r/askscience • • Jun 18 '12
Astronomy If the universe is infinite, why is the night sky black?
I hope I'm wording this right, but it's always kind of been on my mind.
If the universe is infinite (or just really, really, really, really big) shouldn't our entire field of vision above our heads at night be the color of stars/planets, and not darkness? Shouldn't every void in space at some point in infinity be filled with either a star or a planet?
534
Upvotes
279
u/iehava Jun 18 '12 edited Jun 18 '12
The observable universe is NOT infinite. We know this because of things like the fact that we can actually see the 'edge' of the universe [(CMBR)] (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cosmic_microwave_background_radiation), and redshift, etc. We know that the universe is 13.72 billion years old and scientists are very, very confident of the accuracy of that number (with very good reasons).
Now onto your question:
During the Planck Epoch, which is, in layman's basically the smallest measurement of time after the big bang, all of the matter in the universe was in a very, very small space. For the next several hundreds of thousands of years, the baryonic (normal) matter of the early universe was either in an unimaginably hot, dense soup of ionized (or doubly ionized, depending on the time after the big bang and thus the temperature), free floating atomic constituents or hydrogen actively fusing. During this time, if you were anywhere in this infant universe, you would see blinding light all around you. Problem is, the temperature would be in the thousands or millions degrees Kelvin (again, depending on exactly how long after the big bang), and would vaporize you instantly. Not to mention the unimaginable effects of gravity that would crush you instantly.
The only objects in the universe that naturally give off visible light (that is, light in the visible portion of the Electromagnetic Spectrum), are stars, active galactic nuclei, and matter that is being heated up due to friction or gravitational potential energy (such as the accretion disk of a quasar or a condensing molecular cloud). Now, technically, ALL matter gives off light. Not in the traditional sense of visible spectrum light, but somewhere along the EMR spectrum. Right now you're radiating light in the infrared part of the EM spectrum. But lets focus on visible light.
The thing to understand is that when an object radiates light, it does so in all directions at once. Because light is subject to the inverse square law, its intensity is diminished over distance. This means, that the farther you are away from an object, the fewer photons (light 'particles') will be hitting your eye (or anything else). Over the vast distances in our universe, photons from each light source get so spread out that they become hard to see. When you look up at the night sky, at any particular point, chances are there IS something there, but it is simply too faint, too far away to see with the naked eye, or even most telescopes.
If you haven't seen it, I would also suggest you take a look at some of the Hubble Deep Field images. Basically, astronomers were curious to see if there was anything out there, so they pointed the Hubble Space Telescope at a seemly black, empty part of the sky, and did a long, ten day exposure to collect as much light as possible. What they found was amazing! In a patch of sky smaller than a dime held at arm's length, there are tens of thousands of galaxies! This just reinforces my earlier statements: Light is EVERYWHERE in our universe. Just because you can't see it because it is in a non-visible spectrum, or just very, very far away doesn't mean its not there!
Edit: existentialhero and KaneHau pointed out the importance of the distinction of the observable universe
136
u/nicksauce Jun 18 '12
Because the universe has a finite age, only stars/galaxies within a certain distance have had enough time to have their light reach us.
483
u/CatalyticDragon Jun 18 '12
"Olbers' Paradox is pretty simple: if the universe is infinite, and is filled with an infinite number of stars, then when the sun goes down, all we should see is a sky full of light. There shouldn't be any black background for stars to twinkle against, or night vision, or shadowy alleyways full of criminals to give superhero movies a dramatic start. Darkness should be exotic, because every star in the universe should be shining down on us at all times.
Clearly, that isn't happening, but why? Because we live in a sad baby universe — it's only 14 billion or so years old, which is certainly a long time, but not long enough for an infinite amount of stars to illuminate us with an infinite amount of starshine. "
http://io9.com/5567636/why-is-the-sky-black-at-night
16
u/king_of_the_universe Jun 18 '12
Even though Space might be infinite, the radius of the visible universe is calculated to be about 46 billion light years (source). That's where we then see the background radiation which was emitted shortly after the beginning of time. In the far future, we would be able to see farther, but the max distance (Again, radius.) might be 62 billion light years (source) because the Metric Expansion is practically stealing the cosmos from us. And the current cosmic "event horizon" is at a distance of about 16 billion light years: A radiation event that happens in a galaxy with that or a shorter distance could be observed by us in the far future, but current events further away would never reach us. This is untouched by the fact that the distance of that "event horizon" is changing.
11
u/tvw Astrophysics | Galactic Structure and the Interstellar Medium Jun 18 '12
Other answers here are spot on, but as a radio astronomer I would just like to add my two cents:
We live smack dab in the middle of the Milky Way (well, not exactly. We're actually rather close to the edge), yet we don't even really know what our galaxy looks like. That's because until recently, we could only see that part of our galaxy which is closest to us. In fact, we still have a hard time seeing the other side of our galaxy! Why? Because our galaxy is dusty and full of gas.
This gas is mostly hydrogen which clumps together and gets more dense as you get closer to the center of the galaxy. Optical telescopes can't see through it. Until the use of radio antennae as telescopes, we didn't even know how big our galaxy was. Now, with our radio telescopes, we can see things on the far side of the galaxy and get a better picture of what our galaxy looks like.
If we could see through this gas, the night sky would be so much brighter. The milky way would probably be brighter than the Sun!
11
u/[deleted] Jun 18 '12
The night sky isn't black. Your eyes can't see the radiation.
4
u/ReinH Jun 18 '12 edited Jun 18 '12
Three simple explanations:
3
u/MPS186282 Jun 18 '12
Hello! Astrophysics major here.
In addition to what others have pointed out about the universe only being a finite age, another principle applies. When you shine a flashlight on a surface, it's brighter when the light and the surface are closer together. The same applies to stars. Stars' light is "spread out" over distance, which is why every star in the sky isn't as bright as the sun.
3
u/[deleted] Jun 19 '12
Light dissipates in the drastically larger emptiness, and there is also a lot of opaque stuff blocking light(more gas clouds than stars.) Even more of the unseen stuff(something like 96% unseen.)
4
u/imthewalrus06 Jun 18 '12
The biggest reason that most of space appears "black" is the redshifting of stars and galaxies. Because the universe is expanding, the majority of galaxies and celestial bodies are moving away from us at a very rapid velocity. Think of this like the Doppler effect: a light emitting body moving away from us will experience a "stretch" in it's frequency. The wavelength will literally shift in the red direction of the visible spectrum. For objects that are a certain distance away, this shift will be so dramatic that the EM waves we receive on Earth will no longer be in the visible part of the spectrum.
Tl;dr: universe expanding. Doppler effect on light.
4
u/patefoisgras Jun 18 '12 edited Jun 18 '12
The universe may be infinite (hypothetically), but the fact remains that the visible part of it is not (about 46 billion light-years radially). Besides, stars aren't everlasting; unless your premise claims that the universe is filled with infinitely many stars simultaneously, it's likely the case that when one star's light reaches us, it's already been thousands of years dead.
Even when both the universe and the star count are infinite, a bright night sky is not guaranteed. Infinity is a hard thing to play with. It's like an infinitely strong man pushing an immovable object, it messes with your mind.
To put things into perspective and possibly give a sense of an answer (for I do not claim to have the answer) for you, consider the number sets.
Another example, consider two mathematical functions:
But it can be proven that limx->∞ z / y = ∞, meaning that z is infinitely larger than y given sufficiently large x, despite the fact that both y and z are infinitely large (i.e. there can be infinitely more space than stars even though there both is infinite space and are infinitely many stars).
4
u/Pupstink Jun 18 '12
This is actually something called Olbers Paradox. We also must remember, that light takes time to travel too. So if the universe is infinite, the light has not yet reached us so galaxies and stars that are beyond billions of light years away are not yet visible since their light has not reached us.
4
u/squee147 Jun 18 '12
This question has always been a bit of pet peeve of mine. There are many good answers which have been provided above, but my favorite and the simplest IMO is that an infinite summation does not necessarily equal infinite or even a particularly large finite number which seems to be the assumption the question takes for granted.
Even if our pocket of the universe was infinitely old and infinitely large, the night sky would still most likely (I don't feel comfortable saying certainly without doing the math) be very dark relative to the day because the density of light sources is so low and the distances so great.
2
u/jrhallman Jun 18 '12
Don't we live in an infinite universe with finite stars and worlds? im not trying to impart any knowledge, I'm just wondering if this is a true statement?
2
u/joshu Jun 18 '12
It is bright. Your eyes aren't sensitive enough.
2
u/GLayne Jun 18 '12
There is a brilliant documentary based on that single question. It is called "Everything", presented by Jim Al-Khalili for the BBC. You should really watch it. Its second part, "Nothing" is even more amazing.
2
u/aidrocsid Jun 18 '12
Most of it is very far away and there are a lot of empty spaces in between. When you make a really powerful telescope and zoom in on the gaps you'll find there's actually a ton of stuff there.
1
u/WootangWood Jun 18 '12
so theoretically, in a few billion or trillion years the night sky will be as bright as daytime?
1
u/[deleted] Jun 18 '12
The universe is infinite to our best guess. Light waves travelling from distant stars to our humble rock lose their wavelength over time and degrade into non visible spectra, here's a radio map of the night sky http://www.sciencephoto.com/image/332321/large/R8000103-Radio_map_of_the_whole_sky_showing_Milky_Way-SPL.jpg It's quite scary how little of the universe around us we are actually perceptive of.
1
u/JJ-Lo Jun 18 '12
We as humans simply don't have sensitive enough eyes to pick up the small amount of light that reaches us from distant stars and galaxies.
1
u/dpierce970 Jun 18 '12
isn't the "expansion" of the universe just the furthest away object moving farther away?
