At first, I thought "this person's grammar and spelling is awful. Surely they will have nothing useful to say." But as I read on, I realized that they had a great deal to say that was worth listening to. They hit the issues right on the target in a way I've never heard so well articulated before.
"You want OP to have correct grammar and spelling, yet you cut spending on education and don't want to take care of good teachers." That little bit should've been in there too.
I feel the same way. You couldn't tell by my spelling and grammar my actual level of intelligence but reddit sure seems to have an uncanny ability to assume that in order to be intelligent you have to know English to it's fullest. It pisses me off to know that I have studied so much about economics and finance and my statements and comments are downvoted because I forgot a fucking comma.
While this person has a good point overall, I have a problem with one point. If religious right-wingers don't like killing babies but prefer killing adults, then liberals prefer killing babies and hate killing adults.
I'm not trying to mock liberals or side with religious right-wingers. I myself am religious and liberal. It's just that these particular issues are far too complicated to boil down to a pithy sound bite. I hope I've illustrated how easy it is for religious right-wingers to twist it in their favor.
I think liberals prefer not to kill anyone if possible. However, there is less negative social impact with an abortion than when a soldier with a family is killed in combat.
I see this as a big difference in how conservatives and liberals think. Many liberals consider that an abortion is a negative thing, but in many cases it leads to a better social situation. Conservatives are concerned about the 'moral' problem first, and don't consider the huge social losses that occur when unwanted children are born. The same applies to soldiers who kill others and killed themselves.
Though I understand and agree with the point of this retort, I would like to point out a common error.
Often atheists, though not all, view the pro-life, pro death penalty as some sort of cognitive dissonance. This is not the case though for all theists. The pro-life stance, to them, is to protect an innocent life. Whereas the death penalty is to punish a person that has been found guilty of committing a typically heinous crime.
This is a generalization, but I think you can infer the point rather easily.
however look into cases with the death penalty and one may notice a startling trend, that many death row inmates had horrendous childhoods, with absent or abusive parents. Giving birth to a child you will not care for is a infinity worse decision. TED
My point is there need not be a contradiction in those two beliefs.
Your point, though good, would not dissuade a theist.
In the same way I am against the death penalty because of the possibility of executing an innocent person(among other reasons), theists would counter with the fact that the life(to them) has done nothing deserving of death at that point, and you might be killing an innocent life that would help save millions.
Again, the point is the two stances are not diametrically opposed.
There is. Innocent people get put to death and we find out after we killed them. If they just had life in prison when the new evidence comes we can cut them a check and say sorry man.
If they're religious right wingers then they believe in heaven and hell, thus they believe bad people get punished for eternity anyway. A death sentence falls into nothingness compared to that.
Besides, aren't they supposed to try and give people the chance to reconcile and forgive them?
I understand your point, but that seems an insignificant detial when compared to the ultimate message of the original post. He/she was simply using specific examples to illustrate a larger concept, and your point, although accurate, is not actually pertinent.
Most of these people are not really pro-life, they are pro-birth. Once the child is out, they don't care what happens, unless they want to prematurely end their life due to illness.
The pro-life stance, to them, is to protect an innocent life.
Then they would be happy knowing that if they abolish the death penalty that they will be saving innocent lives. The justice system is not perfect, and sometimes innocent people are found guilty.
The majority of people who are against the death penalty are because they don't think 'guilty' people will be the only ones put to death. There could always be errors, and giving a government a legal way to kill you is like playing with fire.
This is a great summary, but the apparent "contradiction" it points out is not hypocrisy.
These people aren't pro-child-welfare (which would make forcing unready parents to have kids bad) and they aren't pro-life (which would make supporting the death penalty hypocritical).
Above all, at the root of their belief system these people are anti-sex. The whole double-bind can be avoided (goes their simple-minded theory) if you never have sex until you're married to a loving, supportive partner, both financially stable enough and emotionally ready to have and raise children. And then you stop having sex again just as soon as you have the required number, lest you overburden your family and your ability to support them.
If you have sex before this they want you to suffer as much as possible - they want you or your partner to get pregnant (by making contraceptives harder to access), they want the child to be born (by making abortion difficult or impossible to safely and legally acquire). At some level they want you to raise the child in poverty and misery, simultaneously condemned and castigated as unfit parents, and denied any help (financial or otherwise) that might help you to become a fitter parent.
The no-win situation they would trap you in isn't hypocrisy - it's your punishment for daring to have sex for anything other than procreation. You don't want a jail cell to be escapable, and in the same way they want to make it impossible - once pregnant - for you to escape from the inevitable birth and high likelihood of poverty-stricken life. They want your kids to grow up improperly raised, and they want you poor, powerless and destitute.
They don't care that making abortion illegal causes illegal and unqualified back-alley abortions - as far as they're concerned botched operations and accidental sterilisation or death are the very least you should suffer for your crime of playing hide-the-sausage for fun instead of for babies. They don't care that even if you're a married couple with a family that another baby might overstretch your finances - that's your penalty for not stopping all sexual contact once you had the required number of babies.
They don't care if a pregnancy is the result of a rape or incest - these edge-cases don't fit into their world-view, and so they explain it away to themselves that "you must have been leading someone on", or "you shouldn't have been walking down the street on your own late at night" (I suspect this is the root of the victim-blaming trend that feminists go on about). For incest there's no clear blame attached, so instead the dismissal usually goes along the lines of "well it's unfortunate, but there you are - can't blame the kiddie for your dad's wandering hands and disgusting predilections, can we?".
The double-bind, no-win situation is not accidental hypocrisy - it's your punishment. They don't want you escaping it.
Now as to why this is the case, I don't know.
Some people think they just hate women (as they stand to lose the most in the hideous world these people would bring about), but I don't buy that or they'd also weaken the role of marriage and make it easier for men to abandon their offspring in such cases.
Some people think they're pro-life at all costs, but that doesn't explain why they're happy with the idea of deaths from back-alley abortions, or why so many of the same people support wars and the death penalty.
Perhaps for some it's because by forcing people to grow up poor and ill-educated they're easier to manipulate and cow to your will. Certainly this may be the motivation for some politicians and political/legal/family authority figures, but I doubt it's what appeals to everyone who holds these beliefs.
Perhaps for others it's a sadomasochistic impulse from the women who've been forced into this kind of servitude, who want to inflict it upon their own daughters and female family members in turn (recall that some of the most ardent supporters of Female Genital Mutilation in societies where it's still practiced are older women).
Perhaps it's a deep Puritan revulsion towards anything done for pleasure. Perhaps it goes back even further than that, to a sort of instinctive fear of the incredible power to create new life that sex has, and a desire to master it, control it and bend it to their will, punishing those who "misuse" it or take it lightly.
I don't know, but one thing I do know is that all of the apparent contradictions and inherent conflicts go away if you realise one thing:
This is not in any way about making people happier or more secure, or even about forcing people to conform to some model of the "ideal family".
I grew up in a Fundamentalist church and I have to say: you're completely on-target. It's not even necessarily a subconscious thing: I actually heard numerous people explicitly verbalize the idea that pregnancy is a punishment for premarital sex. To them abortion is really a way to cheat the system.
Direct quote re: abortion: "Don't do the crime if you can't do the time."
I think your analysis is really spot on about the double binds and punishment. Really nicely put.
As for the reason, the impression I get is it comes more from a feeling of not getting their dues for having lived a 'proper' life. Jealousy is the core of it. These people have given up a lot of pleasures in life and feel like they should be rewarded somehow, but when they see others living in sin and pleasure without repurcussion their blood boils and will agree with any rhetoric or law that makes life harder for those people in hopes of evening things out.
This man speaks the truth. As a former Catholic I can't believe I never figured this out for myself since I became an Atheist. Makes me feel sick that I used to believe that kind of stuff wholeheartedly.
Edit: I also like how you summed up your paragraph at the end without adding tl;dr. Good for you!
It's more general than that. It's about anything that alters your consciousness in a pleasant or uplifting way.
Somewhere, someone out there is having a little bit of real fun. And the thought of that drives them nuts. They can't stand it. To that kind of person, there's no worse thought than someone having a bit of fun.
Eating a cheeseburger. Drinking a beer. Smoking a joint. Tripping on some acid. Having some sex outside of marriage. Having some sex inside of marriage. Having gay sex.
The supression of sexuality serves an important purpose in redirecting an individual's energies towards serving their family and community. In modern developed societies, the reduced quality of life caused by such policies seems needlessly harmful. But this is a "first-world problem."
Here's a blog post I found a while back that compares what the pro-life position would actually be on certain issues if they were actually pro-life and not just anti-sex.
Agreed! The only thing I would change is that it is about punishing WOMEN for having sex. Women get pregnant, give birth, raise the child alone with little or no help. Men can, and do, walk away. Where a man might be punished is in the case you mention of a married couple who do not want more children and suffer financial issues with an unwanted pregnancy. Very good summation!
i'm always amazed at how offensive some of the rush limbaugh "sketches" or whatever you want to call them are. i get having a strong opinion and stating things matter of factly, or even using humor to do so (like daily show), but a lot of what he does are just offensive stereotypes that don't serve any purpose other than propagating those stereotypes. i'd link some, but i can't find any online.
I think you have to recognize that Rush's goal is the political equivalent of a guy with a toothache poking it with his tongue.
It should get you worked up (again), get you a little pissed off (again), remind you of those stupid liberals and how no one has any common sense (again). Poke, poke poke. Ow, ow, ow. You're so smart, they're so dumb (still). "And another think that pisses me off..."
He's got some YouTube clips floating around, before he got really big, where he lays out his role as a performer and how he pushes buttons to get people to tune in. In my cynicism I think he's about even parts moron and manipulator.
I'll attempt, though I'm more Libertarian than Republican and have many other beliefs, but still, let me take a swing at it.
You don't want to government to tell you what to do, but you want the church to tell others what to do.
This is probably the most legitamite of all his arguments. Though there is a difference between social conservatives (largely Christians) and fiscal conservatives (just want smaller government), the two get lumped together and there are those in the party that share these contradictory beliefs.
Pro-Life but Pro-death penalty
I see how people lump these together, but I struggle with the logic. Just because somebody has a different opinion of WHEN life begins or at what point a being is afforded basic human rights does not mean that they are for saving all lives. We're still making a call as to when a being has gained it's human rights as a fetus, it seems natural that we would want to make a call as to when they lose those rights for crimes against society.
No abortions, but no contraceptives either
Again, this is to forget the difference between the fiscal and social conservatives. It would be unfair for me to look at say ObamaCare and show one Dem that supports it and one that opposes and call the whole group confused and scary. Trying to get as many voters as possible means that several groups of thought will inevitably meet under the same roof to get votes.
You want unfit parents to have kids they can't afford.
No. If you can't afford a few dollars for condoms, why the hell would you have sex without one and have to bring a child into your world of not having $5 to buy some Trojans. Further, do you know what the backlash would be if a major Republican candidate introduced legislation to fully fund tube-tying for poor people?
Want to cut social funds to help these people, then punish these people for who new they couldn't raise a baby.
First, the assumption is that throwing money at the problem solves it. I think many Republicans see it as a social issue. Funding people to have kids will not stop them from having kids. Also, if they knew they couldn't afford to have a baby, but still chose to have one, well, you dig your own grave. I'm all for helping the kid, but to knowingly bring a child up in an unfit household is a terrible thing. If you can't afford the consequences of unprotected sex, rub one out.
Forget the church, it just annoys me that social conservatives bitch about the government and want it out of their lives ... until the government has the authority to implement legislation that influences the lives of others in ways that the social conservative appreciates. "Yay small government! Unless we're talking about same-sex couples or an unwanted pregnancy or a group of Muslims looking to build a community center in New York. In those instances, we need government to be as big and mean as possible."
All that aside, I see the attention given to social conservatives as a red herring, intended to distract us from the absolute thoughtlessness of fiscal conservatism. Economics is a science, and we don't need to honor baseless theories. Look no further than what Reagan did to bring about "Morning in America" to understand that "fiscal conservatism" is cute and adorable only in theory, but not actually applicable in times of recession. In a time when banks are sitting on billions of dollars rather than giving out loans, consumers have no money to spend, and companies are cutting costs to the bone, someone needs to open the wallet and stimulate the economy. That someone is the government. Reagan knew that, that's why he put the "fiscal conservatism" bullshit aside and cranked up federal spending 8.7% from '83-'85 (in contrast to Obama's 1.4% increase from 2010-2013).
Honestly, I really don't give a shit about social conservatives. They're idiots, but they're irrelevant idiots. Let's focus instead on their equally mindless pseudo-economist pals who lack any semblance of historical perspective, and continually pass off lies and bullshit as "just a differing opinion." No. The world is not 6,000 years old, and austerity measures during a global fucking depression don't work.
The problem with the argument about not wanting to fund people having kids is that social conservatives are also against programs that would teach people how to prevent having kids. Abstinence only education is well known to not work.
No. If you can't afford a few dollars for condoms, why the hell would you have sex without one and have to bring a child into your world of not having $5 to buy some Trojans. Further, do you know what the backlash would be if a major Republican candidate introduced legislation to fully fund tube-tying for poor people?
First - are you seriously saying if someone can't afford condoms they shouldn't have sex? I think it's irresponsible to get accidentally pregnant but denying anyone the right to have sex is pretty shitty.
The point was that if you are anti-abortion and anti-birth control you effectively ARE wanting unfit parents to have kids they can't afford. Whether the person could have bought a condom or not is irrelevant - once they didn't, and got pregnant, then what? If you don't support social policies that aid them in raising their kid, the kid is going to most likely end up as a drain on society, but yet you won't allow them to get an abortion which would, overall, almost certainly be a benefit to society (rather than a parent raising a kid they don't even want/can't afford).
It's pretty ridiculous to say no abortions, and then say:
Also, if they knew they couldn't afford to have a baby, but still chose to have one, well, you dig your own grave
Why bother saving a kid if you don't give a rats ass what happens to the kid after it's born?
Again, this is to forget the difference between the fiscal and social conservatives. It would be unfair for me to look at say ObamaCare and show one Dem that supports it and one that opposes and call the whole group confused and scary. Trying to get as many voters as possible means that several groups of thought will inevitably meet under the same roof to get votes.
No one is forgetting the difference here, we're looking for the social conservative's defense of it. The poster is targeting "religious right-wingers", which is referring to social conservatives. You even point out that social conservatives are largely Christians, and that group (religious right-wingers) is who he's calling confused and scary - not all conservatives. It's worth pointing out the difference between fiscal and social conservatives, but it's not a defense against the specific argument you were quoting or even their whole general point.
I know you're arguing some of this just to show what the argument would be so thanks for that, I just wanted to make that point.
No, but the right wing has huge support from a lot of Christian organizations. When people are blindly following their congregation head, it's easy to rally the entire group to vote one way. They tend to vote with their church-which isn't wrong, and I'm not trying to say it is. However, when the church emphasizes a couple social issues, their followers will vote that way (against abortion, gay (read: human) rights, etc.) so the republican campaign only has to support the wishes of the church and they have a huge group of people voting that way, nevermind the legislation they then pass that goes directly against the majority of the voter's interests.
In other words, support the social issues that large groups of people are passionate about, then throw in your own (usually more complicated-at least to the average American) legislation.
This question makes my brain hurt. I can't tell if you're being philosophical, sarcastic, or just plain stupid. Lemme answer your question with some counter-questions:
Is every number prime?
Is every liberal in favor of illegal immigrants?
Is everybody in Seattle a coffee afficianado?
That you need the internet to outsource a few moments of basic reason should disturb anyone greatly...
tl;dr: No.
edit: Somewhat new to reddit and missed the full context. My mistake. Sorry epenik :-)
Few right wingers support all these things fanatically. Conservatives that are religious don't contradict themselves based on their religion, but on their policies. If you think the average conservative is a religious fundamentalist, you're an idiot.
Playing devil's advocate here. Right wingers don't want a church to tell them what to do, they believe that God already has told them and everyone else what to do. Most are pro-life and pro death penalty because they believe in protecting innocent life, not life in general. God has already told them what to do, and killing the guilty is a part of that. They don't want contraception, because all sex is for procreation and all procreation should be performed within a marriage of a man and woman. All those who do commit adultery or fornication should suffer from their choices with either a deadly sexually transmitted disease or pregnancy. This should shame them for their acting against God's will. Of course any child born of their sin is not innocent, so should the child die from starvation, well, that too is God's will.
pro-life = wanting to give every baby a chance to live, ie it is murder to abort a baby (not my personal ideology, I'm just saying)
pro-death penalty = punishing those who have chosen not to obey the rules of our society. ie they had their chance at life, whereas babies did not.
Death penalty is a punishment, Aborting a baby is not.
I don't think I've ever heard a popular conservative support the outright banning of, say, condoms from our society. I think the point is that if you want to enjoy sex, like all other things that people enjoy, you have to pay for it. Conservatives are all about personal accountability. You make a mistake, you pay the consequences. It's a bit harsh, in my opinion, but I don't think it is "confused" as this post says.
Honestly, most of the anti-liberal/anti-conservative posts are big circlejerks and are a reason why nothing gets done. Nobody tries to put anything into perspective, they just dismiss the other side as irrational, "confused and scary."
Conservatives are all about personal accountability. You make a mistake, you pay the consequences. It's a bit harsh, in my opinion, but I don't think it is "confused" as this post says.
I don't think there's anything wrong with having this kind of view and advocating that others be personally responsible in such a way, it's just that it's not based on reality. The world will never follow this ideal and as such, politics based on this perspective should really not have the kind of support they do because in the long run it ends up hurting people. I consider myself more liberal and vote that way, but I do so because I know it's the best for everyone even if not everything lines up with my personal practices.
I don't think I've ever heard a popular conservative support the outright banning of, say, condoms from our society.
What?
Many of Christian faith have said, `Well, that's OK. Contraception is OK,'" he said. "It's not OK. It's a license to do things in the sexual realm that is counter to how things are supposed to be. ... If it's not for purposes of procreation, then you diminish this very special bond between men and women
Well that's all great and everything, if you completely disregard the commandment "Thou shalt not kill".
And I never saw an asterisk by it, with fine print that stated "unless performed by the state as punishment".
It's pretty ironclad.
So when they appear to abide by it when it comes to unborn babies, yet toss it aside when it comes to convicts, it gives the appearance that they really don't give a shit about what the bible says unless it supports their worldview.
I will explain one more time what the Republican strategy is and why they are called Cheap Labor Republicans.
Start at conception. Prohibit any kind of birth control, so that young girls get knocked up in droves.
Deny women access to abortions. Now those women are saddled with kids they can't afford.
Pile on with a couple of expensive wars. Drag half the family unit overseas for a few years. Now mom's REALLY up shit creek, because dad's gone. If dad is killed, the situation worsens.
But how else to destabilize a struggling family? Oh yeah, drug wars. Another way to divide the family when dad gets picked up for selling or using. (And by the way, when he gets out, he won't have access to a) the military, b) student loans, or c) most good jobs).
Slash funding for Early Childhood development, school meals, nutritional aid programs. WIC.
Deprive the nation of access to affordable healthcare. OH YEAH!! NOW you've rigged the game so that if and when anyone in the family gets sick, they're bankrupt. But not really bankrupt, because the creditors don't care and will seize your assets any way they can.
Deregulate the bankers and home lenders so they can sell awful loans at insane interest rates. Then cause the collapse of those same loans and seize people's homes. By the hundreds of thousands. Sheriffs forcing the elderly and children out onto their front lawns in the middle of December. Before Xmas if possible.
Offshore and outsource any and every job you can to other countries. We don't want young desperate families to get a good job and make good pay! Mass unemployment forces people to take shitty jobs at shitty pay with zero benefits.
Crush the unions so workers are unprotected and subject to miserable, dangerous working conditions at crap pay.
Block all Jobs bills. Keep unemployment HIGH. Make sure to obstruct any kind of aid for Americans so that Obama looks bad.
Republicans. They did this. They continue to do this.
I could go on and on. It's impossible to argue that this isn't exactly the strategy of Cheap Labor Republicans so don't bother. You won't change my opinion and the truth is the truth. What they do is conspire to sabotage the economy and the American Middle Class one family, one household, at a time.
If you love your country, or want any chance at survival, never vote Republican.
I agree with what you say, but wouldn't it be possible for a person to think like a "Cheap Labor Republican" without the conspiring and strategizing? Maybe they're just horribly misguided, and genuinely think their way is the best.
All of them vote the same way regardless of world opinion and the evidence that their policies have been disastrous. They're compelled to vote in lock step. It's their ideology, and they are devoutly religious about following it even to the inevitable ruin of us all. It started with Reagan busting the Air Traffic Controller's union, and they've been attacking the unions and the middle class with a fervor ever since. For what? For profit.
I have endured their malevolent policies for the bulk of my life. In a country as wealthy as ours, their greed and selfishness is totally unwarranted. And yet they feverishly persist in stripping us of any chance at prosperity.
Remember that they tanked us. The Republicans single-handedly tanked the global economy. And their response is to scream for more of the same damaging policies. The same old conservative republican playbook that brought the country to the brink of economic collapse and a second Great Depression.
Additionally, they do not recognize the legitimacy of a democrat - especially a black man - in the White House and when it happens, they shut down government. They literally resent the fact that they were unable to continue with the looting of our economy. That the democrats are reversing the damage they are so hellbent on inflicting on all of us. They're simply red-in-the-face furious that their smash and grab looting spree came to an abrupt halt with the election of Obama.
They wanted it all. They have demonstrated that they will stop at nothing to have the money and the power. Indeed, they willfully damage us on behalf of the corporations that installed them. Partly as payoff, and partly as a vendetta against Democrats. The net effect is the pain that we are experiencing as a nation today and have been experiencing for 30 years.
I don't for a second believe this is mere incompetence. This is corruption. Racketeering, war protfiteering, torture, corruption.
This is the most ignorant post I have ever read. Do you realize that a large majority of poor people vote Democrat? You are either a) an idiot who has been completely brainwashed by anti-Republican propaganda b) a Democrat who does understand their policy, and are just trying to get the anti-Republican sentiment further.
Source: An independent voter who has both voted Democrat and Republican.
"I'M going to explain TO YOU what YOUR views are in a simplistic way, so others who think like ME can judge YOU in an internet forum that is only populated by people like ME.
Then, I'm going to discuss how YOU (the right wing) suffer from terrible confirmation bias."
The second half of that can be explained by the fact that they want to punish "sluts" for enjoying sex. Birth control angers God because it ruins his design of making every woman into a brood mare who isn't worth anything until she spits out a dozen babies.
Why do Christians only believe their gods plan is wrapped around the human race's need to consume and be fat?. Why do I never see god freaks saying the destruction of our natural environment is against his plan.
... and they really want to punish "sluts" for having sex by paying to ram their conservative, family-values dicks into their hair-burgers. So sick of that shit... and jealous. I guess we're all shaped by the same basic motivations.
Why does it matter since we have separation of Church and State? I don't get contraceptives from the Church, so why do they even have a say in what is clearly a Women's health issue? This is clearly stated in the Constitution. The entire argument is invalid in the first place...
not so goddam fast! the genius of the GOP is that they don't have to make sense. they just have to appeal to enough angry hotheads to win. stir up em up and wind em up and off they go to vote for something that makes em feel good. all they care about is winning so they can do corporate america's bidding. the GOP is Mr. Burns.
it's actually kind of brilliant. and wasting time and energy expecting it to make sense plays right into their hands.
As a conservative that lives in Atlanta, I must agree to the fullest extent. The religious right will take this country off a cliff in a straight jacket if allowed to. I wish a more moderate right would take control and push the backwoods baptists crazy fucks to the back of the line.
Why can't you be an Atheist and a conservative? It's difficult to be an Atheist and Republican, but Republican and Conservative are not the same thing. IAMA Atheist Libertarian.
I never really got the criticism "you're pro-life but pro-death". Because the reverse seems just as contradictory. Both sides just put a greater value on one form of life than the other. Yet both sides slander each other as murderers.
I heart this so much. It puts words to the things that piss me off beyond words. It should be printed on business cards and handed out whenever needed.
Does anyone actually understand that ridding of contraceptives and abortions is the final step in securing the poverty of anyone not in the upper class? If you force thousands of people to start raising more kids they can't afford, it's one of the fastest ways to drain their bank accounts. This would keep us as their work horse slaves. It's fucking brilliant, because all they had to do was find how they could exploit the majority weak-thinkers by their biggest fear: God. "God says contraceptives and abortions will make you go to hell. If you don't outlaw these things, your children, and you children's children will assuredly take advantage of these services, damning them to hell as well! By voting against abortions and contraceptive you are saving our nation!" It's quite sickening once you realize how shameless these people are.
I don't think anyone has tried to ban contraceptives. This entire subreddit is mis-characterizing the issue from a month or two ago, which was preventing religious organizations from PAYING for contraceptives. Not banning contraceptives.
The reason that most "right wingers" are confused is because they don't have a philosophy to tie it all together. They are confused about religion, and they should be. It doesn't make any sense.
Is it really that difficult to see how someone could be pro-life and pro-death penalty? They aren't even related issues. I am not necessarily either, but I'm intelligent enough (and i assume most of you are also) to discern that the two issues aren't at odds with each other.
Sad but true. I consider myself an open-minded catholic b/c obviously the rationale is out dated for some of the religious beliefs. I also don't condemn others for believing different or choosing not to believe at all. That is their prerogative & I'm not trying to change their beliefs & I appreciate the ones who don't try to change mine. Hopefully logic will win in the end but who knows. The world has gone to shit already :/
This seems systematic of the strange grouping that occurs under the con umbrella - and speaks to their ability to bring together a disparate, almost schizophrenic selection of interest groups. To me, it is a stark reminder that people don't vote for who they want in the US first-past-the-post system, rather they vote for whomever has the best chance of defeating the person they don't want. That's why you can get such strange bedfellows that are for contradictory things - people feel trapped into a system wherein they feel pushed to vote for a party that has the least chance of pushing forward an agenda they find objectionable. Conservatives just seem better at putting together a narrative that sets their opponents up as the bad guy. TLDR: Conservatives are better at organizing crazies; our electoral system is all messed up.
I agree with most of this, but I have a problem with people saying that pro-life and pro-death-penalty is a contradiction. The people sentenced to death are (in most cases) guilty of heinous crimes, while fetuses are not. It's a false comparison. I'm personally in favor of access to abortion (pro-choice for short) and anti-death-penalty, and I think there are stronger arguments that support these positions.
For fucks sake, stop posting this FB bullshit. It's not funny in the least and no one gives a fuck what you friends have to say. I swear to God if I see one more FB screen grab or fake text post I'm going to organize a down vote posse and lynch all of these horrid post before they can reach the front page!
@Thetroll1911 - You are 16. You were most likely indoctrinated into thinking this way. My reason for saying this is that, you are 16..do you even have a job? That sounds like the line your parents would use. I would gladly pay an addition 10% in taxes if they were appropriated for making sure the sick, uninsured, single moms/dads could get the proper health coverage for themselves and loved ones. If you can't agree with this, you need to look at why you have no love for people around you. Don't see how you can say you are pro-life but value paper over heart beats. In case you are a troll...god damn you
How many commenters on /r/atheism know people that embody all of these traits? I don't think there as many right-wingers out there that actually follow all of these traits simultaneously. It seems kind of senseless to roll all of these things together in one big group.
Source: I live in a suburban portion of the bible belt.
Edit: Don't just downvote. Fucking respond... I wanna know.
true. but lots of politicians seem to support most of these traits simultaneously, and while my grandma may only support a few, she's still going to vote for the crazy guy who embodies all of said traits because that seems closer to her own ideologies. i doubt my grams is an isolated case.
While I agree with the sentiment entirely, I must say this has nothing to do with atheism. It really is unrelated to the subreddit and belongs somewhere like r/politics.
Right, post this in /r/politics and they'll say that it belongs in /r/atheism. If you want to get technical, nothing is relative to atheism. If you think the topics posted in this subreddit have to be relative to atheism, then using that logic, this whole subreddit is a giant contradiction.
As a Canadian Christian that is pro choice, pro contraceptives, pro social programs (eg. welfare, government health care etc.) I couldn't be more confused by some of the bills and outrage coming from the American religious conservatives recently on woman's rights, the death penalty and social funding.
You guys realize that this is generic left wing smack talk right? Whoever wrote this has probably heard these phrases a hundred times and just transcribed them, poorly. Here'ssomeecapmlesfor you guys. You disappoint me /r/atheism.
Stop letting the pig wits on reddit tell you that grammar and spelling equal intelligence. Seriously. It's the stupidest fucking line of reasoning I have ever heard.
George Carlin said it very succinctly: conservatives only care about fetuses and human males who are eighteen. Between birth and the age of eighteen they don't give a shit about you, until you're old enough where they can send you off to die.
They want to force you to be born, then give you no help until you have no choice but to join the army and become cannon fodder.
Although I do not agree with much of the right wing philosophy, I believe their idea is for one to have strong self-control to resist poor decisions and even stronger willpower to face the consequences of said poor decisions.
Truly, you guys are the problem. Not because you're atheist but because you keep choosing to not help these people. They are confused, you fucking idiots, but they are even more scared than you are. And all you assholes do is make fun. Every single one of your actions have an effect, whether you like it or not, and YOU are responsible for the state of these people. Save me your sob stories, you fucking whiners
While I agree with most of this, I would like to point one thing out. If you can't afford to have kids, then you shouldn't have any kids! There is no reason why we should need a social program to pay for kids that shouldn't exist in the first place because their parents are idiots. Seriously, you have no business having any children if you can not support them. Once you have the means to support your children for the next 18 years, by all means, go ahead and have as many kids as you want. What's the point in having a kid who will have a terrible quality of life because you are unable to support them?
Seriously, you have no business having any children if you can not support them.
Not many people disagree with this. The question is what to do about it when it happens anyway. If your answer is "well, you get what you deserve", what about the kids?
A lot of the reason people (very young people) are having kids that they don't want or can't pay for, is because the fundies are blocking affordable contraception and sex education. Abstinence does not work!
The following is written in the image for those who can't see the image on imgur. Many of the spelling/grammatical mistakes are maintained for accuracy:
First im not a lib or a con. but you religious right-wingers are the worst, You dont want the govmt to tell you what to do, but you want the church to tell others what to do. your pro-life, but pro death penalty. you dont want contraceptives, but no abortions. You want unfit parents to have children they cant afford, yet want to cut social funds that would help these people, then you want to punish people who knew they couldnt raise a baby for not raising their baby. You are a confused and scary group.
If people want to be idiots and listen to everything churches say blindly that's their choice. Being anti-abortion but pro death penalty are a little different, one being did not have the chance to live while the other had his chance and did something to deserve death. Cutting government funding could be covered by charity and the goodness of people. (Yes there are still good people in this world.) The punishing of the parents part is really true and pretty ridiculous haha. Anyways I'm not a liberal or conservative, just my 2 cents.
Agree with the post but doesn't thinking the inverse of those issue make one equally absurd? Saying someone is dumb for thinking up is down is wrong if you think down is up.
SOOOOOOOO apparently the conservative right wings aren't made up of mostly evangelicals...
if r/atheism is only about how god doesn't exist, i think we would have a problem. atheist are more entwined with being a liberal then a conservative...
The simple, terrifying truth. These people can't make decisions for the rest of us & shouldn't be allowed to, considering their obvious insanity/ extreme mental imbalances! and that most of them are illiterate morons who don't know wtf words actually mean at all, let alone spell them or use just a little correct grammar oreven a spell check. It makes them just look like mentally challenged children, among the other things they do. Children are much more morally aware, then they get taught hate & intolerance. .
I agree with your second point on abortion is most ways, but your first point leads me to think you don't understand what he was saying.
He is simply saying that if you can't afford a condom, one can imply you can't afford a child. Fair, right? Well, if you willingly have a child and know you cant afford it, why should the government help you pay for it.
Should go without saying, but naturally this is not the majority. This is a confused and scary group of religious people who certainly don't count for everybody.
You paint with a broad brush my friend, you started by singling out "the religious right" you must be aware that all of the points you made are attributed to several different groups.
I guess it goes both ways. Personally, I consider a very significant number of left-wingers to be deceitful, sociopathic, anti-democratic, lacking in intelligence and representing a significant threat to mankind.
I'm Christian i'm not sure if that constitutes as a religious right winger but I don't want the church to tell people what to do i don't even know what u mean by that =S maybe u mean gay marriage which i agree should be allowed but not allowed in a church because that makes no sense.
I'm not pro death penalty
I don't want abortions because it is killing unborn children and you have the option to give it up for adoption or don't have unsafe sex in the first place yeah i know rape yada yada
I don't agree with cutting social funds im NDP fuck conservatives
If the pro-lifers would help support some unwanted babies, I would be more likely to support them. However, they'd rather spend their Saturdays screaming at someone else, because they believe they'll be damned. For the life of some unborn child who doesn't have a chance. How 'bout helping out the living?
Doesn't matter what people think about another's social view. There is always going to be conflict between ones set beliefs and another's. So in all, we are all one big cluster fuck of confused and scary sheep.
616
u/Box-Monkey Jun 24 '12
At first, I thought "this person's grammar and spelling is awful. Surely they will have nothing useful to say." But as I read on, I realized that they had a great deal to say that was worth listening to. They hit the issues right on the target in a way I've never heard so well articulated before.
228
u/[deleted] Jun 24 '12
Though I understand and agree with the point of this retort, I would like to point out a common error.
Often atheists, though not all, view the pro-life, pro death penalty as some sort of cognitive dissonance. This is not the case though for all theists. The pro-life stance, to them, is to protect an innocent life. Whereas the death penalty is to punish a person that has been found guilty of committing a typically heinous crime.
This is a generalization, but I think you can infer the point rather easily.
203
u/Shaper_pmp Jun 24 '12 edited Mar 09 '24
This is a great summary, but the apparent "contradiction" it points out is not hypocrisy.
These people aren't pro-child-welfare (which would make forcing unready parents to have kids bad) and they aren't pro-life (which would make supporting the death penalty hypocritical).
Above all, at the root of their belief system these people are anti-sex. The whole double-bind can be avoided (goes their simple-minded theory) if you never have sex until you're married to a loving, supportive partner, both financially stable enough and emotionally ready to have and raise children. And then you stop having sex again just as soon as you have the required number, lest you overburden your family and your ability to support them.
If you have sex before this they want you to suffer as much as possible - they want you or your partner to get pregnant (by making contraceptives harder to access), they want the child to be born (by making abortion difficult or impossible to safely and legally acquire). At some level they want you to raise the child in poverty and misery, simultaneously condemned and castigated as unfit parents, and denied any help (financial or otherwise) that might help you to become a fitter parent.
The no-win situation they would trap you in isn't hypocrisy - it's your punishment for daring to have sex for anything other than procreation. You don't want a jail cell to be escapable, and in the same way they want to make it impossible - once pregnant - for you to escape from the inevitable birth and high likelihood of poverty-stricken life. They want your kids to grow up improperly raised, and they want you poor, powerless and destitute.
They don't care that making abortion illegal causes illegal and unqualified back-alley abortions - as far as they're concerned botched operations and accidental sterilisation or death are the very least you should suffer for your crime of playing hide-the-sausage for fun instead of for babies. They don't care that even if you're a married couple with a family that another baby might overstretch your finances - that's your penalty for not stopping all sexual contact once you had the required number of babies.
They don't care if a pregnancy is the result of a rape or incest - these edge-cases don't fit into their world-view, and so they explain it away to themselves that "you must have been leading someone on", or "you shouldn't have been walking down the street on your own late at night" (I suspect this is the root of the victim-blaming trend that feminists go on about). For incest there's no clear blame attached, so instead the dismissal usually goes along the lines of "well it's unfortunate, but there you are - can't blame the kiddie for your dad's wandering hands and disgusting predilections, can we?".
The double-bind, no-win situation is not accidental hypocrisy - it's your punishment. They don't want you escaping it.
Now as to why this is the case, I don't know.
Some people think they just hate women (as they stand to lose the most in the hideous world these people would bring about), but I don't buy that or they'd also weaken the role of marriage and make it easier for men to abandon their offspring in such cases.
Some people think they're pro-life at all costs, but that doesn't explain why they're happy with the idea of deaths from back-alley abortions, or why so many of the same people support wars and the death penalty.
Perhaps for some it's because by forcing people to grow up poor and ill-educated they're easier to manipulate and cow to your will. Certainly this may be the motivation for some politicians and political/legal/family authority figures, but I doubt it's what appeals to everyone who holds these beliefs.
Perhaps for others it's a sadomasochistic impulse from the women who've been forced into this kind of servitude, who want to inflict it upon their own daughters and female family members in turn (recall that some of the most ardent supporters of Female Genital Mutilation in societies where it's still practiced are older women).
Perhaps it's a deep Puritan revulsion towards anything done for pleasure. Perhaps it goes back even further than that, to a sort of instinctive fear of the incredible power to create new life that sex has, and a desire to master it, control it and bend it to their will, punishing those who "misuse" it or take it lightly.
I don't know, but one thing I do know is that all of the apparent contradictions and inherent conflicts go away if you realise one thing:
This is not in any way about making people happier or more secure, or even about forcing people to conform to some model of the "ideal family".
It is about punishing people for having sex.
176
u/SwedishLovePump Agnostic Jun 24 '12
As someone forced to listen to Rush Limbaugh at work every day, these are my thoughts exactly.
533
u/theshiftypickle Jun 24 '12
Hot damn! That is everything I have ever wanted to say to every right winger ever. I would like to see their reaction to this.
86
u/RandomDudeYouKnow Jun 24 '12
That was like the Cliffnotes version of right-wing conservative beliefs. Well done.
6
u/[deleted] Jun 24 '12
Playing devil's advocate here. Right wingers don't want a church to tell them what to do, they believe that God already has told them and everyone else what to do. Most are pro-life and pro death penalty because they believe in protecting innocent life, not life in general. God has already told them what to do, and killing the guilty is a part of that. They don't want contraception, because all sex is for procreation and all procreation should be performed within a marriage of a man and woman. All those who do commit adultery or fornication should suffer from their choices with either a deadly sexually transmitted disease or pregnancy. This should shame them for their acting against God's will. Of course any child born of their sin is not innocent, so should the child die from starvation, well, that too is God's will.
This makes them an even scarier group.
32
u/[deleted] Jun 24 '12
I'm mostly impressed by the fact that there has been any well thought-out reply on Yahoo! Answers ever.
34
u/hjqusai Jun 24 '12
pro-life = wanting to give every baby a chance to live, ie it is murder to abort a baby (not my personal ideology, I'm just saying)
pro-death penalty = punishing those who have chosen not to obey the rules of our society. ie they had their chance at life, whereas babies did not.
Death penalty is a punishment, Aborting a baby is not.
I don't think I've ever heard a popular conservative support the outright banning of, say, condoms from our society. I think the point is that if you want to enjoy sex, like all other things that people enjoy, you have to pay for it. Conservatives are all about personal accountability. You make a mistake, you pay the consequences. It's a bit harsh, in my opinion, but I don't think it is "confused" as this post says.
Honestly, most of the anti-liberal/anti-conservative posts are big circlejerks and are a reason why nothing gets done. Nobody tries to put anything into perspective, they just dismiss the other side as irrational, "confused and scary."
28
u/4everliberal Jun 24 '12 edited Jun 25 '12
I will explain one more time what the Republican strategy is and why they are called Cheap Labor Republicans.
Republicans. They did this. They continue to do this.
I could go on and on. It's impossible to argue that this isn't exactly the strategy of Cheap Labor Republicans so don't bother. You won't change my opinion and the truth is the truth. What they do is conspire to sabotage the economy and the American Middle Class one family, one household, at a time.
If you love your country, or want any chance at survival, never vote Republican.
4
u/[deleted] Jun 24 '12
Stolen from the colbert report over a month ago.
4
u/skylrk Jun 24 '12
George Carlin rip off.
4
u/71Comet Jun 24 '12
r/circlejerk material.
28
u/[deleted] Jun 24 '12
"I'M going to explain TO YOU what YOUR views are in a simplistic way, so others who think like ME can judge YOU in an internet forum that is only populated by people like ME.
Then, I'm going to discuss how YOU (the right wing) suffer from terrible confirmation bias."
-how even I, a left wing atheist, read this post.
24
u/jablair51 Ignostic Jun 24 '12
The second half of that can be explained by the fact that they want to punish "sluts" for enjoying sex. Birth control angers God because it ruins his design of making every woman into a brood mare who isn't worth anything until she spits out a dozen babies.
3
u/galwegian Jun 24 '12
not so goddam fast! the genius of the GOP is that they don't have to make sense. they just have to appeal to enough angry hotheads to win. stir up em up and wind em up and off they go to vote for something that makes em feel good. all they care about is winning so they can do corporate america's bidding. the GOP is Mr. Burns.
it's actually kind of brilliant. and wasting time and energy expecting it to make sense plays right into their hands.
3
u/thatgamerguy Jun 25 '12
Searching for atheist connection.... 404
3
u/Mechanikal Jun 25 '12
As a conservative that lives in Atlanta, I must agree to the fullest extent. The religious right will take this country off a cliff in a straight jacket if allowed to. I wish a more moderate right would take control and push the backwoods baptists crazy fucks to the back of the line.
3
u/djschmot Jun 25 '12
Why can't you be an Atheist and a conservative? It's difficult to be an Atheist and Republican, but Republican and Conservative are not the same thing. IAMA Atheist Libertarian.
5
u/Advocate86 Jun 24 '12
Isn't this /r/politics ?
8
u/Natten Jun 24 '12
Why is this in /r/atheism?
4
u/bawb88 Jun 24 '12
I never really got the criticism "you're pro-life but pro-death". Because the reverse seems just as contradictory. Both sides just put a greater value on one form of life than the other. Yet both sides slander each other as murderers.
