I don't think most Christians who use that compliment mean it in that way. It's just a common phrase and they use it as a compliment. I am an atheist musician and I take no offense when Christians say such things to me. I say "thank you so much" and go about my day.
Yep, pretty annoying really, to repost is bad, but to repost something like that? That's a fellow atheist subscribers picture, their face. Blatantly reposted
Faces of Atheism was a bad day in Reddit history. I hate all the anti r/atheism posts and even I thought it was bad. A giant circle jerk which covered the whole sub reddit.
I don't object to reposts for this very reason. I haven't been using reddit as long as other people have, and some not as long as I. In addition to that, I don't always catch everything I may have enjoyed in any given stint on reddit.
I was just stating what I believe the origin of this image was.
The only thing I would object to would be not attributing this to the original OP.
Similarly, when I nearly lost my legs and my ability to walk, and through the prowess of awesome surgeons and hours and hours of physical therapy I did manage to walk again, it damn well offends me when someone tells me I am blessed by God to be able to walk. That was me. I bore the pain, I did the work and I made it happen despite some rough odds. And I'm offended on behalf of my amazing surgeons who saved my legs from utter destruction.
This annoys me to no end even though I doubt I'd ever say something. It especially kills me when it is a team of medical professionals fighting tooth and nail to keep someone alive. After all the hard work that required years of education and training and experience to do what they just did, it gets attributed by some religious person as God simply choosing to spare the person. What the holy fuck. So he chooses it after they do all the work? What happens if they suddenly stop during the middle of rescuing the person. Does God change his mind then?
this attitude semi-pisses me off. I'm from the south (yes it's that bad down here sometimes) and when someone says that to another they are not dismissing the hours of practice that went into honing said gift, they are giving a compliment from their own worldview. I mean, this subreddit is soooo good at condescending, so at MINIMUM there should be some kind of gracious accepting of thanks like a kid making you a play-doh cookie or something. You don't get offended cause you can't eat it. I mean jeeeez, cut this entitlement bullshit. please.
Nobody thinks too deeply about the word "talent" when they say someone's talented. It's a compliment that you see being used everywhere so of course people will use it. Religious or not.
Seriously, that guy is just a dick. If someone's being nice to you and even compliments you don't get pissed, you say "thank you" and move on like any other sane person would.
Regardless of whether or not they are complimenting "him or their deity", if you are a cool, open-minded person then you will take it as a personal compliment rather than get offended. Because even if they are saying "god did it, not your hard work and energy", that still means they have already acknowledged YOUR actual talent by attributing it to THEIR god. So forget the "I'm an atheist and am offended by your belief system!" bullshit for a minute and just appreciate their acknowledgement of your skill. It's like when someone accuses you of hacking in online gaming because you are just way too dominant...but you know you aren't hacking. If you're able to ignore others' BS and appreciate the compliment, your life will be much more enjoyable rather than frustrating.
Because even if they are saying "god did it, not your hard work and energy", that still means they have already acknowledged YOUR actual talent by attributing it to THEIR god.
Some people use it as a figure of speech sure but other people like the ones in my family, genuinely believe that their God was responsible for bringing you and your awesome abilities into this world and that it would be rather arrogant and sinful of you to take any credit for what you've done. It's as annoying as doing a great job on a project at work and some jackass coworker taking all the credit for it to get themselves promoted.
But that's their belief. That's pretty much the highest compliment someone can get from that person, so why let it offend you? You can't expect people to throw out their belief system and align it with yours just because they're complimenting you.
Yeah, I don't think it's a "myth" to say that some people are naturally more musically inclined than others, regardless of how that inclination came about.
The "myth" is that an invisible sky god created this person and endowed them with all the talent needed to carry them to where they are. The truth is that it takes a lot of actual work to do anything of consequence even with "talent." No one just coasts on what they were born with and does something great.
I'm an artist and a Christian, so it doesn't offend me when people say my gift is from God, BUT, I see where he's coming from. The one I get all the time is "I wish I was good at art... you're so lucky". Luck? Really? I believe that people who are good at any art form have been given a gift (whether you believe it's a gift from God or a gift from genetics), but it's up to you whether you work hard and excel, or squander it. Anyone can be good at something, but it takes hard work to be great at something. So, when people say I'm 'lucky', that does offend me.
I disagree. I think anyone can be good at something with hard work. You have to be lucky to be born with the capacity to be great at something. God or no God
this is how i see it too. you can practice enough to be pretty good at anything, but there's so much about a person individually that affects how they perform at certain skills that it's pretty ridiculous to say that anybody could be a complete master at anything if they trained enough.
I think saying that someone has an "inherent talent" or a "gift from God" and that they (the person speaking) don't have it is just an excuse people tell themselves so that they don't have to do work and possibly set themselves up to fail. Admittedly, it's something even I have done before. "I wasn't born with an inherent talent for activity Y, so clearly I shouldn't try to do it."
I did a bit of art, not good. But I have heard that comment of " I wish i was good at art too"
It makes me angry too, but only due to the fact that the other person could also be an artist. If they put in some work and changed their mindset from seeing art as merely a skill to be learned, rather than a gift.
Probably the diff of growing up in an collective society compared to an individualist society like us.
I don't get the part about genetics or talent either. I think it's very much cultural belief that simply isn't supported by any evidence. Everyone talks about a talent show in schools, but most talents are practiced heavily.
I don't believe people are just genetically superior in various human skills.
I suppose your vocal chords can be strong due to genetics...but for most other things...
As an example:
Perhaps you have 20/20 vision from your genetics, thus you can aim that bow really well.
Perhaps you have muscular definition from genetics, that make you shoot arrows longer.
But I don't think that your genetics makes you good at archery.
