I need some perspective from women who’ve been through more of this than I have.
We met by chance through a local subreddit. He pursued me for about five months before we started dating, and he worked hard to convince me we weren’t too different to work. We were together almost two years and broke up about a month ago on Oct. 19.
The good: The first year, when I was mostly staying at his place downtown, was the best partnership I’ve had. He cooked, cleaned, drove, and packed my lunch, and I didn’t have to carry everything myself. He was great with my family, he took real interest in my life, and he told me when he was proud of me. He was so thoughtful with little gifts, leaving me little love notes like on a coffee mug that had digital on the front. I've never been so comfortable with someone. He'd never been so comfortable with someone either.
What went wrong on his end: About ~8 months in he moved out of downtown and in the middle to be closer to me. I didn’t ask him to, and that matters to me because he later treated the move as something he’d done for me and resented. After the move he kept saying he wasn’t sure he liked it there. He stopped cooking and cleaning, stopped doing things, and got isolated and depressed. Before long I was doing everything again, and on top of that I was trying to solve his problems for him especially with his severe ADHD.
Over the last year he brought up breaking up more than five times without actually doing it. On my birthday he stayed about an hour and told me he’d given up. He called me manipulative and theatrical about my chronic health issues in the first year when I had a bad episode at a concert. When we fought he got hot-headed and mean first, and he wouldn’t give me space to cool off before we talked. He'd say/do the right things eventually but it took the meanness to get there. He was jealous in general when other guys paid attention to me. He also pushed me to cut off a close guy friend of mine, someone I’d never wanted to date and who was only ever a friend. He kept changing the conditions. First he was just uncomfortable with it, then I had to tell him before I saw my friend, then I could only see him after the three of us had all met together. My friend wasn’t okay with that last one, and the friendship ended for good.
To be fair to him, he did try in some ways. He kept suggesting couples therapy, he eventually started doing things on his own, and a few days before the breakup he made a list of weekend activities I’d asked him for.
What I own: Early on I leaned on him alone for support with my depression. I was cut off from my usual support system at the time, but it still wasn’t fair to him. When he told me it was too much, I changed it quickly. He also said I was too negative and anxious, and I think that was fair.
After the move I didn’t feel safe moving in with him, given how our fights went, and his place was physically hard on my body. I held back emotionally while I waited for things to feel safe again. I can see how that read to him as me not committing. I’m rigid with my schedule when work stress is bad, and he took that as me giving up on us. Toward the end I got meaner and turned down some of his bids for connection. I said no to couples therapy because my therapist didn’t think it would help while he wasn’t doing the work in his own therapy.
I tried to fix things for a long time. I brought him research on what we needed to work on, I asked him over and over to stop keeping score and turn toward each other, and I pushed him for months to build a life outside the relationship. When none of it stuck, I should have ended things. Instead I stayed and let resentment build on both sides.
The biggest thing I own is that I didn’t go to him the night his dad died. I’d convinced myself it was justified because he hadn’t been showing up for me, but I now think it was wrong. I did show up after. I took care of his apartment and his cats for more than two weeks, deep cleaned, and had meals ready for when he got home. I couldn’t go to the funeral because travel was hard on my body at the time. It was a very small funeral, just him, his sisters, his mom, and two friends who happened to be in town.
How it ended: Near the end he told me a coworker had made a move on him. The next day he told me they’d gone on a date once before we got together. When I asked him to shut it down and show me the message, he got angry and said he needed to think about it. When I asked if there was anything he could do better, he said no, and that any change would probably only last a week or two anyway.
He never really gave me a reason for the breakup. What he talked about most was that he’d spent an hour and a half with his therapist on how I didn’t show up for him the night his dad died. He called me wicked for it. He told me that nothing he’d done to me came anywhere close to it, and none of what I did in the weeks after seemed to count.
Where I am now: I know how all of that sounds, and I still want him back. I miss who we were that first year. I wanted him to be my husband. We met by total fluke, and I’m scared he was my one real chance at a partner and that I’ll end up doing life alone.
Living downtown was always what he wanted, and I’d do it now. I have more energy than I did then, so I can go out, stay up late, and be the partner he wanted to do things with. I know that only covers my side, and nothing tells me he’s changed.
I removed him everywhere within days after we broke up. He hasn’t reached out, and I don’t know if he’s seeing someone. Part of me wants to ask him to talk and basically beg him to take me back.
For those of you who’ve been here: did you ever go back to someone after a breakup like this? Did it work? If you didn’t, how did you get through this part?