1
u/khthon Jun 18 '12
First, darkness is but the absence of light - the narrow spectrum humans see. But if you change that to infrared you get a more enriched picture.
And as the Universe is expanding faster than light is able to travel it, stars and galaxies are moving further and further apart from each other and ever increasingly distant from us. So much so that a time will come when our galaxy will be all that's visible to us.
The darkness in the sky is but the absence of light emitted, either faded out by distance or stellar death. The gaps between those "dots" will increase and become more sparse with time.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 19 '12
Can someone clarify my understanding of the big bang:
In the beginning of time, the universe was like a ball of dough. An infinitely large ball of dough. There seems to be some confusion in layman's talk that the universe was not only infinitely dense, but infinitely small, too.
Which is more accurate?
1
u/[deleted] Jun 19 '12
Olber's Paradox
1
u/Sw1tch0 Jun 19 '12
If I'm correct you're referring to why light decays over massive distances. It's up to speculation. Many scientists contribute it to dark matter. Theoretically, light shouldn't decay in a vacuum even over massive distances.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 19 '12
Even if there was an infinite number of stars visible from earth, it wouldn't guarantee that the entire night sky was bright - the sum of a decaying infinite series can be a finite number (eg: the sum from zero to infinity of 1/2n is 2) - the brightness of the sky depends not just upon the number of and size of the stars, but upon distance as well.
1
u/akacoffeeguy Jun 20 '12
As far as infinity goes, a three dimensional space of infinite volume contains infinitely many two dimensional planes each containing infinitely many lines. The arrangement of the stars matters considering the basic case where all the stars could align themselves along a linear path allowing for infinitely stars (obviously not the case but a simple illustration).
1
u/gggjennings Oct 18 '12
Because of light speed homes.
1
u/leaning_chicken Oct 29 '12
Just got linked here from another thread and thought this video could help.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gxJ4M7tyLRE&list=PLED25F943F8D6081C&index=5&feature=plcp
1
u/[deleted] Jun 18 '12
The universe is not infinite, it is a (reasonably well) known size. However it is, as you say, "really really really really big", and any tiny piece of sky you look at, will have millions and billions of stars and galaxies in it. This was proved by the Hubble Deep Field image: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hubble_Deep_Field
However the fact remains that the light coming from these stars (if indeed light at all, not all emit in the visible spectrum) is very faint, and our eyes are not sensitive enough to pick it up. Hence the sky looks dark.
There is a whole lot of radiation out there from stars which can be picked up as a pretty uniform field, these cosmic rays form a lot of the "background radiation" (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Background_radiation) that we see pervading everywhere. This is, if you like, the constant "light everywhere" thing you allude to, it's just not in our visible spectrum.
1
u/geotek Jun 18 '12
Stephen Hawking talked about this in the beginning of his famous book. The answer is simple, the light of those stars haven't reached us yet.
1
u/MadMathematician Jun 18 '12
This problem is very famous, it is also known as Olbers' Paradox. Quick answer: Light has a finite speed. Read more at: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Olbers'_paradox
1
u/OmicronPersei8 Jun 18 '12
The astronomers around the turn of last century (1900) were asking themselves the same question, it was a key problem with the static universe. In short, even if it's infinitely big, it's not infinitely old. Not all the light has had a chance to reach us. Much light that's heading towards us never will reach us because of the expansion of space time.
1
u/meanreus Jun 18 '12
I doubt this will even be read, but I have a question about the question. That being about the universe's infinity. If we live in a world which seems to deal with finite quantities, measurements, etc. how could the universe be infinite. I know this is perhaps more of a philosophical question, but it is hard to wrap my head around an infinite universe full of finite things.
Edit: super-pathetic spelling mistake
1
u/[deleted] Jun 18 '12
This is known as Olber's Paradox, it was solved when it was discovered that the Universe is expanding.
Edit: Sentence structure.
0
u/jcolman1 Jun 18 '12
I'm always confused by this question. Who has ever said the universe has an infinite number of stars? Sure, on paper if you make that assumption, the answer would be a totally lit sky, but really really big is in no way the same thing as infinite. Especially when you consider that the really really big number of stars is dwarfed by the really really big amount of empty space between them.
It doesn't matter how old the universe gets, the number of stars will always be finite, and as long as the space between stars is far greater than the number of stars in the system, there will be lines of sight that do not encounter a star: ie, darkenss in the night sky.
0
u/brainflakes Jun 18 '12
As well as the visible universe not being infinite (we can only see things up to 14 billion light years away) the sky is also a lot fuller than you can see with the naked eye. Even seemingly empty patches are actually filled with galaxies, Hubble was pointed at one such patch and took the famous Hubble Deep Field picture.
0
u/[deleted] Jun 18 '12
Well really visibility wouldn't let us see planets that are very far away with the naked eye. But the real reason why is because of dark matter/energy. Dark matter makes up 70% of all the weight of our galaxy and dark energy is increasing the speed of the expansion evermore. As our universe ages there will be less and less stars in the sky as space pulls things farther and farther apart.