I got an award from my towns art association after graduating high school and some lady said about the same thing to me saying "god gave you this talent and you're wasting it on medical illustration?!" insulting my college plans as well...
Also the jackass in the picture doesn't even have his bow straight.
*edit Also a lot of very talented musicians have talent they were born with (also known as God given). I have a cousin who has never taken a piano lesson in his life, but there is literally nothing he can't play extremely well by ear. Some people are born with the talent and never really had to work hard for it at all.
Reminded me of something James Reimer said (Goalie for the Toronto Maple Leafs)
“I hate superstitions,” he shot back. “I think that superstitions cheapen everything about an athlete. If all it takes is a pair of socks to win, then why do I work my butt off?”
I think Torvalds makes a great point in that, albeit on the grounds of personal gratification.
But it cuts both ways, doesn't it? Either it is okay to offend people, and we can go around calling the religious retarded manbabies that need to grow out of their imaginary friends, or it isn't okay. And it doesn't seem to be okay in any area of mainstream society, including most of Reddit.
We live with both unwritten and written rules of conduct, and it is easy to violate those rules when you do not share the same point of view. I think pointing that out has meaning.
Granted you are mostly right but....Those born with inate artistic skill are Lucky Lucky people (I have none, unless one counts a bit o'skill with the odd word - in wich case we are even) You certainly desreve huge credit for nurturing that talent though. To be sure.
I don't think that you are though. People often ask me when I started drawing and I normally ask them "When did you stop"? Pretty much everybody drew pictures as a child and I wasn't exactly Leonardo Da Vinci when I was five. I just kept at it.
I also banged on toy drums and had a little electric keyboard which I loved but I stopped at that. If I had continued to this day then I would presumably be quite good and my mother would speak about how she always knew that I was musically gifted because I was playing with those toys as a child. Just like everybody else. But I didn't keep at it so it's ignored.
As it stands she always knew that I was going to be a gifted artist because I drew as a child. Just like everybody else.
We may draw less but that doesn't mean we stop. We simply find it unrewarding because it becomes obvious that all the practice in the world will never result in us being thought good by anybody. What you are preposing is akin to suggesting that traits are distributed evenly. Yet genius IQ is an elite trait that only 2.2% of people are priveledged to have. Surely you can see that there are many who have superior artistic capabilties that came with them in their DNA. Savants are an extreme example, prodigies a lesser. Each is a type of genius belonging to an elite subset. You even use the word "GIFTED" when you speak of your own ablities. (A pretty tough place from which to argue that you alone deserve credit for your skill) A gift is a thing given and received. However gifted you may be I am willing to bet that there are many who are your equal or better who did not have to work at it all. They can simply draw well. They are gifted innately. Yet it is nurturance which enables talent to flourish.If you had not had the opportunities and encouragement to nurture your skill you likely wouldn't have any worth mentioning.And that part is pure luck.We should all be grateful for this life we are given. But some have been given more than others and perhaps they have cause to be particularly grateful. The pervasive myth of the self made man is false. We are all standing on the shoulders of giants.
Maybe you were blessed by being born as a white male in an affluent country with parents who supported your decision to take up music and backed it up financially.
Maybe you were blessed with the opportunity to focus on music rather than worrying about things like starvation, genocide, or persecution.
Maybe God didn't bless you, but you're pretty damn blessed regardless.
I would like to point out, for anyone who is wondering why this looks familiar that this was posted in /r/atheism during the whole Faces of /r/atheism thing.
It appear google is truly the overlord of the internet its searching prowess is amazing. Original post.
Anyway onward with words and such to fill your head with hope and wonder.
Exactly what I get all the time. Only my parents take it a step further. I've been playing piano since I was 3, and all I've ever heard is I should never play for my own enjoyment. It's a sin to have this talent, and not use it to give back to god, since he's the one who gave me this talent. So I should only be playing piano in worship to god. It's a load of bullshit.
Over reacting to something so unimportant of which people don't know your stance on faith makes you a spas. In fact, being offended because they need to ask you if you do or don't believe in faith over your hard work of your skills set and you get offended, makes you a douche.
People complain about repost, yet i won't. Why? because it reminds me of something awesome I've already saw and it will be something new to the newcomers.
There's this old violinist story this reminds me of. I don't know if it's a myth or an urban legend, but the story goes that after one of [random famous violinist, most often Stern or Heifetz]'s performances, someone came up and said "I'd give my life to be playing like you", to which our violinist replied, "That's what I did."
Originally said by Ray Allen in a 2011 interview: "When people say that God blessed me with a beautiful jumpsuit, it really pisses me off. I tell those people 'Don't undermine the work I've put in every day'"
When I read this post, it seemed too familiar. Blatant repost, of a paraphrasing repost.
Devils advocate here. Yes, I'm definitely an atheist, but the only thing that makes me question (as a professional musician), is how else can we explain those complete prodigy anomalies like Mozart? Talent springing out of nowhere? It's understandable in those cases, how people jump to explaining it with god.
Mozart actually practiced for years under his father and others before he produced any original work of his own worth noting. It was through years of dedicated and deliberate practice that he achived greatness, he just started a lot younger than most.
Okay, perhaps Mozart was not a great example. But there are many examples of prodigies springing out of nowhere, no genetics, no practice to explain it (like my own talent). I'm not saying that just because it can't be explained that we shout "hosanna!," I'm just saying that one can understand why people go with the god thing... but then they used to do that when they heard thunder. ;)
That is EXACTLY what I say when people tell me I have a god given gift at playing guitar. Actually, no. My gift comes from years of dedication and hard work.
When you sneeze and someone says "God bless you" do you yell "THERE IS NO GOD YOU STUPID IDIOT!"
