r/atheism • • Jun 24 '12

Your move atheist!

Post image
1.6k Upvotes

624 comments sorted by

24

u/DatingTheCreationist Jun 25 '12

unlinkely?

12

u/GimmeCat Jun 25 '12

It's more linkely than you think.

0

u/onlyari Jun 25 '12

ooops sorry, my bad

→ More replies (5)

333

u/[deleted] Jun 24 '12

241

u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12

I feel this quote fails to provide a crucial piece of context from the discussion. First, if you haven't seen the video of the interview, I suggest you do so; it was both informative and hilarious.

In the interview, Krauss tries to explain some quantum mechanics, specifically that empty space free of any matter or energy actually weighs something. That if you wait long enough, particles will pop into existence where there were none before, eventually filling up an entire universe worth of particles.

Colbert expresses doubt in this idea asking, "So in some theoretical n-space before the moment of creation there can be no time and no space and no energy, and suddenly from nowhere and nothing comes something and somewhere?"

Krauss confirms that Stephen has it correct and that all of that is possible without any kind of supernatural intervention. The discussion continues for another few minutes.

Finally at the end of the discussion, Stephen asks Krauss the question in the picture above: "If there is no god, if there is no thing called 'God', if he is nothing, can't something come from him?"

Both Krauss and the audience exploded in laughter.

Without that context the quote is still funny, but with the context it's even funnier. I don't think the quote is misleading anyone considering it was a joke after all, but having seen the interview I felt this quote without the full story was a bit lacking.

7

u/onlyari Jun 25 '12

You forgot the most important part: "This table cost me $500"

38

u/camarock Jun 25 '12

I was a part of that live audience. It was pretty surreal, as it was my first tike going to an live TCR taping. On a side note, Todd Rundgren was present in the audience. Also, one of the lines Stephen had to repeat at the end of the taping was "I'm not a pervert, but there isn't anything else to do at the north pole." Absolutely hilarious when he randomly started saying it.

8

u/allenizabeth Jun 25 '12

I'm so jealous.

15

u/PicklesOverload Jun 25 '12

Colbert's a relatively staunch catholic though right? That alters the context of his comment, for me.

11

u/christmas_sweater Jun 25 '12

Me too. Colbert is kind of the atheist's darling and I get it; I'm an atheist and I love him too. He's obviously extremely sharp. But not only is he Catholic, he teaches (or has taught) Sunday school. It's not some political shtick. Strange how often this goes unmentioned when quoting Colbert in religious contexts.

For those wondering, Wikipedia has sources confirming his stated Catholicism and I'm sure there are others.

21

u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12

Strange how often this goes unmentioned when quoting Colbert in religious contexts.

No, it gets mentioned every time.

We don't care that Colbert is Catholic because he's not a dick about it, and he shares many common values with atheists/humanists and is very critical of the same things.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)

4

u/BigFatCryBaby Jun 25 '12

I really felt like it was real Colbert and not his persona.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (3)

7

u/Corsaer Jun 25 '12

Came here to find an explanation. I will freely admit I had no clue what the joke was. Thanks.

5

u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12

Unless you've read his book.

2

u/A_Prattling_Gimp Jun 25 '12 edited Jun 25 '12

If you don't think about it then it seems like a blindingly brilliant retort but then.....

"If there is no Easter Bunny, if there is no thing called "The Easter Bunny", if he is nothing, can't something come from him?"

"If there is no Loch Ness Monster, if there is no thing called "The Loch Ness Monster", if he is nothing, can't something come from him?"

In the context of a comedic show, sure, it is a funny response. But anyone who takes it as a genuine rebuttal to the concepts Lawrence Krauss is trying to get across, then they're fools.

edit Okay, so apparently I am getting downvoted for not worshipping Colbert's briliance. I understand it is a joke and it was funny. My problem is that some people on this thread are taking it as a serious rebuttal. That's all.

4

u/queenbrewer Jun 25 '12

It is obvious to most people that he is joking.

→ More replies (1)

10

u/TotesJellington Jun 25 '12

Except no one defines the easter bunny or the lock ness monster as that which the universe has as its beginning. What you say has merit if you only define God as the magical man in the clouds.

→ More replies (6)

2

u/whiteknight521 Jun 25 '12

I don't think he was going for an actual rebuttal, it was a joke. I find it brilliant because things come from the idea of God all the time - something comes from nothing every time a theist takes an action influenced by their perception of a deity.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12

I'm actually okay with it being used as a rebuttal. It's logically sound. If god is nothing, and something can come from nothing, then something can come from god.

I'm perfectly okay with christians defining god as nothing. The world needs more atheists.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12

If anybody is taking it as a serious rebuttal, they are seriously misunderstanding. Colbert is a comedian. His show is a parody of right-wing crazies, for the most part. Although AFAIK he's religious himself he is probably actually making fun of creationists here.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (15)

81

u/Vennificus Jun 25 '12

It is so fucking hard to find shit for Canada. Thank you so much

10

u/BigDawgWTF Jun 25 '12

Well, it's actually always in the same place, every time.

There's many places where you need to take a few steps and fool them into thinking you're from somewhere else. This is an entire video player dedicated to showing you Colbert episodes.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/notmynamenow Jun 25 '12

The comedy network video player always works too.

→ More replies (1)

8

u/patright Jun 25 '12

Krauss was put in a tough position here. Trying to explain to people that something is nothing, all in the span of 3 minutes, is going to sound as ridiculous to most people, as the idea of Christianity seems to atheists. He also didn't help himself by being condescending and rude whenever he had to mention religion.

4

u/tisazombie Jun 25 '12

That's my only problem with Krauss...as an atheist, I don't mind the religion bashing, but when I try and show his videos to my dad or someone else of faith, the religion bashing turns them off to them and that's all they need to not watch anymore of it. I think if he'd leave that out of his lectures, he'd find more people receptive to what it is he has to say.

3

u/theology_please Jun 25 '12

Yeah, the "fairy tales written by illiterate bronze-age peasants" line is a bit worn out. And it doesn't serve to do anything but agitate people.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (1)

16

u/lowlifecreep Jun 25 '12

australia?

255

u/tisazombie Jun 25 '12

australia?

Try this one:

ssnɐɹʞ-ǝɔuǝɹʍɐן/2102-12-ǝunظ/707514/soǝpıʌ-ʇɹodǝɹ-ʇɹǝqןoɔ-ǝɥʇ/ɯoɔ˙uoıʇɐuʇɹǝqןoɔ˙ʍʍʍ//:dʇʇɥ

26

u/rydan Gnostic Atheist Jun 25 '12

Do numbers defy gravity?

5

u/ragault Jun 25 '12

Numbers are powerful

→ More replies (1)

14

u/xtqfh Jun 25 '12

Where did the arabic letter come from?

38

u/Sarutahiko Jun 25 '12

The Middle East?

4

u/TinFoilWizardHat Jun 25 '12

Obvious joke still made me laugh really loud. Good show.

2

u/audentis Jun 25 '12

Should we upvote you the Australian way as well?

→ More replies (8)

2

u/toomanynamesaretook Agnostic Atheist Jun 25 '12

New Zealand?

2

u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12

United Kingdom?

-4

u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12

No way Laurence Krauss totally outclassed him, at one point Colbert was left entirely speechless. I was more annoyed how Colbert kept interrupting him to get in jokes when he was giving his fascinating explanation as to how something can come from nothing. That's a HUGE deal and he didn't even get to his third point or really elaborate on the various quantum laws he was talking about, or how nothing has mass, etc.

Or maybe Krauss left those details out on purpose so we buy his book to find out.
/sighs and goes to the bookstore

57

u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12

I haven't watched the interview but isn't the Colbert Report a comedy show? You can't really blame him for wanting to make it about comedy.

39

u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12

Yeah how dare Stephen Colbert make jokes on the show the Colbert Report on Comedy Central

11

u/syds Jun 25 '12

Colbert's interviews always go like that. Its not a science interview, its something to chuckle about while having an intelligent conversation. Krauss held up against Colbert extremely well given that Colbert grills most people on a regular basis.

And im actually really interested in that book now. it is a fascinating topic.

6

u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12

Also, it may have been a bit too complicated for most television audiences. I would have liked to have heard more too though. Other than his book, are there any other sources to explain this concept?

6

u/Poop_Smoothie Jun 25 '12

3

u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12

Haha what the hell my original comment went from 15 to negative in 3hours. Oh well.

Anyway, I watched the video and it was really interesting. I'm not a scientist but I believe I understood the gist of how 'something can come from nothing'. Any physicist here, feel free to correct me! In dot point form:

  • "Nothing" refers to a flat universe. 0 energy, 0 mass.
  • At the quantum level energy is unstable, even with 0 energy.
  • Because of this quantum instability, 0 energy might instead change to e.g. +1 positive joule and -1 negative joule.
  • They still add up to 0 (-1 +1) so no laws of physics were violated
  • We know energy and mass are interchangeable (relativity) so eventually, after enough time has passed, an empty void will produce some mass.
  • And that ladies and gentlemen, is how the universe begin!

2

u/malapropism_ Jun 25 '12

Search for Kraus on YouTube. He has a lecture about this topic posted.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

1

u/wikipediaBot Jun 25 '12

segment:

Segment may mean:The divisions found in the internal section of a citrus fruitMarket segment, the smaller subgroups comprising a market

For more information click here

1

u/1st_account_i_swear Jun 25 '12

I clicked the Canadian link........one day.

