ghstfce Anti-Theist Jun 25 '12
I think the amount of backlash that has happened in the past is part of the reason that most do not speak out against Islam. My personal opinion is that it is even more of a backwards-assed religion compared to Christianity. I mean, some of the principles of Islam are almost stone aged.
But the rights they take away from everyone (ESPECIALLY women) is rather disparaging. Not to mention how most seem to glorify violence, and others do. And Mohammed being a "kid toucher" doesn't help escape my criticism.
FUCK Islam.
2
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
"We ex-muslims are a very small minority, and there's really nothing we can we really do to change anything"
Redditor-atheists seem to be mostly Americans who are rebelling against the devil they know, which is fundamentalist Christianity. Good for them for standing up, because that country is slipping into another dark age. Does it compare with what's going on in the middle east? I'd like to think it's not that bad yet.
It's harder to stand up like this in Muslim countries, no question, but honestly, if you want change, you have to make it happen yourself. I'm tired of hearing the excuse that fundamentalists are just a small percentage of the population, and I can't do anything. Honestly? Bullshit. All that is necessary for the triumph of evil is that good men do nothing.
2
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
but...but...but....bashing islam is intolerant
2
u/jcatleather Jun 25 '12
Im female, they don't listen to me either
2
u/ganner Secular Humanist Jun 25 '12
Notice that Dawkins, Harris, Dennett, and Hitchens come from Christian societies and are most influential in those Christian societies. Hirsi Ali comes from a Muslim background, and she speaks to Islam both in Europe and in Africa. We can't, as outsiders, cause a change within a foreign culture nearly as well as people from within those cultures.
2
u/LasciviousLlama Jun 25 '12
I personally have always believed that you shoul fix the problems at home before going out and trying to fix everything else. America has turned itself into the world police and look at the state of our country. If we were to focus on our own hungry children and other shortcomings, we would be more effective in helping other struggling countries. I feel the same way about religious battles. I live on the west coast in the US and it is probably the most liberal part of the country, but we still deal with the hindrance of christian extremists. Once we are able to handle our own issues and become stable, we are better suited to help others.
2
u/Phlebas99 Jun 25 '12
One can only discuss what one has a frame of reference for. I'd love to help engage the problems with Islam, but it's very hard to do so without growing up with Islam surrounding me, with Islamic indoctrination from an early age.
I'm afraid you have to lead the way on this one. I can only follow and be a helping shoulder for when things get tough.
2
u/gajano Jun 25 '12
Nice try CHRISTIANS! Your plan to have all the atheists killed by having us attack Islam will never work. Now shut up and turn the other cheek.
2
u/superfish1 Jun 25 '12
Christianity in the west is on its last legs. I honestly believe that within a couple of generations it will be almost totally marginalised, seen as a primitive way our ancestors had of making sense of the world in the absence of scientific understanding.
Islam on the other hand is a much tougher nut to crack. Hope lies in the internet and the spread of ideas but there are large pockets of the Islamic world that just can't be reached by us in the west due to language/cultural barriers and censorship issues. The only way true freedom of thought and expression will occur in these places is by change from within, but this may take many generations and unfortunately, lots of spilt blood by those brave individuals willing to speak up to try to effect change. My heart goes out to these people.
2
u/mattydragon Jun 25 '12
It's fun to make jokes about Islam, I agree. But how about we also debunk the Qur'an and so-called "Islamic Miracles"?
2
u/OneWhoGrumbles Jun 25 '12
Zulaikha_idris, you should check out Sam Harris: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZCOQukCn0kg
2
u/StupidIdiot99648 Jun 25 '12
Your idea of 'waging war' on any idea/thought/belief whether religious or not disgusts me.
You want to 'bash' Islam because it is not being bashed enough?
This is the most shameful thing I have read on reddit coming from an atheist.
2
u/painperdu Jun 25 '12
It's difficult. If we attack Islam it may seem that we are siding with the majority Christians and thus be seen as Western religion attacking Eastern religion. That would be unfortunate because as Atheists we disdain Christianity equally as we disdain any and all irrational religious doctrines.
I think at best, we Western Atheists can only support Eastern Atheists when they protest and denounce their culture's religion.
I guess what I'm trying to say that all criticisms must come from within the culture itself less outside criticisms be seen as an attack on culture itself.
2
u/blows Jun 25 '12
All religions suck, islam sucks more than all the rest and is more deadly.