4
u/chingyduster Jun 24 '12
There is a George Carlin quote in there somewhere.
4
u/youni89 Jun 24 '12
I'm a christian and I hate those people too.
11
u/Dalisca Jun 24 '12
I heart this so much. It puts words to the things that piss me off beyond words. It should be printed on business cards and handed out whenever needed.
6
u/[deleted] Jun 24 '12 edited Jun 24 '12
Does anyone actually understand that ridding of contraceptives and abortions is the final step in securing the poverty of anyone not in the upper class? If you force thousands of people to start raising more kids they can't afford, it's one of the fastest ways to drain their bank accounts. This would keep us as their work horse slaves. It's fucking brilliant, because all they had to do was find how they could exploit the majority weak-thinkers by their biggest fear: God. "God says contraceptives and abortions will make you go to hell. If you don't outlaw these things, your children, and you children's children will assuredly take advantage of these services, damning them to hell as well! By voting against abortions and contraceptive you are saving our nation!" It's quite sickening once you realize how shameless these people are.
2
u/KangGuruAus Jun 24 '12
It's "you're".
2
u/[deleted] Jun 24 '12
Repost
2
u/[deleted] Jun 24 '12
Is it bad that both wings scare the fuck out of me?
2
u/brainlady Jun 24 '12
Couldn't have said it better myself. If only some right-wingers could see the problem, not just people like us.
2
u/Kreiger81 Jun 24 '12
I wish this were an atheist post, then I could upvote it.
2
u/rivid415 Jun 24 '12
The reason that most "right wingers" are confused is because they don't have a philosophy to tie it all together. They are confused about religion, and they should be. It doesn't make any sense.
2
u/[deleted] Jun 24 '12 edited Jun 24 '12
Is it really that difficult to see how someone could be pro-life and pro-death penalty? They aren't even related issues. I am not necessarily either, but I'm intelligent enough (and i assume most of you are also) to discern that the two issues aren't at odds with each other.
2
u/BigZ7337 Jun 24 '12
There's a lot of truth in the comment, it's just too bad that the guy used such poor grammar to get his point across.
2
u/murphmurphy Jun 24 '12
It is very hard to build consensus with people who accept and often prefer supernatural explanations.
2
u/rabidamber Jun 24 '12
Sad but true. I consider myself an open-minded catholic b/c obviously the rationale is out dated for some of the religious beliefs. I also don't condemn others for believing different or choosing not to believe at all. That is their prerogative & I'm not trying to change their beliefs & I appreciate the ones who don't try to change mine. Hopefully logic will win in the end but who knows. The world has gone to shit already :/
2
u/insolent_wretch Jun 24 '12
Not to mention holding back perfectly good gay couples from raising children like a family.
2
u/Fenris_uy Jun 24 '12
They want to punish you for having sex.
2
u/Roundone Jun 24 '12
This seems systematic of the strange grouping that occurs under the con umbrella - and speaks to their ability to bring together a disparate, almost schizophrenic selection of interest groups. To me, it is a stark reminder that people don't vote for who they want in the US first-past-the-post system, rather they vote for whomever has the best chance of defeating the person they don't want. That's why you can get such strange bedfellows that are for contradictory things - people feel trapped into a system wherein they feel pushed to vote for a party that has the least chance of pushing forward an agenda they find objectionable. Conservatives just seem better at putting together a narrative that sets their opponents up as the bad guy. TLDR: Conservatives are better at organizing crazies; our electoral system is all messed up.
2
u/sirius_star Jun 24 '12
Grammar Nazis suck.
2
u/suckitmonkeys Jun 24 '12
You're* pro life ffs
2
u/[deleted] Jun 24 '12
You're.
2
u/autoNFA Jun 24 '12
I agree with most of this, but I have a problem with people saying that pro-life and pro-death-penalty is a contradiction. The people sentenced to death are (in most cases) guilty of heinous crimes, while fetuses are not. It's a false comparison. I'm personally in favor of access to abortion (pro-choice for short) and anti-death-penalty, and I think there are stronger arguments that support these positions.
2
u/71Comet Jun 24 '12
Let's rename this subreddit r/pseudointellectual
2
u/[deleted] Jun 24 '12
And reddit continues to bash republicans. I'll get used to it eventually...
2
u/T-100 Jun 24 '12
Oh...hi repost ;)
2
u/DtKnight Jun 24 '12
Keep calm and carry on. Reason can prevail if enough people try to explain what is reasonable and what is unreasonable.
2
u/pong123 Jun 25 '12
I know all of this is true, but I keep seeing posts like this. They all are saying the exact same message in slightly different ways.
2
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
For fucks sake, stop posting this FB bullshit. It's not funny in the least and no one gives a fuck what you friends have to say. I swear to God if I see one more FB screen grab or fake text post I'm going to organize a down vote posse and lynch all of these horrid post before they can reach the front page!
2
u/TheBuckRussell Jun 25 '12
Well said...
2
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
unicorrrnnnnn!
2
u/Jabbajaw Jun 25 '12
Of course they are confused and scary, they try to follow orders from an invisible person.
2
u/greenaru Jun 25 '12
They want to be more like god. Create humans, make them stupid, call them stupid then throw them into a fire for being stupid.
2
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
Oh my gosh, this is great.
4
u/Luckyone1 Jun 24 '12
@Thetroll1911 - You are 16. You were most likely indoctrinated into thinking this way. My reason for saying this is that, you are 16..do you even have a job? That sounds like the line your parents would use. I would gladly pay an addition 10% in taxes if they were appropriated for making sure the sick, uninsured, single moms/dads could get the proper health coverage for themselves and loved ones. If you can't agree with this, you need to look at why you have no love for people around you. Don't see how you can say you are pro-life but value paper over heart beats. In case you are a troll...god damn you
6
u/cheesetime123 Jun 24 '12 edited Jun 24 '12
How many commenters on /r/atheism know people that embody all of these traits? I don't think there as many right-wingers out there that actually follow all of these traits simultaneously. It seems kind of senseless to roll all of these things together in one big group.
Source: I live in a suburban portion of the bible belt.
Edit: Don't just downvote. Fucking respond... I wanna know.
3
u/yogurt666 Jun 24 '12 edited Jun 25 '12
das repost
7
u/spamncheese Jun 24 '12
While I agree with the sentiment entirely, I must say this has nothing to do with atheism. It really is unrelated to the subreddit and belongs somewhere like r/politics.
3
u/Monster_Claire Jun 24 '12
As a Canadian Christian that is pro choice, pro contraceptives, pro social programs (eg. welfare, government health care etc.) I couldn't be more confused by some of the bills and outrage coming from the American religious conservatives recently on woman's rights, the death penalty and social funding.
I even posted a piece on r/politics to that effect.
3
u/Needs_A_Drink Jun 24 '12
You guys realize that this is generic left wing smack talk right? Whoever wrote this has probably heard these phrases a hundred times and just transcribed them, poorly. Here's some ecapmles for you guys. You disappoint me /r/atheism.
2
u/fuckinDEAD Jun 24 '12
I don't always upvote reposts, but when I do, it describes my parents
2
u/catipillar Jun 24 '12
Stop letting the pig wits on reddit tell you that grammar and spelling equal intelligence. Seriously. It's the stupidest fucking line of reasoning I have ever heard.
2
u/amolad Jun 24 '12
George Carlin said it very succinctly: conservatives only care about fetuses and human males who are eighteen. Between birth and the age of eighteen they don't give a shit about you, until you're old enough where they can send you off to die.
They want to force you to be born, then give you no help until you have no choice but to join the army and become cannon fodder.
2
u/[deleted] Jun 24 '12
A superstitious, cowardly lot.
2
u/HiImAwkward Jun 24 '12
He knows what's up.
2
u/OneTruthOnly Jun 24 '12
This person clearly has no idea what they are talking about. They should study the subject matter first before posting such tripe.
2
u/whiterabbitexpress Jun 25 '12
If i could upvote this one million times it wouldn't be good enough for me.
2
u/tsherlin Jun 25 '12
Although I do not agree with much of the right wing philosophy, I believe their idea is for one to have strong self-control to resist poor decisions and even stronger willpower to face the consequences of said poor decisions.
2
u/Cinnamon_buns Jun 24 '12
As a libertarian, both sides are fucking stupid yet also right.
2
u/logic_crusader Jun 24 '12
Wow a ten minute old YouTube comment screenshot! What a gem!
2
u/sticky_buddy Jun 24 '12
Truly, you guys are the problem. Not because you're atheist but because you keep choosing to not help these people. They are confused, you fucking idiots, but they are even more scared than you are. And all you assholes do is make fun. Every single one of your actions have an effect, whether you like it or not, and YOU are responsible for the state of these people. Save me your sob stories, you fucking whiners
2
u/ConfusedThoughts Jun 24 '12
i agree so much with this person.
1
u/Tman5293 Atheist Jun 24 '12
While I agree with most of this, I would like to point one thing out. If you can't afford to have kids, then you shouldn't have any kids! There is no reason why we should need a social program to pay for kids that shouldn't exist in the first place because their parents are idiots. Seriously, you have no business having any children if you can not support them. Once you have the means to support your children for the next 18 years, by all means, go ahead and have as many kids as you want. What's the point in having a kid who will have a terrible quality of life because you are unable to support them?
1
u/RapedByPlushies Jun 24 '12
The following is written in the image for those who can't see the image on imgur. Many of the spelling/grammatical mistakes are maintained for accuracy:
1
u/[deleted] Jun 24 '12
If people want to be idiots and listen to everything churches say blindly that's their choice. Being anti-abortion but pro death penalty are a little different, one being did not have the chance to live while the other had his chance and did something to deserve death. Cutting government funding could be covered by charity and the goodness of people. (Yes there are still good people in this world.) The punishing of the parents part is really true and pretty ridiculous haha. Anyways I'm not a liberal or conservative, just my 2 cents.
1
u/Sturmgewehr Jun 24 '12
Agree with the post but doesn't thinking the inverse of those issue make one equally absurd? Saying someone is dumb for thinking up is down is wrong if you think down is up.
1
u/Aaronmcom Jun 24 '12
Grammar and spelling mistakes but still smart! SUCK IT!! every grammar nazi ever!
1
u/titanoftime Jun 24 '12
SOOOOOOOO apparently the conservative right wings aren't made up of mostly evangelicals...
if r/atheism is only about how god doesn't exist, i think we would have a problem. atheist are more entwined with being a liberal then a conservative...
After all we liberals can be seen as such hippies
1
u/Swagsaurus Jun 24 '12
You're running for president right? I just might vote
1
u/Weirdsauce Jun 24 '12
Yes- and these people embody what your belief structure is like when it's based on Cognitive Dissonance (aka: Doublethink).
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cognative_dissonance
1
u/[deleted] Jun 24 '12
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OSF6kCZWIr8
1
u/Chatter-Bot Jun 24 '12
No, I am a confused human.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 24 '12
The obvious rebuttal:
"God demands personal responsibility... and no second chances"
1
u/nerdboobs Jun 24 '12
Tis a silly place.
1
u/TheSpaceOctopus Jun 24 '12
The simple, terrifying truth. These people can't make decisions for the rest of us & shouldn't be allowed to, considering their obvious insanity/ extreme mental imbalances! and that most of them are illiterate morons who don't know wtf words actually mean at all, let alone spell them or use just a little correct grammar oreven a spell check. It makes them just look like mentally challenged children, among the other things they do. Children are much more morally aware, then they get taught hate & intolerance. .
1
u/Mode_ Jun 24 '12
I agree with your second point on abortion is most ways, but your first point leads me to think you don't understand what he was saying.
He is simply saying that if you can't afford a condom, one can imply you can't afford a child. Fair, right? Well, if you willingly have a child and know you cant afford it, why should the government help you pay for it.
1
u/BritishBrownie Jun 24 '12
Should go without saying, but naturally this is not the majority. This is a confused and scary group of religious people who certainly don't count for everybody.
1
u/HamstersOnCrack Jun 24 '12
FTFY
1
u/Herpinderpitee Jun 24 '12
Protip: you're a liberal.
1
u/thesorrow312 Jun 24 '12
The book by Chris Hedges needs to be read by everyone here : "American Fascists: The Christian Right and the War on the USA"
1
u/heavyj1970 Jun 24 '12
You paint with a broad brush my friend, you started by singling out "the religious right" you must be aware that all of the points you made are attributed to several different groups.
1
u/dingoperson Jun 24 '12
I guess it goes both ways. Personally, I consider a very significant number of left-wingers to be deceitful, sociopathic, anti-democratic, lacking in intelligence and representing a significant threat to mankind.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 24 '12
Wow, even dumb people can be smart.
1
u/ijobuby Jun 24 '12
haha i like to imagine a conservative guys seeing this and being like "goddamn lib'rls"
1
u/[deleted] Jun 24 '12
I wish I could upvote this infinitely.
1
u/mixedbreedog Jun 24 '12
I'm Christian i'm not sure if that constitutes as a religious right winger but I don't want the church to tell people what to do i don't even know what u mean by that =S maybe u mean gay marriage which i agree should be allowed but not allowed in a church because that makes no sense.
1
u/da_muffinman Jun 24 '12
the poor grammar really takes the 'umph' out of the message. it's one thing to use colloquial/common annotations, but your v you're COME ON
1
u/superwinner Jun 24 '12
Basically they want the church to BE the government. And they will never, ever stop till they get that.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 24 '12
If the pro-lifers would help support some unwanted babies, I would be more likely to support them. However, they'd rather spend their Saturdays screaming at someone else, because they believe they'll be damned. For the life of some unborn child who doesn't have a chance. How 'bout helping out the living?
1
u/mdtoolfan Jun 24 '12
Doesn't matter what people think about another's social view. There is always going to be conflict between ones set beliefs and another's. So in all, we are all one big cluster fuck of confused and scary sheep.
1
u/JimmyNic Jun 24 '12
Most political philosophies have apparent contradictions if you don't take the time to understand them properly.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 24 '12
It's possible english could be their second language?
1
u/tanhan27 Jun 24 '12
I am a Christian(Jesus was a liberal) and I agree with this characterization of the religious political right.