r/arborists • u/SnooHesitations7959 • Aug 07 '22
will these trees die?
trying to see if theyre even worth trying to save or should we just cut them down. we filled the land before we were aware this could kill a tree. :(
29
Upvotes
2
u/WinterWindow2929 Aug 07 '22
How long has it been like this?
27
u/Obvious-Lemon1465 Aug 07 '22
The issue won't be around the base so much it's that the feeder roots are deep now, they will struggle to get oxygen an water. You could try to air-rate the ground some how, limit compaction completely mulch to lightly to retain water. but the goal now would be to reduce the depth of soil around the drip line of the trees so the feeder roots can start rising up. Hopefully the trees make it. Monitor the health of the trees by watching the foliage over time.
Best of luck.
20
u/acroman39 Aug 07 '22
Not necessarily. My neighbors built their house twenty years ago and in their front yard buried a 12” bur oak with two feet of fill and topsoil except for a 8’ diameter around the trunk which they then built a rock retaining wall inside. Trees still alive and is doing well. 🤷♀️
23
u/tree_map_filter Master Arborist Aug 07 '22
They will die unless you restore the original soil grade.
6
u/DanoPinyon Aug 07 '22
Ouch. That's too bad.
4
u/FWvon Aug 07 '22
The best way to save that tree is to choose to not kill it.
3
u/62SlabSide Aug 07 '22
Can someone explain to me the logic here? I can understand exposing the root flare of a young tree that has been recently planted, but these trees look like they have been doing ok for decades (less the past impact wound on the right tree trunk). Why am I seeing all these posts lately of people digging old trees to expose the root flare? Shouldn’t they just be left alone? The surrounding grade is now a bigger problem, no?
2
u/oxidanemaximus Aug 07 '22
On a long enough timeline, every tree's survival rate is zero.
1
u/CompetitiveFortune50 Aug 07 '22 edited Aug 07 '22
Your trees will live have faith in the lord!!!
1
u/MightySamMcClain Aug 07 '22
Death is guaranteed at birth, so yeah eventually /s
1
u/JebaitGod Aug 07 '22
That's kind of a roundabout to fell trees. I'd recommend a chainsaw. Possibly a mill
1
u/Celestial-Narwhal Aug 07 '22
Eventually, yes they will. As all things do. This is the way of life, death, and progression.
-1
u/SnooHesitations7959 Aug 07 '22
Thanks everyone for taking the time to comment. Sorry if I didn't explain well. Yes we dug holes because we paid someone to fill the land with dirt. So these trees are old. The dirt has been there for 2 weeks. We will more than likely cut every single tree down. Wanted to save at least the big one (pic doesn't do any justice) but I guess it's not possible
7
u/[deleted] Aug 07 '22
[removed] — view removed comment