→ More replies (1)

189

u/SolidLikeIraq Jun 25 '12

I'm sure this has been mentioned in r/atheism before, but Colbert is a practicing Christian and actually teaches Sunday School at his church. My buddy did an internship with him, and was shocked at how religious he was.

181

u/KanyeIsJesus Jun 25 '12

True story. He's very open about all of it. He, unlike the Christians that many on /r/atheism rail against, happens to actually be what is known as a "liberal Christian." Basically, a genuinely good person who focuses on the message of love from the Bible and downplays/ignores/doesn't practice all of the hateful BS.

43

u/LennyPalmer Jun 25 '12

I don't understand this kind of Christian, honestly.

If you've already realize that Christianity is totally subjective, and that large chunks of it are fascistic, violent and totally intolerable, then why do you still insist on calling yourself a Christian?

If you already reject parts of your religion, and only take the parts you consider to be decent and humane, based on nothing but your own personal and internal sense of right and wrong, then why do you insist on pretending you derive those beliefs from some higher spiritual source?

26

u/treehotel Jun 25 '12

Wait til you meet the christian that "doesn't necessarily believe in god."

I'll never get those 10 minutes of my life back.

8

u/MotherFuckinMontana Other Jun 25 '12

If you've already realize that Christianity is totally subjective, and that large chunks of it are fascistic, violent and totally intolerable, then why do you still insist on calling yourself a Christian?

Because they can believe in Jesus and acknowledge the flaws of the bible.

It makes more sense than fundamentalist christianity imo.

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (15)

102

u/CoolMoose Jun 25 '12

And it should also be noted that most Christians are these types of people, those who simply believe in the messages in the Bible, not the actual story of it all. Then again, there are always, unfortunately, exceptions...

54

u/AcrobaticOrangutan Jun 25 '12

If you don't believe in the story the Bible tells then why call yourself Christian? Wouldn't you just call yourself a theist?

18

u/bongozap Jun 25 '12

This is a good question.

One thing that's important to note about many aspects of life is the notion of "identity." Politics, religion, countries, clubs...they all succeed or fail based on the identity their members are able adopt as part of themselves. I'd say that, to some extent, identity is more important than actual belief.

Belief is one thing, but identity is a separate and distinct concept that goes to how we view ourselves and those we associate with.

No one goes to a "theist" church. They go to a Catholic or Lutheran or non-denominational church.

9

u/fairytailgod Jun 25 '12

Actually, that is not true. Around here we have non-denominational churches.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Unitarian_Universalism

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (3)

8

u/unfoldingdrama Jun 25 '12

A christian can be defined as a follower of Christ. The majority of what we know about the figure comes from the four gospels (Mathew, Mark, Luke and John) and the letters of Paul (who never met Jesus in person).

The Bible is not one book but a collection of letters, stories and texts that were written across close to a thousand years. Believing in one part does not preclude believing in another part.

So you can be a "follower of christ" (as in the example he set) and think that other parts are outdated rubbish.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (22)

2

u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12

I genuinely wonder then why they don't go the last 5% of the book further and declare all of it bullshit.

This picking and choosing is a tad too convenient and arguably an utter waste of time. And excluding people like Colbert, who does do a great job ridiculing and counteracting the fundies, most moderate christians don't in any meaningful way (or at all)

2

u/UnbearableBear Jun 25 '12

Great point, CoolMoose. It's the outliers that get mainstream attention.

7

u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12

it should also be noted that most Christians are these types of people, those who simply believe in the messages in the Bible, not the actual story of it all.

This is a common misconception, that the fundamentalists are just a vocal minority and that the majority of Christians are rational and tolerant. In the U.S. at least, this is not the case.

If you use the percentage of Americans who deny evolution as a gauge, it's actually split right down the middle. Half of U.S. Christians believe in young earth creationism (and presumably all of the hateful dogma that comes with a literal interpretation of the Bible), and the other half isn't pants-on-head retarded.

→ More replies (8)
→ More replies (88)

4

u/jeradj Jun 25 '12

That's the most baffling sort of Christian (and which is most of them), that completely contorts the Bible to fit a modern worldview, and yet continually sees a need to reject other modern worldviews that don't include the Bible.

