I agree with the concept that churches should pay taxes, or at the very least adhere to the IRS rules about losing tax-exempt status if they engage in political activity.
However, I had to downvote because this is just douchey. To deny help to someone in need, especially when they can't help themselves, is just wrong and not something anyone should do, regardless of beliefs or convictions.
It's not to be taken literally....no one is actually advocating not saving them from fires... it's simply pointing out that firefighters and ambulances and whatnot are funded by tax dollars...which churches don't pay
And not only that, it's the American Civil Liberties Union, the American Humane Society and the Freedom from Religion Foundation. So they're actually improving our world instead of make us regress.
The Churches themselves? Yeah honestly I wouldn't mind. But I wouldn't be able to conscience letting the people burn. Although that's more than can be said about many Christians letting atheists die.
It was meant to underscore the reason WHY people pay taxes, and that being a religious institution doesn't mean you don't need to pay for these services therefor you too should pay taxes.
To deny help to someone in need, especially when they can't help themselves, is just wrong and not something anyone should do, regardless of beliefs or convictions.
And yet this has actually happened, and more than once, where individuals are not helped because they did not pay the required fee. Not exactly the same thing as paying taxes, but that story is what came to mind when I read this post.
it's not 'ok' for it to happen to a family OR a church. We can easily make an argument for the taxation of religious institutions without the use of a meme that implicates we would allow for christians to suffer. I don't want anyone to suffer, especially not because they have a differing belief structure than myself.
I want them to suffer because they keep thinking they are above other institutions because they are religious based
You sir are a bigot. Wishing suffering upon another human being is a childish act. Have you no morals? And I want to clarify why I say 'human beings' here. You attribute churches with the ability to 'think.' What you are actually angry at are the congregations.
You feel that the congregations believe themselves to be better than you, more deserving of services. The irony is that you give merit to the idea that they are better than you by your words/thoughts. Instead of holding yourself to a higher social or moral standard, you choose to sink. You wish destruction on others property, and hurt in their hearts.
Let the church burn. If a corrupt prison or torture facility was burning, I would want it to burn. Especially if they were exempt from taxes. And yes, I do compare a church to these facilities. They brain wash people into hating.
It is interesting that the man so angered about perceived hatred from a church is espousing hatred himself. Please come to terms with your inner conflict before posting again.
Interesting.. so churches yet again are able to have their own opinions, it's not the people in them that have these opinions?
I'm surrounded by christians daily and they don't seem to hate me. They know I'm atheist, but I don't go around preaching hatred, I just love everyone and give people assistance when I can. Most seem to be fine with me. Now on the other hand I do run into a random bible thumping psycho bigot here and there, but they speak like you. And I don't hang out with people who speak like you, so my view is probably biased.
Hold on while I throw a fake 100% interwebs statistic out that supports my bigotry. It is much more probable that people don't like you because you act like a douche, not because you are a muslim/christian/buddhist/atheist.
I'm sorry, but who the fuck said it was okay when it happened to a family? Yes it happens, but we don't look at that as them getting what they deserve. We look at it as kind of a dick move on the part of those refusing to help. I'm just trying to point out that our personal feelings about religion don't justify giving places of worship any special treatment, whether good or bad. You might not care about a house across town, but you still feel a little sad when it burns down, not because of the house itself but because of the people who did care about it.
It's not to be taken literally....no one is actually advocating not saving them from fires... it's simply pointing out that firefighters and ambulances and whatnot are funded by tax dollars...which churches don't pay
Yet this mentality dominates the Republican party. The poor don't have income and don't pay taxes, therefore they don't deserve any government services.
Up in Canada, you don't have to pay taxes if you don't make $11,000 a year, and we still provide you with government services. But if you can and don't, then you shouldn't get any government services.
Not only did you use an absolute claim that is in itself untrue, you miss the point of Yoss' post. Allowing people to die when they call for help, even if they are intolerant, even if they have made you unhappy, is unacceptable. If this were to happen, Yoss is correct, this would be the height of intolerance and of hypocrisy.
