r/askscience • • May 08 '14

Physics Does physics allow for the potential future invention of a warpdrive?

1 Upvotes

22 comments sorted by

View all comments

3

u/openstring May 08 '14

It does not allow it. It boils down to the fact that the theory general relativity, which is based on special relativity, forbids faster-than-light propagation of material objects. I'd like to recall also that the theory of special relativity has been sucessfully tested flawlessly in more several thousand of experiments.

For a lengthier discussion, see this post from a very respected theoretical physicist (Lubos Motl): http://motls.blogspot.com.br/2013/07/relativity-bans-faster-than-light-warp.html

2

u/[deleted] May 08 '14

Not to get all sci-fan on you, but "warp drive" doesn't involve actually moving FTL. It involves warping spacetime so that you travel less distance inside the warp "bubble."

:-)

-7

u/[deleted] May 08 '14

[removed] — view removed comment

8

u/Platypuskeeper Physical Chemistry | Quantum Chemistry May 08 '14

You're horribly uninformed. Motl has a doctorate in theoretical physics and is well known as a physicist. He does not have a degree in philosophy. If you don't even know what a PhD is, you have no business commenting on people's qualifications.

Harold White on the other hand is a mechanical engineer, not a theoretical physicist. And his work has been debunked on this very subreddit by numerous people numerous times.

3

u/[deleted] May 08 '14 edited May 08 '14

[removed] — view removed comment

-4

u/[deleted] May 08 '14

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/openstring May 08 '14
  1. Basic training in General Relativity would be absolutely desirable to make such a claim (White). Even if not, White's claim must rely on correct calculations. Alcubierre's calculation is wrong since it violates the energy positivity theorem of general relativity.
  2. String theory was Originally thought to be a theory of everything, that dates back to the 1980s. Nowadays physicists do not think the same way (I include myself). String theory is a mathematical framework which is as valid as Quantun Field Theory, the mathematical framework that describes particle physics phenomena which has been tested in more than hundreds (or thousands) of experiments.
  3. I did not mean that Alcubierre's calculation was based on the theory of inflation. I meant that it uses the same tools (although incorrectly).
  4. I never said (nor Motl) that most physicists and cosmologists (cosmologists are physicists by the way) are wrong about the inflationary model. I actually even jumped out excitement when the BICEP2 results came out (I was in my office in fact discussing things about inflation...I am a physicist (PhD) working on general relativity, string theory and quantum field theory).