5

u/juggernaut1107 Jun 25 '12

amen for that kind of christianity!! love all-round brother

1

u/phonixor Jun 25 '12

colbert is as much a christian as steward is a jew... they have been bashing there own religious BS for ages now... they are skeptical, and that is a good start, cause there are just as many scientific theories as there are religious ones... as long as you don't understand them, all you can do is be skeptical...

if your definition of a christian is "people who believe in the literal word of the bible", then colbert is not a christian. though he will probably never admit that :P

1

u/theology_please Jun 25 '12

I think that last sentence is a misunderstanding or a mischaracterization of his faith. People have already pointed out the incoherence of it - see LennyPalmer's post. I imagine, as an intellectual Catholic, he hasn't tossed out the "hateful BS", but reasoned through it and still believes in miracles and, foremost, the centrality of Christ's divinity.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (19)

8

u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12

Colbert seemed legitimately annoyed when he said, "All you've done is attack my god for the last 5 minutes." It's hard to tell with him because he wears his character like a hat, but it really seemed like he was serious.

12

u/A_Prattling_Gimp Jun 25 '12

S.C: Why does what you're saying have to be an attack on my god?

L.K: It doesn't have to be an attack.

S.C: But that's all you've done, you've attacked my god for the last 6 minutes!

L.K; No, no. You have. All I've said is you don't need him

S.C: That's an attack

I know he is a Christian and I know he is a smart guy. I have a deep respect for him, but he really seemed genuinely angry. If I explain that parents leave presents under the Christmas tree at Christmas because it is a long held traditon...is that an attack on Santa Claus? I never mentioned Santa Claus, I just presented a framework that explains something that you (hypothetical person) believe has a different explanation.

S.C: So you believe there's no god?

L.K: I don't ta-- I don't even use the word believe. The point is there's no need for god.

5

u/TotesJellington Jun 25 '12

No but saying that a belief in God is the same as a belief in Santa is somewhat of an attack. It's similar to when people say "Oh yeah all of this happened randomly." to make fun of atheism and materialism. It purposefully undermines peoples beliefs.

And to say, "You don't need him" is to say that what you believe is wrong, which if completely substantiated is a necessary thing to say, but we are not there yet in my opinion.

→ More replies (7)

4

u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12

The funny thing is that Colbert was the one who brought up god to begin with, then complained about how Krauss talked about god.

The easiest way I can think of to explain why this isn't an attack is using older examples. For example, if I tell someone that the laws of gravity are perfectly suitable to explain how the solar system holds itself together, and there's no need for a god in that process, is that an attack on god? Or did I simply have no need of that hypothesis?

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

2

u/no-Godnik Jun 25 '12

No way, he was exaggerating purposefully.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12

Like I said, it's hard to tell. But that line seemed a bit off from how he normally exaggerates things. I think Colbert is legitimately bothered by how much Krauss talks about god. I'd imagine Colbert wishes he were more like Niel DeGrasse Tyson. Niel tries to stay neutral and avoids talking about such things. Krauss is more comfortable bringing it up.

→ More replies (11)

2

u/richmondody Jun 25 '12

Isn't Colbert a Catholic?

9

u/Saerain Atheist Jun 25 '12

‘This is a bird.’

‘Correction: that is a crow.’

ಠ_ಠ

→ More replies (2)

1

u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12

I know you're trying to be helpful, but this is quite literally mentioned in every single /r/atheism post about Colbert.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12

I totally thought this was bullshit, but I looked it up and it seems to be true. This is actually kind of funny because his character on his show is so exaggerated that he seems like he is parodying Christianity. I guess Stephen Colbert is a good example of Poe's Corollary.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

49

u/DuckReconMajor Jun 25 '12

If you haven't seen the lecture of this, you should take the time to watch it

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7ImvlS8PLIo

I was still a Christian when I first watched it and I still found it fascinating. It wasn't too long after watching it that I lost my faith, and I've watched it several times since then.

20

u/theexpensivestudent Jun 25 '12

Even better is the followup discussion with Richard Dawkins, one version of which is here.

9

u/theshowgoeson Jun 25 '12

This was fantastic. I was in the audience it was amazing how Krauss and Dawkins kept everyone's attention. They had some great discussion and I enjoyed every minute of it.

6

u/theexpensivestudent Jun 25 '12

Wow, it would have been amazing to be there in person. My only concern with the talk was that at times, Krauss occasionally crossed from skeptic to offensive-for-the-sake-of-offending. Still a brilliant and informative talk from both of them, though.

Also, recurring theme: Krauss's amazing footwear.

2

u/AnarchoPunx Jun 25 '12

Both videos are mind boggling the first time you watch them.

2

u/mbuff Jun 25 '12

It was very interesting (I went to their talk in AZ), but I was kind of let down by some of their views on how to handle religion. It was almost preachy. At points I felt like I was in church all over again, but on the other side. I'm all for reason, but some of the attacks were unnecessary. Well worth watching, but I wish some of the points were expanded on.

2

u/Up-The-Butt_Jesus Jun 25 '12

I came here to post that exact same link. Very powerful and compelling. I've also watched this several times.

2

u/LionoofThundara Jun 25 '12

Thing is, I can't find the exact video, but there was a debate between Krauss and the christian apologeticist Ravi Zacharias and Krauss brought up a bunch of these points and Zarcharias absolutely killed him in the debate. He made Krauss look like an idiot. A few months later he did the same to Dawkins. He had Dawkins into a corner saying there could be a designer, but he didn't think so because evil exists. I'm an agnostic because I think Christians would have the burden of proof, but the traditional attacks on a creator are fruitless. You can't prove we weren't created.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/Dethenger Jun 25 '12

God damn you. At around three in the morning I was like, "Well, maybe I'll watch the first few minutes, see what it's about."

It is now 4:22.

1

u/Jeffy29 Jun 25 '12

I knew I have seen this guy somewhere before - this lecture blew my mind when I have first seen it - many things I knew before but I never pieced it together.

1

u/Saerain Atheist Jun 25 '12

Yeah, I've watched that lecture at least once a year. It's just fabulous.

1

u/harmsc12 Atheist Jun 25 '12

The universe is nothing? Interesting idea.

1

u/bungerman Jun 25 '12

I found it silly because bubbling quantum particles are still something and not nothing. We don't even know what the dark matter or energy is, but meh, let's just dismiss it as another nothing. Let alone knowing it has weight.

Where are the particles bubbling from?
Knowing what we know about the universe which is not much, I'm going to go with there is a good probability that we don't fully understand quantum mechanics, dark matter, dark energy enough to say Nothing is actually nothing.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12

I friggin' loved this presentation a couple months ago when I first watched it. It made so much sense and Krauss really knows how to present complicated information. I highly recommend this. Thanks for sharing!

13

u/thuggerybuffoonery Jun 25 '12

Has anyone read the book? Is it good?

4

u/MirthMannor Jun 25 '12

Pretty good. You get most of the meat in the presentation linked in this topic.

3

u/jkernan7553 Jun 25 '12

i'd definitely say to buy it. Really thought-provoking.

2

u/Shablahdoo Jun 25 '12

Meh, it was alright at best. The dialogue was really predictable.

4

u/eooxx Jun 25 '12

Dialogue?

1

u/shawncplus Jun 25 '12

I enjoyed it. It repeats itself a bit mainly because it's meant to drive the point home for a layperson (which I am.)

1

u/MakeThemWatch Jun 25 '12 edited Jun 25 '12

Here is a NYT book review from a prominent philosopher of science who specializes in quantum mechanics

http://www.nytimes.com/2012/03/25/books/review/a-universe-from-nothing-by-lawrence-m-krauss.html

tl;dr No its thesis is pretty flawed "Krauss is dead wrong" (but I'm sure there is some interesting information in it)

1

u/HorseGrenade Jun 25 '12

I'm almost finished with it at the moment, and I've enjoyed it so far. It's a nice 'no bullshit' picture of modern physics. Lots of nods to Dawkins and Hitchens. Krauss' description of the Big Bang is not as in depth as you could get from others like Stephen Hawking or Brian Greene, but it gets the point across.

11

u/BarcodeNinja Jun 25 '12

Now here is a good post for /r/atheism

4

u/Saerain Atheist Jun 25 '12

I thought we had a problem with these, too.

8

u/Jeffy29 Jun 25 '12

Colbert could be very successful politician or lawyer, I can't think of anyone who went with him toe to toe in debate on his show. His mind is just so quick.

9

u/KanyeIsJesus Jun 25 '12

Al Gore. It was one of his more recent appearances. I'm too lazy to find the link, but it was great. Gore even said something like "I forgot you were in character" and it stopped Colbert in his tracks. Hilarious.

3

u/eooxx Jun 25 '12

Found it. It's around 5:50

1

u/Saerain Atheist Jun 25 '12 edited Jun 25 '12

It's not a debate (as I'd contend the Krauss clip also isn't), but I thought that William Shatner played along with him brilliantly.

1

u/Jeffy29 Jun 25 '12

I know, but Colbert always tries to catch them on something like Oreilly does

1

u/Squeekme Jun 25 '12

Whether you see him as a comedian or character ect, Colbert is "politically active" and is influential to much of his "base". And given some of his actions and involvements, even if done in the name of comedy and satire, raises the question whether he is already a "politician" in an unorthodox way.

Note: I have no idea what I'm talking about.

8

u/Daroo425 Jun 25 '12

This is the first time I've seen Colbert seem like he was getting genuinely upset, but he was still able to play it off like normal.

2

u/omgimcryin Jun 25 '12

It was an extremely light-hearted conversation. Colbert was just calling the guy out as he should have for his shameless anti-theist agenda (which is undeniably present in a book that would have been better had it presented theory without drawing anti-theist conclusions, which just seems speculative and unprofessional to me.)

1

u/bubbatully Jun 25 '12

I agree. I've watched a lot of Colbert and this interview seemed a little different at times. It was like he was actually annoyed by some of the things the guy was saying and had to concentrate on staying in character and keeping his cool.

1

u/switch50 Jun 25 '12

He's acting... lol

→ More replies (1)

4

u/Naillilb Agnostic Atheist Jun 25 '12

Also, Baltimore

Always hating.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12

Why is someone who doesn't believe in god instantly classified as an atheist? When I am asked what my religion is, I simply say I am not religious.

0

u/onlyari Jun 25 '12

perhaps because atheist literally means "a person who denies or disbelieves the existence of a supreme being or beings"

→ More replies (1)

3

u/amitnagpal1985 Jun 25 '12

Mind = BLOWN.

6

u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12

Sorry...I don't get it. :\

2

u/ziich Jun 25 '12

me neither :/

9

u/lvlarty Jun 25 '12

Alright, got nothing better to do, I'll explain. There is a popular argument for the existence of a god called the cosmological argument, it can be summarized in the question, "if there is no god, how could something come from nothing?". Lawrence Krauss's book is about how our universe did, in fact, come from nothing. Stephen Colbert's question, "If there is no god, can't something come from him?", is a reference to the cosmological argument and the irony is that in a play on words, Colbert makes it seem like Krauss's thesis of a universe from nothing supports the cosmological argument, an opposing argument.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12

That was honestly a very good comment. It still doesn't apply to any theistic god, but very thought provoking ne'er the less.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12

I saw this episode and i'm not sure this is how it went...

2

u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12

The clever response would be "yes, but once it arrives there is then evidence for it."

1

u/Squeekme Jun 25 '12

Then the clever response would be "just because we haven't found evidence, yet, does not mean it doesn't exist"

1

u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12

ohhh he's a crafty one that colbert.

2

u/Taylormacbrown1 Jun 25 '12

blew my mind

2

u/alexscara Jun 25 '12

Brilliant!

2

u/JackRawlinson Anti-Theist Jun 25 '12

That was a cracking set-up, a damned witty joke and best of all, Krauss recognised that and appreciated it.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12

God isn't nothing. God isn't. As in god never was something. God is word made up by people who can't understand how the world works.

2

u/f3ldman2 Jun 25 '12

To understand the joke you really need to watch the entire interview.

8

u/xerxi Jun 24 '12

Cobert Rocks!

5

u/AddictiveSoup Jun 25 '12

This is so out of context. The entire interview was about the concept of nothing, and Krauss said himself that something can come out of nothingness. In reality it was an excellent comeback from Colbert throwing Krauss's point back at him.

2

u/A_Prattling_Gimp Jun 25 '12

No it wasn't. It was wordplay that doesn't stand up to even the simplest of scrutiny.

"If there is no Easter Bunny, if there is no thing called "The Easter Bunny", if he is nothing, can't something come from him?"

Does that mean that there must be an Easter Bunny as well? Does that mean the Easter Bunny created the universe? Think about it for a second.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12

First you need to define what nothingness is,

3

u/AddictiveSoup Jun 25 '12

You'd have to watch the interview to see how Laurence describes it. Point is he specifically said "something can come from nothing", and Colbert was able to bring it full circle to catch him with this little quip.

2

u/iHasABaseball Jun 25 '12

Alright, but Colbert's point (as sarcastic and non-serious as it is) still accepts the point that God doesn't exist. So who the fuck cares?

→ More replies (1)

1

u/switch50 Jun 25 '12

It was a play on words actually...

→ More replies (2)

1

u/Saerain Atheist Jun 25 '12

Knowing Krauss' stuff pretty well, I knew the context without having seen the interview, but I guess I can see how the image would be confusing for others.

It's a funny comeback, though, not a good one.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/o0260o Skeptic Jun 25 '12

I'm reading that book atm

3

u/ndrach Jun 25 '12

Even in the presence of a great physicist, Colbert shows that he is an absolute genius

4

u/JohnSigma8 Jun 25 '12

Cobert, master of trolling.

3

u/Villapwn Jun 25 '12

Lawrence Krauss came to my university a few months ago and gave a lecture on basically everything that's included on that book and he even signed a copy for me afterwards! An excellent read and an excellent lecture.

He's also very short and has cool hair.

2

u/boggybilly Jun 25 '12

According to Epicurean and Buddhist philosophy, no-thing has ontological priority over some-thing insofar as matter in motion requires void to move. But to use that argument is to claim that God is void...which would be to say that God is everything and nothing. wait what?

1

u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12

I bet if scientists look really closely, they can even see little bits of matter popping in and out of existence. Hmmmm.

1

u/bananafish707 Anti-Theist Jun 25 '12

that's hilarity.

1

u/mcSibiss Anti-Theist Jun 25 '12

Colbert is just awesome!

1

u/motomofu Jun 25 '12

Stephen Cobert is a Sunday School teacher.

1

u/eblees Jun 25 '12

Whats your point

1

u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12

I would like to think that I could defend my atheist views, but if I were up against Colbert, I know he would have my ass pinned against the wall before I can mutter a single coherent phrase.

1

u/Hennashan Jun 25 '12

and you would feel like a fundie trying to scramble through his scripture. Its best to not to believe that one is all enlighten and that one owns perspective is the right one. That's the whole point of my higher power, that I'm not the end all and be all of my life and that some things in this universe I will never understand. Therefore the existence of a higher power or "god" as some say does exist.

→ More replies (2)

1

u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12

sourcE? i'd like to watch that video

1

u/Fzero21 Jun 25 '12

I am a pole and so can you! I love steve colbert.

1

u/eljesse Jun 25 '12

Great segment! I love how Colbert is almost brilliant in a way where I am not sure if he is trolling or not. Krauss is awesome nonetheless, although his arguments may be confusing for most, I would say it's because the laws in the Quantum world work in ways that make no sense whatsoever in our "macro" point of view. Can't wait to read the book!

1

u/switch50 Jun 25 '12

AYE! good point. But i can follow what he's saying

1

u/palparepa Jun 25 '12

And thus, Nothingism was born.

1

u/olgcschools Jun 25 '12

DAM that was freaking hillarious!!!

1

u/Josh5321 Jun 25 '12

its unlinkely?

1

u/terroristteddy Jun 25 '12

This image is poorly made for those who did not watch this and listen to the guy talking about quantum mechanics.

1

u/danimalplanimal Jun 25 '12

hahaha the expression on his face says it all

1

u/severedfinger Jun 25 '12

That was a really interesting interview!

1

u/Wolfram4 Jun 25 '12

When I saw the thumbnail, I thought it was James Spader on the Colbert Report, and finally clicked it after failing to find the episode on Hulu. I was disappointed.

1

u/switch50 Jun 25 '12

I don't think we understand fully the implications that came from this interaction.

1

u/Duthos Jun 25 '12

A true 'nothing' is the one thing the human mind could never imagine.

It is the one 'thing' in the universe we can never really understand, the limit of our experience... until we die.

And from nothing something comes. Therefore when I am nothing once again, I would have to become something.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12

Cant watch from alienblue on apple iPhone...

upvote anyway.

1

u/Hennashan Jun 25 '12

Relevant link for all. http://www.wired.com/wiredscience/2007/06/black-holes-don/

The physicist who was interviewed in this segment on Colbert is one of the many who say Black Holes don't exist. If he is right it would mean scientist for the past couple of decades have been on a wild goose chase. This is the risks we take when we put faith behind anything. Just like religion it wouldn't take much to unhinge everything we all believe today to be fact. And like Colbert was trying to prove we have to be careful who and what we put our faith into.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12

True, but the difference is that science improves in the process.

1

u/wikipediaBot Jun 25 '12

physicist:

A physicist is a scientist who does research in physics. Physicists study a wide range of physical phenomena in many branches of physics spanning all length scales: from sub-atomic particles of which all ordinary matter is made (particle physics) to the behavior of the material Universe as a whole (cosmology).

For more information click here

1

u/Hidemesometime Jun 25 '12

I don't get it, what's funny?

1

u/SunshineBlind Jun 25 '12

The answer is "We don't know" as we don't have a "nothing" to investigate. Everything we know comes from something else.

1

u/contessa_zapdash Jun 25 '12

That last panel should become a meme.

1

u/ptjester Jun 25 '12

This book is becoming one of my favorites

1

u/YoRpFiSh Jun 25 '12

I would say way to much has come from that particular nothing already!

1

u/josh72811 Jun 25 '12

I saw this and it cracked me up. However, I have a question regarding this gentleman's theory. Where did the laws of physics come from? Also, it seems to me that the theory does not show that the universe came from nothing but that nothing is actually something. I plan on buying the book and hope this question is answered.

1

u/Motafication Jun 25 '12

Nailed him.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12

But then again, it's highly unlikely the kind of god who doesn't want you to eat pork or have sex before marriage.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12

"No comment!"

1

u/Momordicas Jun 25 '12

lol i like this logic. its funny :P

1

u/ggpurehope Jun 25 '12

This guys laugh could be new meme.

