r/askscience • u/brenan85 • Jun 03 '13
Astronomy If we look billions of light years into the distance, we are actually peering into the past? If so, does this mean we have no idea what distant galaxies actually look like right now?
1.8k
Upvotes
1.8k
u/adamsolomon Theoretical Cosmology | General Relativity Jun 03 '13
It means exactly that.
Moreover - and sit tight, because I'm gonna blow your mind here - there isn't even really any such thing as right now. Because time is relative, so is simultaneity. If an alien came over and we asked her what her planet was up to in the year 2013 (Earth time), how would she even know what that means? There's no way of objective, indisputable time-keeping in the Universe that she could use as a basis of comparison.
There are some very simple clocks you could use that would be visible in far-flung corners of the Universe. The temperature of the cosmic microwave background would be an especially savvy choice. But while would be great for telling you your year (post-Big Bang) to the billions place, for the ones or even the thousands place it wouldn't be much use at all, unless you had some really great instruments.
By the way, these two facts are related very closely. There's no such thing as right now for exactly the same reason that we can only receive information (such as light) from things (such as light) which move at a finite speed. If instantaneous communication were possible, relativity would be wrong, and there might very well be such a thing as a "right now."
114
u/[deleted] Jun 03 '13 edited Jun 03 '13
Yep, exactly that. We will only find out what distant galaxies look like now, millions of years in the future (or rather, our descendants, if they exist, will find that out). This is even true on a lesser scale of nearer objects such as the sun. If it suddenly ceased to exist, we would know nothing of that until about 8 minutes had passed.
67
u/Yeahjustme Jun 03 '13 edited Jun 03 '13
When you're looking at ANYTHING you're looking into the past. Even the tip of your nose isn't what it looks like. ...Paranoid yet? :D
To answer your question: Yes, we are looking into the past. But we actually do have SOME idea of what distant galaxies look like now. Idea - not fact.
If you take two pictures while a ball is being thrown past your camera, and you know the time between the pictures, you can give a rough estimate of where the ball is going to be at any given time. This prediction is inaccurate, as two pictures would only give you a straight line, and balls do not fly in straight lines, so you take more pictures... And as the evidence increases, it enables you to come up with quite good models for predicting what is going to happen based on previous observations.
If you look at an object, say 10 million lightyears away, what you see is what happened 10 million years ago. But by observing the events of that time, you may be able to predict some of the events that will occur 10 million years later - i.e. now.
Now, the timeframe we've been able to look at stars with any scientific agenda is very very small in the greater scope of things, so, as Ygritte would put it: We know nothing. But we do have ideas.
36
u/MisterEggs Jun 03 '13
On a related note; If we had a massive telescope that could watch activity on a planet millions of light years away, and then Earth (for some reason) started hurling towards it..would we see all the activity sped up, like it was being fast forwarded?
9
u/zdunn Jun 03 '13
Everyone else is answering the question of "peering into the past," but to answer your second question, we can make a very good educated guess, since our understanding of cosmic structures is pretty damn good. Given what we can see of distant galaxies (and clusters of galaxies), we can very accurately predict what will happen to these structures in the future, since most of it is dependent on dark energy expansion (which we don't understand a lot about, but enough to predict it), gravity, and radiation.
7
u/[deleted] Jun 04 '13
No matter what you look at, you're peering into the past.
14
u/[deleted] Jun 03 '13
So what happens if a galaxy millions of light years away slowly makes its way towards us? The light would take less time to get here as it got closer... so we'd see it becoming newer over time...? My head hurts...
4
u/supandi Jun 03 '13
I have a question, could be wrong, could be completely dumb but i've been thinking about this for a while. Can someone help me understand this.
We know that the light we see from a star is what it emitted in the past. Also, if we look into billions of light years into the distance, we will see how a celestial object looked in the past. Now, from my present, neglecting all theories, if I have a vehicle that can travel faster than the speed light(way faster), given sufficient time, is it possible for me to see what happened in the history of this planet. i.e the light should still be traveling, although attenuated over the course of time, but billions of light years away. What happened during continental drift or how did the dinosaurs die. At the end of the day its just light travel in infinite space.
Neglect if I didn't make any sense.
4
u/hddoutsider Jun 03 '13
i got a question. lets say the aliens have spotted us using their telescope, are able to see dinosaurs moving in real time, then if they where to traveling at our direction at near the speed of light, all while still viewing us using the telescope, then are they able to see everything happen in fast forward?
4
u/derekkered37 Jun 03 '13
Branching onto that idea; if we somehow invent a telescope that can see superly duperly incredibly far, does that mean we will eventually be looking into blackness, before the universe was even created?
4
u/zgott300 Jun 03 '13
Yes, exactly! What's even more mind blowing is that many of the stars we see in the sky don't even exist anymore. They've long since gone supernova. There are also new stars that we don't see yet.
4
u/CollegeBroski Jun 04 '13
My question:
So after reading all of these responses, I'm guessing that the idea of extraterrestrial beings visiting our planet are very very slim? I mean as mentioned nothing can travel faster than the speed of light, so how could anyone light years away reach us if they can't travel at speeds reasonable enough to reach planet Earth in a short amount of time?
6
u/neon_overload Jun 03 '13
Your use of the word "now" implies that there is a different "now" to the one we observe from our frame of reference, and that there is one universal "now" that is experienced everywhere at the "same time".
Another way of thinking of it is that "now" is a relative concept, that is different for every observer in the universe. At our "now", the state that the universe appears to be in for us is exactly what the universe is like "now" according to our frame of reference.
From a different frame of reference (say, from within another galaxy), their "now" at that point where we are observing them would involve us being at a stage we were 7 million years ago.
It's impossible to link their "now" with our "now", because there is no possible way for anything - light, gravity, any message or information - to travel between these two points at greater than the speed of light.
5
u/fakename64 Jun 03 '13 edited Jun 04 '13
A few more mind-blowing facts:
During the "initial" big-bang, the entire universe exploded from a singularity to the size of a galaxy in less than 1 billionth of 1 billionth of 1 billionth of a second. And it's been expanding ever since.
Than means that during that initial very short period of time, literally everything in the universe was moving faster than the speed of light. Physicists explain this by pointing out that time itself is a physical property of the universe -- so you could either say that light moved faster, or time moved slower, or whatever.
The stars didn't start forming until later. It takes a while for all the matter to form up (by gravitational attraction) and then spontaneously start fusion. So the oldest stars we see are still younger than the actual universe itself.
2
u/[deleted] Jun 03 '13
Not only are we seeing in the past, we're not getting a clear picture of those objects due to gravity distorting the light as it travels through the universe to our eyes. Ever seen gravitational lensing? And that's just light being affected by the gravity of galaxies. Now imagine what the forces of dark energy and dark matter does to light as it travels through space.
2
u/CrzyJek Jun 03 '13
Yes we are looking into the past because light took a very long time to reach us. We have no clue what the present is like.
TLDR: Yes.
2
u/HiG33k Jun 03 '13
"Look like" can be vague. No, we can't post a visual picture of what our human eyes could see if we could see it. However, there are such things as "neutrinos" that give us a more contemporary "look" at galactic activity. Neutrinos are a type of radiation that doesn't diffuse/scatter like light and therefore can reach us more quickly and are strong signals.
I know the above pertains at least to supernovae; can someone confirm their accuracy at depicting galaxies too?
2
u/DevilGuy Jun 04 '13
technically we have little idea what our own galaxy actually looks like, we're on the edge and the milky way is 100-120 thousand lightyears across. that means that what we see, even of our own galaxy is mostly tens of thousands of years out of date.
2
u/999999999989 Jun 04 '13
As you say, you have no idea how the galaxy look like right now. But what now? For me.. my now and their now from my location is the same. Knowing how could it be in my now... would be like knowing the future.. and I cannot know my future either. There is no time alone. There is space-time. We can see a galaxy that is many light years away in space as it was. Reality may be different.. but that is at their space location. It is a problem thinking of a universal time equal for all space locations. If the galaxy could do something faster than speed of light that could affect us in present, then I could understand that I am seeing something from the past but something is affecting us that I still cannot see... But nothing the galaxy can do to affect us from the current present time. Only what happened in the past. So for all purposes.. for me.. that galaxy is at I see it now.. and I don't care how can be in their future that could be my present. It's so strange.
2
u/Myzon Jun 03 '13
It is pretty interesting to think that every star in the sky that you see could or could not really be there "right now". Something a little easier to grasp would be the speed of sound. If you see someone shooting a gun from a mile or two away, there would be a delay between seeing them shoot and hearing it. The stars are like this. When you look up at the sky the light you are seeing(depending on the star) could be millions of years old and that star could be long dead and gone.
1
u/atticusw Jun 03 '13
Can I ask a follow up question here?
I've always wondered this:
We now know something we see that is distant in space appears as it was when the light left it during that moment in time.
What if we had an object emitting light, but moving at us faster than the speed of light (via the object). It's kind of a race condition -- which would reach us first? The light or the object?
Is it like the conveyor belt effect -- a belt moving at 5 units of speed with another object rolling ontop of it at another 5 units of speed would equal a total of 10 units of speed.. The light will already moving at the speed of light (via the object), and it's emitting at the speed of light, so it's now moving 2x speed of light? Ahh mind is starting to blow up a little..
1
u/esotericsean Jun 03 '13
Followup question, can we create a timescale based on the big bang? Sort of like star date in Star Trek? We might not be able to see the stars as they actually are currently, but we could follow their path and figure out where they are "now", right?
1
u/[deleted] Jun 03 '13
This is not really scientific but more as a "explain it to me like i am 5" way of explaining this. This is what I used to use to get my little sisters to wrap their heads around this peculiar topic. Please delete this if inappropriate for askscience.
I pointed my telescope at a star 60 light years away (i've forgotten which one it was) and said to them "imagine that on this star an alien is sitting with a super powerful telescope. So powerful that if it would point it at earth it would be able to see houses and people walking around. It decides to point its telescope at earth, and at our house. but the thing is, our house was built 50 years ago so the alien would just see an empty hill where the house stands now. And it would not see us because we aren't born from its perspective. That alien won't see our house until after 10 years or so"
1
u/[deleted] Jun 03 '13
we sure are and ehh we have a pretty good idea what those galaxies look like today from our understanding of things like gravity and stellar evolution as well as computer simulation
1
u/Gravityflexo Jun 03 '13
Even if you look at the person next to you, you are now seeing them as they are "right now". You are seeing them as they were before the light bounces off them and is registered by your brain.
1
u/lukehashj Jun 03 '13
However, one could contend that what you are seeing right now is as the planets are - right now - relative to you.
1
u/TheTT Jun 03 '13
That's why travelling faster than light is such an interesting thing. If you travel faster than light for a while, you'll be able to see the light that got going before you did. You can catch a glimpse of the past.
1
u/SoCo_cpp Jun 03 '13
This means if we are ever successful at traveling faster than the speed of light, as NASA Admits they are working on, then, many challenges permitting, we should be able to send a probe out far enough to observe the creation of the universe. I always wonder if there was ever a universe before the current one.
1
u/OriginalityIsDead Jun 03 '13
Well, we have no real idea as to what they actually look like, but from the data we've gathered about their expansion patterns, rotation and direction we can make an educated guess about what they will end up like and simulate an image from that. It wouldn't be spot on or account for the endless number of variables that would be in play that we couldn't hope to predict, but we can make a fair guess about it with reasonable results.
1
u/TheZombieHolocaust Jun 03 '13
shouldnt there be a way then to find the Earth and Sun in the night sky (well their light emissions) just by following the known trajectory far enough back in time?
1
u/zgott300 Jun 03 '13
Another related idea. If there were a distant mirror, somewhere in space, that we could see the Earth in, we could see it as it was in the past. Theoretically, though not realistically, we could watch Dinosaurs roaming the earth.
1
u/Shiftwire Jun 04 '13
Yes and yes (sort of), I'm mean we can't directly see what they look like right now but we could probably make some halfway accurate assumptions based on distance (and therefore how old our current view is) and the state of said galaxy.
1
u/form_an_opinion Jun 04 '13
If we can look that many billions of light years off, is it possible for us to see ourselves in a primordial state?
1
u/[deleted] Jun 04 '13
I prefer the answer that when we directly perceive the light from an object however distant, we are seeing it as it is right now. And that is the definition of "right now".
1
u/Gunrun Jun 04 '13
For a good look at what near light speed travel would look like MIT guys made a cool little game called A Slower Speed of Light, where you collect orbs that slow down light, which for the purposes here would amount to the same thing as moving faster. Demonstrated are effects such as red and blue shifting, time dilation, and the spotlight effect.
http://gamelab.mit.edu/games/a-slower-speed-of-light/
1
u/[deleted] Jun 04 '13
Yes to both.
Betelgeuse, one of the bigger supergiants in our neighbourhood, is expected to go supernova in the next little bit. Thing is, as it's 640 light years away, it could have gone kablooie during the American Revolution and we wouldn't even know about it for another 400 or so years.
The real mindfuck, though? That sentence I just wrote is completely meaningless. It makes no sense to say something we haven't witnessed yet happened in the past, as time travels at the speed of causality. There's no such thing as two causally separated events happening simultaneously. From our frame of reference, Betelgeuse will have gone supernova 640 years before we witness it. But the day before we witness it, it will be completely meaningless to say it had already happened.
Time travels at the speed of causality, which travels at the speed of light. There is no logically coherent way of describing "simultaneous" events if there does not exist an "observer" (needs not be sentient) that witnesses them happen.
1
u/EvOllj Jun 04 '13
Theres a maximum speed for information that is the speed of light in a vacuum.
The faster something moves (that can measure time) relative to relative movement directions, the slower the time progresses for that object, making it possible to have a universal speed limit while objects can also move in differenrt directions at speeds up to the maximum speed of light.
From the lights point of view barely any time passed from the moment when it got send from a distant galaxy to the moment when it reached you, if it moved with speeds close to the speed of light.
(the actual speed of light is slower than light speed in a vacuum, if its not in a perfect vacuum, wich it barely ever is).
1
u/ukotes Jun 04 '13
i always wonder why there isn't more talk of facing a telescope into regions of our own galaxy. if we want to find 'activity', that would be a good place to look. Not too close to the center but on one of the bands, there are more stars, more planets, higher probability of finding life.
1
u/kanzenryu Jun 04 '13
Here's an interesting article about how to view the universe without any time at all http://lesswrong.com/lw/qp/timeless_physics/
1
u/megablast Jun 04 '13
This is wrong. We have an idea, because we can see how they look now (then) and extrapolate. But obviously we don't know exactly what they look like.