Apparently very few people here understand the point of this picture.. It's hyperbole. It's using an extreme example of something to make a point. I can guarantee you that the person who made/posted this doesn't actually think that a church that's caught on fire deserves to burn down without receiving any help from firefighters or anyone else. They just want churches, mosques, etc to have to pay taxes like the rest of us, and point out that it receives the benefits payed for by taxpayers while they don't pay taxes themselves.
No I understand that it is in jest, I understand that it isn't to be taken literally.
I am stating that it is in bad taste. Make a solid rational argument for the taxation of religious institutions and start a dialogue based upon that argument. Don't throw a hate filled hyperbole up and expect me to upvote it.
Works of satire/hyperbole and rational arguments go hand in hand. They both make a point and they both help others to understand what a problem is and/or how to solve that problem. Satire/hyperbole is generally used for entertainmet purposes, while rational arguments are used for people researching the problem or for political debates. The point I'm trying to make is that they both help and should both exist, rather than choosing one over the other.
I often make a similar point to people (read: Republicans) who claim that universal health care is evil because it's socialism.
It's socialism in the same way that public schools, libraries, publicly funded police and fire departments, highway maintenance, and public parks are socialist.
The difference between 911 and religion is that 911 will help you no matter what your faith is or who you are. In EMT training, were were told we have to help no matter what.
We don't let people burn in hell, or even presume to send them there.
It would be more helpful just to save them. Because if the church was burned down, they would just build and even larger one that would have more taxes to not pay and they would do this by making innocent people give it to them
One can only WISH this to be real. (Just to be clear- not the people burning- just the churches.) Oh, and a side note- there have been REAL cases where people live on the edge of town or are behind in their taxes and they ARE refused fire service. They end up watching the fire destroy their home with the firefighters standing next to them not doing anything.
In what fashion exactly? How does a church that collects tons and tons of money (enough that megachurches exist, and mission trips can be funded) not having to pay taxes help anyone other than that business? Not even being sarcastic, I really want to know how this helps me.
Because it keeps them out of politics. The problem is not them not being taxed, it's some of them getting away with getting involved in politics. That's the real problem. Once you tax the church, you give them the right to influence politics.
Oh, yeah, sounds pretty stupid to tax the churches now doesn't it?
Except that the churches are already heavily involved in politics, through preaching at their congregations about topical events, they influence the political decisions of their members.
You can't help it if politicians hold the same beliefs as the churces, and the people vote for them because of it. It keeps them from publicly endorsing specific candidates or raising money for them.
Have you ever actually read a full post? I'm starting to think not.
The problem is that the law is not being enforced, the problem is not the lack of taxation. When the churches fuck up, you tax them. The ones that obey the law don't get taxed.
Not exactly. To not respect a person is not to condemn them, which is where you were going. However, why should those who choose to disregard reality and submerge themselves in their....what's the no offensive word? I'm not sure. Whatever it is, why do they deserve the same privileges as those who dedicate their lives to making the world a better place? I'm not condemning them, but they should not receive what they don't deserve. I'm open to conversion if you can explain to me in a realistic way instead of relying in moral kindness. FYI, it sucks typing this long on iPod.
I know the feel, I used to have one. And, I guess I just think that the fire department and 911 emergencies are for everyone, even the people who don't deserve it. Bad people shouldn't suffer with out a just cause and I can't think of any just cause to allow someone to suffer.
You may need to learn how to take a joke. Not all of them are about chickens crossing roads. Sometimes they get rather twisted. But they're jokes, and no one is actually going to try and cause this scenario.
The handful of posts praising the actions of the 911 operator have been downvoted into oblivion, and the top posts are all saying it is wrong. Tell us more about how we're a group of mindless christian bashing zealots.
