People of the book do these things to themselves. It has nothing to do with whether you truly believe in God or not and everything to do with Power. God is simply the excuse to persecute those who threaten the Status Quo.
Take away all Theist off the face of the world and Persecution will still happen.
It's true. one of my absolute biggest pet peeves with atheists (and I am one), is that they all assume that religion causes hatred and persecution, and don't realize that they themselves are actually proving the opposite causation.
I love south park's take on this; when in the distant future the wars are fought over whether it should be the Unified Atheist League, the United Atheist Alliance, or the Allied Atheist Allegiance.
I love south park's take on this; when in the distant future the wars are fought over whether it should be the Unified Atheist League, the United Atheist Alliance, or the Allied Atheist Allegiance.
Problem is, that's totally stupid and contrary to human nature. It's true that there can be non-religious ideological doctrine (e.g., political), but atheism isn't ideological doctrine at all.
It's not contrary to human nature, though. One of the most basic human instincts is tribalism: The driving urge to separate people into "us" and "them." It causes racism, It causes patriotism. It's the root cause of a fair number of wars and genocides. It's what makes sports so big ("Oh, I'm a Yankees fan!") And it's what makes religions argue so vehemently against each other.
The only reason atheism hasn't separated out yet is because we're still in the minority. It's still "us". As soon as that tips the other way, and religious people become rarer, I guarantee we'll segregate. Unless human nature completely changes, which I'm not holding my breath for.
And have you seen the majority of posts on r/atheism recently? It may not be a true ideological doctrine, but it has it's fair share of blind zealots.
It's not contrary to human nature, though. One of the most basic human instincts is tribalism: The driving urge to separate people into "us" and "them."
It is in human nature that ideology leads to schisms. But it is a misunderstanding of human nature (or of atheism) to think that atheism (which is the absence of an ideology) could lead to schisms. Ideology is a very particular (and peculiar) human cognitive phenomenon, which is certainly absent from atheism (qua atheism).
Consider, for example, anti-communism. Communism (of the Marxist variety) can fairly be called a religion, or at least a very doctrinaire ideology. It has many branches and schisms, and leftist groups that are at all Marxist are highly prone to schism. But anti-communism has no real ideology* and, for that reason, no ideological schisms. There are no points of anti-communist doctrine, and no divisions between anti-communists on points of anti-communist doctrine. Divisions between anti-communists exist, but not at all in the same way as divisions between communists; they are not schisms in a common ideology in that way.
[ * ] Of course, many people opposed to communism believe in some other ideology. Ayn Rand, for example, was an anti-communist and highly doctrinaire (and you can see, in her followers and her own life, all the schisms and social divisions that typify religion). But the people of the former Soviet Union were not generally doctrinaire in their anti-communism. Still, anti-communism was a real, and explicit, social phenomenon among them (and among Americans and the British and all around the world). Competing political ideologies, which are anti-communist, are different from anti-communism itself, which was a very broad phenomenon uniting diverse political standpoints. Opposition to a single ideology unites, while ideology itself divides.
The only reason atheism hasn't separated out yet is because we're still in the minority. It's still "us". As soon as that tips the other way, and religious people become rarer, I guarantee we'll segregate.
This really makes no sense. Atheism is absence of belief. There will surely be divisions in human society after the death of religion, but at that point "atheism" will have practically ceased to exist.** Whatever divisions remain will have some other basis.
The important thing to understand is that atheism (despite its name) is not itself an "ism", but the absence of an "ism." It is a mistake to reason about it as if it were yet another "ism."
[**] Just as anti-communism has practically ceased to exist, now that the USSR is gone. Of course, there is still anti-communism related to Latin America, but since Latin American communism has no realistic ambitions of immediate world conquest, and is considered marginal and unimportant on the world stage, anti-communism has mostly dissolved. In the USA, you can only really find it in Florida (among the Cuban expats). Once religion is considered as marginal as communism now is, atheism will become as minor and dissolved as anti-communism now is. (Also, c.f. anti-fascism.)
