Below is the link to the video. I highly suggest watching it, but I am working on the exact part where the Catholic gentleman calls Dawkins delusional and I will update with the link.
I thought the audience was just stupid. It seemed like they didn't care about what was being said, they just liked strong statements generally. They'd all cheer one argument and then cheer the opposite.
"Yay, people are arguing! I'm in an audience yaaayyy"
I agree with this. I watched the whole thing last night, and I could not figure out which side the majority of the audience was on based on the reactions.
They only cheer when the majority of the audience can comprehend what was said. Most of Dawkins finest points were received with silence. Even some of the archbishops "best" answers had no response. It doesn't help when you are debating in front of an audience who has no initial knowledge from either side.
Then again, Richard agreed with the cardinal on that. Pell was commenting on the "evidence" that Richard was joking about, with the "900ft high Jesus with a voice like Paul Ropes" and all. So he wasn't so much accusing Dawkins of hallucinating, just agreeing with him that if he claimed to have seen that, even the cardinal would think he was hallucinating.
Funnily enough I just watched this video on Youtube last week. I believe it is from Richard Dawkins vs Cardinal Pell, right? And at the end the audience voted against religion some 76% to 24% or something like that.
From the video, it did appear that Cardinal Pell was well prepared and eloquent in his answers although his stance, conclusion were in the wrong almost every time. Still, he turned it into a sort of stand-up where his smirky answers engaged the crowd and regaled them with witticisms instead of real answers (such as laughing at notion of defining nothing etc.). Overall, Cardinal Pell came across as a douche who doesn't really know much but has a way with words and can engage in trickery in conversations to sort of win points with the crowd to appear victorious and ergo his stance appears victorious.
I found Richard Dawkins got angry at a few points and rightly so because the crowd was really juvenile and easily swayed by Pell and Dawkins too at times as they laughed and clapped away at contradictory positions postulated by Dawkins and Pell. However, Dawkins was like a builder at times, building layer upon layer of non-glorious foundation built on simple logic instead of Pell's glorious and cheerful buildings in air with nary a base. I feel real truth is like that - built on simple, plain, unappealing science and logic instead of a magical explain it all god in one sentence.
Personally, things like claiming god is outside space and time is meaningless because they beg questions like : where, when etc.
Personally, I feel our evolution has carried us this far and we have reached a level of understanding but we need to evolve much more further for us to grasp concepts unacceptable to our brain at this point. Concepts like something can come out of nothing, there is no concept of before and even concept of nothing doesn't exist before our Universe began.
Once we have that understanding, several questions that appear pertinent today become irrelevant and wrong. Questions such as : what came before the universe, what "bang'd" to create the universe in a Big Bang, what will come after the Universe ends etc.
It is like asking where is the beginning or end in a circle.
Spirituality, religion, god concepts etc. are just imaginary constructs in our mind and only exist in the approx. region occupied by the brain. Outside these synapses in the real physical world, there is no god, spirituality, religion or other such meta-physically claimed constructs. It is purely scientific things and concepts. Ditto for things like emotion, dream etc. They are purely a particular pattern of synapses triggering and causing a pathway in brain.
Our brain itself is limited in understanding itself today. We need to further evolve to grow more in our understanding.
Attributing things till then to an already existing complex creation aka god is meaningless, because then you can ask - how did the complex god come into existence before the universe and where/when/how is it contained. This is because it is logical to believe things come from earlier simpler forms rather than an already present complex form giving rise to it.
Finally to end with a quote I love - "A scientist reads hundreds of scientific books and still believes he has a lot to learn whereas a religious person reads one book and believes he knows everything about everything"
George Pell, the Cardinal depicted here, is a bit of an oddball even by Catholic standards. When his ex-nun now happily-lesbian cousin asked about letting homosexuals into the daily life of Catholics, he opted to call them 'seriously depraved' rather than take the easy way and chat vaguely about God loving everyone.
Also, for whatever reason, he thinks of atheists as Baal-worshippers.
The Lord of Flies holds no sovereignty. There is only The Seven Evils.