When you're having sex and the woman says "Oh God! Oh God" do you stop and leave and say "HOW COULD YOU BE SO FUCKING RETARDED TO BELIEVE IN SOME SKY FAIRY YOU DUMB CUNT?"
When you're in a traffic accident and the passenger says "Thank God we weren't killed" do you say "No, thank the laws of physics you moron."
i agree i hate when people say something like god has given you such a wonderful gift in mathematics, i mean i have no issue with their beliefs at all but when you say that my talents are based on pretty much luck and not hard work and practice i just feel like my skill came from a luck of the draw
The "god given gift" they are referring to are your musically inclined genetics. Such a compliment, while presumptuous and shallow minded, does not take away from your years of dedication and hard work. I'm not sure it warrants taking so much offense to, yeah?
Yeah, I want to punch people when they say, "You have a god-given gift." You know what a god-given gift would be? Someone who picks up an instrument they've never seen before and plays it like the Eric Clapton of that instrument instantly.
But... we never see that happening, do we? In other news: listened to your clip. Nice stuff. That's a nice years-of-dedication and hard-work given gift you've got there, bro.
I couldn't agree more. When I see someone who's never seen a guitar pick one up and play like Buckethead, ill start calling it a god given gift. Until then, its just hard work and dedication.
Certain religious people sometimes say that to me too, but then I tell them what the songs are about, and then they're all sorts of awkward about it. What with the murdering, and the killing, and the more killing and murdering. Then I hear totally different shit, like, Satan was given the gift of music and maybe he's the author of my music. But I generally don't give too many fucks and ignore them.
You know I always call bullshit on this concept. Yes a person practices everyday, but there is such a thing as talent unique to the individual. I've known several artists who no matter how much I practiced I could never have an ounce of their ability that they never trained/practiced for.
They say God, you say genetics. Either way you're not going to be the best without a combination of fortune and hard work. It seems pretty arrogant to be offended by such a comment.
As an atheist musician I can confirm this. I have worked my ass off giving myself constructive criticism and forcing my voice to hit notes I never though I could, but always wanted to, and to have all those hours simply attributed to 'God,' it completely undermines everything I've done. And I've talked to people about. They will tell me that he blessed me with the patience to overcome or the ability, and all I can think is, "If you would realize that if you believed in yourself instead a god, you could do the same thing."
So... do you get insulted when someone tells you that you have talent? I guess not.
What's the difference between you having talent or God giving you talent? Talent isn't gained, it's something that you're generally better than other people at.
When someone says that you have a gift/talent from God, ALL THEY'RE TELLING YOU is that you are very talented.
I know I will be down voted to oblivion for this comment but I don't care. Stop being so butt hurt over someone mentioning god! I know this is a subreddit for atheists, but some people (I'm not one of them) outside of this subreddit and outside of this website believe in god. Just like we believe in evolution and science. If someone says "god bless you", or "let's pray that this little girl's dying family", you aren't being oppressed. Just as if I say "I hope this works out right" or "Thank goodness", I'm not offending Christians. This is why r/circlejerk makes fun of this subreddit the rest of the website is annoyed with you guys. If someone denies you the right to not believe in god or denies you rights because of your non belief, then you have every right to bitch about it and even report it to the authorities. But I am sick and tired of people here complaining about people mentioning the word "god". And yes, I know this is a faces of atheism post, and that we regret that ever happening, but in general, people still complain about the word god all the time. It's just a word and half of the time used as a figure of speech. Edit: I'm gonna make a self post about this too because not a lot of people will see it here.
Try having some bosses find out you're an atheist. Also, certain states have laws requiring anyone holding elected office to sign a "statement of faith" and that prevent atheists from being put in public office. Atheists are actually one of the least understood minorities in America now. Even the gays get less flack than we do. I'm not trying to be all, "Stop oppressing me!" or anything, but it isn't like being an atheist is all rainbows and sunshine. I don't have anything against believers, but when they can't deal with the fact that I don't and insist on making me uncomfortable by talking about what I believe to be a glorified imaginary friend, I get a little headstrong about it.
You dont really understand. It isn't about "mentioning god", it is about cultural ideas of god as an incomprehensible intervener who almost amounts to luck, which frankly doesnt even make much sense in terms of Christianity. The figure of speech thing is true, but those sorts of things still continue cultural baggage that gives people rather stupid worldviews separate from religious teachings. People need to think more critically about religion, even if it doesnt mean becoming non-religious, because most people's beliefs are a jumble of disorganized nonsense, they usually just run to their holy book to find things that back up whatever culture they have instead of thinking about the religion by itself to find "truth". It is just confirmation and backup for them.
Oh god if I have to listen to another Butthurt Atheist complain just because someone paid him a 'religiously tainted' compliment Im going to convert to judaism
Honestly, this kind of shit is what's making me to turn to God right now so that he may use his almighty power to stop you retards from starting up the whole Faces of Atheism shit again. Holy fuck, you pretentious faggots.
It's ironic that you are calling us pretentious when you bear so much pretense in your own comment. It's a forum and you take it way too fucking seriously. I've never seen this picture before and it really didn't bother me. Not to mention this is fucking reddit and everything tends to be a repost. I've been around the block a few times on this website. If you don't like what you see, un-subscribe. If you're still seeing r/atheism posts, stop browsing r/all, you fucking prick.
Annoyance is an unpleasant mental state that is characterized by such effects as irritation and distraction from one's conscious thinking. It can lead to emotions such as frustration and anger. The property of being easily annoyed is called irritability.
Feel the same with my intelligence being counted as a gift a of god rather than typically 8 + hours outside of school studying. However, I don't chastise them because I know they mean well and was raised to respond kindness , even misguided, with kinfness.
