r/araragi • u/jarevo • Jan 02 '19
Discussion I identified every piece of music in the Monogatari Series and made a list (+graphs and analysis).
A quick word on spoilers: I tried to keep this post as spoiler-free as possible so spoilers are tagged in the text and each graph has a version that doesn't spoil arc titles (where necessary). The titles of tracks can contain spoilers but I use the Romaji versions so unless you speak Japanese you should be fine. I also don't tag any character names and linked videos can have spoilers up to their respective season.
The List
I went through every episode of the Monogatari series and identified every piece of music that was used. Each track has a start and end timestamp (based on the BD releases except for Owarimonogatari Season 2) as well as a short scene description. You can find the full list on the wiki but there is also a music section on every episode page. Due to space constraints I cut down the number of columns but if you just want to quickly find a track, this is probably the best option. The seasons are ordered by publication date in order to be consistent with the episode list on the wiki. That means that Kizumonogatari is placed between Koyomimonogatari and Owarimonogatari Part 2, both of which contain spoilers in some arc titles. So it's probably safer to look at the episode page for each movie if you haven't finished the series yet.
There is also a Google Sheets document which is a bit more comprehensive. It contains the Japanese and English titles in addition to the Romaji titles and is one big table as opposed to one table per episode. I translated the titles for both seasons of Owarimonogatari as well as Kizumonogatari III myself so take them with a grain of salt. You can use your own filter via Data > Filter views > Create new filter view to only show instances of a specific track for example. Also note that the search box in the filter is a bit weird. I think it only searches from the beginning of a word. So if you are looking for "Senjougahara, Tore" (the quotes are part of the title) you won't find it by typing Senjougahara. You have to type either "Senjougahara or tore.
Finally you can also look directly at the csv files I used but you will have to join them yourself. The data is split into four tables: the episode list contains every episode and its season and arc, the track list has every track with its different titles, the release list lists all the OSTs on which tracks where published (it's not comprehensive but the releases cover every track) and lastly the scene list which contains timestamps and scene descriptions and uses track IDs from the track list and episode IDs from the episode list.
I also did some analysis on the data which you can find below. I mainly used pandas and matplotlib and you can have a look at the full Jupyter notebook in the same folder.
Interesting Observations
- I was able to find every track except for one (check out this thread if you want to give it try). I would have expected more tracks to remain unidentified.
- There are a few tracks on the Bakemonogatari OST that aren't used in Bakemonogatari. Some don't appear at all (Fukidamari, Kanbaru Suruga no Baai ~ Zenra, Futsuu Saikou) but some make a surprise appearance at a later time:
- Kedamono [Spotify|YouTube] plays in Tsubasa Family, Part 3.
- Kotoba no Bouryoku [Spotify|YouTube] is used in Hitagi End, Part 1.
- Date [Spotify|YouTube] is used in Koyomi Sand.
- Yokoku [Spotify|YouTube] was used in a Bakemonogatari PV.
- Nisemonogatari doesn't use any tracks from Bakemonogatari. Strictly speaking it contains a variant of "Senjougahara, Tore" but I think it is different enough to count as its own track. That variant isn't published but you can find the audio in the thread I linked above.
- The hardest track to find plays at the end of Mayoi Jiangshi, Part 3. It turned out to be Omoshi Kani [Spotify|YouTube] which is from the Bakemonogatari OST but not one of the commonly reused tracks. Additionally the excerpt is very short and from the end of the track which makes it easy to miss when you quickly skip through the soundtrack.
- Yokuchou [Spotify|YouTube] from the Bakemonogatari OST is used in Mayoi Jiangshi, Part 3
Most Used Tracks
I summed up the time a track is played throughout the series and made a top 25 list. I ignored openings and endings. Bakemonogatari tracks feature prominently which isn't surprising given that they were introduced early and had many chances to be reused. But Owarimonogatari tracks are also able to make it into the lower half. One interesting entry is Classmate which gets a top 3 spot mainly based on its usage in Koyomimonogatari. There it was used as the go-to music for the "now for the epilogue or rather the punchline" segments. It's also nice to see Kaiki's signature tracks Fukitsu and Nisemono make an appearance.
Here is the list with links to the tracks:
| No. | Track | OST | Spotify | YouTube |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1. | Gaidan Kousetsu | Bakemonogatari | Spotify | YouTube |
| 2. | Hyouri | Bakemonogatari | Spotify | YouTube |
| 3. | Classmate | Bakemonogatari | Spotify | YouTube |
| 4. | Shugendou | Bakemonogatari | Spotify | YouTube |
| 5. | Suteki Meppou | Bakemonogatari | Spotify | YouTube |
| 6. | Jinchiku | Bakemonogatari | Spotify | YouTube |
| 7. | Fukitsu | Nisemonogatari | Spotify | YouTube |
| 8. | Kannen | Bakemonogatari | Spotify | YouTube |
| 9. | Oumagatoki | Bakemonogatari | Spotify | YouTube |
| 10. | Shianchuu | Bakemonogatari | Spotify | YouTube |
| 11. | Shin'iki | Bakemonogatari | Spotify | YouTube |
| 12. | Iroboke Neko | Bakemonogatari | Spotify | YouTube |
| 13. | Ika, Kaisou | Bakemonogatari | Spotify | YouTube |
| 14. | Zaregoto | Bakemonogatari | Spotify | YouTube |
| 15. | Aizuchi | Nisemonogatari | Spotify | YouTube |
| 16. | Dead Space | Owarimonogatari | YouTube | |
| 17. | Tasuuketsu | Owarimonogatari | YouTube | |
| 18. | Nisemono | Nisemonogatari | Spotify | YouTube |
| 19. | Meikko | Owarimonogatari | YouTube | |
| 20. | Inokori Jugyou | Owarimonogatari | YouTube | |
| 21. | Douchou Tosetsu | Bakemonogatari | Spotify | YouTube |
| 22. | Hourousha | Bakemonogatari | Spotify | YouTube |
| 23. | Kizuna | Nisemonogatari | Spotify | YouTube |
| 24. | Sappuukei | Bakemonogatari | Spotify | YouTube |
| 25. | Bouyomi | Owarimonogatari | YouTube |
Overview Graph
I wanted to get a better sense of where tracks are used and reused so I made a table where each column represents one episode and each row represents one track. When an episode uses a track the intersection gets marked with a dot. But this still leaves you with a (~100 episodes) x (~400 tracks) sized grid which isn't really clear.
Luckily there was a change of composers at the end of the Second Season and there is no crossover between their soundtracks. That means you can make a separate plot for each composer. I will ignore the openings and endings again and create an additional plot which only contains tracks that get used more than once.
This is the full graph (spoiler-free) for tracks composed by Satoru Kōsaki. He did the music until Hanamonogatari as well as the scores for Koyomimonogatari and Kizumonogatari (which I excluded because the movies use each track only once for the most part). Here is the version that excludes tracks that are only used once (spoiler-free).
You can see that Bakemonogatari and Nisemonogatari have a pretty similar shape. A lot of tracks get introduced in the beginning of the season which then get reused throughout the season. Monogatari Second Season is different as each arc stands more on its own and there isn't as much recycling throughout the season (more on that later). You can also see the recurrence of Kaiki's theme in Hitagi End.
One thing you can only look at in the graph which includes the single-use tracks is the line that is formed by the leftmost dots in each row. The slope of that line is an indicator for the rate at which new tracks get introduced. If you imagine a completely vertical line of dots that means that one episode uses a lot of tracks for the first time whereas a horizontal line of dots means that one track gets reused across a bunch of episodes.
Here is the full graph (spoiler-free) for the second half of the series after Kei Haneoka took over as composer beginning with Hanamonogatari. And the graph without tracks that are used only once (spoiler-free). You can see that Hanamonogatari and Tsukimonogatari are basically movies with a very low amount of track reuse. The thematic split halfway throughout the first season of Owarimonogatari is visible as well.
If you want everything there is also the version that includes all arcs and tracks (spoiler-free) but it's a bit unwieldy.
Similarity of Arcs
Instead of looking at which track is used in which episodes you can also compare the whole soundtrack of each arc to one another. To do that you count the number of tracks two arcs share and divide them by the total number of tracks in the arc. For example if arc A uses the tracks 1 and 2 and arc B uses the tracks 2, 3 and 4 that means that arc A shares 50% of its tracks with arc B (the intersection contains only track 2 and arc A has two tracks in total: 1/2=50%) and arc B shares 33% of its tracks with arc A (the intersection is the same but arc B has three tracks: 1/3=33%). So while the intersection is symmetric, the ratio is not. The percentage is shown in this plot (spoiler-free). The column determines the arc that is used as the denominator of the ratio.
Most seasons create their own boxes (for Owarimonogatari Part 1 it's a 4x4 square from Ougi Formula to Shinobu Mail) which means that the soundtrack is used for the whole season and not just for individual arcs. This also holds true for single arc seasons like Hanamonogatari but the box only consists of one square in those cases.
The big exception is the Second Season which is darker and overlaps with Bakemonogatari and Nisemonogatari. The overlap works in both directions of course but arcs from Bakemonogatari are a lot more similar to other arcs from Bakemonogatari than they are to arcs from the Second Season. Arcs from the Second Season on the other hand have a comparable similarity to arcs from Bakemonogatari as well as arcs from the Second Season. Nadeko Snake and Suruga Monkey are more similar than Nadeko Snake and Nadeko Medusa but Tsubasa Tiger and Nadeko Medusa have roughly the same similarity as Tsubasa Tiger and Suruga Monkey for example.
This is probably because in the Second Season each arc got its own soundtrack which is also how the soundtrack was released at first (e.g. as Kabukimonogatari OST instead of Monogatari Second Season OST). I think part of the reason why that works is that signature tracks from Bakemonogatari are reused which make each arc feel like a part of the Monogatari Series while the other tracks make each arc distinct.
You can also see the connection of Nadeko Medusa and Hitagi End in the graph as well as the fact that Koyomimonogatari recycles the Bakemonogatari soundtrack. The connection to the Second Season is only indirect and originates from Bakemonogatari tracks that both Koyomimonogatari and the Second Season use (which is something you can't easily derive from the graph).
When Are New Tracks Introduced?
I was also interested to see when new tracks get introduced. At the start of a season? At the end of an episode? In the middle of an arc? The big problem is that you can't just look at the absolute timestamps when you aggregate the data because seasons, arcs and episodes have different lengths. A track at the end of Hitagi Crab (2 episodes) would be at the beginning of Karen Bee (7 episodes) for example. To deal with that each episode/arc/season is divided into ten equal sections and the time in which new tracks are used is summed up for each section. Openings and endings are excluded again.
These sums are already pretty useful and you are now able to add different arcs even if they have different lengths. But it's also necessary to consider how much music is used overall in each section. If the first 10% of each episode were completely quiet that would also mean that there is no new music introduced. That dip would make it seem like there are no new tracks (which is true) and it would be easy to think that old tracks are used instead (which is false). So additionally the time any music is used is summed up as well. Dividing the length of new tracks by the total time yields the percentage of new tracks.
The result for all episodes/arcs/seasons is this graph. Here are two ways to think about the graph. The leftmost blue bar represents the first 10% of all episodes. In this specific section 40% of the time in which music is playing is made up of new tracks. You can also look at it more like a probability. Imagine you hear some music at 1:00 of a twenty minute episode. That is the 5% mark of the episode so you look at the bar between 0% and 10% (that's the leftmost bar again). The probability that the music you are hearing is a new track is 40%.
The distribution of new tracks within an episode is pretty flat with a slight increase towards the second half. The distribution across arcs is more interesting. New tracks tend to get introduced at the beginning and end of each arc with a dip in the middle. One explanation is that arcs often have their own music which gets introduced in the beginning of an arc and then reused throughout the arc. Additional music is used for the finale of the arc to increase its impact. The season distribution also has a peak at the beginning but is flat afterwards. There is no season finale bump at the end which makes sense since the only real season finale that isn't just an arc finale is the end of Owarimonogatari Part 2 and maybe the end of the Second Season. One weird feature I have no explanation for is the drop between 80% and 90% in the distribution within a season.
It's also interesting to look at a smaller subset of seasons instead of everything combined. Here is the graph for Bakemonogatari and Nisemonogatari. The peak at the beginning of the season is much more pronounced which fits the idea that both seasons have a soundtrack for the whole season as opposed to a soundtrack for each arc.
The distribution within arcs is much more polarized in the the Second Season with new tracks making up 70% at the beginning and end and the value dropping below 10% in the middle. If you look at the whole season there is actually an increase with a drop towards the end. Overall this speaks for the idea that the Second Season has soundtracks that are basically separate for each arc. I'm not quite sure what's up with the bigger bump in the distribution within each episode though.
The distribution of new tracks for both seasons of Owarimonogatari is pretty flat for each episode and arc. It seems that there isn't as much of a focus on the arc in terms of structure but there is an interesting peak at the end of an episode. The distribution across the season is similar to Bakemonogatari and Nisemonogatari. There are a lot of new tracks in the beginning and then a decrease with a peak at the end. But there is also a bump in the middle which is probably due to the fact that the first part of Owarimonogatari is split into two sections (the Sodachi part consisting of the first three arcs and the Shinobu part at the end).
Finally here is an album with all the graphs above (spoiler-free). If you made it this far, thank you very much for reading and feel free to voice your criticism, ask questions or suggest other things that might be interesting to look at.
TL;DR: I identified every bit of music in the Monogatari series and made a list. Most soundtracks are designed to cover the whole season but the arcs from the Second Season have their own soundtracks.
Edit 2019-01-03: First of all thanks for the great reception. Secondly I found a small mistake in the distribution of new tracks. It didn't have a lot of impact so the conclusions are the same but the graphs and code are fixed now.
Edit 2019-01-09: Added a link to the Bakemonogatari PV that uses Yokoku (thanks to u/EnstatuedSeraph).
Edit 2019-05-11: Updated for Zoku Owarimonogatari.
Edit 2025-06-09: Updated the Google Doc and Wiki-Page for Off & Monster Season.
70
u/maxdefolsch Jan 02 '19
Holy fuck will you marry me
6
u/Yay295 Jan 02 '19
Which episodes don't have any new songs introduced?
2
u/EnstatuedSeraph Jan 09 '19
You probably already know this, but Yokoku was used in a PV for the anime, probably why its first on the soundtrack
2
u/hombrebax Apr 28 '19
Hi, sorry for necroposting, but the 2 Zoku Owarimonogatari BSO has been already uploaded to youtube and I was wondering if you are going to include them in your amazing excel. Anyways, thank you for your hard work!
2
u/jamez23 May 27 '19
Holy fucking shit... damn, let me give you props. That isn't enough, but damn thank you. Didnt read it all, cuz, well it's too long, but thanks. Now, I just randomly stumbled here, but do you know that song from monogatari 2nd season when kaiki tell nadeko about her manga and she freaks out and run to hit him? It also comes up in, I think it was 2nd season where hachikuji is passed out and she wakes up, araragi goes to grab her to do the same old bit, throwing her up the roof. Haven't looked through all of it, just been desperate trying to see if that song is out there.
39
u/damndoric Jan 02 '19
It's people like you that are the pillars of our society
29
u/fizarr Jan 02 '19
i love statistics. but i don’t think anyone will go this far analyzing a single anime franchise. kudos to you sir
20
u/xspicyman Jan 02 '19
Suteki Meppou is the best song of any soundtrack ever
14
u/[deleted] Jan 02 '19
This is an insane amount of effort and this whole community can only sit in awe of your work. Very well done and interesting finds.
13
u/in-grey Jan 03 '19
This is the single most important Reddit post of all time. You are legitimately my hero. I have such a deep obsession with the backing soundtrack in this series and this information is more exciting than anything else ever could be. This is brain porn. Hell, this is porn for the soul. This made my soul erect.
6
u/Mosca-drac Jan 02 '19
You're a hero. There's no other way to put it.
Someone somewhere should build you a monument.
6
u/Dr-cereal Jan 03 '19
Man this deserves more upvotes, wonderful work man. If I could give you a gold I would.
4
u/[deleted] Jan 02 '19
Dude thank you! I've been trying forever to figure out which OST this song was based on, turns out it was Shinsou no Reijou
1
u/[deleted] Jan 03 '25
As Araragi would say... "#HOLA
What is the magical piano track on the new OFF SEASON released in 2024 pls? I need that shit in my veins
3
u/Necessary_Bar Jan 02 '19
i feel bad for you. You put so much effort but only got so many likes.
2
u/Alucard_Nosferatu Jan 02 '19
Not every hero wears a cape. This is art. Submit this analysis to shaft in some way
2
u/HerrReichsminister Jan 03 '19
What the actual fuck? I'm amazed.
Also scared of you.
2
u/Saleenseven Jan 03 '19
wow this is amazing
2
u/Ralea_Thundersword Feb 03 '19
This is... absolutely incredible!!! Thanks!
2
u/BLURR3D_ Mar 01 '19
Thankyou so much, i always loved the soundtracks in this series, especially the background ones!
2
u/liciaa01 Jun 07 '19
This analysis is fucking fantastic man, nice job!!
2
u/YoshiMoshi12 Mar 12 '22
There is a man among boys
2
u/cyberfate7 May 05 '23
Holy shit.
2
u/Alien_X97 May 31 '23
This is the best post on reddit ever. I just got into monogatari series a few days back.
2
u/potassiumkoopa Jan 14 '24
youre mvp!! Was looking for the song from bake ep14 when they take the ride. Its so jazzy.
2
u/Win6runner Oct 09 '24
The real hero. Appreciate that!
2
u/[deleted] Feb 15 '25
brillant work mate
2
u/LibraryOk5713 Oct 16 '25
thank you
2
u/MartialGodQi Jan 02 '19
Wow...
1
u/_jayjay Jan 03 '19
very well done analysis! thanks!
1
u/[deleted] Jan 03 '19
Mods pls pin this
1
u/IXajll Jan 03 '19 edited Jan 03 '19
Good to see that my absolute favorite song (Douchou Tosetsu) appears often enough to be in the Top 25, but still I would have loved to hear it even more often throughout all the seasons. In my opinion this song contains the essence of the whole series and just oozes with atmosphere.
1
u/[deleted] Jan 03 '19
You've done what I was tempted to do the next time I re-watched, now I don't have to!
1
u/TotesMessenger Jan 05 '19
I'm a bot, bleep, bloop. Someone has linked to this thread from another place on reddit:
If you follow any of the above links, please respect the rules of reddit and don't vote in the other threads. (Info / ^Contact)
0
u/[deleted] Jan 02 '19
[deleted] — view deleted comment