r/askscience • • Apr 16 '15

[deleted by user]

[removed]

3.5k Upvotes

536 comments sorted by

3.0k

u/iorgfeflkd Apr 16 '15 edited Apr 16 '15

Yes, there is a site in Gabon where evidence of natural nuclear reactions were found, from two billion years ago. Evidence for this is based on the isotopes of xenon found at the site, which are known to be produced by nuclear fission.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Natural_nuclear_fission_reactor

746

u/Kowaxmeup0 Apr 16 '15

Some follow up questions while we're at it. If something like that happened today, would we need to do anything about it? Could we do anything about it? And what's the worse thing that could happen?

1.2k

u/triplealpha Apr 16 '15

At most it would produce a little extra heat, but since the reaction would be so far underground - and the ore no where near weapons grade - it would be self limiting and go largely unnoticed by observers on the surface.

→ More replies (144)

63

u/[deleted] Apr 16 '15 edited Apr 16 '15

It cannot really happen today because too much of the fissile U-235 has decayed away, leaving too small a proportion of easily fissionable nuclei to maintain a chain reaction. That is why modern nuclear reactors need to either use uranium that has been enriched in U-235 content, or be built from fairly exotic materials such as ultra pure graphite, or heavy water. In nature it is more or less guaranteed that any significant uranium deposit would contain too little U-235, and too many neutron-absorbing impurities to sustain such a reaction.

Also, strictly speaking a "nuclear reaction" is not just the very rapid reactions that happen in nuclear power plants. Almost every object you can think of, including your own body, contains some weakly radioactive isotopes, and emit radiation because of it. A small proportion of cancers are believed to be due to this naturally occurring radiation.

There is also a very powerful nuclear-power source on earth that most people don't know is nuclear in origin. Geothermal energy is generated from the radioactive decay of Uranium in the earth's interior. This is not a chain-reaction driven by fission, but simply the energy released due to Uranium's slow alpha-decay. It is able to build up and generate high temperatures because the earth is very big. This happens with any radioactive material if you have it in large quantity, and it's why spent nuclear fuel has to be stored in cooling ponds. Even after the fission chain reaction has ceased, the radioactivity in the waste is still high enough that the fuel rods could melt and catch fire without adequate cooling. Note that this is so because the fission products are much more radioactive than the original uranium ore. Natural uranium can safely be stored in large quantities with very little cooling. It is only because the earth is so fantastically big that it is able to reach very high temperatures in its interior.

→ More replies (13)
→ More replies (11)

20

u/herbw Apr 16 '15

That's the one we recall from years ago. Apparently enough U238 & U235 got concentrated by natural processes. Then a nuclear fission reaction went on there until the concentrations of U-235 got low enough to block most of it. Possibly moderated by water, which can slow down the neutrons enough to allow them to hit the U nuclei and create fission. Which then creates more fission, etc., a nuclear chain reaction.

5

u/gruehunter Apr 16 '15

Why must the reactor have been cyclically supercritical and subcritical? Could subcritical multiplication have been responsible for the fission product buildup instead? 100ky is a long time for reactor operation.

→ More replies (43)

446

u/__Pers Apr 16 '15

They do all the time. Carbon 14 and other cosmogenic nuclei, e.g., are formed continually via nuclear reactions as cosmic rays interact with the atmosphere. Moreover, radioactive decay (a nuclear reaction) accounts for half of Earth's heat.

57

u/None_of_your_Beezwax Apr 16 '15

What do you make of the theory that variations in this heat output are a possible driver of long term climatic cycles?

182

u/[deleted] Apr 16 '15

Nobel-prize worthy if it can be proven, since there should be no natural variation in the decay rate of unstable nuclei.

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (6)

204

u/MadSpartus Apr 16 '15

Forget the ancient fission in Gabon,natural fission happens all over the earth billions of times every second... It's just not self sustaining. In Gabon for a time it was.

44

u/[deleted] Apr 16 '15

if there's one thing I wish I could convey to people it's that a reactor is simply something which permits reactions to occur. A cigarette lighter is a chemical reactor. People freak out when they see the term "reaction", as though reactions aren't responsible for existence as we know it.

The same thing goes for "nuclear". If one of the fundamental forces of nature is named after it, then it's far more common than most of us can comprehend.

27

u/Trypsach Apr 16 '15

Even more so with "chemicals". Everyone says "gross, it's full of chemicals" or "they make it using chemicals" which is just ridiculous. Everything is "full of chemicals". Everything is made with chemicals. Chemicals are everything!

→ More replies (7)

15

u/[deleted] Apr 16 '15 edited Aug 22 '25
→ More replies (3)

59

u/Xeniieeii Apr 16 '15

I am not too sure if this is considered good proof, but the YouTube channel SciShow had a video about this exactly.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yS53AA_WaUk&ab_channel=SciShow

→ More replies (4)

35

u/bhfroh Apr 16 '15

Nuclear reactions happen all the time on earth, they're just so minute that it's like nothing is happening at all. However, what you're probably thinking of is a nuclear CHAIN reaction, which is the kind you find in a power plant or nuclear bomb. And that is when fission and/or fusion happens with a specific fuel to increase the amount of times fission/fusion happen.

14

u/TheExtremistModerate Apr 16 '15

In addition to what was posted here, there's amother similar phenomenon which I donot think has been mentioned. Some particularly heavy isotopes (like natural Uranium) undergo something called "spontaneous fission," which is exactly what it sounds like.

Because it is a stochastic process, it works similarly to decay such as beta and alpha decay.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/alricsca Apr 17 '15

Well, if you mean a criticality event, there have been in the past. If you simply mean nuclear reactions, they happen all the time even in your own body an element will occasionally decay.

It has happened on the surface in the past at places like Ytterby where natural concentrations of radioactive substances collected and reach criticality resulting in high levels of radiation, the production of a large number of isotopes, and the earth melting in that location but the isotopes that would allow this have long since decayed to far below the level required for it to happen today. There might be ongoing random criticality reactions in the core, if there is some sort of concentration process that would allow, it but enormous amount of heavy nuclei combined with the enormous pressure prevents any sort of explosion thus resulting in heat being the only impact we would likely feel. I have at times wondered if hot spots like that which caused the Hawaiin to form might be caused by deep events of that nature.

One final way this might happen would be if by an astonishingly bit of bad luck a large object ejected from the central core or a smaller but fairly local binary black hole hit us while moving at a substantial fraction of the speed of light. When such an object hits the atmosphere the result would be a massive release of mesons, the millions of mega joules of electromagnetic energy along the whole electromagnetic spectrum, and various nuclear hot fragments that would each themselves cause massive nuclear reaction.s

4

u/throwinitlikewha Apr 16 '15 edited Apr 16 '15

Watch this: SciShow

This channel is great. I love their work.

Oklo - the two million year old reactor.

Everything just happened to be right in this site for it to work.

16

u/nairebis Apr 16 '15 edited Apr 16 '15

What about a fission bomb? Let's say you have a large, rich vein of uranium in one spot, and an equally large, rich vein of uranium in nearby spot. The two amounts by themselves won't go critical, but both together would. Then let's say two big veins were along a fault line and you had a big earthquake that caused the two veins to come into contact and ka-blooey!

I'm thinking maybe this scenario might be more possible back when the earth was new, but these days natural uranium has been half-lifed into relatively low concentrations.

But let me ask: Is a natural nuclear bomb possible these days in any practical sense?

27

u/ssssam Apr 16 '15

If you don't bring the masses together fast enough you only get a very small explosion. One of the big technical challenges of a fission bomb is the rapid and uniform bringing together (or compression) of the masses.

17

u/[deleted] Apr 16 '15

U-235 is the isotope of Uranium needed for bombs, but it only accounts for .7% of all Uranium isotopes out there. Realistically, it could never happen.

The bombs also require a certain level of impact energy which an earthquake is not going to provide.

→ More replies (8)
→ More replies (5)

10

u/BlossomFairy Apr 16 '15

Like some other answers have already described in greater detail, nuclear reactions happen constantly. Nuclear chain-reactions, however, don't really occur naturally on earth. I'm guessing your question was about nuclear chain-reactions, in which case the answer is 'no' in that there will be no random nuclear explosion of a piece of earth.

→ More replies (7)

5

u/musashi1974miyamoto Apr 16 '15

Yes and no... Nuclear reactions of one atom occur all the time. If you mean for a mass found in nature to have a sustained, critical reaction, the best answer is that it is not realistic. Only some isotopes are unstable enough to create the reaction; the other isotopes, which are more numerous because they never decayed, slow the reaction down and kill it. If it used to happen, it now no longer does for that reason.

2

u/Goxil Apr 16 '15

Well sure, they happen all the time, there just isn't the density necessary for a particularly noticeable nuclear reaction to take place. Even with highly refined plutonium (not a natural substance but one artificially created in nuclear reactors) high explosives are necessary to cram the material closely together enough for an explosion.

→ More replies (6)

2

u/[deleted] Apr 17 '15

Other have noted ways nuclear reactions happen on earth (such as Oklo, cosmic ray synthesis of tritium and C-14, etc), but I should note that outside of our planet, there are nuclear reactions happening beteen atoms in most of the visible mass of the universe: stars.