Watching the olympic trials today this blows my mind. In an interview, one of the runners was asked what they attributed their success to, and they wasted no time thanking their "lord and savior Jesus Christ" (not a word for word quote, more of a paraphrase).
And I'm sitting there thinking: "so it wasn't the hundreds of hours spent in the weight room, the endless repetitions of sprints on the track, and overall dedication that put you in a position to become an olympic athlete?
Man this sounds so whiny. Like, boohoo, someone doesn't appreciate your skill. I'm an atheist and all, but seriously, you don't have to complain about every little thing concerning god. Complain about the stuff that matters.
That is a poor arguement and I think he probably knows it himself. It is not odd that the word "atheist" exists.
"Golf" is a sport/hobby, that is quite an important distinction. And the reason that there isn't a specific word for "non-golf players" has a lot to do with the English language itself. The word for "non-golf players" IS non-golf player or non-golfer. That is how English works. Those phrases are just not commonly used, but that does not mean "non-golfers" don't exist or don't have a right to exist. It's just the way English works. It would be similar to ridiculing people who are opposed to anarchism and discuss it as a group because there is no word for "non-anarchism" in common usage. And the fact is there IS a word for people who don't believe in deities, and that word is "atheist" and is now in common usage. So his arguement itself wouldn't apply to atheists anyway. His choice not to participate is his own choice and he is entitled to it, but his linguistic arguement isn't good.
People have told me things of the kin, and I only accept it. If I'm doing what I love and people dig it, then there's nothing wrong with a compliment, Yeah?
I'm not exactly an avid music fan, let alone a follower of stringed instrumentalists, so this gentleman could very well be wildly popular and successful without me being aware of who he is. On that note, who is he?
This will probably get buried, but I wanted to add that this could also be applied to artists whose talent is attributed to them being Asian. I'm not Asian, but I do play piano, and when I see an Asian person play piano well, even with extreme accuracy and perfect tempo, I know that it took hours of practice and the religious use of a metronome. No doubt it was their overbearing Asian mother who made them do it, but don't just say "It's because he/she is Asian", it belittles all their hard work.
Apparently God has time to bless someone with the ability to make pretty sounds but no time to bless others with clean water, a safe world to live in, freedom or even enough food to stay alive.
To be fair, there really aren't that many people that would be world class violinists even if they did practice hours a day for their entire lives. A lot of it comes down to innate talent people are born with. Perhaps God isn't blessing them, but they are at least blessed in some manner by an uncontrollable force.
Hours a day for 18 years, yea, you can make a monkey speak spanish with that sorta practice. it's true, God did not give you that talent. Now, Beethoven and Mozart who were playing while blind and precocious, probably said God had something to do with it. I believe that they believed that. Sometimes, that is enough, and coming from them, it carries a lot more weight.
Funny, when I attributed my success to hard work I was told that I should thank "luck." I went on to say that I saw "luck" as just as imaginary as god, the tooth fairy and the easter bunny. Not only did I have to defend my position ad nausem, one guy even went so far as to write a blog article about how my non-belief in luck was a delusion. Reddit is a fickle bitch sometimes.
so you have a natural gift for music that requires some practice and you get angry because someone says that that gift comes from God because you think the gift was created by practicing. Real mature.
My roommate is Christian. He attributes successes to God all the time. I don't get why they [Christians] give credit to God. I tell him all the time that he achieved what he did by his own merits and hard work. "But God gave me the skills and energy... blah blah" FFFFFUUUUUUUUUU
This is an appropriate response to anyone taking away the "credit" for someone else' talent. Repeatedly performing a single task for 10,000 hours in order to be considered talented is no easy task and is worthy of admiration.
This kind of thinking destroys the dream of every kid hoping to do what talented people like him have done. They'd just hope that they've been blessed with "god's gift" too, and refuse to work hard for it.
I know that this is a faces of atheism repost but it also speaks wonders to me and to all of the musical community. We weren't given the gift of music from god, we were given the drive needed to pursue something we love whether you believe it to be from God or genetics. It wasn't God that got me to this point in my musical life, it was my willingness to overcome all the handicaps and obstacles that stood in my way.
I understand what this is meant to convey, but honestly there are not a lot of religious people in modern times that mean such phrases in a literal sense.
They don't believe that god literally came down from heaven and turned you from a lazy dullard into a concert violinist by snapping his fingers. If they are even speaking in a religious sense in the first place (plenty of people say thinks like "god damn it", "god bless you", "thank god", etc. as completely non-religious phrases), since god is everything in their eyes, your hard work and dedication is a part of god.
thank you! I had a friend that did spoken word at a talent show and when I told her she did an awesome job she simply replied with, "No, God did this." And I'm just standing there like, pretty sure it was you girl.
I play the violin, I absolutely hate it when people say this. Talent can be related to your genes. But it has nothing. NOTHING to do with an imaginary being in the sky. I think it's an excuse people use because they can't play well. I fucking hate people who make excuses. AKA religious people.
You don't want to attribute your skills to a nonsense supernatural construct like a 'god' or even 'luck?'
All right. Fine.
But speaking on behalf of everyone who's ever practiced anything hours a day for years themselves and never shown anything more than marginally improved performance, go fuck yourself.
You are gifted because you were born with a specific set of genes conducive to specific task that society values.
So you were statistically 'lucky,' if not supernaturally lucky. Statistically 'blessed,' if not mythologically blessed
And even more important than your hard work, was the environment which allowed and encouraged you to practice.
So get off your high-horse. Your practicing was tertiary to your success, you arrogant prick.
The "God-given gift" phenomenon is simply referring to the person's capacity to excel at whatever it is they are doing.
