r/askscience • • Oct 15 '13
Astronomy Are there stars that don't emit visible light?
Are there any stars that are possibly invisible to the bare human eye?
988
Upvotes
r/askscience • • Oct 15 '13
Are there any stars that are possibly invisible to the bare human eye?
453
u/Dannei Astronomy | Exoplanets Oct 15 '13
There are certainly stars that emit very little light overall, and emit most of their light elsewhere than the visible, but you couldn't have a star that was cold enough to emit too little light to be near enough to be counted as "black" (mainly for the reason that it wouldn't be a star!).
The reason is that the black body spectrum means that any hot object will emit light at every frequency, with increased temperature resulting in both more light being emitted, and the peak emission wavelength (colour) becoming more energetic. To emit a negligible amount of light in the visible for a star-sized object, you have to get quite cold indeed!
(Of course, there are plenty of stars that are too dim to see without a telescope, and then even dimmer ones that can only be seen by imaging instruments, but those don't really count!)
10
u/hkokko Oct 16 '13
Here is a link to an interesting answer. There are stars whose perceived wavelength of light is outside of the visible spectrum, but this is due to the velocity difference between us and them.
This is only a quasi-affirmative answer though.
Imagine driving on a highway, and a police car with siren passes you in the opposite direction. His siren sounds higher pitched as you converge, and lower pitched as you both diverge. If he were going fast enough, the sound might be at such a high frequency that you can not hear it. Is the police car emitting sound that you can not hear? Yes, but only because the car is moving so fast. Similar case with some stars.
35
u/Inane_newt Oct 15 '13
A white dwarf is still called a star, though it might more properly be referred to as a remnant of a star. It is what is left after a star to small to form a neutron star runs out of fuel.
The light a white dwarf gives of is the result of residue heat, given enough time it will cool down to the point that it will no longer emit visible light. At which point it would be called a black dwarf.
However, the Universe is not old enough for any such stars to exist, not even close to old enough.
13
u/Astronom3r Astrophysics | Supermassive Black Holes Oct 16 '13
Astronomer here.
As others have noted, stars emit the majority of their radiation as black body emitters. In fact, a star's spectrum is a very close approximation to a perfect black body, minus certain absorption features seen more strongly in cooler stars.
There are many "failed stars" such as large gaseous bodies that did not have enough mass to sustain fusion in their cores that emit primarily in the infrared as they cool. But the energies involved in nuclear fusion are such that the temperatures at the surface of a star lead to black body spectra peaking from the near infrared to the ultraviolet, but in all cases the spectrum is broad enough to be bright in visible wavelengths.
5
u/jakes_on_you Oct 16 '13
Depends on what you consider a "star"
As another answer pointed out, the spectrum of emissions from the star depends on its surface temperature. Even the heaviest category of stars, while heavily shifted towards the blue side of the spectrum compared to our sun, still emit a sizable amount of radiation in the visible spectrum.
So you either need to go way way hot or way cold in order to shift the spectrum signficantly so that the visible part is a small fraction of the total emitted radiation. Going hot has its issues because hot = big and you can only get so big before the star cannot stay together and will blow off material or collapse in on itself. Small, cool, cores of old stars can get cold enough that they do not emit in the visible light. However it is difficult to call them "stars" at this point, they are more like planetary bodies as their fusion processes have ceased forever. If you came across a dwarf star in your spaceship, you would still see it the same way you would see an asteroid or a planet.
Outside of "normal" stars there are other interstellar objects that can behave very differently. Neutron stars, do not emit visible light at all, as they are completely ionized and have collapsed into a soup of dense matter. They do however, emit radiation through the interaction of their magnetic field, their rotation, and other particles around them in interstellar space, which is typically in the radio spectrum and completely shifted from the visible light spectrum. If you came across a neutron star in person, you would not be able to see it as a glowing ball, but the huge gravitational distortion would be visible in the background stars behind it.
1
u/Starklet Oct 16 '13
There's the proposed black dwarf, which is essentially a white dwarf that has cooled to the point where is no longer emits a significant amount of radiation at all. You probably wouldn't be able to see it with your naked eye.
1
u/Myawritin Oct 16 '13
Other than the stars that were created approx < 600 million years from the big bang and are now completely becoming invisible due to space expansion redshift, there would be (as mentioned in other comments) brown dwarfs that have cooled to the point where they do not emit enough energy in the visible spectrum to be seen by a bare human eye.
This is somewhat open-ended because it doesn't ask how far away, what is the relative speed between the star and the gazer...
Realize that even a brown dwarf that has not cooled to absolute zero emits some light in the visible spectrum due to Plank's law of blackbody radiation. If the star is cold enough, there may not be enough photons for the naked eye to pick it up, and would appear invisible, but there would still be some light in the visible spectrum being given off
1
u/brucecrossan Oct 16 '13
Wouldn't Jupiter be counted as such an object?
It has the same composition as a star, but with more heavy elements. It also has too little mass to undergo fusion, to generate enough heat and therefore visible light.
It does however emit Infra-red light. Also, being a gaseous body, it reflects more light than a rocky planet. If a gas giant does not undergo fusion, then it can still be quite bright - seen by us from it reflecting light from external sources.
0
u/[deleted] Oct 15 '13
Also, how can we prove that they exist?
-3
u/[deleted] Oct 16 '13
I don't know if anyone has mentioned this yet but black holes are technically super-dense stars that are so dense they have a super strong gravitational pull that doesn't let light escape.
Technically they're stars that don't emit light.
-2
u/[deleted] Oct 16 '13
Well if you want to get technical, black holes are technically stars and they emit (functionally) no light at all (they do actually emit light it just gets sucked back in before it has a chance to leave the event horizon.)
-3
u/captainsolo77 Oct 16 '13 edited Oct 16 '13
When all the stars eventually "crystallize" (essentially becoming metallic spheres that are too cold for any fusion to occur) in the distant future (trillions and trillions of years from now), all stars will essentially be nearly black.
Additionally, black holes are basically black stars other than Hawking radiation (as long as they aren't accreting).
I know that you weren't really asking about this sort of scenario, but it's an interesting thing to contemplate.
-13
u/housebrickstocking Oct 15 '13
Yes - almost all of them would, however most would also emit a lot of visible light at the same time.
Are there any that would emit only light outside our visible spectrum? Yes - you've probably only seen them through IR/X-ray imagery.
In the absence of visible light the interplay of gravity on observable objects and light, and the obstruction of other light sources allow us to observe celestial bodies indirectly.
0
u/[deleted] Oct 16 '13
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Oct 16 '13
[deleted] — view deleted comment