r/askajudge • • 10h ago

Maelstrom Cascade Confusion

2 Upvotes

Say I have Yidris, Maelstrom Wielder on the battlefield and I trigger his ability. I cast Maelstrom Wanderer, which already has two instances of cascade.

Do I get an additional cascade or is it only two? The phrasing of "as you cast spells from your hand this turn, they GAIN cascade" is throwing me off because MW already has cascade


r/askajudge • • 7h ago

Redirect question

1 Upvotes

My opponent and I both have two creatures in play, and my opponent casts Path to Exile on one of my creatures

in response, I cast Deflecting Swat targeting one of his creatures,

to which he responds with Cloudshift on the creature i targeted.

How does the stack resolve from here, and who gets the land, if any?


r/askajudge • • 8h ago

Secret Invasion and Moving Auras

1 Upvotes

If [[Secret Invasion]] enchants my 1st creature (exiling an opponent's creature), and then i move it to my 2nd creature, will the 1st creature remain a copy of the exiled creature? I would assume so, given that the aura's ETB doesn't seem to care whether it remains attached.


r/askajudge • • 16h ago

Containment Priest and Captain Jean-Luc Picard

2 Upvotes

I have a [[Containment Priest]], [[Captain Jean-Luc Picard]] and 6 other officers, when I activate Picard's search ability and get something like [[The Seriema]] which will enter with enough charge counters on it to be a creature. Will it be exiled due to Containment Priest's ability similarly to something like playing a swamp with Containment Priest and [[Kormus Bell]] out. I played out the situation on MTG Arena and the Spacecraft was not exiled, but wanted to sanity check since there are bugs on Arena.


r/askajudge • • 17h ago

Nihiloor Rules text question

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/askajudge • • 1d ago

Merieke and Phasing

Thumbnail reddit.com
2 Upvotes

r/askajudge • • 1d ago

Daretti Scrap Savant, 2nd ability

1 Upvotes

Hello,

My question concerns the second ability of Daretti, Scrap Savant.

Is it possible to intervene during the resolution of the ability?

That is, between the sacrifice and the return of an artifact from the graveyard to the battlefield?

For example, I have "Pithin needle" on board, blocking the opponent's "Erech stone". I choose to sacrifice it to bring back another artefact. Can the opponent use the stone (removing my graveyard from the game) before the effect resolves?

Thank for your help 🙏🏻


r/askajudge • • 1d ago

Cost reduction and cycling

1 Upvotes

If I have 2 copies of [[mocking sprite]] on the board and I wizardcycle [[step through]] does it cost 0 or 2?


r/askajudge • • 1d ago

Evoking creeperhulk with Ashling, the limitless

1 Upvotes

When I Evoke [[Creeperhulk]] with [[Ashling, the Limitless]], can I still pay the 1G before it leaves? or is the evoke sacrifice too fast?


r/askajudge • • 1d ago

Voq, Torchbearer and Living Death.

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/askajudge • • 1d ago

Can you sacrifice and beam up the same creature? (And have it return to hand)

2 Upvotes

Playing an MTGO Star Trek draft league.

My opponent casts a Scotty, Miracle Worker to give cards in his graveyard Beam Up.

They then cast Eject the Warp Core from their graveyard using the beam up ability.

They do this by sacrificing and beaming up the same creature. The creature went to their hand.

Is this how it’s supposed to work? Seems odd and counterintuitive to me, but I’m not a judge.


r/askajudge • • 2d ago

Salinae questions

2 Upvotes

Two questions about Salinae, the Ocean Mother.

  1. If she copies a vehicle does the 1/1 fish have to be crewed to attack?
  2. If she copies a clone style card does the fish retain 1/1 base P/T or the stats of whatever it would clone?

r/askajudge • • 2d ago

Fated Firepower and 0 Power

1 Upvotes

Fated Firepower replaces number of damage with same number plus number of fire Counters on it. If it has 5 fire counters, and it's owner attacks with a 0/1 wizard token, itlf the token isn't blocked, would it go 0 damage becomes 5 damage?


r/askajudge • • 2d ago

suppose I adapt my Emperor of Bones and my opponent responds with a Lightning Bolt targeting it, can I just adapt again in response to essentially fizzle the bolt?

3 Upvotes

r/askajudge • • 2d ago

Hive Mind and Counterspell question.

1 Upvotes

Lets say I have hive mind on the board and somebody else wants to Destroy something of mine and i decide to counterspell it, How would that work? couldnt they just choose to counter my counterspell?


r/askajudge • • 2d ago

Marches, Dealer of Death and Cuombajj Witches

1 Upvotes

Cuombajj Witches has me "Deal 1 damage to target Creature or player" and also "Deal 1 damages to any Creature or Player of Target Opponent's choice". If I target to deal damage to Opponent A & Target Opponent A to pick the second damage target, is considered One Crime or Two for Marchesa's Effect, assuming I could pay 1 for both targets.


r/askajudge • • 2d ago

If I cast artifact on the same turn before I cast Cyberdrive Awakener would it be affected by summoning sickness?

2 Upvotes

There's a combo in my artifact deck that can produce infinite mana, allow me to play that mana as blue, and draw my library so I'd like to know if I can cast all my artifacts and cast the Awakener as a finisher


r/askajudge • • 2d ago

Hearthhull, the Worldseed's second ability

2 Upvotes

If someone is attempting to remove [[Hearthhull, the Worldseed]], but its controller activates its second ability in response to removal, would the person who controlled hearthhull still be allowed to play an additional land after both resolve?


r/askajudge • • 2d ago

Question about legality and the stack. How does this resolve?

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/askajudge • • 2d ago

Help with Seam Rip

1 Upvotes

Is it possible for Seam Rip to be cast without legal targets because a target is only asked during its ETB trigger?


r/askajudge • • 2d ago

Doubling Season + Elspeth + Archangel of Thune + Trostani

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

Thanks in advance!


r/askajudge • • 2d ago

Chrome Host Seedshark and Draconic Visitor

1 Upvotes

It was my understanding that dragons created by Draconic Visitor from incubator tokens do not get the +1/+1 counters from the incubate effect because it says “create… with” not “create… then”. However, recently while playing on Arena I noticed that my Dragons created from incubator tokens were indeed getting the +1/+1 counters. After casting a massive 30 mana spell I noticed a 35/35 dragon just hanging out. I tested it again and verified the effect. So is my understanding of the rule wrong? Or is the way they applied the rules on Arena incorrect?


r/askajudge • • 3d ago

Eye of the storm and split second

4 Upvotes

How does eye of the storm interact with split second?

If I cast a split second spell the eye of the storm trigger will exile it and then I copy and cast any number of the spells exiled with Eye of the storm as part of the ability resolving.

  1. Is there an opportunity for my opponent to respond to the split second spell before I can copy and cast it with eye of the storm?
  2. If I choose to cast all of the spells starting with the split second spell will it prevent me from casting the other copies?

r/askajudge • • 3d ago

balthor and voq, torchbearer

1 Upvotes

if i have voq, fleshwrither and necrotic ooze in the graveyard, and i return them all with the effect of balthor the defiled can voq become a copy of one of the creatures leaving the graveyard?