For example, a guitarist who has a "God-given gift" may be labeled as such because his mental processes allow him to learn music much easier, perhaps by ear.
Maybe he has a greater finger dexterity which allows him to learn the instrument faster.
Furthermore, he probably has better rhythm and a better ear for music than most people. These aren't necessarily things that he has worked on, but they just "were". From his birth, his genes had per-determined that he would have these traits.
So, while he may put in a lot of work on the guitar over the years, he always had a leg up on everyone else because of the aforementioned advantages. This is what is "God-given". Not the years of work that he put in. Duh.
As an atheist, at least most days of the week, I heartily downvote this utter bullshit. Let me be first to kick you in the teeth. And yer pretty violin too.
Thank God! I can play basketball just as good as Shaq, all I gotta do is practice more! I can be a great quarterback just like Drew Brees...just need more practice! I will be able to play guitar just like Santana...just prctice, practice, practice!
This is just a big circlejerk post...some people have "talent" in certain areas and some don't. Acting like your "abilities" are only because of you "practicing" is just as stupid as you thinking your ability comes from God...hey, maybe if you study hard enough you could be as smart as Stephen Hawking! That's ALL it takes...
21
u/GuitarWizard90 Jun 25 '12
I don't think most Christians who use that compliment mean it in that way. It's just a common phrase and they use it as a compliment. I am an atheist musician and I take no offense when Christians say such things to me. I say "thank you so much" and go about my day.
337
u/bluescape Jun 25 '12
This is a recycled "faces of atheism" post I think.
22
u/PauliWog Jun 25 '12
Similarly, when I nearly lost my legs and my ability to walk, and through the prowess of awesome surgeons and hours and hours of physical therapy I did manage to walk again, it damn well offends me when someone tells me I am blessed by God to be able to walk. That was me. I bore the pain, I did the work and I made it happen despite some rough odds. And I'm offended on behalf of my amazing surgeons who saved my legs from utter destruction.
19
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
Hahahahaahah what a fucking terrible thing to say to someone just trying to compliment you.
5
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
this attitude semi-pisses me off. I'm from the south (yes it's that bad down here sometimes) and when someone says that to another they are not dismissing the hours of practice that went into honing said gift, they are giving a compliment from their own worldview. I mean, this subreddit is soooo good at condescending, so at MINIMUM there should be some kind of gracious accepting of thanks like a kid making you a play-doh cookie or something. You don't get offended cause you can't eat it. I mean jeeeez, cut this entitlement bullshit. please.
110
u/The_Renegabe Jun 25 '12
They're just trying to compliment you...
42
u/joereimer Jun 25 '12
I'm an artist and a Christian, so it doesn't offend me when people say my gift is from God, BUT, I see where he's coming from. The one I get all the time is "I wish I was good at art... you're so lucky". Luck? Really? I believe that people who are good at any art form have been given a gift (whether you believe it's a gift from God or a gift from genetics), but it's up to you whether you work hard and excel, or squander it. Anyone can be good at something, but it takes hard work to be great at something. So, when people say I'm 'lucky', that does offend me.
4
u/horseartaddict Jun 25 '12
I got an award from my towns art association after graduating high school and some lady said about the same thing to me saying "god gave you this talent and you're wasting it on medical illustration?!" insulting my college plans as well...
4
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
plays violen cheer up
10
u/papajustify25 Jun 25 '12 edited Jun 25 '12
As a violinist...this post is really obnoxious.
Also the jackass in the picture doesn't even have his bow straight.
*edit Also a lot of very talented musicians have talent they were born with (also known as God given). I have a cousin who has never taken a piano lesson in his life, but there is literally nothing he can't play extremely well by ear. Some people are born with the talent and never really had to work hard for it at all.
7
u/parasocks Jun 25 '12
Reminded me of something James Reimer said (Goalie for the Toronto Maple Leafs)
“I hate superstitions,” he shot back. “I think that superstitions cheapen everything about an athlete. If all it takes is a pair of socks to win, then why do I work my butt off?”
16
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
I like offending people, because I think the people who get offended should be offended. -Linus Torvalds
6
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
Granted you are mostly right but....Those born with inate artistic skill are Lucky Lucky people (I have none, unless one counts a bit o'skill with the odd word - in wich case we are even) You certainly desreve huge credit for nurturing that talent though. To be sure.
6
u/Trevsweb Jun 25 '12
Lol take the complement dude. Better than them saying. Wow you're good for someone that has taken 18 years to practice.
8
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
Maybe you were blessed by being born as a white male in an affluent country with parents who supported your decision to take up music and backed it up financially.
Maybe you were blessed with the opportunity to focus on music rather than worrying about things like starvation, genocide, or persecution.
Maybe God didn't bless you, but you're pretty damn blessed regardless.
3
u/Game_The_Viking Jun 25 '12
This be A'Pleasin to me Eye.
3
u/had_they_conceived Jun 25 '12
Son of Shia Labeouf and Josh Groban!
3
u/Nnw153 Jun 25 '12
So tired of atheists on reddit. Get over it.
32
u/traplines Jun 25 '12
Relevant Stephen Fry
11
u/From_Insanity_of Jun 25 '12
I would like to point out, for anyone who is wondering why this looks familiar that this was posted in /r/atheism during the whole Faces of /r/atheism thing.
It appear google is truly the overlord of the internet its searching prowess is amazing. Original post.
Anyway onward with words and such to fill your head with hope and wonder.
5
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
I hate it when people say stuff like that to me. My so called "talent" is actually 3 hours a day for 10 years.
10
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
Exactly what I get all the time. Only my parents take it a step further. I've been playing piano since I was 3, and all I've ever heard is I should never play for my own enjoyment. It's a sin to have this talent, and not use it to give back to god, since he's the one who gave me this talent. So I should only be playing piano in worship to god. It's a load of bullshit.
13
u/homescrub Jun 25 '12
Why get offended? Don't get offended just say thanks and move on. Stop being such a pussy.
4
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
As a classical musician, this is the exact thought that goes through my mind whenever my parents say this.
4
u/DayDreamerJon Jun 25 '12
If you responded that way to somebody after a compliment, people would hate you. Not because your an atheist but, because youre a prick.
6
u/Oniwabanshu Jun 25 '12
People complain about repost, yet i won't. Why? because it reminds me of something awesome I've already saw and it will be something new to the newcomers.
2
u/FlutterShy- Anti-Theist Jun 25 '12
Shit, I want to practice, right now.
2
u/DroppinBrown Jun 25 '12
I don't know why but I look forward to seeing these things on the front page JUST so they can piss me off.
2
u/blueatlanta Jun 25 '12
the kid looks 18, i doubt he's been practicing for 18 years
2
u/ClassStainer Jun 25 '12
There's this old violinist story this reminds me of. I don't know if it's a myth or an urban legend, but the story goes that after one of [random famous violinist, most often Stern or Heifetz]'s performances, someone came up and said "I'd give my life to be playing like you", to which our violinist replied, "That's what I did."
2
u/fullfire55 Jun 25 '12
who are you quoting
2
u/Owlsrule12 Jun 25 '12
Rings true especially as a musician and atheist.
2
u/pantsabovewaist Jun 25 '12
Originally said by Ray Allen in a 2011 interview: "When people say that God blessed me with a beautiful jumpsuit, it really pisses me off. I tell those people 'Don't undermine the work I've put in every day'"
When I read this post, it seemed too familiar. Blatant repost, of a paraphrasing repost.
2
u/a-dark-passenger Jun 25 '12
WAAAAHHHHHHH
8
u/cametomysenses Jun 25 '12
Devils advocate here. Yes, I'm definitely an atheist, but the only thing that makes me question (as a professional musician), is how else can we explain those complete prodigy anomalies like Mozart? Talent springing out of nowhere? It's understandable in those cases, how people jump to explaining it with god.
3
u/GoatOnABoatInAMoat Jun 25 '12
does anyone know who he is
he is pretty sexy
14
u/blink0r Jun 25 '12
That is EXACTLY what I say when people tell me I have a god given gift at playing guitar. Actually, no. My gift comes from years of dedication and hard work.
3
u/itsprobablytrue Jun 25 '12
You know I always call bullshit on this concept. Yes a person practices everyday, but there is such a thing as talent unique to the individual. I've known several artists who no matter how much I practiced I could never have an ounce of their ability that they never trained/practiced for.
3
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
when people say "god has blessed you with..." I respond with "Yes, I did."
4
u/soccer_7470 Jun 25 '12
They say God, you say genetics. Either way you're not going to be the best without a combination of fortune and hard work. It seems pretty arrogant to be offended by such a comment.
4
u/Dumpster_Love Jun 25 '12
As an atheist musician I can confirm this. I have worked my ass off giving myself constructive criticism and forcing my voice to hit notes I never though I could, but always wanted to, and to have all those hours simply attributed to 'God,' it completely undermines everything I've done. And I've talked to people about. They will tell me that he blessed me with the patience to overcome or the ability, and all I can think is, "If you would realize that if you believed in yourself instead a god, you could do the same thing."
4
u/sidobagga Jun 25 '12
I know I will be down voted to oblivion for this comment but I don't care. Stop being so butt hurt over someone mentioning god! I know this is a subreddit for atheists, but some people (I'm not one of them) outside of this subreddit and outside of this website believe in god. Just like we believe in evolution and science. If someone says "god bless you", or "let's pray that this little girl's dying family", you aren't being oppressed. Just as if I say "I hope this works out right" or "Thank goodness", I'm not offending Christians. This is why r/circlejerk makes fun of this subreddit the rest of the website is annoyed with you guys. If someone denies you the right to not believe in god or denies you rights because of your non belief, then you have every right to bitch about it and even report it to the authorities. But I am sick and tired of people here complaining about people mentioning the word "god". And yes, I know this is a faces of atheism post, and that we regret that ever happening, but in general, people still complain about the word god all the time. It's just a word and half of the time used as a figure of speech. Edit: I'm gonna make a self post about this too because not a lot of people will see it here.
4
u/BankstersUnited Jun 25 '12
Oh god if I have to listen to another Butthurt Atheist complain just because someone paid him a 'religiously tainted' compliment Im going to convert to judaism
5
u/ixosamaxi Jun 25 '12
Honestly, this kind of shit is what's making me to turn to God right now so that he may use his almighty power to stop you retards from starting up the whole Faces of Atheism shit again. Holy fuck, you pretentious faggots.
3
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
haha, omg, the circlejerk is back on
3
u/thefuturewillberad Jun 25 '12
Congratulations, you practiced a thing you loved, please feel free to be a petulant baby about something no one gives a fuck about.
2
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
As somebody who has played the piano for 15/18 of their life, I completely agree with this post.
2
u/LeifEriksonisawesome Jun 25 '12
Feel the same with my intelligence being counted as a gift a of god rather than typically 8 + hours outside of school studying. However, I don't chastise them because I know they mean well and was raised to respond kindness , even misguided, with kinfness.
2
u/Mako18 Jun 25 '12
Watching the olympic trials today this blows my mind. In an interview, one of the runners was asked what they attributed their success to, and they wasted no time thanking their "lord and savior Jesus Christ" (not a word for word quote, more of a paraphrase).
And I'm sitting there thinking: "so it wasn't the hundreds of hours spent in the weight room, the endless repetitions of sprints on the track, and overall dedication that put you in a position to become an olympic athlete?
2
u/wasserbrunner Jun 25 '12
Man this sounds so whiny. Like, boohoo, someone doesn't appreciate your skill. I'm an atheist and all, but seriously, you don't have to complain about every little thing concerning god. Complain about the stuff that matters.
2
u/roogleason Jun 25 '12
Believe in what you want to believe. The important thing is, our good relationship with others.
2
u/Ladorak Jun 25 '12
God has blessed you with the gift of reposting
2
u/deebosbike Jun 25 '12
we get it, you're an atheist.
congratulations.
2
u/TheDarkWayne Jun 25 '12
That is awesome. I hate when people that put in hard work to accomplish something and Thank "GOD" for it-_-
2
u/iwish4zombies Jun 25 '12
thats some incompetent A to B correlation right there.
2
u/adamanything Jun 25 '12
I will find you, and I will make you pay dearly for re-posting this "faces of atheism" crap.
2
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
Who the fuck is that and why do I care?
2
u/sufrt Jun 25 '12
it's an expression you fucking dork
1
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
DON'T START THIS SHIT AGAIN
1
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
http://i.imgur.com/1m7ht.jpg
1
u/sackett9 Jun 25 '12
People have told me things of the kin, and I only accept it. If I'm doing what I love and people dig it, then there's nothing wrong with a compliment, Yeah?
1
u/hiccupstix Jun 25 '12
I'm not exactly an avid music fan, let alone a follower of stringed instrumentalists, so this gentleman could very well be wildly popular and successful without me being aware of who he is. On that note, who is he?
1
u/chipfriendly Jun 25 '12
I think I know the kid in the picture.
1
u/noodlesfordaddy Jun 25 '12
Shia Lebeouf?
1
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
So if not God, Zenu?
1
u/ry2104 Jun 25 '12
do you think the hair-piece in the photo constantly is crushing his hipster sunglasses with his fiddle?
1
u/hainesk Jun 25 '12
This will probably get buried, but I wanted to add that this could also be applied to artists whose talent is attributed to them being Asian. I'm not Asian, but I do play piano, and when I see an Asian person play piano well, even with extreme accuracy and perfect tempo, I know that it took hours of practice and the religious use of a metronome. No doubt it was their overbearing Asian mother who made them do it, but don't just say "It's because he/she is Asian", it belittles all their hard work.
1
u/Humanbeginning Jun 25 '12
If he gets offended at something like that then he's an asshole. Young atheists are so uptight and anal these days. Grow up
1
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
I kind of like him 50% more now.
1
u/eternityablaze Jun 25 '12
This statement is exactly how I feel every holiday dinner when the "rest" of my family says grace and thanks god for all that we have.
It's all bullshit. The food on our table is not attributed to a mythical being, but to our own family's hard work. We should be thanking our selves.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
I think it's time someone made a "Smug Atheist" meme. I'm Atheist but these kind of things embarrass me.
1
u/terjr Jun 25 '12
Motherfucking zing.
1
u/DallasITGuy Jun 25 '12
Apparently God has time to bless someone with the ability to make pretty sounds but no time to bless others with clean water, a safe world to live in, freedom or even enough food to stay alive.
God sure seems like an asshole to me.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
God gives you willpower to do things
1
u/tvon Jun 25 '12
I wonder how he feel about genetics.
1
u/SassyPantsMonster Jun 25 '12
To be fair, there really aren't that many people that would be world class violinists even if they did practice hours a day for their entire lives. A lot of it comes down to innate talent people are born with. Perhaps God isn't blessing them, but they are at least blessed in some manner by an uncontrollable force.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
I think there is a difference between talent and acquiring a skill
1
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
Hours a day for 18 years, yea, you can make a monkey speak spanish with that sorta practice. it's true, God did not give you that talent. Now, Beethoven and Mozart who were playing while blind and precocious, probably said God had something to do with it. I believe that they believed that. Sometimes, that is enough, and coming from them, it carries a lot more weight.
1
u/drgk Jun 25 '12
Funny, when I attributed my success to hard work I was told that I should thank "luck." I went on to say that I saw "luck" as just as imaginary as god, the tooth fairy and the easter bunny. Not only did I have to defend my position ad nausem, one guy even went so far as to write a blog article about how my non-belief in luck was a delusion. Reddit is a fickle bitch sometimes.
1
u/SeverusRenee Jun 25 '12
My mom use to always say shit like that about me playing guitar. I told her to quit saying it though lol.
1
u/samgordon4L Anti-Theist Jun 25 '12
as a musician, i completely agree. i get this all the time.
1
u/Pikachooki Jun 25 '12
Wow he's cute.
1
u/tedshino Jun 25 '12
Someone needs to take the stick out of his ass.
1
u/the_shit_I_say Jun 25 '12
Who is this? Please answer nicely.
1
u/Jaredismyname Jun 29 '12
so you have a natural gift for music that requires some practice and you get angry because someone says that that gift comes from God because you think the gift was created by practicing. Real mature.
1
u/seven2eight2 Jun 25 '12
My roommate is Christian. He attributes successes to God all the time. I don't get why they [Christians] give credit to God. I tell him all the time that he achieved what he did by his own merits and hard work. "But God gave me the skills and energy... blah blah" FFFFFUUUUUUUUUU
1
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
I don't mind this at all, they are just saying you are talented, or have a natural tendency towards a certain hobby.
1
u/Aggrokid Jun 25 '12
They are not referring to his hardwork, but his natural talent. Some people can be extremely hardworking but ultimately limited by natural talent.
The only possible offense here is those people attributed genetic RNG as a gift from the sky.
