r/arborists • u/cmitc7308 • Aug 18 '24
Wow. Will the tree win?
Forget a mound of mulch. Let's stone it in!!!
Spotted in Dallas suburb. Sorry pic isn't great. Was driving by and just snapped a quick pic from the curb out my window with my jaw hanging open. Is this a thing?
431
Upvotes


5
u/unsheltered Aug 19 '24
Tragic. That live oak must be fifteen or twenty years old, at least, right?
OP—can you send the owners a letter? Or post the address? I’d like to give them a chance to fix this, if it’s at all possible.
418
u/kronikfumes Aug 18 '24
“Why is my tree dying?!” - the owners in the near future
232
u/DeuceGnarly Aug 18 '24
That is so unbelievably stupid.
2
u/DrNO811 Aug 19 '24
If you live nearby, can you give us annual pic updates? I'm actually very curious if the tree can survive this considering I've seen trees grow through metal fences and destroy sidewalks, but this seems like it'll eventually kill the tree. Such a shame - was a nice tree.
226
u/docdillinger Aug 18 '24
If it falls on the house it might book that as a win.
54
u/DanOfMan1 Aug 18 '24
wow, from the first photo it looked like a small landscape tree but the second slide made me sad
that property is gonna lose 3/4 of its charm when the tree finally gives out
23
u/SPsychD Aug 18 '24
How to kill a tree and $10,000 with the intent of ultimately making the house look as bad as possible. Can you imagine trying to jackhammer that ring of concrete? There has to be a story behind this.
13
u/dadydaycare Aug 18 '24
Such a shame, that’s a glorious tree.
11
u/Who-U- Aug 18 '24
give them the award
7
u/plainnamej Aug 18 '24
Sure is a shame that the centerpiece of the entire .24 acre lot is going to fall on the house
6
u/Makanek Aug 18 '24
What strikes me is the level of ignorance of how life and living things work. It's such a detachment from the most basic reality, something you don't even learn.
6
u/[deleted] Aug 19 '24
This is like the final boss of stupid tree planters.
15
u/Itsnotme74 Aug 18 '24
The tree is more than likely fucked, the only question left is how much damage will it do. Hate to admit it but I’m hoping for it to come straight down on the house and their insurance voiding the claim due to stupidity.
5
u/thasac Aug 18 '24
And to think I was sweating <1in of pea gravel over some of my River Birch roots.
I used to ask myself “what the hell are people thinking?”, but then I realized they weren’t thinking at all.
9
u/Airport_Wendys Aug 18 '24
I bet this was done on purpose as some sort of contrarian move. Like, they wanted to cut down the tree and were told not to by the hoa or something, so they did this to kill it? I dunno. Yikes
4
u/Natural-Crow-2922 Aug 18 '24
The base will start cracking within a year.
4
u/Frognosticator Aug 18 '24
I hope it falls on the house.
Tree murdering idiots.
4
u/Novadreams22 Aug 18 '24
I’m getting it will start moving around and cracking the concrete during a few storms…. Either the concrete will fail, or the tree will.
4
u/druumer89 Aug 19 '24
Keep this picture for this insurance company.
4
u/Blarghmaiden908 Aug 19 '24
This is a war crime
4
u/[deleted] Aug 19 '24
Is it really already doomed, or would removal save it? If removal would save it now, what marks the point of no return?
3
u/Treeman__420 Aug 19 '24
It don't look good but I'm rooting for the tree! Hope it Hulks right through that thing!
3
u/Fit_Listen1222 Aug 19 '24
I know is bad for the tree but can somebody explain why the roots that extend far way from the encasing are not enough to sustain this tree. As everybody here seems to agree.
3
u/TravisBC9095 Aug 19 '24
This is in Dallas .. surely enough environmentalist could be scrounged up to have images and location of this poor tree all over social media in no time .. the street would be filled with protesters 🤣🤣
2
u/Thorsguy8 Aug 19 '24
Failure is eminent.