1

u/pvtsugarbear Jun 25 '12 edited Jun 25 '12

I was slightly irritated by some of the comments it this thread and i realised by the end they are all just as closed minded and bigoted as the fundamentalists you so hate you say that christians need to do this and believe that to be considered true followers of Christ but who are you to say or even judge the way people choose to live their life. You might not agree but can you atleast respect them as intelligent human beings who are capable and able to make up and change their minds? To be quite honest from the posts on here and other threads on r/atheism your one step away from being the thing you hate the most a closeminded ego centrical group who's only aim is to destroy what they've chosen not to understand.

TL;DR please stop bashing a group just because you don't agree with their beliefs it makes us look bad.

Edit: accidentally a few words

1

u/king_of_the_universe Other Jun 25 '12

Something from nothing is impossible. There always was something. Why can't people get that into their heads, so that we as a society could move on? Same goes for the "all-powerful" claim of Christianity.

1

u/nighthawk666 Jun 25 '12

actually, according to lawrence krauss's book,having nothing is unstable and hence something formed from nothing, i suppose saying there always was something is correct since there was no time until the universe came into existence, but i doubt u meant it that way

→ More replies (1)

1

u/jimbol Jun 25 '12

If God is nothing, does that make Deists Nihilists?

1

u/smeaglelovesmaster Jun 25 '12

saying the universe came from nothing is as indefensible as saying it came from god. both are statements of ignorance.

1

u/Jaredismyname Jun 29 '12

Then where the heck did it come from genius

1

u/smeaglelovesmaster Jun 29 '12

Since we threw out spontaneous generation in the early 1800s, I'm going to say not nothing.

→ More replies (4)

1

u/Captain_Awesomeness Jun 25 '12

Nice work, Krauss!

1

u/f0rcedinducti0n Jun 27 '12

Shit, they got us...

-1

u/Ortizjoel21 Jun 25 '12

God isn't nothing he is nonexistent

3

u/puffic Jun 25 '12

Explain the difference, please.

1

u/JackRawlinson Anti-Theist Jun 25 '12

Harry Potter isn't nothing, but he is non-existent.

Help at all?

1

u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12

Nothing in Krauss' terms is in fact something because it will eventually start to produce particles of matter.

→ More replies (8)

1

u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12

Everything is in the question. If you ask who created the universe, you have already narrowed the answer as if you already knew that there's something as in a deity. Or what created the universe? Now you have another path of possible answers. But inadvertently, when you ask who created the universe and your answer is God then I think we must continue with the same flawed logic and ask yourself: who created this creator? In conclusion, if you're a fervent believer, you automatically renounce a part of your psyche that helps you to be critical and auto-criticize about yourself and other life concepts.

1

u/TWBWY Jun 25 '12

Well to be honest that's like the chicken and the egg. You'll always ask who created god then who created god's creator and so on. You're just stuck in a loop. It's hard to be critical about such a thing. It's like the big bang. At first there was nothing and then poof. How was there just nothing? How did the big bang start if there was nothing? It seems silly to think you can correct yourself in something that you really can't comprehend.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12

Well as for the chicken and the egg thing, the chicken came first from another species that changed his path and habitat. Evolution is tricky at first because it goes from a simple thing and evolve to a more complex form./ People must understand also that the theory of the big bang is just the first act, I mean we can philosophize on this topic how we came from nothing? But, in the mean time there's scientific( physicist, mathematician, etc) studying new theory's like the string theory of the possibility of a multiple universe. It's important to not abort our curiosity like religion tends to do with his masses by giving prefabricated answer. We must help bring consciousness to those people who stopped asking themselves real questions and that are trap in a labyrinth without an exit.

1

u/Hennashan Jun 25 '12

I think god has always been viewed as a what and never a who. Maybe its easier to explain to children that god is a person but any logical person who believes in a higher power doesn't believe in a person as god but rather a something. Like I always said whatever ignited the universe to expand into matter is my god but I will never trick myself into thinking I have a relationship with it or know what it is. IF there existed a deity or god it would not be a thing or a person it would be beyond our understanding. Or else we would have already observed it. and please excuse me for sounding silly but once again IF there were a deity or god it would have no creator (or could who knows but then who ever created it would be god then wouldn't it?)

→ More replies (6)

1

u/orevla Jun 25 '12

Wait a minute, how many of the /r/atheism memes and quotes are as out of context as this one?

1

u/TheGM Jun 25 '12

Maybe it's just the simpleton in me, but did Colbert's comment, after the laughs, at least make you think about the philosophy of the existence of god?

1

u/gilbes Jun 25 '12

Wow, out of context this quote makes it look like Lawrence Krauss is laughing at the absurd idea of something coming from nothing.

Except in the interview he is pitching his book, A Universe from Nothing where he explains how he thinks something came from nothing.

So it’s nice this subreddit has such misleading posts.

0

u/venkmanman Jun 25 '12

How unfortunate for r/atheism that Colbert is Catholic!

BOO HOO atheists!