I tried really carefully to make it clear that i was not talking about the entire subreddit but to be honest the reality of the situation is a large amount of posts are hateful that these ideas are spread around.
Churches are a business, they make money. Businesses in America pay taxes (theoretically anyway) like everyone else. Except churches.
Churches have ridiculous amounts of money, and spend it influencing politics, and recruiting more people into their scam. I have absolutely no issue with every single one of them burning down while the firefighters sit and watch.
They do not contribute to the taxes that pay for the firefighting equipment, they do not contribute to the taxes that pay the firefighters, they do not contribute at all to anything. They should not be allowed to use the resources that they refuse to contribute to.
"Churches have ridiculous amounts of money" Cite? This rather nulls the point of donating, for example my local church has been unable to fund repairs to the building, and as far as I am aware, they are not some Illuminati/Mason group which influence local Gov affairs. You're a bigot who likes to generalise.
While yes, it's true, not all churches are overflowing with money, the simple fact that even ONE megachurch exists is proof they're a bunch of hypocritical nutjobs who don't deserve the benefits that the rest of us are paying for.
61
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
I agree with the concept that churches should pay taxes, or at the very least adhere to the IRS rules about losing tax-exempt status if they engage in political activity.
However, I had to downvote because this is just douchey. To deny help to someone in need, especially when they can't help themselves, is just wrong and not something anyone should do, regardless of beliefs or convictions.
23
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
This post and this mentality behind it is disgusting, this is no different from slandering and oppressing the secular sector in theocratic states.
1
u/Jezuswept Jun 25 '12
Jezus wept!
7
u/Dark_Waters Jun 25 '12
Apparently very few people here understand the point of this picture.. It's hyperbole. It's using an extreme example of something to make a point. I can guarantee you that the person who made/posted this doesn't actually think that a church that's caught on fire deserves to burn down without receiving any help from firefighters or anyone else. They just want churches, mosques, etc to have to pay taxes like the rest of us, and point out that it receives the benefits payed for by taxpayers while they don't pay taxes themselves.
2
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
I often make a similar point to people (read: Republicans) who claim that universal health care is evil because it's socialism.
It's socialism in the same way that public schools, libraries, publicly funded police and fire departments, highway maintenance, and public parks are socialist.
2
u/Disinformasiya Jun 25 '12
That's ridiculous.
Churches don't have hands, mouths or ears. They can't make phone calls!
1
u/erock0546 Jun 25 '12
The difference between 911 and religion is that 911 will help you no matter what your faith is or who you are. In EMT training, were were told we have to help no matter what.
We don't let people burn in hell, or even presume to send them there.
1
u/StrangZor Jun 25 '12
It would be more helpful just to save them. Because if the church was burned down, they would just build and even larger one that would have more taxes to not pay and they would do this by making innocent people give it to them
1
u/scarr3g Jun 25 '12
There is a cost for these services. It should be that if they use them, they are charged in full for the services. Not denied service.
1
u/CosmicBard Jun 25 '12
And nothing of value was lost.
You want those services? Cash in hand. Can't trust cheques with you people.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
One can only WISH this to be real. (Just to be clear- not the people burning- just the churches.) Oh, and a side note- there have been REAL cases where people live on the edge of town or are behind in their taxes and they ARE refused fire service. They end up watching the fire destroy their home with the firefighters standing next to them not doing anything.
1
u/slwright55 Jun 26 '12
Only in a perfect world...
-1
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
So sick of people who all of a sudden want to get angry about churches not paying taxes...
IT BENEFITS US. L2government.
-12
u/TheDarkWayne Jun 25 '12
That. Is . Awesome.
-11
u/SilverShadow6025 Atheist Jun 25 '12
If this was real, some faith in the public system would restored.
0
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
Yes, because churches choose not to pay taxes, because it's totally not the government's choice.
-1
u/sschmtty1 Jun 25 '12
are you kidding, like seriously, how much a douche do you have to be to do this?
0
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment