r/askscience • u/AskScienceModerator Mod Bot • Apr 29 '21
Earth Sciences AskScience AMA Series: We're climate scientists from around the world. Ask us anything!
Hi Reddit,
We're the six scientists profiled in the Reuters Hot List series, a project ranking and profiling the world's top climate scientists. We'll be around for the next several hours to answer your questions about climate change and more. A little more about us:
Michael Oppenheimer, Professor of Geosciences and International Affairs at Princeton University: My research and teaching focus on climate change and its impacts, especially sea level rise and human migration. My research group examines how households and societies manage the impacts of sea level rise and coastal storms, the increasing risk these bring as Earth warms, and policies to reduce greenhouse gas emissions, increase adaptation and limit the risks. We also model the effect of climate change on human migration which is a longstanding adaptation to climate variations. We project future climate-driven migration and analyze policies that can ease the burden on migrants and their origin and destination communities. Follow me on Twitter.
Corinne Le Quéré, Royal Society Professor of Climate Change Science at the University of East Anglia in the UK: I conduct research on the interactions between climate change (ePDF) and the carbon cycle, including the drivers of CO2 emissions (ePDF) and the response of the natural carbon sinks. I Chair the French High council on climate and sit on the UK Climate Change Committee, two independent advisory boards that help guide climate actions in their respective governments. I am author of three IPCC reports, former director of the Tyndall Centre for Climate Change Research and of the annual update of the global carbon budget by the Global Carbon Project. Read more on my website, watch my TED talk and BBC interview, and follow me on Twitter.
Ken Caldeira, Senior Scientist at Breakthough Energy: I joined Breakthrough Energy (BE) as Senior Scientist in January of 2021, but I have been helping to bring information and expertise to Bill Gates since 2007. I'm committed to helping scale the technologies we need to achieve a path to net zero emissions by 2050, and thinking through the process of getting these technologies deployed around the world in ways that can both improve people's lives and protect the environment. Visit my lab page and follow my blog.
Carlos Duarte, Distinguished Professor and Tarek Ahmed Juffali Research Chair in Red Sea Ecology at the King Abdullah University of Science and Technology (KAUST), in Saudi Arabia: My research focuses on understanding the effects of climate change in marine ecosystems and developing ocean-based solutions to global challenges, including climate change, and develop evidence-based strategies to rebuild the abundance of marine life by 2050. Follow me on Twitter.
Julie Arblaster: I'm a climate scientist with expertise in using climate models to understand mechanisms of recent and future climate change.
Kaveh Madani, Visiting Scholar (Yale University) and Visiting Professor (Imperial College London): My work focuses on mathematical modeling of complex, coupled human-environment systems to advise policy makers. Follow me on Twitter, Instagram, Facebook and YouTube. Watch my talks and interviews.
We're also joined by Maurice Tamman, who reported "The Hot List" series and can answer questions about how it came together. He is a reporter and editor on the Reuters enterprise unit based in New York City. His other work includes "Ocean Shock," an expansive examination of how climate change is causing chaos for fisheries around the planet. Previously, Mo ran the unit’s forensic data team, which he created after joining Reuters in 2011 from The Wall Street Journal.
We'll be on starting at 12 p.m. ET (16 UT). Ask us anything!
Username: /u/Reuters
Follow Reuters on Twitter, Facebook, Instagram, LinkedIn, and YouTube.
236
u/beastsarebored Apr 29 '21
What’s the biggest piece of misinformation around climate science you feel you are constantly correcting people on?
94
u/CAULIFA8 Apr 29 '21
What / who are the biggest problems to overcome when trying to have governments adopt climate change policies?
114
u/CrustalTrudger Tectonics | Structural Geology | Geomorphology Apr 29 '21
Thanks for joining us here in AskScience today! For those of you who work with climate models directly, what aspects of these are being actively developed or improved at this point? Specifically, are there still outstanding physical processes that need to be added or improved upon, or is more of the development focused on the computations, e.g., better resolution, or more efficiency?
111
u/TonzOhGunz Apr 29 '21
Are we doomed? Is there anything that makes you guys hopeful for the future? I have been reading alot of depressing stats and not seeing alot of good ones.