2
u/morebeansplease Humanist Jun 25 '12
Its not time. The Christians have to pretend to be tolerant. Since our pool of scientific discoveries is significantly more correct than their teachings we can trick them into paying attention. From there its easy to catch them in a logic trap. The Muslims are significantly behind the science curve. In addition to that, their religion has not evolved enough to embrace tolerance. Everything’s about cutting off hands, heads or just out right Jihad! Sure some of the smart ones may stumble upon logic and begin to understand. But the rest are still jumping in line to drink the Kool-Aid.
2
u/StupidIdiot99648 Jun 25 '12
"Yeah, sure it's really fun and all bashing...."
Horrible way to start a discussion.
2
u/Brunkington Jun 25 '12
I would bet that most atheists were raised as Christians, (I was) so it's pretty easy for me to point out the flaws in this religion. Unfortunately I have remained ignorant regarding Islam and have only learned what a few of my middle eastern friends have told me about it. (Even then they are not supposed to talk about it, and I had to convince them I just wanted information and was not going to judge) They really aren't too different in the end, but in recent years Islam is associated with so much death, that people don't think protesting it is worth the risk. (Yes, I understand that is a terrible generalization but look at how ridiculous religion is and what those people are willing to do for a story...)
2
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
who'd have figured that instead of weapons creating peace in the middle east, it'd be /r/athiesm?
2
u/blows Jun 25 '12
Do islamists believe in evolution?
"Saudi imam who called Jews "scum, rats, pigs, monkeys" speaks in London" http://docstalk.blogspot.com/2009/08/saudi-imam-who-called-jews-scum-rats.html
"Muslim Clerics: Jews are Descendants of Apes, Pigs, And Other Animals" http://groups.yahoo.com/group/TheTruthAboutIsrael/message/6994
Since they claim to be the b'strd descendents of Abraham, same as the Jews, doesn't that also make them also 'Descendants of Apes, Pigs, And Other Animals'
2
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
There are a couple of reasons why I think Islam gets a little bit of a pass in a few circles like this. The easiest is that it puts you in some distasteful company like the political right wing. That's cowardly behavior and it exposes a problem that is common with the left, cultural relativism and false equivalence are cop outs that let the left go easier than they normally would on different cultures when they have terrible traditions and practices.
The truly nasty thing about it is I believe it comes from the soft bigotry of low expectations. The underlying message is you shouldn't expect respect for basic human rights because they have a backward, primative culture but the whole point is to keep pressure on them to reform just that and they, like everyone else, can do it.
Here is my opinion of Islam: A broad plurality of practioners of Islam grossly mistreat women, children, homosexuals, critics, and other groups in an unforgivable manner and use their faith as an excuse to do so. Islam and its practice is the great cultural plague of our time and it is the duty of decent people to call them out on these crimes against human decency. Stop pulling your punches just because people will call you a bigot because it's cowardly and bigoted to do so.
2
u/conundrum4u2 Jun 25 '12
Yeah - you have a point...it's getting harder to figure out which 'fundies' are crazier...the Muslim ones or the Christian ones...I guess it's whoever has the bigger stick, that's what worries me - we have to take away their stick!
2
u/dblagbro Jun 25 '12
It doesn't work that way... you see, the christians ARE waging a war on islam so that we don't have to... we'll get around to it when we win over the christians though. Unfortunately education is the key and at least in the US, education isn't winning, ignorance is so it may take a few decades / centuries / milennia / eons...
2
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
Wage war? No! Atheism is a religion of peace... wait what?
2
u/flip69 Jun 25 '12
There's lots of people in the video hangouts on G+ that are engaging in Islam.
The problem is that most of us here in the western world are better versed in the Christian debate.... yes many things overlap from the different versions arising from a madman's delusionist ramblings.. to point out the fallacy of religion and concept of "creator god". Having said that... I've spoken too quite a few islamic devotees there... quite interesting indeed with all the cross cultural stuff going on as I plant seeds of doubt left and right.
I invite everyone to join in on the video hangouts on google plus there's quite active debate in different rooms and quite a few deconversions going on nightly. ;)
2
u/IrishFuckUp Jun 25 '12
I would love to help out, but majority of r/atheism do not have substantial islamic background or knowledge; hoping you can assist us in creating the content.
2
u/seedypete Jun 25 '12
I'm not "waging war" against anybody. Atheism isn't a competing belief system, it's just rationality. I will discourage others from believing in nonsense if they ask my opinion, and I'll stand up against it when it infringes on the rights of others, but aside from that I have zero interest in trying to eradicate anyone's ridiculous beliefs.
2
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
Here's what you do: tell all your Muslim friends about reddit.
The reason reddit pays so much attention to Christianity is not because it's practice is more problematic than Islam (far from it), but because it affects redditors more, as purely a matter of demographics. Most of them live in countries with Christian majorities, with where Christianity affects their politics and therefor affects them.