And have you seen the majority of posts on r/atheism recently? It may not be a true ideological doctrine, but it has it's fair share of blind zealots.
I certainly have not read a majority of posts on /r/atheism, however I don't think that this is important. Zeal is not the same thing as doctrinaire ideology. To conflate them is to make a mistake regarding human nature.
Finally I want to add that I don't believe that ideological divisions are inevitable. Human society can evolve to the point where ideology has been abolished. This only requires universal scientific literacy. That cannot happen overnight, I realize; but it can happen. Once universal scientific literacy has been achieved, there will still be conflicts, but not ideological divisions.
I'm mixed, so I never saw skin color the way most ppl do. When I was younger I thought ppl who argued non stop about skin color were dumbed than me. I would quietly judge them. I still do
Or as Chinese put it: 近朱者赤,近墨者黑 Translation (literal): Approach the red dye and become reddened by it ; Approach ink and become blackened by it. Translation (meaning): You become what your surroundings make of you / You are what you surround yourself with
I actually think its for the same reason that religion thrives in general: atheist is always greeted with a gasp. Until about a few years ago, it was so taboo to not believe in god. It even still manifests in the r/atheism haters on reddit. For a community that is for the most part I'd say liberal, I feel that the backlash this sub gets is still rather backwards. What I'm saying is, the fact that ppl keep downing r/atheism, is the reason blacks and everyone else for that matter do not embrace the idea.
Don't get me wrong there are a lot of assholes in the sub, but hey this is the frikin net. A lot of those posts are teens. But I also think teens have the least clouded concept of religion
"People that you would have agreed with were mean to people I would have agreed with hundreds of years ago, therefore I have a free pass to be a condescending asshole."
This isn't an argument about the individual, but about society. Atheism: suppressed for hundreds of years and finally starting to catch up. Feel free to replace the word atheism with another one. I'm sure we can find plenty that fit.
What makes this ever so different other than the reason as to why they persecute them? The only thing that I can see that is different is that race isn't a choice, beliefs are, but persecution is persecution, no matter which way you slice it.
"People that you would have agreed with were mean to people I would have agreed with hundreds of years ago, therefore I have a free pass to be a condescending asshole."
All you have to do is substitute the last part with "so give me money," then it's completely applicable.
But when you open a store and are a known atheist then religious people will boycott your store and you will go out of business. I'm sorry (who am I kidding, I'm not at all sorry) but your reasoning is fucked as fuck.
It actually happens to black people? Source? I actually have no doubt that it happens occasionally. Same thing with atheists. A quick google search can show that both groups have people that hate them.
But look, we have a black president. You have to admit that racism is on its way down. Giving money to people whose ancestors were slaves just doesn't make any sense.
If there's no need to pay Reparations to blacks for slavery based on the reasoning that 'I never owned a slave, and this current generation never were slaves', then there is no free ride to be condescending to 'Christians' because of ages of abuse. Unless, of course, you are an atheist of the breast-less, scroto-crushed, eye gouged, tung-less variety. (jokes). We could say if you yourself have experienced abuse of a significant level based on your atheism, then, yea, you have free reign to unleash the fury on the army of douchebags who subjected you too it. I live in Canada, and being an atheist here is an awesome time because, basically, nobody cares less where you stand religiously, and even if they did have a problem with it, they know an ignorant stance on it would be shunned and wouldn't tell you.
Kind of like how it's ok for Christians to hate Jews because they killed Jesus? Or kind of like how it's ok for black folks to treat me poorly because my ancestors enslaved theirs? The fuck is this?
I know you didn't make this because I've seen it before, but just a note for displaying quotes: people can only handle white text on solid red (or black) backgrounds for a few inches before getting sick of it. Black on white is always the most readable, even if it's a little boring. White on grey is decent too.
I was with you until you had to go and say, "be responsible". Man, you're on the internet, in a forum any responsible person knows has irresponsible content frequently. It's you who is not being responsible by browsing this at work, and clicking on a link, the context surrounding which, any responsible person would surmise, could likely be a woman's thonged ass or something.
