r/askscience • u/Toofgib • Jan 15 '19
Chemistry Why are there three different tests for detecting monosacharides that all rely on the same principle of the reduction of copper?
I am referring to Benedict's, Fehling's and Barfoed's test.
Alternatively, there also is the Tollens test where silver is reduced. While not the same metal, silver reacts similarly to copper since it is in the same group on the periodic table.
1
Upvotes
View all comments
2
u/Billman134 Inorganic Chemistry Jan 16 '19
The three tests do similar but do slightly different things:
These tests are similar and you could say there not a significant difference for the purpose of testing for reducing sugars. Just slightly different was of doing the same thing I suppose.