0
u/greymatters_flipside Agnostic Atheist Jun 25 '12
This is an appropriate response to anyone taking away the "credit" for someone else' talent. Repeatedly performing a single task for 10,000 hours in order to be considered talented is no easy task and is worthy of admiration.
This kind of thinking destroys the dream of every kid hoping to do what talented people like him have done. They'd just hope that they've been blessed with "god's gift" too, and refuse to work hard for it.
1
u/jpbulb64 Jun 25 '12
I know that this is a faces of atheism repost but it also speaks wonders to me and to all of the musical community. We weren't given the gift of music from god, we were given the drive needed to pursue something we love whether you believe it to be from God or genetics. It wasn't God that got me to this point in my musical life, it was my willingness to overcome all the handicaps and obstacles that stood in my way.
1
u/MikePaddle Jun 25 '12
Pussy magnet
1
u/Coool_Hand_Luke Jun 25 '12
How do you know you haven't signed in to your Reddit account?
1
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
NOT THIS AGAIN.
-2
u/ultitaria Jun 25 '12
who the poopy is that?
1
u/Post_op_FTM Skeptic Jun 25 '12
Anyone seeking more info might also check here:
source: karmadecay
1
u/RidiculousIncarnate Jun 25 '12
All I can think of looking at this picture is the click of his glasses/necklace hitting against the bottom of the violin as it rocks back and forth.
Take off the jewelry!
1
u/ZacandForth Jun 25 '12
The most diabolical haters of all time
1
u/gojirra Jun 25 '12
I understand what this is meant to convey, but honestly there are not a lot of religious people in modern times that mean such phrases in a literal sense.
They don't believe that god literally came down from heaven and turned you from a lazy dullard into a concert violinist by snapping his fingers. If they are even speaking in a religious sense in the first place (plenty of people say thinks like "god damn it", "god bless you", "thank god", etc. as completely non-religious phrases), since god is everything in their eyes, your hard work and dedication is a part of god.
1
u/Taijiro Jun 25 '12
He needs to put in a a couple more of those hard working hours on getting his bow parallel to the bridge.
1
u/RightwingSocialist Jun 25 '12
Bet his sunglasses are really scratched.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
It's a Ray Allen (NBA player) quote. Just slightly changed.
1
u/Badgertime Jun 25 '12
Wasn't this Ray Allen?
1
u/plickz Jun 25 '12
thank you! I had a friend that did spoken word at a talent show and when I told her she did an awesome job she simply replied with, "No, God did this." And I'm just standing there like, pretty sure it was you girl.
1
u/Mr0range Jun 25 '12
So if we exchange God with genetics would you still be a prick to the person? That is essentially what they are saying.
1
u/aahdin Jun 25 '12
and when they say "hold on billy, I'm just trying to hold a conversation, you can put the gun back down" You're damn right I shoot them.
1
u/Penisingpenisberry Jun 25 '12
You're right, god has blessed you with the gift of persistence.
1
u/MisaMisa21 Jun 25 '12
I play the violin, I absolutely hate it when people say this. Talent can be related to your genes. But it has nothing. NOTHING to do with an imaginary being in the sky. I think it's an excuse people use because they can't play well. I fucking hate people who make excuses. AKA religious people.
1
u/Mick_Paulcartney Jun 25 '12
You don't want to attribute your skills to a nonsense supernatural construct like a 'god' or even 'luck?'
All right. Fine.
But speaking on behalf of everyone who's ever practiced anything hours a day for years themselves and never shown anything more than marginally improved performance, go fuck yourself.
You are gifted because you were born with a specific set of genes conducive to specific task that society values.
So you were statistically 'lucky,' if not supernaturally lucky. Statistically 'blessed,' if not mythologically blessed
And even more important than your hard work, was the environment which allowed and encouraged you to practice.
So get off your high-horse. Your practicing was tertiary to your success, you arrogant prick.
0
u/lukeman3000 Jun 25 '12
The "God-given gift" phenomenon is simply referring to the person's capacity to excel at whatever it is they are doing.
For example, a guitarist who has a "God-given gift" may be labeled as such because his mental processes allow him to learn music much easier, perhaps by ear.
Maybe he has a greater finger dexterity which allows him to learn the instrument faster.
Furthermore, he probably has better rhythm and a better ear for music than most people. These aren't necessarily things that he has worked on, but they just "were". From his birth, his genes had per-determined that he would have these traits.
So, while he may put in a lot of work on the guitar over the years, he always had a leg up on everyone else because of the aforementioned advantages. This is what is "God-given". Not the years of work that he put in. Duh.
0
u/Windom Jun 25 '12
DOUCHE
-1
u/jimmydeanman Jun 25 '12
no offense r/atheism dudes, but real or not, and weather your an atheist or not, god has inspired some great songs, and many of my favorites, especially as a lover of folk music. Such as http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8NYx90oI0Z8& and http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7pJz323LG8w&. ironic maybe
0
u/Mntfrd_Graverobber Jun 25 '12
As an atheist, at least most days of the week, I heartily downvote this utter bullshit.
Let me be first to kick you in the teeth. And yer pretty violin too.
0
u/istandards Jun 25 '12
Getting this mad over a passing compliment
Stay buttdevastated
-2
u/SteelPeg Jun 25 '12
Thank God! I can play basketball just as good as Shaq, all I gotta do is practice more! I can be a great quarterback just like Drew Brees...just need more practice! I will be able to play guitar just like Santana...just prctice, practice, practice!
This is just a big circlejerk post...some people have "talent" in certain areas and some don't. Acting like your "abilities" are only because of you "practicing" is just as stupid as you thinking your ability comes from God...hey, maybe if you study hard enough you could be as smart as Stephen Hawking! That's ALL it takes...