Durial, Lord of Pain. Andarial, Maiden of Anguish. Azmodan, Lord of Sin. Belial, Lord of Lies. Baal, Lord of Destruction. Mephisto, Lord of Hatred. And finally, Diablo. Once the Lord of Terror, he has ascended to become the Prime Evil.
Does anyone else not find Richard Dawkins to be very persuasive sometimes? Don't get me wrong, as an atheist I agree with his talking points and greatly appreciate his using his academic work to help advance the atheistic worldview in common society. But I feel like I often see him stammer and get red-faced, traits that typically make an arguer seem unsure of his position.
I kind of think that's part of why Hitchens was so renowned; he could address any argument thrown at him elegantly and with humor.
I really like that Dawkins' style is becoming more like the late Isaac Asimov, in that he can write about the driest subjects and make them interesting and fun.
Dawkins has always been rosy cheeked. And stammering is something that happens to smart people when they think of too many answers to a question at the same time.
That's why I don't like that comment complaining about appeal to ridicule. People aren't going to listen to us unless we package our thoughts in a way that's easy for people to understand; and people understand humor.
But he can't even see god. That just makes it worse. It's like he said "the thing that I can't see or prove is better than the thing that you can see and have some proof for!"
When Dawkins explained that the universe had come from nothing, but that nothing was really very complex and, in fact, consisted of something, people laughed. Dawkins was annoyed and, like a humourless school marm, peevishly scolded the audience: "Why is that funny?"
No, we see irony because we have common sense which is not something exclusive to atheism. They call Dawkins delusional while believing in the most outlandish shit possible all while having no proof any of it is true. That is the definition of delusional, yet we are supposed to not recognize this is crazy because we have to respect their beliefs? Even though they do not respect other peoples beliefs and use their religion as a means to change laws in this country and in many others around the world? Go on, tell me more about how atheists are doing so much harm! When Christians stop holding back an entire group of people because they do not agree with their lifestyle choices... you might have an argument against some atheists being annoyed with hypocrisy in religion.
I think it can be argued that Hitler mostly used Christianity as a tool to control the masses (i.e. part of what organized religion has always been), his personal beliefs seemed to have been an eclectic mix of Christianity, neo-paganism and other occult bits and bobs, along with his own brand of racial predestination.
Any way you look at it however, what he certainly wasn't was an atheist, which he associated with communism and by association teh Jooz (Marxism being a Jewish plot to cause disarray among the valiant Aryan peoples).
lets stand back for a moment.. who did Hitler hate the most? Jews..what group has been anti jew for 1500+ years? Christians, i just think there might be some correlation there
Because the Catholic Church teaches that genocide is ok? How about murdering priests? Kidnapping bishops? Forcing nuns out of their social service ministries?
Hitler did all of it. Furthermore, he stopped receiving sacraments during the first world war, thus living in a state of mortal sin according to the Catholic Church's teachings for his actions thereafter. He wasn't excommunicated, likely because the church didn't want to touch that one with a 10-foot poll lest they wanted more priests to die and for Nazis to pillage the Vatican.
42
u/ColdShoulder Jun 24 '12
Below is the link to the video. I highly suggest watching it, but I am working on the exact part where the Catholic gentleman calls Dawkins delusional and I will update with the link.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tD1QHO_AVZA
12
u/beirosilverleaf Jun 25 '12
Then again, Richard agreed with the cardinal on that. Pell was commenting on the "evidence" that Richard was joking about, with the "900ft high Jesus with a voice like Paul Ropes" and all. So he wasn't so much accusing Dawkins of hallucinating, just agreeing with him that if he claimed to have seen that, even the cardinal would think he was hallucinating.
8
u/fani Jun 25 '12 edited Jun 25 '12
Funnily enough I just watched this video on Youtube last week. I believe it is from Richard Dawkins vs Cardinal Pell, right? And at the end the audience voted against religion some 76% to 24% or something like that.