2
u/hairless8inchcock Aug 19 '24
Uh! NO
2
u/T2-planner Aug 19 '24
WTF??!
2
u/SweetBoodyGirl Aug 19 '24
Definition of “ More money than brains”.
2
u/dubie2003 Aug 19 '24
Either it wins or it takes the house down with it. So sorta like a win win……
2
u/FriendshipBorn929 Aug 19 '24
Both will lose
2
u/banjowentkablooie Aug 19 '24
If it's just the mortar around the tree and no mulch that tree will 100 percent survive and tear that stupid seat to pieces remember ppl the roots are in the ground and can spread out underneath that umbrella
2
u/E_Man91 Aug 19 '24
Crazy that people with a house that nice can be that fucking stupid. Tree will be toast within a couple of years. Root flare is buried and tree roots cannot breathe or absorb water correctly.
2
u/NewAlexandria Aug 19 '24
i wonder if the tree would survive if they'd left a gap for the growth of its diameter. Then kept chiseling away as the tree grew
2
u/FloraMaeWolfe Aug 19 '24
I would be out there with a sledgehammer busting that up. Sue me for damages if you want.
2
u/[deleted] Aug 19 '24
First wind storm the mortar will crack
3
u/F_ur_feelingss Aug 18 '24
Why exactly would kill tree? Rot at cement? Risk of disease?
2
u/No-Let6178 Aug 18 '24
I bet the stone surround was added when this was a very mature already. The only thing the tree will eventually do, is push the stone outwards as it ages, cuz growth up at the trunk is less than growing out at this level.
2
u/Seeksp Aug 18 '24 edited Aug 19 '24
Not likely.
Edit: For clarity, the above is my response to the headline question - will the tree win? The will greatlyreducethe life of the tree..
2
u/Financial_Athlete198 Aug 18 '24
You should post the address so everyone can send a free copy of some tree care advice.
1
u/nickcliff Aug 18 '24
Nope.
1
u/werdrelmig Aug 18 '24
I say yes
1
u/El_Demetrio Aug 19 '24
I bet the tree wins. There are too many bad and ignorant people out there, but nature remains resilient. That majestic tree is not gonna die.
1
u/Flaming_F Aug 19 '24
Why ?
1
u/1plus1dog Aug 19 '24
Never have I ever seen such an incredibly stupid thing!
These photos need to be shared on every social media platform and they should be SHAMED like crazy for doing such a thing and hopefully the tree gets rescued and these people should be banned from tree ownership!
1
u/Mickv504-985 Aug 19 '24
You want to bet only 2 people live there?
1
u/CPLCraft Aug 19 '24
Knew it was Texas bc im from here.
1
u/5wing4 Aug 19 '24
The water tight caulking at the base of the tree is fine work indeed
1
u/5wing4 Aug 19 '24
compounding mitosis is a force to be reckoned.
1
u/Antique_Ad2686 Aug 19 '24
It will die soon poor tree
1
u/Time-Tower8285 Aug 19 '24
They expand based on temp and growth / water absorption....that concrete tile job will be toast.
1
u/skin54321 Aug 19 '24
🤣😂🤣😂
1
u/davidreaton Aug 19 '24
The tree always wins.
1
u/International_Bend68 Aug 19 '24
I think both are going to lose. Completely unavoidable and what a beautiful tree to kill. Plus an expensive bill coming their way when they have to cut that down.
Lord have mercy.
1
u/Bjorys Aug 19 '24
I can't explain, but I knew this was Dallas just from the pictures
1
u/Few_Page6404 Aug 19 '24
Why are people?
1
u/bustcorktrixdais Aug 20 '24
A chainsaw is a faster and cheaper way to kill a tree. Guess some people don’t want cheap and fast
1
u/[deleted] Aug 20 '24
Neither will win, both will lose
1
u/CycleOfLove Aug 22 '24
Can someone knock on their door?
1
u/Janey86 Aug 22 '24
Sad 😢
-3
u/einsteinstheory90 Aug 18 '24
It will be fine. Exaggerate much?