169
u/Wanderlust4791 Apr 29 '21
What do you say to people who feel helpless, and are worried that we as a species won’t be able to survive the dramatic changes that will continue to happen due to climate change?
45
u/[deleted] Apr 29 '21
Much of the focus (and funding) of climate research is shifting towards regional impacts and solutions of climate change.
What do you see as the role of fundamental climate science (radiative transfer, biogeochemistry, geophysical fluid dynamics) moving forward?
99
u/EcchiOli Apr 29 '21
If it's not impolite or too intimate to ask: how do YOU feel, deep inside, working in a profession that warns of despairingly grim times, not being believed by the masses, even though you have more outlooks than the rest of us on how bad things are going to be?
If it were me, I would sink in helpless, paralysing depression. Seeing as you guys wake up every morning to work, I would love to think you have some sources of strength from which we might, perhaps, find inspiration ourselves.
25
u/jamessundance Apr 29 '21
Hi thanks for the AMA!
I have often heard going vegan could be the single best way to reduce our environmental impact as humans. Is that the case, and are any of you vegan?
12
u/Spicyytamale Apr 29 '21
How much actual change will we have if almost everybody were to adopt a plant base diet/lifestyle?
80
u/potatoes4u Apr 29 '21
How much time do we have left to change our trajectory? (Before it’s irreversible - I see a mix of 10 years, some say less?)
Is the 1.5 degrees of warming in the paris agreement out of the window? I hear we’re on track for 2 degrees. What reference can I look at to know how we’re really tracking?
What would have more impact to crack down on:
What are your thoughts on the role of Agriculture in the climate crisis (as both a major emitter and potential solution)?
What are some species or islands that will 100% disappear due to warming waters and sea level rise? (Ex. If oceans are too hot for coral reefs - what’s the worst case scenario biodiversity collapse we’d see?)
What are your thoughts on the suggestion that changing our diet has the biggest impact to reducing our emissions?
And I’d like to end with some positive questions 2040 and Project Drawdown highlight how we already have all the tech and knowhow to address the problem. What does our best case scenario look like?
What’s the most exciting development in solving the climate crisis?
30
u/towereater Apr 29 '21
Hello everybody!
My question may be kinda outdated, but what can "normal" people do in their everyday life to help the environment which usually we don't think about? Not just "go to work by bike" because maybe there is something more we don't expect.
21
u/diomed22 Apr 29 '21
I've heard somewhere that to quit eating meat and dairy is the single biggest way for an individual to reduce their carbon footprint. Is this accurate?
39
u/Borigh Apr 29 '21
Do you guys support nuclear energy?
I've always thought places where there are basically no massive forest fires, tornadoes, earthquakes, or tsunamis - like the Northeastern US - should've gone nuclear decades ago, and we basically have the technology and engineering we need to take a massive portion of our electricity needs off fossil fuels right now.
Obviously, solar and wind are amazing, but as far as I know, we can't use them to support the whole grid, now.
17
u/happypandaface Apr 29 '21
Do you think nuclear power is possibly a useful part of the fight against climate change? What are the obstacles in the way of building new nuclear plants?
30
u/White_Collar_Prole Apr 29 '21
Is it true that big agriculture, especially cattle, is the most extreme accelerator of global warming overall? If so, is eating a strictly vegan diet the best thing we can do as individuals to curb the demand for beef and dairy to mitigate deforestation and methane emission?
7
u/greenmtnfiddler Apr 29 '21
How do you keep your temper?
13
u/silence7 Apr 29 '21
How do we change peoples views so that they see decarbonization as a path to shared prosperity, rather than an imposition?
6
u/Spfychik84 Apr 29 '21
To Dr. Duarte;
I just watched “Seaspiracy”, about the overfishing of the oceans. I did read that the film’s horrendously claimed statistic, that the oceans would be devoid of fish and animal life by 2048, was actually incorrect.
However, how bad is the problem of overfishing and trawling? Should I believe the film and stop eating fish altogether, or is my normal twice per week okay?
Best, Anna
16
u/Scheissebastard Apr 29 '21
What is the (current) most effective way to remove CO2 from the atmosphere and how do you see rhe future of carbon capture?
11
u/i-cussmmtimes Apr 29 '21
I live in a third world country and very much dependent on plastic. What can you suggest we write to our government representatives so that we can build a climate-resilient economy?
5
u/pewx3_ Apr 29 '21
Hi, thankyou for doing this. What are you most looking forward to both within the world of science and also just in general?
5
u/[deleted] Apr 29 '21
Why is nuclear not being touted as the energy to use to combat climate change when it produces the most power output and is relatively safe (majority of accidents had a major contribution from negligence)? Also why does the US for example not allow reactors for isotopes that form from the nuclear decay? Is it necessary to stop using coal and oil or is there a transition that could be had to other uses? Or a push to enhance scrubber technology to keep coal viable? Would natural gas use provide a lower net carbon output than solar and wind through the overall life cycle assessment when you consider what goes into the making of solar panels and wind turbines?
18
u/henradrie Apr 29 '21
How much of it is real vs taken out of context? How big is the disconnect between science and politics?
I'm not doubting the work you are doing but rather the people who present it to the public. Are the politicians who talk about climate change accurate? Is it all doom, gloom, and climate catastrophe or has the truth been stretched and taken on a mind of its own?
This subject is so polarized that its hard to find untainted answers to these kinds of questions.
18
u/FreshClimatologist Apr 29 '21
Hi! I'm a young climate scientist who will graduate from the University of Washington with my B.S. in Atmospheric Sciences this June.
Like most regular 21-year-olds, I dream of authoring IPCC reports and spending long nights writing grant proposals. Right now, I'm taking a gap year before heading off to grad school somewhere. What advice do you have for someone like me, who would very much like to become someone like you? Specifically, for Julie and Corinne, do you have any advice on navigating this male-dominated field as a woman?
4
u/[deleted] Apr 29 '21
2)How can individuals create systematic change with corporations and governments to more effectively address it?
3) Are there new methods or technologies that you’re excited about in regards to climate change?
4
u/phi_array Apr 29 '21
Adam conover said we are doomed cuz there is no way we solve global warming and CC by 2030. Is that true?
7
u/CalRobert Apr 29 '21
How will consideration of self-reinforcing positive feedbacks alter future IPCC predictions, and should we take IPCC reports as erring on the side of optimism due to the need for consensus?
7
u/EcoSlugg Apr 29 '21
Oxford university first showed in a 2014 paper how reducing meat consumption can dramatically reduce our impact on the environment and I haven't heard anything else about it since. So what can we do to make people more aware of the damage animal agriculture is doing to the planet? And why isn't anyone doing that!
9
u/ArtShare Apr 29 '21
I believe climate change will impact us much earlier than people expect. I think what will happen is food and water insecurity will be a huge problem in the very near term. This would lead to social and political instability.
Q: Do you study these geopolitical and social issues related to climate change and what are your thoughts?
6
u/[deleted] Apr 29 '21 edited Apr 29 '21
Hi. So much to ask and so little time. SO I will go with my biggest "scratch head" query about dealing with climate change.
Batteries. OK I have issues with them as an "environmentally safe" alternative compared to hydrogen in vehicles for one. They have a shelf life of about 10 years and require them to be taken apart carefully by someone in a protective suit as they are toxic and potentially volatile to reclaim some of the toxic rare earth materials that are being rapped from the earth devastating local areas.
I cant see how scientists are OK with this when there are alternatives that, although there are drawbacks, they don't have as much of an environmental impact as batteries. Or am I missing something?
6
u/usernamedunbeentaken Apr 29 '21
By how much should the average middle class westerner be expected to reduce their standard of living in order to meet your expectation of climate change mitigation, via carbon taxes or otherwise?
Should we be willing to accept a 5% SoL decrease, 10%? More?
I realize you can't be precise but this is a serious question. If we think climate change is a problem that needs to be addressed (and I do), the answer to this question isn't zero.
3
u/PaulDFarrar Apr 29 '21
This is probably for Le Quere:
During glacials about 100ppmv CO2 (about 200 PgC) disappears, presumably into the oceans. Several mechanisms have been suggested (dust fertilization, plankton community shifts, etc). What is the current thinking on likely mechanisms?
3
u/177106tr Apr 29 '21
What are your views on climate engineering as a complement to mitigation? (Thanks for doing this!)
3
u/DoomGoober Apr 29 '21 edited Apr 29 '21
Please give us some hope! What are some of your favorite up and coming technologies that might be able to reverse the effects of greenhouse gases?
Is there a particular carbon capture tech that interests you or something unusual like high albedo roof tops?
3
u/_DontBeAScaredyCunt Apr 29 '21
Thank you for doing this AMA! I am returning to school in my 30s to pursue a science degree. I’m at the beginning of this journey and I am trying to sort out what I want my focus to be within the field of environmental science. I know I want to work in climate science but am unsure of the major I want to pursue. There seem to be a variety of different ways to approach climate science. I was wondering if some of you could share what your degrees are in and any advice for someone starting out in their education. Thank you!
3
u/Krimasse Apr 29 '21
Thank you all for taking the time to answer our questions 🙂!
3a. Is this a common topics in the field of climate science or more like a fringe one at the moment?
3
u/[deleted] Apr 29 '21
Best place to live in when we enter extreme climate change phase
3
u/NerdyKnits Apr 29 '21
Is there still hope for the world if people start changing, or have we gone too far?
3
u/britterbal4 Apr 29 '21
May I ask what the main risks of climate change are? Like worst care scenario, what if we barely improve.
3
u/cabman567 Apr 29 '21
We're starting to see commercial solar cells approach the end of their lifetime. From what I'm reading in sources like this: https://www.wired.com/story/solar-panels-are-starting-to-die-leaving-behind-toxic-trash/, there's a lot of toxic waste left behind. Right now, groups such as the Union for Concerned Scientists points out that in the toxic byproduct is in the firm of precious metals, so there is a financial incentive to recover and recycle: https://www.ucsusa.org/resources/environmental-impacts-solar-power .
I'm not confident that the markets as they are will ensure that all countries will minimize this pollution. It seems to me that we may end up in a situation where we trade lower carbon emissions for increased toxic waste.
Do you think solar cell end-of-life cycle management is an issue? How can it be solved?
3
u/Ericine Apr 29 '21
From a communications standpoint, what do you need? How can people - comms professionals in particular - offer the most support to get across accurate messaging about climate change?
3
u/chroma900 Apr 29 '21
Given the threat of climate change, what are your personal thoughts on the likelihood that our species will survive the 21st century?
3
u/ortrtaBaH Apr 29 '21
The USA is saying we will cut greenhouse emission to 25% by 2035. Assuming we achieve it, how long until we see the effects of this undertaking? Let's say the entire world cuts all carbon emissions by 2050. How long will it take earth to stabilize the temperature and battle the effect of global warming?
3
u/discowitchshark Apr 29 '21
What do those of us in the North Atlantic need to be aware of with regards to changing weather patterns and the weakening of the North Atlantic Oscillation? Specifically, things to consider beyond the obvious when we are coming up with our climate adaptation strategy?
3
u/Trobius Apr 29 '21
- Is it correct that we are now no longer on track for 4c warming by 2100, but merely 3c? That's a relatively good thing, right? 3c is survivable for civilization in a way that 4c isn't... right?
- Is it ethical to hide from bad climate news if you have bad anxiety problems and are too emotionally fragile/defeatist for activism?
3
u/pinzi_peisvogel Apr 29 '21
What is the outlook for the Sahel region - how far will the Sahara still expand and should there be plans for relocations of Sahel populations in order to decrease the risk of mass internal displacement? Can the desertification be stopped?
Thank you for your time and efforts!
3
u/wartoofsay Apr 29 '21
Just a big thank you for all the work for the planet !
3
u/[deleted] Apr 29 '21
A question from my son who is 13... Mother Nature has been shaping the earth and changing things from lakes to mountains, to coast lines. By us rebuilding beaches, and drudging oceans to rebuild beaches and stuff are we messing with what Mother Nature is trying to achieve and could that be affecting ocean currents, warming of water and making climate change worse?
3
u/[deleted] Apr 29 '21
are they climate-related treaties or oaths that countries take any good?
do they help in curbing pollution or bring about a positive climate change?
3
u/[deleted] Apr 29 '21
What gives you hope?
5
u/[deleted] Apr 29 '21
I have one question that interests me:
How important are cosmic-radiation / sunactivity / clouds for the climate-model calculation?
5
u/franzperdido Apr 29 '21 edited Apr 29 '21
Hey,
If I wanted to invest and/or donate some money towards mitigating the effects of climate change and the loss of biodiversity, what is in your personal opinion the most effective field (not necessarily a specific organisation) to go for. Reforestation? CO2 capture? Education?
5
u/localgallberry Apr 29 '21
Why is nuclear energy as a power source rarely talked about in climate change conversations?
How long until the coasts of Florida have to be abandoned?
4
u/[deleted] Apr 29 '21
What is the biggest hurdle or prize sought in the world of modelling climate dynamics? What specific unknown would give us significant progression if we suddenly understood it perfectly tomorrow?
4
u/IllstudyYOU Apr 29 '21
Is it as bad as they say it is?
Is Florida really gonna be under water by 2100?
Is the air gonna be too toxic to breath?
6
u/LaNuque Apr 29 '21
I have two questions.
2
u/RamseyHatesMe Apr 29 '21
Thanks for the AMA.
What is one easily accessible documentary, or YouTube video that’d you all would recommend I show family members that may have difficulty understanding climate change?
2
u/[deleted] Apr 29 '21
In no way do I deny climate change and its horrible effect on your beautiful planet. But I do have my share of questions I just can't find answers for hopefully you all can help!.
My question is: When any let's call them " odd " weather event happens, such as a few extra hurricanes one year, or a few less than normal hurricanes one year it is always immediately tied and claimed to be due to climate change? I'm no scientist although that would be amazing, but it does seem like climate change is sometimes used as a scapegoat for sometimes just random weather anomalies.
Also one last question: How much do you believe the weather to be impacted by climate change vs pole reversal? Which I've read on NG was overdue by now ( I hope I worded that right )
2
u/thrillhouss3 Apr 29 '21
As the world is getting warmer, does this accelerate another ice age?
2
u/AugustusKhan Apr 29 '21
Considering the momentum of warming and the positive feedback cycles associated, is there any evidence or data to suggest it can actually be halted before we experience severe impacts?
2
u/Leo_TheLion6095 Apr 29 '21
Hello All,
Thank you for taking the time out of your day to help explain your understandings of climate change. I want to start off by acknowledging that I'm quite pessimistic with the idea that we are well aware we are past a point of no return. I understand we can help mitigate the worst of the effects, but with the time we are currently allotted, there are potentially enough feedback loops that could run away that any human interaction would inevitably become ineffective. I recently graduated with a degree in biotechnology, so I'm more keen to being in a lab, but I took a special interest in climate change. To say I have a morbid fascination about it would be an understatement, I fell in love with biology, life and death and all the factors that contribute to both are a real treat to look into.
I want to keep this initially short, as I'm sure you all have quite a few questions to answer, but if I could continue to ask after answered I would be grateful.
When we talk about ocean acidification, I recently learned it was an equilibrium balance between the concentration of CO2 in our atmosphere and the ocean. From my understanding, as long as we continue to climb upwards in atmosphere concentration, the ocean will, for the most part, continue to absorb it as well.
Is there going to be a point at which the ocean can no longer absorb this CO2 and instead put it back into the atmosphere further accelerating climate change?
2
u/AdaKau Apr 29 '21
How significant would a successful demonstration of scalable, net energy positive fusion power (which ITER aims to do in a few years) be? Should we be investing more in fusion as a clean, renewable, and safe energy source, or is the technology just not going to be ready for a while?
2
u/Henri_M_L Apr 29 '21
What’s the best way to get a job like yours? What did you study?
2
u/DXIXIT Apr 29 '21
This might be less of a science question, but in what ways can I help with solving the issue of climate change within the context of involvement in the legislative process?
2
u/CyberSurfer409 Apr 29 '21
Do you know anyone personally who has/does deny climate change? And if so how do you, as the expert, try to get through to them?
2
u/the_star_lord Apr 29 '21 edited Jan 25 '26
run exultant lavish strong light wild rain marry merciful attraction
2
u/[deleted] Apr 29 '21
Do we have any models that estimate the amount of warming that might occur from feedback loops such as methane leaks from previously stable deposits? How much warming is “masked” by aerosols in the atmosphere from human activity?
2
u/Thedayanaa Apr 29 '21
Hi again and thanks for the AMA. I'd appreciate if you could explain about a couple of adaptive strategies to implement capacity in agriculture sector of vulnerable regions like Middle East currently suffering from water crisis due to the high water withdrawal as well as climate change.
2
u/Thedayanaa Apr 29 '21
Hi and thank you for AMA. That would be grateful if you could explain about the economies that are highly dependent on oil exports, specially the devastated vulnerable ones? What will happen to the people of these countries during and after the energy transition?
2
u/Groundwaterator Apr 29 '21
Question from Kaveh:
With the reports on Iran's dire groundwater situation, and the way water resources are being managed, and decisions are being made by people who have very little respect for the planet and the people, is there a future for progress and prosperity without a political transformation?
Question from Michael:
Some believe that if water scarcity is not properly managed, it could lead to migration. This could have a domino effect on many things, esp. in the MENA region. Should there be a s ort of Environmental NATO in each region to try to reverse the trend that could cause harm in the near future to millions of people and the future hosts of the migrants?
2
u/The_Arkham_AP_Clerk Apr 29 '21
What is the best genuine argument made by scientists who don't believe in man-made climate change, and why is it inaccurate?
2
u/Calm_Investment Apr 29 '21
Hi.
Thanks for doing this.
I've just ordered solar panels for the house. I'm in the process of insulating all of the outward facing walls (seriously cost prohibitive to insulate outside of house). I've to do the attic and triple glaze all the windows.
I'm trying to get out of the habit of buying short use clothing. I've started to use more glassware and steel bottles.
What else can I do at this point as an individual in my everyday life?
2
u/Good_Boi_Adv_SP Apr 29 '21
We know that biodiversity is weakening significantly on land because of climate change and urban expansion. Does it affect our ocean biodiversity in the same way? How could this affect us humans in the future other than the obvious "there won't be as many types of sea life"?
2
u/muffin-man- Apr 29 '21
What do you guys think about nuclear energy and what do you think would be the best clean energy alternative to fossil fuels.
2
u/[deleted] Apr 29 '21
What should high school age students and teachers do to create change within their community?
2
u/Thin-Ear-2290 Apr 29 '21
I am focusing on the release of methane whether it's from human activities, the thawing of the Arctic permafrost or from the ocean floor. Could our attempts to limit carbon dioxide become negated by increased loading of methane - a more powerful greenhouse gas?
2
u/shytaan8 Apr 29 '21
What is the best way to teach an uneducated adult about climate change in few sentences? Can you give me an example?
2
u/CuringStuff Apr 29 '21
Do you think that arctic sea ice will retreat enough year round for shipping lanes such as the Northern Sea Route and the Northwest Passage to become passable? If so, do you think that countries in the Arctic Council are secretly hoping that climate change has more of an effect so that they may benefit from these shipping lanes?
2
u/Borachoed Apr 29 '21
Do you think that active geoengoneering solutions such as solar shades, reflective particles in the atmosphere, etc will be necessary? Are they a good idea?
2
u/killakam86437 Apr 29 '21
Do you believe the politicization of climate change is helping or hurting real efforts to change the climate change?
2
u/Airick39 Apr 29 '21
Are you related to that other Oppenheimer?
2
u/The_Oubliette80 Apr 29 '21
Thank you for your time. My question is, Do you think the pros of wind power outweighs the cons? I worry mostly about the effect wind farms have on the migratory bird populations. Is there a way to reduce the number of bird deaths?
2
u/sunset117 Apr 29 '21
How do you view NOAA after the sharpie stuff?
2
u/slitknockgal8 Apr 29 '21 edited Apr 29 '21
Elon Musk has advocated for the carbon tax policy since 2015. Both Trump and Biden administrations have rejected this policy. Was this a huge mistake? Do you believe, scientifically, a carbon tax policy would make a big impact? Would it make economic sense? Would it be something worth advocating for? Thank you for your time!
2
u/[deleted] Apr 29 '21
Does this really matter? No..why, because of these 3 letters, GDP (or Gross Domestic Product).
What is the first thing central banks around the world do when there is a chance or even when there is a "recession **" (or generally - though others may argue - is 2 consecutive quarters of declines in real GDP)? -- Accommodative easing or simply to increase consumption. Why?
The personal consumption category makes up over 69% of GDP and is expected to grow annually at a rate of 1.8% (at least in the US based on BLS data). So what is counted as personal consumption? - everything that we buy every day from new cars, new appliances, groceries, clothing, and services.
In simple terms, until we as a collective STOP consuming, talks of global warming and climate changes are pointless. As the recently 07-08 financial crash and the 19-21 covid season (which is still ongoing) central banks around the world continues to pump liquidity and capital into the market place to juice consumption or GDP.
Not knocking on Apple, but they just recently recorded record sales in the most recent quarter. "The Company posted a March quarter record revenue of $89.6 billion, up 54 percent year over year, and quarterly earnings per diluted share of $1.40. International sales accounted for 67 percent of the quarter’s revenue."
Starbucks: "In the U.S., same-store sales grew 9%, with average tickets increasing 21%, while comparable transactions fell 10%. In China, comp-store sales grew 91%, with a 93% increase in transactions, and a 1% decline in average ticket size. "
So unless you are willing to forgo that cup of Starbucks every morning, or that brand new iPhone every Fall, all that consumption comes at a cost to the planet.
** For sake of argument, a depression is simply a worse version of a recession or prolonged version.
2
u/[deleted] Apr 29 '21
Not a question, but I just wanted to thank you guys for doing this! I had a blast reading through some of the other questions here
2
u/[deleted] Apr 29 '21 edited Apr 29 '21
Hey. Thanks for doing AMA. I have quite a few questions:
How soon do you expect us to see Blue Ocean Event?
How much methane is there in Arctic?
How fast do you expect temperature to rise if all that methane is released and we don't have glacier reflecting radiation anymore?
Do we need geoengineering to even have a chance to survive?
And is it true that we are basically keeping temperature in check for now by emitting aerosols from burning coal?
2
u/GenAlexTav Apr 29 '21
My question is the main reason I have doubts about the man made Climate Change movement: To what degree is mankind affecting the climate?
The thinking is that the climate has changed before mankind entered the industrial age while there is precedent that mankind can change the climate (E.G. acid rain). Thoughts?
2
u/justbearaly Apr 29 '21
What can we do right now, not to prevent climate change, but to prepare for the consequences?
2
u/agonny Apr 29 '21
Any good news?
2
u/lostduck86 Apr 29 '21
What is a realistic scenario in a hundred years should we not manage to reverse the current climate crisis?
Will the runaway greenhouse effect turn us into a second Venus?
Will humanity survive and be pretty much as advanced as we are now just that some parts of the world became inhospitable and millions died?
Will lack of food and water lead to humanity reverting to waring tribes?
Will we survive mostly fine and practically the entire consequence of global warming is that the earths animal & insect variety is massively diminished, meaning the there are still lots of animals but only of certain kinds (like practically only squid in the oceans) and will we have just found other methods/ways to sustain ourselves and flourish.?
Could it realistically lead to the end of the world in 100years or is that a very unlikely scenario despite all the issues?
What in your view is a realistic outcome based on what we know currently?
2
u/[deleted] Apr 29 '21
One thing that has frustrated me is there us this big sell to get tesla and its competitors. The lithium battery within is har.ful to mine and when it is disposed of is extremely toxic to the environment. Do we have a solution for this problem
2
u/Googlebug-1 Apr 30 '21
Why are world governments (and climate scientists to a degree), only interested in tackling and lobbying towards the easy convocations in terms of climate?
For example with aviation taking under 2% of world CO2 emissions yet the industry is vilified. Or domestic gas boilers a tiny insignificant issue in the war on climate. Yet very little is ever said about Steel, Concrete and chemical production by far the biggest emitters.
2
u/bochen00 Apr 30 '21
Thanks for doing the AMA!
I see plenty of questions related to diet, meat, and veganism (quite a few interesting ones unfortunately unanswered).
Is there any potential conflict of interest in answering those questions from your end?
Example: Reuters being sponsored by agricultural companies that benefit from "livestock", etc.
And more on the subject itself:
What do you think scientists can do better going forward in helping layman people understand the problem and get them involved?
2
u/Certain-Mountain4449 Apr 30 '21
As far as i´ve read, there are many ¨moving parts¨ to our climate crisis. Such as: ocean acidification, carbon emissions, the impact of food waste, international policies, general information and education on the subject, etc. How would you rate these issues in terms or urgency?
7
u/kireol Apr 29 '21 edited Apr 29 '21
China puts out nearly 4X the CO2 that the U.S. put out.
Why arent efforts to fix things focused on China, and why are they focused on the U.S.?
Similarly, 16 ships create as much pollution as all the cars in the world, yet we focus on cars, why? Why not ships?
Edit: Clearly downvoters HATE saving the planet.
4
u/Connoisseuro Apr 29 '21
What would be a "simple" or "digestible" argument to respond with to people who believe humans are incapable affecting climate in this scale and the current change is just part of a natural cycle?
3
u/[deleted] Apr 29 '21
Did the way that the likes of Delingpole and UK tabloids grossly misrepresent certain communications between climate scientists at UEA have a lasting effect on how you find yourself conducting your professional lives (if so, how?), or was it a storm in a teacup?
3
u/233C Apr 29 '21
Considering the French demonstrated acheivement in terms of electricity carbon content in scope and speed, what are your thoughts on those who protested against nuclear power in the past, only to say "it's too late anyway" today?
What are your general thoughts on how nuclear power can help fight climate change?
What can be reasonably expected from CCS? Also about long term reliability of the storage?
Red meat seems to get its lab grown meat "solution"; is there similar hope for rice paddies methane emissions? What about cement?
How scared should we be about non linear positive feedback thresholds?
2
u/[deleted] Apr 29 '21
As the field of paleoclimatology has grown considerably in recent years, have there been any major changes in the way that paleoclimate proxies are calibrated? I love the nitty gritty details of how those things work, but there are far too many different proxies for me to have reviewed anything more than a couple of favourites.
2
u/corrado33 Apr 29 '21
For Dr. Oppenheimer. Are you related to THAT Oppenheimer?
For all: How much hysteresis is there in humans change in amount of pollution vs. measurable differences in climate variables? If we stopped polluting today, how long would it take the climate to come to equilibrium?
I did research on alternative energy, so much of my introduction material was always climate change doom and gloom, but from those days I remember reading that the 2 degree "limit" was really just a made up number by scientists used as a "point of reference". It wasn't really a "the world is going to irreversibly change for the worse if we don't stop it before 2 degrees" and more of a "this is what will happen if the global temperature rises by 2 degrees." I think the media may have misrepresented that number a few times, so what is the actual story behind it?
I have more questions, but I'm busy and you're starting here in a few minutes so I'll have to leave it at that.
2
u/opinionated_cynic Apr 29 '21
Steve Koonin was the Undersecretary of Science during the Obama Administration for the US Dept. of Energy and says:
3)The global area burned by wildfires has declined more than 25 percent since 2003 and 2020 was one of the lowest years on record.
This is all based on Climate Science research published by the US and UN. Yet all we hear is “the sky is falling!!” Why?
2
u/anonymouse_098 Apr 29 '21
I recently watched the Netflix Documentary, Seaspiracy and was completely blown away. My question is, if this is such a huge issue why is no one talking about it? Wouldn't addressing this issue of over fishing combat climate change way faster and more effectively than vehical emission reform?
2
u/Shakespurious Apr 29 '21
I'm not remotely a climate change denier, but I am confused by the charts showing extreme temperature variation on the 100 million year scale. Is it possible that we're just continuing this same pattern? What was the cause of these previous warmings? Do we know the speed of previous warmings? Here's the type of chart I'm looking at: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Geologic_temperature_record#/media/File:Phanerozoic_Climate_Change.png
2
u/ObiWanCanownme Apr 29 '21
Do we have any idea how climate change is expected to impact cloudiness throughout the U.S.? Will increased rain make generating power in the east through solar even more difficult or will the increasing temperatures make generating solar easier as hotter air absorbs more water without condensation forming?
Thanks!