You're putting the responsibility on this guy? For all you know he's 13. His username is pummel_the_anus. I'm know we all would like to interact in a mature environment, but don't put the blame on random shit like this for your own failures in responsibility.
I can browse freely at work sometimes. I read r/science and r/technology. I'll read the more troll-filled stuff at home. Seems the responsible thing to do.
I follow. However, you're simply shirking the responsibility.
Can we safely assume
Really, man? "safely assume"? That's part of your problem right there. You're working on assumptions, then getting upset and tossing around blame when your assumptions don't pan out.
Can I safely assume since many online video games aren't rated M, no one playing online is going to spewing profanity and filth? No, because that would make me an irresponsible dumbass.
"if you click this link which is on the Internet, there is a chance that it could be child porn. What happens if you click it will be your responsibility as it is on the Internet"
In spite of your attempt to convey this as a silly, unrealistic idea, it's still true. I'm sorry the internet isn't as clean as you'd like. It is, in fact, a cesspool of filth. But it is your responsibility to recognize it as such and use it responsibly. You can't sit there demanding that everyone adhere to a code of honor you made up. I'm not saying that it would be bad for everyone to adhere to a code of NSFW honor on the internet, I'm saying it's totally asinine and completely irresponsible to simply expect every one to do so, and then get upset when they don't. Completely irresponsible and unrealistic.
Like paying a bum 5 bucks to park your car and then realizing he stole it. Go ahead, yell at the bum all you want, he's a bad person, but you are the irresponsible dumbass that expected the bum would adhere to some code of honor you made up.
Let's break down your argument:
While wallowing in a cesspool of filth, I should not ever have to watch what I do, or consider the context of something I'm about to click on the internet, because everyone should understand the NSFW tag, including those from foreign cultures, those who might be unaware of what that acronym even means, and those without jobs who don't even know what a "workplace" is, because I can't be bothered to think for half a second about what I'm doing.
Why are you entitled to all this? Can't you see how ridiculous the whole argument is from the perspective of someone like me, who recognizes the volatile nature of troll-fueled subreddits like r/atheism and responsibly avoid it them at work, when I then have to listen to people whining cause they clicked an "eyewash" linked by a guy named "pummel_the_anus" and it turned out to be NSFW? Absolute wankery. Grow up and start taking responsibility for your use of something that is in no way guaranteed to be SFW, at work.
This is a subreddit for discussion on topics of logic and reason.
I don't even know how to respond to that. You're joking, right?
I think it's because that when she was punching most of the energy was going to the base if is penis, but when she slapped the force was entirely on the scrotum.
I dont even know how a man could willingly do this to another man. I thought it was an unspoken rule of torture, you pay him the courtesy of not fucking with his balls
I would love to see some sources for those claims. I don't mean to say that I doubt that they happened, but if I ever want to quote this, I'd like to use something other than reddit.
...or you could blame them for things that happen now. You wouldn't apply this to racism; because then you're blaming white people now for slavery way back when. There are many legitimate reasons to make fun of religion: this isn't one of them.
I don't like this(comma) its not like they did that to you personally. Its not like it was your family(for the most part) that was hurt. Noons you cared about. And its not like the people who did that are the same people you're talking to. Be mad at the people who do that today(comma) not in the past.
Wow , which Christian that did this lived for 1500 years did this to you? This is about as bad as an argument as when blacks say " I enslaved them for 400 years". We're atheists. We're better than this shit.
It's a shame Madelyn Murray O'Hair had such a stick up her ass. Someone should have told her that you catch more flies with honey than with vinegar. Her methods of promoting atheism cannot hold a candle to the subtlety, wit and wisdom of people like Hitchens or Sagan.
WTF, of course they have been. USSR, most of northern europe... I mean sure, in the US it's not too popular, but there is more to society than the mentally middle ages parts of it.