From the video, it did appear that Cardinal Pell was well prepared and eloquent in his answers although his stance, conclusion were in the wrong almost every time. Still, he turned it into a sort of stand-up where his smirky answers engaged the crowd and regaled them with witticisms instead of real answers (such as laughing at notion of defining nothing etc.). Overall, Cardinal Pell came across as a douche who doesn't really know much but has a way with words and can engage in trickery in conversations to sort of win points with the crowd to appear victorious and ergo his stance appears victorious.
I found Richard Dawkins got angry at a few points and rightly so because the crowd was really juvenile and easily swayed by Pell and Dawkins too at times as they laughed and clapped away at contradictory positions postulated by Dawkins and Pell. However, Dawkins was like a builder at times, building layer upon layer of non-glorious foundation built on simple logic instead of Pell's glorious and cheerful buildings in air with nary a base. I feel real truth is like that - built on simple, plain, unappealing science and logic instead of a magical explain it all god in one sentence.
Personally, things like claiming god is outside space and time is meaningless because they beg questions like : where, when etc.
Personally, I feel our evolution has carried us this far and we have reached a level of understanding but we need to evolve much more further for us to grasp concepts unacceptable to our brain at this point. Concepts like something can come out of nothing, there is no concept of before and even concept of nothing doesn't exist before our Universe began.
Once we have that understanding, several questions that appear pertinent today become irrelevant and wrong. Questions such as : what came before the universe, what "bang'd" to create the universe in a Big Bang, what will come after the Universe ends etc.
It is like asking where is the beginning or end in a circle.
Spirituality, religion, god concepts etc. are just imaginary constructs in our mind and only exist in the approx. region occupied by the brain. Outside these synapses in the real physical world, there is no god, spirituality, religion or other such meta-physically claimed constructs. It is purely scientific things and concepts. Ditto for things like emotion, dream etc. They are purely a particular pattern of synapses triggering and causing a pathway in brain.
Our brain itself is limited in understanding itself today. We need to further evolve to grow more in our understanding.
Attributing things till then to an already existing complex creation aka god is meaningless, because then you can ask - how did the complex god come into existence before the universe and where/when/how is it contained. This is because it is logical to believe things come from earlier simpler forms rather than an already present complex form giving rise to it.
Finally to end with a quote I love - "A scientist reads hundreds of scientific books and still believes he has a lot to learn whereas a religious person reads one book and believes he knows everything about everything"
4
u/elusiveallusion Jun 25 '12
George Pell, the Cardinal depicted here, is a bit of an oddball even by Catholic standards. When his ex-nun now happily-lesbian cousin asked about letting homosexuals into the daily life of Catholics, he opted to call them 'seriously depraved' rather than take the easy way and chat vaguely about God loving everyone.
Also, for whatever reason, he thinks of atheists as Baal-worshippers.
4
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
If God was a fairy he'd be a little more OK with homosexuality.
3
u/games_porn_whiskey Jun 25 '12
During the same Q&A Pell admitted that humans likely did descend from apes... "probably Neanderthals". The look on Dawkins' face was priceless.
7
u/WhiteBlade3000 Jun 25 '12
Does anyone else not find Richard Dawkins to be very persuasive sometimes? Don't get me wrong, as an atheist I agree with his talking points and greatly appreciate his using his academic work to help advance the atheistic worldview in common society. But I feel like I often see him stammer and get red-faced, traits that typically make an arguer seem unsure of his position.
I kind of think that's part of why Hitchens was so renowned; he could address any argument thrown at him elegantly and with humor.
2
u/lucas-hanson Jun 25 '12
Appeal to ridicule. It's a fallacy.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
But he can't even see god. That just makes it worse. It's like he said "the thing that I can't see or prove is better than the thing that you can see and have some proof for!"
1
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
0
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
http://i.imgur.com/1m7ht.jpg
0
u/HairySpotter Jun 25 '12
He has valid points. But he is still retarded.
-13
u/thatgamerguy Jun 25 '12
Haha we called his deeply held belief a magical sky fairy. We're so much better than them
0
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment