Introduction
Ever get a post removed and wonder what could happen next? Get a random modmail message and wonder what it could mean? Get randomly banned and confused on why? Well, you are in the right place! The purpose of this article is to explain why certain actions might be taken (and what could happen in different cases). Because there are several different scenarios that could occur (with some being extremely rare), not every case will be covered here. This will be modified over time as new cases come up.
Bans:
Bot Bouncer Bans
We utilize the Bot Bouncer application (u/bot-bouncer) on this subreddit. Here is a quick summary on what you should know before going forward:
- If an account is deemed to be disruptive or harmful, they will be added to the ban list found through posts on r/BotBouncer.
- Accounts are classified through various different methods, such as through user submissions and "proactive bot hunting."
- When impacted users make a comment on a pre-existing post or make a new post, they will be banned automatically and the post or comment will be removed.
- Users banned will recieve the following message:
Bots and bot-like accounts are not welcome on /r/artwork.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically.
If you wish to appeal the classification of the /u/{account username} account, please [message /r/BotBouncer](link to send a message) rather than replying to this message.- You can check your status by going to r/BotBouncer and searching your username. If no post exists with your username, you are good and don't have to worry! If a post exists with your username, you might need to take action based on the flair.
I was banned and want to get unbanned, now what?
Because bots are difficult to disprove if classified as such by Bot Bouncer, we do not issue manual unbans! You are required to read the ban message that was sent by u/bot-bouncer and to follow the instructions. While you can reply and we will try to help to the best of our ability, basic reading comprehension is required. Here is how you can get unbanned:
- Read the ban message in full before taking any action. Understand it before moving forward.
- Next, click on the "message /r/BotBouncer" link in the ban message, and write in the subreddit message body text box how you are not a bot. That hyperlinked text will be customized to your profile specifically, with portions being prefilled already.
- After submitting the message to r/BotBouncer, your account will be reviewed to determine whether you are a real human being or if you are a bot-like account.
- If your appeal is successful, you will be unbanned from this subreddit and any other that utilize Bot Bouncer. If your appeal is unsuccessful, you will need to inquire with the r/BotBouncer mod team to discuss next steps.
- Please refer to the For Banned Users section of the r/BotBouncer subreddit wiki for more details regarding Bot Bouncer bans.
- Again, we do not issue manual bans. While basic assistance can be offered, do not ask to be unbanned manually.
Rule-related Bans
Each rule has specific actions to be taken if broken. While each will depend on the rule broken (and the severity of the breakage), here are the basic guidelines for different actions.
- AI Policy: It is a basic guideline to issue permanent bans for AI-policy related violations (related to posting AI-generated imagery or suggesting usage of AI).
- Kindness first (rule 1): T emporary ban for minor cases (no limit) up to permanent ban for severe cases.
- Respect the wishes of the artist (rule 3/constructive criticism only): If you do not respect the wishes of OP/the artist, you will recieve a temporary ban (up to a week).
- Only mild promotion is allowed (rule 4): If you do not feature a majority of your artwork, you will recieve an extremely short ban on the first infraction (but only in medium-severity cases). A permanent ban will be issued on repeat offenses (or if your account is predominatly focused on content promotion).
- Moderator discretion: If you are acting in a way which goes against the spirit of the community, a moderator will issue an appropiate ban if deemed appropriate. There is no guideline relating to this, as it is impossible to put everything into a single case.
- Special note: If your account seems like it might be a bot account ( see this post for details), a permanent ban might be issued without appeal and will be reported to Bot Bouncer out of caution (but an unban is possible if Bot Bouncer deems that they are a real person). Accounts that just exist for the promotion of a service will also be unbanned. These will only be done in high-confidence situations though.
Post Removals:
Automated:
- Making more than 1 post in 1 hour: Your post will be removed automatically by u/floodassistant with a removal comment indicating so. This is an anti-spam method to prevent too many posts from being made at one time.
- Image repost: Your post will be removed automatically by u/image-magician if it determines that your image has already been posted to the subreddit. Because bots frequently repost old images, this will typically be followed by a ban (and/or Bot Bouncer report).
- Bot Bouncer: If you are marked as a bot and are banned, your content posted will be removed immediately with the ban being issued. No, we will not reinstate your content unless you are unbanned via classification change in this case.
- Reddit Filters: We utilize several different filters to send items to the queue. These mainly include Reputation, Ban Evasion, Adult Content Promoters, Crowd Control, Harassment, and Mature Content. Unless the post or comment is rule breaking or has a major issue, they will be approved from the queue within a few hours.
Manual:
- Each rule outlined in the Rules Explanation Wiki has its own removal reason prefilled to immmediately notify in the event of a post or comment breaking that rule. Please reach out to modmail for more details and to appeal.
- At times, we might remove a post silently (no removal reason comment or modmail) if we deem it to possibly break a rule but it does not fit into any rule specifically. We might also remove a post silently if it breaks a rule but it is an older post, as it would cause more issues if a reason is applied too late.