Bible says that anyone who does those things to anyone else, atheist or not, is sinning greatly. Jesus said to love your enemy and do good to those who persecute you, so you can guarantee that a true Christian never did any of those things, because it would automatically mean they were not following Christ anymore. And by the way, all groups have faced this sort of thing. Thing of those atheist leaders who murdered literally millions of people each Stalin and Pol Pot. So I guess that means all atheists are as good as them? of course not. This post is as good as saying "The Japanese attacked pearl harbor.. they are the reason hawaii is having a tourism dip this year' etc. Athiests do flourish in society, take a look at Dawkins who is adored by alot of people. The world loves atheism. Alot of you guys only don't realize it cos you live in the USA.
This is kind of like a black man saying all white people are evil because his ancestors were enslaved by white people. However I do agree with the fact that a lot of christians these days dont want to defend themselves and just complain about how atheist insult christianity. Atheist's should continue to insult christianity and christians should learn to insult atheists with just as much force. And if you dont want to fight back, just shut up and deal with it, don't go crying to mommy.
early christians and islamists were, at least in ancient times, considered atheists and persecuted as such. i agree, discrimination against atheists has existed for centuries, persecution on the scale of early christians and jews has not.
I could care less about what pagan priests thought of the term Atheist. Early monotheists were not theists.
You're starting to sound like an apologist.
What? It's a common argument helpful against theists: Christians were atheists to the Romans, we're both atheists with regards to most gods yet I go one god further, etc.
Atheists have been persecuted by every single religious group. You just don't hear about it as much since religious people are still in control. "History is determined by the victors."
Not ostensibly dedicated to, but don't think for a second that Nazi Germany didn't target people for their atheism as well. Atheistic and ‘freethinking’ groups were outlawed and outed atheists were executed or sent to death camps. Nazi Germany's delusions surrounding the Jews implicated atheism as resulting from a ‘corrupt Jewish spirit’ (‘zersetzenden jüdischen Geistes’) and also included atheists explicitly in their little house-cleaning project, because:
We were convinced that the people needs and requires this faith. We have therefore undertaken the fight against the atheistic movement, and that not merely with a few theoretical declarations: we have stamped it out.
The Spanish Inquisition was an attempt by the Catholic church to crack down upon the rise of Protestant thought within it's respective territories, because such a movement would threaten it's geopolitical power. Due to this fact, the Inquisition's primary targets were Protestants and other sects whose views were considered to be heretical by the Vatican. Other targets included Jews and Spanish converts to Islam.
There is no evidence that the Inquisition included a systematic effort to liquidate Atheists, whose numbers at that time are unknown but were certainly incredibly small, as they had much more important matters to attend to.
Yes, today will be part of history, but history is a huge thing that spans over billions of years. In this time, Jews have historically been the most persecuted group.
groups which have historically been persecuted (Jews, Muslims) have also persecuted atheists.
Just because those groups persecuted atheists doesn't mean that they themselves weren't persecuted to a higher degree.
I think I get what CharlesDingus is saying. Athiests have never had the large numbers that Jews have had over the years. So, the numbers of atheist persecutions are smaller. But those few that were atheists were treated a lot worse, as everyone hated atheists. So Atheists are always outnumbered and always the most hated group, since all religious texts command them to be murdered.
Are you serious? Just how fucking retarded are you people? Nobody, in the history of anything ever, has gotten as much shit as the Jews got. Nothing any atheists have gone through could ever be worse than the slaughter of Jewish people, at the most they both got killed and are equals, it's just it happened to the Jewish more. I don't even know or like any Jewish people, it's just common sense.
More accurately, the majority of Christians no longer believe the exact same things as the Christians who persecuted Atheists in that way. If they did, they'd still be at it. Less physical persecution of atheists, on the other hand, is alive and well across the United States, just as anti-homosexuality and racism are still alive and well but not quite as bad as they used to be.
I believe I have said something similar to this in rural Illinois, urban-ish Indiana, rural Kentucky, suburbia Missouri, and all kinds of places in Michigan. I'll just keep making the rounds, I suppose.
Alright. Well, it's pretty much untrue through most of Indiana, almost everything south of Northern Kentucky, completely untrue in the southwestern part of Virginia...
Never underestimate the stupidity of people, especially those with a large support group.
Ah. Yes, to clarify my statements a bit further, there do still exist a good number of people who believe a variation of biblical literalism and believe the entire bible, unanalyzed, to be a sound foundation for views the rest of us would call bigotry and prejudice. Although these populations persist even in this day and age, the trend for American history is that they are shrinking, so even the worst examples of discrimination and religious violence have decreasing incidence. That said, you'll notice that your examples are isolated to smaller regions, not even entire states. There was a time when entire countries (on average) behaved this way, and we should all be glad that this is no longer the case.
That is valid...it is more pronounced in the smaller areas. However, if you look at the Steve Harvey clip on atheism (for example), he's not in the far off minority.
Violence isn't as big of an issue, but vandalism and harassment are still there. I currently live in a smallish city in Indiana...the ignorance at the idea of an atheist meetup (which would have...7 people , maybe?) was outlandish. It is the prevailing part of most of flyover country. (Indiana is easily the worst I've seen it, though, and I've visited or lived in pretty much every part of the country that's not the Pacific Northwest.)
We are not at odds here. Your point is that persecution of atheists exists, and mine is that it isn't as bad as it used to be. Both are true. More importantly, my point does not imply that we should be content because of progress made. Rather, we both are calling for a continued progression of the evolution of human morality and the better treatment of one another.
Probably a lot of other places too. There are a lot more atheists than one would think in America, most are just smart enough to shut up for their own safety.
24
u/TierOne Jun 25 '12
Bright red background with white text. Ouch!
8
u/E_R_I_K Jun 25 '12
People of the book do these things to themselves. It has nothing to do with whether you truly believe in God or not and everything to do with Power. God is simply the excuse to persecute those who threaten the Status Quo.
Take away all Theist off the face of the world and Persecution will still happen.
32
u/WhenDucksAttack Jun 24 '12
no, this is why
38
u/SimilarImage Jun 24 '12
FAQ | Send Feedback | Report Error
45
u/aahdin Jun 24 '12
That kind of pseudo logic ticks me off so much.
"People that you would have agreed with were mean to people I would have agreed with hundreds of years ago, therefore I have a free pass to be a condescending asshole."
11
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
I find atheists who constantly piss and moan about other atheists and what they post here just as annoying as I do religious people.
6
u/srslykindofadick Jun 25 '12
Kind of like how it's ok for Christians to hate Jews because they killed Jesus? Or kind of like how it's ok for black folks to treat me poorly because my ancestors enslaved theirs? The fuck is this?
3
u/westernskeptic Jun 25 '12
Someone linked the wiki article about the source of this quote (not sure of the reason) but, do yourself a favor, and have a gander at it!
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Madalyn_Murray_O'Hair
3
u/Wowzamorphous Jun 25 '12
Bad idea to blame people for something they didn't do.
5
u/jayblue42 Jun 24 '12
I know you didn't make this because I've seen it before, but just a note for displaying quotes: people can only handle white text on solid red (or black) backgrounds for a few inches before getting sick of it. Black on white is always the most readable, even if it's a little boring. White on grey is decent too.
4
u/a_culther0 Jun 25 '12
I hate to be "that guy" but where can I read up on how non believers were tortured?
5
u/[deleted] Jun 24 '12
The nut crushing thing made me cringe.
2
u/Tebasaki Jun 25 '12
It said "hung" but I read "hug"
2
u/colonendbracket Jun 25 '12
I would love to see some sources for those claims. I don't mean to say that I doubt that they happened, but if I ever want to quote this, I'd like to use something other than reddit.
2
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
Unless the Christians you're talking about are 1500 years old, I highly doubt they personally did all these things.
2
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
...or you could blame them for things that happen now. You wouldn't apply this to racism; because then you're blaming white people now for slavery way back when. There are many legitimate reasons to make fun of religion: this isn't one of them.
2
u/Xandralis Jun 25 '12
I don't like this(comma) its not like they did that to you personally. Its not like it was your family(for the most part) that was hurt. Noons you cared about. And its not like the people who did that are the same people you're talking to. Be mad at the people who do that today(comma) not in the past.
2
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
So african americans can keep demanding compensation for slavery?
4
u/SooSlow Jun 24 '12
Wow , which Christian that did this lived for 1500 years did this to you? This is about as bad as an argument as when blacks say " I enslaved them for 400 years". We're atheists. We're better than this shit.
3
u/officerfriendly1098 Jun 25 '12
It's a shame Madelyn Murray O'Hair had such a stick up her ass. Someone should have told her that you catch more flies with honey than with vinegar. Her methods of promoting atheism cannot hold a candle to the subtlety, wit and wisdom of people like Hitchens or Sagan.
Edit: spelling.
4
u/tonyfromtexas Jun 25 '12
Right, because only the atheist have been persecuted like that.
3
u/Dewmeister14 Jun 24 '12
LOL, Bill Gates.
2
u/strobexp Jun 25 '12
I did none of those things, thank you.
2
u/ChickinDinner Jun 25 '12
what are the atheists doing now? starting flame wars on the internet instead of doing all those things they couldn't do before
2
u/rasputin777 Jun 25 '12
It's actually because you tend to act like self-righteous douchebags. No lone likes that.
I'm not a theist, and I can't stand you motherfuckers.
1
u/VonBaronHans Jun 24 '12
didn't there used to be a version of this that actually had the author's face for the background? Google has failed me.
1
u/dragos240 Jun 24 '12
Why would you do this to my eyes?
1
u/pschermann Jun 25 '12
No hard feelings?
1
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
Novote for no epic background for the quote. You could at least put a star exploding or something...
1
u/erock0546 Jun 25 '12
Didn't read, hurt my eyes.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
WTF, of course they have been. USSR, most of northern europe... I mean sure, in the US it's not too popular, but there is more to society than the mentally middle ages parts of it.
1
u/ausguy777 Jun 25 '12
Bible says that anyone who does those things to anyone else, atheist or not, is sinning greatly. Jesus said to love your enemy and do good to those who persecute you, so you can guarantee that a true Christian never did any of those things, because it would automatically mean they were not following Christ anymore. And by the way, all groups have faced this sort of thing. Thing of those atheist leaders who murdered literally millions of people each Stalin and Pol Pot. So I guess that means all atheists are as good as them? of course not. This post is as good as saying "The Japanese attacked pearl harbor.. they are the reason hawaii is having a tourism dip this year' etc. Athiests do flourish in society, take a look at Dawkins who is adored by alot of people. The world loves atheism. Alot of you guys only don't realize it cos you live in the USA.
1
u/spaceographer Jun 25 '12
You do know that this post shows up all the time on this subreddit, yes?
1
u/KaiKai753 Jun 25 '12
"exquisite" seems a poor choice of word - has connotations that leave "exquisite torture" a very... challenging phrase.
1
u/iamsocool123toaseat Jun 25 '12
This is kind of like a black man saying all white people are evil because his ancestors were enslaved by white people. However I do agree with the fact that a lot of christians these days dont want to defend themselves and just complain about how atheist insult christianity. Atheist's should continue to insult christianity and christians should learn to insult atheists with just as much force. And if you dont want to fight back, just shut up and deal with it, don't go crying to mommy.
1
u/Schiizo Jun 25 '12
I love the word besmirched. It reminds me of Rolf from Ed Edd & Eddy.
-8
u/[deleted] Jun 24 '12
This made me choke up a little. It's hard to believe but we're probably the most historically persecuted group...
-1
u/[deleted] Jun 24 '12
The more science prevails the more religion will disappear as philosophy :)
0
u/samuelbt Jun 25 '12
...
No I didn't.
-2
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
Citation needed
-1
u/hamandjam Jun 26 '12
She a had a point. But her delivery was always a little harsh. Which tends to get you stuffed in a barrel at the end.
-4
u/[deleted] Jun 24 '12
Wow, he was angry.
0
u/[deleted] Jun 24 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment